29 Jun 2001, 10:04 UTC
Energy Issues
- From
- Miyung Buster miyung.buster@enron.com
- To
-
Ann M Schmidt, Bryan Seyfried, Elizabeth Linnell, filuntz@aol.com, James D Steffes, Janet Butler, Jeannie Mandelker, Jeff Dasovich, Joe Hartsoe, John Neslage, John Sherriff, Joseph Alamo
and 48 more
Karen Denne, Mark Palmer, Mark Schroeder, Markus Fiala, Michael R Brown, Mona L Petrochko, Nicholas O'Day, Peggy Mahoney, Peter Styles, Richard Shapiro, Rob Bradley, Shelley Corman, Stella Chan, Steven J Kean, Susan J Mara, mike.roan@enron.com, Alex Parsons, andrew.morrison@enron.com, Laura Ipsen, Janel Guerrero, shirley.hudler@enron.com, Kathleen Sullivan, Tom Briggs, Linda Robertson, Lora Sullivan, Jennifer Thome, jkradin@marathon-com.com, rlichtenstein@marathon-com.com, Sandra Yamane, Ken Smith, Hedy Govenar, Scott Govenar, Bev Hansen, Carin Nersesian, Robert Neustaedter, John Shelk, Chris Holmes, Evan Hughes, Roberta Staehlin, Lamar Frazier, Ban Sharma, Pat Shortridge, Karen Moore, Kurt Lindahl, Marcus Dotson, Alan Comnes, Melinda Pharms, Lysa Akin - Bcc
- Angela Wilson
- Date
- Fri, 29 Jun 2001 03:04:00 -0700 (PDT)
Please see the following articles: Sac Bee, Fri, 6/29: Power firms held in contempt (Enron mentioned) Sac Bee, Fri, 6/29: Edison's parent gets new cash Sac Bee, Fri, 6/29: Refineries exempt from power cuts SD Union, Thurs, 6/28: Enron, Mirant cited for contempt by Senate committee SD Union, Thurs, 6/28: Secretary of State accuses governor of failing state in energy crisis LA Times, Fri, 6/29: Congress Reacts Sluggishly to Bush's Energy Proposals LA Times, Fri, 6/29: Senate Panel Lashes Out at 2 Energy Firms SF Chron (AP), Fri, 6/29: California Senate committee cites power companies for contempt for withholding documents SF Chron (AP), Fri, 6/29: California oil refineries exempt from rolling blackouts SF Chron, Fri, 6/29: Conservation funds restored to energy legislation by Bush SF Chron, Fri, 6/29: Refineries exempt from blackouts Oil firms' support services also shielded Mercury News, Fri, 6/29: Officials criticize energy report Mercury News, Fri, 6/29: Extra `power plant' shows deregulation can spur innovation (Editorial) OC Register, Fri, 6/29: Gas Co. to give consumers nearly 50% price break in July Individual.com (Business wire), Fri, 6/29: California Municipal Electric Utility Launches Apogee Demand Exchange to Reduce Peaks Wash. Post, Fri, 6/29: Greenspan Unafraid Of Energy Price Caps; Calif. Problems Ease, Fed Chief Says WSJ, Fri, 6/29: Federal Energy Panel Approves Power Price Controls for New York ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------ Power firms held in contempt By Emily Bazar Bee Capitol Bureau (Published June 29, 2001) A special legislative committee investigating electricity price manipulation voted Thursday to hold two power companies in contempt for refusing to turn over thousands of pages of documents. By unanimously declaring Enron Corp. and Mirant in violation of its subpoenas, the state Senate committee summoned powers that haven't been invoked in the Legislature for more than 70 years. As a result of the unusual move, power company executives could find themselves facing jail time. Possible punishments include fines or the forced turnover of documents. "There isn't a lot of legal precedent," said the chairman of the committee, Sen. Joe Dunn, D-Santa Ana, after the hearing. "Jailing an individual is an option, and we intend to preserve all of our options." The committee is trying to determine whether electricity generators or marketers have artificially inflated prices of wholesale electricity. Other state agencies, including the attorney general's office and the Public Utilities Commission, also have initiated investigations. Under the committee's 5-0 decision, Mirant and Enron have until July 10 to change course and turn over documents. If they do so, the contempt charges will be expunged. If not, the committee will forward its contempt findings to the full Senate, which will determine which punishments, if any, should be levied. As part of its investigation, the committee began requesting documents from most generators in April. After receiving little or no response -- and complaints from companies concerned about giving out proprietary information -- the panel issued subpoenas to several companies June 11. The subpoenas called for documents of all kinds, including those with specific details -- prices, quantities and capacity -- of companies' transactions in the state's wholesale electricity market. Telephone bills, e-mail messages and personal appointment books also were requested. Many of those companies did not respond to the subpoenas until the deadline Thursday. Only two -- Dynegy Inc. and Reliant Energy Inc. -- actually provided documents. During the nearly four-hour meeting, Dunn interrupted the proceedings several times to announce that various letters or documents arrived moments before. For example, Dunn said midway through the hearing that Dynegy had just delivered 18,603 documents to his Capitol office. For those companies that didn't comply with the subpoena, but promised to deliver the necessary documents before July 10, the committee agreed to withhold judgment until that date. Robert Bittman, who represented Mirant at the hearing -- and was allowed to make a hasty phone call to the company in an attempt to avoid the contempt finding -- in the end was unable to adequately assure the senators that Mirant would deliver all required documents before July 10. After the hearing, Mirant spokesman Patrick Dorinson said the company will do everything it can before July 10 to resolve the dispute. "What Mirant needs is assurance from the committee that the company-specific information in these documents doesn't find its way to some public forum where it could be misused," he said. Legislators were particularly irked by energy marketer Enron, which didn't send a representative to the hearing. Instead, Enron delivered a letter to Dunn on Thursday questioning whether the committee was violating the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission's jurisdiction in its investigation. "My great frustration here is getting a letter from Enron on the day the (documents) are due explaining why we don't have jurisdiction," said Sen. Debra Bowen, D-Marina del Rey. Rather than jail time, Bowen said she would like to see fines levied against companies that have violated the subpoenas. The last time the Legislature held someone in contempt was 1929. The case involved a price-fixing conspiracy, but the commodity was concrete. Several officials from concrete companies were subpoenaed, but some declined to testify or divulge documents to a Senate committee. The Bee's Emily Bazar can be reached at (916) 326-5540 or ebazar@sacbee.com. Edison's parent gets new cash By Dale Kasler Bee Staff Writer (Published June 29, 2001) In a move that keeps creditors at bay for now, Southern California Edison's parent company obtained $1.19 billion in fresh financing Thursday. But the troubled company had to pay a higher interest rate than it originally expected, reflecting investors' anxieties about the state energy crisis. The move doesn't affect the beleaguered Edison utility, which has been on the verge of bankruptcy for months, but eases immediate financial stress on its parent Edison International. The parent, through a newly created subsidiary called Mission Energy Holding Co., borrowed the funds at rates of up to 14 percent. That's one percentage point higher than Edison expected last week, according to Standard & Poor's Corp. The company had to