5 Jun 2001, 09:56 UTC
Energy Issues
- From
- Miyung Buster miyung.buster@enron.com
- To
-
Ann M Schmidt, Bryan Seyfried, Elizabeth Linnell, filuntz@aol.com, James D Steffes, Janet Butler, Jeannie Mandelker, Jeff Dasovich, Joe Hartsoe, John Neslage, John Sherriff, Joseph Alamo
and 45 more
Karen Denne, Lysa Akin, Mark Palmer, Mark Schroeder, Markus Fiala, Michael R Brown, Mona L Petrochko, Nicholas O'Day, Peggy Mahoney, Peter Styles, Richard Shapiro, Rob Bradley, Sandra McCubbin, Shelley Corman, Stella Chan, Steven J Kean, Susan J Mara, mike.roan@enron.com, Alex Parsons, andrew.morrison@enron.com, Laura Ipsen, Janel Guerrero, shirley.hudler@enron.com, Kathleen Sullivan, Tom Briggs, Linda Robertson, Lora Sullivan, Jennifer Thome, jkradin@marathon-com.com, rlichtenstein@marathon-com.com, Sandra Yamane, Ken Smith, Hedy Govenar, Scott Govenar, Bev Hansen, Carin Nersesian, Robert Neustaedter, John Shelk, Chris Holmes, Evan Hughes, Roberta Staehlin, Lamar Frazier, Ban Sharma, Pat Shortridge, Karen Moore - Date
- Tue, 5 Jun 2001 02:56:00 -0700 (PDT)
Please see the following articles: Sac Bee, Tues, 6/5: Ose electricity bill buffeted by political storms Sac Bee, Tues, 6/5: Bush vs. price caps: Economists correct a faulty power lecture (Editorial) SD Union, Tues, 6/5: A game of victims and villains SD Union, Tues, 6/5: Idled plants coming back on line SD Union, Mon, 6/4: Planned plant shutdowns easing, boosting state's power supply SF Chron, Tues, 6/5: Chevron threatens to cut gas supply in state SF Chron, Tues, 6/5: PG&E creditors approve bonuses Utility must file reorganization plan by end of year, or CEO only gets $600,000 extra SF Chron, Tues, 6/5: 56% favor limits on electricity prices, poll finds SF Chron, Tues, 6/5: Developments in California's energy crisis SF Chron, Tues, 6/5: PG&E sues to challenge reimbursement to state Mercury News, Tues, 6/5: Critics say Calpine plan too generous Mercury News, Mon, 6/4: PBS documentary shines light on energy crisis (Enron mentioned) Mercury News, Tues, 6/5: California's big turnoff (Editorial) Mercury News, Tues, 6/5: FERC shirk (Editorial) OC Register, Tues, 6/5: Edison plugging shareholders into Capitol OC Register, Tues, 6/5: SDG&E to seek rate hike to cover $915 million tab OC Regiser, Tues, 6/5: Energy notebook AES power plant repairs might not meet target date Individual.com (Businesswire), Tues, 6/5: GWF Signs Long-Term Contract to Provide 430 MW of Power to California WSJ, Tues, 6/5: Electricity prices (Chart) NY Times, Tues, 6/5: Surplus of Finger-Pointing In California Energy Crisis LA Times, Tues, 6/5: California PSEG Signs 10-Year Contract to Supply Electricity to State LA Times, Tues, 6/5: Panel OKs Subpoenas for Energy Companies Electricity : Special state Senate committee will demand pricing information in inquiry into whether California has been gouged ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ----------------------------------- Ose electricity bill buffeted by political storms By David Whitney Bee Washington Bureau (Published June 5, 2001) WASHINGTON -- Rep. Doug Ose's legislation to bring order to skyrocketing wholesale electricity prices is helping House Republicans rescue an emergency electricity bill, but it hasn't quelled Democrats' increasingly strident call for more extensive price controls. Utility sources, meanwhile, said the Sacramento Republican's legislation won't do enough to stop the rapid escalation in wholesale power rates in California and the West Coast. And Mark Cooper, director of research for the Consumer Federation of America, charged that the bill would lead to even higher power rates for most Californians. "Ose's bill simply legalizes the transfer of billions of dollars from California to Texas and Oklahoma," Cooper said. Ose, chairman of the House Government Reform Committee's energy policy panel, introduced his bill last month. The measure was promptly referred to the House Energy and Commerce Committee, whose Republican leaders saw it as a way out of a politically sticky mess. With Democrats demanding that federal regulators set wholesale rates based on generators' actual cost of producing power and the Bush administration opposing anything that looks like price caps, Ose's idea contained the seeds of compromise. Ose expanded on what the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission already had endorsed in a controversial "price mitigation" order for the California market that took effect last week. That order states that during a power emergency, the wholesale price on the spot market will be pegged to the cost of production at the highest-cost, least-efficient plant selling into the market at the time. Ose's bill defuses some of the Democratic criticism of that action by making the order apply at all times and throughout the 13-state Western region. "It is not a cap," Ose said. "It is market driven. It rewards those who are most efficient, and it rewards those who are most environmentally sensitive and responsible." House Energy and Commerce Committee leaders hope to use the bill this week as the framework to jump-start a package of emergency electricity provisions, including authorization of a $200 million fix of a critical Central California transmission line bottleneck. California Democrats, heartened by the leadership change in the Senate that strengthens Sen. Dianne Feinstein's hand on her price-control legislation, are working to derail the Ose compromise. "By allowing the least-efficient generator to set the price, this proposal creates a system that will encourage massive market manipulation, raising prices even further," they said in a statement. "This amendment will do nothing to help stop the economic bleeding." The Bee's David Whitney can be reached at (202) 383-0004 or dwhitney@mcclatchydc.com. Bush vs. price caps: Economists correct a faulty power lecture (Published June 5, 2001) In his recent commencement address at Yale University, President Bush saluted the C students in the graduating class: "I say you, too, can be president of the United States." But when he lectured California last week on the evils of electricity price controls, the joke seemed less funny. What America's most famous C student didn't learn in economics class is costing the state dearly. "Price caps do nothing to reduce demand, and they do nothing to increase supply," Bush said in his Los Angeles address, repeating a standard lesson out of introductory economics textbooks. Unfortunately, as 10 energy economists from universities around the nation made clear last week in an open letter on the state's electricity crisis, Bush must have missed the later chapters. The textbooks' admonitions against price controls apply to competitive markets. When competition breaks down, giving one or a few producers the ability to control prices, the textbooks are equally firm that regulation is needed to keep them from exploiting consumers. That's the situation confronting California -- and federal regulators. Electricity markets here long ago ceased to be competitive. Because of a flawed market structure and a temporary imbalance between supply and demand, generators learned last year that they had market power: By withholding supply at key times and places, they drove up the price of power beyond the level that would otherwise prevail in a competitive market. "We cannot expect a market to operate to benefit consumers ... if effective competition does not exist," the economists said in their letter. "In this case, cost-of-service prices are an obvious remedy." They noted that several useful proposals have been submitted to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) for temporary price restraints on wholesale prices. These would last only until new plants now being built come online to alleviate the shortage. Such restraints could meet the federal legal requirement that prices be "just and reasonable" without discouraging construction of new power plants or generation from existing plants, which is needed to keep the lights on this summer. In fact, as some economists have pointed out, the right kind of price controls could actually increase supply by removing any incentive for generators to withhold electricity to game the market. Bush's regulatory inaction is producing an unprecedented transfer of wealth from California households and businesses to the generating firms, a shift that endangers the health of the state's economy. Unless FERC or Congress steps in, that wealth transfer likely will yield a political backlash not only against electricity deregulation, but also against market-based policies in general. Even a C student should know enough history to understand that's not a risk an incumbent politician wants to court. A game of victims and villains Stereotypes cloud the complexity of energy issue By Dana Wilkie COPLEY NEWS SERVICE June 5, 2001 WASHINGTON -- When Gov. Gray Davis refers to those Texans taking Californians to the cleaners with electricity prices, the impression he apparently wants to leave is one of greedy and unscrupulous Republicans who probably look like oil baron J.R. Ewing. And when Bush administration officials sniff that Californians got themselves into this energy mess, they seem to be conjuring up the image of short-sighted, tree-hugging Democrats who care more about Alaskan caribou than about people. Even if Davis and Bush shook hands and appeared civil in California last Tuesday, the previous weeks of discord between the two left an indelible impression on the public, experts said -- one colored by stereotypes that easily strike a chord with voters but that also cloud the complexity of the energy issue. Those stereotypes pit the languid, Birkenstock-wearing Californian against the respectable Texas corporate man; the gluttonous executive against the rabid environmentalist; John Wayne against out-of-towners in black hats. Just as when many in this country maligned Arabs during the 1970s oil embargo, attempts to create victims and villains in the current energy crisis easily appeal to public emotion. Davis, a Democrat, recently invoked the image of hand-to-hand combat with a fearsome foreigner: "We are literally in a war with energy companies, many of which reside in Texas," Davis said after Bush, a Texan, released his energy plan. The image is straight from an old western. "Gray Davis is playing John Wayne against the guy with the black hat," said Mark Petracca, chairman of the political science department at the University of California Irvine. "You sound like a socialist if you demonize middle-aged white guys in suits who own capital. You sound