30 Jul 2001, 10:46 UTC
Energy Issues
- From
- Miyung Buster miyung.buster@enron.com
- To
-
Joseph Alamo, Bev Hansen, Rob Bradley, Tom Briggs, Michael R Brown, Janet Butler, Stella Chan, Alan Comnes, Shelley Corman, Jeff Dasovich, Larry Decker, Karen Denne
and 57 more
Marcus Dotson, filuntz@aol.com, Markus Fiala, Lamar Frazier, Bryan Gottredson, Janel Guerrero, Joe Hartsoe, Hedy Govenar, Chris Holmes, shirley.hudler@enron.com, Evan Hughes, jkradin@marathon-com.com, Steven J Kean, Ken Smith, amy.kim@enron.com, Kurt Lindahl, Elizabeth Linnell, Laura Ipsen, Chris Long, Peggy Mahoney, Jeannie Mandelker, Susan J Mara, Luiz Maurer, Karen Moore, andrew.morrison@enron.com, Carin Nersesian, John Neslage, Robert Neustaedter, Nick O'day, Mark Palmer, Alex Parsons, Dave Perrino, Mona L Petrochko, Melinda Pharms, rlichtenstein@marathon-com.com, Ralph Reed, mike.roan@enron.com, Linda Robertson, Ann M Schmidt, Mary Schoen, Mark Schroeder, Scott Govenar, Bryan Seyfried, Richard Shapiro, Ban Sharma, John Shelk, John Sherriff, Pat Shortridge, Roberta Staehlin, James D Steffes, Peter Styles, Kathleen Sullivan, Lora Sullivan, Sandra Yamane, Jennifer Thome, Lysa Tracy, Michael Tribolet - Bcc
- Angela Wilson
- Date
- Mon, 30 Jul 2001 03:46:00 -0700 (PDT)
Please see the following articles: Sac Bee, Mon, 7/30: Dan Walters: Who will pay for power -- and how much -- back on front burner Sac Bee, Mon, 7/30: Power grab: Before you sign, get facts (Editorial) Sac Bee, Mon, 7/30: Huge PG&E bankruptcy case creates many conflicts of interest SD Union, Mon, 7/30: Customers' huge 'debt' to SDG&E called sham SD Union, Mon, 7/30: State refund may be under $4 billion SD Union, Sun, 7/29: Energy crisis has workers shedding coats, ties SD Union, Sat, 7/28: Five state energy consultants fired for conflicts of interest SD Union, Sat, 7/28: Deals with private firms spark growth of Mexico's energy empire LA Times, Sun, 7/29: Huge Fees, Many Conflicts In PG&E Case LA Times, Sat, 7/28: 'Invention' Fueling Only Cries of Fraud SF Chron, Mon, 7/30: Federal energy order leaves California with $4 billion less in power refunds SF Chron, Mon, 7/30: Texas inches toward power deregulation as pilot program goes into effect Tuesday SF Chron, Sun, 7/29: Energy crisis gives juice to new trend: power plants on American Indian reservations SF Chron, Sun, 7/29: Federal order limits potential state refunds by $3 billion SF Chron, Sun, 7/29: Gas suppliers accuse El Paso pipeline firm of constricting flow to drive up prices SF Chron, Sun, 7/29: News briefs on the California power crisis SF Chron, Sun, 7/29: Power consultant firings called 'tip of iceberg' Secretary of state says disclosure list should be expanded Mercury News, Mon, 7/30: Federal order limits potential California refunds by $3 billion Mercury News, Mon, 7/30: Huge PG&E bankruptcy case creates many conflicts of interest Mercury News, Mon, 7/30: PG&E and Santa Cruz couple in power struggle LA Times, Mon, 7/30: Business; Financial Desk Sempra Unit Pulls in Profit, and Scrutiny Energy: The trading arm, which has come under increasing criticism, raked in $310 million in the last 18 months WSJ, Mon, 7/30: State of California Lets Go 5 Consultants Tied to Energy Firms ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------- Dan Walters: Who will pay for power -- and how much -- back on front burner (Published July 30, 2001) From its onset a year ago, California's energy crisis has always encompassed two aspects -- price and supply. In the real world of energy distribution, the two are intimately connected. Prices will rise when supplies are constricted and fall during periods of abundance. Rising prices, meanwhile, will have a major effect on demand, which directly relates to supply. California's politicians, from Gov. Gray Davis downward, have tended to treat the two as distinct factors. The question that's hovered over the crisis, although rarely voiced publicly, is whether the rate-paying and voting public would be less tolerant of price spikes or power interruptions. When the crisis first surfaced in San Diego last summer, Davis and the Legislature saw it almost purely as a matter of price. San Diegans' power bills were spiking as their local utility adjusted rates to meet its wholesale power costs, and the Capitol responded with an expedient scheme that rolled back retail prices, but did nothing about the wholesale costs. The utility began amassing debts to cover the rate-cost gap and within a few weeks, other utilities -- their rates frozen by law -- began running up even larger debts that eventually surpassed $13 billion. By early this year, however, the threat of power blackouts assumed a greater political importance, and when the utilities had their credit cut off because of their huge debts, Davis and the Legislature began running up their own multibillion-dollar debts to keep the lights burning. For most of this year, supply was the chief political focus, but so far, the threat of blackouts appears to have eased. Conservation awareness, higher power bills and unusually cool weather in much of the state have kept demand below supply limits, although August and September could still pose a threat. With supply worries muted, price is once again becoming the chief political focus in several interwoven fronts. Who will pay for the $20 billion-plus in debts run up by the utilities and the state? Who'll cover the costs of the state's $43 billion (at least) in contracts for future supplies? Will the rate increases already approved by the state Public Utilities Commission this year be sufficient to cover all needs for revenue? Or is someone playing a game of "hide the pea"? There are multiple claimants for the revenue stream, and each faction is claiming, in effect, that its share of the money can be covered under existing rates, implicitly pointing the finger at some other claimant if, in fact, rates must be raised. One example of the complex conflict over money surfaced last week, when the Davis administration declared its "revenue requirement" for past and future power purchases can be covered without another rate increase. But when the details were released a day later, the numbers had been changed -- a change the administration says does not alter its conclusions -- and critics emerged. The chief naysayer is Pacific Gas and Electric Co., the state's largest utility, which took itself into bankruptcy court last spring. PG&E issued a blistering analysis of the state's report, citing "missing data, discrepancies and conflicting claims." And the utility demanded a full hearing on both the state's numbers and its intent that all future costs be passed on to ratepayers automatically, without PUC review. PG&E officials are talking about challenging the state's revenue report not only before the PUC, but before the Office of Administrative Law, which governs regulations issued by state agencies, and perhaps in the courts. If unresolved, the conflict could hold up the sale of the state's long-stalled, $13.4 billion bond issue to cover its power-purchase debts and thus create a state cash-flow squeeze. Underlying the confrontation is PG&E's suspicion that the state, by skimming its share off the top of the revenue stream, is insulating Davis from political fallout and setting up utilities to take the blame for future rate increases. Could crass politics be driving the state's power-pricing strategy? Heaven forbid. The Bee's Dan Walters can be reached at (916) 321-1195 or dwalters@sacbee.com <mailto:dwalters@sacbee.com>. Power grab: Before you sign, get facts By Robert A. Masullo Bee Time & Money Writer (Published July 30, 2001) The large newspaper advertisement sounded enticing: "Last year natural gas rates soared 350%. This year you can lock in a rate that will soar 0% ... With guaranteed pricing from the NewPower Co., Californians can avoid such increases this winter." Exactly what is NewPower, a recently formed gas and electric supplier based in Purchase, N.Y., offering? Two deals, says company spokeswoman Terri Cohen. In the first, a customer agrees to buy natural gas from NewPower for two years and the company will guarantee a monthly price of 80 cents a therm, the unit used for measuring natural gas for billing purposes. In the second, a customer agrees to buy natural gas from NewPower for two years and the company guarantees a therm rate of 40 cents from June through August and 83 cents from September through May. In both cases, a monthly service charge of $2.99 is tacked on, and customers will pay a $50 penalty if they break the contract before two years is up. Are the NewPower offers good deals? Perhaps. It depends on what happens in the natural gas market. Last winter, nationwide shortages in the natural gas supply caused prices to shoot up to around $2 a therm. When consumers opened their winter heating bills, they were shocked. But prices have been dropping considerably since then. Per therm rates were 78 cents in May, 60 cents in early July, and 40 cents just a few days ago. During the course of a year, the highest prices for natural gas are always in winter, when usage is great, and lowest in summer, when usage is minimal. According to Pacific Gas & Electric, the traditional supplier of natural gas in the area, natural gas prices usually average around 70 cents a therm in winter and 30 cents a therm in summer. So if natural gas rates go back to what they were last winter, then NewPower's offers may be excellent deals. But if rates go down, they may be poor choices. It's up to the consumer, then, to make an educated guess about which way rates will go. But new drilling for natural gas could indicate that supply will be plentiful in the coming years. Dan Jacobson is the legislative advocate for the California Public Interest Research Group, a consumer organization. He's skeptical of NewPower's offers. "It sounds to me like (NewPower's) main aim is to get consumers to commit to a long-term contract," he says. "That's something I would always advise caution on. Long-term contracts -- for natural gas or anything else -- are fraught with danger. "It's possible, of course, that natural gas prices will go back to what they were last winter. But that seems highly unlikely. What I've been hearing, instead, is that there will be a glut of natural gas next year. Then prices would be lower and NewPower's deal would be a very bad one, indeed." Claudia Chandler, assistant executive director of the California Energy Comission, the state's primary energy policy and planning agency, said much the same. "Storage is up," she says, "and we believe there will ample supplies of natural gas this fall and winter." Unlike NewPower, PG&E sets its natural gas prices according to market prices, which fluctuate daily. PG&E spokeswoman Staci Homrig says PG&E encourages people "to shop around for the for the best price." NewPower is able to make these offers because of deregulation of the energy industry. Deregulation allows NewPower -- and other companies -- to compete with firms that own the natural gas delivery systems, such as PG&E. Prior to deregulation, delivery system companies were the only suppliers of natural gas. Of course, deregulation in California is a controversial issue, with many blaming it for the current electricity crisis. As far as natural gas goes, deregulation permits the old gas-and-electric companies, such as PG&E, to continue as the sole owner of the delivery systems -- pipes, meters and related hardware. But now they have competition supplying the gas. NewPower is closely allied with Enron Corp., the Texas energy giant, which owns about 40 percent of the company, according Cohen, the NewPower spokeswoman. Currently, only three companies -- PG&E, NewPower, and ACN Energy Inc. of Farmington Hills, Mich., which offers natural gas at market rates -- are supplying natural gas to this area. More companies, however, can be expected to follow. The Bee's Robert A. Masullo can be reached at (916) 321-1118 or bmasullo@sacbee.com <mailto:bmasullo@sacbee.com>. Huge PG&E bankruptcy case creates many conflicts of interest SAN FRANCISCO (AP) -- The third largest bankruptcy in U.S. history is also becoming the most complex. As Pacific Gas and Electric Co. wades through its pile of debts, many of the legal and financial teams representing the utility and its creditors often run into conflicts of interest. Since PG&E is so large and far reaching, it may be difficult to find firms and businesses that are not somehow associated with the utility. In addition, many large accounting and legal agencies are getting involved because of their expertise in bankruptcy cases. "Very few people have the expertise for high-profile, high-stakes bankruptcies, so you have a small pool from which to draw representation, and that's where . . . potential conflicts come up," Nancy B. Rapoport, a University of Houston law professor who's a bankruptcy ethics expert, told the Los Angeles Times. Since the utility filed for Chapter 11 protection in April, its lead counsel, Howard, Rice, Nemerovski, Canady, Falk & Rabkin already has racked up $2.65 million in the first two months of the case. Last year, that same firm reported earning $1.9 million from PG&E. The total court-approved amount in the filing could reach at least $470 million, said Lynn LoPucki, UCLA law professor and expert on bankruptcy practice. "The bigger the case, the bigger the fees," LoPucki told the Times, calling the bankruptcy "one of the most complex cases ever." PG&E's bankruptcy ranks third behind Texaco Inc. and Financial Corp. of America when comparing assets -- PG&E reportedly has $31.5 billion in assets. And about a dozen companies are in line for contracts to work for PG&E or the committee representing the company's creditors. Experts say the potential for ethical dilemmas to occur already exists based on the firms approved by the case's Judge Dennis Montali. For example, the