3 Jul 2001, 10:16 UTC
Energy Issues
- From
- Miyung Buster miyung.buster@enron.com
- To
-
Ann M Schmidt, Bryan Seyfried, Elizabeth Linnell, filuntz@aol.com, James D Steffes, Janet Butler, Jeannie Mandelker, Jeff Dasovich, Joe Hartsoe, John Neslage, John Sherriff, Joseph Alamo
and 48 more
Karen Denne, Mark Palmer, Mark Schroeder, Markus Fiala, Michael R Brown, Mona L Petrochko, Nicholas O'Day, Peggy Mahoney, Peter Styles, Richard Shapiro, Rob Bradley, Shelley Corman, Stella Chan, Steven J Kean, Susan J Mara, mike.roan@enron.com, Alex Parsons, andrew.morrison@enron.com, Laura Ipsen, Janel Guerrero, shirley.hudler@enron.com, Kathleen Sullivan, Tom Briggs, Linda Robertson, Lora Sullivan, Jennifer Thome, jkradin@marathon-com.com, rlichtenstein@marathon-com.com, Sandra Yamane, Ken Smith, Hedy Govenar, Scott Govenar, Bev Hansen, Carin Nersesian, Robert Neustaedter, John Shelk, Chris Holmes, Evan Hughes, Roberta Staehlin, Lamar Frazier, Ban Sharma, Pat Shortridge, Karen Moore, Kurt Lindahl, Marcus Dotson, Alan Comnes, Melinda Pharms, Lysa Akin - Bcc
- Angela Wilson
- Date
- Tue, 3 Jul 2001 03:16:00 -0700 (PDT)
Please see the following articles:
Sac Bee, Tues, 7/3: Details emerge in power contracts
Sac Bee, Tues, 7/3: Duke Energy claims it's been vindicated
Sac Bee, Tues, 7/3: Out-of-state generators pull plug over uncertainty on
price controls
SD Union, Tues, 7/3: Duke energy agrees to refund money
SD Union, Tues, 7/3: State's grid issues stage 2 alert, triggering new price
caps
SD Union, Tues, 7/3: Full airing of accords touches off new debate
SD Union, Mon, 7/2: Duke energy lashes back at charge of price rigging
LA Times, Tues, 7/3: Hidden Costs Revealed in Power Pacts
LA Times, Tues, 7/3: Davis Scraps Deal With Consultants
LA Times, Tues, 7/3: Generator Bows, Pledges to Cut Electricity Bill by $20
Million
LA Times, Tues, 7/3: Power Sales Halted by New Pricing Curbs
SF Chron, Tues, 7/3: Scorching weather triggers Stage 2 alert, price caps
SF Chron, Tues, 7/3: Uncensored power pacts made public
State controller says deals will burden general fund for years
SF Chron, Tues, 7/3: Corporate casualties
PG&E executives are receiving bonuses, while some of its veteran employees
have
been waiting months for their disability checks
SF Chron, Tues, 7/3: Developments in California's energy crisis
SF Chron, Tues, 7/3: Duke Energy slashes $20 million from California power
bill
SF Chron, Tues, 7/3: Duke opens record books but keeps mum on prices
SF Chron, Tues, 7/3: Duke releases California energy records to counter
accusations of price gouging
Mercury News, Tues, 7/3: Las Vegas hit by rolling blackouts
OC Register, Tues, 7/3: Blackout hits Las Vegas as number 120 comes up
Individual.com (AP), Tues, 7/3: State One and Stage Two Emergencies Declared
as Demand Soars;
California ISO Strongly Urges Conservation
Individual.com (AP), Tues, 7/3: Duke Energy Releases California ISO, Internal
Records that
Confirm Appropriate Operation of South Bay Plant
Individual.com (AP), Tues, 7/3: Calpine's Sutter Energy Center Is Up and
Running First New
Major Baseload Generator for California
Individual.com (AP), Tues, 7/3: Duke Energy Will Offset Receivables Above
FERC Proxy Price
Individual.com (AP), Tues, 7/3: New York Power Producers Announce Five-Point
Program to
Address State's Long and Short-Term Energy Needs IPPNY Plan Designed to
Prevent
California-style Crisis in New York
NY Times, Tues, 7/3: Power Company Rebuts Accusations of Gouging
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-----
Details emerge in power contracts
By Carrie Peyton and Chris Bowman
Bee Staff Writers
(Published July 3, 2001)
California's power bills for the next decade probably will exceed the
forecasts of Gov. Gray Davis, the State Controller's Office said Monday as it
released unedited versions of long-term contracts in a new jab at the
governor.
The electricity contracts, which Davis' office sought in court to keep
secret, offer a glimpse into the rapid, high-stakes deals struck early in the
state's power crisis and illustrate the way deregulation's unraveling could
haunt California for years to come.
Some show that builders of new power plants could recoup the entire cost of
those plants in four years or less. Some show lucrative swaps for power,
including one arranged the same day California was rocked by rolling
blackouts.
More than two dozen additional administrative contracts detail the price
California is paying its consultants to seek a way out of the power mess,
from tens of thousands for Davis' aides down to $51 an hour for copying and
phone answering.
The governor's office defended its estimates of the state's future power
bill.
The 41 long-term contracts, 27 consulting contracts, five short-term deals
and stacks of receipts and invoices released Monday by state Controller
Kathleen Connell may just be the start.
Her office hopes to provide details about how much California has already
paid individual power generators in the volatile short-term, or "spot,"
market.
The deals include so many intricate pricing formulas that Connell said she
couldn't immediately predict exactly how high California's hourly power costs
would go.
Walter Barnes, chief deputy controller of finance, said the contracts
probably would be "well in excess" of the $69 a megawatt-hour that Davis once
said would be California's average cost for contract power for the next
decade.
The contracts' prices range from $55 to $249 a megawatt-hour, and most are
more than the $69, Connell said.
The state Department of Water Resources, the state's power buying arm, later
revised the $69 forecast to $70 a megawatt-hour through the end of 2010, with
the higher priced power coming first.
If anything, those figures could decline because natural gas, the fuel for
most new power plants, is getting cheaper, DWR spokesman Oscar Hidalgo said,
adding that his office sticks with its forecasts.
"We're on pretty solid ground here," he said.
As the statewide elected official who pays California's bills, Connell
repeatedly has criticized the governor for his electricity spending, saying
that she never believed the contracts should be kept secret.
But Davis' office blasted her for giving out details that power generators
and traders could use to learn the state's negotiating positions and buying
practices and said the information could boost wholesale prices within days.
"When they open their electric bill next time, every Californian can thank
Kathleen Connell for higher electricity costs," Davis spokesman Steve
Maviglio said.
The long-term contracts were first released June 15 by the water resources
department with power plant names, performance data, delivery points and
other details blocked out under heavy black strokes.
Analysts said that was the sort of data they could have used to calculate how
much more than the production costs the state was going to be paying for the
electricity purchased on behalf of three cash-strapped investor-owned
utilities.
As analysts began sizing up some of the specifics Monday, early reactions
were wary.
"This just shows when the state comes in and takes over the utility system,
we're just going to be in deep from all sorts of expenses and inefficiencies
that we were trying to get away from" with deregulation, said Arthur
O'Donnell, who edits a trade newsletter, California Energy Markets.
Bill Marcus, a power consultant who had analyzed the edited contracts for a
consumer group, quickly read through the unedited versions muttering things
such as "offensive" and "they got absolutely ripped here."
In one swap that was negotiated on a day of rolling blackouts in March, the
state agreed to send Powerex, the trading arm of British Columbia's
government utility, 2
times more electricity in the spring than Powerex
would return in the summer.
Although seasonal swaps are common, the 2
-to-1 ratio was a sign of "panic"
and inexperience on the state's part, he said.
The consultants who advise California on power deals were frenetic at the
time, with one staffer at the Navigant consulting firm billing for hours
worked that were the equivalent of 9.7 hours a day for 34 consecutive days.
The power purchase terms disclosed Monday confirm many energy analysts'
predictions that California consumers would be paying premium prices for
years to cover the costs of the new plants coming on line.
In several of the contracts, the state agreed to pay generators a 25 percent
to 30 percent annual return on their plant construction costs, which could
pay off the entire plant in four years or less.
Before deregulation, utilities generally received 3 percent to 18 percent
annual return on their capital investments over 30 years, said Marcus, a
veteran energy analyst whose firm, JBS Energy Inc. of West Sacramento,
represents ratepayer groups.
"We're all going to have to pay more for power plants over the next 10 or
more years because the generators are looking to pay off their plants in half
the time," he said.
"Beyond blackouts and price spikes, this will be the long-term legacy of
deregulation," he said. "The private market needs a high rate of return on
their investment."
Several contracts were drafted in the late winter and early spring when
California endured Stage 2 and Stage 3 energy alerts.
The unmasked terms in some of those agreements reflect the state's
desperation for megawatts amid fears of routine blackouts when temperatures
and energy use began to rise in the summer.
For example, the state agreed in a March 29 contract to pay Calpine $232 a
megawatt-hour to supply 300 megawatts nonstop from July 1 through Sept. 30.
But a more recent Calpine contract calls for about $59 a megawatt-hour,
starting Oct. 1.
Time made all the difference, said Jim Macias, a Calpine senior vice
president. He said that last winter, Calpine couldn't guarantee that plants
under construction in Sutter County and the East Bay would be on line by
summer. So the company bought the power on the spot market for the state,
Macias said.
"Back in the winter, $232 was a good price for electricity this summer," he
said.
Calpine officials said that they made no money on the sale and even knocked
15 percent off their price to maintain good relations with the state power
buyers.
The gesture more than paid off with the signing of the 10-year contract, said
Kathleen Potter, Calpine spokeswoman.
"It was a great transaction for us," Potter said. "We appreciate the
business."
Proponents of "free-market" energy buying have said that in the long-run,
competitive forces would result in more-efficient, less-costly power
generation.
But the contracts show that pressed for more electricity this summer and
fall, officials resorted to buying power from some of the least-efficient
plants in the state, guaranteeing owners of these aging generators 10 more
years of income.
The Bee's Carrie Peyton can be reached at (916) 321-1086 or
cpeyton@sacbee.com.
Duke Energy claims it's been vindicated
By Dale Kasler
Bee Staff Writer
(Published July 3, 2001)
Rebutting allegations that it manipulated electricity output to maximize
profits, a major power generator said Monday it's been vindicated by
documents suggesting the plants were run at the direction of California's
transmission-grid operator.
But a state senator leading the investigation into alleged market
manipulation said the generator, Duke Energy Corp., isn't necessarily off the
hook. Sen. Joe Dunn said Duke must provide detailed data about its pricing
practices if it wants exoneration -- something Duke won't yet do.
Duke, rebutting allegations by three ex-workers that it adjusted production
up and down during a time of extreme shortages, released confidential
control-room records Monday indicating the production changes were ordered by
the state Independent System Operator. The allegations focused on Duke's
practices at two Chula Vista plants Jan. 16-18, when the state experienced
its first wave of rolling blackouts.
In some cases, the plants were "literally driven by the ISO" through a
computerized system called automatic generation control, said Jeff Stokes, a
Duke executive vice president. In other cases, Duke retained control of the
plants but adjusted production levels in response to computer dispatches sent
by the ISO, sometimes as often as every 10 minutes, Stokes said.
"Duke Energy was not making the decisions to ramp the plant up and down," he
said. "(The ISO was) ramping it up and down to meet the minute-by-minute
changes in the grid."
Duke released a memo from Tracy Bibb, the ISO's director of scheduling, to
state officials confirming the accuracy of Duke's records and acknowledging
that Duke was following the ISO's dispatch orders.
The memo, along with the plant records, "clearly refute the allegations,"
Stokes said.
Yet Dunn, D-Santa Ana, chairman of a Senate select committee probing
wholesale power prices, said the Duke investigation will continue.
