10 May 2001, 11:01 UTC
Energy Issues
- From
- Miyung Buster miyung.buster@enron.com
- To
-
Ann M Schmidt, Bryan Seyfried, Elizabeth Linnell, filuntz@aol.com, James D Steffes, Janet Butler, Jeannie Mandelker, Jeff Dasovich, Joe Hartsoe, John Neslage, John Sherriff, Joseph Alamo
and 41 more
Karen Denne, Lysa Akin, Mark Palmer, Mark Schroeder, Markus Fiala, Michael R Brown, Mona L Petrochko, Nicholas O'Day, Peggy Mahoney, Peter Styles, Richard Shapiro, Rob Bradley, Sandra McCubbin, Shelley Corman, Stella Chan, Steven J Kean, Susan J Mara, mike.roan@enron.com, Alex Parsons, andrew.morrison@enron.com, Laura Ipsen, Janel Guerrero, shirley.hudler@enron.com, Kathleen Sullivan, Tom Briggs, Linda Robertson, Lora Sullivan, Jennifer Thome, jkradin@marathon-com.com, rlichtenstein@marathon-com.com, Sandra Yamane, Ken Smith, Hedy Govenar, Scott Govenar, Bev Hansen, Carin Nersesian, Robert Neustaedter, John Shelk, Chris Holmes, Evan Hughes, Roberta Staehlin - Date
- Thu, 10 May 2001 04:01:00 -0700 (PDT)
Please see the following articles: Sac Bee, Thurs, 5/10: "PUC sweats $4.8 billion rate raise" Sac Bee, Thurs, 5/10: "PG&E wants panel to get boot" Sac Bee, Thurs, 5/10: "Major job losses predicted; governor presses generators" Sac Bee, Thurs, 5/10: "Bond-sale bill goes to Davis " Sac Bee, Thurs, 5/10: "State revenue outlook shrinks " SD Union, Thurs, 5/10: "No blackouts despite dip in supplies" SD Union (AP), Wed, 5/9: "Biggest users face huge rate hikes under PUC plan" LA Times, Thurs, 5/10: "Rate Hikes Up to 60" Proposed by PUC Chief" LA Times, Thurs, 5/10: "Bush Energy Stance Begins to Worry Some in GOP" LA Times, Thurs, 5/10: "In Office Buildings, the Lights Are On, But Nobody's Home" LA Times, Thurs, 5/10: "Power Shifts to Congress" (Commentary) SF Chron, Thurs, 5/10: "Proud state forced to knees in power hunt" SF Chron, Thurs, 5/10: "Power bills set to skyrocket for heavy users Graduated rate increase would take effect in June " SF Chron (AP), Thurs, 5/10: "Developments in California's energy crisis " SF Chron (AP), Thurs, 5/10: "PG&E says fewer small power plants offline " SF Chron (AP), Thurs, 5/10: "A look at two rate designs before power regulators" SF Chron, Thurs, 5/10: "Lights stay on despite failure of big plant" SF Chron, Thurs, 5/10: "PG&E fights consumer committee Obstruction feared in bankruptcy case " SF Chron, Thurs, 5/10: "Generators silent on Davis plan He offers lower compensation to stave off Edison bankruptcy " Mercury News, Thurs, 5/10: "Rate plans shield most households" Mercury News, Thurs, 5/10: "Energy bond plan gets final legislative OK, faces delay" Mercury News, Thurs, 5/10: "Fusion research gets a boost" OC Register, Thurs, 5/10: "Power is Money PUC details plan to raise Edison rates up to 34%. Half of users to see no hike" OC Register, Thurs, 5/10: "Economic crisis in forecast" OC Register, Thurs, 5/10: "GOP stalls sale of bonds with vote" OC Register, Thurs, 5/10: "Electricity notebook Davis asks power suppliers to accept 30% less than owed" OC Register, Thurs, 5/10: "Regulators says more electricity rate hikes are likely" OC Register, Thurs, 5/10: "Starting all over again The Legislature's special session on the power crisis ends today -- with more work to do at an added cost" OC Register, Thurs, 5/10: "Davis is set to sign a $13.4 billion bond-issue measure today to cover electricity costs" OC Register, Thurs, 5/10: "Papering over state electricity problems" Individual.com (AP), Thurs, 5/10: "Task Force To Propose Legislation" Individual.com (AP), Thurs, 5/10: "Stage 2 Electrical Emergency Declaration; SCE to Curtail 'Load' for Some Customers" Individual.com (Bridgenews), Thurs, 5/10: "[B] FULL/ Pacific Gas & Electric restores all Qualifying Facilities --Pacific Gas & Electric says 8 of 300 QFs still shut down" ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------- PUC sweats $4.8 billion rate raise By Carrie Peyton Bee Staff Writer (Published May 10, 2001) Big industries' electric bills would leap 50 percent or more and household bills would rise an average of 11 percent to 17 percent under two proposals outlined by state regulators Wednesday for revamping electric rates. The twin proposals are efforts by Loretta Lynch, president of the state Public Utilities Commission, and Christine Walwyn, a PUC administrative judge, to decide how to divide the burden of a $4.8 billion rate hike. "Both of them are just going to be very, very hard on business," said Bill Booth, an attorney for the California Large Energy Consumers Association. He said it appeared that some cement and steel makers could face 90 percent rate hikes. But small consumers were equally dismayed. "This never should have happened in the first place," said Bob Finkelstein, an attorney with The Utility Reform Network, placing the blame for soaring rates on electric deregulation. "In terms of allocating the fallout from the failed experiment, they seemed to do a reasonable job. But it assumes that the fallout should be allocated in the first place, and that just sticks in our craw," he said. Several PUC commissioners have said they want to select a new rate design at a special meeting Monday, so the higher electric bills can begin going out June 1 to customers of Pacific Gas and Electric Co. and Southern California Edison. One version before the PUC would include Lynch's call to begin looking for ways to charge federal installations power rates that are tied to wildly gyrating wholesale costs. Reportedly first floated as a joke, the idea quickly took hold within the PUC. Lynch said she wants to set it up as "pilot program," perhaps beginning in mid-summer, so the federal government can test its own theories about unfettered market prices being good for consumers. "I