utility's primary law firm also represents banking interests linked to nearly $1 billion in debts. PG&E's accounting firm also has worked for more than 80 companies involved in the bankruptcy case, including some creditors. Experts say the multitude of conflicts surrounding the case could allow professional firms to alter outcomes to benefit certain companies while hurting PG&E. "By traditional conflict standards, the large firms could not participate in the cases," LoPucki said. "There has been a huge shift in what is acceptable. It is more lenient. A firm is allowed to represent clients today where they would not have been allowed 20 years ago." Some firms have submitted disclaimers describing the ties and in some cases have said there are so many connections with various involved companies, they may not even be aware of them all. While other have created "ethical walls" within their companies or have asked clients to sign waivers releasing the professionals from conflicts of interest. Accounting firm PricewaterhouseCoopers, which works for PG&E and its parent corporation PG&E Corp., agreed to build an "ethical wall" in order to also serve as accountant and financial adviser for the committee representing PG&E's creditors. Judge Montali approved the hiring of the accounting firm despite objections from Linda Ekstrom Stanley, the U.S. trustee assigned to guard against abuses and money-making schemes that can occur during bankruptcy proceedings. Her office has involved itself several times, objecting to everything from excessive fees to conflicts. But some say it would be impossible for PG&E's bankruptcy proceedings to move forward if every conflict were closely examined. "It would be horrendous," said Daniel Bogart, a law professor at Chapman University. "There are conflicts that matter and those that don't. The parties have to reach a level of comfort quickly." Customers' huge 'debt' to SDG&E called sham \ objattph By Craig D. Rose UNION-TRIBUNE STAFF WRITER July 30, 2001 San Diego's largest consumer group says the dreaded "balancing account" -- a debt of $750 million that ratepayers allegedly owe SDG&E -- is a bookkeeping illusion bordering on fraud, and in reality the utility owes its customers money. In a filing late last week with state regulators, the Utility Consumers' Action Network joined other consumer advocates in arguing that San Diego Gas & Electric Co. and parent company Sempra Energy created a bogus debt by not reporting key profits and by withholding an assortment of overcharges that should be rebated to consumers. When the profits, overcharges and penalties are appropriately applied against the $750 million claim, UCAN says, consumers would owe less than $50 million. And much or all of that would be offset by SDG&E's share of refunds expected to be ordered by federal regulators. The consumer group said the balancing account is "fiction, if not a fraud," that the state appears to have accepted. UCAN was joined in the filing by The Utility Reform Network and Aglet Consumer Alliance, which are based in Northern California. The groups made the allegations in opposition to a plan proposed last month by Sempra and Gov. Gray Davis that purports to clear the alleged $750 million debt. SDG&E disagreed with the consumer groups' position. A company official said the agreement between Sempra and Davis is balanced, and the alternative could be a lengthy court fight. The matter is scheduled to go before the California Public Utilities Commission, perhaps as early as Thursday. UCAN argues that SDG&E's claim of making a $319 million contribution toward resolving the debt is "misleading and fallacious." Instead of making any contributions, UCAN says, SDG&E and Sempra stand to reap billions in profits from the proposal to clear the debt, and from agreements to sell power lines and electricity to the state. Fears of a balancing account and potential balloon payment have hung over local utility ratepayers since last fall, when SDG&E said it began to incur losses by paying more for electricity than it was allowed to collect from customers under a state-imposed cap. Electricity customers could have faced payment of the debt as early as next year. Last month, Davis, flanked by state Sens. Steve Peace and Dede Alpert, as well as Sempra officials, announced an agreement he said would eliminate the debt without raising rates. At the same time, the governor and the company announced a plan for the state to purchase SDG&E's power lines for $1.2 billion but said that was a separate proposal, unrelated to the debt plan. UCAN claims there is a relationship, saying the purchase is another excessive payment to the utility. The consumer group is urging the Public Utilities Commission to consider the proposed settlement with Sempra in the context of both the transmission line deal and a contract under which Sempra will sell 1,900 megawatts of electricity to California over the next decade. UCAN also is concerned that SDG&E's profit from the power line sale would not be shared with customers. The utility, which the state continues to regulate, has shared past gains with its customers. At the heart of the groups' filing, however, is the allegation that SDG&E has not accounted for what UCAN estimates is $450 million in profits the utility will earn from two key electricity purchase contracts. Those gains alone would offset 60 percent of the losses SDG&E claims to have suffered from buying electricity. The Public Utilities Commission ruled this year that profits from these contracts belong to the utility's customers, not its shareholders. For months during the power crisis, SDG&E described itself as a middleman and said it earned nothing from the sale of electricity to customers. Under the state's deregulation plan that went into effect in 1998, the company's profit-making business was supposed to be restricted to the delivery of electricity, not the purchase and sale of the commodity. Nonetheless, SDG&E has gone to court seeking to overturn the PUC decision and take possession of the profits earned from selling electricity. As part of the settlement with the state, SDG&E would be awarded ownership of the power contracts but would agree to refund $219 million. But SDG&E would earn $120 million by selling power to the state from these deals during the second half of this year. So UCAN argues that SDG&E's $219 million concession is effectively reduced to less than half that sum. Sempra also has a separate long-term contract to sell electricity to the state. UCAN says that deal also is overpriced. SDG&E defended its agreement with the state and said the prospect of lengthy litigation over the profits from power contracts should be considered in assessing the overall agreement. "We have a strong case in court," said Edwin Guiles, chairman of SDG&E. "And this overall balanced solution is a better way to deal with it rather than fight it out in court." Guiles also said SDG&E is forgoing $100 million by agreeing to a complex provision to provide power at regulated rates from the San Onofre Nuclear Generation Station, instead of whatever rates the market would allow. SDG&E is a part owner of the nuclear plant. The consumer group says SDG&E has not refunded to customers an assortment of overcharges and overcollections totaling $154 million. UCAN added that under the governor's plan $133 million of the debt claimed by Sempra is not eliminated but would be paid off by consumers through their monthly bills. State refund may be under $4 billion \ objattph By Karen Gaudette ASSOCIATED PRESS July 30, 2001 CALIFORNIA'S POWER CRISIS SAN FRANCISCO -- A closer reading of last week's order from federal energy regulators shows California will receive refunds for overpriced electricity, but the amount could be slashed to just under $4 billion -- less than half of what the state requested. Gov. Gray Davis plans to appeal the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission decision today, state officials said yesterday afternoon. Refunds could help prevent the state from raising electric rates to cover its power-buying costs, which are now beyond $8 billion. "We found a number of disturbing things that lead us to believe FERC may not be so pro-refund as they want Californians to believe," said Nancy McFadden, an adviser to Davis. For months, Davis and other state officials have asked the FERC to find electricity prices charged since May 2000 to be unjust and unreasonable -- prices which climbed 10 times higher than past years. The state stands to lose a portion of the billions it has spent buying electricity for Pacific Gas and Electric Co. customers and two other financially ailing utilities. Power companies maintain they did not work together to drive up power prices to unreasonable levels. FERC's 40-page decision confirms the commission will only order refunds for power bought since October 2000, rather than May 2000. That means $2 billion less than the state, utilities and others could receive, McFadden said. State officials had hoped to receive as much as $9 billion in refunds. FERC also said it will not issue refunds for power the state Department of Water Resources bought directly from power companies. FERC only will recognize purchases through the state's now-defunct power market or from the manager of the state's power grid. But the DWR bought most of its megawatts directly from power companies after a FERC ruling in December abolished the Power Exchange, the state's key entity that bought and sold power. The Independent System Operator, keeper of the state's grid, then began adding a surcharge on big purchases, McFadden said. That stripped $3 billion more off the potential refund amount. All told, the most the state could expect to get back would be roughly $3.9 billion, said Barry Goode, a legal secretary to Davis. And despite the overcharges, some of that money has to pay power companies for past power deliveries at a price FERC determines is just and reasonable. A call to FERC for comment was not immediately returned yesterday afternoon. FERC has ordered an evidentiary hearing, to be completed within 60 days, to determine the size of the refund from providers of wholesale power. Energy crisis has workers shedding coats, ties \ objattph By Jeff McDonald UNION-TRIBUNE STAFF WRITER July 29, 2001 With summer temperatures in full swing and office thermostats stuck in the high 70s, something had to give. And the clear losers this fashion season are neckties, sport coats and the dread of career women everywhere: pantyhose. Stodgy bankers, stiff politicians and even utility company executives have rewritten their dress codes in recent weeks to make employees more comfortable while the bean counters shave expenses by turning off the air conditioning. "We have definitely taken more of a business-casual attitude because of the increased temperatures in the office," said Joanne Licausi of Wells Fargo Bank, which last month extended "dress-down Fridays" through the workweek. Like their counterparts at hundreds of big companies, from San Francisco to San Diego, Wells Fargo officials have taken numerous steps to lower electric bills. They've installed motion sensors in buildings so lights shut off automatically when no one is using an office. Computers, printers and copy machines also are turned off when not in use. Yet the most dramatic shift in the hunt for energy savings came by hiking thermostats to 76 degrees -- a couple of points below temperatures in offices at Sempra Energy and San Diego City Hall, among others, but still on the warm side. While the summer weather has not been stifling so far, it's the temperature inside that matters when you're counting kilowatts. "You still see a number of individuals in a coat and tie, but at least now they have the option," Licausi said. The folks who deliver electricity to 1.2 million San Diego area homes and businesses also uncoiled their collars as their indoor climates were pushed to 78 degrees. "We try to practice what we preach, so we've cut consumption by 20 percent in all of our buildings," said Laura Farmer, a spokeswoman for San Diego Gas and Electric Co.'s parent company, Sempra Energy. "But, boy, does it get hot." Even though they approve of the relaxed dress standard, not all higher-ups have embraced the policy firsthand. Sempra media director "Doug Kline still wears a suit every day, but you see many more golf shirts, short-sleeve shirts," according to Farmer. "It's not as buttoned up as it used to be." Things are nearly as loose at San Diego City Hall, where politicians last month adopted a four-page Summer Energy Action Plan intended to slow reeling electric meters and save taxpayer money. Thousands of workers there are invited "to wear cooler, casual attire throughout the week" as thermostats were ratcheted up to 78 -- frequently hotter than the temperature outdoors. "The women here, we tend to dress a little less formally," said Elena Cristiano, press secretary to Mayor Dick Murphy. "Our shoulders will show; it's still dressy but it's considered to be relaxed." In Chula Vista, officials have been on the conservation bandwagon since 1993, upgrading the heating and cooling systems and retrofitting lights, among other measures. The temperature inside City Hall is set at a relatively mild 74 degrees, but workers are nonetheless encouraged to ditch the formal business wear. "If I tried 78 in my work area, it would be unbearable," said Willie Gater, the Chula Vista environmental resource manager. "I have a plate glass window at my desk." Steven Bucky has been monitoring business fashion trends for years. Director of professional training at the California School of Professional Psychology in Mira Mesa, Bucky said energy-conservation measures have prompted employers to be more sensitive to the needs of workers. "We understand it's warmer, less comfortable, so we need to be more flexible," he said. "If