12 Jul 2001, 11:24 UTC
Energy Issues
- From
- Miyung Buster miyung.buster@enron.com
- To
-
Joseph Alamo, Bev Hansen, Rob Bradley, Tom Briggs, Michael R Brown, Janet Butler, Stella Chan, Alan Comnes, Shelley Corman, Jeff Dasovich, Larry Decker, Karen Denne
and 53 more
Marcus Dotson, filuntz@aol.com, Markus Fiala, Lamar Frazier, Janel Guerrero, Joe Hartsoe, Hedy Govenar, Chris Holmes, shirley.hudler@enron.com, Evan Hughes, jkradin@marathon-com.com, Steven J Kean, Ken Smith, amy.kim@enron.com, Kurt Lindahl, Elizabeth Linnell, Laura Ipsen, Chris Long, Peggy Mahoney, Jeannie Mandelker, Susan J Mara, Luiz Maurer, Karen Moore, andrew.morrison@enron.com, Carin Nersesian, John Neslage, Robert Neustaedter, Nick O'day, Mark Palmer, Alex Parsons, Mona L Petrochko, Melinda Pharms, rlichtenstein@marathon-com.com, Ralph Reed, mike.roan@enron.com, Linda Robertson, Ann M Schmidt, Mary Schoen, Mark Schroeder, Scott Govenar, Bryan Seyfried, Richard Shapiro, Ban Sharma, John Shelk, John Sherriff, Pat Shortridge, Roberta Staehlin, James D Steffes, Peter Styles, Kathleen Sullivan, Lora Sullivan, Sandra Yamane, Jennifer Thome - Bcc
- Angela Wilson, Lysa Tracy
- Date
- Thu, 12 Jul 2001 04:24:00 -0700 (PDT)
Please see the following articles: Sac Bee, Thurs, 7/12: Enron files suit in contempt bid Sac Bee, Thurs, 7/12: Davis' refund plan faces a tough road: Several experts say it's unlikely the FERC will buy the state's figures Sac Bee, Thurs, 7/12: Energy Digtest: UC, CSU, Enron extend contract Sac Bee, Thurs, 7/12: Energy consultants failed to file disclosures, Jones says Sac Bee, Thurs, 7/12: Fudging at FERC: Feds must define 'just' energy charges (Editorial) SD Union, Thurs, 7/12: Big customers want to shop around -- and there's the rub SD Union, Thurs, 7/12: Senate panel, energy firm fighting tough SD Union, Thurs, 7/12: Energy firm scraps plans for plant in Chula Vista SD Union, Thurs, 7/12: Governor tells FERC to be fair and then some SD Union, Thurs, 7/12: Enron Corp. sues to block Senate from forcing document release SD Union, Thurs, 7/12: Regulators want broad, regional power markets LA Times, Thurs, 7/12: Huntington Loses Battle on Generators LA Times, Thurs, 7/12: Enron Gets 2nd Chance to Turn Over Documents SF Chron, Thurs, 7/12: Coal futures to begin trading but analysts aren't sure it'll heat up energy markets SF Chron, Thurs, 7/12: Developments in California's energy crisis SF Chron, Thurs, 7/12: Enron files suit over subpoena Provider challenges move for documents SF Chron, Thurs, 7/12: PUC cancels vote to drop voltage levels PG&E tells commission its electric distribution system is already operating at minimal power SF Chron, Thurs, 7/12: Power regulators hold off on energy-savings plan SF Chron, Thurs, 7/12: Regulators order utilities to form regional systems Giant step toward national deregulation SF Chron, Thurs, 7/12: Universities, Enron cut deal on electricity Prices 5% below limited rate Mercury News, Thurs, 7/12: Voltage cut won't work, PG&E warns Mercury News, Thurs, 7/12: Energy dispute goes to court Individual.com (AP), Thurs, 7/12: Regulators Look to Develop Markets Chicago Tribune, Thurs, 7/12: For now, electricity crisis has dimmed WSJ, Thurs, 7/12: Regulators Order Formation of Big Grids To Optimize the Flow of Electricity in U.S. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ----- Enron files suit in contempt bid By Emily Bazar Bee Capitol Bureau (Published July 12, 2001) State legislators pressed forward with contempt findings against Enron Corp. on Wednesday after the company failed to produce subpoenaed documents and filed a lawsuit asking the court to intervene on its behalf. Lawmakers on a special Senate committee investigating electricity price manipulation warned that the voluminous lawsuit, filed in Sacramento Superior Court, could have far-reaching implications for the Legislature's ability to conduct investigations and make findings. A few even suggested the legal action could trigger "a constitutional crisis" that could end up in the California or U.S. supreme court. "You are treading into the territory of asking a court to make judgment on the rules and the law governing the rights of the Legislature," said state Sen. Steve Peace, D-El Cajon. "It is a separation of powers issue of the highest order." Representatives from Enron, a power marketer based in Houston, said they are merely concerned that the committee has violated their due process rights. Enron and another company, Mirant, were initially found in contempt by the committee June 28 for refusing to turn over thousands of pages of documents that had been subpoenaed June 11. But the committee offered the companies a reprieve. If they complied with the subpoenas, signed confidentiality agreements and set up a document depository in Sacramento by Tuesday, the contempt findings would be expunged. Committee attorney Laurence Drivon reported at the hearing that Mirant had complied with the requirements, and had set up a document depository in the U.S. Bank building downtown. Mirant spokesman Patrick Dorinson said 159,000 pages of documents had been turned over in 44 boxes as of Wednesday morning. As a result, the panel voted to purge the contempt findings against Mirant, but said it would review the company's compliance again in about 30 days. Enron, however, did not turn over any documents or sign a confidentiality agreement since the last hearing, Drivon said, and negotiations yielded little progress. On a 6-0 vote, the panel agreed to move forward with contempt proceedings against Enron. As early as next week, the committee will forward a report to the Senate, which will vote on the contempt findings and levy punishments that could range from jail time for company officials to steep fines. The panel said Enron could still purge the contempt findings if it complies with the subpoena before the report is forwarded. But company officials fired back at the committee, accusing members of unfairly singling out Enron and treating it differently from other energy companies. "It is exceedingly difficult to discern whether the committee's actions are designed to uncover the facts underlying the price spikes in California's wholesale electric power market, or to create a convenient political scapegoat to shoulder the blame for California's policy mistakes," one official wrote to the committee. All along, Enron officials have said they have several objections to the committee's process. They believe the panel is violating the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission's jurisdiction in its investigation; that it isn't entitled to documents that are stored outside California; and that it doesn't have the right to the confidential information and trade secrets in the documents. They also argue that their due process rights have been violated because they received no response to their written objections to the subpoena before the June 28 contempt vote. The committee chairman, Sen. Joe Dunn, D-Santa Ana, overruled most of their objections Wednesday. However, Enron officials argued it's unfair for a committee member to rule on their objections. "It is a foregone conclusion that the objections are going to be overruled," Enron lawyer Michael Kirby said at the hearing. Officials believe an impartial third party should determine the merits of their concerns, which was a primary reason the company filed the lawsuit, said Enron spokeswoman Karen Denne. In the lawsuit, Enron seeks a court injunction to end contempt proceedings until the company's objections "have been duly considered and ruled upon by an impartial hearing officer." But Dunn said the Legislature's investigations are different from court inquiries, and so are its procedures. "The same due process concerns applicable to a court proceeding are not equally applicable to an investigation by the Legislature," he said. He denied the committee had singled out Enron, and said he believes Enron's lawsuit is really asking the court to force the Legislature to end its investigation. The committee is scheduled to consider contempt findings against other power companies next week. "Enron (has) raised, potentially, a constitutional crisis with this litigation," Dunn said. Constitutional scholar Clark Kelso said legislators clamoring about a constitutional crisis may be exaggerating. But Kelso, a professor at McGeorge School of Law in Sacramento, believes the suit should be dismissed because it is premature. He said the contempt process is still under way in the Capitol, and has yet to be acted upon by the Senate. Reacting to Enron's claims that an impartial third party should hear its objections, Kelso also disagreed. "A court is not going to hold a Senate committee to the same standard of impartiality it would hold a judge to," he said. The Bee's Emily Bazar can be reached at (916) 326-5540 or ebazar@sacbee.com <mailto:ebazar@sacbee.com>. Davis' refund plan faces a tough road: Several experts say it's unlikely the FERC will buy the state's figures. By Dale Kasler Bee Staff Writer (Published July 12, 2001) Gov. Gray Davis' defiant "see you in court" broadside to federal regulators this week demonstrates that it's unlikely the regulators will deliver the multibillion-dollar refund from wholesale power generators that Davis is demanding. Davis' team limped out of Washington empty-handed Monday, concluding two weeks of fruitless refund negotiations with generators. Instead of the $8.9 billion he wanted, Davis got a $716 million offer from generators -- and a conclusion by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission judge who oversaw the talks that California isn't entitled to anything near $8.9 billion in refunds. Judge Curtis Wagner plans to recommend that FERC hold a full hearing on the state's refund claims but said he doubts the refunds would amount to more than $1 billion. That sum is so small that Wagner said the refunds would be canceled out by the unpaid debts owed to the generators. State officials proclaimed the talks a victory of sorts. The governor's chief negotiator, Michael Kahn, said "our positions were vindicated" because generators for the first time put refund dollars on the table. The governor says generators and marketers, in violation of a federal law setting a "just and reasonable" limit on wholesale electricity prices, have routinely overcharged California, plunging the state into a crisis that's bankrupted Pacific Gas and Electric Co. and could do the same to Southern California Edison. Insisting they've done nothing wrong, generators and marketers said they offered the refunds simply to put the matter behind them. "It was to get rid of the litigation and investigations -- they're a huge drag," said Enron Corp. spokesman Mark Palmer. He wouldn't say how much the Houston-based marketer had offered. Palmer and several experts said the state faces an uphill battle convincing FERC that California is entitled to the mega-refund Davis wants. FERC, which will make the final call on refunds, probably believes it's helped California already by imposing price controls on wholesale electricity, and may not be inclined to order huge refunds, said Larry Foster, editor of the Washington newsletter Inside FERC. "At some point the commission might say, 'We've done all we can do (for California), and if you don't like it, go to court,' which is what the state is going to do anyway," Foster said. The governor said Tuesday that he will sue FERC if it fails to order $8.9 billion in refunds. "You order what you think is fair," he said. "We'll take what you order, and we'll see you in court." Undaunted by the threat, generators and marketers were chortling over remarks by Wagner, who wrapped up the failed settlement talks by saying refunds probably