11 Jul 2001, 11:54 UTC
Energy Issues
- From
- Angela Wilson angela.wilson@enron.com
- To
-
Ann M Schmidt, Bryan Seyfried, Elizabeth Linnell, filuntz@aol.com, James D Steffes, Janet Butler, Jeannie Mandelker, Jeff Dasovich, Joe Hartsoe, John Neslage, John Sherriff, Joseph Alamo
and 51 more
Karen Denne, Mark Palmer, Mark Schroeder, Markus Fiala, Michael R Brown, Mona L Petrochko, Nicholas O'Day, Peggy Mahoney, Peter Styles, Richard Shapiro, Rob Bradley, Shelley Corman, Stella Chan, Steven J Kean, Susan J Mara, mike.roan@enron.com, Alex Parsons, andrew.morrison@enron.com, Laura Ipsen, Janel Guerrero, shirley.hudler@enron.com, Kathleen Sullivan, Tom Briggs, Linda Robertson, Lora Sullivan, Jennifer Thome, jkradin@marathon-com.com, rlichtenstein@marathon-com.com, Sandra Yamane, Ken Smith, Hedy Govenar, Scott Govenar, Bev Hansen, Carin Nersesian, Robert Neustaedter, John Shelk, Chris Holmes, Evan Hughes, Roberta Staehlin, Lamar Frazier, Ban Sharma, Pat Shortridge, Karen Moore, Kurt Lindahl, Marcus Dotson, Alan Comnes, Melinda Pharms, Lysa Akin, Luiz Maurer, Chris Long, Larry Decker - Bcc
- Miyung Buster
- Date
- Wed, 11 Jul 2001 04:54:00 -0700 (PDT)
Please see the following articles: Sac Bee, Wed, 7/11: Mediator talked of a bigger refund: He reportedly suggested a $4.5 billion deal midway through the failed talks Sac Bee, Wed, 7/11: Davis repeats threat to sue FERC to get full refund Sac Bee, Wed, 7/11: Dan Walters: Davis plays in a virtual world while the energy reality continues Sac Bee, Wed, 7/11: Energy Digest: Ratepayer panel shot down again Sac Bee, Wed, 7/11: Missing megawatts: Conservation saving state from blackouts (Editorial) SD Union, Wed, 7/11: Governor tells FERC to be fair and then some SD Union, Wed, 7/11: Calpine says deal with state close on alleged overcharges SD Union, Wed, 7/11: Judge refuses to let ratepayers form official committee in utility bankruptcy case LA Times, Wed, 7/11: Judge Bars Ratepayers Panel From PG&E Case SF Chron, Wed, 7/11: Developments in California's energy crisis SF Chron, Wed, 7/11: Enron Corp. sues to block Senate from forcing document release SF Chron, Wed, 7/11: Governor threatens to sue utilities for refunds Davis says California won't settle for $1 billion SF Chron, Wed, 7/11: News briefs on the California power crisis Mercury News, Wed, 7/11: White House bends under energy conservation pressure Mercury News, Wed, 7/11: Davis ups the voltage (Editorial) OC Register, Wed, 7/11: Lights go out on Davis' power show (Commentary) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------ Mediator talked of a bigger refund: He reportedly suggested a $4.5 billion deal midway through the failed talks. By David Whitney Bee Washington Bureau (Published July 11, 2001) WASHINGTON -- Midway through the negotiations between California and power sellers to settle the myriad issues arising out of the state's energy crisis, the mediator told California's negotiating team that he thought a deal worth more than $4.5 billion would be appropriate -- a much higher figure than he suggested after the talks ended Monday. Whether the statement by Curtis Wagner, the chief administrative law judge for the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, was a negotiating ploy or a reflection of his evolving beliefs is not clear. Before the settlement talks began two weeks earlier, Wagner said he thought Gov. Gray Davis' demand for $8.9 billion in refunds was too high and that a settlement probably would be in the range of $2 billion to $2.5 billion. The disclosure that Wagner had contemplated a much higher figure midway through the negotiations suggests the state had more support than the judge let on Monday when he said after the talks foundered that he thought a deal should involve "hundreds of millions, maybe a billion" dollars. While the state wants $8.9 billion, $3 billion of that was for overcharges during the five months preceding last October and are beyond FERC's scope of review. Even as a starting point then, the $4.5 billion mentioned by Wagner represented 75 percent of the money the state was demanding for alleged price gouging between October and May. The judge's $4.5 billion figure, divided between cash payments and savings from long-term power contracts, was confirmed by three sources who asked to be identified only as "close to the negotiations" because participants had been required to sign confidentiality statements. The sources gave virtually identical accounts of a July 2 meeting with Wagner in which the judge also dismissed as "inadequate" a $670 million settlement offer made by power generators and marketers. By Monday, the settlement offer had risen to $716 million. But the state refused to back off its $8.9 billion demand, and there never was any serious back-and-forth negotiations during the 15-day period the regulatory commission had given Wagner to craft a deal. As a consequence of the failed talks, Wagner said Monday that within a week he will send the five-member commission his recommendations on how it might approach an order refunding power overcharges. Among Wagner's suggestions is that the commission convene a hearing before a different administrative judge to take testimony from generators, marketers and the state on how to arrive at a fair settlement. The options sketchily outlined by Wagner on Monday included limiting the time when refunds are allowed -- something that could reduce state claims by about one-third -- and changing the way power plant costs are calculated to a formula more favored by generators. It is not clear whether Wagner, who moved from one negotiating team to another during his two-week quest for a deal, ever raised the $4.5 billion settlement figure to the power marketers and generators. Joel Newton, who represented Dynegy Power, Duke Energy, Reliant Energy, Williams-AES and Mirant in the talks, said Tuesday he was bound by the confidentiality pledge to keep silent on the internal negotiations. Wagner also is refusing all media calls. According to the account of the negotiations confirmed by sources Tuesday, Wagner was angry at the snail's pace of progress after the first week of the talks. On Friday, June 29, Wagner