don't believe it's a dig at the FERC (Federal Energy Regulatory Commission)," she said during a news conference. But she repeated her attack on federal regulators, saying electric rates are rising in California only because the FERC has refused to cap runaway wholesale electric prices. Commissioner Richard Bilas later called a special federal rate "silly" and "kindergartenish," and said the proposal was clearly intended "just to get back at the federal government." Any of the five appointed commissioners can offer an alternate version of the rate design, as Lynch did. The alternates will be considered alongside the proposal by Walwyn, the judge who presided over lengthy hearings on how the new rates should be crafted. She recommended increases that would fall slightly more softly on residential customers -- averaging 11 percent for Edison and 15 percent for PG&E -- and more heavily on large industrial users, averaging 52 percent for Edison and 55 percent for PG&E. But within those averages could be much higher individual increases, and advocates for everyone from farmers to manufacturers waited anxiously throughout the day for detailed tables that would list rates for dozens of customer categories. "I have got my expert economist standing by to look at the numbers when they come out," said Ron Liebert, associate counsel for the California Farm Bureau Federation. The release of the rate proposal has been delayed repeatedly as the PUC tried to cram work that usually takes months into just a few weeks, and many of its details remained obscure late Wednesday, dismaying those who are still arguing for changes. "We have to file comments on this by Friday. What they're doing is, they're shutting down the comment period," said Jack Stewart, president of the California Manufacturers & Technology Association. He said it appears that some rates could nearly double, and "that's just a death knell for many California manufacturers." Lynch provided only sketchy summaries of her ideas, saying she wanted to raise residential rates 16 percent for Edison and 17 percent for PG&E on average, raise industrial rates 50 percent to 52 percent and cap agricultural rate increases on a sliding scale from 23 percent to 30 percent, partly at Gov. Gray Davis' urging. She said that about half of households statewide would see no increase under a state law that protects those who use less than 130 percent of a "baseline" amount. However, PG&E has calculated that far more households -- 69 percent -- use more than the baseline at some point during the year. PG&E's baseline varies by region and season but generally runs between 300 and 400 kilowatt-hours, or about 50 percent to 60 percent of average electricity use per household. It was created to give people access to a minimal amount of power at a lower rate. The heaviest household users still would see no increase on their first few hundred kilowatt-hours, but after that prices would rise sharply, in tiers, so that some households could see their overall bills rise 34 percent or more. Lynch and Walwyn also have proposed "bill limiters" so that businesses with unusual usage patterns won't get hammered by unintended rate spikes. The increases will not affect customers of the Sacramento Municipal Utility District, which recently approved its own hikes, averaging 22 percent, and other ratepayer-owned utilities. The Bee's Carrie Peyton can be reached at (916) 321-1086 or cpeyton@sacbee.com. PG&E wants panel to get boot By Claire Cooper Bee Legal Affairs Writer (Published May 10, 2001) SAN FRANCISCO -- Pacific Gas and Electric Co. on Wednesday asked a judge to disband an unprecedented committee of ratepayers appointed last week to represent consumers in the utility's bankruptcy case, saying that some in the group were politically biased. The utility filed a motion arguing that U.S. Bankruptcy trustee Linda Ekstrom Stanley exceeded her legal authority by designating a consumers committee armed with broad powers to investigate and negotiate alongside the utility and its creditors. The utility denounced the committee as a collection of "special interest" groups with "well-known political and policy agendas" and a "history of aggressive lobbying and litigation." The PG&E motion, which was set for a hearing May 18 before Bankruptcy Judge Dennis Montali, warned that turning the consumer committee loose could "substantially retard the progress of this case and seriously prejudice its outcome." On Friday, PG&E singled out Consumers Union and The Utility Reform Network as "well-organized lobbyists and political operatives." Consumers Union regional chief Harry Snyder, a committee member, said he would have no comment. TURN's representative to the committee, Nettie Hoge, did not respond to a request for comment. In appointing the ratepayers committee last week, Stanley, who is administering the bankruptcy proceedings, said she was bringing it into the case because the state, which ordinarily would represent the public, has chosen to stay out. Stanley chose the nine committee members to represent a mix of energy consumers -- households, businesses, farms and government. In addition to Consumers Union and TURN, the groups include the California Farm Bureau, the California School Boards Association and the California Manufacturers & Technology Association. If Montali upholds Stanley's action, PG&E must pay for the committee's lawyers, accountants and other consultants to analyze data and present arguments in the bankruptcy proceedings from the consumer's perspective. "They (will) have all of the information that's going on," said Judy Beckner Sloan, a bankruptcy expert at Southwestern Law School, who speculated that PG&E was balking at the committee's