like a cowboy with a white hat when you demonize oil barons." U.S. Sen. Barbara Boxer, another Democrat, plopped a black hat on Vice President Dick Cheney, architect of Bush's energy plan: "You have the vice president sounding like an oil man." Said Petracca: "Of all the possible images that one could pick, the oil baron is the easiest to manufacture. It has the deepest cultural resonance, because people have been exposed to this imagery on TV stations for years and years." Helping to bolster that image, of course, is the fact that both Bush and Cheney worked in companies involved with oil. While Bush professes no part in the blame game -- "He's not interested in finger-pointing," said White House press secretary Ari Fleischer -- Cheney raised the stereotype of the superficial, mollycoddled, air-headed Californian. On a national news program, he called California's electricity deregulation scheme "harebrained" and Davis' suggestion that Bush allowed price-gouging "goofy." "You have a war of two biases," said Jack Pitney, a government professor at Claremont McKenna College. "The bias of Texas as greedy and money-grubbing, and the bias of California as shallow and narcissistic." No matter how unrepresentative, these stereotypes are a way for the Davis and Bush administrations, and the national political parties, to convince voters whom to blame for the energy mess. That one of the parties should be a "culprit" is itself somewhat disingenuous, since the crisis has roots that run across Republican and Democratic administrations. Davis' once-stellar public approval ratings have withered, as Californians increasingly disapprove of how he has handled the crisis. Facing re- election next year and a considered a presidential prospect in 2004, the governor often reminds Californians that the crisis grew out of a Republican deregulation scheme, and that he is working around the clock to build new power plants. California Attorney General Bill Lockyer, also a Democrat, recently portrayed power-company executives as criminals: "I would love to personally escort (Enron Corp. Chairman Kenneth) Lay to an 8-by-10 cell that he could share with a tattooed dude who says, 'Hi, my name is Spike, honey,' " Lockyer said. Meanwhile, national Democrats have aired a TV ad in the Long Beach district of GOP Rep. Stephen Horn that says the congressman teamed with Bush to oppose price caps that might have offered relief from summer blackouts. "It's a short-term effort by Davis to blame (others) for his difficulties, but it's also part of a longer-term national Democratic Party effort to make a case that the administration is rather friendly to the big-energy interests, and less friendly to conservationists," said Bruce Buchanan, a University of Texas expert on the presidency. If gasoline prices stay high, or if California's electricity problems spill over into other states, it may be Bush -- and Republicans running in next year's elections -- who land in trouble with the public. The GOP fears that voters may perceive Republicans as the monopolistic and environmentally unfriendly tools of oil companies. In the 1970s, politicians found an easy culprit for long lines at gas stations and high fuel prices: They preyed on stereotypes of Arabs. "All you had to do was show a bunch of Arab sheiks -- who already look to us sort of exotic -- meeting in some country that makes people think of international terrorism," said UC Irvine's Petracca. "Bingo -- you have some people to blame." Now, as then, the images have little to do with reality. Ben Paulos, who promotes alternative power with the Energy Foundation, said "it's a simplification" to paint the culprits in California's energy crisis as Texas oil companies. "These are international companies that own things all over the place," he said. In fact, most of the privately owned power generators in California are owned by companies that are not from Texas. And while conservationists get mileage out of associating these companies with J.R. Ewing -- the Larry Hagman character who ran an oil company on TV's "Dallas" -- "these (Texas) companies we're talking about are not oil companies," Petracca said. "They're energy companies, natural gas companies. But people lump it all together." Said Pitney: "When you're trying to get on (with news anchor) Dan Rather, detailed matters about energy policy just don't make the cut." Idled plants coming back on line By Don Thompson ASSOCIATED PRESS June 5, 2001 SACRAMENTO -- California's electricity production should improve in the next few weeks weeks as more power plants come back on line after spring maintenance shutdowns, the state's grid operator said yesterday. That, coupled with conservation efforts detailed by state officials Sunday, could help during this summer's high temperatures, independent observers said -- but not enough to stave off blackouts. "We still find blackouts are inevitable," said Michael Zenker of Cambridge Energy Research Associates, an energy research and consulting organization. "There just isn't enough generation available." By the middle of this month, every existing plant is scheduled to be producing power. That contrasts with a historic high this spring when about a third of the state's power generation was unavailable due to scheduled or emergency shutdowns. The high number of shuttered plants prompted state officials to suggest power generators were deliberately withholding electricity to drive up prices, and Gov. Gray Davis ordered inspectors into plants to make sure generators weren't cheating. Generators objected, saying they have run their plants so hard since last year that routine maintenance was overdue, which caused more unplanned breakdowns. The Independent System Operator, which runs the power grid, says equipment breakdowns typically account for about 2,500 megawatts being off-line on any given day. Forced outages stripped the power grid of 2,673 megawatts yesterday. The power grid was short 4,144 megawatts due to planned shutdowns yesterday, beating the Independent System Operator's projections that 5,800 megawatts would be unavailable. That was down from 9,800 megawatts off-line for scheduled maintenance when the state narrowly avoided rolling blackouts Thursday. The ISO projects that in a week, about 3,000 megawatts should be down for maintenance, said ISO spokeswoman Stephanie McCorkle. "It looks like we're on target with our goal of getting the planned maintenance down to zero by mid-June." More generation, however, "doesn't mean consumers can cut back on their conservation, because at the same time more plants come on line, temperatures continue to rise," McCorkle said. By summer's peak in August and September, California can be using more than 45,000 megawatts. Californians cut their electricity use by 11 percent overall, and by about 10 percent during peak demand hours last month compared to the same month last year, the California Energy Commission said Sunday. In addition, the Davis administration has signed more power contracts, and the price of that power is falling. "All that's good news. We're moving in the right direction," said Severin Borenstein, director of the University of California Berkeley's energy institute. However, "the amount of conservation we're going to need in the late summer is even greater than we have now. We've got a long stretch ahead of us." Planned plant shutdowns easing, boosting state's power supply By Don Thompson ASSOCIATED PRESS June 4, 2001 SACRAMENTO ) California's electricity production should improve in the coming weeks as more power plants come back on line after spring maintenance shutdowns, the state's grid operator said Monday. That, coupled with conservation efforts detailed by state officials Sunday, could help during this summer's high temperatures, independent observers said ) but not enough to stave off blackouts. "We still find blackouts are inevitable," said Michael Zenker of Cambridge Energy Research Associates, an energy research and consulting organization. "There just isn't enough generation available." By mid-June, every existing plant is scheduled to be producing power. That contrasts with a historic high this spring when about a third of the state's power generation was unavailable due to scheduled or emergency shutdowns. The high number of shuttered plants prompted state officials to suggest power generators were deliberately withholding electricity to drive up prices, and Gov. Gray Davis to order inspectors into plants to make sure generators weren't cheating. Generators objected, saying they have run their plants so hard since last year that routine maintenance was overdue, which caused more unplanned breakdowns. Last Thursday, for instance, when California came within a hair of a seventh day of statewide blackouts, one of Duke Energy's 750-megawatt Moss Landing units began springing boiler leaks. "We almost lost it that day because we'd been putting off scheduled maintenance for so long," said company spokesman Tom Williams. "You can nurse those along for a while, but after a while they'll trip (off-line) and they'll do it during the peak of the summer." The Independent System Operator, which runs the power grid, says equipment breakdowns typically account for about 2,500 megawatts being off-line on any given day. Forced outages stripped the power grid of 2,673 megawatts Monday. The power grid was short 4,144 megawatts due to planned shutdowns Monday, beating the Independent System Operator's projections that 5,800 megawatts would be unavailable. That was down from 9,800 megawatts off-line for scheduled maintenance when the state narrowly avoided rolling blackouts Thursday. By comparison, California was expected to use about 31,000 megawatts of power during its afternoon peak period Monday, and top out at about 31,800 megawatts Tuesday afternoon. The 4,144 megawatts unavailable due to planned shutdowns Monday would have powered about 3.1 million homes. The ISO projects that in a week, about 3,000 megawatts should be down for maintenance, said ISO spokeswoman Stephanie McCorkle. "It looks like we're on target with our goal of getting the planned maintenance down to zero by mid-June." More generation, however, "doesn't mean consumers can cut back on their conservation, because at the same time more plants come on line, temperatures continue to rise," McCorkle said. By summer's peak in August and September, California can be using more than 45,000 megawatts. Californians cut their electricity use by 11 percent overall, and by about 10 percent during peak demand hours last month compared to the same month