wouldn't top $1 billion. Californians "got hammered" by Wagner, said Enron's Palmer. "The judge told them, 'Look, your claim is bogus.'" Wagner has retreated somewhat from his statement, telling the San Jose Mercury News that he isn't sure what the final numbers would be. Sources have said that at one point in the talks, he suggested a $4.5 billion refund -- including $2 billion in cash and $2 billion in discounts on long-term power contracts. But it wasn't clear how seriously anyone took that proposal, and as the talks wound down the judge was clearly dismissive of the state's insistence on getting $8.9 billion. Experts say FERC probably will hold the formal hearing and employ a formula Wagner recommended for calculating the refunds -- a formula that spells good and bad news for both sides. For one thing, Wagner will likely urge a formula based on the price-control system FERC implemented last month -- something that could work to California's advantage. The controls limit prices to a ceiling based on the production costs of the least-efficient power generator in California. But Wagner's plan would calculate production costs differently than FERC has so far. He would employ a system that's significantly more favorable to the generators, said John Stout, senior vice president with power generator Reliant Energy Inc. Also, Wagner would ignore alleged overcharges prior to last October. That alone could wipe out about $2.9 billion in potential refunds, according to the Independent System Operator, which runs California's power grid. Suppliers say a full accounting of costs, particularly the skyrocketing natural gas expenses, will show the prices they charged were fair. "The more days of testimony you have, the stronger Wagner's case becomes, the weaker-looking Davis' case becomes," said Enron's Palmer. Nonetheless, California officials said a hearing could produce a refund in excess of $1 billion. "Any reasonable calculation is going to give you a much higher number than that," said Severin Borenstein of the University of California Energy Institute. The Bee's Dale Kasler can be reached at (916) 321-1066 or dkasler@sacbee.com <mailto:dkasler@sacbee.com>. Energy Digtest: UC, CSU, Enron extend contract By Claire Cooper Bee Legal Affairs Writer (Published July 12, 2001) SAN FRANCISCO -- A truce was declared Wednesday in a legal dispute between California's largest electricity user -- its university systems -- and Enron Energy Services. Both sides agreed "in principle" to extend their four-year contract by two years, until March 2004. They have until Dec. 1 to negotiate a price and other terms. Early this year the Texas-based energy giant, which had been selling discounted power directly to the University of California and California State University, switched more than 24 campuses covered by the contract to shaky public utilities, subjecting them to potential blackouts and price hikes. A federal judge ruled that Enron probably had violated the contract and ordered the company to resume deliveries. But the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals issued a stay and set the case for review. Energy consultants failed to file disclosures, Jones says By Amy Chance Bee Political Editor (Published July 12, 2001) The Davis administration failed to abide by state ethics laws as it hired 45 outside consultants to help the state cope with the electricity crisis, Secretary of State Bill Jones charged Wednesday. While such consultants are required to file statements of economic interests -- reports of outside income that might represent a financial conflict with their responsibilities for the state -- Jones said a check by his aides Monday found that none of them had filed the documents. Although the administration began hiring consultants in January, Jones aides said they were told that the state Department of Water Resources -- which has handled the state's electricity-buying efforts -- only recently became aware that the reports were necessary. Jones released a copy of a June 15 memo in which the department notified energy contractors that they were required to file the statement and disqualify themselves from decisions that could affect their financial interests. The memo was written one day after Jones demanded that two of Gov. Gray Davis' consultants, Chris Lehane and Mark Fabiani, file conflict-of-interest forms. "It's a sad commentary when an administration only decides to comply with ethics and anti-corruption laws after their violations have been exposed," Jones, a Republican who wants to challenge Democrat Davis for governor next year, said at a Capitol news conference. "I am also deeply concerned that when filed, the statements of economic interests will show that a number of consultants have illegally engaged in policy discussions and decisions that affect their personal finances." Davis press secretary Steven Maviglio said Wednesday that all consultants required to file the statement had done so or would do so within the required 30-day time period. But he was unable to produce any of the statements, saying they would first have to be reviewed to remove home addresses and other personal information. Information provided by the state Fair Political Practices Commission on its Web site states that the forms are public records that state agencies must make available for "public inspection or reproduction during regular business hours no later than the second business day after they are received." Jones called on state Attorney General Bill Lockyer to investigate what he called the administration's "blatant disregard for the state's full-disclosure and conflict-of-interest laws." A Lockyer spokeswoman said the attorney general would consider the request. Maviglio noted that the statements, which fall under the purview of the FPPC, are not Jones' responsibility as secretary of state. He said Jones is "on a witch hunt on something outside his jurisdiction." Jones said if consultants involved in negotiating billions of dollars worth of contracts with electricity generators had financial conflicts, the public has a right to know. "The governor's insistence on secrecy throughout the energy crisis has prompted increased public cynicism of their government," Jones said. "Unfortunately, it appears that the cynicism is justifiable in this case." The Bee's Amy Chance can be reached at (916) 326-5535 or achance@sacbee.com <mailto:achance@sacbee.com>. Fudging at FERC: Feds must define 'just' energy charges (Published July 12, 2001) The economists say that some of the record-high electricity prices that have plagued California in the past 14 months are the result of generators and traders exploiting flaws in a dysfunctional market to exert market power over prices. The problem is that federal regulators have been slow to wake up to reality and exert some power of their own to enforce the law. The Federal Power Act is supposed to protect the public by keeping prices for electricity "just" and "reasonable." With price limitations now in place going into the future, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission has done only half of its job. Now it must do the other half by reviewing and remedying the abuses of the past. Gov. Gray Davis estimates that generators have overcharged California to the tune of about $9 billion. Generators and traders, on the other hand, have suggested refunding something less than $1 billion. Efforts at a settlement have gone nowhere. So now FERC must settle the score, even if it means a trial-like proceeding that puts the last year under a microscope, one questionable transaction at a time. While much of the political focus has been on price, the job of the regulators is to consider both price and circumstance. An unjust transaction is born out of broken market conditions, when the buyer has little choice but to accept the price of seller who can move the market by his own actions. When the price exceeds by many multiples the actual cost to produce power, there is compelling reason to look for gouging. Undoubtedly, there were times over the last year when generators and traders weren't gouging California, as evidenced by records of some transaction recently released by the state. During the winter when the price of natural gas (the state's primary fuel for electricity) was high, there's a reasonable explanation for high power prices. Yet last fall and last summer, when natural gas was cheaper yet electricity was outrageously expensive, there's reason to doubt that the market was working reasonably. Reviewing the prices charged in the last year is a test case for FERC, one that it has sought to avoid. It requires FERC to concede that it was not on alert as California ventured into the uncharted world of deregulation. Yet the future of electricity competition in California, and perhaps the nation, depends on the federal government showing that it is able and willing to do its duty to protect the public from unfair market conditions. Settling this score also affects the math of potential deals to put Pacific Gas and Electric and Southern California Edison back on their feet. The refund that Californians are owed is likely somewhere between those $1 billion and $9 billion estimates. It's time for FERC to go find out the right amount. Big customers want to shop around -- and there's the rub \ objattph State energy contracts must be paid off by users in system By Ed Mendel UNION-TRIBUNE STAFF WRITER July 12, 2001 SACRAMENTO -- California businesses are being hit by big electricity rate increases, some as high as 100 percent, and they would like to be able to shop around for cheaper power. But state regulators are poised to ban customer choice, or "direct access" as it has come to be called, because they want to make sure that enough customers remain with utilities to pay for state power purchases. After a month of closed-door talks, the revelation that the state has signed $43 billion worth of long-term power contracts at above-market prices helped scuttle an attempt to work out a compromise in the Assembly. "If the intent of the big customers is to leave the small customers paying for those contracts, we are going to fight like hell," said Lenny Goldberg, a lobbyist for The Utility Reform Network. Jack Stewart, president of the California Manufacturers and Technology Association, said large business users were offering to pay off the back debt of Southern California Edison, estimated at $3.5 billion, in exchange for direct access. "I thought we were making a lot of progress until the information on the contracts came out," Stewart said. "We really don't have a way of dealing with those contracts." Now Stewart is suggesting that direct access be slowly phased in over a period of years and that the long-term power contracts be renegotiated, perhaps with some being switched from the state to big-business users. The manufacturers association and the California Chamber of Commerce helped organize a business coalition, Californians for Energy Action, that wants a cheaper alternative to power purchased for utility customers by the state. "Many large and small California businesses have seen their electric bills double," says a newspaper ad being run by the coalition this week. "These cost increases are a burden that will cause consumer prices to increase, some businesses to fail and jobs to be lost." A rate increase approved by the state Public Utilities Commission for PG&E and Edison customers in May fell heaviest on business users. The PUC said that the average residential increase was about 50 percent, while the average business increase was about 75 percent. Legislation that authorized the state to begin buying power in January for the utilities, who were crippled