potential power and its costs to the bankruptcy estate. "The creditors and PG&E are opposed to their presence because to the extent the judge heeds the consumers' concerns, he's going to be less aggressive about raising rates," said Jesse Fried, a law professor at the University of California, Berkeley. While Fried said Stanley's decision was defensible because the judge "is supposed to take into account the wider interests of society," Los Angeles bankruptcy lawyer Richard Levin sided with PG&E. Only the state should have been allowed to represent consumers, Levin said, and its decision not to do so should be final. The Bee's Claire Cooper can be reached at (415) 551-7701 or ccooper@sacbee.com. Major job losses predicted; governor presses generators By Dale Kasler, Ed Fletcher and Emily Bazar By Dale Kasler, Ed Fletcher and Emily Bazar (Published May 10, 2001) As a private consultant predicted the state will lose 135,000 jobs from a summer of blackouts, Gov. Gray Davis on Wednesday pressed power generators to forgo 30 percent of their California earnings to help pull the state out of the energy crisis. Summoning executives of the companies he has repeatedly accused of price gouging, Davis said the generators probably would have to forgive a portion of the debt they're owed by California's two destitute utilities to win the Legislature's approval for his controversial plan to repay the debts and rescue the utilities. "I suggest that they should look to (accept) 70 percent of what they claim they were owed," Davis said after a four-hour meeting in the Capitol. "I felt the Legislature will insist on a reduction." Although Davis said, "I believe they are willing to take some reduction," at least one generator, Reliant Energy Inc., immediately dismissed the governor's proposal. The meeting capped a roller-coaster day in which anti-generator protesters brought a pig to the Capitol and the state narrowly averted a third straight day of rolling blackouts. But while enough megawatts were found to scrape by for a day, the state is surely facing a summer of severe shortages. A study, commissioned by some of the state's most influential business lobbyists and partly funded by Intel Corp., predicted chronic blackouts will mean significant economic harm to California. The study by John Urbanchuck of New Jersey-based AUS Consultants said the blackouts would erase 135,000 jobs and cause $26 billion in economic devastation. Several California economists said the prediction was overblown, but none doubted the electricity crisis could significantly harm the state's business climate. "It really depends on how severe the blackouts are," said UCLA economist Chris Thornberg. "If we have 30 straight days of blackouts in June ... you're going to end up with a mess." Everything else being equal, the loss of 135,000 jobs would raise California's unemployment rate by 0.7 percent, to 5.4 percent, based on the latest numbers from the Employment Development Department. Ted Gibson, chief economist with the state Department of Finance, said AUS' estimates seem high. "It'd be hard for me to think those relatively limited, one-hour-at-a-time (blackouts) would have such an impact," Gibson said. As it is, the blackouts have struck some of California's most important employers, such as Sun Microsystems Inc. and Advanced Micro Devices. Tuesday's blackout hit Apple Computer Inc.'s lone U.S. factory, in Elk Grove. Economic development agencies from other states have stepped up recruiting efforts in California, hoping to capitalize on the state's misfortunes. A few glass manufacturers have moved production, said Jack Stewart, president of the California Manufacturers & Technology Association. It could get worse. For example, a leading Silicon Valley electronics manufacturer, Solectron Corp. of Milpitas, said it is seriously considering pulling some of its operations out of California. "The blackouts and the lack of reliable power are our biggest concerns," said Solectron spokesman Bob Kula. "We have the ability to move (production) quickly." Solectron, whose factories were hit with blackouts in January and March, employs 4,000 workers in Northern California. A top state official said business leaders around the country look at the electricity crisis as emblematic of a state that's becoming iffy as a place to do business. "The whole question of how did the state allow it to get this far -- I keep hearing that from Wall Street, I keep hearing that from the business community," said the official, who asked to remain anonymous. "The last year has demonstrated that the risks of doing business in California are much higher than anywhere else in the United States." The state was spared a third day of blackouts Wednesday when cooler, windier weather in the late afternoon produced a spurt of wind-generated electricity and a much-needed drop in demand. Throw in an unexpected power purchase from the Pacific Northwest, and the state's fragile power grid suddenly had 1,400 megawatts it wasn't expecting, more than enough to compensate for a breakdown of a major Bay Area power plant in early afternoon. Another boost: Pacific Gas and Electric Co. said all but a handful of its alternative-energy suppliers have resumed production. These suppliers, responsible for a fourth of the state's energy supply, have been closed for weeks because of nonpayment by PG&E and Southern California Edison. The two stricken utilities are paying them again. But while blackouts were unlikely today, there were no guarantees. "We're not swimming in megawatts," said spokeswoman Stephanie McCorkle of the Independent System Operator, which runs the state's power grid. Representatives from a dozen wholesale power generators -- 