people are trying to save money, obviously something has to go with the dress." Besides, Bucky added, consumers these days are more likely to favor substance over style. "I don't want to go to an attorney because he or she is wearing a three-piece suit; I want to go to the best lawyer I can find." Pamela Shank, an Escondido personal shopper who makes her living advising people on what to wear, has noticed leanings toward casual work clothes among clients for several years, what with more firms observing dress-down Fridays and the 1990s run of Internet startups, which helped set a new standard in informal wear. "Companies are trying to give more of a benefit to people," she said. "It gets so boring to have to wear a suit and tie or a proper dress every day." For men seeking that subtle but well-groomed look, Shank suggests Izod and Polo cotton shirts with open necks, Dockers-style khakis with leather belts and, perhaps, tassled loafers. She also likes the blue jeans-and-Oxford shirt look with a sport coat accompaniment, but cautions that denim remains taboo at many workplaces. Women have more choices in how to dress to impress while maintaining maximum comfort in heated environs, said Shank, who counts dress slacks, skirts and light pantsuits among her collection of comfort clothes. "We can dress casual so easily," she said. "We can put anything together." Very few workers at the California Department of Transportation office in Old Town employ the services of a personal shopper. Yet most are pleased with the new, less-rigid dress code in their corner of the state bureaucracy, which is under governor's orders to reduce power consumption. "Everybody's been very supportive, thankful for a little leniency to try and stay comfortable and productive," said Tom Nipper, a Caltrans spokesman who now saves his neckties for special occasions. "I'm not wearing one today, but I do have one," he said of the traditional neckwear. "If I do a TV interview, I put it on." Five state energy consultants fired for conflicts of interest \ objattph ASSOCIATED PRESS July 28, 2001 LOS ANGELES ) Five state energy consultants were fired for conflicts of interest because they helped California buy power from a company in which they owned stock, officials said. The consultants owned shares of Calpine Corp., a San Jose-based power generator that has been awarded about $13 billion in state contracts to supply electricity for up to 20 years. The state bought more than $14 million worth of electricity from Calpine in the first quarter of this year, records showed. The consultants owned anywhere from a few thousand dollars to more than $100,000 worth of Calpine stock, according to records cited Saturday by the Los Angeles Times. "We did not want them making governmental decisions and holding these stocks," Barry Goode, legal affairs secretary to Gov. Gray Davis, said Friday. Consultant William F. Mead, who was fired on Thursday, said he bought most of his Calpine shares 2 years ago for $12,000. The value has soared because of stock splits. "I came up here, away from home, living in a hotel room, trying to keep the lights on, trying to get the state through a crisis and now I get a finger pointed at me as if I'm some sort of criminal," he told the Times. "I guess it's just politics and we're the pawns." The Davis administration hired more than 50 consultants and advisers this year as it struggles to deal with the state's electricity crunch. On July 18, the administration told consultants buying energy for the state to sell their stock holdings in energy companies immediately or quit their jobs. Nine divested. Another consultant quit four days earlier after disclosing she had purchased Calpine stock in February. Another person, a state lawyer, was shifted to a non-energy related job, said Davis spokesman Steve Maviglio. Davis is looking for more cases of conflict of interest among his energy-buying staff after Saturday's firings, his aide told the Orange County Register. The governor has begun an internal review focusing on whether state-hired energy buyers made deals with companies in which they had a significant financial interest. Bill Wood, the chief counsel for Secretary of State Bill Jones, said other potential conflicts could affect at least some of the $43 billion worth of power contracts that have been signed by the state in the past six months with private power generators. Under pressure from Jones, a Republican who hopes to challenge Democrat Davis for re-election next year, the administration has moved to obtain statements of economic interest from most of the energy consultants. Last week, Jones called for a federal Securities and Exchange Commission investigation of stock purchases by state energy consultants. Deals with private firms spark growth of Mexico's energy empire \ objattph By Diane Lindquist UNION-TRIBUNE STAFF WRITER July 28, 2001 ROSARITO BEACH -- At the modern new power plant next to the Pacific Ocean here, it takes just two operators at sleek computer consoles to run a facility that can send electricity throughout Baja California, into Sonora and -- in energy emergencies -- into Southern California. The plant, part of the Presidente Ju?rez complex at this resort city 15 miles south of the U.S. border, has been operating since July 5. Alstom Power, a Swiss global energy firm, built the project in an arrangement that allows private companies to take part in an energy sector previously restricted to the Mexican Federal Electricity Commission, or CFE. Mexican President Vicente Fox says he would like more development firms involved in the country's energy endeavors, but he needs the national Congress' approval. For now, the current arrangement is Mexico's best solution to meeting the cash-strapped nation's growing power needs. Most of the 3,246 megawatts being added this year to the national electricity system result from similar private construction arrangements. "This new plant marks an advance in the scheme of financing CFE projects," Jos, Miguel Olea, the agency's deputy construction di rector for the plant, said during a tour Thursday. "It puts us in a position to better serve our clients and maintain a reasonable margin of reserve to keep up with the constant growth the border area has experienced in recent years," he said. Under Alstom's contract, the company built the Rosarito plant and will lease it for 15 years, then transfer it to the government. CFE is the sole operator, however, whether the facility's ownership is under Alstom or the agency. As a result, the new plant, called Rosarito III, is among the most modern in Mexico. The combined-cycle facility is fired by natural gas, making it cleaner, more efficient and less costly to operate than plants of previous generations. Only the tops of the plant's two red-banded chimneys are visible from the main highway through Rosarito Beach. The plant is made up of two units, each of which produces 244 megawatts. A megawatt is enough to power 750 to 1,000 homes in the United States. Turbines and condensers are in separate buildings. The electricity moves through pipes that penetrate the top of each building and extend to a tower, where the power is sent out on transmission lines. Outside each main building is a structure of stainless steel pipes and tanks that uses ocean water to cool the operation. While the Swiss company was building the plant, the electricity agency converted the fuel source of its two existing facilities -- Rosarito I built in 1963, and Rosarito II built in 1991 -- so that now all are fired by natural gas. The conversion has transformed one of the state's worst sources of air pollution. With the use of natural gas, sulfur dioxide emissions have been eliminated and nitrogen oxide emissions have been lowered. Sempra Energy International, a subsidiary of San Diego-based Sempra Energy, built the natural gas pipeline to Presidente Ju?rez under a government contract with terms similar to those under which Alstom built the plant. InterGen, another global power generation firm, plans to construct two plants near Mexicali under the same build-lease-transfer system. In contrast, Sempra will own a plant it is building near Mexicali outright because the electricity will be exported north of the border. There are no limits on the number of similar plants that can be developed in Baja California for the export market, Mexican Energy Secretary Ernesto Martens has said. The Rosarito III plant adds 488 megawatts to the amount Presidente Ju?rez produces, increasing the total to 1,328. That's a 24.7 percent boost to Baja California's overall capacity, Olea said. About 652,000 homes and 78,000 businesses and industries in Tijuana, Mexicali, Ensenada, Tecate and Rosarito Beach in Baja California and San Luis R?o Colorado in Sonora will receive electricity from the Presidente Ju?rez complex. "The new plant should cover the region's current demand and high future growth with a adequate reserve through 2004," Olea said. InterGen and Sempra are expected to start operating their plants in 2003. The Rosarito plant will supply California consumers when needed, said Ram?n Fern?ndez, the agency's resident manager of projects, but Baja California and Sonora needs must be met first. "CFE has always considered opportunities to export to and support California as part of the Baja California regional market," he said. Prices charged to California consumers will be set by market conditions, he said. Exports are limited by the 408-megawatt capacity of the two cross-border transmission lines, Fern?ndez said, but the agency expects the capacity to be expanded to 2,400 megawatts by next year. Diane Lindquist's e-mail address is diane.lindquist@uniontrib.com <MAILTO:diane.lindquist@uniontrib.com>. Her voice mail is (619) 542-4579. Huge Fees, Many Conflicts In PG&E Case Bankruptcy: The sheer size of the professional firms involved and the vast reach of the utility make entanglements almost inevitable. By TIM REITERMAN TIMES STAFF WRITER July 29 2001 SAN FRANCISCO -- When a big bankruptcy case comes along, so does the bankruptcy gang. After PG&E Corp.'s Pacific Gas & Electric Co. filed for protection from creditors in April, major law firms and other high-priced professionals queued up and began billing. PG&E's lead counsel already has charged $2.65 million in the first two months of a case that some experts say could stretch into years. A financial advisor asked for as much as $350,000 a month and once considered seeking a "success fee" of $20 million if the company's reorganization panned out. A financial consultant of the PG&E creditors committee has proposed a $1.5-million fee for six months' work. The PG&E case offers an extraordinary view of an arcane field usually outside the limelight. Total court-approved fees in the bankruptcy filing--the third-largest in U.S. history--could amount to at least $470 million, said UCLA law professor Lynn LoPucki, a leading expert on bankruptcy practice. "The bigger the case, the bigger the fees," he said. But even that figure, LoPucki said, could go higher because of the regulatory and public policy issues involved in the case, which he described as "one of the most complex cases ever." Along with those huge fees come complex potential conflicts. Ethical problems have long haunted the bankruptcy field, despite repeated efforts at reforms that have followed scandals involving prominent firms. Though the PG&E bankruptcy case is in its earliest stages, entanglements that experts say could present ethical issues already have arisen as several prominent firms were approved by the bankruptcy judge: * PG&E's main law firm also represents banking interests that are tied to one of the utility's biggest debts, a nearly $1-billion credit arrangement. * PG&E's accounting firm has done unrelated work for more than 80 companies involved in the PG&E bankruptcy case, including some of the utility's creditors. * The law firm for the official committee of PG&E creditors represents a $400-million Arizona power project being developed by an arm of PG&E's parent company. * The accounting firm for the committee does work for PG&E and its parent company, a corporate relationship being examined by the state's utility regulator. For shareholders or creditors of a company in bankruptcy proceedings, conflicts can create serious problems. The complex legal and accounting issues that arise in a bankruptcy case provide numerous opportunities for professional firms to alter outcomes in ways that benefit a favored company and harm the client relying on their advice. Experts say the sheer size of today's professional firms and the vast reach of PG&E, whose business activities touch virtually every sector of California, make conflicts almost inevitable. "Very few people have the expertise for high-profile, high-stakes bankruptcies, so you have a small pool from which to draw representation, and that's where . . . potential conflicts come up," said Nancy B. Rapoport, a University of Houston law professor and a leading bankruptcy ethics expert. "Today," LoPucki said, "it's not a question of whether there's a conflict, it's how big it is." Dozens of Firms Vying for Contracts The bankruptcy case of PG&E, with a reported $31.5 billion in assets, is big, indeed. Only two cases from the late 1980s, Texaco Inc. and Financial Corp. of America, surpass it when measured by the dollar value of the assets at stake. Records show that about a dozen firms are in line for lucrative contracts with either PG&E or the official committee representing thousands of the utility's unsecured creditors. So are dozens of other firms that have continuing legal work for the company. All will be paid from the PG&E bankruptcy estate, if Judge Dennis Montali approves their employment. To become eligible for legal, accounting and consulting work, each firm must convince the judge that it is qualified to do the job and does not have unmanageable conflicts of interest. Many firms in the PG&E case have worked with one another or represent parties with a financial interest in the outcome, such as lenders and creditors, in matters outside the case. With the limited number of bankruptcy specialists, "naturally you have lawyers and others working both sides of the fence," said Mary Josephine Newborn Wiggins, professor at the University of San Diego School of Law. "There are bound to be some situations where it gets sticky." Time and again, firms acknowledged in disclaimers filed with Bankruptcy Court that they have so many ties to other companies that they may not have unearthed all connections and potential conflicts. Some addressed potential conflicts by erecting "ethical walls" within their own firms or having clients sign waivers that absolve the professionals of conflicts of interest. Experts say ethical walls amount to honor systems with no outside monitoring and that waivers sometimes are granted without the client's full understanding of the potential conflicts. They also point out that not all connections between adversarial interests constitute conflicts, and not all conflicts are serious enough to disqualify a firm from a case. The fact that so many issues arise in cases of this magnitude has meant that the bankruptcy system is forced to make accommodations for big firms with overlapping clients. "By traditional conflict standards, the large firms could not participate in the cases," LoPucki said. "There has been a huge shift in what is acceptable. It is more lenient. A firm is allowed to represent [clients] today where they would not have been allowed 20 years ago." 