by a failed deregulation plan, bars rate increases for residential customers who use up to 130 percent of the baseline, the minimal amount deemed necessary for a household. Senate President Pro Tempore John Burton, D-San Francisco, and other legislators have argued that large businesses should bear most of the burden of the failed deregulation plan because it was business, not residential consumers, who pushed for deregulation. Alan Zaremberg, president of the California Chamber of Commerce, said that forcing businesses to bear a "disproportionate" rate increase will cost everyone through higher prices for goods and services and possibly a loss of jobs. "If government didn't allow implementation of deregulation in the right manner," Zaremberg said, "then we all have to find a solution. We are all in this together, and that's residential and business alike." The legislation that authorized the state to buy power also directed the PUC to ban direct access power purchases, if the loss of rate revenue from the departing customers would harm the ability to pay off a power bond. The state plans to issue a bond of up to $13.4 billion in September or October to repay the taxpayer-supported state general fund for power purchases. The bond would be paid off by ratepayers over 15 years. Last week, the Senate rejected a bill by Sen. Debra Bowen, D-Marina del Rey, on a 19-12 vote that would have allowed businesses to shop for power if they paid an "exit fee" to protect the bond payments. Business groups said the fee was too large and would not result in lower power costs. "I cannot carry a direct-access bill that makes it harder to sell the bonds or that shifts costs from large users, who leave for cheaper power, to smaller users and residential ratepayers," Bowen said. Burton and Bowen have both criticized Gov. Gray Davis' plan to keep Southern California Edison from joining Pacific Gas and Electric in bankruptcy. They say the plan, which includes the state purchase of the Edison transmission system, is too generous to Edison. Both Burton and Bowen have suggested that an Edison bankruptcy may not be a calamity. But in the Assembly, Speaker Robert Hertzberg, D-Van Nuys, launched a drive for an alternative Edison rescue plan that was based on gaining business support by offering direct access. Hertzberg asked a former Democratic assemblyman, Phil Isenberg of Sacramento, to try to work out an agreement among the various special interest groups: business, labor, consumers and generators. The basic plan considered by the Isenberg group would have left "core" customers -- residences and small businesses -- in a regulated system receiving power at stable prices from the generators and contracts retained by the utilities. Businesses and other large users, the "non-core" customers, would be free to shop around for low-cost power by 2003 if they agreed to help pay off the Edison debt. The Edison rate increase for large users would be limited to 50 percent. The PUC would create a "balancing account" to track costs, issuing a refund if too much was collected or raising rates if revenue fell short. Business and generator groups told Hertzberg last week that they reached agreement on a general framework, with the exception of the state purchase of the Edison transmission system and some other issues. But the consumer and labor representatives opposed the framework. Mike Florio of The Utility Reform Network said in a dissenting statement that an across-the-board allocation of state power costs would be "clearly unfair" and cause residential users to subsidize direct-access customers. Hertzberg said he is considering some of the ideas in the framework presented by the Isenberg group and may make a proposal in a week or two. "We are looking at all the possibilities," Hertzberg said. "We are trying to do some form of direct access within the current contract structure." Senate panel, energy firm fighting tough \ objattph By Bill Ainsworth UNION-TRIBUNE STAFF WRITER July 12, 2001 SACRAMENTO -- A Senate panel moved a step toward holding Enron, an energy trading firm, in contempt for refusing to turn over documents senators hope can shed light on the state's soaring energy prices. Enron fired back by filing a lawsuit yesterday asserting that only the federal government has the authority to investigate the power market. The panel, which had previously reached agreements with all the other major generators and marketing companies in California, voted 6-0 to prepare a contempt recommendation for the Senate to consider next week. The Senate, which last issued a contempt citation in 1929, must approve any contempt recommendation. It then has wide-ranging powers to impose fines or jail time. The chairman of the Senate committee, state Sen. Joe Dunn, D-Laguna Nigel, said that if Enron agrees to turn over documents to the committee soon, then he will recommend that contempt proceedings be dropped. The Senate Select Committee to Investigate Market Manipulation also decided yesterday to drop contempt proceedings against Mirant, an Atlanta-based marketing company, because it had agreed to turn over documents. The dispute also touched on broader issues. Enron, the politically connected Houston-based marketing company, has been pushing electricity deregulation throughout the world. Company chairman Kenneth Lay is a friend and campaign contributor to President Bush. Last month the firm helped sponsor a congressional fund-raiser featuring the president, where contributors in tuxedos and gowns dined and drank around a giant gold "W" that reached to the rafters at the Washington Convention Center ballroom. Enron has also helped shape Bush's energy plan. It is one of several major donors accused of meeting secretly with Vice President Dick Cheney to draft the plan. Several senators on the panel disputed Enron's claim that only federal regulators, and not the state government, could investigate the electricity market. Further, they blasted the company for saying that California could not have access to documents stored outside the state at the firm's Houston headquarters. State Sen. Steve Peace, D-El Cajon, said the company was so defiant that it looked suspicious. "Your client doth protest too much," he said to Enron's attorney, Michael Kirby. "One can only wonder: What do you have to hide?" But Kirby said the company merely wanted to protect confidential information and get answers to its objections. That, he said, is why it filed a lawsuit contesting the committee's power to seek documents that Enron claimed would reveal trade secrets. "We want it to make a ruling and give us our day in court," he said. Peace, however, took issue with the lawsuit, calling it a dramatic escalation in the dispute over an energy crisis that has cost the state billions. "You just declared war on this state's political system," he said. Energy firm scraps plans for plant in Chula Vista \ objattph Ramco says price limits would make it unprofitable By Kristen Green UNION-TRIBUNE STAFF WRITER July 12, 2001 CHULA VISTA -- Controversial plans to build a power plant by Sept. 30 have been dropped, much to the liking of city officials. Ramco Inc. pulled out of the project yesterday, saying that the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission's month-old price limits would prevent it from making money. "We are pleased, whatever the reason," said Michael Meacham, Chula Vista's conservation coordinator. The city opposed construction of the 62.4 megawatt plant on Main Street, and had asked the state to reconsider its June 13 decision. The plant was approved under the governor's 21-day emergency procedure for siting what are known as peaker plants, those that can be used when energy supplies dip dangerously low. The proposal was exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act, and city officials maintained that allowing the plant to be constructed -- the fifth of its kind in the Otay region -- would be an environmental injustice. City officials have been planning an appeal to the state Supreme Court, an action that appeared to be their last recourse. "Our council felt we were doing what was necessary to protect the public health and safety," Meacham said. Meacham said yesterday the council would still file the appeal because Ramco officials could change their mind. They have permission to build the plant as long as they are able to complete construction by Sept. 30. Despite the city's pleas, Ramco had, until now, moved forward with its plans. But Ramco consultant Dale Mesple said company officials recently had a change of heart. They are worried that the California Independent System Operator won't pay them and that FERC's price limits, which established formulas for maximum prices during emergency and non-emergency periods, won't allow them to turn a profit. "There's no reason to run the plant, and no reason to build it," Mesple said. The California Energy Commission received a letter from Ramco yesterday announcing the San Diego company's decision not to build the plant. Spokesman Rob Schlichting said Ramco is the first company to pull out of plans to build a plant under the fast-track system. Nine other peaker plant projects are still on track, including two Ramco is building in Escondido and one in another Chula Vista location. A tenth peaker-plant, a 49.5-megawatt facility in Otay Mesa, was approved yesterday. "The loss of this one peaker plant is not going to be catastrophic," Schlichting said. "It's not going to jeopardize the California grid or anything, but I'm surprised a company would feel this way." Governor tells FERC to be fair and then some \ objattph Davis firm on demand for $8.9 billion refund By Ed Mendel UNION-TRIBUNE STAFF WRITER July 11, 2001 SACRAMENTO -- Gov. Gray Davis had a tough message for federal regulators yesterday after the failure of settlement talks in California's bid to get an $8.9 billion refund from electricity suppliers: "See you in court." The governor said California will seek a full $8.9 billion refund for electricity overcharges, even if federal regulators award the maximum refund of $5.4 billion allowed under their guidelines. "Our message is just order what you are going to order," Davis said of the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission. "We believe you should order $8.9 billion. But you order what you think is fair. We will take what you order, then we will see you in court." Davis, joined by his negotiating team, made the remarks at a news conference a day after two weeks of closed-door talks with suppliers in Washington failed to reach an agreement. An administrative law judge made a recommendation to the regulatory commission that Davis' top negotiator, Michael Kahn, chairman of the California Independent System Operator, expects to result in a refund of more than $1 billion. Davis said that a revealing decision will be made by the commission, which he hopes has embarked on a "new path" with the appointment by President Bush of two new members, Pat Wood of Texas and Nora Brownell of Pennsylvania. "Are they on the side of consumers, as the federal power act envisions them being," Davis asked, "or are they just there to do the industry's bidding, as they have so often in the past?" Kahn said rules adopted by FERC cut off the refund period at last October, trimming $3 billion from the $8.9 billion overcharge claimed by California dating to May 2000. He said FERC has no jurisdiction over municipal utilities, such as the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power, that sold power to the state. The municipal districts overcharged the state by about $600 million, according to Kahn. As a result, he said, the maximum refund that FERC could order for California is about $5.4 billion. "We made it clear to everyone that if we did not settle for $8.9 billion, we would seek redress in court for the remainder of the money above $5.4 billion," Kahn said. Calpine of San Jose and several other generators have expressed interest in the state's offer to negotiate one-on-one with the state while the federal regulators consider their decision, Kahn said. Enron Corp. sues to block Senate from forcing document release \ objattph By Jennifer Coleman ASSOCIATED PRESS July 11, 2001 SACRAMENTO ) A Senate committee investigating possible price gouging in California's energy market voted Wednesday to ask the full Senate to find Texas-based Enron Corp. in contempt for failing to comply with a subpoena for documents. Just hours earlier, Enron sued the Senate Select Committee to Investigate Market Manipulation to stop the subpoena of its financial and electricity trading records. Enron attorney Michael Kirby said the company is prepared to turn over 25,000 documents that were already in California, but that other documents the committee wants are in Texas and out of the panel's reach. Kirby filed 17 objections to the subpoena, including one that only the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission has the authority to investigate wholesale markets. The committee voted to overrule most of the objections. The committee will prepare a report to the full Senate, recommending the company be cited for contempt. If Enron turns over the records before the Senate takes up the matter, the report will be shelved. "They've sent two things to Texas ) our money and these documents, and they're saying we can't get either one back," said Laurence Drivon, special legal counsel to the Senate committee. The other subject of possible sanctions, Atlanta-based Mirant Inc., agreed to turn over subpoenaed documents. The committee will review Mirant's compliance in 30 days and could revisit whether to find it in contempt. Mirant spokesman Pat Dorinson said the company has turned over 159,000 pages of documents that were being transferred to a repository in Sacramento to comply with the subpoena. The company and the committee reached an agreement Tuesday night on the confidentiality concerns, Dorinson said. Committee chairman Joe Dunn, a Santa Ana Democrat, said the committee's investigation will continue despite Enron's "pure act of intimidation. We're not going to back down." Enron's suit, filed in Sacramento Superior Court, said the company's financial papers are outside the committee's jurisdiction because most of its operations and paperwork are outside California. That shouldn't matter, Drivon said, citing last year's successful subpoena of out-of-state documents during the investigation into the activities of former Insurance Commissioner Chuck Quackenbush. Previous investigations have included documents subpoenaed from other nations, he said. Companies doing business in California cannot claim immunity from its laws or oversight, Drivon and Dunn said. Houston-based Reliant Energy made the same argument but then agreed to turn over 1,800 documents. Enron's suit also says Dunn's committee has not given the company a fair hearing, and the committee has not followed due-process protections before seeking sanctions. Not so, said Dunn and Drivon, adding that they negotiated with generators to give them time to comply with the subpoenas. Proof of that, they said, comes in the decision to give Williams, AES, Reliant, Dynegy, Duke and NRG an extra week past Tuesday's deadline to turn over documents subpoenaed last month. In a letter to Dunn, Steven J. Kean, an Enron executive vice president, said several municipal districts were profiting from the power crisis. "Yet, remarkably, the committee has inexplicably chosen not to include these market participants in its investigations." Enron officials are concerned the purpose of the investigation, Kean said, is to "create a convenient political scapegoat to shoulder the blame for California's policy mistakes and changes in market fundamentals." If the full Senate approves a contempt citation, it will be the first time since 1929, when the Senate briefly jailed a reluctant witness during a committee investigation of price fixing and price gouging allegations involving cement sales to the state. There are no set penalties, Drivon said ) by law, "the Senate can take such action as it deems necessary and appropriate." Enron is one of the world's leading electricity, natural gas and communications companies, with $101 billion in revenues in 2000. It owns 30,000 miles of pipeline, has 20,000 employees and is active in 40 countries. During the first quarter of this year, Enron's revenues increased 281 percent to $50.1 billion. It is well connected politically. It has supported both President Bush and his father, President George H.W. Bush. Last year, Enron gave more than $172,000 to politicians and campaigns in California. Last month the firm helped sponsor a congressional fund-raiser featuring the president, where contributors in tuxedos and gowns dined and drank around a giant gold "W" that reached to the rafters at the Washington Convention Center ballroom. Enron has also helped shape President Bush's energy plan. It is one of several major donors accused of meeting secretly with Vice President Dick Cheney to draft the plan. Company chairman Kenneth Lay is a friend and one of the largest campaign contributors to Bush and the GOP. Several prominent members of the Bush administration hold Enron stock. Regulators want broad, regional power markets \ objattph ASSOCIATED PRESS July 11, 2001 WASHINGTON ) Despite California's problems with electricity deregulation, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission reinforced its commitment Wednesday to developing broad, regional power markets. The FERC, which regulates wholesale electricity markets, directed power grid managers in the Northeast and in the South to develop broad regional power transmission management organizations. By unanimous votes, the agency rejected proposals in both regions of the country for smaller geographical markets. The FERC kicked back proposals for separate regional transmission organizations in New England, New York and the mid-Atlantic states. Regulators said the parties should develop a single regional organization covering all three areas. At the same time, the commission said it wanted a broad organization covering most of the Southeast as well. In both cases, the agency directed that a mediator help the regions develop the new regional power market systems. The commissioners have maintained that large, regional power management organization are necessary if electricity is to flow freely in a competitive marketplace. "The actions will go a long way toward facilitating ... more efficient regional power markets," said Lynne Church, president of the Electric Power Supply Association, which represents independent power producers. The vote was the first on the issue since two new commissioners ) Pat Wood and Nora Brownell, both appointed by President bush ) joined the commission. HUNGTINGTON BEACH Huntington Loses Battle on Generators Power: AES receives go-ahead to restart two shut-down units without a restriction on out-of-state sales that the city had fought for. STANLEY ALLISON and CHRISTINE HANLEYS TIMES STAFF WRITER July 12 2001 The California Energy Commission on Wednesday voted to allow giant power company AES to move ahead with plans to restart two mothballed generators in Huntington Beach even without the company's guarantee that it would sell the electricity within the state. The decision permits AES to begin operating the generators next month. The 3-1 vote marks a defeat for Huntington Beach, which had agreed to AES' plans only with the company's pledge that all electricity generated would be used to ease the state's power crisis. In granting approval, energy commissioners conceded that the deal does not come without potential harm to the environment. "We do not know the extent of the plant's contribution to the transport of bacteria to the beach, which can result in beach closures and the loss of recreational opportunities to beach visitors and commercial opportunities to local merchants," the ruling says. State officials said they decided to drop the restriction that AES sell power within California to avoid more delays and help fulfill Gov. Gray Davis' executive order that the state significantly boost power production over the next year. "It adds power that will make California's power grid more secure, and the more power we can get, the more secure we are from rolling blackouts," said energy commission spokesman Rob Schlichting. AES originally agreed to the restriction. But the company demanded that it be dropped after negotiations with the state over long-term energy contracts broke down in June. With no contracts, AES argued it should have the right to sell power produced in Huntington Beach to whomever it wants. Huntington Beach officials who lobbied hard for the sales restriction said they felt betrayed by the decision. They said the commission bowed to the demands of a corporation over local concerns. "AES got exactly what it wanted," said City Councilwoman Connie Boardman, who testified at the hearing. "There's a lot of impacts the residents of Huntington Beach put up with. The energy crisis is the reason this project was approved so rapidly. Now that seems irrelevant. I think it's a big waste of time." An AES spokesman said the company would prefer to sell its power to customers in California. But he acknowledged there is no guarantee the extra electricity will remain in the state. Councilwoman Debbie Cook said she fully expects AES to sell the power to out-of-state companies. "They're going to sell it where they can get the most money," Cook said. "If they can sell it outside the state and resell it at a higher rate, then that's what they're going to do." The two 40-year-old generators, which have been out of service since 1995, can produce enough power to supply 337,500 homes and represent almost 10% of the 5,000 megawatts Davis has said he will bring into service this summer. AES said the retooling of Unit 3 is 75% complete and it should be on line by Aug. 7, and Unit 4 is 70% complete and could come on line a week later. AES had also requested a 10-year license to operate the generators. But the commission on Wednesday sided with Huntington Beach on that point. The city lobbied for a five-year license and a five-year renewal if the company complies with a host of laws and regulations. Copyright 2001, Los Angeles Times <http://www.latimes.com> Enron Gets 2nd Chance to Turn Over Documents Energy: State Senate panel gives the electricity seller a way around a contempt citation. But the company balks. CARL INGRAM TIMES STAFF WRITER July 12 2001 SACRAMENTO -- Acting five hours after Enron Corp. sued to stop a legislative investigation of its business practices, a state Senate committee Wednesday gave the electricity wholesaler a second chance to turn over documents and rid itself of a contempt citation. But officials at Enron, a major player in the California power market, brushed aside the gesture, saying it fell far short of meeting the company's objections. "Our position has not changed. . . . The issues we had at the beginning of the hearing, we still had at the conclusion of the hearing," spokeswoman Karen Denne said. The Houston-based electricity wholesaler claimed in a letter to the Senate investigative committee that it was being singled out as a "political scapegoat" for the energy mistakes of California officials. In the suit, Enron charged that the committee's investigation went far outside the law, an allegation denied by Chairman