10 in person and two by phone -- attended the Capitol summit. Despite months of verbal potshots between Davis and the generators, the meeting was described as cordial by John Stout, senior vice president of Houston-based Reliant. But Davis also said he told the executives that unless they accept a reduction in payment for back debts, the Legislature is likely to reject his plan to buy the utilities' transmission lines -- a key element of his plan to pay back billions the utilities owe them. If the plan goes through, the generators can get paid this year, Davis said. If it's killed, they'll probably have to wait three or four years to get their money in Bankruptcy Court. So far only Edison has agreed to sell its lines to the state. Senate President Pro Tem John Burton, D-San Francisco, said Wednesday that the Edison deal will be rejected unless the generators forgive some debts. "I'm going to insist that they take at least a 30 percent haircut on the monies that they're owed," Burton said earlier. The Bee's Dale Kasler can be reached at (916) 321-1066 or dkasler@sacbee.com. Bee Staff Writer Kevin Yamamura contributed to this report. Bond-sale bill goes to Davis (Published May 10, 2001) The state Senate sent legislation to Gov. Gray Davis on Wednesday authorizing the largest revenue bond sale in U.S. history over continued Republican opposition. The bill, SB 31x, would allow California to sell $13.4 billion in bonds, starting in August, to repay the state for past and future power purchases. Davis is expected to sign the bill today. Because the bill failed to receive the two-thirds majority needed for an urgency measure, however, the bonds can't be sold until 90 days after the end of the Legislature's special session. Lawmakers are expected to end the session Monday, and most of the 200 pending energy bills already introduced will be reborn in a second energy session, said Senate President Pro Tem John Burton, D-San Francisco. SB 31x passed on a 23-12 vote, with most Democrats supporting the measure and all Republicans opposing it. Sen. Joe Dunn, D-Garden Grove, was the only Democrat to vote against it. Republicans proposed that the state use the surplus to write off $6 billion that California has spent on electricity since mid-January. But Democrats said the state needs to replenish those funds to support other state programs in education, transportation and health care. Treasurer Phil Angelides had pursued a bridge loan of $4.13 billion to bolster the state's budget and ensure that non-energy programs remain funded. But when Assembly Republicans assailed the immediate bond sale, the short-term loan was lost. Zane Mann, editor of the California Municipal Bond Advisor, said the delay in the bond sale "casts a cloud" over the project but won't kill it. It will probably lead to a higher interest rate, which will add to the ratepayers' costs, he said. -- Kevin Yamamura and Dale Kasler State revenue outlook shrinks By John Hill Bee Capitol Bureau (Published May 10, 2001) Legislative Analyst Elizabeth Hill dropped a budget bombshell Wednesday, reporting to legislators that state revenues will be $3.4 billion lower than Gov. Gray Davis predicted in his January budget proposal. Instead of enjoying a $1.9 billion reserve, the Davis budget plan for the fiscal year beginning July 1 would now leave the state $1.5 billion in the hole, Hill wrote in a letter to legislators overseeing the budget. Dwindling revenue from a faltering economy leaves Davis' plan in need of major revisions. The new revenue estimates would require cuts in one-time expenditures that Davis proposed for programs such as clean beaches and fiscal relief for local governments. Cuts also may have to be made in new spending contemplated for education, which got most of the new money in the $104.7 billion January budget proposal. "The number is so deep that it's going to be hard for us not to contemplate cuts or make cuts," said Assemblyman Tony C?rdenas, D-Sylmar, vice chairman of the Joint Legislative Budget Committee. "We don't know where those cuts are going to come from." Little will be immune, said Dan Howle, chief of staff for Sen. Steve Peace, D-El Cajon, chairman of the Joint Legislative Budget Committee. "It's going to include programs the governor is very supportive of and would like to get done, but we're in a little bit of a cash crunch here, and you've got to do what you've got to do," he said. "If anything's got a protective fence around it, it's education. But I still think it'll have to take a share of the cuts." These grim budget figures don't take into account possible hits on the budget caused by the state's breathtaking expenditures on electricity. Those effects could be negligible if the state is able to sell bonds to pay for power and replenish the treasury. But considering recent events in the volatile energy crisis, no assumption is safe. The budget crunch will likely highlight conflicting spending priorities and could lead to more polarization between Democrats and Republicans who have been squabbling over the energy crisis. "A third of the Assembly has never done a budget," Howle said. "Another third has never dealt with anything other than huge surpluses. Now you're saying we've got to go in and cut. This could be a long, hot summer." The new revenue projections are a dramatic illustration of the state's faltering economy. Revenues for the fiscal year that starts July 1 are now expected to be $4.8 billion less than anticipated in January, Hill wrote. That includes a decrease of $3.9 billion in income tax, $500 million in sales tax and $600 million in bank and corporation taxes, offset by some moderate increases in insurance and estate taxes, said Brad Williams, chief