'Ethical Walls' Used to Avoid Conflicts The complexity of the entanglements--and the manner in which the system has adapted to them--can be seen in the roles played in the PG&E case by two of the nation's largest accounting firms, Deloitte & Touche and PricewaterhouseCoopers, and one of its most prominent law firms, Milbank, Tweed, Hadley & McCloy. When PG&E proposed hiring Deloitte & Touche for a base fee of $855,000 and an hourly rate of $450 to $650 for partners, the U.S. trustee in the case, Linda Ekstrom Stanley, objected. The U.S. trustees office is an arm of the Department of Justice that Congress created in 1978 to help combat what critics derisively dubbed bankruptcy rings. The trustees administer bankruptcy cases and are instructed to guard against abuses and profiteering by professionals. So far in the PG&E case, Stanley's office has weighed in against the appointments of several major companies, voicing objections ranging from excessive fees to conflicts. Her office succeeded in preventing the creditors committee from hiring a public relations firm, and it won a tentative ruling that would prevent PG&E from indemnifying a financial consulting firm against negligence claims arising from its work. The investment banking firm, Dresdener, Kleinwort & Wasserstein, has stopped working for PG&E because of the lack of indemnification. PG&E is hunting for a new financial consultant. In the case of Deloitte & Touche, Stanley's office seized on the company's disclosure that it had worked not only for PG&E but also for its parent company and for another subsidiary, PG&E National Energy Group. The accounting firm had performed $14.4 million in work last year for the three PG&E entities. The trustee said that work posed a potential conflict because the California Public Utilities Commission was reviewing PG&E's controversial transfers of funds to its parent company. Deloitte & Touche argued successfully that its relationships with three PG&E entities did not compromise the company's ability to fairly represent PG&E in the bankruptcy. In the interest of full disclosure, Deloitte & Touche reported it formerly employed a daughter of Judge Montali. The firm also said it employs the wife of another bankruptcy judge in San Francisco. She logged fewer than 50 hours of tax consulting work last year for PG&E's parent, the firm said. Ethics experts said such personal connections generally would not be enough to prompt a judge to disqualify a firm. "It's obviously an interesting relationship," Rapoport said. "It comes down to . . . how much of an appearance of too much closeness he wants to put up with." Issues involving the second accounting firm, PricewaterhouseCoopers, arose when the committee representing PG&E's creditors proposed hiring the firm as its accountant and financial advisor. Stanley's office objected that the firm, like Deloitte & Touche, works for PG&E and its parent. "Professionals . . . must have no conflict of interest . . . and owe undivided loyalty to the creditors committee," the trustees office said. "It is not beyond imagining that [PG&E and its parent] could influence [PricewaterhouseCoopers] through these continuing relationships, the promise of future engagements and other intangibles," the trustee said in one filing. PricewaterhouseCoopers said it would build an ethical wall within the firm to avoid problems or other dicey situations in which PG&E, its parent or affiliates are adversaries. The judge approved the hiring. Rapoport said such ethical walls do not necessarily prevent improper communications within firms. "I don't think you can rely on an honor system or an internalized moral compass. That is why we have rules in the first place," she said. As its legal counsel, the PG&E creditors committee received permission to hire Milbank. The law firm disclosed that it represented some of PG&E's creditors in matters unrelated to the bankruptcy. The firm also represents a $400-million Arizona power plant project being developed by a subsidiary of PG&E Corp.'s National Energy Group. Some bankruptcy experts said there was a potential for conflict, but the firm said the connection was tangential. In addition, the firm worked for the California Power Exchange, the now-bankrupt entity that under California's deregulation plan served as the state's energy marketplace. Milbank resigned that post several weeks before the Power Exchange filed its own bankruptcy petition in March. The resignation, Milbank said, was "due to certain potential conflicts with creditors" of the exchange. One of Milbank's clients is Enron Corp., which, using other counsel, sued the Power Exchange, trying to get back collateral held by the exchange to ensure power deliveries. Enron now sits on the PG&E creditors committee represented by Milbank. Another of PG&E's creditors is the Power Exchange, which is seeking nearly $2 billion for energy companies that sold electricity to the utility but were not paid. Records show Milbank has filed a claim of about $373,000 against the exchange for legal work. George Sladoje, president and chief executive of the Power Exchange, said he was shocked when Milbank, its longtime counsel, quit. "It was very difficult to find [new] counsel," he said. "There were conflicts all over the place" among law firms because so many did legal work for PG&E and Southern California Edison. Ed Feo, managing partner of Milbank's Los Angeles office, said the company did its best to avoid conflicts in both bankruptcy cases--by dropping representation of a client in one and fully disclosing its connections in the other. As for Milbank's role in the PG&E case, Rapoport said that representing creditors and a creditors committee is "OK as long as their interests do not diverge." However, she said, "Bankruptcy is like the Chinese game of Go. Moves have ramifications 20 steps later." Disclosure Often Is Safest Legal Course As a practical matter, the safest course legally in a bankruptcy case is to try to disclose every connection and let the judge decide whether to allow a firm to participate. "Disclosure cures a multitude of ills," said Lawrence Gottesman, chairman of the bankruptcy practice at Brown, Raysman, Millstein, Felder & Steiner in New York City. By contrast, he said, "the penalty for working with an undisclosed conflict can be severe." Milbank learned that three years ago, when John G. Gellene, once a lawyer with the firm, was sentenced to 15 months in prison and fined $15,000 for failing to disclose during a bankruptcy case that he also was working for a creditor in separate litigation. Before the sentencing, the firm had returned $1.9 million in legal fees and fired Gellene. To ferret out potential conflicts, firms rely heavily on the computer. Those involved in the PG&E case, for example, usually checked their computerized client lists against the biggest 100 PG&E creditors and other players, such as other professional firms, the trustee's staff and the judge. Even then, there are limits. The computerized checks did not touch tens of thousands of smaller PG&E creditors. And the firms themselves commonly issue disclaimers, saying they might not have turned up all their potential conflicts. If a law firm finds it has a troubling conflict, it also can seek a conflict waiver from its existing client, which essentially gives the firm permission to pursue dual representation. PG&E's lead counsel, Howard, Rice, Nemerovski, Canady, Falk & Rabkin, reported receiving $1.9 million from the company in the year before the Chapter 11 filing and it billed $2.65 million in fees and expenses for the two months after that. Among the firm's potential conflicts was its representation of an affiliate of Bank of America Corp. The bank participates in a revolving credit agreement that allows PG&E to borrow up to $1 billion. PG&E listed Bank of America as the agent for a $938-million claim. The law firm said its relationship with the Bank of America affiliate was "sufficiently attenuated" that it did not need a conflict of interest waiver from its client. But the firm sought and received conflict waivers from a second bank and the affiliate of a third bank involved in the credit agreement. There was no objection by the trustees office, and the judge approved hiring the firm. "We see if [a firm has] a disqualifying connection and, if not, we let it go," said Stanley, the U.S. trustee. Indeed, if every potential conflict were examined closely, some say, the bankruptcy system would grind to a halt. "It would be horrendous," said Daniel Bogart, a law professor at Chapman University. "There are conflicts that matter and those that don't. The parties have to reach a level of comfort quickly." Copyright 2001, Los Angeles Times <http://www.latimes.com> 'Invention' Fueling Only Cries of Fraud Energy: Tribe promised riches from power plant using secret technology suspects it's been had. Firm's founder, a felon, denies allegations. By BETTINA BOXALL TIMES STAFF WRITER July 28 2001 BISHOP, Calif. -- It would be difficult to write a better spoof of the energy frenzy than the tale that has been unfolding here on a small Indian reservation. There is the pony-tailed convicted felon who came to this remote Eastern Sierra town with bodyguards, secrecy agreements and plans for a power plant that would reap millions in annual profits for the local tribe, require no fuel and produce no pollution. There was the prototype: two boxes connected to a car chassis suspended off the ground. When a switch was flipped, the tires turned. There were the company code names for employees: Falcon, Caesar, Cleopatra. But it's not a spoof. It's the story of QSFG Research and Development Inc. of North Las Vegas and founder Michael J. Marshall, who has left a trail of angry investors, laid-off employees and allegations of fraud from Nevada to Hawaii. Marshall is a silver-haired 47-year-old who boasts, in language grandiose to the point of parody, that he has invented a new technology that will power everything from cars to electricity plants and transform the energy industry. Centuries from now, he declared at a groundbreaking here, "They will be looking back at us, this day right here. We are initiating the start. We are lighting the match." He sold company shares at $25,000 a pop, signed a contract to build a 250-megawatt power station on the Bishop Paiute reservation and promised investors an energy empire. In a brief telephone interview Friday, Marshall dismissed all the doubts and allegations. "I don't care what you write because the truth is the truth. I'm only two weeks away from having a prototype showing I can run power stations. It does work. It does run," insisted Marshall. "Where the Past Ends and the World's Future Begins," proclaims the brightly lettered sign on his now-closed office-warehouse in a North Las Vegas industrial park. It is a phrase he used before, in New York state, where Marshall spent 2 1/2 years in prison for fraud and larceny. According to Cortland County files, the case involved $25,000 he took from an elderly man to patent an invention--apparently a "fuel-less generator" for cars. After his release from prison in 1998, Marshall wound up in Las Vegas, where he incorporated QSFG last year. He started off with plans to outfit cars and trucks with his technology. When California's energy crisis hit, he switched to power plants, becoming one of many offering unusual solutions to the state's electricity problem. "We're certainly hearing a lot more schemes. Not all of them are unreasonable," said Rich Ferguson, research director at the nonprofit Center for Energy Efficiency and Renewable Technologies in Sacramento. "This particular thing sounds like a violation of fundamental physical law, so it's a little hard to take seriously." Site at Reservation Has Legal Advantages Last spring, QSFG sent letters to Las Vegas casinos and Native American tribes in California and Nevada, pitching "a groundbreaking advanced electromagnetic technology" with which the firm could build new energy plants and retrofit existing ones. Marshall, who wears a long braid or ponytail, said he was part Cherokee. But his interest in tribal land extended beyond any Native American ties. The reservations are self-governing, QSFG