The documents "seem to give (Duke) partial exoneration," Dunn said, but the
generator still needs to disclose how much it charged the state. He also said
there were times when Duke seemed to be acting on its own, and not in
response to the ISO's directions, when it adjusted output from the plants.
Asked about prices, Stokes declined to release detailed information but said
Duke charged California roughly $1,200 a megawatt-hour for power from the two
plants during the three January days cited by the ex-workers. The high prices
mainly reflected a risk premium because of the shaky finances of California's
electric utilities, he said. The state Department of Water Resources didn't
step in as a creditworthy power purchaser until Jan. 19, the day after the
three-day period that was the subject of the ex-workers' allegations.
Stokes said Duke will disclose actual prices "at the appropriate time and in
the appropriate setting."
Stokes also disclosed that Duke agreed Monday to forgive almost $20 million
that it says it's owed by California for power supplied in January and
February. The reduction was ordered in March by the Federal Energy Regulatory
Commission, which said Duke and other generators had overcharged the state.
Even with the $20 million deducted, Duke says it has received just "pennies
on the dollar" for power consumed by California's troubled utilities.
On the other hand, the ISO has calculated that Duke overcharged California by
about $804.7 million from May 2000 to February 2001, the latest data
available. Only one other generator stands accused of overcharging more,
according to a confidential ISO memo that surfaced recently: Williams Cos.,
at $860.9 million.
With state officials claiming power generators have overcharged California by
about $9 billion, the allegations by the ex-workers hit Duke like an unwanted
jolt of electricity.
In testimony before Dunn's committee June 22, three former employees of
Duke's South Bay 1 and 2 plants in Chula Vista said the company manipulated
supplies to drive up prices Jan. 16-18.
Lt. Gov. Cruz Bustamente called their testimony the "smoking gun," while Gov.
Gray Davis invited the trio to breakfast.
Duke, already battered by the revelation that it charged the state a whopping
$3,880 a megawatt-hour for power at a different plant in January, took out
full-page advertisements in the state's major newspapers rebutting the
ex-workers' charges. It then took the extraordinary step of releasing plant
control-room logs to demonstrate that it was following orders.
At the heart of the matter is the computerized "automated dispatch system"
implemented by the ISO last summer to balance supply and demand more
precisely. Before that, the ISO had to resort to phone calls to get
generators to increase or decrease production.
Gregg Fishman, an ISO spokesman, said the ISO will continue its analysis of
market practices by all generators and doesn't consider the Duke matter
closed.
The Bee's Dale Kasler can be reached at (916) 321-1066 or dkasler@sacbee.com.
Out-of-state generators pull plug over uncertainty on price controls
By Dale Kasler
Bee Staff Writer
(Published July 3, 2001)
Confused by the federal government's new controls on electricity prices,
generators withheld so much power from California on Monday that the state
was nearly plunged into rolling blackouts, state officials said.
The confusion began when the state's electric grid operators declared a Stage
1 power alert in the early afternoon, triggering the price caps for the first
time since they went into effect June 21.
Out-of-state generators pulled about 1,500 megawatts of electricity off the
table at midafternoon, enough to power about 1.1 million homes, because of
uncertainty about how much they could charge under the new Federal Energy
Regulatory Commission pricing system, said Oscar Hidalgo, spokesperson for
the state Department of Water Resources. The department buys electricity for
the state's financially distressed utilities.
"They didn't understand what they were going to be paid; there was confusion
over the FERC order," Hidalgo said. "We saw 1,500 megawatts disappear."
The problem was exacerbated by a heat wave across the West, which forced
California to compete with other states for scarce electricity, he said.
Rolling blackouts hit southern Nevada.
Most California officials credit the FERC system, which is based on a
variable price cap, with reining in what had been a runaway wholesale power
market. But power generators have complained that the price caps, by limiting
profits, could discourage the production of critically needed electricity.
And as Monday's episode suggested, even the uncertainty about where the cap
will fall could lead to unexpected shortages.
"That's the risk that you run (with price controls)," said Arthur O'Donnell,
editor of the newsletter California Energy Markets. "People want any kind of
certainty at all."
Hidalgo said the state avoided blackouts only because of last-minute imports
from the Bonne'ville Power Administration, the federal agency that markets
government-produced hydroelectric power in the Pacific Northwest. The state
went into a Stage 2 power alert, the next-to-last level before blackouts are
ordered. The alert was canceled in late afternoon.
The blackouts would have been the first in California since May 8.
FERC imposed a round-the-clock ceiling on power throughout the West. The
price fluctuates and is tied to the production costs of the least-efficient
plant operating in California during a "power alert" declared by the
Independent System Operator, which runs the state's power-transmission grid.
When there's no alert, prices can't exceed 85 percent of the cap that was
established during the latest alert.
Until Monday, the maximum price held steady at about $101 a megawatt-hour in
California. But when the ISO declared a Stage 1 power alert in early
afternoon, signifying that reserve supplies had dwindled to less than 7
percent of demand, confusion set in, Hidalgo and others said.
Because of a steep drop in the price of natural gas, which fuels many
California power plants, suppliers knew the cap would fall. But no one knew
by how much until the price was posted by the ISO.
The ceiling for California fell to about $77 at 3 p.m. but was back up to $98
in two hours, according to the ISO. Those prices include the 10 percent
premium that sellers can charge California because FERC said there's a credit
risk in selling to the state.
O'Donnell said it's likely suppliers will pull back from the market every
time the ISO declares a power alert.
In-state generators have to operate their plants if summoned by the ISO. But
out-of-state suppliers can withhold supplies, and on Monday it was the
out-of-staters that were pulling back, Hidalgo said.
The Bee's Dale Kasler can be reached at (916) 321-1066 or dkasler@sacbee.com.
Duke Energy agrees to refund money
By Bill Ainsworth
UNION-TRIBUNE STAFF WRITER
July 3, 2001
SACRAMENTO -- As hot summer weather triggered the first Stage 2 power alert
yesterday in more than a month, Duke Energy agreed to refund money from an
earlier extremely high price to comply with an order from federal regulators.
While California was able to squeeze by with tight power supplies, southern
Nevada was not so lucky and was forced to endure brief rolling blackouts
during triple-digit heat.
California's electricity grid manager, the Independent System Operator, had
issued the last previous Stage 2 alert on May 31.
The hot weather is expected to continue. "Conservation is going to play a key
role in reducing demand," said Greg Fishman, spokesman for the ISO.
California's electricity demand peaked at about 4 p.m. with 41,600 megawatts,
with an available supply of 42,402 megawatts. A megawatt can power about 750
homes.
Meanwhile, Duke Energy announced that it would follow rather than fight an
order from the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission to refund money from
January when it charged a state record $3,880-per-megawatt hour. Duke was
allowed to charge only $273 per megawatt-hour, according to FERC.
The North Carolina-based company said that it would slash $20 million from
California's power bill, including $2.1 million from February.
Unlike the action for January, the February price cut was not ordered by the
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission.
"It's our way of creating a good working atmosphere to come up with some
solutions," said Terry Francisco, a company spokesman.
The money is a mere fraction of the $805 million that the ISO says the
company overcharged California residents.
In all, the ISO says power companies have overcharged California at least
$8.9 billion.
Company officials, meanwhile, continued to fight price-gouging charges
leveled by former employees of Duke's Chula Vista plant.
They held a news conference explaining in detail the actions it took from
Jan. 16 through Jan. 18, a time when it charged the state the record price
for power.
Previously, the company had released a memo from the ISO saying that the
Chula Vista plant was operating under the grid manager's instructions when it
throttled up and down during that period.
Jeff Stokes, executive vice president of Duke, would not detail the price the
company charged during that time. But in addition to the $3,880 per megawatt
hour, he said, Duke charged between 25 percent and 33 percent of that record
price. That would make the other prices about $1,000 per megawatt hour.
Yesterday, a megawatt hour sold for $92 on the spot market, and that's about
three times the going price in the spring of 2000.
Officials from the ISO say the amount of the bids the company offered is
needed to determine whether Duke engaged in price gouging.
A March report by the ISO accused generating companies of driving up prices
in two ways: by withholding power and by bidding prices so high the state
couldn't afford them.
Gov. Gray Davis said, in a written statement, that Duke owes Californians an
explanation.
"Duke has a lot of explaining to do for charging Californians the outrageous
price of $3,880 a megawatt hour," he said.
State's grid issues Stage 2 alert, triggering new price caps
By Don Thompson
ASSOCIATED PRESS
July 2, 2001
SACRAMENTO ) California's electric grid operator triggered price caps in 11
Western states Monday when it issued an energy alert for the first time since
federal regulators imposed the cost ceilings two weeks ago.
Power deficiencies were expected to continue Tuesday from 10 a.m. until
midnight, according to a statement from the California Independent System
Operator.
Unexpectedly high temperatures across much of California and the Southwest
brought higher energy use that required the ISO to declare a Stage 2 alert,
meaning electricity reserves fell below 5 percent.
Unless an emergency happen, the ISO said rolling blackouts remained unlikely.
Still, it asked consumers to conserve, especially during afternoon and early
evening peak use periods.
"Even if things are OK outside California, if there's a Stage 1 (or higher)
in California they all get" the caps, said Mike Wilczek, a senior western
power market reporter for Platts, the energy market information division of
The McGraw-Hill Companies.
The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission's June 19 order expanded price
restrictions it imposed in April on wholesale electricity sales in California
during peak demand periods when blackouts were threatened.
The restrictions now cover power transactions 24 hours a day, seven days a
week throughout 10 Western states along with in addition to California. It
also closed several loopholes that allowed power generators to circumvent the
April order. The price cap is pegged to the cost of production at the least
efficient electricity generating plant in the region.
ISO spokeswoman Stephanie McCorkle said the state won't know the baseline
price until the energy alert ends, probably Tuesday. Electricity had been
trading at nearly $92 per megawatt hour before the cap took effect, Wilczek
said.
"It's going to be an interesting week," said ISO spokesman Gregg Fishman.
Temperatures were about 5 percent higher than forecast, and the state was
using about 2,000 more megawatts than predicted, said McCorkle. That's enough
electricity to power about 1.5 million homes.
The Desert Southwest was seeing triple digit temperatures, meaning the region
had less electricity to share.
Imported electricity into California dropped from about 4,000 megawatts
Sunday to about 3,300 megawatts Monday, she said. In addition, California
lost about 1,500 megawatts when a plan went off-line in Southern California
over the weekend. A megawatt is enough power for about 750 homes.
The high temperatures were expected to continue through most of the week, but
electricity use was expected to fall Wednesday for Independence Day. However,
energy use could climb higher than normal on Thursday as office buildings
were cooled after being shut down for the holiday, Fishman said.
??
On the Net: Track the state's blackout warnings on the Web at
www.caiso.com/SystemStatus.html.
Full airing of accords touches off new debate
Uncensored electricity contracts show some edge for both sides
By James P. Sweeney
COPLEY NEWS SERVICE
July 3, 2001
SACRAMENTO -- Uncensored copies of long-term contracts that commit California
to buy $43 billion worth of electricity suggest that both generators and the
state may have cut better deals than previously disclosed.
"Some of these prices are more favorable to the utilities than we could tell
from the earlier contracts," said Roger Bohn, an energy specialist and
associate professor at UCSD. "Then there are some provisions that look more
favorable to the state ... at least in the short run."
Bohn, who served on the market monitoring committee of the defunct state
Power Exchange, reviewed several of the largest contracts, including that of
Sempra, the parent of San Diego Gas & Electric.
Under court order, Gov. Gray Davis' administration released the long-term
contracts June 15. But significant sections of some, and snippets of others,
had been omitted or blacked out to protect proprietary information and the
state's bargaining position, administration officials said.
Several news organizations, including The Copley Press, which publishes The
San Diego Union-Tribune, sued seeking full disclosure. State Controller
Kathleen Connell, who has openly feuded with fellow Democrat Davis, also had
urged a public airing of the complex documents.
A San Diego judge last week issued an opinion in favor of releasing the full
contracts, but had not yet made her ruling final.