economist in the non-partisan Legislative Analyst's Office. "It's deterioration in the stock market and implications for capital gains and stock options," Williams said, "and also the weakening outlook for the economy as a whole." The $4.8 billion blow is softened somewhat by unexpectedly strong revenues from last year's tax returns, which helped boost revenues $1.4 billion higher than had been anticipated. The net effect is $3.4 billion less for the fiscal year that begins July 1. If the Democratic governor's budget were approved as is, the deficit would reach almost $6 billion in the fiscal year that begins July 1, 2002, Hill wrote. The governor is expected to release his revised budget Monday. The state Department of Finance said Wednesday that it wouldn't comment on the new revenue estimates until then. One obvious target for budget cutters is one-time expenditures in the January proposal. This includes money for local governments, state building projects, housing initiatives, replacing diesel engines that contribute to air pollution, cleaning up beaches, law enforcement technology grants, flood control, parks along rivers and more. Even if the state axed $2.5 billion for one-time expenditures that Davis proposed, it would still have to cut an additional $1.7 billion proposed for ongoing programs. Davis' budget -- which projected an $8 billion surplus -- includes at least $1.9 billion more for education than required under formulas approved by voters in Proposition 98. But considering Davis' commitment to education, most believe it's unlikely the governor would balance the budget by throttling back to the minimum funding level, which would require cuts to existing education programs. C?rdenas said education, health care and transportation should be protected from cuts. Assembly Republicans agree about education, but have different ideas about the rest. On Wednesday, the Republicans released their plan for the revised budget. It includes protecting schools and law enforcement, creating a $4 billion reserve for future electricity purchases, and striking a proposed 1/4-cent sales tax increase. The sales tax, which went into effect in the early 1990s, was removed this year, but Davis has proposed restoring it in 2002. "All this does is put a new burden on the backs of Californians" already coping with higher energy costs, said Assemblyman George Runner, R-Lancaster, a member of the Assembly Budget Committee. Republicans say an electricity reserve could avoid the need to do another bond sale for power purchases next year. "This is the time to make sure we are putting money aside and that we're not going to have to turn back to taxpayers or ratepayers and put an additional burden on them," Runner said. The Bee's John Hill can be reached at (916) 326-5543 or jhill@sacbee.com. No blackouts despite dip in supplies Stage 2 alert, power plant breakdown add to concerns By Jeff McDonald UNION-TRIBUNE STAFF WRITER May 10, 2001 In the nip-and-tuck world of meeting California's energy needs, a small victory was notched yesterday in Folsom, where managers of the state power grid avoided blackout orders for the first time since the weekend. But tensions nonetheless ran high among power industry officials, and business leaders in San Diego County are growing increasingly alarmed at the nagging energy crisis. The number of available megawatts fluctuated throughout the day yesterday and a major power plant broke down, but engineers at the Independent System Operator maintained service across the state. Persistent shortages combined with unusually high temperatures prompted power alerts as early as 10:15 a.m., when grid officials warned that supplies had dipped within 7 percent of reserves. With more than 12,000 megawatts of power unavailable from idled plants, system operators issued a Stage 2 warning about 11:45 a.m. and asked large users to cut back consumption through the afternoon. Two hours later, a boiler tube leak knocked out a 750-megawatt power plant in the Bay Area. Repairs will probably take several days. "It wrecked my day," said Jim McIntosh, the Independent System Operator director of grid operations. "It just changed the whole perspective of what was going on." The loss of the 750 megawatts deepened concerns in Folsom, where ISO engineers measured a peak afternoon demand that barely trailed supplies of almost 34,000 megawatts. As late as 3 p.m., grid officials expected to be forced into cutting service to hundreds of thousands of homes and businesses. Cooling temperatures and conservation efforts helped kill the last threat, McIntosh said. More blackouts could be ordered today, however, and tomorrow may be just as problematic. "The next couple of days will certainly be impacted by the loss of that unit," McIntosh said. The latest breakdown added to some already high drama at utility companies, where officials braced through the day for orders to cut power to hundreds of thousands of customers. Blackout orders never came. But executives at San Diego Gas and Electric Co. spent the day on heightened alert, calling critical-need residents and businesses and informing them of potential service interruptions. "This has become relatively commonplace," SDG&E spokesman Douglas Kline said. "We handle it as a matter in the course of business now, unfortunately. We've been on high alert all day." Service was cut to more than 23,000 customers in several San Diego-area neighborhoods Monday and Tuesday afternoons. More than 500,000 homes and businesses across the state also lost power. In a power interruption unrelated to the power problems across the state, a number of major businesses in downtown San Diego were cut off unexpectedly in midafternoon. Customers between