restructure the deal because of investor uncertainty, S&P said, and there was speculation by analysts the deal might get scrapped. Even with the higher interest rate, the financing was a must-do for Edison International, said S&P analyst Richard Cortright Jr. The proceeds will go to pay off numerous Edison International debts, including a $618 million bank loan due Saturday and $250 million in bonds due July 18. The company has told the Securities and Exchange Commission that it needed new financing "to meet its cash requirements." The company paid a steep price for meeting those requirements. Part bank loan and part bond sale, the financing cost Edison International about twice what a creditworthy corporation would pay. The bank loan is at a variable rate 7.5 percentage points above the London Interbank Offered Rate, a common benchmark for loans. The deal originally called for Edison International to sell nearly $1.2 billion in bonds, but the company had to scale back the bond offering and pull together the bank loan to make up the shortfall, analysts said. Analysts said the new financing still leaves Edison International about $33 million short of having enough to pay the bond and bank debt coming due this year. The company said it will sell its Edison Select unit to Tyco International Ltd. for an undisclosed price. Edison Select provides home security and warranty-repair services. The Bee's Dale Kasler can be reached at (916) 321-1066 or dkasler@sacbee.com. Refineries exempt from power cuts (Published June 29, 2001) Oil refineries and makers of key chemicals they use will be exempted from rotating outages to avoid gasoline shortages, state utility regulators voted unanimously Thursday. Members of the state Public Utilities Commission said they were acting at the urging of the governor and the state Energy Commission, which had warned that even a one-minute outage could shut down a refinery for up to three weeks. Energy officials told regulators that because California has only 13 refineries, loss of fuel production from even one of them could cause a sharp drop in inventories, triggering substantial price hikes at the pump. The interim decision, which commissioners said they could expand or revise later, does not apply to storage or other facilities. --Carrie Peyton State off 'credit watch' With California's budget squeeze temporarily eased by a bridge loan, a leading Wall Street credit agency removed the state from its dreaded "credit watch" list. Standard & Poor's said it was removing California from "credit watch" -- the term it uses for entities whose credit ratings might be downgraded -- because the state was able to borrow $4.3 billion for electricity purchases. The loan is designed to tide the state over until California can sell $12.5 billion or more worth of electricity bonds this fall. "The interim loan facility buys the general fund time to find a satisfactory workout situation," S&P said. State Treasurer Phil Angelides said last week he'd lined up $4.55 billion in bridge loans. But he still hasn't finalized a $255 million loan from State Street Corp. of Boston, said a spokeswoman for the treasurer. So for now the bridge loans total $4.3 billion. S&P had downgraded the state's credit rating two notches in April because of the mushrooming cost of electricity purchases and kept California on its "credit watch" list, indicating that the credit rating might fall further. California's credit rating stands at "A-plus," with a negative outlook, S&P said. The agency said it was still concerned by the "state's continued rapid level of spending for power purchases." --Dale Kasler Contracts to be released State Controller Kathleen Connell on Thursday said she will release unedited copies of the state's long-term electricity contracts next week, even if Gov. Gray Davis appeals a court ruling requiring him to do so. Connell, who has been highly critical of her fellow Democrat's handling of the state's energy crisis, said Davis negotiated the contracts "in a moment of panic" earlier this year. Davis for months refused to provide copies of the pacts but sent out edited copies earlier this month as a San Diego Superior Court judge ordered them released. On Wednesday, the judge expanded her ruling, telling the state's power buyers to make public the unedited versions. The administration has until Thursday to appeal. But Connell, speaking at a forum in Los Angeles, said she will post them on the Internet on Thursday no matter what Davis decides to do. "There is no reason that the veil of secrecy should not be lifted," she said. --Dan Smith Enron, Mirant cited for contempt by Senate committee By Jennifer Coleman ASSOCIATED PRESS June 28, 2001 SACRAMENTO ) A Senate committee investigating possible price manipulation in California's energy markets voted Thursday to cite generators Enron Corp. and Mirant Inc. for contempt. Both companies had been subpoenaed to produce documents earlier this month by the Senate Select Committee to Investigate Market Manipulation, along with four other generating companies that complied in various ways with the subpoenas. Houston-based Enron said it keeps its documents in Texas, which is outside the committee's jurisdiction. Reliant Energy, also based in Houston, said that too, but it agreed to turn over 1,800 documents. An attorney for Mirant, based in Atlanta, said the company wanted to comply, but Mirant did not act fast enough for the committee, which then included it with Enron in the contempt citation. If the full Senate agrees with the committee's contempt request, it will be the first time since 1929. Then, the Senate briefly jailed a balky witness during a committee's investigation of price fixing and price gouging allegations involving cement sales to the state, said Laurence Drivon, the committee's special counsel. The state Supreme Court eventually upheld the Senate's right to jail those who fail to comply with its subpoenas, Drivon said, but ordered that particular witness freed after determining senators hadn't followed all the proper procedures. By seeking the contempt citations, the committee needs the full Senate to follow through. There are no set penalties, Drivon said ) by law, "the Senate can take such action as it deems necessary and appropriate." Sen. Joe Dunn, D-Santa Ana, chairman of the committee, said there was little precedent for what penalties the Senate could impose. "Jailing an individual is an option and we're going to preserve all our options," he said, adding the Senate could also vote to fine the companies if they don't comply. Enron's claim the committee lacked jurisdiction outraged Sens. Steve Peace, D-Chula Vista, and Debra Bowen, D-Marina del Rey. They said previous legislative investigations have called on documents throughout the country and from overseas. "If they've done nothing, if they've got nothing to hide, there's no reason" not to comply, said Bowen. The committee has been negotiating with the companies over the conditions under which they would release the documents, including those that would remain confidential. The committee has also asked the generators to sign agreements not to destroy any potentially relevant documents. So far, some companies have agreed verbally; none has signed an agreement. "These are the same documents we requested April 5, and to date the summary is: three months, zero documents," Drivon said. Dynegy Energy Services has provided 18,000 documents, committee members said, although no one knows for sure what they include. Duke Energy agreed to comply with the subpoenas and store documents in