Yesterday, Connell released unabridged versions of some 41 contracts, most of
which stretch over the coming decade. At least one extends 20 years.
Connell's move touched off another heated exchange with the governor's
office.
The controller said the state almost certainly has never before assumed such
a massive financial obligation without prior public review.
Connell and her top aides said the previously excised portions of the
agreements show the governor saddled the state with huge electricity costs
through the end of the decade.
She also released short-term contract information which was of particular
concern to the governor's office. Steve Maviglio, the governor's press
secretary, criticized that decision, saying it would help power generators
continue to manipulate the market.
"Unfortunately, the controller is seeking political vengeance at the expense
of the California ratepayer," Maviglio said. "She's uninformed and clueless
about the impact of the long-term contracts on bringing down spot-market
prices."
Few others were weighing in on the debate yesterday. Most consumer advocates
and other analysts were reserving judgment until they finished poring through
the nearly 30 pounds of documents.
But Walter Barnes, the controller's chief financial officer, said the
contracts' average cost "probably will be well in excess" of the $69 per
megawatt-hour claimed by the governor's chief negotiators.
UCSD's Bohn called that conclusion "plausible," but said it will depend on
the future price of natural gas, which no one can predict. Many power plants
are fired with natural gas, the cost of which gyrated wildly over the past
year.
"Neither (Connell) nor the governor are saying what gas prices they assumed,
so we don't really know what the $69 figure is based on," Bohn said.
While generators may have bargained for higher rates than previously thought,
the state secured what appear to be floating market rates with a cap in at
least one major contract, the deal with Sempra, Bohn said.
In that agreement, the state is "not locked into an arbitrarily high price
for this summer. The way things are looking now, that may turn out to be a
good deal for California," he said.
While largely critical of the contracts, Connell appeared to confirm that
many of the deals have a flexibility that could prove beneficial to
ratepayers.
She said her staff found an "interesting pattern" in the state's June power
purchases. Given a choice between available long-term supplies and the spot
market, the state's energy traders bought almost as often in the spot market.
While entering into long-term contracts, the state's ability to continue
buying some power on the spot market benefited consumers when prices on the
market started to fall, according to Davis associates.
S. David Freeman, the governor's chief energy adviser, said the long-term
commitments drained some demand and restored some sanity to a spot market
that had been rising to unheard-of prices. Since then, the Federal Energy
Regulatory Commission also has imposed wholesale price controls in California
and 10 other Western states.
Freeman said the state negotiated the best deals it could starting in
January, when it endured rolling blackouts and spot market prices averaging
nearly $280 per megawatt-hour.
Along with the contracts, Connell released details of power purchases to date
under the long-term agreements.
Contract power purchased so far appeared to average $173 per megawatt-hour.
The administration, however, had warned the rates it negotiated were steeper
at the front end.
Connell said the contract prices range from $55 to $249 per megawatt-hour,
with most exceeding the $69 average the administration has claimed. Perhaps
more troubling, she said, is that many of the contracts contain clauses that
could prevent purchase of the power at the lower prices.
In addition, she said, "there is a great deal of negotiation that remains to
be done on many of these contracts as market conditions evolve."
"So the state does not have a firm commitment on price, other than a floor
price on many of these contracts."
The deals should guarantee nearly 600 million megawatt-hours for the state
over the next decade. That is projected to cover about 45 percent of the
amount of power the state's utilities cannot cover with their own plants.
But the price of half the long-term commitments will fluctuate with the price
of natural gas, and 70 percent of the power has been promised from power
plants that have not yet been built.
Duke Energy lashes back at charge of price rigging
By Bill Ainsworth
UNION-TRIBUNE STAFF WRITER
July 2, 2001
SACRAMENTO -- Duke Energy, which has been stung by allegations of price
gouging at its Chula Vista plant, has begun fighting back by selectively
releasing documents it says exonerate the company of trying to drive up
prices by withholding electricity during a critical power shortage in
January.
Duke has released a memo from the state electricity grid manager saying the
company was following state orders when it powered the plant up and down
during three days in January.
But the company has refused to release price information that a spokeswoman
from the Independent System Operator, the grid manager, said was critical to
fully understanding whether the company engaged in price gouging.
The dispute is part of a larger battle between Gov. Gray Davis and the power
generating companies that have made enormous profits from the California
energy crisis.
Last month, in a dramatic public hearing before a state Senate committee,
three former workers at the Chula Vista plant accused Duke of turning
electricity production up and down to manipulate prices, throwing away spare
parts and prolonging plant outages.
Duke, which is based in North Carolina, leases the plant from the San Diego
Unified Port District.
Duke officials called the allegations "baseless," saying plant workers
weren't in a position to know why the plant was powered up and down. Duke
spokesman Tom Williams acknowledged that the company never explained its
actions to employees, saying it was none of their business.
Duke said the plant was following orders from the ISO when it powered down on
Jan. 16 during a Stage 3 alert, when electricity supplies were so low that
rolling blackouts were threatened.
Yesterday, the company released a memo from the grid manager confirming that
from Jan. 16 through Jan. 18, the company followed ISO direction. "The units
did follow the ISO dispatch orders," the memo said.
But Duke refused to disclose how much it charged the state for electricity on
those days, saying the information was confidential.
The ISO, in a March report, accused Duke and other generating companies of
manipulating the market by withholding power and by bidding prices higher
than the state can afford.
Stephanie McCorkle, spokeswoman for the ISO, said the pricing information is
needed to get a complete picture of Duke's actions in January. She said the
grid manager may have ordered the South Bay plant to power down because Duke
was charging prices so high the state could not afford them.
"The ISO frequently orders plants to ramp down because the plant owner is
charging high prices. Output will certainly fluctuate if the price is so
astronomical we can't afford it," she said.
The ISO has the pricing information but is not allowed to release it without
authorization from the power company.
Duke spokesman Williams yesterday said the ISO memo shows that Duke reduced
plant output to keep the electricity grid in balance -- that is, to make sure
that supply was equal to demand.
He said Duke charged high prices during those three days in January,
including the record price of $3,880 per megawatt-hour, because it feared it
would not be paid.
"It's not a secret at this time that we had some high credit prices," he
said.
Michael Aguirre, a lawyer who is suing Duke and who helped get the ex-workers
to testify to the Senate committee, chastised the company for not fully
disclosing the prices.
"They should have the courage that these workers had to come forward with all
the information," he said. "They should make a full disclosure."
The memo from the ISO does not address broader charges by the former
employees that the company had been powering its plant up and down for the
entire year to drive up the price of electricity.
Glenn Johnson, a former mechanic at the South Bay plant, has said working
turbines frequently were taken offline for "economic reasons." He and other
plant workers say that meant the company was trying to drive prices higher.
Williams yesterday said "economic reasons" meant the cost of running the
extra turbines was so high the company could not recover the operating costs.
"It's not to drive prices up, it's because you can't produce the power and
make money," he said.
Aguirre said he was skeptical that Duke could not make money operating close
to capacity at a time when wholesale electricity prices were skyrocketing.
Lt. Gov. Cruz Bustamante yesterday accused the company of trying to explain
away its price gouging. "Duke should stop trying to manipulate the media the
way it has California's energy market," he said.
On Friday, Duke asked the ISO to release its memo to just two news
organizations, the Los Angeles Times? and the Charlotte Observer? in North
Carolina. But McCorkle refused, saying a document should be available to
everybody or to nobody.
The newspapers nevertheless obtained the document. Williams said the company
selected those two news organizations because it had been working with them
for weeks on the story. He said Duke plans to release the memo to the public
at a news conference today.
Davis wants nearly $9 billion in refunds from Duke and other companies that,
under the state's flawed deregulated electricity system, acquired power
plants from public utilities and raised wholesale rates dramatically.
Duke Energy, which has been accused by state and federal regulators of
overcharging California customers for its power, set a California record when
it sought $3,880 per megawatt-hour in January.
By comparison, during the first half of 2000, power sold for about $30 a
megawatt-hour.
Hidden Costs Revealed in Power Pacts
By RICH CONNELL,ROBERT J. LOPEZ and JEFFREY L. RABIN, Times Staff Writers
?????California consumers on Monday were given their first detailed glimpse
of the unpredictable and potentially higher costs they'll face in the future
under power-buying deals signed by Gov. Gray Davis' administration.
?????State Controller Kathleen Connell released previously secret elements of
the state's long-term electricity contracts, along with a new warning that
the price tag could exceed the administration's previous estimate of $43
billion.
?????Technical vagaries in the pacts, Connell said, could leave state power
bills open to wild fluctuations over the next decade. Even after weeks of
analyzing the 41 agreements, she said, her office is still unable to say
"what the [cost] ceiling could be."
?????Among other things, the controller said, most costs under the contracts
are now running between $70 and $200 per megawatt-hour, and she predicted
that costs over the next decade will be far higher than the $69 per hour
suggested by Davis' aides.
?????More certain are the amounts the state is paying more than two dozen
private consultants who have been drawn into the electricity crisis and whose
contracts also were released Monday by the controller.
?????Some of those consultants--working on behalf of Davis or the state
agency that has been purchasing power since January--are making tens of
thousands of dollars each month.
?????Connell's release of the uncensored electricity contracts came one day
after the California attorney general said Davis would not appeal a judicial
order declaring them public records in their entirety. The court action in
San Diego was filed by The Times and other news organizations.
?????Three weeks ago, after another ruling favorable to the media, the
administration released the contracts, which will govern the cost of
wholesale electricity for years to come. But key technical provisions were
redacted from those documents.
?????Davis planned to release the contracts later this week, but the
controller upstaged him Monday, offering her own spin on the deals and
prompting the governor's office to shoot back.
?????His aides insisted Connell's warning of possibly higher costs was based
on incomplete information. Her price figures, they said, were skewed toward
purchases made earlier in the year, when electricity and natural gas prices
were significantly higher.
?????"Unfortunately, the controller doesn't let the facts get in the way of a
good story," said Davis spokesman Steve Maviglio, adding that the controller
has been at odds with Davis since he endorsed her rival, Antonio
Villaraigosa, in the Los Angeles mayor's race. "This is just a drive-by
shooting where she does not have the full set of information."
?????Millions in Hidden Costs
?????Still, the contracts released Monday show for the first time the
millions of dollars in hidden costs that are being shouldered by taxpayers.
?????At least one of the energy suppliers, Houston-based Dynegy Inc.,
negotiated terms that allow it to pass along to the state high-cost delivery
charges for natural gas, experts said.
?????Robert Michaels, an energy consultant and professor of economics at Cal
State Fullerton, said the Dynegy contract permits the firm to use the state's
most costly benchmark of natural gas prices.
?????Dynegy "has its choice of the highest [cost delivery] point," said
Michaels, who once advised the company. Like Connell and others, Michaels
said that even with the complete picture of the contracts, it is difficult to
determine how much added cost ratepayers may face as the deals extend into
the next decade.
?????Also, in just the first three months of the Dynegy contract, the state
picked up about $10 million in pollution, start-up and other operational
costs for the firm.
?????Likewise, a contract with San Diego-based Sempra Energy Resources,
parent company of San Diego Gas & Electric, allows the company to choose
where it delivers electricity into the state grid, Michaels said after an
initial review of the agreement.
?????"It seems to offer a lot of flexibility for the supplier," said
Michaels, who also has been a consultant for power suppliers. "It's not
obvious what the state got out of this [deal]."
?????The new details on fuel and emission costs underscored some critics'
fears. "As you look at the devil in the details, it gets worse," said UC
Irvine economist Peter Navarro.
?????He noted, for example, that Dynegy has been one of the power merchants
labeled by Davis as "pirates."
?????But examining the company's complete contract Monday, Navarro said, it
seemed as if the state was saying, "You pirate, take California's dowry."
?????Navarro and other critics note that power prices have fallen
dramatically in recent weeks, well below those the state is paying under the
long-term contracts.