F Street and Harbor Drive lost power about 3:15 p.m. when something went wrong with an underground cable that serves, among others, the Marriott Marina hotel, SDG&E said. Service was restored within two hours, but not before convention meeting rooms went dark and hotel restaurants closed. The heat wave that has hung across California the past three days is expected to begin cooling today and tomorrow, the National Weather Service said. That should reduce demand for air conditioning, one of the biggest power draws in the state. However, the constant uncertainty in the electricity industry is taking its toll on local businesses, which not only are seeing huge run-ups in utility costs but are girding for potential losses that even a few minutes of interruptions can cause. "From a business standpoint, it's not 15 minutes of downtime for many of our companies," said Julie Meier Wright, president of the San Diego Regional Economic Development Corp. "For many of them, it means the loss of hours, days, weeks and even longer of work." Biggest users face huge rate hikes under PUC plan By Karen Gaudette ASSOCIATED PRESS May 9, 2001 SAN FRANCISCO ) Customers of California's two largest utilities who use the most electricity would pay much more to run canneries, tumble laundry and conduct other tasks under a tiered rate plan implementing record hikes approved in March. The rate plan proposed Wednesday by Loretta Lynch, president of the state Public Utilities Commission, suggests how the rate hikes should be allocated among residential, industrial, commercial and agricultural customers. Residential customers of Pacific Gas and Electric Co. and Southern California Edison Co. who use the most electricity would face average rate hikes of 35 percent to 40 percent. And industrial users, such as factories and food processors, could face hikes of 50 percent or more as the state desperately tries to start recouping the $5.2 billion it already has paid to buy power for customers of those financially ailing utilities. Still, under Lynch's plan, as many as half of the 9 million customers of PG&E and SoCal Edison would not see their bills rise at all. Lynch's plan is the culmination of weeks of discussion among customers, state officials, consumer activists and the utilities about how best to allocate the record rate hikes approved in late March by the PUC. Those rate hikes will affect all classes of customers, from small families to the huge Silicon Valley facilities powering the Internet, but not all will face the same magnitude of rate increases. And, even within those classes, customers will pay more depending on when they use the electricity. Those who use power during times of highest demand ) generally, during daylight hours ) will pay the most. Lynch said her plan "recognizes that energy is expensive at every hour of every day by every customer," but penalizes those who do not cut back on energy use or try to shift to different times of the day. Under Lynch's proposal, agricultural customers could face rate hikes ranging from 23-30 percent, with increases capped at 30 percent. Industrial users face average increases of 50 percent or more, and commercial users average 34 percent to 45 percent hikes. Her proposal, Lynch said, designs rates to encourage conservation and provides $5 billion over the next year to help pay the state Department of Water Resources for the billions it has spent providing electricity for customers of PG&E and Edison. Lynch left the door open for future rate hikes, noting that the state provides its electricity-buying expenses to the commission only on a monthly basis, while wholesale electricity prices continue to soar. Lynch's proposal, and a largely similar proposal from PUC administrative law judge Christine Walwyn, will be reviewed in public hearings throughout the state the rest of this week. Rate Hikes Up to 60% Proposed by PUC Chief Power: Lynch says about half the residential customers of Edison, PG&E would escape increases. Her plan draws fire from all sides. By TIM REITERMAN and NANCY RIVERA BROOKS, Times Staff Writers ?????SAN FRANCISCO--About 4 million California residential electricity customers will face increases in their monthly bills of up to about 60% under a proposal unveiled Wednesday by the state's chief utility regulator. Interest groups on all sides promptly condemned the plan as too hard on either consumers or businesses. ?????The proposal by California Public Utilities Commission President Loretta Lynch would increase the bills of roughly half of Southern California Edison's residential customers, who consume medium to heavy amounts, by $8 to $93 a month. Pacific Gas & Electric Co. customers would be hit with hikes of $6 to $87 a month. Elisabeth Charion is among about 70 people testifying at a PUC hearing Wednesday in Fullerton, most venting their anger at elected officials and utility companies, whom they blame for the crisis. IRFAN KHAN / Los Angeles Times ?????About half of the residential customers of the state's two biggest public utilities would see no increase under the proposal if they continued to consume energy at their current pace. ?????Lynch said she could not guarantee that more rate increases would not be necessary. "Even these astronomical average rates may prove inadequate," she said, noting that wholesale electricity prices are still high and unpredictable. ?????The rate hike, Lynch said at a news conference, is necessary because "federal regulators have failed to follow federal laws to ensure just and reasonable prices." ?????The deepening energy crisis compelled Lynch to release her proposal after public hearings on the rate increase already had begun. Lynch said that she wished her proposal had