last year, the California Energy Commission said Sunday. In addition, the Davis administration said has signed more power contracts, and the price of that power is falling. "All that's good news. We're moving in the right direction," said Severin Borenstein, director of the University of California, Berkeley's energy institute. However, "the amount of conservation we're going to need in the late summer is even greater than we have now. We've got a long stretch ahead of us." Planned maintenance shutdowns this winter and spring helped prompt six days of rolling blackouts, said ISO spokesman Gregg Fishman. The ISO recently delayed installation of pollution control equipment at five plants until winter so those plants can operate through the hot summer months. "The idea is the plants go down mainly in the springtime, because usually there's the hydro(electricity) there to replace them," Fishman said. But not with this year's water and snowfall shortage: "We got squeezed a couple of times because of the hydro shortage either here (in California) or in the Northwest." Chevron threatens to cut gas supply in state Bernadette Tansey, Chronicle Staff Writer Tuesday, June 5, 2001 ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle URL: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2001/06/05/MN159275.DTL Chevron Corp. will reduce gasoline production at its two California refineries unless they are exempted from rolling blackouts, the company's chief executive warned Gov. Gray Davis. In a move that could raise California gas prices, Chevron's Richmond and El Segundo plants will scale back output and rely solely on the power provided by their own electrical generators, Chevron Chairman David O'Reilly said in a letter Friday obtained by The Chronicle. Chevron would not say how much less gas it would supply from its refineries, which have a combined capacity of 485,000 barrels per day. But a spokesman for the California Energy Commission said motorists could feel it at the pump. "Any reduction in production has an impact in the marketplace," said senior fuel specialist Gordon Schremp. "Prices are going to go up." Chevron's gasoline sales account for more than 18 percent of the California market, company spokesman Fred Gorell said. While other California refiners met yesterday's deadline to apply to state regulators for exemptions from temporary outages, O'Reilly said Chevron would not submit an application. To qualify for one of the exemptions being considered by the state Public Utilities Commission, Chevron would have had to assert that its vulnerability to blackouts would present "imminent danger to public health or safety" -- something O'Reilly said Chevron could not do. "Chevron will never operate its facilities in a manner that jeopardizes the health or safety of its employees or its neighbors," O'Reilly wrote. Unless the PUC or the Legislature shields Chevron from blackouts, it will rely on its cogeneration plants. Chevron set no time line for cutting production, but Gorell said the company is looking for state action "as soon as possible." Industry groups, backed by the California Energy Commission, have been pressing state officials to overturn a PUC decision that stripped refineries of a former exemption from blackouts. Legislation that would create a blanket exemption for refineries is stalled in the state Senate. Davis spokesman Steve Maviglio said the governor has not yet responded to Chevron's letter and has not taken a position on the refinery exemption law proposed by Assemblyman John Dutra, D-Fremont. Industry officials have warned that a refinery blacked out for just a few hours could take as much as a week to bring back online. State regulators could not be reached for comment on Chevron's letter. Gorell said O'Reilly's letter should not be read as saying that conditions at Chevron could be dangerous if the refineries suddenly lost power. At the Valero refinery in Benicia, however, spokesman Scott Folwarkow said his company did not hesitate to warn in its exemption application that sudden shutdowns can pose a risk. He said refineries were designed under the assumption that they would have a reliable supply of power. "If you start flipping the switch on and off, unpredictable things can happen," he said. E-mail Bernadette Tansey at btansey@sfchronicle.com. ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle ? Page?A - 4 PG&E creditors approve bonuses Utility must file reorganization plan by end of year, or CEO only gets $600,000 extra David Lazarus, Chronicle Staff Writer Tuesday, June 5, 2001 ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle URL: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2001/06/05/MN159696.DTL PG&E's creditors have agreed to management's plan to shower top executives with $17.5 million in bonuses but balked at the bankrupt utility's initial demand that the cash come with no strings attached, The Chronicle has learned. Instead, the creditors say they forced Pacific Gas and Electric Co. to link the bonuses -- in some cases doubling the pay of senior managers -- to quickly filing a Chapter 11 reorganization plan, no later than January. However, PG&E spokesman Ron Low insisted yesterday that the utility had always intended for the bonuses to be tied to submitting a reorganization plan. "Our original proposal closely resembled what was filed with the court," he said. The bonuses are expected to figure prominently when PG&E's management holds a court-mandated meeting with creditors on Thursday in San Francisco. Bankruptcy Judge Dennis Montali, who has the final say on all compensation questions, is scheduled to issue a ruling June 18. Critics have slammed the utility's "management retention program" as an unwarranted payout to the same executive team responsible for steering PG&E into its worst-ever financial crisis. But the company insists that without extra incentives, corporate leaders would depart and thus slow PG&E's return to creditworthiness. "It's a question of efficiency," said Allan Marks, a lawyer representing the 11 companies comprising the creditors' committee in PG&E's bankruptcy proceedings. "It's not a question of whether these people are good or bad managers," he said. "It's simply more efficient to keep these people in place." Marks said that when PG&E first proposed the bonuses last month, the creditors' committee quickly noted that the cash was a virtual handout to about 226 top executives. PG&E Chairman Robert Glynn and nearly two dozen other senior managers would receive 100 percent of their salaries to stay on, while hundreds of other employees would receive bonuses of between 25 and 75 percent of their salaries. After what Marks described as candid negotiations, he said PG&E had agreed to link the bonuses to a commitment that its reorganization plan be on the table by the beginning of 2002. "This is one way that we can assure efficiency in the process," he said. "Our goal is to make sure the company operates as quickly as possible." But PG&E's Low said that the creditors had actually requested only minor changes in wording and that the timing of a reorganization plan had never really been in dispute. A reorganization plan is the blueprint for a company's eventual recovery from bankruptcy. Glynn would receive a bonus of 100 percent of his $900,000 annual salary if PG&E's plan is submitted on time. If he misses the deadline, he would have to make do with just two-thirds of that amount. While there is no reason to believe that PG&E's managers would have dragged their heels without piles of extra cash, Marks said it was common in bankruptcy cases for corporate leaders to receive an incentive to remain in their jobs and seek a resolution to the company's difficulties. "We ended up with something that we think is fair," he said. The creditors' committee includes financial heavyweights Bank of America and Merrill Lynch, as well as power giants Enron Corp. and Dynegy Inc. The committee's actions set the tone for PG&E's dealings with its thousands of other creditors, who are owed more than $9 billion. Harvey Rosenfield, head of the Foundation for Taxpayer and Consumer Rights in Santa Monica, said that by accepting the bonus plan for PG&E's top brass, the creditors' committee had signaled that it would agree to almost anything that would help them recover outstanding costs. "The creditors are in this to get reimbursed fully," he said. "Their idea is to ultimately soak ratepayers for the entire cost of the bankruptcy." Marks said the creditors would seek nothing less than full payment of PG&E's obligations. "We're very firm on this," he said. Full payment will only come if the bankruptcy court sells off some of PG&E's assets, such as the utility's power lines or dams, or if consumers end up paying surcharges on their monthly bills. To date, PG&E has insisted that none of its assets are for sale. E-mail David Lazarus at dlazarus@sfchronicle.com. ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle ? Page?A - 4 56% favor limits on electricity prices, poll finds Washington Post Tuesday, June 5, 2001 ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle URL: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/chronicle/archive/2001/06/05/M N212214.DTL Washington -- Most respondents to a Washington Post-ABC News poll released yesterday agree with California Gov. Gray Davis that the federal government should set limits on the wholesale price of electricity, which President Bush has said he opposes amid the likelihood of rolling blackouts this summer in the largest state. Of those polled, 56 percent said they favored price limits, even though it was pointed out that such a measure could discourage development of new supplies. Forty percent said they opposed price caps, which Davis said he would seek in federal court after Bush ruled out the idea during a face-to- face meeting last week. Bush's energy plan, which he announced last month and has been promoting with a series of road trips, is weighted toward increasing production of oil, coal and natural gas, as well as nuclear power. Democrats contend the plan would benefit the energy industry without lowering prices for consumers. The poll of 1,004 adults was taken May 31 through Sunday and has an error margin of plus or minus 3 percentage points. ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle ? Page?A - 4 Developments in California's energy crisis Tuesday, June 5, 2001 ,2001 Associated Press URL: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/news/archive/2001/06/05/state1 022EDT0151.DTL (06-05) 00:03 PDT (AP) -- Developments in California's energy crisis: TUESDAY: * A leading advocacy group for the poor tells state leaders to use the economic power of the state's huge pension funds to leverage power companies. The Pacific Institute for Community Organization says the two pension funds own at least $1.2 billion in stocks and bonds in most of the firms that sell electricity to California. MONDAY: * A special Senate committee investigating whether out-of-state power companies are illegally profiteering the state's power crisis gets permission from the Senate Rules Committee to subpoena documents from the companies detailing bidding, pricing and other aspects of their electricity sales to the state. The committee plans to subpoena Mirant, Dynegy, Williams, AES, Duke, Enron, NRG and Reliant, and could also issue subpoenas to the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power and the state Department of Water Resources to access details of their power selling and buying processes, respectively. * The state's grid operator says California's electricity production should improve in the coming weeks as more power plants come back on line after spring maintenance shutdowns. That, coupled with conservation efforts, could help during this summer's high temperatures, independent observers say -- but not enough to stave off blackouts. * The state's expanded Low Income Home Energy Assistance Program (LIHEAP) program begins with $120 million in state money. It is aimed at helping working poor households, senior citizens, disabled persons, migrant seasonal farm workers, limited-English-speaking persons and households with very young children whose incomes fall at or below 250 percent of the federal poverty level. That includes households with four members having an annual gross income of $44,125 or less; three-member households earning $36,575 or less; two-member families earning $29,025 or less; and individuals earning under $21,475. Further information is available at www.csd.ca.gov or at 1-800-433-4327 (HEAP). * Ten schools in three Southern California districts cut their electricity waste up to 18 percent through the Alliance to Save Energy's Green Schools Program. Together, the schools saved more than $51,000 over about eight months by changing their usage habits, according to Southern California Edison, which sponsored the program. More information is available at www.ase.org/greenschools. * Critics tell the San Jose Mercury News that the federal agency overseeing California's electricity market needs to add resources and become more aggressive in watching for energy price gouging, issuing subpoenas for company documents if necessary. The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission has been accused of backing off investigations after energy generators have resisted, prompting some FERC officials to say their own system is flawed. * The FERC issues a statement saying it won't act on a request from small power generators to block a March 27 decision from the state Public Utilities Commission that has lowered the price they can charge for electricity. FERC says it won't step in because the matter is still pending at the PUC. * No power alerts Monday as electricity reserves stay above 7 percent. * Shares of Edison International closed at $10.58, down 42 cents. PG&E Corp. closed at $11.40, down 25 cents. Sempra Energy, the parent company of San Diego Gas & Electric, closes at $27.34, up 20 cents. WHAT'S NEXT: * Davis' representatives continue negotiating with Sempra, the parent company of San Diego Gas and Electric Co., to buy the utility's transmission lines. * In federal bankruptcy court Tuesday, Pacific Gas and Electric will ask U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Dennis Montali to stop the manager of the state's power grid from buying electricity for utility or charging it for any electricity bought after the utility filed for bankruptcy on April 6. THE PROBLEM: High demand, high wholesale energy costs, transmission glitches and a tight supply worsened by scarce hydroelectric power in the Northwest and maintenance at aging California power plants are all factors in California's electricity crisis. Edison and PG&E say they've lost nearly $14 billion since June to high wholesale prices the state's electricity deregulation law bars them from passing on to consumers. PG&E, saying it hasn't received the help it needs from regulators or state lawmakers, filed for federal bankruptcy protection April 6. Electricity and natural gas suppliers, scared off by the two companies' poor credit ratings, are refusing to sell to them, leading the state in January to start buying power for the utilities' nearly 9 million residential and business customers. The state is also buying power for a third investor-owned utility, San Diego Gas & Electric, which is in better financial shape than much larger Edison and PG&E but also struggling with high wholesale power costs. The Public Utilities Commission has approved average rate increases of 37 percent for the heaviest residential customers and 38 percent for commercial customers, and hikes of up to 49 percent for industrial customers and 15 percent or 20 percent for agricultural customers to help finance the state's multibillion-dollar power buys. ,2001 Associated Press ? PG&E sues to challenge reimbursement to state Greg Lucas, Sacramento Bureau Chief Tuesday, June 5, 2001 ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle URL: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/chronicle/archive/2001/06/05/M N52029.DTL Sacramento -- Saying it is being shortchanged, Pacific Gas and Electric Co. filed suit yesterday challenging the amount of money California will get from consumers as reimbursement for buying electricity. The suit filed with the state appellate court in San Francisco claims that the California Public Utilities Commission is giving the state too big a share of the monthly revenue collected from consumers -- all at PG&E's expense. The suit by PG&E was expected. If the utility wins, it could make it harder and longer for the state to recoup its power purchases. The state stepped in to purchase wholesale electricity for the utilities after their credit soured as power costs skyrocketed. The state has spent more than $7 billion so far with reimbursement expected from consumers. Earlier, Southern California Edison filed a similar legal challenge. At issue is the amount of money the utilities receive from consumers and the amount given to the state to cover electricity purchases. PG&E contends that the PUC's calculation puts the utility $2.2 billion in the hole because state regulators underestimated the cost of running the nuclear power plant at Diablo Canyon and the cost of contracts with alternative energy producers, like solar and wind generators. The utility wants its share of consumer revenue increased, leaving less for the state. Under a bill lawmakers passed in January, it was the calculation of how much of consumer money was needed to reimburse the state for energy purchases that would dictate how many bonds the state could sell to repay itself. The limit on bond sales was four times that calculation, totaling about $13 billion. But both utilities challenged the PUC's initial decision, saying it was too generous to the state. Fearing legal action from the utilities, lawmakers passed a second bill in May that delinked the authorization to sell up to $13.4 billion in bonds from the calculation of how much consumer money the utilities receive. That bill allows the bond sale to happen as early as Aug. 14. As a result, yesterday the Davis administration and State Treasurer Phil Angelides said the utilities' move did not affect the bond sale, scheduled for late summer. "This doesn't create chaos, it just means we can't sell the bond until the middle of August," said Joseph Fichera, CEO of Saber Partners and one of Gov. Gray Davis' energy advisers. Had the utilities not appealed, the PUC's ruling would have allowed the bond sale to occur sooner, Fichera said. In its initial ruling in March, the PUC said its allocation of ratepayer money would send $1.8 billion to help pay off the state's bond sale. Fichera said a utility court victory could potentially lead to more rate increases to cover the lost income to the state but added he was "not certain." E-mail Greg Lucas at glucas@sfchronicle.com. ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle ? Page?A - 5 Critics say Calpine plan too generous Posted at 10:35 p.m. PDT Monday, June 4, 2001 BY MIKE ZAPLER Mercury News In what would be a highly unusual break for a local business, San Jose officials are proposing to rewrite city law and spend tens of millions in taxpayer funds to ease construction of Calpine's controversial power plant in Coyote Valley. The provisions highlight just how far the city has come on Calpine's proposed 600-megawatt Metcalf Energy Center. Just months ago, city leaders stood in solid opposition to the $400 million project, threatening lawsuits and other tactics to block it. Now, those same officials appear ready to go to extraordinary lengths to make Metcalf happen. Part of an agreement reached last week by Mayor Ron Gonzales and the company would require the city to pay $50 million upfront to extend a recycled-water pipeline needed to cool the power plant. Calpine will reimburse San Jose for just $10 million of that cost, far less than the city had sought, and will make its payments over 30 years. Another clause would allow Calpine, which reported an increase in first-quarter profits of more than 400 percent, to spread over 10 years a $3.9 million sewer connection fee. That would be a first for the city. Typically those levies are collected upfront; the city council would have to amend a law that set a five-year limit on sewer connection payments. ``I'm not comfortable with that,'' said Councilman and Metcalf opponent Forrest Williams, whose District 2 would be home to Metcalf. ``They're a very profitable company .?.?. they should pay the connection fee.'' Councilwoman Pat Dando said the overall agreement, set to be considered by the council this afternoon, is probably the best the city could do under the circumstances. But she added: ``I believe Calpine's payment should be the same as other businesses that develop in San Jose.'' The money for the pipeline would come from a fund to expand and increase the reliability of the entire recycled-water system. Projects the city had planned to build sooner would have to be delayed, but the water pollution control plant would not raise rates to pay for the Metcalf extension, environmental services