24 Jul 2001, 10:13 UTC
Energy Issues
- From
- Miyung Buster miyung.buster@enron.com
- To
-
Joseph Alamo, Bev Hansen, Rob Bradley, Tom Briggs, Michael R Brown, Janet Butler, Stella Chan, Alan Comnes, Shelley Corman, Jeff Dasovich, Larry Decker, Karen Denne
and 56 more
Marcus Dotson, filuntz@aol.com, Markus Fiala, Lamar Frazier, Janel Guerrero, Joe Hartsoe, Hedy Govenar, Chris Holmes, shirley.hudler@enron.com, Evan Hughes, jkradin@marathon-com.com, Steven J Kean, Ken Smith, amy.kim@enron.com, Kurt Lindahl, Elizabeth Linnell, Laura Ipsen, Chris Long, Peggy Mahoney, Jeannie Mandelker, Susan J Mara, Luiz Maurer, Karen Moore, andrew.morrison@enron.com, Carin Nersesian, John Neslage, Robert Neustaedter, Nick O'day, Mark Palmer, Alex Parsons, Dave Perrino, Mona L Petrochko, Melinda Pharms, rlichtenstein@marathon-com.com, Ralph Reed, mike.roan@enron.com, Linda Robertson, Ann M Schmidt, Mary Schoen, Mark Schroeder, Scott Govenar, Bryan Seyfried, Richard Shapiro, Ban Sharma, John Shelk, John Sherriff, Pat Shortridge, Roberta Staehlin, James D Steffes, Peter Styles, Kathleen Sullivan, Lora Sullivan, Sandra Yamane, Jennifer Thome, Lysa Tracy, Michael Tribolet - Bcc
- Angela Wilson
- Date
- Tue, 24 Jul 2001 03:13:00 -0700 (PDT)
Please see the following articles: Sac Bee, Tues, 7/24: Transmission lines project draws bidders Sac Bee, Tues, 7/24: Dan Walters: Blame game over California's energy crisis will continue for years (Enron mentioned) Sac Bee, Tues, 7/24: Initiative effort seeks to lower natural-gas prices Sac Bee, Tues, 7/24: Daniel Weintraub: There's no shame in doing nothing for Edison (Editorial) SD Union, Mon, 7/23: State consultants don't see need for more rate hikes SD Union, Mon, 7/23: Senate committee told Morgan Stanley destroyed power records SD Union, Tues, 7/24: News briefs on the California power crisis SD Union, Mon, 7/23: State sells surplus power at a loss LA Times, Tues, 7/24: Rush for Power Plant in Chino Raises Concerns LA Times, Tues, 7/24: Surplus Power Sold at a Loss LA Times, Tues, 7/24: Pacific Gas Gets 4-Month Extension on Filing Plan SF Chron, Tues, 7/24: State sells surplus electricity at a loss BUY HIGH, SELL LOW: $14 million deficit SF Chron, Tues, 7/24: San Diego tries to undo the damage THE PLAN: Regional public power SF Chron, Tues, 7/24: 13 plans submitted to alleviate power transmission bottleneck SF Chron, Tues, 7/24: Developments in California's energy crisis Mercury News, Tues, 7/24: Figures show state lost big on extra power Mercury News, Tues, 7/24: Temperatures likely to rise all week Individual.com (AP), Tues, 7/24: Wholesale Competition Contributed to Trend of Lower Power Prices, According to New EPSA Study ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ -------------------------------------- Transmission lines project draws bidders By Dale Kasler Bee Staff Writer (Published July 24, 2001) Aiming to ease one of the festering problems in California's energy crisis, 13 companies and public agencies have bid for the right to widen a notorious bottleneck in the state's transmission lines, federal officials said Monday. The bidders range from the East Bay Municipal Utility District to wholesale power generators such as Mirant Corp., Calpine Corp. and Williams Cos. Some independent experts argue that if a generator wins the bid, it could use its control over those transmission lines to manipulate the electricity market. The bottleneck is Path 15, a narrow 90-mile stretch of power lines near Los Banos that carries electricity between Northern and Southern California. It has less transmission capacity than other portions of the power grid, which has led to blackouts. In January, Northern California suffered power outages in part because Path 15 couldn't deliver the surplus electricity that was available in Southern California. The proposed expansion would add 1,500 megawatts of capacity. "It's a very big issue; there's been a lot of congestion," said Severin Borenstein of the University of California Energy Institute. In addition, the Independent System Operator, which manages the power grid, estimates the congestion generated by Path 15 added an estimated $221.7 million to California's power bill in a 16-month period that ended in December. Borenstein said he believes there are considerable hidden costs as well, because the bottleneck has created an incentive for sellers to withhold power. Path 15 effectively cuts California into two separate markets, making it easier for sellers to manipulate each submarket to raise prices, he said. Pacific Gas and Electric Co., which owns the existing Path 15 transmission lines, already has been conducting environmental studies with an eye toward widening the path. To speed things along, the federal government in May asked for bids on the project, which sparked proposals from generators and others. Borenstein said having a generator widen Path 15 could bring new problems. Whoever builds the additional power lines owns them and can charge "tolls" to companies that use the lines to transmit electricity. A power generator could deliberately withhold supplies, thereby increasing the congestion on Path 15, and increase the tolls, Borenstein said. PG&E is among those bidding to widen the path. So is its sister company, an unregulated entity called PG&E National Energy Group. Other bidders include a partnership led by Sempra Energy Resources, an unregulated sister company of San Diego Gas & Electric Co. The federal government estimates it will take $300 million and three or four years to widen Path 15. The costs are ultimately paid by utility customers. U.S. Energy Secretary Spencer Abraham, speaking to reporters in Los Angeles on Monday, called the expansion of Path 15 "a critical component in solving the long-term power crisis in this state." The Bee's Dale Kasler can be reached at (916)321-1066 or dkasler@sacbee.com <mailto:dkasler@sacbee.com>. Bee news services contributed to this report. Dan Walters: Blame game over California's energy crisis will continue for years (Published July 24, 2001) The wrestling match between politicians and Enron Corp. moved into a more intense arena over the weekend when a state Senate investigating committee sought contempt penalties because the huge energy company has refused to turn over internal documents. Although Houston-based Enron owns no major power plants in California, it has adopted the toughest stance of all energy companies against the multiple investigations of why wholesale energy prices spiked so high. And it has become, in turn, a whipping boy for California politicians. At one point last spring, state Attorney General Bill Lockyer said he wanted criminal charges against Enron and its chairman, Kenneth Lay. "I would love to personally escort Lay to an 8-by-10 cell that he could share with a tattooed dude who says, 'Hi, my name is Spike, honey,' " Lockyer said. With less colorful language, Gov. Gray Davis has often castigated Texas-based companies as price gougers -- even though Texas firms have been fairly minor suppliers to California. Some of it is just buzzword politics. Lockyer and Davis know that Californians dislike anything associated with Texas, and Lay has been one of President Bush's major political supporters. Enron, meanwhile, cites the rhetoric as evidence that Lockyer, Davis and legislative investigators are interested less in finding the truth than in seeking scapegoats. Enron also filed a lawsuit challenging the legality of the Senate's subpoenas of trading data. Most other energy companies have complied with the demands, creating Sacramento repositories of the data under elaborate confidentiality agreements worked out with the special Senate committee headed by Sen. Joseph Dunn, D-Santa Ana. But Enron has refused, and on Saturday, Dunn submitted a report asking the Senate for "an appropriate coercive sanction." Does Enron have something to hide? Or does it sincerely believe that what's happening in California is political scapegoating? Are the companies' fears about the confidentiality of the data sought by the Senate justified? Would data be selectively leaked to show the firms in the worst light? Would data be used by competitors? Or could the information find its way into the hands of class-action attorneys? Dunn, a prominent trial attorney himself, insists that confidentiality will be protected and that the information being sought is only for legislative purposes. But Enron and the other companies have some reason to be wary of turning over confidential information to politicians. Similar information was leaked -- without penalty -- in last year's investigation of former state Insurance Commissioner Chuck Quackenbush. And there are indications that private lawyers are working closely with investigators. Mike Aguirre, the San Diego attorney seeking a "smoking gun" to prove collusion among energy companies, supplied Dunn's committee with a few dissident Duke Energy workers who alleged, in highly publicized hearings, that the firm had manipulated production at its San Diego plant to create artificial shortages and drive up spot market power prices. Duke then refuted the charges by releasing some excerpts from the records of the Independent System Operator, the controller of California's power grid, indicating that ISO had ordered the plant operational changes. Aguirre subsequently asked the governor's office to pressure the ISO -- now under Davis' direct