called everyone into his hearing room and scolded them. He condemned the California team, saying they all ought to wear "clown suits" because they were "in the pocket" of Davis and refused to show any independence. He then turned to the generators and said that after a week of talks, nothing had been heard from them. He told them he wanted them to produce "real numbers, and hard numbers" over the weekend and that if they didn't, he would -- "and you're not going to like it." Wagner's admonition apparently moved no one toward a deal. On Monday, in the meeting with the California delegation, one source quoted Wagner as saying the settlement number he received from the generators and marketers "is so low I can't even present it to you." "I'm not happy with the figures, they're not adequate," others quoted the judge as saying. At that point, the sources said, Wagner said he was thinking of a settlement of $2.5 billion in cash, $2 billion in long-term contract savings and other money from out-of-state investor-owned utilities and even the federal Bonneville Power Administration, which markets power from dams in the Northwest. But as the clock wound down on the negotiations, nothing much happened until Friday and Saturday, when the California team met with the five largest power generators. It was at those meetings that the generators offered $510 million in refunds to settle their disputes with the state. But the money would have gone to reduce the tab for what they were owed by the state and California utilities, and it was loaded with conditions, including the state dropping all of its investigations and lawsuits. Wagner declared the talks over Monday, saying he was unable to bring the parties together. The Bee's David Whitney can be reached at (202) 383-0004 or dwhitney@mcclatchydc.com. Davis repeats threat to sue FERC to get full refund By Emily Bazar Bee Capitol Bureau (Published July 11, 2001) Gov. Gray Davis shot words of caution at federal regulators Tuesday, warning that he will sue them if they order power companies to refund anything less than the $8.9 billion he and other state officials have demanded. The Democratic governor also lobbed threats at state legislators, suggesting that he may call a special session to prevent them from embarking upon a monthlong summer break next week. Instead of vacationing, Davis said, lawmakers must work to approve an agreement between the state and Southern California Edison that would save the utility from bankruptcy. Though the governor has indicated previously that the state may take the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission to court, his announcement Tuesday made it clear he intends to follow through. Settlement talks with power generators to determine how much, if any, the companies overcharged California for electricity concluded Monday with no resolution. Now, the decision rests with the FERC's governing board, and Davis said the state won't back away from the $8.9 billion figure it demanded during talks. "You order what you think is fair," Davis said during a news conference with the state's top negotiators. "We'll take what you order, and we'll see you in court." Davis acknowledged that a legal battle could drag out for months or years. He added that he believes the disagreement -- or even a protracted court battle -- will not affect a tentative agreement between the state and Edison. Under terms of the deal, money to pay off the utility's debt would come from a state purchase of its transmission lines and from a portion of consumers' electricity rates. According to the agreement, the Legislature must approve the deal by Aug. 15, and Davis said he intends to hold lawmakers to that date. Davis said the deadline is important because creditor committees will scrutinize the Legislature's every move to determine whether to force Edison into bankruptcy court rather than await a political deal. Legislators are scheduled to leave for summer recess July 20 and return Aug. 20. Davis threatened to use his executive powers to force lawmakers to remain in Sacramento and work on the Edison agreement, if necessary. The Bee's Emily Bazar can be reached at (916) 326-5540 or ebazar@sacbee.com. Dan Walters: Davis plays in a virtual world while the energy reality continues (Published July 11, 2001) California still has a very real and very severe energy crisis, to wit: The state is still running up massive debts as it pays more for power than it can recover from ratepayers and is having trouble borrowing billions of dollars to cover the debt. There is a strong possibility, perhaps a probability, that when summer's heat truly descends, there will be severe power blackouts as air conditioners demand more juice than California can generate or buy. One major utility, Pacific Gas and Electric, has filed for bankruptcy protection and a second, Southern California Edison, is on the brink of joining it. There is, however, a virtual energy crisis consisting of political spin, media leaks and made-for-television buzz words -- and it is rapidly becoming dominant, while the real situation fades into the background. This week's comic opera proceedings before a Federal Energy Regulatory Commission administrative judge in Washington had little to do with reality and everything to do with the virtual version. Gov. Gray Davis and other officials demanded $8.9 billion in refunds from the generators and brokers who have been selling California power for the past year, alleging that California is, in Davis' words, "being gouged and ripped off." But the number itself was more or less plucked out of thin air -- an arithmetic exercise by the state power grid's traffic controller not intended for a refund proceeding. And while Judge Curtis Wagner saw it as unrealistic, Davis and other state officials insisted on its validity. "There are refunds due that total hundreds of millions of dollars and maybe a billion dollars," Wagner said as a final negotiating session collapsed. But that's a far cry from the $8.9 billion that Davis insists is due. "If you think California is going to settle for $1 billion in refunds, we will see you in court," Davis said Tuesday. Why