director Carl Mosher said. Company at advantage The criticized provisions are part of a larger package settled on after roughly five weeks of negotiations. The talks occurred in a political atmosphere that heavily favored the power company: Gov. Gray Davis endorsed Metcalf in April, and the California Energy Commission is widely expected this month to override the city's November denial of the plant. Mayor Ron Gonzales and Calpine executives defended the deal, saying its unusual terms were tailored to a unique project. Metcalf, they said, would become the city's biggest customer of recycled water, consuming an average of 3 million gallons daily -- or nearly one-third of the current total usage -- to cool the plant. That would help the city achieve its goal of reducing freshwater usage and diverting more water from the San Francisco Bay for ecological reasons. And the city would receive other concessions from Calpine, supporters say, including two extra air-monitoring stations and $6.5 million mostly for parks and open space. ``The energy crisis requires us to do business differently than we have in the past,'' Gonzales said. ``When you take the entire package it's a win-win for the city.'' Critics, while acknowledging that Calpine had a commanding position at the bargaining table, say the city still is giving up too much. They questioned why Calpine is paying only $10 million -- one-fifth of the total cost -- to extend the water pipeline, when Metcalf will be its sole customer, at least in the near future. The city entered negotiations with Calpine wanting the company to cover the entire $50 million cost of the pipeline extension, a senior city official said. Others involved in the negotiations say that was never officially broached by the city, although Calpine development manager Ken Abreu acknowledged that ``obviously the city would have been happy for us to pay for as much of the pipeline as possible.'' That's what the city should be demanding, said Issa Ajlouny, a resident of the Santa Teresa neighborhood adjacent to Metcalf and leading opponent of the plant. ``This agreement is giving away millions of dollars of our money,'' he said. ``The city should be outraged.'' Early last year, according to city officials and transcripts of a California Energy Commission hearing, the city and Calpine had an understanding that the power company would pay at least $25 million to $30 million for the recycled-water line if the power plant were built. If San Jose decided to construct a larger pipeline to serve more customers, the city would make up the difference. Deal fell apart But that informal arrangement fell apart when Metcalf emerged as a major political battle. Gonzales came out against the plant in June 2000, and the council went on to vote against it in November. By the time the negotiations began, Calpine didn't really need the city's help. All indications were that the California Energy Commission would override the city and approve the plant anyway. What emerged from the talks was a $10 million payment, spread over 30 years, from Calpine for the recycled-water line. Company officials say that 20 percent is roughly the same share of the pipeline capacity Metcalf would use. The other 80 percent has yet to be allocated, but officials said they hope to sign up other recycled-water users, such as golf courses. ``Our perspective is we're doing what's fair,'' Calpine's Abreu said. As the agreement heads to the council this afternoon, some neighborhood activists are accusing the council of trying to suppress public debate. Often, controversial neighborhood issues are heard at evening sessions to give working residents a chance to be heard. ``This certainly creates an appearance that they're trying to stifle public input,'' said Elizabeth Cord of the Santa Teresa Citizen Action Group. She said consideration should be delayed until the next evening council meeting June 18 to give residents time to review the document. But Gonzales said he's not inclined to defer the item. He said today's meeting is already filled with difficult land-use decisions. ``We have already heard from the neighborhood,'' he said. ``It was their concerns we negotiated.'' Contact Mike Zapler at mzapler@sjmercury.com or at (408) 275-0140. PBS documentary shines light on energy crisis LOS ANGELES (AP) -- As California's energy crisis casts a widening shadow, PBS' ``Frontline'' helps illuminate the issue with a high-wattage documentary. ``Blackout'' is both a comprehensive report and a warning: California's power deregulation woes represent a national problem not destined for a quick or painless solution. The hourlong film, with reporting by ``Frontline'' correspondent Lowell Bergman done in conjunction with The New York Times, airs 10 p.m. EDT Tuesday on PBS stations (check local listings). If you're a consumer frustrated by price hikes or concerned about what might happen in your state, ``Blackout'' should be considered required viewing. Major players, ranging from power company chiefs to consumer advocates to Vice President Dick Cheney, make their case on energy policy. Gov. Gray Davis and others grappling with California's flawed new system, which has inspired many states to put their own deregulation efforts on hold, are interviewed. ``Blackout'' also touches on alleged machinations involving the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission that could affect how much, if at all, the federal government will weigh in on power prices, and renews questions about corporate influence on the Bush administration. What ultimately emerges is a classic debate, framed in 2001 political realities, over whether an unfettered market is invariably the best approach or whether capitalism sometimes must bend to regulation. Bergman is adamant about the importance of understanding a power industry that has undergone massive change. ``We've launched ourselves into a great economic and social experiment in the free market with a commodity that 65 years ago the country decided to put under heavy regulation because it was so vital,'' he said in an interview. ``We've gone into this experiment without having a full national debate about what the consequences could be,'' Bergman said. ``It may all work out, but it's clear that we're at least in a transition period where a lot of people are going to pay the price.'' In New York, for instance, blackouts are a possibility this summer and rate hikes of up to 40 percent a likelihood, Bergman said. There are those striking it rich in this bold new world. ``Blackout'' opens on Houston's ``energy alley,'' home to new-breed power companies including what the documentary calls the 800-pound gorilla, Enron Corp. Enron, which has drawn attention because of chairman Kenneth Lay's close ties to President Bush, generates profits by serving as middleman between electricity makers and consumers. The world's largest energy trader, Enron sees from $2.5 billion to $3 billion in purchases and sales a day, according to its chief executive officer, Jeff Skilling. ``We are doing the right thing,'' Skilling tells ``Blackout.'' ``We are working to create open, competitive, fair markets. ... We are the good guys. We are on the side of angels.'' If that's true, Bergman says in the film, the good guys have been winning: The past year saw a ``vast transfer'' of wealth from energy consumers to power sellers and traders like Enron. They are taking advantage of the end of an era: the federal regulatory system implemented by President Franklin D. Roosevelt in the 1930s to limit abuses by utility monopolies. In the 1980s, ``Blackout'' tells us, free-market proponents began pushing for an end to regulation. In 1992, a federal law was passed that allowed for states to deregulate electricity. There was broad but not unanimous support for such change. ``It's OK for the price of fur coats to go up and down. ... It's not OK for the oxygen of life in this high-energy civilization,'' David Freeman, the former Los Angeles Department of Water and Power head and now state energy czar, tells ``Blackout.'' Mark Cooper, director of research at the Consumer Federation of America, who notes there have already been price spikes in electricity in the Midwest and New England, says the outcome speaks for itself. ``How do we go from $40 a megawatt for capacity in a regulated system to $1,000 in a deregulated system, and you're telling me I'm better off?'' Cooper asks in the documentary. Enron's Lay weighs in on the other side. ``I've yet to see any system in the world ... that over time does a better job of setting prices and allocating supplies than a competitive market,'' Lay says in ``Blackout.'' He has a key philosophical ally in the Bush administration, which says increased supply and not federal intervention is the logical answer. ``We're doing everything we can to help California on a short-term basis,'' Cheney says. ``There's not a lot you can do. You can't manufacture kilowatts in the West Wing of the White House.'' Bergman, the former ''60 Minutes'' producer who was portrayed in the movie ``The Insider,'' believes there is one certainty about the power crisis: The media generally has given it short shrift. ``Unfortunately this story has been covered, particularly on television, in much the same way a car crash is covered. You never learn whether the car was safe or the highway was safe. You just see the blood and guts.'' ``Nobody's spent the air time to explain to people how this all happened and why this may be coming to a neighborhood near you.'' California's big turnoff Published Tuesday, June 5, 2001, in the San Jose Mercury News IF you ask us, we will cut back. California's residents and businesses used 11 percent less electricity in May 2001 than they did in May 2000. Keeping up this level of conservation throughout the summer won't necessarily insulate the state from blackouts, but it's a big deal all the same. State power officials have said May and June could be the most difficult months this year. Additional power is expected to come on line later in the summer. The most important time to cut back is at the peak of demand, usually hot afternoons, when blackouts are most likely and the cost of buying electricity can shoot up stupefyingly. With Californians having cut peak usage by 10.4 percent, the price for the power that the state is buying on the daily market is coming down. June marks the beginning of the state's 20/20 rebate plan, under which customers who reduce their use at least 20 percent from last year will get a 20 percent rebate. It also marks the introduction of new, higher rates