control -- to release all of the Duke-related documents that would show, he says, that the firm actually manipulated the situation. Duke and other companies insist that the ISO-held documents are proprietary. Aguirre pleaded with one Davis adviser in an e-mail that "we need your help in properly getting this information out." But Aguirre, in an interview, said he had not yet obtained cooperation from Davis aides. The political and legal struggle to affix blame for California's energy woes will continue for months, perhaps years. The crisis will cost ratepayers at least $50 billion, and they'll want to know why as they make out their utility bill checks. The Bee's Dan Walters can be reached at (916) 321-1195 or dwalters@sacbee.com <mailto:dwalters@sacbee.com>. Initiative effort seeks to lower natural-gas prices By Jim Miller Bee Capitol Bureau (Published July 24, 2001) Amid higher utility rates, the threat of rolling blackouts and legislative indecision on how to solve California's energy problems, there is one proposal to get voters involved. A ballot initiative to let cities, counties and other public agencies, such as municipal utilities and irrigation districts, buy and sell natural gas has been cleared for signature collection by the secretary of state's office. The initiative emerged from the office of Assemblyman Dennis Cardoza, D-Merced, whose district includes three electricity-supplying irrigation districts. To Cardoza and others, putting public agencies in the natural-gas business would result in lower gas and electricity prices for consumers because most generators run on natural gas. Cardoza's proposal is the first of what observers say could be several energy-related measures on future ballots. For months, consumer advocates have warned that they would use the initiative process if they feel lawmakers are saddling taxpayers with the costs of the state's botched energy deregulation. "As soon as we find out what the Legislature has done or has not done this fall, we'll react appropriately," said Jamie Court, executive director of the Foundation for Taxpayer and Consumer Rights, one of the groups considering an initiative. "If there's a bailout (of utilities), we'll go to the ballot box. If there isn't a bailout, it's not clear what we'll do," Court said. "Right now, we're fund raising to be able to have the capacity to do whatever needs to be done." The future of Cardoza's initiative is uncertain. Since its approval by the secretary of state's office May 29, there has been no effort to collect signatures or to raise money for a campaign. The initiative needs the signatures of 670,816 registered voters by Oct. 26 to qualify for the ballot. The electric industry strongly opposes the Cardoza initiative. "This came about during the winter because it looked like there was going to be a natural-gas shortage," said Stephanie Espinosa, a spokeswoman for Pacific Gas and Electric Co. "Since then, we've been able to provide sufficient natural gas to our customers." A recent poll, however, showed Californians may be in the mood to approve energy-related ballot measures. The Public Policy Institute of California poll found that 65 percent of all adults believe measures on the 2002 ballot are the best way to solve the energy crisis. Thirty percent said the Legislature and Gov. Gray Davis would provide the best solution. The Modesto Bee's Jim Miller can be reached at (916) 326-5544 or jmiller@modbee.com <mailto:jmiller@modbee.com>. Daniel Weintraub: There's no shame in doing nothing for Edison (Published July 24, 2001) To understand why state lawmakers are inching closer to handing over billions of dollars of consumers' money to California's second-largest utility, you need to appreciate the collective psyche of the Legislature. Not appreciate as in enjoy. But appreciate in a scientific way, in the manner of an anthropologist studying the mores of a foreign culture. Confronted with a big problem, legislators think they need to solve it. Doing nothing is not a comfortable option. It makes them feel ineffective and impotent. When the governor is demanding a bill, the pressure grows even more intense. They want to do something -- anything -- rather than having to go back to their districts and admit that the problem is not theirs to fix. In this case, though, doing nothing might be the wisest course. Lawmakers now have on their desks three bills that take various approaches to rescuing Southern California Edison from the brink of bankruptcy. The company has a $3.5 billion debt left over from the state's failed experiment in electricity deregulation. If something isn't done about it in the next few weeks, the utility's future is likely to wind up in the hands of a judge. But all three bills ignore a fundamental fact: Edison got itself into this mess. Maybe the utility should get itself out. Edison was a big cheerleader for the 1996 bill that restructured the way electricity was bought and sold in California. Supporting a freeze on retail rates, which was the centerpiece of that legislation, the company took a huge gamble. If wholesale prices remained low, Edison would rake in billions by capturing the difference between the price it paid for power and the much higher price it was allowed to charge its customers. The money would go to compensate the utility for power plants it built as a regulated monopoly, plants that might no longer be profitable in a free-market, competitive industry. Like all gambles, this one came with a risk. If wholesale prices rose, they might exceed the retail rate cap. Edison would be forced to sell its electricity at retail for less than it was paying in the wholesale market. The tide of dollars that flowed in so nicely would begin to flow back out again. And that's exactly what happened. Some of the world's smartest utility minds guessed wrong. An electricity surplus turned into a shortage. Wholesale prices soared. Things got so bad at Edison that the state stepped in to buy power on the company's behalf. But before things got ugly, Edison enjoyed two flush years of artificially high rates. During 1998 and 1999, the company pocketed billions from its customers, paid down debt and sent money to its parent firm, Edison International. Now Edison wants to divide the question. The money that flowed in, Edison says, the company should get to keep. And the money that flowed out -- well, that should be someone else's responsibility. The utility is asking the Legislature to ignore the first two years of hefty profits and reimburse the company for the one year of big losses. Gov. Gray Davis negotiated his version of the Edison bailout several months ago, but that deal was seen as so rich for the company that it went nowhere in the Legislature. The Senate approved its version last week, a bill that would reduce the payout to Edison by $1 billion and then stick business with the remaining tab. The Assembly, meanwhile, is considering two other measures, both of which would spread the pain between business and residential consumers. "This is corporate welfare at its worst," state Sen. Bill Morrow, R-Oceanside, said of the Senate bill. "This is not even a bailout. It's a corporate handout." Edison and the state's other big utility, Pacific Gas & Electric, which is already in bankruptcy, say they are entitled to the money because they never should have been put in the position of charging less for electricity than they were paying to obtain it. That's a legal argument that belongs before a judge. There is a good chance the court would want to balance the profits the utilities made under deregulation with the losses they incurred. Under that scenario, they wouldn't need a bailout. But even if the utilities were to win their case, consumers probably would fare no worse than they would under the various legislative proposals under consideration. Sen. Steve Peace, D-San Diego, who helped craft the 1996 bill that restructured the industry and who now supports the Edison bailout, lectured his fellow senators on the floor the other day about the need to take a risk. "We can do nothing and be safe," Peace said. "Or we can do something, and do our job." Everyone is weary of the state's energy crisis. It is human nature to want to get it behind us, to sweep it away, even at great cost. But lawmakers shouldn't feel it's their job to "do something" -- especially when that thing carries a multibillion-dollar price tag for consumers. This time, doing nothing means standing up for ratepayers. What's the shame in that? The Bee's Daniel Weintraub can be reached at (916) 321-1914 or at dweintraub@sacbee.com <mailto:dweintraub@sacbee.com>. State consultants don't see need for more rate hikes \ objattph Outlook brightens; price cut may be possible by 2003 By Ed Mendel UNION-TRIBUNE STAFF WRITER July 23, 2001 SACRAMENTO -- State consultants, releasing a new estimate of power costs with an improved outlook, said yesterday they do not believe an additional rate increase will be needed -- and a rate cut may be possible by 2003. The state issued a long-awaited "revenue requirement" asking for a little more than half of the revenue from a record rate increase imposed by the state Public Utilities Commission earlier this year. The state power-purchasing agency, the Department of Water Resources, wants 1.65 cents of an increase of 3 cents per kilowatt-hour that began last month for customers of Pacific Gas and