is Davis being so belligerent? Because it's good politics. Ever since he began berating out-of-state generators and accusing them of ripping off California, Davis' approval ratings have been climbing. If he settled for substantially less -- the power generators probably would agree to a couple of billion dollars to rid themselves of the matter -- Davis would be embarrassed. Politically, he's served by continuing to portray himself as fighting for California and against the out-of-state generators. That it's more political construct than reality is indicated by another event this week, Davis' release of state power purchase data from early in the year -- numbers that were made public only because a judge told him he had to do it. Davis and his minions have been accusing Texas-based generators and power brokers of particularly egregious price gouging -- clearly playing on Californians' instinctive mistrust of anything Texan and implying that Texan George W. Bush is a co-conspirator. But the power purchase records -- which were released only to journalists willing to pay a stiff fee -- indicate that less than 10 percent of California's power purchase dollars were going to Texas and the private sellers, in general, charged the state less than such publicly owned utilities as the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power. The clearly adverse position being taken by FERC and the purchase data that undercut his jingoistic sloganeering are not, however, deterring Davis from continuing to operate, at least for public consumption, in the melodramatic virtual world. One cannot, however, ignore reality forever. The likelihood of a pro-generator decision from FERC means that there will be no easy out for Davis, or for his pending deal to prevent Southern California Edison from slipping into bankruptcy court. The Legislature has refused to act on the Edison rescue plan while it awaited an indication of whether the utility's debts would be slimmed down by FERC. This week's farcical events make it more likely that the Edison deal will stall out permanently in the Legislature and its creditors will force the utility into bankruptcy court later this summer. That's part of that nasty old reality that cannot simply be wished away. The Bee's Dan Walters can be reached at (916) 321-1195 or dwalters@sacbee.com . Energy Digest: Ratepayer panel shot down again (Published July 11, 2001) SAN FRANCISCO -- U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Dennis Montali on Tuesday reaffirmed his earlier decision to disband a ratepayers committee that would have given consumers an official voice in the Pacific Gas and Electric Co. bankruptcy case. The judge said bankruptcy court isn't the right forum for refunding rates or settling potential future claims. He eliminated erroneous statements from the opinion he originally issued seven weeks ago. U.S. bankruptcy trustee Linda Ekstrom Stanley, who had moved for reconsideration, called the new version "a very careful decision" but did not rule out an appeal. Stanley on May 4 appointed an official committee of ratepayers to represent PG&E customers, saying they might be forced to pay for the utility's massive losses. --Claire Cooper Missing megawatts: Conservation saving state from blackouts (Published July 11, 2001) A public that doesn't believe that California's electricity crisis is genuine is nonetheless acting as if it is. Experts are revising down scary predictions of rolling blackout after rolling blackout as Californians have opted to conserve rather than consume. During June, Californians cut back on electricity use by roughly 4,750 megawatts when it mattered the most, on hot afternoons. Those decisions shaved about 12 percent from the expected demand. That's equivalent to the output of nine or 10 medium-size power plants. Last June, grid operators had to call six shortage alerts. This June, which was hotter, they called none. For a state that's been derided as selfish and wasteful, that's nothing short of amazing. Some of what Californians are doing now to conserve isn't likely to become habit in the long run. Businesses may want to turn back on all the banks of lights. Homeowners may decide that 82 degrees is the right temperature when power is short but too warm when California's supply emergency is over. Yet there's a huge potential payoff into the future if some of these changes become permanent. It's encouraging that the most effective forms of conservation -- switching to more energy-efficient appliances or manufacturing techniques -- have yet to be implemented on a large scale. Subsidies for these programs have yet to translate into changes in businesses and in homes that will lower demand even further. For a while this spring, some attempted to diminish the role of conservation. Conservation is a "personal virtue," said Vice President Dick Cheney. But Californians know it's become both a personal and public necessity. The public may have thought the electricity shortage was an illusion, but everyone knew that the higher electricity bills that began arriving in June were real. And so was the risk that the lights would go out on hot days. Yes, the state needs more supply to catch up with the growth in demand. Yet long after the crisis is over, there will be plenty of potential on the efficiency side of the equation as well, to protect the quality of life and reduce the high electricity costs that will likely plague the state for years. Governor tells FERC to be fair and then some Davis firm on demand for $8.9 billion refund By Ed Mendel UNION-TRIBUNE STAFF WRITER July 11, 2001 SACRAMENTO -- Gov. Gray Davis had a tough message for federal regulators yesterday after the failure of settlement talks in California's bid to get an $8.9 billion refund from electricity suppliers: "See you in court." The governor said California will seek a full $8.9 billion refund for electricity overcharges, even if federal regulators award the maximum refund of $5.4 billion allowed under their guidelines. "Our message is just order what you are going to order," Davis said of the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission. "We believe you should