?????A Times analysis of payments made so far under the contracts shows the
average cost per megawatt-hour has been $173. Recent spot prices for peak
power have been as low as $50 a megawatt-hour, according to surveys by Platts
Energy Trader, an industry newsletter. By Monday, when an energy emergency
was declared, the price had risen to about $92 a megawatt-hour.
?????Administration officials, including Davis' chief contract negotiator, S.
David Freeman, have said the state had little negotiating leverage when many
of the deals were struck early this year.
?????"Early on, we were having a very difficult time gaining any advantage,"
said Oscar Hidalgo, spokesman for the state Department of Water Resources,
which oversees power purchases. Still, Hidalgo and others in the
administration contend the power deals will stabilize prices in the long
term, and have tamed high spot prices this year.
?????"Now, we have gained the upper hand," Hidalgo said.
?????A Big Payday for Consultants
?????Meanwhile, payments to outside consultants hired to assist the governor
and the state Department of Water Resources in dealing with California's
energy crisis reached nearly $2.8 million by late last month, according to
the figures released Monday.
?????But those payments represent only a fraction of the total contracts the
state has signed with a broad array of consultants to assist with the
purchase of power and acquisition of transmission lines, to provide legal and
technical advice, and to mount advertising campaigns and polish Davis' image.
?????The agreements include a $1.5-million multiyear contract with the
Washington, D.C., law firm of Grammer, Kissel, Robbins, Skancke & Edwards,
which specializes in energy and environmental law.
?????Attorney Elisa J. Grammer and other members of the firm will represent
the state in proceedings before the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission and
related court proceedings through the end of May 2004.
?????Another contract calls for the state to pay $1.1 million to two New York
consulting firms--the Blackstone Group and Saber Partners--at the rate of
$275,000 a month. The contract includes the services of Joseph Fichera, one
of Davis' chief advisors on the energy crisis.
?????Blackstone/Saber could be paid an additional $14.58 million if the
Legislature approves deals to buy electric transmission systems from the
state's three private utilities--the financially rocky Southern California
Edison, Pacific Gas & Electric, which has filed for bankruptcy, and San Diego
Gas & Electric. Critics say the contract, in effect, provides a huge
financial incentive for the consultants to boost the price the state will
have to pay for the transmission system, which would result in higher fees
for them.
?????Davis also drew criticism in late May when he hired two former White
House strategists--Mark Fabiani and Chris Lehane--at $15,000 a month each.
Both also did consulting work for Edison to help the utility win approval of
a financial rescue package that Davis is pushing. Critics charged the two had
a conflict of interest representing both the governor and the utility.
?????The governor announced late Friday that Fabiani no longer works for him
and that Lehane would work for less money. Davis' statement said that Lehane
would be paid $9,900 a month, roughly the same pay as the governor's last
communications director, and he would not work for Edison while consulting
for Davis.
?????Also released was the state's contract with the governor's energy
conservation czar, Freeman. The former head of the Los Angeles Department of
Water and Power is being paid $120,000 for six months' work from April 15
through Oct. 15.
---
?????Times staff writers Nancy Rivera Brooks, Virginia Ellis, Davan Maharaj,
Doug Smith, Nancy Vogel and Daryl Kelley contributed to this story.
Davis Scraps Deal With Consultants
Media: One has left his position and the other will get a smaller fee.
By DAN MORAIN, Times Staff Writer
?????SACRAMENTO--Under continuing pressure for employing two well-known
Democratic communications strategists on the public payroll, Gov. Gray Davis
announced late Friday that he had scrapped their deal.
?????In a statement released at 7:42 p.m., Davis announced that he had
dropped a controversial contract with high-priced communications consultants
Mark Fabiani and Chris Lehane. Davis' statement said that Fabiani left state
service altogether, and that Lehane would work for a lower fee.
?????A month ago, as his poll numbers fell, Davis retained Fabiani and Lehane
for what was to be a six-month contract at a fee of $30,000 a month in
taxpayer funds. Fabiani and Lehane also do consulting work for Southern
California Edison, helping the troubled utility win approval of a rescue deal
that Davis is pushing.
?????Critics of the proposed Davis-Edison deal quickly attacked the hiring,
saying that Lehane and Fabiani had a conflict of interest.
?????Republican legislators contended that Fabiani and Lehane, who had worked
in the Clinton White House defending the former president against a variety
of scandals, are political operatives who should not have been paid out of
taxpayer funds. Fabiani also is a well-known figure in Los Angeles, where he
once worked for Mayor Tom Bradley, another Democrat.
?????A Republican anti-tax advocate sued to force Fabiani and Lehane to
disclose their outside clients and recuse themselves from issues related to
the electricity crisis, while Controller Kathleen Connell, a Democrat feuding
with Davis, vowed to withhold their pay.
?????Davis had insisted Lehane and Fabiani are "worth every penny" they were
paid, saying last month that they helped him shape his message that
independent power generators are responsible for California's energy crisis.
?????Davis' statement also said Lehane would be paid $9,900 a month, roughly
the same pay as Davis' previous communications director, and that hewould not
work for Edison while consulting for Davis.
Generator Bows, Pledges to Cut Electricity Bill by $20 Million
Power: Duke Energy had been accused by the state of price gouging. Gov. Davis
insists that the company still has much to explain.
By NANCY RIVERA BROOKS and RICH CONNELL, Times Staff Writers
?????Caving to state and federal pressure, Duke Energy Corp. said Monday that
it will reduce by $20 million the amount it claims it is owed for electricity
sales in California.
?????The Charlotte, N.C., company is one of the state's largest power plant
operators and, with other generators, has been flayed by politicians and
regulators in recent months for alleged overcharges in the California market
and for supposedly manipulating electricity supplies.
?????Duke also on Monday formally released internal documents of its own, as
well as from the California Independent System Operator, showing that the
agency was responsible for huge swings in production at a San Diego-area
power plant that sparked accusations of price gouging.
?????In sworn testimony June 22 before a state Senate investigating panel,
three former workers at Duke's Chula Vista plant offered internal operating
logs for three days in January, saying they showed that the company throttled
generators up and down "like a yo-yo" to boost prices during power
emergencies.
?????The company denied the allegations, saying that the workers were not in
a position to know that Cal-ISO, which operates most of the statewide power
grid, was controlling the changes.
?????Duke has been "shocked and appalled by the accusations that have been
leveled against our company," said Jeff Stokes, its executive vice president
for Western gas and power. The letter from Cal-ISO acknowledging that it
ordered the production gyrations in the course of maintaining grid
reliability was reported Saturday by The Times.
?????Duke said the $20-million refund for January and February will come from
a "credit premium" that it had placed on electricity sales because it feared
it would never be paid by Southern California Edison and Pacific Gas &
Electric, the utility companies then lurching toward bankruptcy. PG&E has
since filed for bankruptcy-law protection, and Edison remains financially
shaky.
?????The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission in June said Duke was entitled
to no more than $273 per megawatt-hour of electricity in January and ordered
the company to pay back everything it reaped above that price for the
month--including an infamous charge of $3,880 per megawatt-hour, which a
spokesman for Gov. Gray Davis called "obscene."
?????Davis said Monday that Duke still has much to explain.
?????"There's no doubt in my mind that there's been an effort by many of the
power producers to 'game' the system," Davis said, after dedicating Calpine
Corp.'s 540-megawatt Sutter Energy Center in Yuba City, the second of four
major power plants to begin operation this summer.
?????So far, Duke executives said, the company has been paid less than 2
cents on the dollar for the power it provided the state in January and
February. The federal commission is holding a settlement conference to seek
agreement on possible refunds owed California by power generators and
marketers.
?????A Cal-ISO spokesman declined to comment on the Duke revelations, citing
a gag order imposed by the administrative law judge overseeing the settlement
conference.
?????Although Cal-ISO late Friday acknowledged that the ramping at the Chula
Vista plant was in response to its orders, representatives of the grid
agency, the governor's office and the special state Senate committee probing
alleged power gouging warned Monday that Duke's activities at the plant are
still being scrutinized.
?????The ramping activity ordered by Cal-ISO is only part of the picture,
they say. Further investigation of pricing is underway.
?????State officials suggest, for example, that the grid operator may have
ramped down generation at times to avoid paying unreasonably high prices.
Duke Energy has refused to release details of the prices it charged for power
on the days at the heart of the ex-employees' allegations, and did so again
Monday in a conference call with reporters.
?????Under questioning Monday, Duke executive Stokes did indicate that the
prices charged for the power associated with the January logs were in the
range of $1,000 to $1,500 per megawatt-hour, enough electricity to serve
about 750 California homes for an hour.
---
?????Times staff writer Eric Bailey in Yuba City contributed to this story.
Power Sales Halted by New Pricing Curbs
Electricity: Confused suppliers, unsure what they will be paid, refuse to
sell to state, which asks FERC for a ruling but doesn't get it.
By NANCY VOGEL, Times Staff Writer
?????SACRAMENTO--Confusion over new federal price restrictions prompted
several electricity sellers to back away from sales to California on Monday
afternoon, pushing the state closer to blackouts, energy officials said.
?????The state lost sales that would have provided enough electricity to
supply more than 1 million homes, said Ray Hart, deputy director of the
California Department of Water Resources, which has been buying much of the
state's electricity since January.
?????At least five companies producing or marketing power "are telling us
that since they don't know what they're going to get paid, they're not going
to take the risk, and so they're not going to sell the energy," Hart said.
?????The electricity sales fell through after power consumption soared in
summer heat and grid operators were forced to declare a Stage 1 emergency,
meaning reserves had dipped below 7%. It was the first such emergency since
May 31.
?????Under a June 19 order by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
intended to bring down wholesale electricity markets across the West, a power
emergency in California triggers the setting of a new price limit that
applies to power plant owners from Washington to Arizona.
?????The new price is supposed to be based upon whatever it costs to run the
most inefficient, expensive power plant selling electricity to California
grid operators during the first full hour of a Stage 1 emergency.
?????But much uncertainty remains about exactly how and when the new price is
supposed to be established under the commission's order, and that apparently
drove away sellers, Hart said.
?????Shortly after the state issued the Stage 1 alert at 1:30 p.m., putting
the old price limit of $90 per megawatt-hour in question, companies that had
committed to provide the state electricity hour by hour Monday afternoon
backed out, Hart said. The companies include TransAlta Energy Marketing of
Oregon, Constellation Power of Baltimore and Sempra Energy Trading, a unit of
the San Diego-based energy conglomerate.
?????Forced to dip even deeper into the state's power reserves and declare a
Stage 2 emergency, water agency officials called the federal energy
commission's hotline for clarification about what the new price should be and
when it should take effect. They got no answer.
?????Hart said commission officials reached at home promised to try to
clarify their order today. One outstanding question is what obligations power
suppliers have to deliver electricity to California in an emergency.
?????Both buyers and sellers in the market agree that the new price, when it
is set, will probably be lower than $90 per megawatt-hour because the price
of natural gas, the main fuel in California power plants, has dropped lately.
?????Temperatures soared several degrees higher Monday than grid operators
had anticipated. But they said they expected to avoid rolling blackouts in
part because the Bonneville Power Administration in Portland, Ore., had
agreed to provide several hundred megawatts of Pacific Northwest hydropower
each hour in exchange for a return of electricity from California later this
summer.
?????"Bonneville is giving us emergency power to get us through," Hart said.
Copyright 2001 Los Angeles Times
Scorching weather triggers Stage 2 alert, price caps
Jim Herron Zamora, Chronicle Staff Writer
Tuesday, July 3, 2001
,2001 San Francisco Chronicle
URL: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2001/07/03/MN225511.DTL
Driven by yesterday's sizzling temperatures, California's Independent System
Operator issued this summer's first Stage 2 energy alert.
ISO officials remained uncertain last night whether the state's energy
reserves today and tomorrow would drop again to dangerous levels as
temperatures continue to hit triple digits in many locations.
That's because energy demand may be less than expected if people get a jump
on Independence Day and take off from work early.