for businesses and for many households. All the more reason for Californians to keep up the good work. FERC shirk Published Tuesday, June 5, 2001, in the San Jose Mercury News THE introduction of a free market in electricity is not cause for federal energy regulators to start working half days. Instead, their jobs could well become harder and more vital. As of now, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission does not seem up to the task. In a pair of stories Sunday and Monday, Mercury News reporters Eric Nalder and Mark Gladstone described how FERC is unprepared to undertake the extensive data-gathering and sophisticated number-crunching necessary to detect market manipulation in the complicated wholesale electricity market. Market manipulation, or gaming, encompasses many activities that are entirely legal. But a market easily gamed is one that does not provide electricity at the best prices to consumers. It is a market in need of reform. Moreover, it is one that does not conform to federal law requiring electricity prices to be ``just and reasonable,'' which FERC is supposed to enforce. Economists inside and outside FERC say the agency lacks the staff and the attitude to be a vigorous supervisor of the market. This is not entirely surprising. FERC is hardly the electricity industry's only player, public or private, to be caught unprepared by the way a restructured market evolved in California and other states. FERC's investigation of price spikes in California early last summer demonstrated its shortcomings. Its report correctly fingered the usual suspects of weather, rising demand, stagnant supply and a badly constructed market. It failed to decide whether power producers had taken advantage of the circumstances to push prices skyward. The economist who directed the probe found it weak in analysis and in aggressiveness. FERC, for instance, is reluctant to use its subpoena authority to compel power generators to turn over records. The deficiencies must be remedied. A free market in electricity should not be an unsupervised market, just as the free market for stocks is not unsupervised. The Securities and Exchange Commission aggressively enforces rules for accounting, stock sales, disclosure of information. It doesn't hesitate to issue subpoenas. Only FERC can monitor the wholesale market in electricity. If only it would do it. Edison plugging shareholders into Capitol A telephone lobbying effort for Davis' bailout has earned the wrath of legislators. June 5, 2001 By HANH KIM QUACH The Orange County Register SACRAMENTO - Southern California Edison has launched an aggressive lobbying campaign in which it telephones its shareholders, describes the dire consequences for them if the utility goes bankrupt, and then transfers the call directly to the Capitol so they can personally implore lawmakers to vote for a controversial financial bailout plan. The members of the Senate and Assembly and their staffers say that often the shareholders - many of whom appear to be senior citizens - are confused, and scared at the prospect of their investments in the utility being permanently degraded or wiped out. The tactic has raised the ire of legislators in both parties, although the cash-strapped utility says it is simply practicing honest, effective lobbying. "The fact that they're targeting them is distressing because it brings a threatening situation to their lives," said Assemblywoman Pat Bates, R-Laguna Niguel. "You have a very vulnerable population and I think it's extremely insensitive.'' But Edison International's vice president of public affairs, Brian Bennett, said keeping shareholders informed and asking for their help is part of the company's obligation to them. Calling shareholders, many of whom happen to be older, is part of a very above-board $3 million campaign that includes letters, financial reports and television commercials to tell them about what's happening in Sacramento, he said. The thrust of the message is that if the Legislature continues to try to craft its own plan, rather than quickly endorse one that Gov. Gray Davis and Edison favor, the utility could be forced into bankruptcy by its creditors. "We would feel less inclined to spend money if the Legislature would act faster. Then, we wouldn't have to run to commercials and remind the public we are in dire straits,'' Bennett said. "Legislators need to hear from their constituents back home, particularly the retirees because of the drop in stock income.'' The lobbying effort comes at a critical juncture. The Davis-Edison plan calls for the state's taxpayers to come to Edison's rescue by purchasing the company's transmission lines for $2.7 billion, thus providing it with enough money to hold off creditors who threaten to push the utility into bankruptcy. Meanwhile, the legislative leadership has been looking at several versions of that same plan. The latest would force the state's 3,600 largest businesses - those that pushed for deregulation - to pay for most of the bailout. Lawmakers don't think the Edison lobbying campaign is that effective. Often, the callers don't know that the Davis-Edison plan would have the state buy the transmission lines. And once they do, they often change their minds, lawmakers said. The last thing many shareholders want is for the state to be in charge of transporting electricity, particularly after many believe it bungled the deregulation of the market in the first place. But Bennett said it's unfair for lawmakers to assume the callers are not well-informed. "Our shareholders are average people. But if you're a shareholder and you've seen the dramatic decline of the company, do you think they don't know what they're talking about or feeling?'' he said. Three Orange County shareholders contacted by Edison representatives said they did not mind being asked to lobby for the bailout bill. However, one said he did not know some of its key points and the another said he didn't realize it was Edison who had called him. Roberto Chica of Laguna Niguel didn't know the state would acquire transmission lines for $2.7 billion - and is against it. "The state should own nothing. They don't have any business in any of this,'' said Chica, 59, who owns 1,000 shares of Edison. At one point, he said, his stock was worth $30,000 - three times what it is now. Even though Chica doesn't agree fully with the deal, he agrees with Edison's larger goal: avoiding bankruptcy. "It's a mess. You rely on this investment for the long term and the politicians screw it up and you get scared,'' Chica said. San Clemente's Fred Beck, 74, said he didn't know who called him, but he agreed to be patched through to a Bates aide, to whom he expressed his anger about the energy crisis in general. Beck said he bought his stock in 1993 for the dividends it would pay out during retirement. He paid about $23 a share; they now trade around $10. SDG&E to seek rate hike to cover $915 million tab That amount was needed to pay another agency for electricity. June 5, 2001 By ANNE C. MULKERN The Orange County Register The power company that serves 100,000 south Orange County residents wants to hike electricity rates to pay back the state for power purchases. San Diego Gas & Electric Co. proposes raising rates in a five-tiered plan similar to one approved in May for Southern California Edison customers. The utility needs to collect $915 million to pay the Department of Water Resources, which is buying power for cash-strapped utilities. The hike would be greatest for those using the most power. Low-income customers and those using 130 percent or less of their baseline allocation would not see any rate hike. Baseline is the amount of power considered necessary for essential uses. About 60 percent of customers wouldn't pay higher rates, said SDG&E spokesman Ed van Herick. Customers who use the most - 300 percent of their baseline or more - would pay 26.67 cents per kilowatt hour for that extra power, more than twice the lowest rate. State regulators will vote on the proposal June 28 and, if approved, it would take effect July 1. The proposed increase is in addition to another hike SDG&E applied for earlier this year. Regulators will vote on that hike this summer. Consumer activist Michael Shames, of the Utility Consumers Action Network, expressed concern that DWR's need for additional funds could lead to a rate increase without consideration for what is fair and reasonable. "There is no apparent check on DWR's appetite," Shames said. "The law is not clear as to whether (regulators) review DWR's purchases for reasonableness, whether they are legitimate and justified. Absent that, there's a clear unbalance." The Public Utilities Commission will hold hearings to take comments on the plan. The Orange County hearing will begin at 1 p.m. June 12 at the Country Inn Hotel, 35 Via Pico Plaza, San Clemente. Register staff writer Mary Ann Milbourn contibuted to this report. Energy notebook AES power plant repairs might not meet target date. June 5, 2001 From staff and news service reports HUNTINGTON BEACH - AES Corp.'s Huntington Beach power plant is struggling to get two of its generating units online by a June 17 target, but might be delayed by a few days. The two units, which generate 430 megawatts of electricity, were taken offline in April for a turbine overhaul and installation of catalytic converters to reduce smog emissions. But power plant workers found more damage than expected to the turbines, and parts to repair the equipment are hard to find. "We're still shooting for the deadline," said Ed Blackford, the plant's president, referring to units 1 and 2. The plant's units 3 and 4, which have been shut down for several years, are being retooled and are expected to be online by mid-August. State says Edison rescue deadline goes past Friday ROSEMEAD - California power regulators don't have to act on Gov. Gray Davis' rescue plan for Southern California Edison by Friday, as provided in the agreement, a state energy official said. That statement by California Public Utilities Commissioner Carl Woods surprised Edison's investors and officials. Under Davis' "memorandum of understanding" with Edison, the regulators had 60 days to act on six elements of the rescue. That deadline is Friday. PUC officials think it would be "acceptable" for the agency to act by August, Wood said. If the PUC doesn't meet the Friday deadline, the utility's creditors may decide the agreement will die and file to put it into bankruptcy. San Onofre Unit 3 back in full operation over weekend SAN CLEMENTE - Workers at the San Onofre Nuclear Generating Plant successfully brought Unit 3 into full operation over the weekend, providing an additional 1,120 megawatts of electricity. Operators began to bring the unit online gradually beginning Friday. Ray Golden, Southern California Edison spokesman, said it became fully operational Sunday. The unit had been closed since Jan. 2, first for refueling then after a fire Feb. 3 forced repair of the turbines. Combined with Unit 2, the plant now provides 2,240 megawatts - enough to power 1.68 million homes. Unit 1 is in the process of being decommissioned. 