order $8.9 billion. But you order what you think is fair. We will take what you order, then we will see you in court." Davis, joined by his negotiating team, made the remarks at a news conference a day after two weeks of closed-door talks with suppliers in Washington failed to reach an agreement. An administrative law judge made a recommendation to the regulatory commission that Davis' top negotiator, Michael Kahn, chairman of the California Independent System Operator, expects to result in a refund of more than $1 billion. Davis said that a revealing decision will be made by the commission, which he hopes has embarked on a "new path" with the appointment by President Bush of two new members, Pat Wood of Texas and Nora Brownell of Pennsylvania. "Are they on the side of consumers, as the federal power act envisions them being," Davis asked, "or are they just there to do the industry's bidding, as they have so often in the past?" Kahn said rules adopted by FERC cut off the refund period at last October, trimming $3 billion from the $8.9 billion overcharge claimed by California dating to May 2000. He said FERC has no jurisdiction over municipal utilities, such as the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power, that sold power to the state. The municipal districts overcharged the state by about $600 million, according to Kahn. As a result, he said, the maximum refund that FERC could order for California is about $5.4 billion. "We made it clear to everyone that if we did not settle for $8.9 billion, we would seek redress in court for the remainder of the money above $5.4 billion," Kahn said. Calpine of San Jose and several other generators have expressed interest in the state's offer to negotiate one-on-one with the state while the federal regulators consider their decision, Kahn said. Calpine says deal with state close on alleged overcharges By Don Thompson ASSOCIATED PRESS July 10, 2001 SACRAMENTO ) Calpine Corp. said Tuesday it is near agreement with California officials over money the state says the company overcharged for electricity. That would make it the first company to settle a part of the $8.9 billion the state wants in negotiations before the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission. However, San Jose-based Calpine has offered far less than the $236 million the state claims it is owed. "We obviously disagree with that number, because we disagree with some of the assumptions" used for the estimate, said Calpine spokesman Bill Highlander. "We don't think it's anywhere near that. We think it's a low number." He wouldn't specify the company's counteroffer, but noted new FERC figures showing the company did $29 million in business with the state in the first five months of this year. The California Independent System Operator estimated the company owed more in overcharges than it had in total sales for the period from May 2000 to May 2001, a financial impossibility, Highlander said. The ISO essentially multiplied what Calpine was able to produce by the amount it charged for electricity, Highlander said, without taking into account how much electricity the company actually sold. ISO spokesman Michael Bustamante defended the projections by the state's grid operator, estimates he said were validated during two weeks of FERC negotiations that ended Monday. The ISO took the methodology adopted by the federal regulator in a June 19 order capping electricity rates, then worked backward to May 2000 to reach its estimate, Bustamante said. Generators and state negotiators were unable to reach a settlement during the two weeks of talks overseen by FERC chief administrative law judge Curtis L. Wagner, leaving Wagner to make his own recommendation to the commission. Wagner said Monday the state may be owed perhaps $1 billion in overcharges, but said that could be offset by money the generators are owed for the power they sold into the state. California officials believe generators owe about $4 billion in refunds using the June 19 order that Wagner adopted as his benchmark, even given Wagner's determination that the commission can only consider overcharges after Oct. 2. At one point during negotiations, Wagner told California officials he thought an appropriate settlement should top $4.5 billion, according to one negotiator who spoke on condition he not be named. Wagner suggested generators could pay $2.5 billion in cash and $2 billion in long-term electricity contracts at cheaper rates, the source said. That was very different from the $670 million in refunds Wagner privately said generators were offering. For instance, the source said, while Reliant Energy on Monday offered $50 million in refunds, California believes Reliant's share of overcharges is closer to $1 billion. Jan Smutny-Jones, executive director of the Independent Energy Producers, applauded the possibility that some generators will settle with the state without waiting for a FERC decision and likely protracted court battle. "We need to solve this problem and move on," Smutny-Jones said. ?? ) Associated Press writer Mark Sherman contributed to this story from Washington, D.C. Judge refuses to let ratepayers form official committee in utility bankruptcy case ASSOCIATED PRESS July 10, 2001 SAN FRANCISCO ) The federal judge overseeing Pacific Gas and Electric Co.'s bankruptcy case ruled Tuesday the utility's ratepayers cannot form an official committee to represent their interests. Ratepayer advocates had sought such recognition to ensure the utility would not raise rates further as a way of paying off its debts. But U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Dennis Montali agreed with PG&E and the official creditors committee and rejected the idea for the second time in two months. Montali suggested instead that ratepayers organize an informal committee to bring their concerns to the court, and said the ratepayers also could bring matters before the state Public Utilities Commission. A separate committee of ratepayers would have been able to vote on the final reorganization of the company, a plan that could affect power service and rates. PG&E filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy April 6, and owes billions of dollars to more than 50,000 creditors. It was brought down, in part, by California's botched experiment with deregulation. Judge Bars Ratepayers Panel From PG&E Case Power: Customers are not creditors in the utility's bankruptcy, ruling says. Action does not preclude refunds for consumers. TIM REITERMAN TIMES STAFF WRITER July 11 2001 SAN FRANCISCO -- A federal judge Tuesday reaffirmed his decision to bar a ratepayers committee from Pacific Gas & Electric Co.'s bankruptcy case and denounced the committee's attorney for suggesting that the action could prevent PG&E customers from receiving refunds for excessive energy charges. Judge Dennis Montali ruled against a U.S. trustee and the ratepayers committee in deciding that ratepayers as a group had no claims and were not creditors when PG&E filed for bankruptcy on April 6. But Montali criticized "misguided remarks" by a committee attorney on July 5 and news media accounts that followed the hearing. The judge said the reports left the misconception that by disallowing a ratepayers committee, he would reject all claims of ratepayers and they could lose out on future refunds. The judge and PG&E officials emphasized that there are no matters involving PG&E customer refunds before the state Public Utilities Commission. State officials are seeking about $9 billion in refunds, however, from the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission for alleged overcharges to Californians by energy companies since last year. The distribution of any ratepayer refunds would be decided by the PUC, and customers would be paid whether or not they filed Bankruptcy Court claims by a Sept. 5 deadline, the judge and PG&E attorneys said. The judge took the highly unusual step of directing PG&E and U.S. Trustee Linda Ekstrom Stanley to consider remedies to allay any confusion among PG&E's 5.5 million customers. He suggested publishing clarifications in newspapers that carried the erroneous information, in PG&E customer bills and on Web sites. Stanley had formed a ratepayers committee of business, government and consumer representatives, saying they will be affected by PG&E's Chapter 11 reorganization. But Montali decided that ratepayers do not qualify as creditors under bankruptcy law and are not entitled to official status that allows them to participate in the bankruptcy and receive funding from PG&E. Stanley said she has not yet decided whether to appeal the ruling to federal district court. Copyright 2001, Los Angeles Times Developments in California's energy crisis The Associated Press Wednesday, July 11, 2001 ,2001 Associated Press URL: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/news/archive/2001/07/11/state1 036EDT0129.DTL (07-11) 07:36 PDT (AP) -- Developments in California's energy crisis: WEDNESDAY= * No power alerts Wednesday as electricity reserves stay above 7 percent. TUESDAY= * U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Dennis Montali again agreed with PG&E and the official creditors committee, saying such a committee of Pacific Gas and Electric Co. ratepayers has no legal standing in bankruptcy court. Ratepayer advocates had sought the recognition to ensure the utility would not raise rates further as a way of paying off its debts. * PG&E has agreed to pay $4.1 million in tax penalties to 49 counties where the utility owns property. The utility already paid $41.2 million in overdue property taxes in May -- the additional amount covers a 10 percent fee for paying those taxes late. * Calpine Corporation says it is near agreement with California officials over money the state says the company overcharged for electricity. That would make it the first company to settle a portion of the $8.9 billion dollars the state is seeking in proceedings before the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission. But the San Jose-based company is offering much less than the $236 million dollars the state claims it is owed. * No power alerts Tuesday as electricity reserves stay above 7 percent. * Shares of Edison International closed at $14.05, up 5 cents. PG&E Corp. drop 55 cents to close at $13.55. Sempra Energy, the parent company of San Diego Gas & Electric Co., closed at $27.67, up 15 cents. WHAT'S NEXT= * The Senate committee investigating possible price manipulation in California's energy market meets Wednesday. The committee will vote on contempt citations against generators Mirant and Enron, which failed to comply with subpoenas for documents. The committee will meet again July 18 to consider compliance by six other suppliers that have until Tuesday to turn over documents. THE PROBLEM: High demand, high wholesale energy costs, transmission glitches and a tight supply worsened by scarce hydroelectric power in the Northwest and maintenance at aging California power plants are all factors in California's electricity crisis. Southern California Edison and Pacific Gas and Electric say they've lost nearly $14 billion since June 2000 to high wholesale prices the state's electricity deregulation law bars them from passing on to consumers. PG&E, saying it hasn't received the help it needs from regulators or state lawmakers, filed for federal bankruptcy protection April 6. Electricity and natural gas suppliers, scared off by the companies' poor credit ratings, are refusing to sell to them, leading the state in January to start buying power for the utilities' nearly 9 million residential and business customers. The state is also buying power for a third investor-owned utility, San Diego Gas & Electric, which is in better financial shape than much larger Edison and PG&E but is also struggling with high wholesale power costs. The Public Utilities Commission has approved average rate increases of 37 percent for the heaviest residential customers and 38 percent for commercial customers, and hikes of up to 49 percent for industrial customers and 15 percent or 20 percent for agricultural customers to help finance the state's multibillion-dollar power buys. Track the state's blackout warnings on the Web at www.caiso.com/SystemStatus.html. ,2001 Associated Press ? Enron Corp. sues to block Senate