"It's going to be an interesting week," said ISO spokesman Gregg Fishman.
National Weather Service forecaster Steve Anderson agreed. "In the warmest
areas people will really want to use their air conditioners," he said. "It's
going to be a long, hot week."
Yesterday, Livermore reached a record high of 106 degrees, while Hollister
hit a record 101. Other inland parts of the Bay Area were hot as well, while
San Francisco peaked at a comparatively comfortable 80 degrees.
The three-hour Stage 2 alert declared yesterday was the first time a
California power shortage triggered price caps for 11 other Western states.
Under federal rules adopted June 19, wholesale price ceilings that go into
effect when power reserves in California drop under 5 percent (a Stage 2
emergency) were extended to Arizona, Colorado, Idaho, Montana, Nevada, New
Mexico, Oregon, Utah, Washington and Wyoming.
The caps are designed to prevent energy suppliers from exploiting shortages
by spiking wholesale prices during threatened blackouts. The restrictions,
which cover all power transactions in the 11 states, are pegged to the cost
of production at the least efficient electricity generating plant in the
region.
It's not yet clear how the caps will change prices, according to the ISO.
Electricity had been trading at nearly $92 per megawatt hour before the cap
took effect.
Triple digit temperatures throughout the desert and mountain regions mean
that many of those states have less energy to export.
The energy crisis was felt the most yesterday in Nevada, where soaring
temperatures triggered rolling power blackouts yesterday in the southern part
of the state. But power woes did not dim the lights on the Las Vegas strip,
where temperatures were as high as 120 degrees. Virtually all major casinos
and hotels there have backup generators.
California's Stage 2 alert came the same day that Gov. Gray Davis threw the
switch to open the 540-megawatt Sutter Energy Center Project in Sutter
County, the largest power plant licensed by the state to open since the
California Energy Commission began permitting plants in 1976. Last week, the
state's first new major power plant since 1988 -- the 320-megawatt Sunrise
Power Plant -- opened in Kern County.
Chronicle wire services contributed to this report.
E-mail Jim Zamora at jzamora@sfchronicle.com.
,2001 San Francisco Chronicle ? Page?A - 3
Uncensored power pacts made public
State controller says deals will burden general fund for years
Carolyn Said, Christian Berthelsen, David Parrish, Chronicle Staff Writers
Tuesday, July 3, 2001
,2001 San Francisco Chronicle
URL: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2001/07/03/MN109919.DTL
State Controller Kathleen Connell yesterday released uncensored versions of
California's energy contracts, including short-term contracts that Gov. Gray
Davis had hoped to keep under wraps for three months.
Connell said the contracts for $43 billion worth of power were negotiated at
the worst possible times, for higher prices and longer periods than are
necessary. But Davis' office countered that Connell was grandstanding and
that her release of short-term contracts would hurt the state in its
negotiations with power generators.
Connell said the contracts showed California paying more than the $69 a
megawatt hour Davis had stated. Ranging from $44 to $249 per megawatt hour,
most are between $100 and $200 a megawatt hour, she said, adding that
variables prevented calculating an exact average.
But Steve Maviglio, Davis' spokesman, said Connell had selectively mixed in
some higher-priced short-term contracts "to misrepresent facts about the
price we negotiated."
Although a fellow Democrat, Connell has long had a contentious relationship
with Davis. In an interview yesterday, she said the deals Davis made could
mean the general fund would be in debt for years to come. She added that it
appeared the administration would run out of money to buy electricity by
December.
Davis is "indebting future generations of Californians to ease the potential
pain a portion of people might feel over the summer of 2001," she said.
A judge ordered the contracts to be released two weeks ago, but Davis' office
blacked out many vital elements, such as where power would be generated and
transmitted. The judge last week ordered Davis to release that redacted
material, which the governor's office said he had planned to do this Thursday
- - omitting the short-term contracts. Instead, Connell released the material
yesterday.
Among other new revelations:
-- Consultants. The state signed agreements for more than $15 million to
consultants for help in negotiating the contracts, legal advice and other
services, some for months or years into the future. To date, the state has
paid out nearly $2.8 million on those contracts, including $30,000 to S.
David Freeman, the former head of the Los Angeles Department of Water and
Power, whom Gov. Gray Davis retained as an energy adviser in April.
The largest of the 27 consulting agreements was for up to $6.2 million with
Electric Power Group LLC of Pasadena for help in negotiating the long-term
contracts with the power providers. The firm is headed by several former
executives with Southern California Edison.
"There are a number of consulting contracts that appear questionable,"
Connell said. Citing one example, Connell said she had refused to pay the
contract of Mark Fabiani and Chris Lehane, two political image consultants
retained by Davis, because the firm was also representing Southern California
Edison.
Maviglio said: "The governor makes no apologies for hiring the best talent to
fight the arsenal of generators. They have several floors of skyscrapers in
Houston armed with the best talent money can buy."
-- LADWP. Los Angeles' municipal utility, the Los Angeles Department of Water
and Power, sold the state $57.8 million worth of power in March and April.
LADWP charged the state between $213.50 to $174.60 per megawatt-hour of
electricity, a price that included a 15 percent premium.
LADWP was not profiteering, said Eric Pharp, director of public affairs for
the municipal utility. "I don't think most people would think that is
excessive," Pharp said. "Fifteen percent is what people felt was a reasonable
return." The 15 percent markup was decided on last December by Freeman, then
LADWP's director, and approved by the LADWP board.
"What if LADWP found itself short of power, would it expect to get that power
from the state at a reasonable cost?" asked Severin Borenstein, head of the
University of California Energy Institute. "If they expect backstop help from
the state if they ever get in trouble, now's the time to step forward on that
basis."
-- Price. Bill Marcus, principal economist with JBS Energy, a Sacramento
consulting firm that represents consumer and environmental groups in utility
issues, said the new material showed the state had paid huge amounts for
short- term power, more than twice as much as recent federal price caps.
He also questioned whether California had acted in a panic to buy too much
power. "The system is not going to have enough flexibility built into it,
come three to four years from now if we keep signing contracts," he said.
"I'd like them to stop and take a breath, see if there are ways to change the
worst contracts, rather than running hell-bent for election as fast as they
can, trying to sign these things."
Maviglio said the contracts represented a "balanced portfolio" of purchases;
provided California with a reliable price for electricity; and had helped
drive down spot market prices. "Instead of being vulnerable to the whims of
the market, we know exactly how much we'll be paying," he said.
E-mail Carolyn Said at csaid@sfchronicle.com.
,2001 San Francisco Chronicle ? Page?A - 3
Developments in California's energy crisis
The Associated Press
Tuesday, July 3, 2001
,2001 Associated Press
URL:
http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/news/archive/2001/07/03/state1
037EDT0155.DTL
(07-03) 07:37 PDT (AP) --
Developments in California's energy crisis:
TUESDAY:
* No power alerts Tuesday as electricity reserves stay above 7 percent.
MONDAY:
* California's electric grid operator triggers price caps in 11 Western
states when it issues an energy alert for the first time since federal
regulators imposed the cost ceilings two weeks ago. High heat led to higher
energy use that required the Independent System Operator to declare a Stage 2
alert for about three hours when reserves fell below 5 percent. It maintained
a Stage 1 alert into the evening, meaning reserves were below 7 percent.
* State Controller Kathleen Connell releases unedited versions of $43 billion
worth of long-term energy contracts with 18 power generators, the subject of
a court fight between Democratic Gov. Gray Davis, Republican legislators, and
news organizations.
Connell also releases documents showing the state has paid $402.6 million
toward the long-term energy contracts. The state also paid various energy
consultants $2.8 million. Those contracts include payments to several
industry officials who have been negotiating the state's long-term power
contracts, such as David Freeman, the governor's chief energy adviser.
* Davis opens the 540-megawatt Sutter Energy Center Project in Sutter County,
the largest power plant licensed by the state to operate since the California
Energy Commission began permitting plants in 1976.
* Electricity supplier Duke Energy unveiled operations logs Monday to fight
accusations that it manipulated turbine output to boost prices in California
during January. State grid operators already have acknowledged that they, not
the company, were the ones in charge during the three days in question. But
Duke declined to specify on the bigger question of how much it charged during
that period.
* The 800 employees of Allan Hancock College in Santa Maria over the next
month will take three-day weekends to eliminate Friday use of air
conditioning.
* Vallejo city officials are planning what they say will be the nation's
largest solar "micro-utility." The California Energy Commission has given
Vallejo a $2.5 million grant to build a 1 megawatt solar farm in partnership
with BP Solar. The project, which will provide enough power for about 750
homes, is expected to be finished by the end of the year.
* Shares of Sempra Energy, parent company of San Diego Gas & Electric Co.,
close up 26 cents at $27.60. Shares of Pacific Gas and Electric Corp. close
up $1.30 at $12.50. Shares of Edison International close at $11.64, up 49
cents.
WHAT'S NEXT:
* The Senate Judiciary Committee plans to continue its debate at a hearing
Thursday over Davis' proposal to aid financially strapped Southern California
Edison.
* After waiting a few extra days at the request of the Legislature, state
power regulators are set to decide Tuesday whether California ratepayers can
shop around for their electricity or whether they must buy it from their
traditional utility.
THE PROBLEM:
High demand, high wholesale energy costs, transmission glitches and a tight
supply worsened by scarce hydroelectric power in the Northwest and
maintenance at aging California power plants are all factors in California's
electricity crisis.
Southern California Edison and Pacific Gas and Electric say they've lost
nearly $14 billion since June 2000 to high wholesale prices the state's
electricity deregulation law bars them from passing on to consumers. PG&E,
saying it hasn't received the help it needs from regulators or state
lawmakers, filed for federal bankruptcy protection April 6. Electricity and
natural gas suppliers, scared off by the companies' poor credit ratings, are
refusing to sell to them, leading the state in January to start buying power
for the utilities' nearly 9 million residential and business customers. The
state is also buying power for a third investor-owned utility, San Diego Gas
& Electric, which is in better financial shape than much larger Edison and
PG&E but also struggling with high wholesale power costs.
The Public Utilities Commission has approved average rate increases of 37
percent for the heaviest residential customers and 38 percent for commercial
customers, and hikes of up to 49 percent for industrial customers and 15
percent or 20 percent for agricultural customers to help finance the state's
multibillion-dollar power buys.
Track the state's blackout warnings on the Web at
www.caiso.com/SystemStatus.html.
,2001 Associated Press ?
Duke Energy slashes $20 million from California power bill
MARK SHERMAN, Associated Press Writer
Tuesday, July 3, 2001
,2001 Associated Press
URL:
http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/news/archive/2001/07/03/state0
328EDT0110.DTL
(07-03) 00:28 PDT (AP) --
With BC-CA--Power-Duke Plants, Bjt
WASHINGTON (AP) -- Duke Energy, accused of price-gouging during the energy
crunch, has slashed $20 million from California's power bill.
The Charlotte, N.C.-based company on Monday became the first wholesaler to
cut its charges for electricity sold to the state during January and
February.
The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission has identified $124 million in
potential overcharges for the first two months of the year. But it singled
out Duke for criticism in a June 19 order extending price controls in
California. Regulators said the company had overcharged California by
millions of dollars by selling its electricity at rates as high as $3,880 per
megawatt-hour. The commission said it was entitled to charge only $273 per
megawatt-hour.
Duke said it was abiding by the commission's order even though it contests
the gouging accusations.
"It's our way to say, let's get beyond that," Duke spokesman Terry Francisco
said. "Let's try to come up with a long-term solution."
Officials of the California Independent System Operator, which manages most
of the state's electricity grid, had no comment on Duke's action.
Power providers and users continue closed-door talks on an overall settlement
of overcharges in California and the rest of the West. The state contends
that Duke owes it $805 million for overcharges and that, in all, wholesalers
should refund a total $8.9 billion.
"The question of refunds is on the table back in Washington. It would be
premature to comment specifically on Duke's announcement," ISO spokeswoman
Stephanie McCorkle said.