Joe Dunn (D-Santa Ana). He also denied the scapegoat charge. The lawsuit was filed in Superior Court 62 minutes before the select committee investigating market manipulation was to finalize its earlier finding of contempt against Enron. Enron appears to be the last of eight power sellers to refuse to make documents available to the committee. Seven others also had held out, but in the last two weeks have said they will provide the records or are negotiating to do so. Dunn said the committee must examine the hundreds of thousands of documents, including what Enron called its "most closely guarded secrets," to determine whether price gouging occurred and whether remedial legislation is necessary. Gov. Gray Davis and other officials are convinced that the wholesalers overcharged the state $8.9 billion during the energy crisis. A federal mediator has said the overcharges are closer to $1 billion. But at Wednesday's hearing, an angry Sen. Steve Peace (D-El Cajon), a sponsor of California's flawed 1996 deregulation law, charged that by suing the committee, Enron was trying to "precipitate a constitutional crisis" between the judicial and legislative branches of state government. "You just went to war with the state of California and the people of California!" Peace shouted at Michael Kirby, a San Diego attorney representing Enron. "You are already at war economically. Now you are at war politically." Kirby replied that Enron was merely trying to defend its right to due process against what he called unlawful violations by the committee. He complained that Enron was held in contempt on June 28 but that the company had never been given a chance to present its objections. "An accused criminal has been given more opportunity to have a hearing on their objections than I have [in this committee]," Kirby told the lawmakers. Sen. Debra Bowen (D-Marina del Rey), also an attorney, told Kirby that legislative subpoenas are far different than those issued in the court system and are not subject to the same restrictions because lawmakers must deal with policy issues, not matters of guilt or innocence. In their suit and testimony to the committee, Enron representatives charged the committee had ventured far out of its jurisdiction and that only the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission could legally undertake a wholesale price investigation and impose sanctions. The committee asked for a vast array of documents, including those involving business decisions and transactions in other states. But Enron claimed that the committee had no authority to issue subpoenas outside California and that the subpoenas themselves were flawed. The company asked the court for an injunction against further investigation by the committee and proposed that a "neutral" arbitrator or judge try to fashion a compromise. Dunn suggested that the lawsuit was an effort to intimidate the committee. But he insisted it "will not impact our investigation." Under contempt procedures, last used in 1929, the committee can find an individual or entity in contempt. It then reports its recommendations to the full Senate, which must ratify the committee's action. The Senate also can impose sanctions, ranging from possible jail terms to heavy penalties. Dunn offered Enron what he called a "middle ground" that would give the company an opportunity to change its mind and comply with the subpoenas instead of facing an immediate report to the Senate. Under Dunn's recommendation, approved on a bipartisan 5-0 vote, the report of Enron's failure to comply would be compiled and written, but it would not be delivered to the full Senate until Monday at the earliest. If Enron were to reverse itself and agree to provide the records the committee wants, sign a confidentiality agreement and create a Sacramento repository for its records, the committee would hold the report back. If compliance continued, Dunn said, the committee's contempt finding would be purged. Dunn said he decided to give Enron a second chance because his "No. 1 priority is to get the documents. Contempt is the last resort." Denne, the Enron spokeswoman, noted that the company recently established a document repository in Sacramento for records of its California operations, but not the disputed documents involving business elsewhere. She contended that the confidentiality agreements proposed by the committee failed to "guarantee that these documents would remain confidential." Another wholesaler, Mirant, also had been held in contempt by the committee. But Dunn said that since its June 28 citation, Mirant had become cooperative. The committee agreed to review Mirant's citation in a month and possibly erase it. Copyright 2001, Los Angeles Times <http://www.latimes.com> Coal futures to begin trading but analysts aren't sure it'll heat up energy markets BRAD FOSS, AP Business Writer Thursday, July 12, 2001 ,2001 Associated Press URL: <http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/news/archive/2001/07/12/natio nal0435EDT0461.DTL> (07-12) 01:35 PDT NEW YORK (AP) -- While the New York Mercantile Exchange believes it can stoke interest in coal futures trading, analysts say this fossil fuel won't necessarily take off like wildfire on commodities markets. "It's gonna be real wait and see," said David Khani, a coal analyst for Friedman, Billings, Ramsey Group Inc. of Arlington, Va. Futures exchanges exist to transfer the risk of price volatility from people who don't want it -- in this case, power producers or steel manufacturers -- to speculators who are willing to take a gamble on making profits from this uncertainty. One of the main reasons for doubts about coal as a commodity is that it has little history of wide price fluctuations, a key ingredient in bringing together buyers and sellers. And of the roughly 1 billion tons of coal burned in the United States annually, 80 percent is bought through long-term contracts, not on the daily spot market. Skeptics also contend that the exchange is overestimating the industry's need for coal futures, arguing that power producers are protected from price swings by passing along higher costs to consumers. But those assumptions were under assault as Nymex's Central Appalachian futures contracts were to begin trading on Thursday. The price of coal per ton doubled in a matter of weeks last winter in some parts of the country, boosting the stock prices of coal companies just as quickly. Also, as more and more states deregulate electricity markets, power providers like Mirant Corp., American Electric Power Company Inc. and Dynegy Inc., won't be able to hide behind laws allowing them to pass on higher costs to consumers. Instead, they will be forced to become more competitive with one another, said Andy Ozley, manager of fossil fuels for Atlanta-based Mirant. "Welcome to the free market," he said. "The pace of deregulation will encourage more and more activity on the exchange. At least that's the hope." The swapping of coal contracts is not entirely new. Energy traders, including Mirant, Enron Corp. and Aquila Inc., helped build an international over-the-counter exchange on which some 1 million tons of coal can switch hands on any given day. Some days, not a single transaction takes place. Just how much daily volume Nymex coal futures will add to the mix is anybody's guess. Nymex Executive Vice President Neal Wolkoff said, "If it starts in the low hundreds and builds to maybe 5,000 contracts a day I think that would be viewed as a successful marketplace. "We don't expect this to approach anywhere near the size of natural gas and crude oil," for which hundreds of thousands of contracts are swapped each day, Wolkoff said. At the very least, Wolkoff said, the Nymex coal futures will benefit the industry by making a "transparent price reference" available to buyers and sellers of both long- and short-term contracts. But critics believe Nymex's coal futures will suffer the same low trading volume that the exchange's electricity futures have since 1996. "There will be a flurry of trading when it starts, though I'm not so sure it's going to be a long-term success," said Howard Simons, a finance professor at the Illinois Institute of Technology and a former commodities trader. The run-up in coal prices last winter occurred as demand outstripped supply. Coal companies curtailed production and even closed some mines after a mild winter in 2000 at a time when power producers sought a less expensive alternative to natural gas, which had quadrupled in price. Developments in California's energy crisis The Associated Press Thursday, July 12, 2001 ,2001 Associated Press URL: <http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/news/archive/2001/07/12/state 1038EDT0155.DTL> (07-12) 07:38 PDT (AP) -- Developments in California's energy crisis: THURSDAY= * No power alerts Thursday as electricity reserves stay above 7 percent. WEDNESDAY= * Enron Corp. sues state officials to stop a Senate subpoena of its financial records in a dispute over alleged overcharges for its electricity sales to California. The suit comes hours before the committee voted to ask the full Senate to cite the Houston-based company for contempt. The other subject of possible sanctions, Atlanta-based Mirant Inc., agreed to turn over subpoenaed documents. The committee will review Mirant's compliance in 30 days and could revisit whether to find them in contempt. * State power regulators shelve a plan to save much-needed electricity by slightly reducing the juice to common household appliances after a misunderstanding with Pacific Gas and Electric Co. Regulators at the state Public Utilities Commission were set to approve the conservation measure at a meeting Thursday, but will postpone action, saying "last-minute concerns" raised by PG&E have made the plan less attractive than advertised. PG&E officials said they think the plan is a good one and are baffled why the PUC is not passing it. * California's two public university systems reach a tentative settlement with Enron Energy Systems Inc. to buy cheap power, bringing to an end a federal lawsuit accusing the Houston company of wanting to sell the electricity at a higher cost. * Secretary of State Bill Jones says dozens of energy consultants hired by Gov. Gray Davis haven't filed required statements of economic interest. Jones says as many as 47 consultants should have to file the statements. Oscar Hidalgo, spokesman for the Department of Water Resources, says about 20 consultants have been told they have until Monday to file those forms. * The Assembly Appropriations Committee approves a bill to create criminal penalties for energy price gouging. The bill, by Lt. Gov. Cruz Bustamante and Assemblyman Dennis Cardoza, D-Atwater, now goes to the Assembly for a vote. * The state Energy Commission approves San Diego area "peaker" plant which will generate 49.5 megawatts during high-demand periods. The CalPeak Power at Border Project is the 11th peaker plant licensed by the commission under an expedited review process. * Davis helps celebrate the 25th anniversary of the California Conservation Corps, particularly their participation in the PowerWalk energy conservation program. The corps members have distributed more than 500,000 energy efficient fluorescent light bulbs, and by summer's end will have distributed more than 1.6 million bulbs, saving 100 megawatts. * Shares of Edison International closed at $14.06, up a penny. PG&E Corp. stock increases 20 cents to close at $13.75. Sempra Energy, the parent company of San Diego Gas & Electric Co., closed at $27.49, down 18 cents. * No power alerts Wednesday as electricity reserves stay above 7 percent. WHAT'S NEXT= * The Senate committee investigating possible price manipulation in