representatives noted, potentially eliminating local and state red tape and speeding up the approval process. A few tribes responded, including Bishop and nearby Benton. Marshall and his entourage paid them a visit in May. "He reminded me of a used-car salesman," recalled Joseph Saulque, vice chairman of the Benton Paiute tribe. "He talked real fast. He sounded quite intelligent and up on what he was talking about. But he refused to let anybody see what he was talking about. He refused to let us see his alleged engine." The Benton tribe didn't pursue the matter. But the larger Bishop reservation found Marshall's story too tempting to resist: the tribe could make as much as $15 million a year in exchange for letting QSFG build a nonpolluting power plant on three acres of their land. QSFG signed a contract with the Bishop tribe May 31; the groundbreaking was in early June. Shaded from the high desert sun by a large blue-and-white tent, Marshall and a parade of his employees took the microphone like evangelists. This was the technology of the new millennium, they told a small gathering. It was an historic moment akin to the Wright brothers and their first flight. "There's what you call closet inventors--I'm one of them," Marshall said. None of the speakers detailed exactly how the energy plant would work. There was mention of rotary power, north polarity and an electromagnetic engine. All along, Marshall insisted his invention was a carefully guarded secret--so valuable that he required bodyguards. Pressed, he would show people his prototype: a car chassis with a steering column and four wheels. In place of the engine were two boxes that he refused to open. He would jack the chassis off the ground, flip a switch and the wheels would turn. It wasn't much. But apparently it was enough to convince those who wanted to believe Marshall's engine could be the next big thing, as well as their ticket to millions. "This man is a very good and fast talker . . . you believe him," said Juanita Ikeda, a former accountant for QSFG. "He was able to get everyone's greed to work against them." Ikeda, who quit the company in June, says she is the one who discovered Marshall's New York conviction and made sure the Bishop tribe heard about it after the groundbreaking. Calling the episode "a very embarrassing learning experience," Bishop tribal council chairman Monty Bengochia said the tribal development corporation "doesn't anticipate following through with the QSFG agreement." Marshall laid off his staff early this month. According to the Nevada labor commissioner's office, 16 claims for back wages totaling more than $100,000 have been filed against QSFG by former workers. In Hawaii, the state Department of Commerce and Consumer Affairs is investigating a fraud complaint against Marshall and QSFG by investor Michael H. Wong Sr. A government engineer who lives in Hawaii, Wong bought a $25,000 share in QSFG after hearing about the company from a friend in Las Vegas. Marshall's invention sounded plausible to Wong. "If this guy has it and wants to bring it out to the world I was all for it," he said. But after Marshall canceled several public debuts of his technology, failed to pay any dividends and showed Wong nothing more than a car chassis, he doesn't believe he has an invention. "He does not have anything at all," Wong said. His Las Vegas friend, Michael Kauffman, is similarly disenchanted. "This was my first investment. It was very stupid," lamented Kauffman. "It's a wash. I'm not getting my money back." Kauffman says he has complained to the Las Vegas office of the FBI, which declined to comment on whether it is investigating. Former Employees Tell of Ploys Marshall insists that Wong is furious at him because he won't reveal his technology secrets. "The money went into the corporation, not into my pocket," he said. "As far as me scamming--that is not true." Many of QSFG's employees and some of the investors knew each other before their involvement with the company. They fell into line with Marshall like dominoes. Kauffman heard about Marshall from his roommate, Alesa Beck, who worked in a video store Marshall patronized. Marshall gave her an office job in the company. When he was looking for "spokesmodels" to promote QSFG, she referred him to friends who worked in Vegas as strippers. He hired them. Kauffman told his sister, Teresa Romero of San Diego, about Marshall's invention and she bought $25,000 in stock. Wong told his son about the company and his son went to work for Marshall. A network of acquaintances followed, including a Southern Nevada community college professor of criminal justice who was hired as head of security and later made CEO. Sitting in the restaurant of a downtown Las Vegas casino recently, Kauffman and five ex-employees described an operation sustained by alluring promises. Marshall hired them at handsome salaries, paid them in the beginning and then erratically. He once insisted a solar flare had interrupted the computer transfer of payroll funds. He told them if they would hang on, they'd make a fortune. He assigned code names to the staff--he was Caesar and a young woman he identified as his wife was Cleopatra. He made them sign nondisclosure agreements and claimed he had been nominated for the Nobel Prize. Ikeda and others say Marshall wanted to create the impression of a healthy business when members of the Bishop tribe visited the QSFG offices. But the phones had been cut off and there was very little office equipment. So, the ex-staffers say, they were instructed to bring in their own personal computers. They spoke in mock conversations on phones that didn't work. Marshall gave investors binders of material outlining ambitious corporate plans to employ thousands and build a string of plants to manufacture auto converter kits for his fuel-less engine. The binders included a November 2000 letter from the Texas governor's office, signed by George W. Bush. "We would be happy to welcome you to Texas," Bush wrote. It was a generic form letter sent to companies inquiring about setting up business in the Lone Star State, but it lent an air of legitimacy to QSFG, especially when energy prices were skyrocketing. "The letter from Gov. Bush. It just all made sense," Romero said. Copyright 2001, Los Angeles Times <http://www.latimes.com> Federal energy order leaves California with $4 billion less in power refunds KAREN GAUDETTE, Associated Press Writer Monday, July 30, 2001 ,2001 Associated Press URL: <http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/news/archive/2001/07/30/natio nal0557EDT0472.DTL> (07-30) 02:57 PDT SAN FRANCISCO (AP) -- California will receive refunds for overpriced electricity, but not as much as it had asked for. A closer reading of last week's order from federal energy regulators shows the amount the state will receive could be slashed to just under $4 billion -- less than half what the state requested. Gov. Gray Davis plans to appeal the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission decision Monday, state officials said. Refunds could help prevent the state from raising electric rates to cover its power buying costs, which are now beyond $8 billion. "We found a number of disturbing things that lead us to believe FERC may not be so pro-refund as they want Californians to believe," said Nancy McFadden, an adviser to Davis. For months, Davis and other state officials have asked the commission to rule electricity prices charged since May 2000 to be unjust and unreasonable -- prices which climbed 10 times higher than past years. The state stands to lose a portion of the billions it has spent buying electricity for Pacific Gas and Electric Co. customers and two other financially ailing utilities. Power companies maintain they did not work together to drive up power prices to unreasonable levels. The commission's 40-page decision confirms it will only order refunds for power bought since October 2000, rather than May 2000. That means $2 billion less than the state, utilities and others could hope to receive, McFadden said. In addition, the commission also said it will not issue refunds for power the state Department of Water Resources bought directly from power companies. FERC only will recognize purchases through the state's now-defunct power market or from the manager of the state's power grid. That stripped another $3 billion off the potential refund amount, reducing the refund by a total of $5 billion. State officials had hoped to receive up to $9 billion in refunds. A call to FERC for comment was not immediately returned Sunday. The commission has ordered an evidentiary hearing, to be completed within 60 days, to determine the size of the refund from providers of wholesale power. Texas inches toward power deregulation as pilot program goes into effect Tuesday NATALIE GOTT, Associated Press Writer Monday, July 30, 2001 ,2001 Associated Press URL: <http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/news/archive/2001/07/30/natio nal0614EDT0475.DTL> (07-30) 03:14 PDT AUSTIN, Texas (AP) -- After several delays, the entrance of Texas into the deregulated electricity market is set to begin Tuesday. Under a pilot program, officials of the state's electrical grid will begin switching some customers to new power providers at 12:01 a.m. Tuesday. The Legislature created the pilot program to give power companies several months to test their systems before full-scale deregulation, which is scheduled to begin Jan. 1 in most of the state. Industry officials have promised that deregulation will be smoother in Texas than in California, where it has been blamed for rolling blackouts and skyrocketing utility rates. They say the recent construction of several new power plants in Texas will help the state avoid supply shortfalls that have plagued California. The Electric Reliability Council of Texas, which manages the state's grid, gave the go-ahead for the pilot program last week. Deregulation allows customers to choose their power provider much like they select a long-distance telephone carrier. Under the Texas pilot program, up to 5 percent of electric customers can switch power companies. The pilot program is getting under way nearly two months after its first scheduled start date of June 1. Numerous delays were caused by computer problems. While the delays were unfortunate, "we think waiting until all the systems are ready will let us provide good customer service," said Eleanor Scott, spokeswoman for Austin-based Green Mountain Energy. Energy crisis gives juice to new trend: power plants on American Indian reservations MICHELLE DeARMOND, Associated Press Writer Sunday, July 29, 2001 ,2001 Associated Press URL: <http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/news/archive/2001/07/29/natio nal1352EDT0473.DTL> (07-29) 22:08 PDT LOS ANGELES (AP) -- On an American Indian reservation along the Colorado River, a power company and a tribe are blazing a trail in the battle to boost energy supplies. The Fort Mojave tribe joined forces with the Calpine Corp. to build the first power plant on tribal land to generate electricity for the wholesale market. The plant is expected to become a model for tribes and energy companies looking for lucrative, fast-tracked projects. "I think it could be a brilliant idea. You could short-circuit all of these delays that have beset other projects," said Craig Goodman, president of the National Energy Marketers Association. Federal and tribal governments control whether such plants are built, allowing energy companies to bypass state and local regulations that often slow projects, and to avoid lawsuits by residents. "You don't get stopped by local folks going to their local courts to stop the project," said Ross O. Swimmer, a Tulsa, Okla., attorney who brokers deals between tribes and energy companies. The South Point Energy Center at Fort Mojave is owned and run by Calpine on land the firm leases from the tribe. The $300 million plant went into operation last month and can provide energy for 540,000 households in Arizona, California and Nevada. The reservation occupies parts of all three states. Tribal involvement in the power industry is picking up momentum throughout the West as tribes search for ways to make money off undeveloped land and power companies learn about the tax breaks and other incentives of building on reservations. Projects are under consideration in California, Montana, Nevada and Oregon. The trend is gaining the greatest momentum in California, where the energy crisis has prompted rolling blackouts and skyrocketing utility bills. At least a third of California's more than 100 tribes are exploring ways to build their own plants with help from investors, or to lease land to energy companies. Some of the power would be for the tribe's own use, some for sale on the wholesale market. Congress is considering legislation that would encourage energy development on tribal land by allocating money for power projects. And California lawmakers are considering legislation to help expedite projects and establish purchasing contracts between the state and tribes. San Jose-based Calpine also has major projects in the works on the Moapa Paiute reservation near Las Vegas and on the Torres-Martinez reservation in southeastern California. Both proposals are still in the federal permitting process. "The Indian tribes, by and large they're poor and they're looking for economic development companies to come on board and develop economic interests," said John Rocchio, Calpine's senior vice president of business development. Supporters believe power plants can attract other businesses while giving a tribe capital for other enterprises. "When you consider how big it is for a tribe that has basically had no economic development to have as its first economic development project a non-gaming project -- it's really magnificent," said Bobbi Fletcher, project coordinator