Duke says it has yet to be paid for much of the power it provided California
in January and February.
,2001 Associated Press ?
Duke opens record books but keeps mum on prices
LESLIE GORNSTEIN, AP Business Writer
Tuesday, July 3, 2001
,2001 Associated Press
URL:
http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/news/archive/2001/07/03/financ
ial0329EDT0111.DTL
(07-03) 00:29 PDT (AP) --
With BC-Power Refunds, Bjt
LOS ANGELES (AP) -- Duke Energy released operating logs to counter
accusations it reduced output at a Southern California generating plant to
boost prices.
Former workers have told state investigators that two of four turbines at the
South Bay plant in Chula Vista were shut down on Jan. 16, 17 and 18 -- all
days when California had Stage 3 power shortages.
The Charlotte, N.C.-based firm on Monday released detailed power production
logs for the three days. During most of that time, the logs show, units One
and Two were either supplying all their power to the California market or
providing what's known as ancillary services.
That's when a plant is paid not to produce, but to stand by in case of
emergency, or if the state's grid is already at capacity.
There were also several hours when the turbines were either refueling or
performing mandatory tests of new environmental equipment, Stokes said.
The rest of time, Duke had offered bids for power or services but had been
turned down, Stokes said.
The California Independent System Operator, which oversees most of the
state's electricity grid, has acknowledged that it, not the company, was
controlling the turbines at the time.
"Duke was responding to their requests," said Jeff Stokes, executive vice
president of Duke's western gas and power operations.
"We are shocked and appalled by the accusations that have been leveled
against our company, particularly in a forum in which we were denied an
opportunity to respond," Stokes said in a conference call and Webcast.
The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission last month found the company had
overcharged California by millions earlier this year when it was charging
$3,880 a megawatt-hour for electricity. The commission found that Duke was
entitled to charge only $273 per megawatt-hour.
But Stokes said Duke's prices during those three days were somewhere around
25 percent of the $3,880 figure.
He would not be more specific.
State officials were not impressed.
Duke is drawing conclusions from partial information, said Sen. Joe Dunn,
D-Santa Ana, chairman of the Senate Committee to Investigate Price
Manipulation.
Releasing selected documents presents "nowhere near the complete picture,"
Dunn said.
He has asked the system operator to analyze whether the Duke logs and its own
logs indicate any patterns that suggest price manipulation, but "we don't
have the complete information even yet."
If that ISO information exonerates Duke, Dunn said he will make that clear as
well.
,2001 Associated Press ?
Duke releases California energy records to counter accusations of price
gouging LESLIE GORNSTEIN, AP Business Writer
Tuesday, July 3, 2001
,2001 Associated Press
URL:
http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/news/archive/2001/07/03/nation
al0548EDT0468.DTL
(07-03) 02:48 PDT LOS ANGELES (AP) --
Duke Energy has released operating logs to counter accusations by former
workers that it reduced output to boost prices during California's energy
crisis.
Ex-employees told state investigators two of four turbines at Duke's southern
California plant were shut down for three days in January during Stage 3
power alerts, which can lead to rolling blackouts.
The records show that during most of that time, units One and Two at the
South Bay plant in Chula Vista were either supplying all their power to the
California market or providing what are called ancillary services.
That's when a plant is paid not to produce, but to stand by in case of
emergency, or if the state's grid is already at capacity.
California's Independent System Operator, which manages most of the state's
power grid, has acknowledged that it, not Duke, was controlling the turbines
at the time.
"Duke was responding to their requests," Jeff Stokes, executive vice
president of Duke's western gas and power operations, said Monday.
Stokes added that Duke's prices during those three days were somewhere around
25 percent of the $3,880 figure noted by the Federal Energy Regulatory
Commission when it singled out Duke for criticism in a June 19 order
extending price controls in California.
State officials were not impressed with Duke's operating logs.
Sen. Joe Dunn, chairman of the Senate Committee to Investigate Price
Manipulation, said Duke was releasing selected documents that presented
"nowhere near the complete picture."
Dunn asked the ISO to analyze whether the Duke logs and its own logs indicate
any patterns that suggest price manipulation.
Duke, based in Charlotte, N.C., also on Monday slashed $20 million from
California's power bill, becoming the first wholesaler to cut its charges for
electricity sold to the state during January and February.
FERC has accused Duke of overcharging the state millions of dollars by
selling electricity at rates as high as $3,880 per megawatt-hour when it was
only entitled to charge $273 per megawatt-hour.
Duke contested the gouging accusations but said it would abide by the
commission's order.
"It's our way to say, let's get beyond that," Duke spokesman Terry Francisco
said. "Let's try to come up with a long-term solution."
The ISO had no comment on Duke's $20 million move.
Meanwhile, California's electric grid operator issued an energy alert Monday
for the first time since FERC imposed the cost ceilings, triggering price
caps in 11 Western states.
Unexpectedly high temperatures brought higher energy use that required the
ISO to declare a Stage 2 alert for about three hours, meaning electricity
reserves fell below 5 percent. The ISO maintained a Stage 1 alert into the
evening, meaning reserves were below 7 percent.
California wasn't the only state wallowing in power woes Monday. Triple-digit
temperatures triggered rolling blackouts across southern Nevada for the first
time in the state's history.
By the afternoon, Nevada Power's 1.2 million customers had cranked up air
conditioners enough to demand a record 3,924 megawatts of power, forcing the
utility to cut about 100 megawatts, or enough electricity for roughly 75,000
homes.
"About 10,000 customers were affected for about an hour," said Paul Heagen,
spokesman for Nevada Power Co. "Today was a wake-up call."
Nevada Power asked its major power users, including the neon-lit resorts on
the Las Vegas Strip, for voluntary reductions at about 3 p.m.
Casinos switch to backup generators and took conservation measures that went
mostly unnoticed by guests.
The utility also imposed rolling blackouts until it could purchase power on
the open market, Heagen said.
,2001 Associated Press ?
Las Vegas hit by rolling blackouts
Posted at 7:02 a.m. PDT Tuesday, July 3, 2001
BY JOHN WOOLFOLK, STEVE JOHNSON AND MIKE ZAPLER
Mercury News
LAS VEGAS, Nev. -- In one of the clearest signs yet that the power crisis is
not just California's problem, rolling blackouts swept through Las Vegas on
Monday afternoon in the city famed for its dazzling casino lights, the first
forced outages to hit Nevada.
Energy experts said the blackouts were the first in the West outside of
California since the energy crisis began. Until now, said Frank Wolak, a
Stanford University economist and power grid analyst, ``California has been
rather unique in that regard.''
With a Western heat waving baking Las Vegas, Nevada Power Co. cut electricity
beginning at 4:10 p.m. for 45 minutes to about 10,000 customers. Temperatures
hit 114 degrees at the airport and were reported as high as 120 degrees on
the strip, pushing power demand for air conditioning to record levels.
Ironically, California avoided rolling blackouts Monday despite triple-digit
temperatures that pushed the state for the first time in more than a month
into a Stage 2 emergency, the second-highest level of alert. Despite
forecasts of high temperatures this week, state power officials expect to
squeak by without blackouts.
Nevada, which backed off its electricity deregulation plan in light of
California's troubles, had expected tight supplies this summer, and had
called upon casinos and other big businesses to conserve.
But Monday's forced outages came as a shock to the desert gambling resort.
``This was a surprise,'' said Nevada Power spokeswoman Susan Boswell.
Along the Strip, the outages passed largely unnoticed even as hundreds of
thousands of gamblers and visitors poured in for the Fourth of July holiday
week. Casinos, shopping malls and other public gathering places are exempt
from rolling blackouts in Nevada, Boswell said.
But the casinos did voluntarily cut back their power use, saving a total of
50 megawatts and sparing the rest of the city from more extensive blackouts.
The Aladdin and Bellagio casinos shut off their fountains. Caesars Palace and
the Las Vegas Hilton cut back on air conditioning in ``non-essential areas,''
such as in ballrooms that were not being used. Others dimmed their marquees.
Because the outages hit during the day, the famous lights weren't an issue.
``The casinos did a great job curtailing, which really helped,'' said Nevada
Power spokesman Paul Heagen.
Affected customers were mostly homes and businesses on the northwestern end
of town in the newer suburban Summerlin area, Boswell said. One resident of
northwest Las Vegas, Louise Ruskamp, arrived home Monday afternoon to find
her digital clocks and VCR flashing.
``I think a lot of people are going to be scared we're having the same
problems as in California,'' Ruskamp said. ``If you look at the big elderly
population we have in the city, we'd be having a lot of casualties. You can't
survive in Las Vegas without air conditioning.''
Chuck Umnuss, an elderly resident who lives in Summerlin but wasn't hit by
the blackouts, was still confounded by the news.
``Not more than a month ago everyone was saying there wouldn't be any
problems, that it was a California problem, and here it happens. It's
amazing,'' Umnuss said. ``The people I've talked to are nervous.''
The governor's office reported no health problems as a result of the brief
blackouts. But the outages came with little warning. Nevada Power declared a
``yellow alert,'' similar to California's Stage 2, just minutes before
calling a ``red alert,'' which signals rolling blackouts, Boswell said.
Power officials blamed shortages on the high temperatures as well as power
plant breakdowns that limited both local supplies and imports.
``This was not a Nevada situation,'' Heagen said. ``The whole West and
Southwest was in a heat wave. There just wasn't enough power to go around.''
The unexpected shutdown of two generators at a Mojave power plant that serves
California left 1,500 megawatts unavailable Monday. California saw its
imports drop as neighboring states held on to their power. Nevada lost a
350-megawatt generator.
A bit of luck prevented further outages. A power plant went on line Monday in
Yuba City, and in Nevada several long-term power contracts went into effect.
Nevada officials did not blame California's power troubles for Monday's
outages but noted that the Golden State has stressed the entire Western grid.
``Was today's problem a result specifically from California? No,'' said
Marybell Batjer, chief of staff to Nevada Gov. Kenny Guinn. ``In the larger
picture, California's energy situation has put the entire Western grid into a
situation that's a daily concern for all of us.''
At least five temperature records were set Monday in Nevada, including 122
degrees in Bullhead, in northwestern Nevada, said Steve Anderson, a National
Weather Service forecaster. Temperatures reached 106 in parts of Utah and 116
in Arizona.
Record highs in California included 106 in Livermore and 101 in Hollister.
The previous records had been 104 in Livermore and 97 in Hollister, both set
in 1960.
These kinds of hot temperatures ``usually occur more in August,'' Anderson
said. ``Temperatures will be about the same or actually even hotter
throughout the week, across the same area.''
Blackout hits Las Vegas as number 120 comes up
And California calls its first power alert since May as the mercury soars.
July 3, 2001
From staff and news service reports
Las Vegas suffered its first rolling blackout ever Monday as soaring
temperatures and churning air conditioners outstripped the local utility's
ability to provide electricity.
Nevada Power Co. cut about 100 megawatts, or enough electricity for 75,000
homes, for about an hour.
Scattered outages were reported around the Las Vegas area, where temperatures
reached 120 degrees. Earlier, the utility asked its major power users,
including the neon-lit resorts on the Las Vegas Strip, for voluntary
reductions. Casinos instituted conservation measures largely not noticeable
by guests.
Meanwhile, in California, high temperatures led the Independent System
Operator to declare an emergency alert for the first time since May 31.
A Stage 1 alert was called at 1:35 p.m. as reserves fell below 7 percent of
demand. The alert was upgraded to a Stage 2 at 2:40 p.m., meaning reserves
fell below 5 percent.
The alert didn't trigger new wholesale price limits under a system recently
ordered by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission. Under the FERC rules, a
Stage 1 alert must be in effect for a full clock hour (i.e., 2 to 3 p.m.) to
reset the caps, said Stephanie McCorkle, a spokeswoman for the ISO. Since the
Stage 1 was upgraded to Stage 2 before a clock hour passed, that condition
was not met, she said. The cap, designed to prevent price spikes, remains at
$92 a megawatt-hour.