been ready sooner, but that at least some of the remaining public hearings will have the benefit of reviewing it. ?????PUC passage of the essential elements of Lynch's plan seems likely. ?????Along with two of her colleagues on the five-member commission, Lynch was appointed by Gov. Gray Davis, and they often vote as a bloc. Lynch said, however, that testimony later this week from utilities, the public and other interested parties could prompt modifications. ?????Structuring the $5-billion rate increase is an important but politically sensitive step in California's attempt to restore stability to the delivery of power to 9 million customers of two financially troubled utilities while protecting the state budget. ?????The PUC has tried to design rates that would encourage conservation without damaging business. Competing interest groups, ranging from consumer advocates to large manufacturers, have been jockeying for advantage for weeks. ?????The PUC approved a rate increase of 3 cents per kilowatt-hour March 27 to help pay the state's mounting power tab, which now exceeds $5 billion. This week, the commission is conducting statewide hearings on how the pain should be shared among millions of residents and businesses. On Monday the panel is set to vote on Lynch's plan and a similar one by a PUC administrative law judge. ?????Neither proposal appeared to please anyone. ?????"The PUC says everyone should share the pain, but we think the fair share of the pain for residential consumers should be zero," said Mindy Spatt, spokeswoman for the Utility Reform Network, a San Francisco consumer group. "It should be paid by commercial and industrial customers who wanted and still want deregulation." ?????Consumer activist Harvey Rosenfield said regulators should go after power generators and their hefty profits rather than ratepayers. ?????"Rate increases are not the answer, and this is not going to be the end of them," said Rosenfield, president of the Foundation for Taxpayer and Consumer Rights in Santa Monica. "This is like organized crime: The more you give them, the more they want." ?????Commercial and industrial customers would see increases of up to 50%, and agricultural interests would face increases of 23% to 30% under Lynch's proposal. ?????Business interests contend that the rate hikes hit them much harder than residential users. ?????Calling the proposal "a death knell for the California economy," Jack M. Stewart of the California Manufacturers and Technology Assn. estimated that industrial customers would see their power rates increase an average of 53%. And the pain of the rate hikes will be compounded by blackouts this summer, which the group contends will cost California businesses $21.8 billion in lost productivity. ?????"For most large manufacturers, energy is a large piece of their operating costs," Stewart said. "If you add 53% to that, it's going to severely hamper their ability to do business." ?????Unlike residential customers, the business customers are not grouped into tiers based on their amount of usage. Lynch said there was insufficient time to establish a tiering system for nonresidential customers by June 1, when the rate hikes will start showing up on bills. ?????An earlier proposal by Lynch had attempted to narrow the gap between residential rates and the lower rates paid by nonresidential customers. But the commission president said that goal could not be immediately achieved without seriously damaging the state's economy. ?????To protect the largest users from gigantic rate increases, Lynch's proposal caps the maximum bill increase at 300% for most customers and 250% for agricultural customers. ?????"While we understand bill limiters may have some troubling conservation impacts, at some point, price signals are unbearable for customers. Bill limiters will protect customers from unanticipated extraordinary bill impacts," Lynch wrote. ?????In recent weeks, the commission has received about 20 plans for structuring the rate increase, including one from Davis, who had proposed a slightly smaller overall rate increase. Lynch said her plan incorporates a number of features of the governor's plan, including a tiered structure that would punish heavy users and reward those who conserve. ?????Under state legislation, there is no rate increase for consumption up to 130% of baseline, the amount deemed the minimum needed by a customer in a given area and noted on ratepayer bills. Also exempted are low-income customers who already receive discounted electricity rates. ?????Edison and PG&E said they could not assess how the PUC proposals would affect their customers because the commission had not provided details to the utilities as of late Wednesday. ?????But PG&E has disputed the commission's claim that half of customers would not be affected by the increase, noting that only 32% of PG&E customers never exceeded 130% of baseline usage in the last year. ?????Industrial and commercial customers complained that the plan should not exempt such a large group of residential customers, in any event. A rate increase for these users--based on the PUC's estimate that the group will constitute about half of residential customers--could generate an extra $1 billion. ?????If the PUC insists on exempting so many, the $1-billion shortfall should be covered solely by other residential users, businesses say. ?????Under Lynch's plan the burden of paying that amount would be split equally among commercial, industrial and nonexempt residential customers. ?????If covering the shortfall were not shared by the three groups, Lynch said, some residential customers would suffer a 100% increase in their bills. ?????The proposal calls for a pilot program, including