9,000 blackout-exemption applications flood the PUC SAN FRANCISCO - The state Public Utilities Commission had received more than 9,000 applications from businesses seeking exemptions from blackouts by the 5 p.m. deadline Monday. The commission is expected to make a final decision by Aug. 2 on who will get the relatively few additional exemptions available. To get an exemption, a company must show that there would be a threat to public health and safety if it were to lose power. Power production expected to improve in weeks ahead SACRAMENTO - California's electricity production should improve in the coming weeks as more power plants come back online after spring maintenance shutdowns, the state's grid operator said Monday. That, coupled with conservation efforts detailed by state officials Sunday, could help during the summer, independent observers said - but not enough to stave off blackouts. By mid-June, every existing plant is scheduled to be producing power in some or all units. Federal regulator says California's ills a priority WASHINGTON - New federal energy regulator Patrick Henry Wood III says California's electricity crisis is a national emergency requiring a federal solution. Only a month ago, Vice President Dick Cheney opposed further federal action to help California with chronic power blackouts and price shocks this summer. But Wood, the outgoing chairman of the Texas Public Utility Commission, said fixing California's electricity market was his top priority in his new job with the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission. Register staff writers Kate Berry and Mary Ann Milbourn and Bloomberg News, Knight Ridder Newspapers and the Associated Press contributed to this report. GWF Signs Long-Term Contract to Provide 430 MW of Power to California June 5, 2001 PITTSBURG, Calif.--(BUSINESS WIRE)--June 4, 2001 via NewsEdge Corporation - California-based GWF Energy LLC has signed a 10-year contract with the California Department of Water Resources (CDWR) to provide up to 430 megawatts of electricity to California. According to the contract, initial energy deliveries are planned to begin in September 2001, when GWF's 90 megawatt Hanford Energy Park Peaker plant goes on line. The Hanford project, which was permitted under Governor Davis' Executive Order to expedite peaker plant permitting, was approved by the California Energy Commission on May 10. GWF also expects to build and operate two additional plants in California by 2002 -- in Kings and San Joaquin counties. "GWF and its employees appreciate the opportunity to work with CDWR in providing much-needed electricity supply along North Path 15," said Duane Nelsen, President of GWF Energy LLC. "All of the agencies involved in this process have been working around the clock to expedite the construction of this facility -- so California can get the additional energy it needs. We're proud to be part of the solution." GWF began operations in the 1980s and currently owns and/or operates seven small power generating facilities in Central and Northern California -- generating more than 1,000,000 megawatt hours of electricity annually for Pacific Gas & Electric. GWF is owned by a partnership of PSEG Global located in Parsippany, New Jersey; and Harbert Cogen located in Birmingham, Alabama. CONTACT: GWF Power Systems | Kelli Norton, 916/447-8186 Electricity Prices (Chart) ? 06/05/2001 The Wall Street Journal Page A1 (Copyright (c) 2001, Dow Jones & Company, Inc.) The Mirant National Power Index, a demand-weighted average price for peak-period electricity in the continental U.S., in dollars per megawatt-hour; daily close Business/Financial Desk; Section A Surplus of Finger-Pointing In California Energy Crisis By RICHARD A. OPPEL Jr. ? 06/05/2001 The New York Times Page 1, Column 1 c. 2001 New York Times Company Natural gas prices have plunged in the last few months -- everywhere, that is, but Southern California. While gas in New York costs about $4 per thousand cubic feet, gas delivered to Southern California still costs more than $11 wholesale. That such numbers demand an explanation was about the only thing President Bush and Gov. Gray Davis could agree on when they met in Los Angeles a few days ago to discuss California's energy crisis. Mr. Bush assigned Patrick H. Wood III, a fellow Texan confirmed last month as a member of the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, to investigate. To many experts, the woes of California's natural gas market are as profound as those of its electricity market: the state is short on pipelines, and the rules of the gas market, critics say, encourage sellers and traders -- including the biggest local gas utility -- to drive prices higher. At peak times, half of California's electricity is generated by gas-fired power plants, a higher proportion than in most parts of the country. And because 85 percent of the gas consumed in California comes from outside the state, the shortage of pipelines both into California and within the state has become a big handicap in fueling those plants. The strain has become especially acute as drought in the Pacific Northwest has curtailed imports of hydropower and gas-fired power plants have worked overtime to meet the demands of a booming state economy. Vice President Dick Cheney's energy policy report last month proposed initiatives to speed approval and construction of new pipelines, noting that New England and other regions faced capacity squeezes, too. The report says that the United States needs 38,000 miles of new gas transmission pipelines, almost a 20 percent increase. In the meantime, some industry executives and public officials take the argument one step further than the Bush administration, contending that today's shortage of capacity has made it possible for energy companies, intent on maximizing profits, to manipulate prices. ''It really strains credulity to say this is a functioning market,'' said Representative Joe Barton, Republican of Texas, who as chairman of the House energy subcommittee has been leaning on the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission to scrutinize the California gas market. ''Reasonable people could conclude people have gamed the system.'' In one significant case, California utility regulators and Southern California Edison, one of the state's struggling electric utilities, have accused the El Paso Corporation of using its control of a major pipeline into the state to inflate prices artificially. El Paso officials deny wrongdoing and accuse California officials of making the company a scapegoat for the state's failure to build more pipelines. A judge at the federal energy commission is hearing the case in Washington. But fingers are pointing in other directions, too. For example, the Southern California Gas Company, the state's largest gas utility, has reaped huge profits buying and selling gas in the last year -- activity encouraged by state regulations intended to lower gas prices for consumers. But some gas marketers and electricity generators contend that the trading has contributed to price spikes, by tying up valuable pipeline space during peak times with gas shipments driven by financial deals, not power demands. At the same time, Edison says that Southern California Gas failed to put enough gas into storage last fall for residential and small-business customers. If so, that would have driven the gas company back into the market in the winter, when demand from power plant operators was high, helping push gas -- and hence electricity -- prices yet higher, Edison complains. Between them, El Paso and Southern California Gas were responsible for $3.7 billion in excess prices for energy in the last year, Edison contends. Southern California Gas, a unit of Sempra Energy, denies that its trading has harmed the market. Rather, its executives note that electricity generators and industrial gas consumers -- which under state rules are responsible for managing their own gas supplies -- put very little gas into storage last year. By one estimate, large gas consumers in Southern California had only 11 percent as much gas in storage at the end of November as they did at the same time during the prior two years. Another problem may emerge this summer, according to William L. Massey, a member of the federal energy commission. Mr. Massey said new commission rules intended to limit electricity price spikes in California will almost certainly prompt energy-trading companies -- which deal in both gas and electricity -- to manipulate gas prices. That is because the rules allow electricity generators to charge more if gas prices move higher. Similarly, growing attention is being paid to the role played by financial trading tied to the price of electricity and natural gas. Industry critics question whether huge trading volumes in these financial derivatives gives energy marketing companies the incentive to manipulate prices in tight markets. Federal regulators ''don't seem to understand that firms are really trying to make as much money as they can,'' said Severin Borenstein, director of the University of California Energy Institute, a research organization on the Berkeley campus. ''That's what they do for a living.'' Fixing the problem is simple, Mr. Borenstein said. ''If you build more capacity,'' he said, ''you reduce both the scarcity issue and you reduce the ability of people who currently own capacity to exercise market power.'' Regardless of whether companies are manipulating prices, the California natural gas market is fattening bottom lines. In the El Paso case, testimony has shown that pipeline capacity acquired by the company's marketing affiliate in March 2000 for $38.5 million produced profits of almost $900 million over the next 13 months. El Paso said its share of those profits was $184 million, the rest going to other companies with which it entered into hedging transactions intended to limit El Paso's exposure if gas prices fell. About half of those transactions were with the biggest energy trader, the Enron Corporation, according