from forcing document release DON THOMPSON, Associated Press Writer Wednesday, July 11, 2001 ,2001 Associated Press URL: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/news/archive/2001/07/11/state1 212EDT0141.DTL (07-11) 09:12 PDT SACRAMENTO (AP) -- Enron Corp. is suing state officials to stop a Senate subpoena of its financial records in a dispute over alleged overcharges for its electricity sales to California. "They've sent two things to Texas -- our money and these documents, and they saying we can't get either one back," said Laurence Drivon, special legal counsel to the Senate Select Committee to Investigate Market Manipulation. The suit came hours before the committee will consider asking the full Senate to cite the Houston-based company for contempt Wednesday. The other subject of possible sanctions, Atlanta-based Mirant Inc., appears to be cooperating, Drivon said. Committee chairman Joe Dunn, a Santa Ana Democrat, said the committee's investigation will continue despite Enron's "pure act of intimidation. We're not going to back down." Enron's suit said the company's financial papers are outside the committee's jurisdiction because most of its operations and paperwork are outside California. That shouldn't matter, Drivon said, citing last year's successful of out-of-state documents during the investigation into the activities of former Insurance Commissioner Chuck Quackenbush. Previous investigations have included documents subpoenaed from other nations, he said. Companies doing business in California cannot claim immunity from its laws or oversight, Drivon and Dunn said. Houston-based Reliant Energy made the same argument but then agreed to turn over 1,800 documents. ,2001 Associated Press ? Governor threatens to sue utilities for refunds Davis says California won't settle for $1 billion Mark Martin, Chronicle Staff Writer Wednesday, July 11, 2001 ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle URL: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/chronicle/archive/2001/07/11/M N139275.DTL Sacramento -- One day after a federal judge rebuked California's claim that energy generators owe the state $8.9 billion, Gov. Gray Davis all but vowed to sue the companies to recoup the money. "If you think California will settle for $1 billion in refunds, we'll see you in court," Davis said yesterday. Continuing his heated rhetoric on the energy crisis, Davis blasted the energy companies for being inflexible during a 14-day negotiation session in Washington, D.C., that ended Monday. Both the state and power generators argue each is owed money as a result of California's dysfunctional electricity market. Federal Energy Regulatory Commission chief administrative law Judge Curtis L. Wagner ended the talks by saying the state was owed far less than it claimed, but the FERC's governing board will make a final decision on who owes what to whom in the coming months. Yesterday, Davis made it clear he wouldn't accept a FERC decision that strayed far from the state's calculations that power companies overcharged California nearly $9 billion. "The ball is in the FERC's court," he said. "They must step up and provide the refunds we've asked for." While Davis said California officials had gone to Washington prepared to discuss ways to reach a settlement, including renegotiating long-term contracts to buy power, an energy industry official faulted the state for its unwillingness to compromise. Generators put forward an offer even though they believe no refunds are owed, said Jan Smutny-Jones, executive director of the Independent Energy Producers. Smutny-Jones said the state needed to stop thinking it would get the $8.9 billion. "It's clear from the way the issue was characterized by the judge that $9 billion is not something the state is going to see any time in the near future, " he added. "It is not based in reality." Davis also took heat from Republicans yesterday. "He desperately needs that refund, so he can renegotiate the dreadful contracts he has entered into," said Rob Stutzman, a consultant for the California Republican Party. "He's sitting at the poker table with very few chips." In other energy news yesterday, a judge refused to let a committee represent the public in the Pacific Gas & Electric Co. bankruptcy case and said a consumer lawyer's "irresponsible position" at a hearing last week could mislead PG&E customers into filing needless refund claims with the court. U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Dennis Montali said any refunds owed to customers were unrelated to the bankruptcy case and would be determined by regulators. At the hearing Thursday, attorney KaarenThomas argued that unless a committee represented customers' interests, PG&E could try to bar all refund claims that weren't filed by Sept. 5. Montali ruled in May that the committee was not authorized by federal bankruptcy law, and reaffirmed his ruling yesterday. Chronicle staff writers Lynda Gledhill and Robert Egelko contributed to this report. E-mail Mark Martin at markmartin@sfchronicle.com. ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle ? Page?A - 3 News briefs on the California power crisis The Associated Press Wednesday, July 11, 2001 ,2001 Associated Press URL: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/news/archive/2001/07/11/state0 738EDT0118.DTL (07-11) 04:38 PDT SAN JOSE, Calif. (AP) -- Energy supplier Calpine Corp. has reached a deal to purchase 236 billion cubic feet of natural gas in Texas and New Mexico for $355 million plus assumption of nearly $50 million of debt. Company officials made the announcement Tuesday and said the purchase will increase its natural gas reserves. "This transaction meets our desire to own and operate production in a strategic basin," said Cathy Piece, Calpine's director of land and acquisitions. "These assets significantly strengthen our reserve base and will help fuel our growing Western power program." The San Jose-based company has agreed to purchase 35 wells in New Mexico that produce 6 million cubic feet of gas per day from The Bayless Companies. The second transaction involves the acquisition of a majority interest of Michael