a repository in Sacramento as long as the company and the committee agree on how to keep the documents confidential. Lawyers for both sides said they could work out an agreement. Williams, AES, Reliant, Dynegy, Duke and NRG will have until July 10 to turn the requested documents over to the repository. Enron and Mirant can have their contempt citations purged if they also comply by then. The Senate Rules Committee subpoenaed the documents ) which include details on bidding, pricing and other aspects of power sales ) earlier this month. Generators said they haven't complied because they have not been able to negotiate an acceptable confidentiality agreement. Secretary of State accuses governor of failing state in energy crisis By Michelle Dearmond ASSOCIATED PRESS June 28, 2001 LONG BEACH ) Giving a glimpse at the hostile tone the state's next gubernatorial contest likely will take, Secretary of State Bill Jones attacked Democratic Gov. Gray Davis on Thursday for his handling of California's energy crisis. Jones, who is seeking the Republican nomination for governor in 2002, expects to face Davis in next year's general election. Davis, who is expected to seek re-election, has not formally announced his candidacy but has already raised more than $26 million. Jones has not had to report his campaign contributions yet but it is widely believed he will have only a fraction of that sum. "During all my years in public service, I have never seen anyone shirk as many tough decisions or seek to blame as many people for his own shortcomings as I've seen from Gray Davis in the last two years," the secretary of state said at a Long Beach Chamber of Commerce luncheon. "His inattention to duty, inaction and lack of leadership has unnecessarily caused much of the economic turmoil our state faces today." Davis press secretary Steve Maviglio said Thursday the governor will be "putting more power online in the next two weeks than in the previous 12 years." He pointed to Davis' 23 executive orders to speed the building of power plants and the 25 percent reduction in energy use in state-run buildings. "The facts speak for themselves," Maviglio said. "The governor licensed the first power plant in 12 years within four months of taking office, in April 1999. While federal regulators were still holding hearings, the governor last summer signed legislation and executive orders." Davis has cited the energy deregulation plan signed into law by his Republican predecessor, former Gov. Pete Wilson, as the start of California's energy woes and has accused power suppliers of manipulating prices. He also has attacked the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, which regulates wholesale energy transactions, and President Bush for not stepping in to help the state. Regulators recently agreed to cap electricity prices throughout the West; Bush has opposed price controls in energy markets. Jones laid the blame for the state's energy crisis on Davis, who he said failed to heed early warning signs of the problem last summer and has devoted more attention to building his campaign coffers than solving the state's problems. "Rather than practicing political gamesmanship, Gray Davis should have paid more attention to the state's pressing policy issues and avoided his multibillion dollar energy mistakes," Jones said. Although Davis took office during a time of prosperity, the state now faces a weakening economy and "antibusiness climate," Jones said. Stealing a page from the book of California's favorite son, former President Reagan, he asked voters if they are better off than they were four years ago. A survey published Thursday by the Los Angeles Times showed that a majority of Californians agree with Davis that energy companies have manipulated the electricity market to boost their profits. Nearly half of those polled also gave Davis low marks for his handling of the crisis. Still, he received nearly four times as much support as Bush. More than 60 percent of respondents deemed the energy crisis the state's top problem and more than half believe there hasn't been enough progress to resolve it. The Times interviewed 1,541 residents over four days beginning Saturday. The paper said the poll had a margin of error of plus or minus 3 percentage points. Jones made no reference in his speech to his Republican opponents by name, but noted that he's the only GOP candidate to have won statewide elections twice. Outgoing Los Angeles Mayor Richard Riordan, a moderate Republican who has endorsed Democrats in the past, is contemplating a run for the office, and businessman William E. Simon Jr. recently announced his candidacy. In an interview with The Associated Press, Jones criticized Riordan for having crossed party lines in partisan races with both endorsements and donations. Jones also trumpeted his own experience as a longtime lawmaker and faithful Republican and noted that Simon hasn't held statewide office. Congress Reacts Sluggishly to Bush's Energy Proposals By JANET HOOK and RICHARD SIMON , Times Staff Writers ?????WASHINGTON--More than a month after the White House unveiled its national energy plan with great fanfare, President Bush's proposals are languishing on Capitol Hill, casting doubt on whether Congress has the political will to pass the kind of sweeping redirection of policy that Bush is seeking. ?????Several powerful trends are contributing to the impasse: Gasoline prices are moderating across the country. So far, there have been no summer power outages in California. Members of Bush's own party are obstructing efforts to expand oil and gas drilling. And polls suggest the public isn't really sure if the country faces a true energy crisis. ?????Fearful that one of its signature policy initiatives has been all but unplugged, the administration fought back Thursday by launching a new public relations offensive. ?????Leaders of both parties still promise passage of energy legislation later this year, but it seems increasingly likely to be far less sweeping than the bold action sought by Bush and Vice President Dick Cheney. ?????Many Republicans, for example, have broken ranks with the White House on oil and gas exploration in Alaska's Arctic National Wildlife Refuge. ?????Last week, the House voted to ban drilling off the Florida coast and in national monuments. And Thursday, a sizable contingent of House Republicans teamed with Democrats to ban drilling under the Great Lakes. ?????"We're worried about it," acknowledged Majority Leader Dick Armey (R-Texas). "Those votes were disturbing." ?????"Of course, we're discouraged," added Rep. W.J. "Billy" Tauzin (R-La.), chairman of the House Energy and Commerce Committee. ?????Democrats aren't getting their way either. Their proposals to impose rigid price caps on electricity in the West are going nowhere in the House, and Senate sponsors are holding off on pursuing the issue. ?????To be sure, probably nothing would help Bush's energy plan more than an ugly summer of blackouts in California to stoke the nation's sense of urgency about the problem. One reason political momentum has flagged, analysts say, is the perception that the crisis is abating in California and elsewhere. ?????"The urgency in California is starting to dissipate," said Sen. John B. Breaux (D-La.), who supports much of the Bush plan but put the chances of passage of comprehensive energy legislation at no better than 50-50. "There's less of a rush" to act. ?????"The shoe isn't tight enough," said Sen. Frank H. Murkowski (R-Alaska), who until recently was the chairman of the Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee. "The prices aren't high enough." ?????Noted Stephen Bell, chief of staff to Sen. Pete V. Domenici (R-N.M.), a senior member of the Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee: "The momentum behind a comprehensive energy package has seriously dissipated. The truth is, not many people have any idea what to do." ?????Bush sought to put the spotlight back on his plan Thursday by announcing $86 million in federal grants to encourage educational institutions and private firms to develop more efficient fuel technologies. ?????He also unveiled a variety of actions to curb energy use within the federal bureaucracy, including setting new standards for "vampire" electrical devices that drain energy even when not in use. These devices include many consumer products and household appliances. ?????Bush Cites Need for 'Wise Choices' ?????"Our nation must have a strategy, a broad, comprehensive energy strategy that calls upon the best of the nation's entrepreneurs to help us develop the technologies necessary to make wise choices in the marketplace as well as calls upon our nation's innovative technologies to help us find new sources of energy," he said. ?????Referring to California, Bush said he was "pleased to see" a new power plant come on line Wednesday in Kern County, calling it "the beginnings of what is a rational energy policy that will help the good people of California get out from underneath 10 years of neglect." ?????Congressional Republicans, many of whom are heading home today for a weeklong recess, have been armed with talking points, computer presentations and briefing papers to tout Republican energy plans at town hall meetings with constituents. White House strategists are meeting daily to plot strategy. ?????"The president has taken many steps to help people who are feeling the energy crunch right now," said Jim Wilkinson, a White House official involved in the effort. "It's up to us to make sure they know he's fighting for them." ?????That effort is driven, in part, by GOP concerns that Democrats have been promoting their solution to the West's electricity crisis--price controls--without an aggressive Republican rejoinder. ?????Democrats, especially in the House, continue to see political advantage in the issue. They believe that if energy woes intensify in California and around the country this summer, Republicans will bear the political blame if they are seen as doing nothing to remedy the problem. ?????On Wednesday, House Democrats began circulating a petition to force Republican leaders to bring price-control legislation to a vote. Congressional investigators, prodded by Democrats, are pressing Cheney to release records of private meetings held with special interests during drafting of the energy plan. If the documents are not provided, subpoenas could be issued. ?????The contrast with the way Congress considered Bush's tax cut is striking. Both issues were central to Bush's campaign for the presidency. After he became president, the House began work on his tax cut even before he submitted a formal plan. And the entire bill barreled through Congress in a mere four months. ?????But his energy initiative met with more ambivalence from the outset. ?????"It's not like taxes, where the Democrats knew they were in trouble on the issue," said David M. Nemtzow, president of the Alliance to Save Energy, a Washington-based coalition of business, consumer, government and environmental advocates. "Democrats are gleeful about picking a fight on energy." ?????Even as Cheney was unveiling the plan in mid-May, Republicans were expressing reservations about key elements. The proposal to expand energy exploration in the Arctic refuge was treated as dead on arrival. A proposal to empower federal authorities to condemn private property for new power lines met with immediate opposition, even from conservatives within Bush's own party. ?????Polls show widespread public concern about the environmental effects of the energy proposals. ?????"On offshore drilling, [tougher sport-utility vehicle fuel economy] standards, more emphasis on conservation, you see Republicans not all that different from Democrats," said Carroll Doherty, political analyst at the Pew Research Center for the People and the Press. ?????Meanwhile, action by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission to restrain utility price hikes in California and the West has eased pressure on Congress to act. ?????The change of leadership in the Senate also has had a big effect. Republicans had planned to bring up an energy bill in June but lost control of the Senate after Sen. James M. Jeffords of Vermont left the GOP and became an independent. ?????Democrats, instead, brought up legislation to expand patients' legal rights in dealing with health maintenance organizations. ?????Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle (D-S.D.) said he would move energy legislation in the "not too distant future." He didn't say exactly what would be in the bill but added that one thing certainly would not be: Bush's proposal to expand drilling in Alaska's wildlife refuge. ?????Republicans plan to hammer Democrats during the July recess, arguing that they have relegated the nation's growing energy needs to the back burner. ?????In the House, where Republicans are still in the majority, leaders have asked committees that handle pieces of energy policy to draft their part of the legislation by mid-July, in hopes of bringing it to the floor before the August recess. ?????But it's not clear how far they can go in pushing Bush's proposals to increase energy production. ?????"What's striking is that even Republicans are unenthusiastic about the administration's energy plan," said Marshall Wittmann, senior fellow at the conservative Hudson Institute, citing recent anti-drilling votes in the GOP-controlled House. "If you can't make it there, you can't make it anywhere." ?????Senate Energy Committee Chairman Jeff Bingaman (D-N.M.), who met with Bush at the White House on Thursday, said he hopes to draft a comprehensive bill that would put more emphasis on promoting conservation, energy efficiency and renewable energy sources. But he doubted it would be ready to move to the Senate floor until after the summer recess. ?????Both Parties' Bills May Be Combined ?????Efforts are underway to consolidate common features of Democratic and Republican energy bills into a package that could be acted upon quickly. ?????Such a measure would likely include provisions to promote conservation, offer tax credits for buying fuel-efficient gas-electric hybrid cars, reduce the patchwork of gasoline recipes blamed for contributing to price spikes and supply shortages, boost energy assistance to low-income people, and extend a law limiting the liability of nuclear power plants in the event of an accident. ?????The administration also is moving ahead to implement a number of directives that can be carried out by executive order or through the actions of regulatory agencies, without requiring congressional approval. --- ?????Times staff writer Edwin Chen contributed to this story. Copyright 2001 Los Angeles Times Senate Panel Lashes Out at 2 Energy Firms Hearings: Lawmakers hold Enron and Mirant in contempt for refusing to help in pricing probe. By CARL INGRAM, Times Staff Writer ?????SACRAMENTO--Angered by the refusal of electricity wholesalers to surrender information about suspected price gouging, a Senate committee voted Thursday to hold two big energy companies in contempt of the Legislature. ?????It was uncertain what