to people present at briefings El Paso officials have given to California officials. An Enron spokesman, Mark Palmer, said it was possible that Enron took the other side of the trades, but he said that Enron would have resold the pipeline capacity almost immediately, thus profiting little from the rise of gas prices in California. Federal regulators, concerned that the high gas prices in California may not be legitimate, have proposed requiring companies selling gas in the state to disclose extensive data about their transactions. They are also considering whether to reimpose price caps on short-term sales of pipeline capacity that were eliminated early last year. Further, regulators are scrutinizing the so-called gray market in which energy marketers bundle gas and transmission capacity and sell it to large customers, like electricity generators, for one price. Federal regulators have oversight responsibility for the interstate portion of gas shipments, but they have not looked closely at these bundled transactions, Mr. Massey said. ''The whole thing has fallen through the cracks,'' he said. Nearly all of California's gas comes from the Southwest, the Rocky Mountain states and Canada through a few huge, highly pressurized pipelines. In California, the gas is shunted onto intrastate pipelines that deliver it to consumers and to underground storage fields for later use. Those pipelines are now largely running full, and their capacity is about 300 million cubic feet a day less than what interstate pipelines can deliver. The difference is the amount of gas it takes to continuously fuel a 1,300 megawatt power plant -- enough to light more than a million homes. ''It's not resources, it's straws -- the straws needed to suck this gas where it needs to go,'' said Thom Kelly, assistant executive director of the California Energy Commission. ''If the straws are full, that's a problem.'' Operators of interstate pipelines have proposed new construction that could double delivery to the state. Indeed, odd as it seems now, some in the industry worry that California could be ''overpiped'' later this decade, just as it was in the mid-1990's. Likewise, Southern California Gas plans only limited expansion of its in-state pipelines, partly because it expects demand to fall as hydroelectric power supplies return to normal levels and older, less efficient gas-fired power plants are phased out. But the gas company's intentions are regarded with skepticism by others in the industry. Some executives contend that Southern California Gas has damaged the marketplace through its enthusiastic embrace of a state program that allows it to split with customers the profits from buying, selling and lending gas. A coalition of power generators, including Reliant Energy, the Williams Companies and the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power, has complained to state officials that the program ''creates perverse incentives'' for the gas company. The generators say it results in extra demand for pipeline space when capacity already is at a premium, making prices more volatile. The consequences of the gas company's low storage inventories were evident in early December, according to John Stout, a senior Reliant executive. He recalled listening in on a conference call as a Southern California Gas official talked about injecting gas into storage. ''I was floored,'' Mr. Stout said. ''Prices were sky high, and they were putting more upward pressure on prices.'' Lee M. Stewart, president of energy transportation services for Southern California Gas, called the criticism ''bogus.'' The utility's storage and trading practices have neither hurt the market nor curtailed gas sales to customers, he said. ''To say gas prices drive electricity prices is a falsehood,'' Mr. Stewart added. But to many regulators, it is clear that gas prices play an increasingly important role in electricity prices. Problems in the California natural gas markets ''haven't been given the prominence they deserve for the detrimental role they are playing in high electricity prices,'' said Linda K. Breathitt, another member of the federal energy commission. ''Natural gas prices have been the stepchild of this California crisis.'' This article is part of a joint reporting project with the PBS series ''Frontline,'' which will broadcast a documentary about California's energy crisis tonight. Photo: This Redondo Beach, Calif., power plant, owned by the AES Corporation, uses natural gas, as do almost half of the state's electric plants. About 85 percent of the gas consumed in California comes from outside the state. (Agence France-Presse)(pg. C12) Chart/Map: ''A Vital Network Under Pressure'' Though California is crisscrossed by natural gas pipelines, capacity is limited, magnifying the state's energy woes. Half of California's electricity is generated by gas-fired power plants, and the shortage of highly pressurized pipelines both into California and within the state has become a big handicap in fueling those plants. (Source: California Energy Commission)(pg. C12) Business; Financial Desk California PSEG Signs 10-Year Contract to Supply Electricity to State ? 06/05/2001 Los Angeles Times Home Edition Page C-2 Copyright 2001 / The Times Mirror Company A California unit of Public Service Enterprise Group agreed to sell up to 430 megawatts of electricity to the state's Department of Water Resources under a 10-year contract, the company said Monday. GWF Energy said power deliveries are expected to begin in September when its 90-megawatt "peaker" plant goes online in Hanford in California 's Central Valley. The company owns or operates seven small power units in the state and plans to build two more in the Central Valley. A peaker unit typically generates less than 300 megawatts of electricity --enough for about 300,000 homes--and runs during the hours of the highest demand for energy. The value of the contract with the water agency was not disclosed. Gov. Gray Davis ordered the agency to step in as California 's principal electricity buyer in January after PG&E Corp.'s Pacific Gas & Electric unit and Edison International's Southern California Edison subsidiary amassed about $14 billion in power purchase costs that they could not pass to customers under the state's flawed deregulation law. PSEG shares rose 29 cents to close at $51.34 on the New York Stock Exchange. California ; Metro Desk Panel OKs Subpoenas for Energy Companies Electricity : Special state Senate committee will demand pricing information in inquiry into whether California has been gouged. CARL INGRAM; MIGUEL BUSTILLO ? 06/05/2001 Los Angeles Times Home Edition Page B-1 Copyright 2001 / The Times Mirror Company SACRAMENTO -- The Senate Rules Committee agreed Monday to issue subpoenas to eight out-of-state power generating companies demanding documents on pricing, bidding and other aspects of electricity sales in the state. Sen. Joe Dunn (D-Santa Ana), chairman of the special Senate committee that is investigating whether power wholesalers are illegally profiteering from California 's energy crisis, said he expects the companies to resist. That would set the stage for a court fight, he said. In addition to subpoenas aimed at the private generating companies, the committee also put the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power on notice that unless it voluntarily provides information on its power sales to the state, the data will be subpoenaed as well. And the panel threatened to subpoena records of the state Department of Water Resources unless it turns over information on how it has spent more than $7 billion to keep electricity flowing in California . Under Senate regulations, Dunn's panel needed approval of the Rules Committee to issue the subpoenas. Industry executives deny that they have broken any laws in selling electricity at premium prices to California 's financially strapped utilities and the state water department. The subpoenas will be issued to Reliant Energy, which Gov. Gray Davis has publicly accused of price gouging, Dynegy Energy Services Inc., Williams Energy, Enron Corp., NRG Energy Inc., Duke Energy, Mirant Inc., and AES Corp. Dunn said executives of the generators seemed cooperative when the investigation was launched two months ago. Since then, he said, they have raised barriers, including demands that the confidentiality of their documents be protected. The demand for information from the Los Angeles DWP and the state's water resources department were pushed by Sen. Ross Johnson (R-Irvine), vice chairman of the rules panel. "Why are we not attempting to subpoena the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power? There certainly have been suggestions that they have profited," Johnson said, referring to reports from the California Independent System Operator about large profits that DWP made by selling power to the rest of the state. Reflecting the views of many lawmakers, Johnson said the Legislature also needs information on power purchases that the state water department makes from wholesalers and the bidding strategies used to make the bids. Davis has refused to make details of the purchases public. He contends that if generators knew how much the state was spending on power, they might raise their prices. Several news organizations and a legislator are suing to make the information public. Senate President Pro Tem John Burton (D-San Francisco), chairman of the Rules Committee, opposed issuing subpoenas to the city and state departments, at least temporarily, leading to the agreement for a one-week delay before subpoenas would be issued to the agencies. The big energy companies also took a hit Monday from a leading advocacy group for the poor. The Pacific Institute for Community Organization, a coalition of faith-based groups that has pressed for California to cover more of the millions of working citizens without any health insurance, voiced concern that the energy crisis is hitting the poor hardest. The group, which scheduled a Capitol rally today, plans to urge political leaders to use the economic power of the state's huge pension funds to leverage the companies. The two pension funds own at least $1.2 billion in stocks and bonds in most of the major firms involved in the state energy crisis, from Enron of Texas to Duke of North Carolina, the advocates said. "They could bring the voice of stockholders into the debate, as a major stockholder, and take a more enlightened view of what is happening to California ," said activist Jim Keddy. "We really have no voice inside those companies right now."