Electric and Southern California Edison. The PUC is not expected to rule on the state's revenue request until the middle of next month, when the regulators also are scheduled to approve an increase for the customers of San Diego Gas & Electric. PG&E and Edison did not immediately say whether the state's proposal would leave enough money for the utilities. But as if expecting criticism, the state consultants said utilities often ask for larger rate increases than they are granted. An adviser to Gov. Gray Davis said the administration was "mocked" by critics when it forecast in April that the average cost of power would drop during the summer, even though heat would drive up the demand for power. "Quote: 'They just don't know what they are doing,' " consultant S. David Freeman recalled the critics saying. "Well, we did know what we were doing. Quite frankly, I think this is a good-news story of major proportions." The widely derided forecast issued in April said the average cost of power that must be purchased on the expensive spot market would drop from $346 per megawatt-hour in April through June to $195 in July through September. Now the "reasonably conservative" estimate is that the average price of power in July through September will be $129 to $130 per megawatt-hour, said Ron Nichols of Navigant Consulting. Nichols attributed the price drop to a number of factors: long-term contracts, cooler weather, cheaper natural gas used by generators, more small and large generators back online and floating federal price caps. The state began buying power for utility customers Jan. 17 after PG&E and Edison, whose rates were frozen by deregulation as wholesale power costs soared, ran up massive debts and were no longer able to borrow. The consultants estimated that the state will have spent $13 billion on power by the end of next year. But they also predicted that the state power-purchasing fund would develop a substantial surplus by then. "That would allow for a rate decrease in 2003, based on our current projections," said Joseph Fichera of Saber Partners. The new revenue requirement issued by the state yesterday is needed for a series of actions planned by the PUC next month to pay for a record bond issue to repay the taxpayer-supported state general fund for power purchases. Fichera said that, despite reports to the contrary, the recommendation is for a $12.5 billion bond -- leaving a cushion in the authorization of $13.4 billion. The bond will be paid off by ratepayers over 15 years. The consultants said their projection of state power costs is cautious. They assume consumer conservation will drop from 7 percent to 6 percent, though it actually has been 11 percent and 12 percent in recent months. The projections are intended to leave some ability to absorb unforeseen costs, such as scorching temperatures later this summer or next summer, or a spike in natural gas prices as happened last winter. The cost projections do not include any overcharge refund from generators. Davis has asked federal regulators for an $8.9 billion refund and has vowed to seek full recovery in the courts. The governor wants to get the state out of the power-buying business by the end of next year. But that requires legislative approval of a rescue plan for Edison that could become a model for getting PG&E out of bankruptcy. The Senate, which left for a monthlong recess after approving a state budget early yesterday, approved an Edison rescue plan that the utility says is too weak to restore its ability to borrow. The Assembly is struggling with two competing Edison rescue plans. Talks may continue during the recess in an attempt to reach an agreement before the Aug. 15 deadline set by Davis to reach a deal to keep Edison out of bankruptcy. The consultants say there is enough room in the existing rates to give the two utilities a revenue stream for bonds to pay off their debts -- 0.4 cent per kilowatt-hour for Edison and 0.7 cent for PG&E. Fichera said he disagrees with speculation that falling power prices and the rate increase might give Edison enough revenue to avoid bankruptcy without a legislative rescue plan. To pay off Edison's $3.5 billion debt, he said, $2 billion would come from the bond, but $1.5 billion would have to come from the sale of Edison's transmission system to the state under the governor's plan. Senate committee told Morgan Stanley destroyed power records \ objattph ASSOCIATED PRESS July 23, 2001 SACRAMENTO ) Morgan Stanley, a multibillion dollar financial firm and adviser to several power generators, destroyed documents that potentially could show efforts to gouge California consumers ) and a state Senate committee wants to know why. The company recently also has come under the scrutiny of an Oregon lawmaker who is concerned the company's purchase of the rights to move power between California and Oregon could result in artificially high prices. For several weeks, Morgan Stanley had told the committee it would provide the documents, but said last week they had been destroyed as a matter of routine "years ago," said Sen. Joe Dunn, D-Santa Ana, the committee's chairman. Members of the committee are trying to determine whether power companies worked together to raise prices by purposefully holding back electricity to drive up demand. Morgan Stanley's involvement would have been several years ago, when it advised out-of-state energy companies to buy California power plants up for sale. A Morgan Stanley attorney told the Orange County Register that the company did not destroy any documents after Dunn's committee requested the documents May 16. "At the end of the project, they decided what they were going to keep and what they weren't going to keep, and those decisions were made years before the energy crisis and years before the committee existed," said Paul Patono, a company attorney. Dunn noted it is not illegal to raise prices as long as a company doesn't collude to force prices upward. Private utilities became able to sell their plants as part of the 1996 plan to deregulate the electricity market. Although the plants were expected to sell below their book value, they instead sold for up to three times that price, although the state then had an oversupply of electricity and old plants. While the public was told deregulation would lead to lower electricity prices, energy officials and experts testifying before the committee have said it's unlikely investors would buy aging power plants if they believed that to be true. Dunn is curious if there was any kind of plan or advertising that said the plants, if bought a certain way, would give of the buyers market power in the wholesale electricity market. The committee is still moving forward with contempt proceedings against Houston-based power marketers Enron Corp. and Reliant Energy for refusing to hand over documents to committee investigators. New York-based Morgan Stanley, now Morgan Stanley Dean Witter & Co., got into the energy trading in 1984 and now is one of the top 20 U.S. power marketers. The company also has come under the scope of Rep. Peter DeFazio, D-Ore. Morgan Stanley bought the rights to transmit just under a third of the power flowing between California and Oregon from the Bonneville Power Administration through February 2002. DeFazio has written a letter to the BPA, asking that the agency make sure the Northwest keeps its "reliable, affordable" energy source. "The ability of a financial services company, which has no obligation to serve electricity consumers, to lock up all available capacity for a year raises serious concerns," DeFazio wrote. A company spokeswoman said Morgan Stanley acquired the transmission capacity from BPA to meet its power delivery obligations in the Northwest, and had no intention of manipulating the market. News briefs on the California power crisis \ objattph ASSOCIATED PRESS July 24, 2001 IRVINE ) Future Olympic swimmers in Southern California may no longer have a training facility if the state's power crisis continues. Utility bills have jumped significantly over the past couple of months and aquatic centers across Southern California have felt the pinch. At Heritage Park in Irvine, home to gold medalist Amanda Beard and silver medalist Aaron Peirsol, the monthly energy bill has doubled from $7,000 to between $13,000 and $15,000. Officials at the Rose Bowl Aquatics Center in Pasadena have raised membership fees 10 percent to offset electricity costs that have more than doubled. The Industry Hills Aquatics Complex in Industry may close its doors on Sept. 9, in part because of the rate increases. Gas-powered heaters and electric motors run 24 hours a day at most swimming centers to keep water temperatures warm. Some swim coaches said a temperature drop in the pool can hamper an athlete's training regiment and possibly raise health concerns. Swimming facilities run on a tight budget, say coaches, and the soaring energy costs have eaten away any profit margins the training programs once had. The Industry Hills facility has even used trash and methane gas from the landfill it sits on to heat the pool. But the complex lost about $85,000 last year and operators expect natural gas costs will double this winter. The property management company, which owns the land, has given a Sept. 9 deadline to reduce operating costs or close the swimming center. )) CHINO ) The largest of 11 power plants that are supposed to be