punishment, if any, may be in store for Enron Corp. of Houston and Mirant Corp. of Atlanta. But committee members said potential sanctions could include heavy fines and/or the jailing of corporate executives. ?????"Jailing of an individual is an option and we intend to preserve all our options," warned state Sen. Joe Dunn (D-Santa Ana), chairman of the committee investigating whether the wholesalers had manipulated the market. ?????"Could we impose, say, $9 billion in fines?" Sen. Debra Bowen (D-Marina del Rey) asked rhetorically. ?????Enron reacted angrily. "This is a shakedown," charged spokesman Mark Palmer. "And if this is a shakedown, we're going to protect our legal rights." ?????Enron had further enraged the committee by sending a letter saying the legislative panel had no authority to conduct its investigation because wholesale prices were the "exclusive jurisdiction" of the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission. ?????A spokesman for Mirant said the company intends to keep talking to the committee to reach an agreement. ?????The bipartisan committee had been prepared to find eight generators--mostly out-of-state companies--in contempt for refusing to produce the subpoenaed records. But by the end of the four-hour hearing, companies that said they would cooperate--AES, Duke, Dynergy, NRG, Reliant and Williams--escaped a citation, at least temporarily. ?????Though the committee found Enron and Mirant in contempt, its action is subject to ratification by the full Senate. ?????Dunn said contempt citations are so rare there are few guidelines to follow in determining a punishment. He said it "could be anything that the Senate believes is necessary and reasonable." ?????The finding of contempt for failure to obey a legislative subpoena is rarely used in California. Sources said it last was done in 1929 when an officer of a cement company refused to cooperate in a price-fixing investigation. ?????Late in 2000 and earlier this year, the profits of major electricity wholesalers soared astronomically, throwing the state's two biggest utilities, Pacific Gas and Electric Co. and Southern California Edison Co., into financial chaos. Edison is teetering on bankruptcy and PG&E is in Bankruptcy Court. ?????The committee, which first asked the companies to provide the information voluntarily in April, encountered strong resistance from the energy companies. They complained that their trade secrets might be exposed to competitors, the public and government regulators. ?????Frustrated, the committee two weeks ago issued subpoenas demanding the information, including whether the power sellers had destroyed any records. ?????The committee set Thursday as the deadline for compliance and threatened to find violators in contempt, a tactic that appeared to turn around all but Enron and Mirant. ?????"Let's move forward. We want to facilitate your investigation," said Duke attorney Joel Kleinman of Washington, whose company had objected to its subpoena. ?????At the last minute, several sellers began sending urgent fax letters or witnesses to Dunn. Dunn said a quick scan of the letters showed wholesalers were pleading for a second chance and assuring that the subpoenaed data would be forthcoming. ?????Kleinman told the committee Duke did not want to be held in contempt. ?????"We will make tens of thousands of documents available for inspection," Kleinman said. ?????But he said Duke and the committee staff still must settle on a confidentiality agreement, a matter he indicated was close to resolution. Other wholesalers appeared to fall into line. ?????Dunn said he was concerned that "minor problems" in reaching a confidentiality agreement might become a tactic for further delay. ?????The committee gave the six companies until July 10 to reach confidentiality agreements and turn over a vast assortment of records. ?????The contempt finding against Mirant and Enron would be abandoned if they, too, provided the confidential documents by July 10, when the committee will review the companies' compliance. ?????The wholesalers also are the targets of similar investigations by Atty. Gen. Bill Lockyer and the state Public Utilities Commission. --- ?????Times staff writer Nancy Vogel contributed to this story. Copyright 2001 Los Angeles Times California Senate committee cites power companies for contempt for withholding documents JENNIFER COLEMAN, Associated Press Writer Friday, June 29, 2001 ,2001 Associated Press URL: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/news/archive/2001/06/29/nation al0450EDT0476.DTL (06-29) 01:50 PDT SACRAMENTO, Calif. (AP) -- A Senate committee investigating possible price manipulation in California's energy markets cited two power generators for not turning over documents requested for the probe. The documents -- which include details on bidding, pricing and other aspects of power sales -- had been requested in subpoenas issued earlier this month to Enron Corp., Mirant Inc. and four other generating companies. On Thursday, the Senate Select Committee to Investigate Market Manipulation approved a contempt motion, citing Enron and Mirant for not producing the materials. The other four generators complied. The motion still needs approval by the full Senate. The Senate Rules Committee had subpoenaed the materials. Enron, based in Houston, said its documents are outside the committee's jurisdiction because they are kept in Texas. An attorney for Atlanta-based Mirant said the company wanted to comply, but did not act quickly enough to avoid the contempt vote. California law does not specify penalties for a contempt finding, said Laurence Drivon, the committee's special counsel. "The Senate can take such action as it deems necessary and appropriate," he said. Enron's claim that the committee lacked jurisdiction outraged some senators, who said previous legislative investigations have sought documents from throughout the world. "If they've done nothing, if they've got nothing to hide, there's no reason" not to comply, Sen. Debra Bowen said. The committee has been negotiating with the companies to try to reach a confidentiality agreement for the release of the documents, and has asked the generators to sign agreements not to destroy any potentially relevant documents. So far, some companies have agreed verbally, but none has signed. Duke Energy agreed to comply with the subpoenas and store documents in a repository in Sacramento, if the company and the committee can agree on how to keep the documents confidential. Lawyers for both sides said they could work out an agreement. Enron and Mirant can have the contempt citations withdrawn if they turn over the requested documents to the repository by July 10. On the Net: Senate select committee: www.sen.ca.gov/ftp/sen/committee/select/INVESTIGATE/_home1/PROFILE.H TM Enron: www.enron.com Mirant: www.mirant.com ,2001 Associated Press ? California oil refineries exempt from rolling blackouts KAREN GAUDETTE, Associated Press Writer Friday, June 29, 2001 ,2001 Associated Press URL: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/news/archive/2001/06/29/state1 545EDT0208.DTL (06-29) 00:02 PDT SAN FRANCISCO (AP) -- Rolling blackouts will no longer threaten the oil refineries that produce more than a third of California's gasoline supply. State power regulators voted unanimously Thursday to exempt the refineries and associated pipelines and chemical factories from power outages, ensuring a stable fuel supply and helping keep gasoline prices from rising at the height of the summer driving season. An outage of even a minute can