California's energy market meets July 18 to consider compliance by six energy suppliers who had documents subpoenaed last month. THE PROBLEM: High demand, high wholesale energy costs, transmission glitches and a tight supply worsened by scarce hydroelectric power in the Northwest and maintenance at aging California power plants are all factors in California's electricity crisis. Southern California Edison and Pacific Gas and Electric say they've lost nearly $14 billion since June 2000 to high wholesale prices the state's electricity deregulation law bars them from passing on to consumers. PG&E, saying it hasn't received the help it needs from regulators or state lawmakers, filed for federal bankruptcy protection April 6. Electricity and natural gas suppliers, scared off by the companies' poor credit ratings, are refusing to sell to them, leading the state in January to start buying power for the utilities' nearly 9 million residential and business customers. The state is also buying power for a third investor-owned utility, San Diego Gas & Electric, which is in better financial shape than much larger Edison and PG&E but is also struggling with high wholesale power costs. The Public Utilities Commission has approved average rate increases of 37 percent for the heaviest residential customers and 38 percent for commercial customers, and hikes of up to 49 percent for industrial customers and 15 percent or 20 percent for agricultural customers to help finance the state's multibillion-dollar power buys. Track the state's blackout warnings on the Web at www.caiso.com/SystemStatus.html <http://www.caiso.com/SystemStatus.html>. ,2001 Associated Press Enron files suit over subpoena Provider challenges move for documents Lynda Gledhill, Chronicle Sacramento Bureau <mailto:lgledhill@sfchronicle.com> Thursday, July 12, 2001 ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle </chronicle/info/copyright> URL: <http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/chronicle/archive/2001/07/12/ MN193079.DTL> Sacramento -- In another escalation in the war between California and out-of-state energy providers, Enron Corp. filed a lawsuit yesterday challenging the Legislature's authority to subpoena company documents. The suit came as a Senate panel investigating market manipulation voted 6 to 0 to move forward with a contempt motion against Enron. A report will be forwarded to the full Senate early next week if the marketer continues to refuse to comply with the subpoena. "You just went to war with the state of California," Sen. Steve Peace, D-El Cajon, told the lawyer representing Enron. ". . . You already initiated a war economically; now you're in a political war." The Senate committee investigating price manipulation found Enron and Mirant Corp. in contempt last month for not turning over subpoenaed documents. The finding against Mirant was vacated yesterday because it agreed to turn over documents. The committee, chaired by Sen. Joe Dunn, D-Santa Ana, requested documents from power providers in early April. When the requests were ignored, the committee issued subpoenas asking generators for documents covering business plans, operations, risk management and investment strategies. Peace argued that forcing a judge to decide the scope of the Legislature's authority could provoke a constitutional crisis. "You are treading into the territory of asking the court to make judgment on the rules and the law governing the rights of the Legislature," Peace said. "It is a separation of powers issue of the highest order." But Michael Kirby, a lawyer hired by Enron, said the Houston company was simply looking for due process. "A subpoena is a subpoena and once you go that route you must comply with the law," he told the committee. "We are entitled to some kind of hearing with a neutral arbitrator. It was not our preference to file a lawsuit." Kirby and the lawsuit cite several objections to the Senate's subpoena. These include the confidentiality of the documents and whether a California body can require documents from outside the state. Enron also says that only federal regulators have the power to subpoena their records. Kirby and members of the committee disagreed over the scope of what a legislative subpoena covers versus one used in a criminal matter. "I think there is a fundamental misunderstanding about our legislative inquiry," Dunn said. "We are not drawing conclusions about guilt or innocence. We want to see what fixes must be made in the law." Kirby did say Enron has set up a depository in Sacramento and has 30,000 documents ready to be deposited, pending an agreement can be reached on confidentiality issues. But that is not good enough for committee members, who believe that Enron has continue to evade the committee. "We have no indication that Enron ever intends to comply with the subpoena, " said Sen. Debra Bowen, D-Marina del Ray. E-mail Lynda Gledhill at lgledhill@sfchronicle.com <mailto:lgledhill@sfchronicle.com>. ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle </chronicle/info/copyright> Page A - 15 PUC cancels vote to drop voltage levels PG&E tells commission its electric distribution system is already operating at minimal power David Perlman, Chronicle Science Editor <mailto:dperlman@sfchronicle.com> Thursday, July 12, 2001 ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle </chronicle/info/copyright> URL: <http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/chronicle/archive/2001/07/12/ MN27161.DTL> Faced with objections by Pacific Gas and Electric Co., the California Public Utilities Commission called off a vote yesterday that would have allowed power companies to lower the voltage levels they supply to their customers. PUC Chairwoman Loretta Lynch promptly said she was exasperated by the company's attitude, because until yesterday, she said, officials there had appeared to be going along with the state's energy-saving effort. Dropping the voltage carried by power lines by as little as 2.5 percent was proposed last month by Bill Wattenburg, an engineer and consultant to the Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory who said that the move could save enough energy statewide to equal the output of a 500-megawatt power plant. His proposal was supported by Energy Commissioner Arthur Rosenfeld and Robert Kinosian, the PUC's energy adviser. Officials at Southern California Edison and San Diego Power & Light Co. had already agreed to make the move and the state PUC had been scheduled to vote today on amending its voltage rules to permit the change. But lawyers for PG&E filed a 10-page document with the commission on Tuesday, saying that its electricity distribution system "is already operating at the lowest voltages possible" and that it would take about three months to adjust even 10 percent of its system's circuits. "While some further voltage reductions can be made, substantial additional peak demand power reductions are not available," the company told the commission. According to Wattenburg, the two big Southern California utilities could save the equivalent of at least 200 megawatts and that PG&E could save an additional 200 to 300 megawatts. Total electricity consumption throughout the state during summer can reach as high as 40,000 megawatts. The concept of lowering power line voltages in an attempt to save energy has been applied by utilities in several other states, but it remains controversial. Michael O'Hare, an engineer and professor of public policy at the University of California at Berkeley, insists that energy economies from voltage reductions "are precisely zero" when they are applied to refrigerators, air conditioners or "anything else controlled by a thermostat" because they would merely run a little longer than they do with full voltage. "In sum," O'Hare said in a recent comment to The Chronicle, "the promised efficiencies from voltage reduction are either imaginary or subject to being nibbled away by human compensating behavior" -- in other words, by people using electric bulbs with higher wattages or by setting thermostats lower on their air conditioners. An electrical engineer who designs substations for Silicon Valley industries and who asked that his name be withheld commented: "The theory of voltage reduction is a bit of smoke and mirrors. Unless you were looking at your lights when the reduction happened, you would not know the difference, but the time it takes to make that morning coffee or create some hot water when you are last in line for the shower would seem like forever." E-mail David Perlman at dperlman@sfchronicle.com <mailto:dperlman@sfchronicle.com>. ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle </chronicle/info/copyright> Page A - 15 Power regulators hold off on energy-savings plan JUSTIN PRITCHARD, Associated Press Writer Thursday, July 12, 2001 ,2001 Associated Press URL: <http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/news/archive/2001/07/12/state 0320EDT0111.DTL> (07-12) 00:20 PDT SAN FRANCISCO (AP) -- State power regulators are poised to protect consumers from a problem they don't yet confront -- phone companies trying to shut down their service because they haven't paid for all the sodas, pizzas, and lattes they used their cell phones to buy. Cellular service providers in other countries -- notably Japan -- have rigged their phones to bill some goods, and U.S. companies are eager to catch up. But once they get around to offering such services, cellular providers in California won't be able to disconnect subscribers whose fast-food gluttony lands them with fat bills they can't pay. Not if the state Public Utilities Commission has its way. The PUC is scheduled to pass that "first-in-the-nation" consumer protection at its Thursday meeting, according to President Loretta Lynch. What the PUC will not be addressing is a plan to save much-needed electricity by slightly reducing the juice to common household appliances. That plan was shelved by a misunderstanding between the PUC and Pacific Gas and Electric Co. Lynch said the PUC was set to approve the conservation measure at Thursday's meeting, but will postpone action due to PG&E's "last-minute concerns" that make the plan less attractive than advertised. Under the proposal, the state's three largest utilities would reduce the voltage from 120 volts to about 117 volts. While that would have little effect on individual lights and appliances, bundled together the savings would reach hundreds of megawatts -- in a pinch, enough to avert rolling blackouts. PG&E officials said they think the plan is a good one and were baffled why the PUC postponed debating it. At issue are how much power the plan would actually save, how long it would take to implement, and whether it might make some service less reliable. PG&E promised hundreds of megawatts in savings within a month, but in papers submitted late Tuesday reduced those expectations to 40 megawatts over a three-month span, said Robert Kinosian, energy adviser to PUC President Loretta Lynch. "Every sort of thing in implementing this was more problematic than before," Kinosian told reporters Wednesday. "I thought that everybody was working on the same page, until yesterday." Lynch blamed PG&E for taking the shine off what appeared to be a sparkling way to reduce electricity demand with little downside. But Lynch misunderstood PG&E's comments, according to Les Guliasi, the utility's director of regulatory relations. He said PG&E would happily reduce voltage to save the 40 megawatts -- enough to power about 30,000 homes. "I think she should read over the comments," Guliasi said. "We've been very up front and forthcoming in these discussions." Indeed, Guliasi said, PG&E already has implemented "voltage reduction" across