built by Sept. 30 under the governor's emergency fast-track program appears to be running behind schedule. The concrete foundation hasn't been poured at the $125-million natural gas facility, which sits near the California Institution for Men in Chino. The plant, being built by Delta Power Co. of New Jersey, would supply about 135,000 homes with electricity. Environmentalists warn that the plant will produce smog five times more than the legal limit and want state air quality officials, who will conduct a hearing Tuesday, to deny a final operating permit to Delta Power. Delta officials said they hope to meet the Sept. 30 deadline despite the objections by environmentalists and residents who live near the proposed plant. They also pledged to install equipment by November that would reduce nitrogen oxide compounds, which contribute to smog. If Delta and other energy companies finish their power plants by the end of September, they receive incentives such as eliminating environmental analyses and the ability to emit pollutants for months at levels exceeding state standards. State sells surplus power at a loss \ objattph ASSOCIATED PRESS July 23, 2001 LOS ANGELES ) State officials sold excess electricity at a loss of nearly $14 million in the first 16 days of July ) roughly 4.5 percent of the total amount the state spent on power during that period. According to the Department of Water Resources, the state purchased 3.5 million megawatt-hours at an average price of $118 per megawatt-hour. It sold off 177,000 surplus megawatt-hours at an average price of $36.95 per megawatt-hour. Industry officials told the Los Angeles Times it is routine for utilities and electric companies to at times either sell power at a loss, work out an exchange or give it away when they find themselves with surplus power. However, some say this is an indication that the state government does not belong in the power business. The sales of surplus power "get to the issue of, do these people really know what they're doing? Are they really competent to be managing this to the lowest cost for the ratepayers?" said Assemblyman John Campbell, R-Irvine. "It reinforces to me that we should get the state out of doing this as soon as practically possible." Department of Water Resources Director Thomas Hannigan disclosed the details in response to an inquiry by Campbell. Assemblyman Roderick Wright, D-Los Angeles, said he did not see a problem with DWR's power sales. "Right now the summer is cool," said Wright, who is also chairman of the Assembly utilities committee. "If this had been a normal July, we would have used all that power." Department of Water Resources officials expect the sales to stop if temperatures heat up later this week. Department spokesman Oscar Hidalgo said the sales show that the water department has stabilized the state's electricity market. The average price the department has paid for a megawatt-hour is falling, from $271 in May to $119 in June to $89 so far in July. Since January, the state has spent more than $8 billion buying electricity for the customers of three financially ailing utilities ) Pacific Gas and Electric Co., Southern California Edison Co. and San Diego Gas and Electric Co. The state had to take over buying electricity to keep the state's lights on after federal energy regulators ruled that only creditworthy entities could buy electricity. CHINO Rush for Power Plant in Chino Raises Concerns Energy: The facility may exceed pollution limits if it begins operations by Sept. 30. Opponents say that would endanger public health. By TERENCE MONMANEY TIMES STAFF WRITER July 24 2001 CHINO -- Seldom are government bureaucrats criticized for moving too quickly, but so goes the battle here over a power plant slated for the sun-blasted grounds of a men's prison. The proposed plant--big enough to supply 135,000 homes--is one of five in California that have been licensed to start up despite exceeding pollution standards as part of Gov. Gray Davis' rush to bring more power online. The program, covering small to mid-size facilities that run during hours of peak demand, slashes licensing review from a year to three weeks, eliminates comprehensive environmental analyses, and authorizes plants to emit pollutants for months at levels exceeding state and federal air quality laws. The catch is that the plants must operate by Sept. 30 or those rare and lucrative incentives could be withdrawn--a possibility confronting developers of the Chino plant, which a growing number of environmentalists opposes. So far, with only 69 days left until the deadline, workers haven't poured a drop of concrete foundation for the $125-million natural gas-burning facility, developed by Delta Power Co. of New Jersey. The site is on the outskirts of the California Institution for Men. The proposed plant, the largest of 11 so-called peakers given expedited approval, is galvanizing opposition to the governor's emergency fast-track program. Environmentalists decry the fact that until the plant installs devices to reduce nitrogen oxide compounds, which contribute to smog, the level of the pollutant will reach five times the legal limit. Five groups, including the Natural Resources Defense Council and the Planning and Conservation League, have joined in petitioning state air quality officials to deny the plant a final operating permit. They contend that excess nitrogen oxides will endanger public health and that the fast-track process jeopardizes decades of gains against smog. "We're not necessarily opposed to a power plant on the site," said Gail Ruderman Feuer, an attorney in the Los Angeles office of the Natural Resources Defense Council. "We're just opposed to one without environmental review and without all the pollution controls." Critics also are wary of the fast-track process because the state has a vested interest in making sure the plants are built quickly. The Davis administration has promised to spend billions buying electricity from plants that aren't built yet. "It's a massive subterfuge," said Sandra Spelliscy, an attorney with the Planning and Conservation League in Sacramento. Jay Roland, manager of the Chino facility for Pegasus Power Partners, a subsidiary of Delta, said the extra nitrogen oxides released from the plant for a month or so are "not going to cause damage to anybody." Roland said he is so frustrated by the "interveners," he sometimes wishes the whole state would go dark, to underscore the power shortage that the plant is intended to address. Though opponents have made a tough job even tougher, he said he hoped to make the end-of-summer deadline. Missing it could mean applying to the state all over again under the old rules, he said. "Then I sit here nine months with $120 million in equipment that's not generating any revenue." State officials said it was necessary to approve the extra-polluting plants because of the need to avoid blackouts and because there is a backlog of emissions-control equipment. Besides, they said, state-of-the-art gas-burning plants emit fewer pollutants without controls than do many older plants with them. Kevin Kennedy, a California Energy Commission official who reviewed the Chino project, acknowledged that public involvement in the process has suffered somewhat. "It's been difficult to get the word out . . . to make sure people in the communities have enough information to know what's going on." Site Seems Ideal for Power Plant In many respects, the 11-acre Chino site looks right for a power plant. It rests on flat surplus land at the northern boundary of the state's largest prison property, where grasslands cover hundreds of acres. Half a mile away is a booming warehouse district and a Southern California Edison substation, which would relay the new power to the transmission grid. Moreover, Pegasus runs a small power plant on the prison property across a narrow utility road from the site. Supplying steam and a few megawatts to the penal institution, the company sells the bulk of its 27 megawatt output to Edison. Delta's president, Dean Vanech, bristles at charges that his company doesn't care about the environment. He said equipment to reduce nitrogen oxide compounds won't be available until around November, at which time engineers will work "as quickly as humanly possible" to install it. Other air pollutants, such as carbon monoxide and microscopic dust particles, will be controlled from the beginning. Also, though energy officials reviewed the proposal in a matter of weeks, they closely scrutinized the company's nine-part application, which took two months and $1 million to assemble, plant officials say. The company moved the plant's site after biologists discovered two protected bird species nesting nearby--burrowing owls and red-tailed hawks. That required engineers to redesign gas, water and transmission lines and tinker with the plant structure, Roland said. Owlets in a nest by a proposed transmission tower still pose an obstacle. "We have to wait for the babies to leave," construction manager Robert Surette said. Key decisions over the plant's future lie with the South Coast Air Quality Management District, the air pollution agency, which said in May it would give the Chino plant a construction permit. But after environmental groups petitioned in late June, the agency asked Pegasus for more data describing the possible impact of elevated levels of nitrogen oxides on people in the plant's vicinity. "We're still in the evaluation phase, and we're not going to prejudge this project," said district executive director Barry Wallerstein. He said the plant emissions were probably negligible compared with those from the parade of diesel trucks in the nearby warehouse district. Those "could be a larger health hazard to the community than this particular power plant," he said. Public Hearing to Be Held Today The air quality agency has scheduled a public hearing today at its Diamond Bar office to weigh issuing the plant a waiver needed to exceed state air quality standards. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency has indicated it will not prosecute the Pegasus plant for temporarily emitting more nitrogen oxides than the federal Clean Air Act permits. Vanech of Delta said the company would want to build the plant even if it had not received expedited approval: "The reason we're doing the project is that we have a favorable long-term view of the California energy market.' Delta operates 13 power plants nationwide, five of them in California on state-controlled property. The Chino plant promises to benefit this diverse, mostly blue-collar city of 66,000. Although the developer is leasing the property from the state, Delta agreed to pay the city $500,000 up front, plus $75,000 annually and millions more over the years in water and natural gas fees. Vanech said the half-million-dollar "host fee" was compensation to City Hall for its swift handling of the project's mountainous paperwork and for the wear and tear that construction crews will cause on city roads. In the neighborhood closest to the plant, where large new houses rest on half-acre lots fronted by bridle paths, residents seemed divided. Jim Tippings, 59, who is retired, said he didn't have a problem with the plant running a month or so without full nitrogen oxide controls: "I don't think a month is going to hurt us." Rising utility bills are what really hurt, he said. Up the street, 35-year-old Kent Hobbenslefken was not aware that a power plant was going up a mile away. A former hazardous waste manager who sells health insurance, he was skeptical of the need to run the generators without full pollution controls, just to meet a bureaucratic deadline. "What's a couple of months delay?" he said. "We're already in the crisis. What's it going to do for John Q. Public? Are our rates going to go down? I don't think so." MORE INSIDE Power glut: An excess forces sale of power at a $14-million loss. B8 Getting soaked: High utility costs threaten swimming programs. D1 Copyright 2001, Los Angeles Times <http://www.latimes.com> Surplus Power Sold at a Loss Electricity: Cool summer and effective conservation efforts result in excess supplies. Industry officials say it's a routine move. By NANCY VOGEL TIMES STAFF WRITER July 24 2001 SACRAMENTO -- Caught with an excess of electricity as a result of cool weather and heavy conservation, the state government sold power at a loss approaching $14 million in the first 16 days of July. The loss amounts to roughly 3.5% of the total amount the state spent on power during that period. To keep power flowing to 27 million Californians, the state purchased 3.5 million megawatt-hours at an average price of $118 per megawatt-hour, according to the state Department of Water Resources. It sold off 177,000 surplus megawatt-hours at an average price of $36.95 per megawatt-hour. Department of Water Resources Director Thomas Hannigan disclosed the details in response to an inquiry by Assemblyman John Campbell (R-Irvine). The sales of surplus power "get to the issue of, do these people really know what they're doing? Are they really competent to be managing this to the lowest cost for the ratepayers?" Campbell said. "It reinforces to me that we should get the state out of doing this as soon as practically possible." Industry officials, however, say it is routine for utilities and electricity companies to at times find themselves with more electricity than their customers need. They either sell the power at a loss, work out an exchange of power or give it away. "It's not all that uncommon for utilities to be buying one day and selling the next," said one Pacific Northwest trader who asked not to be identified because his company does not permit him to talk to reporters. He said a rule of thumb in the industry is to match supply to demand within 1% to 2%, although "5% on a load like California isn't that much." Assemblyman Roderick Wright (D-Los Angeles), chairman of the Assembly utilities committee, said he did not see a problem with DWR's power sales. "Right now the summer is cool," he said. "If this had been a normal July, we would have used all that power." "The worm could have turned the other way." Department of Water Resources spokesman Oscar Hidalgo said the state's crew of 15 power purchasers found themselves selling a "very minimal" amount of electricity in May. In June, more power was sold, but less than was sold in July, he said. The department has not released those figures. Department officials expect the sales to stop if temperatures heat up later this week. The water department was thrust into the role of buying 30% to 50% of the state's overall electricity in January after the state's major utilities became so financially crippled by high wholesale electricity prices that energy companies refused to sell to them. The department has so far spent roughly $8 billion of taxpayer money purchasing power that is sent to the customers of Pacific Gas & Electric, Southern California Edison and San Diego Gas & Electric. Hidalgo said the sales show that the water department has stabilized the state's electricity market. The average price the department has paid for a megawatt-hour is falling, from $271 in May to $119 in June to $89 so far in July. "If we were out scrambling for power right now," Hidalgo said, "the market would reflect that and adjust to it, and we would most likely be paying much more in overall purchases." Campbell said he assumes the department sold its most expensive, marginal megawatts of power. But Hidalgo said that is not necessarily so. The department does not track what it paid for the power it sells, he said. The department's statement to Campbell shows sales to 25 different companies, including the federal Bonneville Power Administration, the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power, and several private energy companies that bought power plants from California's utilities under the state's 1996 deregulation scheme. Those firms include Dynegy Corp., Reliant Energy, Mirant Corp. and Duke Energy. Copyright 2001, Los Angeles Times <http://www.latimes.com> Pacific Gas Gets 4-Month Extension on Filing Plan Bloomberg News July 24 2001 PG&E Corp.'s Pacific Gas & Electric, California's largest utility, won a four-month extension to file a Chapter 11 recovery plan free from interference from creditors and other groups. The utility's sole right to file a plan was extended from Aug. 6 to Dec. 6. Creditors, shareholders and others with a stake in the case could have presented their own plans had the extension not been granted. Companies reorganizing under Chapter 11 have the sole right to advance a recovery plan in the first 120 days after filing for bankruptcy. Courts routinely extend this period in large and complex cases. A committee representing unsecured creditors in court papers said it "firmly believes that all parties in interest should move quickly and provide assurance that any filed plan will pay creditors in full and remedy PG&E's various issues and problems." PG&E Corp. shares fell 75 cents to close at to $14.25 on the New York Stock Exchange. Copyright 2001, Los Angeles Times <http://www.latimes.com> State sells surplus electricity at a loss BUY HIGH, SELL LOW: $14 million deficit Paul Feist, Lynda Gledhill, Chronicle Staff Writers <mailto:lgledhill@sfchronicle.com> Tuesday, July 24, 2001 ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle </chronicle/info/copyright> URL: <http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2001/07/24/MN217124.DTL> California has lost $14 million during the past three weeks selling surplus electricity back to power generators as mild temperatures and energy conservation slackened demand statewide. The state, which has spent more than $8 billion purchasing power on behalf of financially troubled utilities, became an electricity seller this month, racking up losses and triggering criticism from Republican lawmakers and consumer groups. State Department of Water Resources Director Thomas M. Hannigan said in a letter that since July 1, the state had sold 177,571 megawatt hours at a rate of $36.95 each. California paid just over $118 a megawatt hour for the electricity, Hannigan said in the letter to Assemblyman John Campbell, R- Irvine. Some of the exports to 25 buyers went to out-of-state power providers such as Atlanta-based Mirant and Texas-based Reliant Energy, which a state Senate committee has found in contempt for not complying with subpoenas for documents as part of its investigation into alleged price manipulation. Excess electricity also went to public power agencies such as the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power and even abroad to Powerex, the trading arm of BC Hydro. The giant Canadian power firm has started issuing rebates to its customers, citing "strong