knock a refinery out of service for up to a week, the California Energy Commission told state power regulators. Carl Wood, a member of the state Public Utilities Commission, said he proposed the exemption after the petroleum industry, Gov. Gray Davis, the Legislature and the California Energy Commission warned the PUC that the gas supply could drop and prices could soar without quick action. "The importance of the petroleum industry to California's economy has been recognized by the Legislature," Wood said. The vote affects 13 refineries in Pacific Gas and Electric Co. and Southern California Edison territory. Four oil refiners -- Valero Energy, Tosco, Exxon Mobil and Equilon Enterprises -- had petitioned for blackout exemptions at their facilities which produce about one-fourth of the state's refining capacity. That's about 2.3 million barrels a day. The state's largest refiner, San Francisco-based Chevron Corp., bypassed the PUC and told Davis it would stop production at its two California refineries if regulators and state lawmakers did not protect them from blackouts. Chevron controls about 18 percent of the state's refining capacity. The PUC is still reviewing applications from nearly 10,000 other businesses which hope to be protected from rolling blackouts. Wood said exempting the refineries only accounts for one percent of the pool of customers that can receive outages. That means the PUC can exempt only 9 percent more from that pool when it decides in August who will get to keep their lights on and their businesses running when blackouts roll through. On the Net: www.cpuc.ca.gov/ ,2001 Associated Press ? Conservation funds restored to energy legislation by Bush New York Times Friday, June 29, 2001 ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle URL: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/chronicle/archive/2001/06/29/M N73892.DTL Washington -- President Bush sent Congress proposed energy legislation yesterday that includes the restoration of nearly $300 million for Clinton-era research programs on energy conservation. The conservation money came after a series of polls showed that Americans believed Bush's energy plans were primarily about helping oil companies and drilling in the Arctic, rather than encouraging energy savings. Bush's focus on conservation runs contrary to earlier dismissive references made by Vice President Cheney, who suggested that conservation did not constitute an energy strategy. In addition to restoring the research funds, Bush called for federal and corporate work on small devices called "vampire slayers" that could cut the power consumption of appliances that draw electricity as they await use -- copiers, fax machines and cell-phone chargers. Environmental groups said Bush was avoiding mention of conservation measures that could prove far more effective, such as raising fuel-efficiency standards for cars. "Everything he did on the standby power problem is good, but it is comparatively small potatoes," said David Nemtzow, president of Alliance to Save Energy, which has been lobbying for more conservation measures. Both mileage standards and restoring the Clinton administration's proposals on air conditioner efficiency would save far more power than anything the president discussed yesterday, he said. ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle ? Page?A - 7 Refineries exempt from blackouts Oil firms' support services also shielded Bernadette Tansey, Chronicle Staff Writer Friday, June 29, 2001 ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle URL: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/chronicle/archive/2001/06/29/M N168779.DTL Yielding to appeals from Gov. Gray Davis and industry officials, state regulators exempted oil refineries yesterday from rolling blackouts that may sweep California this summer if electricity supplies run short. The state Public Utilities Commission shielded the state's 13 refineries from service interruptions that Chevron and other companies said could disrupt gasoline production for weeks and increase prices. The new exemption also covers some support services, such as waste- treatment plants and contractor firms, that the oil companies maintain are essential to keep the refineries running. The decision is good news for motorists, said Scott Folwarkow, a spokesman for the Valero refinery in Benicia. "California has a tight supply-demand balance (for gasoline)," Folwarkow said. "By ensuring that refineries are exempt from blackouts, you should not have shortages that could translate into higher prices at the pump." The commission had stripped the refineries of exemptions earlier this year as California's utilities tried to prune the ranks of customers immune from blackouts to eliminate any that did not qualify as "essential services," such as hospitals and fire stations. To avoid a power system crash, the utilities must each have 40 percent of their customers vulnerable to blackouts. During power emergencies, customers on numbered circuits known as "blocks" take their turn suffering interruptions that may affect no more than one block and last for two hours or less. But refinery officials warned that even brief blackouts that forced units to shut down suddenly could damage equipment and halt production for days or weeks. In response to the industry call for a blanket refinery exemption, the PUC in May invited not only refineries but all other businesses to make their case that public health or safety could be threatened if they were not spared from breaks in service. Those applications are now being considered by a consultant, and the commission is not scheduled to act on them until August. But as summer approached, Chevron sent a letter to Davis warning that it would cut back production at its two refineries in Richmond and El Segundo if the company could not be assured of a reliable power supply. Chevron said it would produce only at levels that could be supported by its cogeneration plants. Davis followed up with a letter to the PUC urging a blanket refinery exemption, a measure supported by the California Energy Commission, state Assemblyman Joe Canciamilla, D-Pittsburg, and other state officials. Chevron spokesman Fred Gorell said the PUC action yesterday was "good public policy and in the best interest of California consumers." "This provides the reliability we need to operate at or near capacity," Gorell said. E-mail Bernadette Tansey at btansey@sfchronicle.com. ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle ? Page?A - 7 Officials criticize energy report Posted at 8:06 p.m. PDT Thursday, June 28, 2001 BY CHRIS O'BRIEN Mercury News California's energy crisis is expected to increase unemployment, reduce production and aggravate an already weakening economy, according to researchers at the University of California-Los Angeles. The impact, however, will likely depend on how state officials choose to deal with the failed deregulation scheme. The authors of the report released Thursday come down heavily in favor of lifting price controls and dramatically increasing the price consumers pay as a way to reduce the economic fallout. ``California's economy is sufficiently large and dynamic that it will weather the current power crisis without being derailed,'' the report says. ``However, our analysis reveals that this impact can be moderated by an approach that does not shift today's problems to tomorrow.'' The study, ``Short Circuit: Will the California Energy Crisis Derail the State's Economy,'' came under fierce criticism from Gov. Gray Davis' office. Steven Maviglio, Davis' spokesman, said many of the assumptions used to produce the report are either outdated or flat wrong. ``It deserves its rightful place sitting on the shelf gathering dust,'' Maviglio said. ``Like any crystal-ball report, it's essentially irrelevant.'' Edward Lamer, a UCLA professor, and Christopher Thornberg, a visiting professor at UCLA, collaborated on the report with a team of researchers from the Cambridge Energy Research Associates. The study concludes that California's gross state product will be cut by anywhere from .7 percent to 1.5 percent in 2001 as a result of the energy crisis. In addition, energy problems will increase unemployment by .5 percent in 2001 and 1.1 percent in 2002. The report predicts consumers can expect 112 hours of rolling blackouts this year. However, the report argues that the impact could be dramatically reduced if the state would raise the price consumers pay for energy to match the wholesale costs. This could reduce blackouts to 12 hours, lower the debt and interest the state will have to pay for electricity and encourage investment in the state to increase energy supplies. But Peter Navarro, a management professor at the University of California-Irvine, was skeptical of the report's findings. He said it was almost impossible to build models complex enough to take into account all the factors that affect energy prices in the state. In addition, he said the report seems to assume that there is no manipulation of the current market, which Navarro argues could be distorting prices as well. ``How do you justify raising retail rates to 45 cents for power that costs a nickel to generate when there is some evidence that the market is flawed?'' Navarro said. ``This report seems to have an industry point of view and an industry agenda.'' Contact Chris O'Brien at cobrien@sjmercury.com or (415) 477-2504. Extra `power plant' shows deregulation can spur innovation Published Friday, June 29, 2001, in the San Jose Mercury News CALIFORNIA fired up a medium-sized power plant on Wednesday, and might be about to discover another one hiding in the electric grid. The first is of the steel-and-concrete variety. The Sunrise Cogeneration and Power Project near Bakersfield is a 320-megawatt plant, generating power for some 240,000 homes. The plant will be eligible for a $1 million bonus for opening ahead of schedule. But while the construction was speeded along by new state policies, the application for the plant was filed in December 1998. The plant illustrates both the previous unhurried permit process and the current speedy one. More intriguing is the second ``power plant,'' which is not a plant at all, but a way of operating the grid to squeeze more electricity out of it. Scientists and technicians think that reducing the voltage coming into homes from 120 volts to 117 volts would save the equivalent of 500 megawatts statewide. We'll take their word for it. But in any event, such a reduction evidently would not damage appliances or electronic equipment. If that's true, it should be implemented. It's a free power plant. Encouraging such ingenuity is one benefit of a deregulated market in electricity. Gas Co. to give consumers nearly 50% price break in July An average user can expect to save $5.73 compared with a year ago. June 29, 2001 By KATE BERRY The Orange County Register After months of paying the highest natural-gas prices in the country, consumers in Southern California will get some relief this summer. Southern California Gas Co. said it will cut gas prices nearly 50 percent on July bills, the largest drop in four years. The Gas Co. will cut its price per therm to 27 cents for July bills,down from 52.1 cents in June and 46.1 cents in July 2000. A therm is a measure of heat energy. It takes 0.02 therm to brew a pot of tea. An average consumer who uses roughly 30 therms a month can expect to pay $20.10, including distribution charges, on the July gas bill, vs. $25.83 a year ago, said Ed van Herik, a spokesman. The company is required to reduce consumer rates when wholesale gas prices fall. The San Diego-based utility, which supplies 5 million households with gas, had raised prices as high as 74 cents per therm in March because of a shortage of natural-gas supplies. Prices have fallen because the company is buying natural gas mostly from producers in the Southwest, rather than at the California border, where prices are higher, spokeswoman Denise King said. Border prices are the subject of investigations by federal regulators. El Paso Energy Corp. of Houston, the major gas supplier to Southern California, is the target of federal inquiries to determine why gas prices in California are so much higher than in other parts of the country. The wholesale cost of natural gas delivered to Southern California has ranged from $11 per million British thermal units earlier this month to as much as $60 per million Btus in December. On Thursday, prices at hubs in the Western region fell to as low as $3.34 per million Btu. California Municipal Electric Utility Launches Apogee Demand Exchange to Reduce Peaks June 29, 2001 ATLANTA--(BUSINESS WIRE)--June 28, 2001 via NewsEdge Corporation - Sacramento Municipal Utility District (SMUD), one of California's largest municipal electric utilities, is using Apogee Interactive's Demand Exchange(SM) Internet platform to reduce peak electric loads with its commercial and industrial customers. With SMUD's voluntary, web-based programs EnergyNet (Demand-Bid) and EnergyDirect (Direct Load Control), SMUD offers customers financial incentives in exchange for load reductions. All communication and transactions are conducted over the web and customers are given anywhere from one hour to two days to plan ahead for reduced electrical use. Using The Demand Exchange website, EnergyNet customers review SMUD's offered price for upcoming peak periods and automatically calculate what their financial savings will be using various load reduction scenarios. If they elect to participate, they submit their pledge over the website. "For us the key to making a curtailment program work is automation. The Demand Exchange platform lets us notify many customers simultaneously, see how they plan to respond, and streamline the process of posting bill credits associated with those customers' participation," said Harlan Coomes, program manager for SMUD. SMUD is just one of the California utilities using The Demand Exchange. The California Energy Commission has approved The Demand Exchange as one of six key components in its Peak Load Reduction Program menu. "The Demand Exchange offers customers an easy way to reduce costs and utilities an effective way to aggregate relatively small individual loads to achieve significant system-wide impact at enormously reduced administrative costs," said Joel Gilbert, chief executive officer of Apogee. The number of utilities using The Demand Exchange has jumped to more than 25, including San Diego Gas & Electric Co. (NYSE: SRE), Portland General Electric, Entergy (NYSE: ETG), GPU Energy (NYSE: GPU) and Southern Company (NYSE: SO). Apogee projects the Exchange will facilitate 100,000 megawatt-hours in peak load reductions this summer and twice that amount by the end of the year. SMUD's EnergyNet and EnergyDirect programs are a cooperative effort between SMUD, Apogee Interactive, ABB Energy Interactive Inc. and Stonewater Software. Formed in 1994, Apogee is a leading provider of Internet solutions, web content and e-learning courseware to the energy industry. Apogee's clients include all of the major U.S. investor-owned utilities and many of the country's cooperatives and municipal systems. Company information is available at www.apogee.net. CONTACT: Apogee Interactive | Kathy Hart | Mobile: 404/271-1489 | Office: 770/270-6512 | Fax: 770/270-6532 | khart@apogee.net Financial Greenspan Unafraid Of Energy Price Caps; Calif. Problems Ease, Fed Chief Says John M. Berry ? 