Petroleum of Houston. The Texas company produces about 43 million cubic feet of gas per day. Calpine officials said the agreements will allow them to meet their future capacity demands for both natural gas and electricity. The company wants to generate more than 70,000 megawatts of electricity by the end of 2005 and have natural gas reserves of 6.7 trillion cubic feet. LOS ANGELES (AP) -- Newly elected Mayor James Hahn has postponed selling the city's surplus power to the state so he can examine how it will impact ratepayers. Hahn's predecessor, Richard Riordan, said last month the city's Department of Water and Power would sell its extra electricity -- about 500 megawatts a day_ to the state at cost between July and September. The contract was supposed to have been signed last week. Steve Maviglio, a spokesman for Gov. Gray Davis, said Tuesday that the state is ready to sign the contract. "We're ready to sign," he said. "Like most negotiations that aren't final, things go back and forth. The new (Hahn) administration wants to review the document before it." Davis had threatened to seize surplus power from municipal utilities, which haven't been subjected to the California energy crisis, because he claimed they were gouging the state. TEMECULA, Calif. (AP) -- State officials said they are studying alternative routes for a power transmission line proposed by San Diego Gas and Electric Co. The utility wants to run a 500,000-volt power line through southwestern Riverside County connecting its power grid with Southern California Edison's. The cost of the project is estimated at $271 million and must be approved by the state's Public Utilities Commission. But state officials listed alternative routes in papers released at a public hearing Tuesday. Some of the other ideas include putting the transmission line around the edges of an Indian reservation or running a route through the Cleveland National Forest. Once a final selection is made, the information will be given to PUC commissioners who will either approve or deny the project. Many residents who live in the path of the proposed transmission line don't want the project. An attorney representing several groups that oppose SDG&E's plans said there was no mention of alternative routes in environmental documents submitted by the company. "Looking at the various route segments offered by SDG&E as alternatives is like trying to arrange the deck chairs on the Titanic," said attorney Mark Mihaly. ,2001 Associated Press ? White House bends under energy conservation pressure Posted at 6:25 a.m. PDT Wednesday, July 11, 2001 BY H. JOSEF HEBERT Associated Press Writer WASHINGTON (AP) -- Under pressure to include more conservation measures that reduce energy use, congressional Republicans are moving toward a compromise to increase fuel efficiency requirements for sport utility vehicles as part of an energy package. Key House GOP lawmakers said Tuesday they expect some increase in fuel economy requirements, especially for SUVs, in energy legislation working its way through the House. Democrats, who have a majority in the Senate, also favor requiring improved motor vehicle fuel efficiency. At the same time, the Bush administration signaled its willingness Tuesday to begin a rule-changing process that would allow the first increase in 25 years in the federal corporate automobile fuel economy, or CAFE, standard. Transportation Secretary Norman Mineta asked Congress to lift immediately a six-year prohibition that bans the department from consideration of fuel economy increases. Lawmakers already agreed this year not to extend the ban beyond September, but Mineta said he wants to start examining possible changes right away. CAFE standards, which mandate fuel economy requirements for vehicle fleets, have not been increased since their introduction in 1975. That year's law, spurred by energy shortages in the early 1970s, required passengers cars to meet a fleet average of at least 27.5 miles per gallon. Light trucks -- a category that includes SUVs, vans and pickups -- have to meet a 20.7 mpg fleet average. With the widespread popularity of SUVs and vans in recent years, many environmentalists have argued that the lower truck standard has compromised the intent of the 1975 law. SUVs and vans comprise more than 40 percent of the passenger vehicles on the road today. As three committees began crafting energy legislation, lawmakers were searching for a bipartisan compromise to increase fuel economy requirements for motor vehicles. Some increase in the CAFE requirement was virtually assured, several GOP lawmakers said, although disagreements remain on how much of an increase, whether it should apply to automobiles as well as SUVs, vans and small trucks, and the timetable for phasing in new requirements. Energy legislation that the House Energy and Commerce Committee was taking up later Wednesday contains no fuel economy provision. But Rep. Billy Tauzin, R-La., the committee chairman, said discussions were under way to work out a compromise on a fuel economy proposal. He said he expects an amendment on CAFE to be added to the bill, either during deliberations in his committee or on the House floor. Rep. Joe Barton, R-Texas, chairman of the subcommittee drafting the energy package, saw a good chance the truck standards will be raised and said the automobile standard might be increased as well. Other GOP sources who talked about the private discussions on condition of not being identified by name said a likely outcome is that the truck standard will be increased three or four mpg and the auto standard left alone. Momentum for some CAFE increase has been growing in recent weeks as GOP lawmakers came under increasing pressure to come up with additional conservation proposals to those proposed in the White House's energy policy. It largely focuses on production, with few specific measures to dramatically curb energy demand. Democrats have pressed for tougher automobile fuel economy standards. Automakers have fought attempts to increase the standards. They say such government edicts limit consumer choice and force manufacturers to build smaller cars that customers don't