exports" to California and elsewhere earlier this year. "To me this reinforces the idea that the state should get out of the power buying business as soon as practically possible," Campbell said. TAXPAYERS GET STUCK When Pacific Gas & Electric Co. or Southern California Edison makes a similar mistake, he said, shareholders pay for it. But when the Department of Water Resources is to blame, taxpayers are left holding the bag. A spokesman for Gov. Gray Davis defended the losses, calling them minuscule in the bigger context of the state's power-purchasing strategy. "This is all an inexact science," said Davis spokesman Steve Maviglio. "This has been a handful of days over seven months, and the amount is minuscule. If the choice is keeping the lights on or having rolling blackouts, it's a small risk to take." Because power can't be stored, all power trading operations are occasionally forced to sell excess electricity, Maviglio said. He said that people would have laughed in January had the administration predicted that the state would have more than enough power this summer. Mild weather and a strong conservation effort by Californians have led to days when the state hasn't needed all the power it has on hand. SHARP DROP IN DEMAND In recent days, the peak load on California's grid has been around 33,000 megawatts -- far below the 40,000-plus megawatt demand that can come on a hot summer day. "When we bought power at these prices, who would have thought that it was going to be the coolest July in 20 years?" said Assemblyman Rod Wright, D-Los Angeles. "The problem becomes when you second-guess things." The state Department of Water Resources has negotiated about $43 billion worth of electricity contracts spanning 15 to 20 years. The contracts were made public after media organizations, including The Chronicle, and GOP lawmakers sued the Davis administration. Consumer groups yesterday criticized the losses, calling them an inevitable byproduct of the state's entry into the power-buying business. "It's one of the costs of secrecy. You've got an agency that is totally unaccountable to the public," said Doug Heller, a consumer advocate with the Foundation for Taxpayer and Consumer Rights. "They haven't done a great job of serving the public's needs for energy procurement." Assemblywoman Carole Migden, D-San Francisco, said Campbell and other critics were not being fair to the Davis administration. "You can't say at one time get the energy situation under control, but then question every line item a month out," she said. E-mail the reporters at pfeist@sfchronicle.com <mailto:pfeist@sfchronicle.com> and lgledhill@sfchronicle.com <mailto:lgledhill@sfchronicle.com>. ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle </chronicle/info/copyright> Page A - 1 San Diego tries to undo the damage THE PLAN: Regional public power David Lazarus, Chronicle Staff Writer <mailto:dlazarus@sfchronicle.com> Tuesday, July 24, 2001 ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle </chronicle/info/copyright> URL: <http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2001/07/24/MN190387.DTL> San Diego -- This city, which was first to bear the brunt of the state's energy crisis a year ago as electricity bills tripled, is now aiming to be first with a long- term solution: regional public power. A bill is making its way through the Legislature -- and being fought at every turn by the power industry -- to make San Diego County one of the largest municipal utility districts in the nation. If the measure fails, San Diego officials intend to refashion the local water authority as an alternative utility hub that would construct efficient new plants and steal business away from costlier, decades-old facilities owned by out-of-state generators. Some consumer advocates believe that San Diego's efforts could serve as a model for large-scale public power systems in Northern California. "If we can pull this off, we can bring down prices and show the way to energy independence," said Rep. Bob Filner, D-San Diego. "If we don't change the rules, we're going to be back where we were." It won't be easy, though. Even if San Diego can overcome vigorous opposition from power companies, its public-power scheme still could run afoul of Gov. Gray Davis, who is counting on statewide revenue to finance next month's municipal bond offering, the largest in U.S. history. Going its own way as a municipal utility district would mean San Diego could avoid purchasing electricity from the state Department of Water Resources, thus reducing the flow of cash into California's coffers. Steve Maviglio, a spokesman for the governor, said Davis would not take a position on San Diego's public-power bill until it cleared the Legislature. "But the governor would obviously look extremely carefully at anything that would affect revenue to pay off the bonds," he said. Twelve months after California's energy crisis first erupted in San Diego, leading to statewide blackouts and financial catastrophe for utilities, residents of this city, to a large extent, have tried to put last summer's difficulties behind them. San Diego Gas & Electric Co., owned by Sempra Energy, had been the first of California's three investor-owned utilities to pay off outstanding debts and thus qualify for a lifting of the rate freeze that accompanied deregulation of the state's power market. Unfortunately for San Diegans, wholesale electricity prices suddenly skyrocketed, and San Diego Gas & Electric was free to pass along its rising costs directly to consumers. Customers of Pacific Gas and Electric Co. and Southern California Edison were still protected by the rate freeze and thus saw no changes in their power bills -- although the two utilities, in turn, were forced to absorb about $14 billion in unrecovered expenses. San Diego power rates subsequently were limited by state regulators to restore stability to the local market -- but not before many residential and business customers saw their monthly bills go through the roof. "I'm still paying almost double what I was paying before," said George Aguilar, owner of a downtown jewelry store. "We should talk to lawyers and sue the people in the government responsible for this. It was pure negligence." WELL-INFORMED POLITICIANS In fact, San Diego's political leaders are now among the best informed in the nation about energy issues and the volatility of electricity markets. When power bills spiked last year, outraged consumers demanded that their representatives take steps to remedy the situation. Democrats and Republicans alike took a crash course in the frequently arcane minutiae of the energy business. "We didn't create this problem. We didn't make any mistakes," said San Diego Supervisor Dianne Jacob, who has been among the most aggressive local politicians in responding to the energy mess and is a leading proponent of the county's public-power plan. "But one way or another, we're going to have to pay for it," she said. "This was a very bad experiment." Her solution is to establish a vast municipal utility that essentially would take over the entire service area of San Diego Gas & Electric, which provides power to 1.2 million customers. PLANS FOR NEW POWER PLANTS The county-run utility would build its own power plants and renewable- energy resources and would transmit electricity to customers over existing San Diego Gas & Electric lines. Funding for the municipal utility's activities is not yet clear. "There's no question in my mind that we can generate power for less than what the generators are putting on the market," Jacob said. REGIONAL APPROACH PRAISED Medea Benjamin, a San Francisco consumer advocate, said the regional approach sought by San Diego -- which requires a rewriting of state law -- would benefit consumers by making construction of new plants more economically feasible. Municipal utility districts statewide are now limited to individual cities. The Los Angeles Department of Water and Power is one of the few large enough to generate its own juice and sell off excess capacity. San Francisco voters will be asked in November whether to replace the existing San Francisco Public Utilities Commission with an independent power and water authority. "It would be wonderful if San Diego's disastrous experience with deregulation results in them taking a leadership role in creation of regional public power," Benjamin said. Not everyone, however, backs the plan. San Diego Gas & Electric's parent, Sempra, has actively lobbied against the public-power bill in Sacramento, fearing that it would allow seizure of the utility's distribution system by a county energy authority. "It's unclear what the bill is trying to accomplish," said Art Larson, a Sempra spokesman. "California's energy crisis isn't a local-utility problem. It's a demand-and-supply problem." PUBLIC OWNERSHIP CRITICIZED Another considerable opponent of the plan is Jessie Knight, head of the San Diego Regional Chamber of Commerce and a former member of the state Public Utilities Commission. He believes that public officials are no match for savvy power-industry executives in a competitive marketplace and that the county cannot guarantee lower rates by building its own plants. "This thing looks like the biggest shell game in the world," Knight said. Moreover, he said, he could not see how San Diego would win legislative backing for regional public power when state authorities, including the governor, were counting on revenue from all customers to back California's multibillion-dollar bond offering. Assemblyman Mark Wyland, R-Escondido (San Diego County), author of the public-power bill, said it was too soon for anyone to speculate about San Diego's breaking away from the rest of the state's power grid. "We have to be realistic about the future of this," he said. "Right now, SDG&E is the utility in San Diego County, and there is no intent to transform that overnight." Meanwhile, in case Wyland's bill is defeated, a separate legislative effort is taking shape to expand the San Diego water authority's jurisdiction to include electricity. E-mail David Lazarus at dlazarus@sfchronicle.com <mailto:dlazarus@sfchronicle.com>. ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle </chronicle/info/copyright> Page A - 1 13 plans submitted to alleviate power transmission bottleneck Carolyn Lochhead, Chronicle Washington Bureau <mailto:clochhead@sfchronicle.com> Tuesday, July 24, 2001 ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle </chronicle/info/copyright> URL: <http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/chronicle/archive/2001/07/24/ MN185739.DTL> Washington -- More than a dozen private investors have turned in proposals to ease a Central Valley bottleneck in California's electricity transmission grid that can contribute to blackouts in Northern California, Energy Secretary Spencer Abraham said yesterday. The 13 investment plans were in response to the Bush administration's national energy plan, which called for the expansion of Path 15, an 84-mile stretch of interconnected transmission lines located between Los Banos (Merced County) and Coalinga (Fresno County). The lines form the main link for power flows between the northern and southern parts of the state. "When we announced our plan in May to upgrade Path 15, it was dismissed as an old idea on which little had ever been done," Abraham said in a statement. "Today, I am pleased to announce that those days of neglect and inaction are over." The administration's plan calls for $230 million in new investment from local utilities and other private entities. Abraham called it "the first concrete step to relieve congestion on the state's power grid." The Bush administration, he said, "is taking a leadership role in addressing a long-neglected problem in Caifornia's electricity transmission system." Pacific Gas and Electric Co. owns Path 15. During the late 1980s, the utility held public hearings in the Central Valley to discuss a possible expansion, but dropped the plans after concluding that existing transmission lines could handle future demand. When California's electricity shortages began to mount last year, Path 15 proved to be a major bottleneck. By preventing an increased flow of power from the southern to the northern parts of the state, it contributed to blackouts in Northern California. Earlier this year, the state PUC ordered an upgrade to the transmission system. The federal Western Area Power Administration, which manages hydropower projects in the Central Valley, is conducting studies for the Path 15 expansion and will be holding environmental impact hearings in Coalinga on Aug. 27 and in Los Banos on Aug. 28. More information is available on the agency's Web site at www.WAPA.gov <http://www.WAPA.gov>. The agency will review the proposals and make a recommendation to Abraham. The proposals were made by, among others, PG&E Corp., Calpine Corp. and Mirant Corp, the Western Area Power Administration said. The expansion plans calls for a third transmission line and other upgrades that would permit an additional 1,500 megawatts of transmission capacity, enough to power 1.5 million homes. Construction time is estimated at three to four years and would cost $300 million. The companies are expected to recapture their investment by adding a surcharge on power transmitted over the new lines, Abraham said. The expansion is likely to follow the same route identified in the hearings a decade ago, running in a 2,000-foot-wide corridor through the foothills west of Interstate 5, mainly over privately owned ranchland. In a related development, Sen. Barbara Boxer, D-Calif., hailed an agreement between the House and Senate to spend $1.3 million for the new environmental impact report and feasibility studies to expand Path 15. The money will go to the Western Area Power Administration. Tell us what you think -- What are your suggestions for saving energy? Send your best tips to Energy Desk, San Francisco Chronicle, 901 Mission St., San Francisco CA 94103; or put your ideas in an energy-efficient e-mail to energysaver@sfchronicle.com <mailto:energysaver@sfchronicle.com>. Chronicle news services contributed to this report. / E-mail Carolyn Lochhead at clochhead@sfchronicle.com <mailto:clochhead@sfchronicle.com>. ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle </chronicle/info/copyright> Page A - 10 Developments in California's energy crisis The Associated Press Tuesday, July 24, 2001 ,2001 Associated Press URL: <http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/news/archive/2001/07/24/state 1037EDT0155.DTL> (07-24) 07:37 PDT (AP) -- Developments in California's energy crisis: TUESDAY: * No power alerts Tuesday as electricity reserves stay above 7 percent. MONDAY: * U.S. Energy Secretary Spencer Abraham unveils a plan to help alleviate a transmission bottleneck that has kept power from flowing freely throughout the state during times of peak usage. The plan calls for expanding the state's power grid along so-called Path 15 by attracting private investment for the $300 million project. * A Senate committee investigating possible price manipulation has given the full Senate a report asking for Houston-based Enron Corp. to be cited for contempt. The Senate Select Committee to Investigate Price Manipulation of the Wholesale Energy Market says Enron failed to comply with a subpoena for financial and trading documents. The Senate recessed Sunday until Aug. 20 and could take up the matter when it returns. * Secretary of State Bill Jones asks the state Assembly to allot $250,000 for a legislative review into whether Gov. Gray Davis' advisers complied with conflicts of interest laws. Jones, a Republican who plans to challenge Davis in the next election, says the advisers failed to disclose that they held stock in energy companies. The Senate rejected a proposal Saturday to earmark that money for a bipartisan investigation. Steve Maviglio, Davis' spokesman, says the governor's office, the attorney general and the Fair Political Practices Commission are "working together to resolve any conflicts of interest and to deal appropriately with any violations." * U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Dennis Montali gives Pacific Gas and Electric Co. four additional months to produce a reorganization plan in its Chapter 11 filing. PG&E lawyers had argued for the extension because of the complexity of the case. The bankruptcy case is believed to be the largest ever. * The Department of Water Resources says that since July 1, the state has sold 177,571 megawatt hours at $36.95 each. During the same time, DWR purchased 3.5 million megawatt hours of electricity at $118 per megawatt hour. That amounts to a loss of about $14 million. Assemblyman John Campbell, R-Irvine, says it's proof the state needs to get out of the power business. DWR spokesman Oscar Hildalgo says it's normal for utilities to sell excess power they have purchased. * Shares of Edison International close at $13.67, down 57 cents. PG&E Corp. stock close at $14.25, down 75 cents. Shares of Sempra Energy, the parent company of San Diego Gas & Electric Co., close at $25.20, down $1.09. * No power alerts Monday as electricity reserves stay above 7 percent. WHAT'S NEXT: * The deadline for the Legislature to approve Davis' rescue deal for Southern California Edison is Aug. 15. THE PROBLEM: High demand, high wholesale energy costs, transmission glitches and a tight supply worsened by scarce hydroelectric power in the Northwest and maintenance at aging California power plants are all factors in California's electricity crisis. Southern California Edison and Pacific Gas and Electric say they've lost nearly $14 billion since June 2000 to high wholesale prices the state's electricity deregulation law bars them from passing on to consumers. PG&E, saying it hasn't received the help it needs from regulators or state lawmakers, filed for federal bankruptcy protection April 6. Electricity and natural gas suppliers, scared off by the companies' poor credit ratings, are refusing to sell to them, leading the state in January to start buying power for the utilities' nearly 9 million residential and business customers. The state is also buying power for a third investor-owned utility, San Diego Gas & Electric, which is in better financial shape than much larger Edison and PG&E but is also struggling with high wholesale power costs. The Public Utilities Commission has approved average rate increases of 37 percent for the heaviest residential customers and 38 percent for commercial customers, and hikes of up to 49 percent for industrial customers and 15 percent or 20 percent for agricultural customers to help finance the state's multibillion-dollar power buys. Figures show state lost big on extra power Posted at 9:53 p.m. PDT Monday, July 23, 2001 