06/29/2001 The Washington Post FINAL Page E03 Copyright 2001, The Washington Post Co. All Rights Reserved In a broad analysis of the state of U.S. energy markets, Federal Reserve Chairman Alan Greenspan last night disagreed sharply with the Bush administration's argument that capping spot prices for electricity in California would discourage construction of new power plants. Greenspan, in a speech to the Economic Club of Chicago, argued exactly the opposite. "Analogies to the economics of office buildings are evident," Greenspan said. "Few office buildings would be constructed in the absence of the ability to reach long-term leases. Short-term rental agreements are no more conducive to new office construction than spot prices for electric power are to the building of new power plants." A copy of the text was released in Washington. California 's energy problems appear to be easing, but they still represent a "worrisome situation for Californians, certainly," Greenspan said. "And because the state comprises one-eighth of our national [economy], it should be a concern for the U.S. economic outlook as well. Fortunately, the overall effects on the California economy, and on those of its neighboring states, seems to have been modest, at least to date." Greenspan noted that large increases in the cost of gasoline and other petroleum products, natural gas, and electricity have hurt the U.S. economy in several ways. The most significant is the reduced profitability of non-energy firms, which has forced many companies to reduce spending for new plants and equipment. "As best we can infer, a substantial part of the rise in the total costs of corporations between the second quarter of last year and the first quarter of this year reflected higher energy costs, only a small part of which companies apparently were able to pass through into higher prices" of the things they sell, he said. Most recently, however, natural gas prices "have fallen significantly" and so have gasoline prices, particularly in the Midwest, Greenspan said. " Electricity power costs continued to rise through May, but overall energy prices paid in April and May were down from the levels of the first quarter, suggesting some easing in pressures on profit margins from energy this quarter." Greenspan cautioned that "because of the unpredictability of events in the Middle East," crude oil supplies are never fully secure. "Nonetheless, it is encouraging that in market economies, well-publicized forecasts of crises, such as earlier concerns about gasoline price surges this summer, more often than not fail to develop, or at least not with the frequency and intensity proclaimed by headline writers." Greenspan said it was necessary to rely on market forces to guide both energy production and consumption. "In the short run, energy markets must be monitored closely for their potential effects on the cyclical behavior of the macro economy," he said. "Over the longer haul, the experience of the past 50 years -- and indeed much longer than that -- suggest the central role that can be played by market forces in conserving scarce energy resources, directing those resources to their highest valued uses, and ultimately ensuring adequate productive capacity for the future." By Greenspan's analysis, California made a serious mistake by insisting that companies supplying power to retail customers buy that power only on the spot market. http://www.washingtonpost.com Contact: http://www.washingtonpost.com Economy Federal Energy Panel Approves Power Price Controls for New York By Andrew Caffrey ? 06/29/2001 The Wall Street Journal Page A2 (Copyright (c) 2001, Dow Jones & Company, Inc.) Federal energy regulators, who last week authorized electricity price controls for California and 10 other Western states, yesterday approved a plan by New York officials to curb price spikes in that state's volatile wholesale electricity markets. However, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission expressed concern that the New York measure could restrict electricity prices that are legitimately high. The agency, therefore, allowed the New York curbs only as a temporary measure through Oct. 31, which would see New York through the high-power-demand summer months. State officials had sought approval for the measure as a continuing tool to keep prices in check. New York officials say the mitigation plan is necessary this summer to prevent power generators from taking advantage of the state's tight supply market and charging excessive prices for electricity when demand is at its greatest. The federal commission's approval is "an important step toward protecting energy consumers," New York Gov. George Pataki said in a statement. Mr. Pataki's appointees at the New York Public Service Commission had first pushed for the price-curb plan after concluding in December that the state's wholesale power markets are "dangerously vulnerable to market power abuse during a normal or hotter- than-normal summer." Under the plan, the New York Independent System Operator Inc., which administers the state's wholesale trading markets, would automatically review generators' bids when power prices exceed $150 a megawatt hour during periods of high demand or when many electric plants are offline. System Operator officials would look for bids that are either $100 more or 300% higher than a historic average of bids from an individual facility to determine whether the generator is trying to manipulate the market. If the generator can't offer a good explanation for its high bid, System Operator officials automatically would lower it to the historic average. But the federal commission was hardly enthusiastic about the New York plan. The agency sided with power generators in contending the New York plan would allow officials to cancel high bids in cases lacking evidence of generators' trying to manipulate the market. The federal commission, saying the plan should be only a "temporary solution," also expressed concern that the system wouldn't allow for "sufficient consultation" with generators. While expressing "disappointment" in the ruling, Gavin Donohue, executive director of the Independent Power Producers of New York Inc., said he was heartened that the federal commission "recognized there's problems" with the new plan and applied it for a limited time period. Mr. Pataki and New York Attorney General Eliot Spitzer both called on the federal commission to now authorize a separate pending proposal that would allow the New York System Operator to assess hefty fines and publicize the names of generators found to be charging excessive prices. The federal commission's approval yesterday follows its decision last week to impose price controls on California and 10 other states in the Western power market. The Western states' plan differs from New York's in that it uses California -specific energy data, such as natural-gas prices, to calculate a "proxy" price for electricity . That price is presumed "reasonable" and is applied, with minor variation, throughout the electrically interconnected 11-state region. Generators can charge more, but, as in New York, may be forced to justify higher prices to federal regulators. The proxy price now is $92 a megawatt hour.