much of its system. Because of that, he said, there's not much more the utility can squeeze out of the program. The comments PG&E filed with the PUC Tuesday conclude that the utility "is ready and willing to immediately implement the voltage reductions." Now that won't happen before the PUC meets Aug. 2. At that meeting, Lynch said, the commission might approve voltage reduction for Southern California Edison and San Diego Gas & Electric Co. -- even if problems with PG&E are not resolved. Regulators order utilities to form regional systems Giant step toward national deregulation Christian Berthelsen, Chronicle Staff Writer <mailto:cberthelsen@sfchronicle.com> Thursday, July 12, 2001 ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle </chronicle/info/copyright> URL: <http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/chronicle/archive/2001/07/12/ MN167808.DTL> In a move that pushes the nation farther down the path of deregulating its power systems, federal energy regulators yesterday ordered that transmission grids in the Northeast and Southeast be combined to form regional systems. The decision represents a victory for marketing companies that buy, sell and trade electricity. Power marketers such as Enron, based in Houston, which have created a new kind of business buying power where it is abundant and selling it where it is scarce, had fought for creation of the regional systems. They argued that utility ownership created a costly barrier to entry in many markets and that more regional systems would better enable them to transmit power over longer distances. The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission has been slowly nudging power interests toward the regional systems for two years. Yesterday, in a sudden and aggressive demonstration of its intent, the commission ordered three independent system operators covering 12 Northeastern states to form one regional transmission group, and ordered four utilities in the Southeast, including Southern Co. and Entergy, to form another system. Under the latest federal orders, utilities that own or control power lines will have to turn them over to nonprofit groups called regional transmission organizations that will manage them. The groups would set rules for the regional market systems and facilitate easier transmission of power across state lines. A similar move has been proposed in California, but California power grid managers and utilities have resisted it, saying the market in the state is broken and needs to be fixed before further deregulatory steps can be taken. In a filing with the regulatory commission last month, the California Independent System Operator, Southern California Edison and San Diego Gas & Electric resisted federal attempts to push the state into a regional system too quickly. "Most of the rest of the West is leaning toward weak ISO/RTO structures that give far too much power to marketers and not enough to the central authority," said Mike Florio, a lawyer for The Utility Reform Network, a consumer advocacy group. "We have seen where that got us in California." E-mail Christian Berthelsen at cberthelsen@sfchronicle.com <mailto:cberthelsen@sfchronicle.com>. ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle </chronicle/info/copyright> Page A - 15 Universities, Enron cut deal on electricity Prices 5% below limited rate Tanya Schevitz, Chronicle Staff Writer <mailto:tschevitz@sfchronicle.com> Thursday, July 12, 2001 ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle </chronicle/info/copyright> URL: <http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/chronicle/archive/2001/07/12/ MN151542.DTL> The University of California and the California State University systems won their fight yesterday to prevent Enron Corp. from cutting off their electricity and throwing them back to the state's utilities. Although the universities had signed four-year contracts with Enron as protection from the uncertainties of California's deregulation, the Houston energy broker dropped service to the universities on Feb. 1 so it could sell the power for more money elsewhere. That left the university systems relying on Pacific Gas and Electric Co. and Southern California Edison, which were struggling to survive and subject to rolling blackouts. The university systems won a court injunction ordering the service restored. When an appellate judge suspended the injunction, the two sides got together to reach an agreement. "Our primary objective was to get restored as direct-access customers, and we are now restored," said UC spokesman Chuck McFadden. Until the contract expires March 31, 2002, the university systems will be guaranteed power at prices 5 percent below the capped rate created under the state's 1996 deregulation law. Enron and the universities will also discuss a two-year contract extension. Mark Gutheinz, chief of plant, energy and utilities for CSU, said the settlement "will save us quite a bit of money in the long run, and it will give us a more stable supply of power." Peggy Mahoney, spokeswoman for Enron, said the company planned to take back all its direct-access customers even before the agreement was reached. "We are very happy that it is over. We have been working with them all along," she said of the universities. With UC's systemwide peak load at 332 megawatts and CSU's at 117 megawatts, the universities together rank as the largest single user of electricity in California. E-mail Tanya Schevitz at tschevitz@sfchronicle.com <mailto:tschevitz@sfchronicle.com>. ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle </chronicle/info/copyright> Page A - 15 Voltage cut won't work, PG&E warns Published Thursday, July 12, 2001, in the San Jose Mercury News BY MICHAEL BAZELEY Mercury News In a move that blindsided state regulators, Pacific Gas & Electric officials have raised serious concerns about a novel plan to conserve energy by reducing the voltage sent into homes and businesses. Company officials told the Public Utilities Commission this week that its electric distribution system is already operating at a low voltage level and that any energy savings would fall short of expectations. What is more, company officials said they would not be able to complete the voltage changes for three months -- too late to help the state if hot summer weather forces rolling blackouts. At the urging of Gov. Gray Davis, the PUC was to consider today changing its regulations to allow utilities to lower their voltage, possibly starting this month. Officials said they were stunned to receive a filing from PG&E Tuesday afternoon raising concerns about the proposal. Scientists, the PUC and utilities have been working on the voltage reduction plan for more than a month, and PG&E voiced no major concerns before now, PUC officials said. ``It's quite unfortunate that even though we had a cooperative process . . . those concerns were not submitted earlier,'' said PUC President Loretta Lynch. ``It's derailed at this point so we can be serious about addressing PG&E's concerns.'' Lowering voltage The change, championed by scientist and talk show host Bill Wattenberg, would crank down the voltage on the state's electrical grid from about 120 volts to 117 volts, a drop of about 2.5 percent. State officials expected the reduction to go unnoticed by most users and to conserve about 500 megawatts of power during peak periods -- enough to possibly spare the state from blackouts on high-demand days. About half that energy savings was expected to come from PG&E customers. But in their filing with the PUC, utility officials said their system is ``already operating at the lowest voltages possible'' under current regulations. The company said that, at most, it could probably reduce load by about 40 megawatts. ``We are operating at the low end of the system,'' said Les Guliasi, director of regulatory relations for the utility. ``We've been very up front and frank with what we could achieve with these savings.'' Lynch's energy adviser, Robert Kinosian, said 40 megawatts is ``significantly lower than what they said before.'' ``If 40 megawatts is all we're going to get, should we even take the time to do it?'' Kinosian said. Southern California Edison officials also said their reductions would be lower than state officials expected. John Ballance, director of network engineering for Edison, said Wednesday the utility could probably shave 100 to 150 megawatts off its load with the lower voltage. Disputing numbers PG&E spokesman John Nelson said the utilities have insisted all along that the 500-megawatt savings touted by Davis and others was unreasonable. ``All the utilities have disputed that number,'' he said. Wattenberg, who has been helping PG&E test the voltage reduction idea, said he doubted the utility was operating at the low end of the voltage range. ``That's funny,'' Wattenberg said from his Sierra home. ``I'm sitting here with 122 volts.'' Kinosian said the PUC would study PG&E's concerns and might send inspectors out to test the utility's system. If necessary, he said, state regulators could go ahead with the reductions elsewhere in the state. Contact Michael Bazeley at mbazeley@sjmercury.com <mailto:mbazeley@sjmercury.com> or (415) 434-1018. Energy dispute goes to court Published Thursday, July 12, 2001, in the San Jose Mercury News BY DION NISSENBAUM Mercury News Sacramento Bureau SACRAMENTO -- A Texas-based power company moved to thwart an investigation of alleged price gouging in the electric industry by taking its case Wednesday from the Capitol to the courthouse. The legal action prompted angry lawmakers to accuse Enron of escalating its dispute with the state. ``You just went to war with the state of California,'' a seething state Sen. Steve Peace, D-La Mesa, told Enron's attorney at a hearing. Enron's lawsuit forced the legislative investigation of alleged price gouging into uncertain territory with some legal experts predicting that the issue might have to be settled by the U.S. Supreme Court. The lawsuit was the latest salvo in an ongoing political and economic battle over billions of dollars companies such as Enron have made during the energy crisis. Enron filed its lawsuit in Sacramento Superior Court an hour before its attorney was scheduled to appear before a Senate committee that two weeks ago declared them in contempt for refusing to turn over thousands of pages of documents. The power company argued in its lawsuit that the committee had no authority to subpoena out-of-state records or examine highly confidential trade secrets. Lawyers also argued that the Legislature was treading on federal oversight powers. In a letter to committee chairman Joe Dunn, an Enron executive suggested the probe had unfairly singled out his company to be vilified. ``It is exceedingly difficult to discern whether the committee's actions are designed to uncover the facts underlying the price spikes in California's wholesale electric power market, or to create a convenient political scapegoat to shoulder the blame for California's policy mistakes,'' wrote Steven J. Kean, Enron's executive vice president. Dunn, a Democrat from Garden Grove, suggested Enron was trying to undermine his investigation and spark a constitutional crisis by asking the courts to overrule the Legislature. ``This first step into the litigation arena may be the first of many in an effort to intimidate us out of completing the investigation,'' said Dunn. ``This raises the stakes dramatically.'' A few hours after Enron filed the suit, Dunn and his committee unanimously reaffirmed a contempt finding and voted to send a report to the full Senate next week. At that point, the Senate would have broad authority to decide how to penalize Enron. It could vote to throw