BY JOHN WOOLFOLK Mercury News State figures show California may have lost about $14 million this month selling surplus electricity for less than it cost. The Mercury News disclosed last week that some power was being sold at a loss. But the new figures provide the first indication of just how much excess power the state bought in its desperate effort to avoid blackouts -- and how cheaply some of that power was sold when it turned out not to be needed. A Republican lawmaker said Monday the loss also shows Democratic Gov. Gray Davis' energy policies are needlessly costing consumers. ``This whole thing is a mess,'' said Assemblyman John Campbell, R-Irvine, who requested details of the state's surplus power sales. ``The government needs to get out of the power business before it costs Californians even more money.'' A state spokesman didn't dispute the $14 million figure outright but said it is an approximation based on average prices and that the actual loss probably is less. ``It's a number I'm sure he likes very much, but it's definitely an estimated number, and it could be far lower,'' said Oscar Hidalgo, spokesman for the state Department of Water Resources. Campbell responded that the loss also could be higher. The state has spent $415 million on power so far this month. State officials last week confirmed that cool weather and consumer conservation have left California holding more power than it needs. The revelation was a stunning turnaround for a state that months ago was paying top dollar for power, expecting shortages this summer. Price that was paid The state bought 3.5 million megawatt-hours of electricity for July at an average price of $118 per megawatt-hour, according to a response Friday by the Department of Water Resources to Campbell's inquiry. The state has sold 178,000 surplus megawatt-hours in July at an average price of $37, the department said. Based on those average prices, the state paid $21 million for the surplus power, which it sold for $6.5 million -- $14.5 million less than it cost. A more precise calculation of the state's loss is difficult because purchased power is acquired at different times and prices and pooled as a ``portfolio.'' Purchases included long-term contracts that averaged $138 per megawatt-hour as well as cheaper spot-market buys. State officials last week said they were selling surplus at $15 to $30 a megawatt-hour, while some traders cited unconfirmed sales as low as $1. Hidalgo noted that the surplus sales represent just 5 percent of California's July purchases, which totaled $415 million. The $6.5 million from sales will help lower the state's power bill, he said, adding that utilities routinely sell some extra electricity. ``Despite the fact that we're in somewhat of a surplus, any power-buying operation in the world is going to have to plan for these types of situations,'' Hidalgo said. ``It's not unique, and in fact it's normal operating procedure for any utility.'' Other Western utilities, including Portland General Electric in Oregon, have said they, too, are selling some surplus power at a loss and describe it as a cost of doing business. The suppliers buying the state's surplus electricity on the cheap include the big out-of-state energy companies that the governor has called price-gouging ``snakes.'' Among them are Duke Energy, Dynegy Power and Marketing, El Paso Power Services, Mirant, Reliant Energy and Williams Energy. `Best bid' taken Hidalgo said the state took the best offers it could find. ``It's only reasonable to get the best bid you can,'' he said. Campbell said the $14 million loss is troubling because ratepayers or taxpayers will have to cover the cost, whereas a private utility could be forced to eat the expense if regulators determined it was unreasonable. State officials say what's more important is that the overall cost of power is dropping, from an average daily tab of $64 million in May to $25 million this month, in part because the state has so much power. Contact John Woolfolk at jwoolfolk@sjmercury.com <mailto:jwoolfolk@sjmercury.com> or (408) 278-3410. Temperatures likely to rise all week Published Tuesday, July 24, 2001, in the San Jose Mercury News BY DANA HULL Mercury News Temperatures throughout the Bay Area are expected to rise each day this week, and some inland cities could see low 100s by Thursday or Friday. Despite the warming trend, officials for the California Independent System Operator said Monday they should get by without any rolling blackouts. Hotter temperatures, often accompanied by spikes in air conditioning use, can strain the state's electric grid. ``We believe we'll be fine this week,'' said Lorie O'Donley of the ISO. ``Our understanding of the forecast is some localized heat in Northern California,'' but the coastal regions and Southern California will be more moderate. Meteorologists say that the atmospheric ``upper trough,'' or cool air, is moving out of the Bay Area. ``Cool air has been parked over the West Coast and California,'' said Ryan Walbrun, a meteorologist with the National Weather Service. ``It moved in shortly after the Fourth of July, but that system is weakening and will move out. Things will heat up in the Central Valley and eastern portions of the Bay Area. It will be a gradual warming trend during the work week.'' Contact Dana Hull at dhull@sjmercury.com <mailto:dhull@sjmercury.com> or (510) 790-7311. Wholesale Competition Contributed to Trend of Lower Power Prices, According to New EPSA Study July 24, 2001 <JavaScript:userButton(> WASHINGTON, July 23 /PRNewswire/ via NewsEdge Corporation - Calls for a return to cost-plus rate regulation in the wake of the California power crisis are misplaced, according to an independent study released today that found that competitive markets contributed to a 36 percent decline in retail electricity prices among surveyed utilities. "That decrease is in sharp contrast to the increases that consumers experienced in the days of solely cost-plus rate regulation," said Electric Power Supply Association President Lynne H. Church, who released the findings during a media luncheon in conjunction with the group's summer membership meeting. "This analysis is evidence that we should continue to move forward toward more competition in order to apply downward pressure on prices." The study: "Assessing the 'Good Old Days' of Cost-Plus Regulation," analyzed sales data for 60 of the nation's investor-owned utilities during 1985-1999, when traditional cost-plus rate regulation began evolving toward more competition. Complete sales figures for 2000 were not yet available when the study was completed. The study was commissioned by EPSA and conducted by Craig Roach, Ph.D, principal of Boston Pacific Co. "In the wake of the California power crisis, some people have expressed a longing for a return to the 'good' old days of cost-plus regulation, but those days were far from good," Roach said. "People seem to forget that, in the days of cost-plus regulation between 1970 and 1985, inflation-adjusted electricity prices actually increased 25 percent for residential customers and increased 86 percent for industrial/commercial customers." "So much for the good old days," Church said. "The price increases under cost-plus regulation were precisely what drove the start of electricity competition in the early and mid-1980s." During the 1985-1999 period, according to the analysis, inflation-adjusted electricity prices decreased an average 30 percent for residential customers and 36 percent for industrial/commercial customers. "We should not allow the problems in California to cast a false shadow on competition," Church said. "The evidence presented in this study makes it clear that it would be counterproductive and unwise to go back to the old ways." "It is important to understand that what happened in California resulted, in part, from market rules that prohibited basic risk management," Roach said. "Specifically, utilities were required to take on the risk of selling at a fixed price to customers, but not allowed to manage that risk by arranging contracts with fixed-price suppliers or use other risk management tools. Managing risk appropriately benefits consumers, and risk management is more efficient and effective in a truly competitive regime." "This study bolsters our belief that the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission should continue to move expeditiously toward more efficient wholesale markets, states should continue to move quickly toward opening their retail power markets, and Congress should quickly adopt comprehensive legislation to help them along," Church said. Note: A copy of the complete study is available at www.bostonpacific.com/powerprices . EPSA is the national trade association representing independent power producers and power marketers active in U.S. and global power markets. As suppliers of reliable, clean, competitively priced electricity, EPSA members seek to bring the benefits of competition to all electricity customers. Contact: Mark Stultz, 202-628-8200 Audrey Duff, 202-354-8205 MAKE YOUR OPINION COUNT - Click Here http://tbutton.prnewswire.com/prn/11690X71763169 SOURCE Electric Power Supply Association CONTACT: Mark Stultz of Electric Power Supply Association, +1-202-628-8200; or Audrey Duff, +1-202-354-8205, for Electric Power Supply Association Web site: http://www.epsa.org http://www.bostonpacific.com/powerprices