for the Torres-Martinez tribe. The Torres-Martinez tribe is one of California's poorest, with more than 600 members and virtually no revenue. Tribal members hope to get better housing through power plant revenues and improve their quality of life, which for some could mean running water and reliable power. The incentives for power companies extend beyond affordable lease costs and reduced red tape. Businesses on tribal land get tax write-offs in the early years and see more cash flow sooner, Swimmer said. There also are tax credits for companies that employ American Indians, and exemptions from some local and state taxes. Some energy executives dispute suggestions that the federal permitting process for plants on tribal land is faster and less bureaucratic. They say the real motivation is the location. "They have holdings that are very close to major transmission and major gas lines -- two of the most important things that a company is looking for when we're siting a project," said Kent Robertson, a Calpine spokesman. ,2001 Associated Press Federal order limits potential state refunds by $3 billion KAREN GAUDETTE, Associated Press Writer Sunday, July 29, 2001 ,2001 Associated Press URL: <http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/news/archive/2001/07/29/state 1921EDT0655.DTL> (07-29) 23:39 PDT SAN FRANCISCO (AP) -- California will receive refunds for overpriced electricity, but not as much as it had asked for. A closer reading of last week's order from federal energy regulators shows the amount the state will receive could be slashed to just under $4 billion -- less than half of what the state requested. Gov. Gray Davis plans to appeal the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission decision Monday, state officials said Sunday afternoon. Refunds could help prevent the state from raising electric rates to cover its power buying costs, which are now beyond $8 billion. "We found a number of disturbing things that lead us to believe FERC may not be so pro-refund as they want Californians to believe," said Nancy McFadden, an adviser to Davis. For months, Davis and other state officials have asked the FERC to find electricity prices charged since May 2000 to be unjust and unreasonable -- prices which climbed 10 times higher than past years. The state stands to lose a portion of the billions it has spent buying electricity for Pacific Gas and Electric Co. customers and two other financially ailing utilities. Power companies maintain they did not work together to drive up power prices to unreasonable levels. The FERC's 40-page decision confirms the commission will only order refunds for power bought since October 2000, rather than May 2000. That means $2 billion less than the state, utilities and others could hope to receive, McFadden said. In addition, the FERC also said it will not issue refunds for power the state Department of Water Resources bought directly from power companies. FERC only will recognize purchases through the state's now-defunct power market or from the manager of the state's power grid. That stripped another $3 billion off the potential refund amount, reducing the refund by a total of $5 billion. The DWR bought most of its megawatts directly from power companies after a FERC ruling in December abolished the Power Exchange, the state's key entity that bought and sold power. The Independent System Operator, keeper of the state's grid, then began adding a surcharge on big purchases, McFadden said. All told, the most the state could expect to get back would be roughly $3.9 billion, said Barry Goode, a legal secretary to Davis. And despite the overcharges, some of that money has to pay power companies for past power deliveries at a price FERC determines is just and reasonable. State officials had hoped to receive up to $9 billion in refunds. A call to FERC for comment was not immediately returned Sunday afternoon. The FERC has ordered an evidentiary hearing, to be completed within 60 days, to determine the size of the refund from providers of wholesale power. Gas suppliers accuse El Paso pipeline firm of constricting flow to drive up prices Bernadette Tansey, Chronicle Staff Writer <mailto:btansey@sfchronicle.com> Sunday, July 29, 2001 ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle </chronicle/info/copyright> URL: <http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/chronicle/archive/2001/07/29/ MN206471.DTL> The Texas energy company already accused by state officials of manipulating the natural gas market now faces new allegations by fellow industry players that last winter it systematically starved the state of necessary fuel in order to drive up consumer prices and boost profits. Formerly tight-lipped shippers that lease space on the pipeline El Paso Corp. runs from the gas fields of the Southwest to Southern California are blaming El Paso for California's energy price explosion. And a lawyer for one group of pipeline customers is urging fellow shippers to unite against El Paso as a "common enemy" that is strangling traffic in natural gas to preserve its bottom line. The new accusations came as a result of evidence presented at a hearing before a federal regulatory judge in May. El Paso Corp., which has been targeted by state regulators, utilities and legislators convinced it helped cause California's disastrous season of soaring energy costs, had hoped that the hearing would lay all suspicions to rest. Instead, the hearing has given rise to a fresh round of grievances -- not only from state officials, but also from industry heavyweights. Major shippers say that while heating bills soared and California's gas prices were the highest in the nation last winter, they were willing but unable to get more gas into the state because El Paso curtailed their deliveries -- even though they held contracts for pipeline space. 'CAUSED ENORMOUS HARM' "Shippers are losing multimillions of dollars," the suppliers said in a July 13 complaint to federal regulators. "These problems also have contributed to artificially high gas prices . . . which have caused enormous harm to both gas and electric markets throughout the West." El Paso officials declined to give detailed responses to the new complaints while they are pending before the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission. "We all here at El Paso feel very confident that the facts will demonstrate that we have abided by the terms of our contracts," company spokesman Mel Scott said. El Paso runs the biggest interstate pipeline system serving California, accounting for about half the capacity to the state. The federal hearings held in Washington, D.C., on May 14 concerned accusations by state regulators and utilities, described in detail in a May 13 article in The Chronicle, that the company had rigged a contract in early 2000 to award a huge block of pipeline space to its own gas-sales affiliate. The affiliate, El Paso Merchant Energy, then left half its share of the pipeline idle and raised barriers to other shippers who could have paid for the excess space, according to the complaint. The result: Gas supplies shrank and prices in California soared to as much as 10 times the national average, costing the state an extra $3.7 billion for gas and electricity in 2000 and early 2001, according to consultants for Southern California Edison, which joined in the complaint. El Paso Corp. has called the claims against its affiliate unfounded. The company says the price rise was caused by dry weather that forced hydroelectric plants to cut back, pushing up demand for power from natural gas- fired plants. It also says supplies were squeezed because of inadequate pipeline networks within California. RELIEF COULDN'T GET THROUGH The latest accusations against El Paso concern a larger chunk of pipeline space -- about two-thirds of its capacity -- that the company did not lease to its affiliate. A group of major energy firms that bought rights to that pipeline space from El Paso say they have been unable to get extra supplies through to California -- an influx that could have lowered prices during the big crunch last winter -- because El Paso rationed service to them. Those shippers, including Amoco Production Co., BP Energy Co. and Burlington Resources Oil & Gas Co., complained to the FERC this month that El Paso oversold its pipeline space, then failed to deliver what it promised. Instead of using the remaining one-third of the pipeline to meet those obligations, the gas firms complain, El Paso sold that block to its own affiliate and reaped a windfall at their expense. "El Paso and its marketing affiliate, El Paso Merchant, have been unjustly enriched by this situation," the complaint says. According to the gas suppliers' complaint, El Paso officials testified in the Washington hearings that the company could not ship all the gas it promised to California because of growing demand from Arizona, Nevada and New Mexico. The major shippers to California, joined by the state's utilities and the Public Utilities Commission, say El Paso is accommodating a dramatic increase in demand by Southwestern customers while skimping on gas to California. Gas suppliers in Sun Belt states say they're entitled to all the gas they need under their own El Paso contracts. But the California shippers want the FERC to set limits on how much gas customers in other states can draw from the pipeline. BREACH OF PROMISE ALLEGED Joel Greene, a lawyer who represents a group of gas firms and utilities east of California, including Arizona Electric Power Cooperative Inc., Public Service Co. of New Mexico, Salt River Project and the Southern Union Gas Co., said the warring shippers should stop quibbling with each other and focus on El Paso, which he described as the "common enemy" that has broken faith with all of them. Greene said El Paso breached a promise to all the shippers, who collectively saved the company from ruin in 1996 when El Paso had a glut of capacity it couldn't sell. Shippers on both sides of the state border agreed to pay higher rates through 2006 to cover the pipeline's operating costs. In exchange, Greene said, El Paso promised to expand its network if necessary to meet demand. Greene said El Paso was warned in 1999 that gas demand was catching up with supply, but that the company failed to invest in new pipelines. El Paso would not have gotten more revenue for the new construction because its rates were frozen under the 1996 settlement, according to the complaint the shippers filed with the federal commission. "If you're El Paso, why go out of your way to build if you can't recover until 2006?" Greene said. El Paso recently filed plans with the FERC for a new pipeline that would help meet the needs of shippers to California. Suppliers on both sides of the state border want the FERC to require El Paso to use all future expansions to fulfill its existing contracts before it takes on any new customers. The FERC still is not finished with the first complaint against El Paso -- the one accusing the company of awarding pipeline space to its own affiliate, which then, allegedly, withheld it from the market. SUBPOENAS THREATENED El Paso executives, including company President William Wise, will face another round of questioning as a second phase of hearings begins Thursday before Curtis Wagner Jr., the commission's chief administrative law judge. Wagner threatened to subpoena Wise in May, complaining he was "getting the runaround" from other executives. Harvey Morris, an attorney for the PUC who is arguing the state's case against El Paso, said evidence that emerged in the last round of hearings strengthened the state's demand that the federal government order El Paso to refund as much as $200 million in profits -- though he added, "It'll never make California whole." Morris is preparing briefs claiming El Paso's pipeline affiliate reduced pressure on the system to further worsen the scarcity of gas flowing to California, at the same time its gas-sales arm was withholding pipeline capacity from competing shippers. Once gas prices started to peak in November, Morris claims, the pipeline restored the lost pressure -- and El Paso Merchant Energy used all its capacity to reap the profits. "This wasn't just El Paso Merchant Energy exercising market power," Morris said. "It was the pipeline company itself exercising market power." E-mail Bernadette Tansey at btansey@sfchronicle.com <mailto:btansey@sfchronicle.com>. ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle </chronicle/info/copyright> Page A - 1 News briefs on the California power crisis The Associated Press Sunday, July 29, 2001 ,2001 Associated Press URL: <http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/news/archive/2001/07/29/state 2004EDT0671.DTL> (07-29) 17:04 PDT SAN FRANCISCO (AP) -- Residents of Potrero Hill are intensifying their fight against Mirant Corporation's plan to build a 540-megawatt power plant in their neighborhood. The Atlanta-based company wants to expand an aging 210-megawatt plant and three 52-megawatt peaker units on a site at 23rd and Illinois streets where a small power plant occupies 27-acres. But residents say a bigger plant would have an adverse impact on public health and the environment. A lawsuit was filed against Mirant in federal court last month for alleged air-pollution violations at the peaker facilities it now has on Potrero Hill. Residents and environmental activists are considering more lawsuits and using the ballot box as a way to oppose the expansion of the power plant. Mark Harrer, Mirant's project director, dismissed opposition as NIMBYism, "not-in-my-back-yard" negativity. But whether or not the power plant is augmented depends on the Independent System Operator. "The controlling agency is the Independent System Operator, and the ISO has conditions," Edward Smeloff, the city's top power-policy official, said. "One is enough in-city capacity and the other is additional capacity from the South Bay. It's conceivable you'd have a new plant on Potrero Hill." SANTA CLARA, Calif. (AP) -- More than ten families living about 20 miles from Livermore near the Santa Clara County border are setting the example of homes who generate all their own power. These families live in a remote stretch of Mines Road where PG&E has no reach. The Westbrooks, one of the families in the no-power zone, built their house so it would be completely energy-efficient. The couple spent about $30,000 to install their off-grid system but didn't have to deal with the red tape associated with connecting to the PG&E grid. Photovoltaic systems like the Westbrook's are becoming increasingly popular as energy costs rise and more homeowners turn to clean, renewable energy sources. The Westbrooks buy propane in large amounts to save money. They use about 2,000 gallons per year at about $5.50 per day. The cost to run their off-grid system to supply electricity to their three bedroom house is negligible. Greg Gahagan, board member of the California Solar Energy Industries Association in Napa, told the Contra Costa Times his organization is seeing increased interest in solar because of several incentives available to businesses and homeowners. But most customers have to wait a few months before they can get panels. There is a backlog in production of solar panels because of the great demand, Gahagan said. ,2001 Associated Press Power consultant firings called 'tip of iceberg' Secretary of state says disclosure list should be expanded Bernadette Tansey, Kelly St. John, Chronicle Staff Writers <mailto:btansey@sfchronicle.com> Sunday, July 29, 2001 ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle </chronicle/info/copyright> URL: <http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/chronicle/archive/2001/07/29/ MN15752.DTL> Calling the dismissal of five Davis administration energy consultants who disclosed ownership of power company stocks "just the tip of the iceberg," Secretary of State Bill Jones continued yesterday to attack potential conflicts of interest in the state's electricity-buying program. "These few firings don't resolve the issue at all," said Jones, a Republican who may challenge Davis in the next gubernatorial race. Jones said the list of advisers required to file financial disclosures should be expanded and the issue further investigated by state Attorney General Bill Lockyer and by the state Fair Political Practices Commission. Davis spokesman Steve Maviglio said yesterday that financial statements have been submitted by all 42 contractors required to do so under state law. All of the traders who held stock in energy companies met a deadline last week to sell their shares, and the few whose disclosures raised questions have been let go, he said. "The governor's office is now involved in making sure (traders) meet the highest ethical standards," Maviglio said. Five energy traders who helped negotiate state spot market purchases or long-term power contracts were dismissed and a sixth left state service for another job after the Davis administration reviewed their financial statements last week, Maviglio said yesterday. Susan Weber, chief counsel for the state Department of Water Resources, which began buying power in January for state utilities swamped with debt, has also been reassigned because the Davis administration was dissatisfied with her handling of the ethics issue. "Despite being under a tremendous burden, it's no excuse for not following the law," Maviglio said. He said the state water department sought guidance in April from the attorney general's office and the Fair Political Practices Commission on which of the energy contractors, who were swiftly hired to help keep the lights on in California, were required to submit financial statements. The department did not act quickly enough to order the disclosures once it received that advice, Maviglio said. Four of the dismissed traders owned stock in Calpine Corp., based in San Jose: William F. Mead, Herman Leung, Constantine Louie and Peggy Chen. A fifth, Bernard Barretto, owned stock in Enron. Calpine sold the state power worth $14 million early this year and signed a significant share of the $43 billion in long-term contracts later secured by the state. A higher-ranking consultant, Richard Ferreira, disclosed that he owned up to $10,000 in Calpine stock. Concerns ranging from the timing of the stock purchases and the adequacy of the financial statements led to termination of the five traders, Maviglio said. "They were close to the line," he said. "We thought that was inappropriate." Reached by phone at his home in Duarte (Los Angeles County) yesterday, Mead said state officials never told him owning energy stock was a problem until they abruptly asked him to sell the stock earlier this month. He complied immediately. Mead, hired in February as a trader on the spot market, bought 800 shares of Calpine in 1999 and watched them soar to a value of more than $100,000 today. "I feel like, honestly, there was no conflict of interest," said the 55- year-old engineer, who noted that Calpine does not sell power in the spot market where he was trading. "I was never put in a position to make a decision on Calpine." "We're ultimately pawns in a political game," Mead said. Jones said Davis is still exempting 21 advisers involved in the power purchasing effort from filing financial disclosures. He wants Davis' two Wall Street advisers, Joseph Fichera and Michael Hoffman, to fill out the forms. But Maviglio said Fichera and Hoffman have nothing to do with power purchases, serving only as consultants in the pending issue of $12.5 billion in bonds to reimburse the state for its power purchases. E-mail Bernadette Tansey at btansey@sfchronicle.com <mailto:btansey@sfchronicle.com> and Kelly St. John at kstjohn@sfchronicle.com <mailto:kstjohn@sfchronicle.com>. ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle </chronicle/info/copyright> Page A - 15 Federal order limits potential California refunds by $3 billion Posted at 11:13 p.m. PDT Sunday, July 29, 2001 BY KAREN GAUDETTE Associated Press Writer SAN FRANCISCO (AP) -- A closer reading of last week's order from federal energy regulators shows California will receive refunds for overpriced electricity, but the amount could be slashed to just under $4 billion -- less than half of what the state requested. Gov. Gray Davis plans to appeal the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission decision Monday, state officials said Sunday afternoon. Refunds could help prevent the state from raising electric rates to cover its power buying costs, which are now beyond $8 billion. ``We found a number of disturbing things that lead us to believe FERC may not be so pro-refund as they want Californians to believe,'' said Nancy McFadden, an adviser to Davis. For months, Davis and other state officials have asked the FERC to find electricity prices charged since May 2000 to be unjust and unreasonable -- prices which climbed 10 times higher than past years. The state stands to lose a portion of the billions it has spent buying electricity for Pacific Gas and Electric Co. customers and two other financially ailing utilities. Power companies maintain they did not work together to drive up power prices to unreasonable levels. The FERC's 40-page decision confirms the commission will only order refunds for power bought since October 2000, rather than May 2000. That means $2 billion less than the state, utilities and others could hope to receive, McFadden said. In addition, the FERC also said it will not issue refunds for power the state Department of Water Resources bought directly from power companies. FERC only will recognize purchases through the state's now-defunct power market or from the manager of the state's power grid. That stripped another $3 billion off the potential refund amount, reducing the refund by a total of $5 billion. The DWR bought most of its megawatts directly from power companies after a FERC ruling in December abolished the Power Exchange, the state's key entity that bought and sold power. The Independent System Operator, keeper of the state's grid, then began adding a surcharge on big purchases, McFadden said. All told, the most the state could expect to get back would be roughly $3.9 billion, said Barry Goode, a legal secretary to Davis. And despite the overcharges, some of that money has to pay power companies for past power deliveries at a price FERC determines is just and reasonable. State officials had hoped to receive up to $9 billion in refunds. A call to FERC for comment was not immediately returned Sunday afternoon. The FERC has ordered an evidentiary hearing, to be completed within 60 days, to determine the size of the refund from providers of wholesale power. Huge PG&E bankruptcy case creates many conflicts of interest Posted at 11:08 p.m. PDT Sunday, July 29, 2001 SAN FRANCISCO (AP) -- The third largest bankruptcy in U.S. history is also becoming the most complex. As Pacific Gas and Electric Co. wades through its pile of debts, many of the legal and financial teams representing the utility and its creditors often run into conflicts of interest. Since PG&E is so large and far reaching, it may be difficult to find firms and businesses that are not somehow associated with the utility. In addition, many large accounting and legal agencies are getting involved because of their expertise in bankruptcy cases. ``Very few people have the expertise for high-profile, high-stakes bankruptcies, so you have a small pool from which to draw representation, and that's where . . . potential conflicts come up,'' Nancy B. Rapoport, a University of Houston law professor who's a bankruptcy ethics expert, told the Los Angeles Times. Since the utility filed for Chapter 11 protection in April, its lead counsel, Howard, Rice, Nemerovski, Canady, Falk & Rabkin already has racked up $2.65 million in the first two months of the case. Last year, that same firm reported earning $1.9 million from PG&E. The total court-approved amount in the filing could reach at least $470 million, said Lynn LoPucki, UCLA law professor and expert on bankruptcy practice. ``The bigger the case, the bigger the fees,'' LoPucki told the Times, calling the bankruptcy ``one of the most complex cases ever.'' PG&E's bankruptcy ranks third behind Texaco Inc. and Financial Corp. of America when comparing assets -- PG&E reportedly has $31.5 billion in assets. And about a dozen companies are in line for contracts to work for PG&E or the committee representing the company's creditors. Experts say the potential for ethical dilemmas to occur already exists based on the firms approved by the case's Judge Dennis Montali. For example, the utility's primary law firm also represents banking interests linked to nearly $1 billion in debts. PG&E's accounting firm also has worked for more than 80 companies involved in the bankruptcy case, including some creditors. Experts say the multitude of conflicts surrounding the case could allow professional firms to alter outcomes to benefit certain companies while hurting PG&E. ``By traditional conflict standards, the large firms could not participate in the cases,'' LoPucki said. ``There has been a huge shift in what is acceptable. It is more lenient. A firm is allowed to represent clients today where they would not have been allowed 20 years ago.'' Some firms have submitted disclaimers describing the ties and in some cases have said there are so many connections with various involved companies, they may not even be aware of them all. While other have created ``ethical walls'' within their companies or have asked clients to sign waivers releasing the professionals from conflicts of interest. Accounting firm PricewaterhouseCoopers, which works for PG&E and its parent corporation PG&E Corp., agreed to build an ``ethical wall'' in order to also serve as accountant and financial adviser for the committee representing PG&E's creditors. Judge Montali approved the hiring of the accounting firm despite objections from Linda Ekstrom Stanley, the U.S. trustee assigned to guard against abuses and money-making schemes that can occur during bankruptcy proceedings. Her office has involved itself several times, objecting to everything from excessive fees to conflicts. But some say it would be impossible for PG&E's bankruptcy proceedings to move forward if every conflict were closely examined. ``It would be horrendous,'' said Daniel Bogart, a law professor at Chapman University. ``There are conflicts that matter and those that don't. The parties have to reach a level of comfort quickly.'' PG&E and Santa Cruz couple in power struggle Posted at 9:45 p.m. PDT Sunday, July 29, 2001 BY CHUCK CARROLL Mercury News Ken Adelman, who owns one of the most powerful solar electric systems in California, has had it with PG&E. The utility wants Adelman and his wife, Gabrielle, to pay about $600,000 to upgrade the power lines and other equipment in their rural Santa Cruz Mountains neighborhood so their 31-kilowatt system doesn't overload the power grid. ``That's more than I paid for my house,'' said Ken Adelman, a retired tech millionaire who spent about $400,000 this spring for the photovoltaic system with enough juice for about a dozen homes. They intend to feed their excess energy back to PG&E for credit to ``zero-out'' their utility bill. The state has been so hungry for new power sources it is offering rebates to solar buyers who hook up to the grid. But the Adelmans can't get their $138,317 rebate until PG&E allows them to go on line. So, after months of wrangling for the right to connect to the grid, Adelman flipped the switch himself last week -- with nobody's permission. ``I'm sitting here watching my meter run backward,'' said Adelman, who said he sent about 10 kilowatts back onto the grid for a 