Stage One and Stage Two Emergencies Declared as Demand Soars; California ISO
Strongly Urges Conservation
July 3, 2001
FOLSOM, Calif.--(BUSINESS WIRE)--July 2, 2001 via NewsEdge Corporation -
The California Independent System Operator (California ISO) issued a Stage
One Emergency at 1:35 p.m. today, July 2, 2001, and a stage two emergency at
2:40 p.m. as operating reserves dipped below five percent. The state's
appetite for power is 2,000 megawatts over forecasts due to temperatures that
are 5 to 6 degrees hotter than meteorologists predicted. Because the heat
wave is regional in nature, levels of imported power have decreased as other
states, especially those in the southwest, also cope with high demand for
power. In addition, 1,500 megawatts of imported power was also reduced when a
two-unit power plant that serves Southern California tripped offline over the
weekend.
The expected peak demand on the transmission system is expected to reach
about 40,000 megawatts around 4:00 p.m. today. Consumers can help reduce the
strain on the power grid by conserving electricity today, especially during
the peak afternoon hours. The California ISO requests that customers
voluntarily reduce their use of electricity to prevent more severe
curtailment measures. -0- *T Powerful Habits at Home:
-- Set your thermostat at 78-80 degrees when home, 85 or off
when away.
-- Avoid using appliances during the peak usage period 8:00
a.m. to 8:00 p.m.
-- Turn off your pool pump and avoid outdoor watering during
peak periods. Powerful Habits at Work:
-- Turn off computer monitor when you are away from your desk
-- Turn off half the overhead lighting.
-- Set the thermostat at 78-80 *T
Today's Stage One and Two declarations, expected to be in effect until 6:00
p.m., enables the California ISO to access emergency resources to help
maintain operating reserves. A Stage Two is declared when reserves drop below
five percent. At this level, large commercial customers that have signed up
to voluntarily curtail power during high demand days will be asked to do so.
If an operating reserve shortfall of less than one-and-a-half percent is
unavoidable, Stage Three is initiated. Involuntary curtailments of service to
customers including "rotating blackouts" are possible during this emergency
declaration. The California ISO's Electrical Emergency Plan (EEP) is part of
the state's enhanced reliability standards enacted by landmark legislation
Assembly Bill 1890 that led to the restructuring of California's electricity
industry.
The California ISO is charged with managing the flow of electricity along the
long-distance, high-voltage power lines that make up the bulk of California's
transmission system. The not-for-profit public-benefit corporation assumed
the responsibility in March 1998, when California opened its energy markets
to competition and the state's investor-owned utilities turned their private
transmission power lines over to the California ISO to manage. The mission of
the California ISO is to safeguard the reliable delivery of electricity,
facilitate markets and ensure equal access to a 25,526 circuit mile "electron
highway."
Conservation tips and continuous system condition updates are available on
the web at www.caiso.com and the California Flex Your Power website is at
www.flexyourpower.ca.gov
Other helpful contacts: -0- *T
Pacific Gas and Electric 415/973-5930
Southern California Edison 626/302-2255
San Diego Gas and Electric 877/866-2066 *T
CONTACT: California ISO, Folsom | Stephanie McCorkle, 888/516-NEWS
Duke Energy Releases California ISO, Internal Records That Confirm
Appropriate Operation of South Bay Plant
July 3, 2001
SALT LAKE CITY, July 2 /PRNewswire/ via NewsEdge Corporation -
Duke Energy (NYSE: DUK) today released previously confidential records that
demonstrate changes in power output at its South Bay power plant near San
Diego were directed by the California Independent System Operator (ISO),
which operates the state's power grid.
Records from the ISO's Automatic Dispatch System demonstrate that Duke Energy
Trading and Marketing (DETM) received instructions from the ISO for
increasing and decreasing the power output from the South Bay plant. Those
instructions were relayed by DETM to operators in the plant control room.
DETM is the California ISO certified scheduler for the Duke Energy plants.
The records graphically refute allegations made by three former San Diego Gas
& Electric (SDG&E) employees that reductions in output at South Bay during
the period January 16-18, 2001, were made at Duke Energy's own direction.
"The records released today are clear proof that the units were made fully
available and followed the direction of the ISO," said Jeff Stokes, Duke
Energy's executive vice president, western natural gas and power for Duke
Energy North America. "Duke Energy has been in the business of generating
electricity for nearly a century. We are proud that our California plants
produced 50 percent more electricity in 2000 than in 1999 and achieved
reliability records that exceeded national standards."
In a media webcast today, Stokes reviewed the plant logs for the three days
in question and the corresponding ISO automatic dispatch logs to demonstrate
the plant was following the direction of the state agency. He also reviewed
DETM logs that demonstrated that the full capacity of both units was offered
to the ISO on the days in question.
Stokes noted that the ISO relies on natural gas plants like South Bay to help
balance supply and demand on the electrical grid -- essential for system
reliability. For that reason, the logs show frequent changes in power levels
as the ISO worked to keep supply and demand in balance.
In order to be able to call on a plant for grid balancing, the ISO purchases
what are known as "ancillary services" from generators. Purchasing ancillary
services essentially puts the generating capacity on hold, allowing the ISO
to call upon it as needed to meet increases or decreases in demand.
Stokes displayed charts from the three days in question that showed the
portion of the power from the South Bay units that was purchased by the ISO
as ancillary services or that was offered and not purchased, as well as the
actual generation from the plant.
"It is important to understand that the reliability of California's power
supply depends not only on adequate energy flows, but on the ability of the
grid operator to keep supply and demand perfectly balanced. Duke Energy has
deep expertise in grid operations and knows that having ancillary services at
their disposal is critical to ISO's mission of keeping the power on," Stokes
said.
A replay of Stokes' webcast with the charts may be seen in the News Center at
www.duke-energy.com.
Duke Energy, a diversified multinational energy company, creates value for
customers and shareholders through an integrated network of energy assets and
expertise. Duke Energy manages a dynamic portfolio of natural gas and
electric supply, delivery and trading businesses -- generating revenues of
more than $49 billion in 2000. Duke Energy, headquartered in Charlotte, N.C.,
is a Fortune 100 company traded on the New York Stock Exchange under the
symbol DUK. More information about the company is available on the Internet
at: www.duke-energy.com.
To see the June 28, 2001 memo from the California ISO, go to the Duke Energy
Web site at:
www.duke-energy.com/decorp/content/newscenter/newsreleases/2001/jul/ISO.pdf
Or, from the Duke Energy Web site, click here to go directly to the
California ISO statement:
Statement from California ISO:
MAKE YOUR OPINION COUNT - Click Here
http://tbutton.prnewswire.com/prn/11690X54568509
SOURCE Duke Energy
CONTACT: Tom Williams, 805-595-4270, or pager, 877-364-5170, or Jennifer
Hillings Epstein, 704-382-1221, or 24-Hour, 704-382-8333, both of Duke Energy
Company News On-Call: http://www.prnewswire.com/comp/257451.html or fax,
800-758-5804, ext. 257451
Web site: http://www.duke-energy.com (DUK)
Calpine's Sutter Energy Center Is Up and Running First New Major Baseload
Generator for California
July 3, 2001
First New Major Baseload Generator for California
SAN JOSE, Calif., July 2 /PRNewswire/ -- In a milestone for California, San
Jose-based Calpine Corporation [NYSE: CPN] announced operation of its Sutter
Energy Center, located near Yuba City. Sutter is the first major
combined-cycle facility built in California in over a decade. This new highly
efficient facility is providing 540 megawatts of affordable electricity to
California on a 24 hours a day, seven days a week availability.
Governor Gray Davis and Calpine CEO Peter Cartwright will hold a press
conference Monday afternoon to note the importance of the Sutter Energy
Center in alleviating the shortage of generation in California and the
support of the local community, the construction and trades people, and
numerous groups that helped make the project a reality.
Cartwright said, "Sutter is the first of eleven announced modern, highly
efficient energy centers Calpine is building in the State. As a California
company, we are committed to providing affordable, reliable electricity, and
we're pleased to announce a second Calpine project, the Los Medanos Energy
Center, will begin operations later this month. Three more Calpine projects
are under construction, and our California initiative will yield 12,000
megawatts of needed electricity by the end of 2005."
Calpine's vision to invest in new power for California preceded the current
energy crisis. With development efforts beginning in 1996, the Sutter Energy
Center is the first facility to be licensed by the California Energy
Commission since the restructuring of the State's electric utility market.
After approval in the spring of 1999, Calpine began construction in June.
Building costs are estimated to be approximately $350 million. More than 500
construction and trade personnel worked on the project over a 2-year span.
During the past several months, the project scheduled two ten-hour shifts,
six days a week to get the plant operating as soon as possible in light of
the energy crisis.
The Sutter Energy Center is located just south of Yuba City in Sutter County
near Sacramento and is operated by a 25-member staff of highly trained
personnel.
As with all of Calpine's modern baseload facilities, Sutter uses
combined-cycle design with natural gas-fired turbines in combination with a
steam turbine. Best available control technologies ensure that emissions are
low. Environmental protection and project safety are always emphasized.
Based in San Jose, Calif., Calpine Corporation is dedicated to providing
customers with reliable and competitively priced electricity. Calpine is
focused on clean, efficient, natural gas-fired generation and is the world's
largest producer of renewable geothermal energy. Calpine has launched the
largest power development program in North America. To date, the company has
approximately 32,800 megawatts of base load capacity and 7,200 megawatts of
peaking capacity in operation, under construction and in announced
development in 29 states and Canada. The company was founded in 1984 and is
publicly traded on the New York Stock Exchange under the symbol CPN. For more
information about Calpine, visit its Website at www.calpine.com.
This news release discusses certain matters that may be considered
"forward-looking" statements within the meaning of Section 27A of the
Securities Act of 1933, as amended, and Section 21E of the Securities
Exchange Act of 1934, as amended, including statements regarding the intent,
belief or current expectations of Calpine Corporation ("the Company") and its
management. Prospective investors are cautioned that any such forward-looking
statements are not guarantees of future performance and involve a number of
risks and uncertainties that could materially affect actual results such as,
but not limited to, (i) changes in government regulations, including pending
changes in California, and anticipated deregulation of the electric energy
industry, (ii) commercial operations of new plants that may be delayed or
prevented because of various development and construction risks, such as a
failure to obtain financing and the necessary permits to operate or the
failure of third-party contractors to perform their contractual obligations,
(iii) cost estimates are preliminary and actual cost may be higher than
estimated, (iv) the assurance that the Company will develop additional
plants, (v) a competitor's development of a lower-cost generating gas-fired
power plant, and (vi) the risks associated with marketing and selling power
from power plants in the newly competitive energy market. Prospective
investors are also cautioned that the California energy environment remains
uncertain. The Company's management is working closely with a number of
parties to resolve the current uncertainty, while protecting the Company's
interests. Management believes that a final resolution will not have a
material adverse impact on the Company. Prospective investors are also
referred to the other risks identified from time to time in the Company's
reports and registration statements filed with the Securities and Exchange
Commission.
MAKE YOUR OPINION COUNT - Click Here
http://tbutton.prnewswire.com/prn/11690X05763853
SOURCE Calpine Corporation
CONTACT: Media Relations, Katherine Potter, 408-995-5115, ext. 1168, or
Investor Relations, Rick Barraza, 408-995-5115, ext. 1125, both of Calpine
Corporation
Web site: http://www.calpine.com (CPN)
Duke Energy Will Offset Receivables Above FERC Proxy Price
July 3, 2001
CHARLOTTE, N.C., July 2 /PRNewswire/ via NewsEdge Corporation -
Duke Energy (NYSE: DUK) announced today that it will offset its receivables
due from the California Independent System Operator (ISO) and the California
Power Exchange (PX) for electricity it sold the two entities in January and
February 2001 by about $20 million. The company will make the appropriate
filing with the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) today.