company executives in jail, as the Senate did in 1929 during a price fixing investigation of the cement industry. It could vote to fine Enron. Or it could decide on some other penalty. But Dunn and the other lawmakers gave Enron another chance to turn over the kinds of documents other companies have given to the committee. So far, a half dozen other companies have managed to avoid similar threats by turning over, or agreeing to turn over, thousands of pages of confidential papers. On Wednesday, the committee withdrew a contempt finding against Mirant, which turned over more than 100,000 documents. Contact Dion Nissenbaum at dnissenbaum@sjmercury.com <mailto:dnissenbaum@sjmercury.com> or (916) 441-4603. Regulators Look to Develop Markets July 12, 2001 WASHINGTON (AP) via NewsEdge Corporation - Despite California's problems with electricity deregulation, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission reinforced its commitment Wednesday to developing broad, regional power markets. The FERC, which regulates wholesale electricity markets, directed power grid managers in the Northeast and in the South to develop broad regional power transmission management organizations. By unanimous votes, the agency rejected proposals in both regions of the country for smaller geographical markets. The FERC kicked back proposals for separate regional transmission organizations in New England, New York and the mid-Atlantic states. Regulators said the parties should develop a single regional organization covering all three areas. At the same time, the commission said it wanted a broad organization covering most of the Southeast as well. In both cases, the agency directed that a mediator help the regions develop the new regional power market systems. The commissioners have maintained that large, regional power management organization are necessary if electricity is to flow freely in a competitive marketplace. ``The actions will go a long way toward facilitating ... more efficient regional power markets,'' said Lynne Church, president of the Electric Power Supply Association, which represents independent power producers. The vote was the first on the issue since two new commissioners _ Pat Wood and Nora Brownell, both appointed by President bush _ joined the commission. News For now, electricity crisis has dimmed Karen Brandon, Tribune staff reporter 07/12/2001 Chicago Tribune North Sports Final ; N Page 8 (Copyright 2001 by the Chicago Tribune) The lights have been on all summer in California . Given the extent of the ongoing energy crisis, this is considered a feat, but by no means does it signal the end of the drama that is likely to be playing in the West for years to come. With demand down significantly and supply up, Henwood Energy Services Inc., a power industry consulting and software firm, predicts California won't face any more blackouts. "We're now saying there's a fairly good chance we should be able to avoid blackouts this summer," said Richard Lauckhart, senior project manager in Sacramento. In March, the company predicted California would be plagued by 300 hours of blackouts over the summer. Still, he cautioned, the energy crisis in the West isn't over. "The financial and political crisis is going to drag on for a long time," he said. Indeed, many analysts say the real test of all the measures being taken to keep demand down and supply up is yet to come. "We shouldn't take too much comfort that we had a pretty good June," said James Bushnell, co-director of the University of California -Berkeley Energy Institute. "June is usually pretty good. August and September are peaks." The last blackout in California was May 8; the only outage since then briefly hit parts of Las Vegas. California has fared much better this summer than anyone expected. The demand for electricity is down, the result of myriad efforts to conserve electricity , including making deals to close aluminum companies that are huge electricity users in the Northwest and letting some farms lie fallowto use less water. Even the economic downturn may be playing a role, analysts said. "We don't know whether it's just the fact that the economy slowed down, and the timing was right, or incentives and exhortations to be good citizens and conserve helped us squeak by," said Bushnell. In California , usage is down 12 percent from June 2000 to this June, even with differences in weather taken into account. During peak periods, usage is down by 14 percent. The state is considering a plan that would allow utilities to reduce the voltage slightly to homes and businesses during peak periods. At the beginning of the year, when the crisis seemed to be at its peak, many old plants were under repair, and power providers were suspected of withholding power to inflate prices. Since then, repairs have been made, and federal and state oversight of plants has increased. Federally imposed price limits have helped to moderate electric bills. "I don't think the [wholesale] price has gone for $95 a megawatt hour," said Paul Joskow, director of the Center for Energy and Environmental Policy Research at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. "Last year, you could have gotten over $700." In Northern Illinois, wholesale electricity prices in Commonwealth Edison Co.'s territory were about $36 per megawatt hour in June, according to Platts Energy Trader. Prices in California have been volatile. June 1998 was the cheapest month for electricity purchases that year, with rates averaging $12 a megawatt hour, compared with $90 a megawatt hour that was the average this June, Bushnell said. "They're not out of the woods yet since it can still get hot in California and the West," Joskow said. The price "depends a lot on the weather." The political situation is already very hot. The lights may be on, but Californians are beginning to realize just how much they are paying. State leaders who once debated what to do with a budget surplus are contemplating the financial repercussions of the electricity crisis. In January, California began buying electricity for the customers of the state's largest utilities, which have been financially crippled because they had to buy power at high prices and could not pass on the increases to their customers. But the electricity purchases are draining the state's coffers. As details of the state's $43 billion purchase of long-term electricity contractsemerge, many are questioning the deal, and the prospect of renegotiation looms. Economy Regulators Order Formation of Big Grids To Optimize the Flow of Electricity in U.S. By Rebecca Smith 07/12/2001 The Wall Street Journal Page A2 (Copyright (c) 2001, Dow Jones & Company, Inc.) The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission said it wants four big electric-transmission organizations formed that will optimize the flow of electricity in the Northeast, the Southeast, the Midwest and the West. The push to consolidate the operation of high-voltage transmission systems is an attempt to create a solid foundation for competitive power markets that have been sullied by California 's market failure. The commission said it wants utilities and independent grid operators in the Northeast and Southeast regions to meet with FERC mediators within one week and hammer out plans within 45 days to form two broad organizations to centrally manage power markets and energy flows in the East. The action illustrates the FERC's frustration with the slow pace of electric-transmission consolidation and is expected to be followed by similar orders for the Midwest and the West. The federal orders are intended to accelerate development of electric-transmission organizations that the FERC endorsed in a landmark decision called Order 2000 issued in December 1999. In that order, the FERC urged utilities to voluntarily surrender control of their transmission systems to grid organizations that would run daily markets for power and manage power flows across multiutility regions. The agency said consumers would benefit from larger, more efficient wholesale- electricity markets in which transmission owners no longer would be able to give their own power sales preferential access to the power-delivery system, snubbing lower-cost competitors. In addition, formation of regional transmission organizations, or RTOs, would propel "postage stamp pricing" for transmission services, FERC said, so suppliers could move power across vast distances for a single charge instead of incurring "pancaked" costs as power traversed separately operated systems. Commissioner William Massey described yesterday's directives as a "watershed" because "never before have we been as explicit" about the FERC's resolve to form big grid organizations "that can't be gerrymandered according to what utilities want to do." The FERC orders likely will face resistance in the Southeast, where states haven't deregulated their retail electricity markets and where fear of federal control is particularly acute. "My guess is that those states will say, `We're happy with what we've got and with keeping control over our own utilities,'" said Frank Wolak, an economics professor and power-markets expert at Stanford University. "Any state that surrenders control to FERC, after what's happened in California , isn't thinking clearly." The directive also creates big problems for existing grid-running organizations that thought they already were doing what the agency wanted. Currently, New York, New England and the mid-Atlantic states each are represented by separate, nonprofit independent system operators, or ISOs, that operate transmission systems still owned by local utilities. PJM Interconnection LLC, which controls power flows in the mid-Atlantic region, is regarded as having the best market structure. The FERC said it intends the PJM "platform" to be used as the basis of a single Northeast grid-running organization. That upsets the plans of the other two operators that have been working with PJM to harmonize market rules and create a "virtual RTO" that would permit suppliers to schedule power flows across all three ISO areas. Such a virtual structure would preserve the underlying organizations, each of which has its own control rooms, computer systems and governing boards. Carol Murphy, spokeswoman for the New York ISO, said attempts to smooth out market incongruities, or "seams issues," likely will be halted now. She said her organization will participate in the mediated talks, as directed, but it intends to conduct a cost-benefit analysis to determine whether consolidation really offers substantial benefits. Some market watchers had expected the FERC to compel utilities to surrender operational control of their power lines to the independent operators by Dec. 15, as required in Order 2000, but only push them to merge into giant regional organizations in three to five years. Commissioner Patrick Wood said that approach seemed slow and wasteful. "These organizations aren't cheap to set up," he said. "And why have eight or 10 organizations in the East when a couple will do?" The FERC actions also show the commission is becoming more confident about the organizational structure it believes best for competitive markets. When it began pushing electricity deregulation after 1992, the agency conceded it didn't know which market design was best and encouraged experimentation. Mr. Wood said the FERC's "glorious inattention to detail" is partly to blame for California 's distress. He said the agency may establish field offices to better monitor market health. Mr. Wood said a FERC workshop last month aimed at eliminating seams issues between the three Northeast ISOs convinced him that market participants are "crying out for more leadership from FERC."