20-minute test that proved his system was safe. ``PG&E is taking out all the guns. And so am I.'' Pacific Gas & Electric was not amused. Spokesman John Nelson said the company didn't know about Adelman's test, but he should have called PG&E so it could inspect the system before he put any power on the grid. The state's Public Utilities Commission requires that, Nelson said. Not only did Adelman's test violate those requirements, it ``possibly created a safety threat to himself, PG&E workers and his neighbors,'' Nelson said. Fight continues Their fight over power continues. The Adelmans filed a complaint this month with state regulators -- starting a process that could wind up being a test case for small, independent power generators. They want the PUC to order PG&E to hook up their system at no charge and to refund about $500 a month for the electricity they've bought since June 1 to power their 4,200-square-foot home -- with its pool, hot tub, Internet servers and four electric cars in the garage. The Adelmans say a new state law says they shouldn't have to pay a cent to hook to the grid. For years, the utilities have been required to allow solar systems of up to 10 kilowatts to connect to the grid for free, and get credit for the power they put online. But in April, lawmakers eager to encourage new sources of power raised the limit by 100 times -- to 1 megawatt. Adelman's system is one of the first to take advantage of the new law. But PG&E is plugged in to a different state rule. Nelson said the utility is bound by a document known as ``Rule 21.'' That rule requires the Adelmans -- not ratepayers -- to pay for any upgrades to the power system to safely handle the amount of power they want to add to the grid at the end of a circuit that wasn't built for such a load, Nelson said. When state lawmakers changed the law to accommodate new power generators in April, it didn't automatically change Rule 21, said PUC regulatory analyst Valerie Beck, without taking sides in the dispute. Rule must be changed ``There's nothing that can be done until Rule 21 is changed,'' Nelson said. Connecting solar and wind systems to the grid -- known as ``net metering'' -- allows owners to get credit on their utility bills for power they feed back. The Adelmans don't need all 31 kilowatts of electricity their system could produce. And generating all that power off the grid wouldn't make economic sense, because they would have to use their batteries every night and wear them out too fast, Adelman said. PG&E says the main problem with the Adelmans' new system is that it's so big and so remote -- at the end of a power circuit about two miles from the center of tiny Corralitos. The Adelmans, both electrical engineers who each made millions selling their start-ups to Cisco Systems and Nokia, said PG&E's estimate of $450,000 for upgrades and $150,000 in federal taxes is far too much. Ken Adelman agrees the transformer on the utility pole outside his house probably needs to be replaced for a few thousand dollars. He said he'd be happy to pay that, even though he's convinced the law says he shouldn't. Regulators and solar industry experts say they haven't heard of a utility trying to charge a solar operator a connection fee anywhere near $600,000. But the law is new, and the Adelman dispute could be a test as more people with wind and solar systems try to get connected. ``The law stands firmly on his side,'' said Bill Brooks, a consultant to the state Energy Commission who helped draft the law. ``It's certainly not worth it for PG&E to fight this.'' Law was changed This spring, actor Clint Eastwood lobbied lawmakers to change the law so renewable energy generators larger than 10 kilowatts, like his Tehama Golf Club in Carmel -- a system about the same size as Adelman's -- would be able to hook up to the grid and sell back their surplus energy. In Eastwood's case, the hookup fee wasn't an issue, said Carmel developer Michael Waxer, who headed up the project. The golf course is in a developed area with power lines that can easily handle Eastwood's surplus power. The state is watching PG&E and other utilities closely to see how well they cooperate with small independent power producers, said engineer Tony Mazy, with the PUC's Office of Ratepayer Advocate. These producers, he said, represent ``a very real threat to alter the fundamental architecture of the electrical distribution system'' under which utilities have thrived. Contact Chuck Carroll at ccarroll@sjmercury.com <mailto:ccarroll@sjmercury.com> or (650) 688-7598. Business; Financial Desk Sempra Unit Pulls in Profit, and Scrutiny Energy: The trading arm, which has come under increasing criticism, raked in $310 million in the last 18 months. DAVAN MAHARAJ 07/30/2001 Los Angeles Times Home Edition Page C-1 Copyright 2001 / The Times Mirror Company While the state's two largest utilities, Pacific Gas & Electric Co. and Southern California Edison Co., are struggling for survival, the parent of San Diego Gas & Electric Co. is racking up record profit from the state's energy crisis, thanks in part to a subsidiary that buys and sells energy on the wholesale market. In the last 18 months, Sempra Energy's trading subsidiary has raked in $310 million in profit. That's $120 million more than the sum Sempra paid for the trading outfit 3 1/2 years ago. And analysts expect profit to climb higher as the trading arm continues to take advantage of volatile energy markets in California and across the United States. The trading activities of San Diego-based Sempra are drawing increasing scrutiny from regulators and consumer watchdogs who question why the state is doling out attractive energy contracts to a company that already is flush with cash. Records recently revealed that a Sempra power generator sold all its capacity at attractive prices over an extended period to the California Department of Water Resources, which has been procuring power for the state's largest utilities. "Sempra has become like the multimillionaire that refuses to tip," said Michael Shames, executive director of the Utility Consumers' Action Network in San Diego. "There seems to be a fundamental violation of the principle of fairness whereby Sempra's trading arm is hugely profitable at the expense of consumers." Sempra insists its trading business is a worldwide operation that deals in not just electricity but oil, gas and other commodities. Only a small portion of the trading unit's profit comes from California and the Western region, said company spokesman Doug Kline. State records revealed this month that Sempra Energy Trading--and several other wholesale electricity merchants--charged California some of the highest prices for electricity during the first three months of the year. Sempra officials say they were only procuring power for the state when supplies were critically low, but critics want Sempra to refund the alleged overcharges. Separately, Sempra is battling lawsuits that it conspired with several gas and pipeline companies to eliminate competition, drive up natural gas prices and discourage the construction of electricity generating plants in California . Sempra's activities have come under scrutiny because critics say its trading subsidiary was influential in driving wholesale electricity prices to levels that helped ignite California 's energy crisis. These high prices helped saddle its own SDG&E, PG&E and Edison with billions of dollars in debt. PG&E and Edison also have energy-trading businesses, though they are not as lucrative as Sempra's. California 's 1996 deregulation law created a competitive marketplace where more than 100 energy traders now buy and sell electricity . Energy traders serve as middlemen, buying power from generators and reselling them to utilities and commercial power users. Some middlemen are connected to firms that own power plants, but others are speculators, such as Morgan Stanley Capital Group. Traders may buy a block of electricity a day, month or year ahead of time and resell it to another broker, a city or a utility. In California 's energy crisis, a single electron might be traded a dozen times before it reaches a ratepayer's home. Sempra acquired a trading unit when it bought American International Group Inc. for $190 million in 1997. Sempra Energy Trading earned $13 million in 1998 and $19 million the next year. As the energy crisis exploded, Sempra Energy Trading's profit soared to $155 million in 2000. For the first two quarters of this year, the trading unit has accounted for $155 million in profit. Critics say Sempra can maximize profit for its trading arm--and various other business units--by knowing the direction of the market. For example, if executives in Sempra's trading arm know that its sister subsidiary, Southern California Gas Co., is planning to buy large supplies of gas for storage, they could structure their trades to take advantage of anticipated higher prices, consumer watchdog groups say. "What you have is a back-room, cottage industry for information whereby affiliates and generators of the same holding company secretly trade in a market that they have been able to manipulate to exact exorbitant profits at the expense of those customers who don't have access to that information," Shames said. "It's classic insider trading for which people like Michael Milken served time in jail, and yet these holding companies get to build palaces." Sempra and its subsidiaries have denied allegations of insider trading and insist that all of the company's activities have been legal. Strict Public Utilities Commission rules prohibit Sempra from sharing information among its business units, said Chairman and Chief Executive Stephen L. Baum. Baum, however, acknowledged that it isn't "particularly healthy" for Sempra's trading arm to sell electricity in the California market, where purchases by the state are eventually billed to SDG&E ratepayers. "I don't like being embarrassed to announce earnings in some of my business units of Sempra because people are suffering in San Diego in the electricity crisis," Baum said. "That's not a healthy corporate situation." Baum has hinted that the parent company might decide to spin off Sempra Energy Trading or other business units to create shareholder value and avoid perceived conflicts of interest. For now, the parent company is contesting allegations that Sempra's business units are cashing in on insider knowledge. In a recent filing with the state Public Utilities Commission, a group of primarily municipal generators detailed how the Gas Co. may have acted to drive up the price of gas for customers so it could rake in additional profit. In mid-2000, the gas utility paid $16.5 million for option contracts that entitled it to buy gas at the end of the year. The contracts gave the Gas Co. an incentive to buy "abnormally high" volumes of gas at the California border during the winter months, said Norman Pedersen, an attorney for the Southern California Generation Coalition. High border purchases by the Gas Co. drove up border prices, Pedersen said, allowing the utility to take in $70 million from the deal. The Gas Co. has vigorously denied that the $70-million gain was related to California border transactions. "Customers were not only protected by, but directly benefited from [our] . . . options programs," the utility's lawyers said in a response filed with the PUC. Under a state incentive program that rewards utilities for keeping costs down, the Gas Co. is required to split savings--such as the $70 million--50-50 with ratepayers whenever the company's gas costs fall slightly below market levels. Because the Gas Co. has consistently beaten the market, those savings have multiplied nearly tenfold during the state's power crisis. Pedersen's clients, which include the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power, want the PUC to reconsider the incentive program, saying that it "may have contributed to recently disproportionately high border prices" and higher gas costs. Last month, the Gas Co. told the PUC it would accept only $30 million of the $106 million it was due under the state incentive program. In return the state must agree to continue the incentive program, according to the Gas Co. proposal. Analysts who follow Sempra's stock, which is trading near its 52-week high, said Sempra is being unfairly targeted for being successful. Merrill Lynch energy analyst Donato Eassey said Sempra moved more quickly than PG&E and Edison to take advantage of the state's law that deregulated California 's energy market and invested the proceeds in trading and other profitable operations. "There is nothing illegal about making profits," said Eassey, who recently upgraded Sempra's stock to "buy." "People in California need to pay the damn bill and shut up." State of California Lets Go 5 Consultants Tied to Energy Firms 07/30/2001 The Wall Street Journal Page A4 (Copyright (c) 2001, Dow Jones & Company, Inc.) SACRAMENTO, Calif. -- The California state government has stopped using five consultants in its giant electricity -buying operation because of conflict-of-interest concerns stemming from the individuals' stock ownership in big energy companies doing business with the state. The conflicts-of-interest issue arose recently after the stockholdings appeared on state-mandated financial disclosure forms filed by some of the 58 electricity -related consultants hired by the administration of Gov. Gray Davis. The consultants worked in a range of capacities, including negotiating power-purchase deals with energy suppliers and helping to arrange for electricity deliveries. Steve Maviglio, the governor's press secretary, said 11 of 42 people filing financial disclosure forms said they owned energy company stocks or had other financial interests in such firms. When the issue arose, the state demanded that the individuals sell their stock. All did, Mr. Maviglio said.