want. Supporters of increased fuel economy argue that new technologies are available to increase fuel efficiency without decreasing vehicle size. President Bush's energy blueprint would consider CAFE increases, but not before a National Academy of Sciences report is issued, probably this month, on impact of the standard on energy savings, safety and auto industry competition. Davis ups the voltage Published Wednesday, July 11, 2001, in the San Jose Mercury News Vow to sue for refunds may be a bluff, but he should keep pushing FERC THE strategic choice facing Gov. Gray Davis in the struggle over electricity price refunds has come down to three questions: When do you negotiate, when do you demand, and when do you bluff? Negotiations are over, Davis declared Tuesday. He demanded that the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission order refunds now. ``The case is nearly a year old,'' he said. ``They have to decide which side they're on.'' Probably no one but Davis knew to what extent he was bluffing when he also said, ``If you think California is going to settle for $1 billion in refunds, we will see you in court.'' A FERC administrative judge said Monday that the amount due the state may be around $1 billion, or perhaps nothing at all, when counter-claims against the state are subtracted. Energy experts are divided about whether the state would win a suit to overturn a decision by a federal commission. The federal courts have some limited jurisdiction, according to University of California Energy Institute director Severin Borenstein, but that a court would reverse a commission in a case like this is ``extremely unlikely.'' Frank Wolak, a Stanford economist, had the opposite view, when asked whether the state has a good chance of winning: ``I think so. It happens all the time.'' At a Sacramento press conference, Davis continued to insist that there have been overcharges of $8.9 billion. But other state officials conceded that only $5.4 billion of that is actually on the table in the FERC proceedings. Davis said he'll take what he can get there, and sue for the rest. The state argues that because FERC has determined that wholesale prices have not met the Federal Power Act's requirement to be ``just and reasonable,'' refunds are in order. But the commission has not defined what portion exceeded ``just and reasonable.'' Throughout his press conference, Davis used the prospect of litigation like a goad to spur the federal regulators into action. But if you listened carefully, he also indicated he'll give them more time to consider the case. Considering the iffy odds of winning in court, we suggest he keep goading the federal commissioners -- while giving them all the time they need. Wednesday, July 11, 2001 Lights go out on Davis' power show Three new developments show that some economic reality finally is being applied to California's electricity crisis: First, "The nation's chief energy judge said Monday that California is owed maybe $1 billion in refunds from power generators, a fraction of the $8.9 billion demanded by Gov. Gray Davis," reported the Register yesterday. Even that $1 billion amount might be balanced by the amount the state still owes the power producers. To suggest workable and market-oriented solutions to the California electricity crisis. Judge Curtis Wagner's recommendation will be taken up by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, which is being petitioned for the money by the state of California. Because the judge's words will bolster FERC's apparent desire not to grant the "refunds," the state probably will go to court, where the matter could be stuck for years. "In the long term, this may indicate that competitive electricity has a future even in California, but not thanks to the state," Robert Michaels, a professor of economics at Cal State Fullerton, told us. He's referring to the state's botched 1996 "deregulation" effort, which has been made worse by Gov. Gray Davis and other officials since the crisis began a year ago. "FERC since the 1980s favors competition, within the parameters of political reality," Mr. Michaels added. "Now we're at square one: The industry doesn't owe $9 billion to California." As this process continues, he said, another positive aspect will be that a lot of facts will get aired. "We'll see what has been happening in the markets" in which power is bought and sold. Second, light already is shining on one area: This crisis was not "Made in Texas'' by cronies of President Bush, as Gov. Davis and other Democrats have been contending. In May, the governor attacked the president for ignoring "the greed of these Texas energy companies," such as Reliant and Dynergy. In fact, according to information on state power contracts the governor finally released Monday, Texas companies were way down on the list of producers. "In roughly the first five months of the year, the state shelled out $1.2 billion to Atlanta-based Mirant, the most any company was paid for electricity, followed by $1 billion to Powerex, the marketing arm of BC Hydro in British Columbia [in Canada]. It also paid $331 million to the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power," reported the San Jose Mercury News. Only about 10 percent of our state's power during this period came from companies with headquarters in Texas. Third, and finally, a new study by the Cato Institute shows what should be done next: lAbolish retail rate caps, allowing prices to be set by the market. This would be a better system than the present one, where the state buys the electricity and passes much of the cost along through the state budget (paid by taxpayers) and bonds paid for by long-term electricity price increases. Higher immediate prices would encourage conservation and production, leading in time to lower prices. lMove to real-time pricing so people shift activities such as washing to off-peak hours. lAbolish the Independent System Operator, which moves electrons around. Give this function back to the utilities, who did it far better before "deregulation." Gov. Davis should set the pace by ending his Clintonian blame shifting and embracing these realistic solutions.