Duke Energy's prices for electricity sold during March, April and May do not
require offsets based on the criteria used by FERC to determine the need for
offsets or refunds during these months.
In its June 19 order, FERC required Duke Energy to offset any invoiced
amounts above the proxy price it set for electricity in January, which was
$273 per megawatt-hour. Based on the ISO data FERC used to develop its order,
Duke Energy's invoiced amounts above that price totaled $17.8 million for the
month.
Duke Energy also announced it would take the additional step of offsetting
approximately $2.1 million for prices it invoiced above the FERC established
$430 per megawatt-hour proxy price in February.
Duke Energy will provide the ISO and PX with revised invoices to reflect the
offsets. Even with the adjusted billings, Duke Energy has only been paid for
a small fraction of the power it sold to the ISO and the PX for the
California spot market during January and February.
"We are continuing to work diligently with other parties for rational,
long-term solutions to the flawed restructuring of the California electric
power markets," Jim Donnell, president and chief executive officer for Duke
Energy North America. "We look forward to the resolution of the many
outstanding issues and final settlement of the debts owed electricity
suppliers so we may all totally focus on providing a reliable supply of
electricity for California's consumers."
Duke Energy operates approximately 5 percent of California's electricity
capacity from four power plants with a generating capability of 3,351
megawatts. For additional information about Duke Energy's California
operations and the California electricity crisis, please visit our Web site
at www.duke-energy.com/california.
Duke Energy, a diversified multinational energy company, creates value for
customers and shareholders through an integrated network of energy assets and
expertise. Duke Energy manages a dynamic portfolio of natural gas and
electric supply, delivery and trading businesses -- generating revenues of
more than $49 billion in 2000. Duke Energy, headquartered in Charlotte, N.C.,
is a Fortune 100 company traded on the New York Stock Exchange under the
symbol DUK. More information about the company is available on the Internet
at: www.duke-energy.com.
CONTACT: Terry Francisco
Office: 704/373-6680
24-Hour: 704/382-8333
MAKE YOUR OPINION COUNT - Click Here
http://tbutton.prnewswire.com/prn/11690X37089297
SOURCE Duke Energy
CONTACT: Terry Francisco of Duke Energy, 704-373-6680, or 24-Hour,
704-382-8333
Company News On-Call: http://www.prnewswire.com/comp/257451.html or fax,
800-758-5804, ext. 257451
Web site: http://www.duke-energy.com/California
Web site: http://www.duke-energy.com (DUK)
New York Power Producers Announce Five-Point Program to Address State's Long
and Short-Term Energy Needs IPPNY Plan Designed to Prevent California-style
Crisis in New York
July 3, 2001
IPPNY Plan Designed to Prevent California-style Crisis in New York
ALBANY, N.Y., July 2 /PRNewswire/ -- The Independent Power Producers of New
York, Inc. (IPPNY) today unveiled its Energy Solutions Program (ESP); a
five-point action plan to address the long-and short-term energy needs of New
York.
Designed to avoid a California-style energy crisis, IPPNY's ESP addresses the
supply and transmission issues facing New York. It calls for -
-- Increasing energy conservation,
-- Encouraging utilities to enter into contracts to protect consumers
against short-term price volatility,
-- Accelerating the siting process for new, cleaner, diverse power
sources,
-- Fostering an efficient, multi-state energy marketplace, and
-- Upgrading the state's power transmission system.
"New York is at a crossroads: We can either go down the same road as
California, leading to high energy prices and debilitating shortages, or we
can follow the examples of other regional energy markets so that we continue
to enjoy reliable energy at competitive prices," said IPPNY Executive
Director Gavin J. Donohue. "As we move into the hot, humid days of July and
August, when the air conditioners are humming and power demand skyrockets,
the time is right to highlight the need to solve the potential energy
shortages and volatile energy prices that face New York consumers."
Mr. Donohue said that while a California-like emergency is unlikely to hit
New York this summer, the state will experience energy shortfalls and
resulting price increases in the near future unless the government, power
suppliers and consumers begin to take steps now to address known problems. In
developing its plan, IPPNY examined the experiences of other states along
with those of various metropolitan markets in New York since the state began
to restructure its power market in 1996.
"We were struck by the contrast between California and states like
Pennsylvania, where customers enjoy adequate supply and prices 4.5% below the
national average," said Mr. Donohue. "We based the IPPNY ESP on proven
results."
IPPNY's five-point program calls for -
1. Conservation. Energy conservation, particularly by commercial and
industrial consumers, can help reduce New York's power needs in the
short term, as well as help with long-term supplies. The New York
Energy Research and Development Authority's "Energy Smart" program --
which provides energy efficiency information, conducts research and
development on energy efficiency, and provides incentives to consumers
to purchase energy efficient products -- is a good start. Conservation
would be further encouraged if all energy users were able to readily
see how the cost of electricity differs throughout each day. An easy
start would be a tiered system of rates with higher costs for power in
mid-day -- when power is at peak consumer demand -- than the morning.
2. Encouraging New York's utilities to enter into contracts and use
financial risk-management techniques to protect consumers against
short-term price volatility. In a competitive energy market, prices --
particularly in a daily spot market -- rise and fall based on supply
and demand. Utilities can insulate their customers from abrupt and
sharp price changes by relying less on daily spot markets to set their
customers' prices and instead enter into a rational blend of contracts
with power suppliers to stabilize prices. Several New York utilities
already employ these tools to protect customers from price spikes; all
New York utilities should do the same.
3. Getting new, cleaner, diverse power sources on line. The New York
Independent System Operator (NYISO), the non-profit entity that manages
the state's power supply, says that the state needs 8,600 megawatts of
new generating capacity by 2005 to meet growing demand. New York
hasn't put a major new power plant on line since 1995.
New power plants are cleaner and more efficient and New York's
rigorous permitting process guarantees environmental protections. At
the same time, we must maintain our existing base of generation,
powered by a diverse mix of fuel types to prevent over reliance on one
fuel.
New York's ever increasing demand for power dictates that the time
is now to get new, cleaner, more efficient plants up and running.
4. Creating a seamless, multi-state energy market. Current administrative
and regulatory differences between New York, New England and the mid-
Atlantic states prevent power from flowing smoothly among them when
truly needed. As a result, consumers are losing out on the
opportunities for lower costs, better environmental performance, and
higher reliability. The ISOs for each of these bordering regions,
together with the state and federal governments, should expedite
ongoing efforts to eliminate such differences and foster the creation
of a unified northeast market. The recent agreement between the NYISO
and ISO New England on sharing operating reserves is an example of how
this cooperation can work.
5. Upgrading transmission lines so power can efficiently flow from where
it is produced to where it is needed. New York's energy transmission
system is antiquated, inefficient and insufficient to meet the state's
rising demand. For example, the inability to transmit power from
western New York to the eastern part of the state as well as inadequate
power interconnects with the mid-Atlantic and New England regions
inflates prices in the east and New York City. State policymakers need
to quickly determine how to build and pay for an improved transmission
system that will make it cheaper, easier and more efficient to move
power around the state.
"These five steps, if instituted by utilities and state and federal agencies,
would go a long way towards ensuring that New York's lights stay on and power
prices are reasonable and stable," Mr. Donohue said.
The Independent Power Producers of New York, Inc. (IPPNY) is a trade
association representing more than 100 companies involved in the development
of generation, marketing and sale of electric power and natural gas in New
York State. Utilizing cutting-edge technologies and fuel types such as
Cogeneration, Hydro, Coal, Landfill Waste, Resource Recovery and Biomass,
IPPNY members produce approximately 70 percent of New York State's electric
power.
Contact:
Gavin J. Donohue,
Executive Director
(518) 436-3749
MAKE YOUR OPINION COUNT - Click Here
http://tbutton.prnewswire.com/prn/11690X63324797
SOURCE Independent Power Producers of New York, Inc.
CONTACT: Gavin J. Donohue, Executive Director of IPPNY, 518-436-3749
National Desk; Section A
Power Company Rebuts Accusations of Gouging
By JAMES STERNGOLD
?
07/03/2001
The New York Times
Page 10, Column 5
c. 2001 New York Times Company
LOS ANGELES, July 2 -- Duke Energy, one of California 's larger electricity
generators, and state officials today rebutted charges by three former Duke
employees that the company had manipulated output to drive up prices, saying
the shifts had been ordered by a state-controlled agency. And the agency, the
California Independent System Operator, agreed.
Stephanie McCorkle, a spokeswoman for the semi-independent agency, which is
empowered to manage the state's power grid, said it largely controlled how
much power was being produced by the Duke Energy plant. She added that the
agency had not offered this information at the time the former employees
testified in the State Senate because it had not been asked.
In the Senate hearings on June 22, the three former plant workers said the
company had ramped output up and down, manipulated maintenance schedules and
even thrown away some spare parts at a plant in suburban San Diego County in
an apparent effort to drive prices higher in January when supplies were
tight.
The hearing was another theater in the war of words between the state and the
electricity generators, as each has accused the other of causing the energy
crisis.
The state, particularly Gov. Gray Davis, has accused the generators of
gouging the state on the wholesale power market. Gov. Davis recently demanded
about $9 billion in refunds from the generators, including Duke, while the
companies have asserted that the state fell victim to market shortages
created by its own policies.
Some top state officials had called the testimony by the three former Duke
Energy employees -- two plant mechanics and a control room technician -- the
first ''smoking gun,'' proving market manipulation.
''In my opinion, there was price manipulation,'' Glenn Johnson, a certified
power plant mechanic, said of Duke's actions at the San Diego plant. Duke
supplies about 5 percent of California 's electricity from four plants in
California .
But today Duke Energy sought to demonstrate that the state itself had caused
the fluctuations at its plants and that the people who testified were simply
unaware of the company's overall commitments to the market.
The company offered a highly detailed presentation, saying that the rise and
fall in output had been ordered by the agency.
Jeff Stokes, an executive vice president of Duke Energy, which has its
headquarters in Charlotte, N.C., offered copies of handwritten logs from the
plant and other documents to show that the workers saw only a partial picture
of the operation of the plants and so were unaware that at various times the
agency had deliberately set aside some of the output capacity as a reserve.
Mr. Stokes explained that at times the plants are actually put at the
disposal of the agency, which increases or decreases output to maintain
balance in the overall electrical grid. At other times, the agency keeps some
operating capacity off-line as a reserve, so it can meet sudden increases in
demand, he explained.
Mr. Stokes said the bottom line was that during those critical days in
January covered by the testimony in the State Senate, the plant, which has
four operating units, was effectively at the state's disposal.
''The full available output was offered at all times,'' Mr. Stokes said.
Ms. McCorkle, the spokeswoman for the agency, said of the presentation, ''I
thought it was a very accurate description.'' She added that at times the
agency had not bought all the output from the plant because Duke was asking
too much for the power, not because it was being withheld from the market.
Still, some remained skeptical. Governor Davis, who switched on a brand new
power plant in Sutter County today, said through his spokesman that he was
not convinced. Earlier, Mr. Davis had invited the three former plant workers
to breakfast and had offered a tribute to their integrity.
''There are still a lot more questions out there,'' said Steve Maviglio, the
governor's spokesman.
Mr. Maviglio said that even if Duke had refuted the charges the most
important issue outstanding was how much the power generators should refund
to the state for overcharges.
There have been numerous investigations by federal and state agencies of the
wholesale prices charged this year, and several have found what they have
described as convincing evidence of overcharging. But no definitive orders
have been handed down and a host of investigations are continuing.
Indeed, for an industry that was supposedly deregulated several years ago,
the utilities and power generators are now subject to the most intensive
regulatory scrutiny perhaps in their history.
In fact, California triggered price limits in 11 Western states today by
issuing a power alert. It was the first time the limits went into effect
since they were imposed by federal regulators two weeks ago.
Photo: Gov. Gray Davis of California presided yesterday as a power plant went
on line in Sutter County. (Associated Press)