one that would let federal agencies based in California "experiment with their own market rate policies." ?????Lynch challenged federal agencies to try to live with "real time," or hourly, prices in the volatile wholesale marketplace--a slap at officials of the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission who favor a free wholesale market over price caps. Use of real-time pricing requires installing a special meter. ?????"'It would be great if the federal users respond to price signals enough that prices come down," Lynch said, adding that she was skeptical that would happen in today's dysfunctional market. ?????A FERC spokeswoman declined to comment on Lynch's proposal. ?????During the third day of PUC hearings, about 200 people gathered at Fullerton College. Seventy people testified, most venting their anger at elected officials and utility companies, whom they blame for the state's flawed deregulation plan. ?????"I am opposed to any rate increase for residences and small business," testified Ruth Shapin, a Santa Ana attorney. "This crisis was created by politicians. PG&E and SCE have transferred billions of dollars to their parent companies. Let them bail themselves out, not the ratepayers." ?????Others said the baselines might be unfair because the commission had not taken into consideration home size, the number of occupants and the location. ?????"It's going to be hard for many people to stay below the 130% baseline," said Sylvia Hartman of Lakewood. "Some customers could easily go 400% over the baseline." --- ?????Reiterman reported from San Francisco, Rivera Brooks from Los Angeles. Times staff writer Dan Weikel in Fullerton contributed to this story. Copyright 2001 Los Angeles Times Bush Energy Stance Begins to Worry Some in GOP By GREG MILLER and RICHARD SIMON, Times Staff Writers ?????WASHINGTON--As power shortages and price spikes spread beyond California, congressional Republicans are beginning to worry that the Bush administration's reluctance to offer much immediate relief could hurt the party in the 2002 elections. ?????A national energy plan to be unveiled by the White House next week will focus on long-term strategies. But with California and other states bracing for a summer of electricity turmoil and gasoline prices surging across the country, some GOP lawmakers are pressing for short-term solutions. U.S. Rep. Mary Bono, left, and Gov. Gray Davis discuss meeting with executives of power-generating companies. Bono plans to seek $100 million to help poor people pay energy bills. AP ?????"The White House has been taking a look at the big picture," said a GOP leadership aide in the House. "But they're going to be around in four years. We might not have members around in two years if we don't show we care." ?????That sentiment is being voiced by a rising number of GOP lawmakers. "We're in a crisis situation, which is only going to get worse if we don't act very aggressively," Rep. Elton Gallegly (R-Simi Valley) said Wednesday. Gallegly is one of four congressional Republicans from California to break with the administration by supporting temporary price controls on wholesale electricity. ?????The rising anxiety, which has begun spreading beyond the California delegation, underscores how much has changed since the state declared its first Stage 3 power emergency in December. At that time, Congress' response was largely: That's Gov. Gray Davis' problem. ?????Not anymore. ?????Thirty-nine Stage 3 alerts later, a House committee today will take up a GOP-drafted emergency bill that would, among other things, allow Davis to temporarily waive certain emission standards for power plants during an emergency and provide federal aid to relieve a notorious bottleneck in the California power grid. ?????But some GOP lawmakers say the legislation doesn't go far enough, and plan to offer amendments containing their own ideas. Rep. Mary Bono (R-Palm Springs) plans to push for $100 million in energy assistance to low-income households and for a directive to federal facilities in the West to cut energy use by 20%. ?????"House leaders recognize that they could lose the House in California if there's not an action plan that members can campaign on," said Scott Reed, a GOP strategist. ?????As lawmakers search for ways to provide immediate relief, the White House continues to cite California's troubles as evidence of the need to upgrade an aging, overburdened electricity transmission system. ?????Responding to reports that the administration would propose legislation to give the federal government eminent domain authority in siting power lines, White House press secretary Ari Fleischer said Bush wants to ensure that the distribution infrastructure can move electricity from regions with surpluses to regions that need more power. ?????"That's one of the reasons that California is going through the difficulties it's going through," Fleischer said. "There is energy available in other parts of the country, but it can't be shipped to California as easily as you would hope, because of infrastructure problems." ?????Fleischer took exception to a front-page story in The Times reporting that Bush, in a speech delivered Tuesday, "offered no hint of what his administration might do" to help California avert a possible economic downturn caused by power blackouts. ?????Though the president did not specifically mention possible actions in the speech, Fleischer said Bush last week "announced a series of steps, including conservation," to help California get through an energy crisis this summer. ?????He said that the Pentagon is reducing its energy needs within California by 10% and that all other federal agencies, at Bush's direction, are reviewing their energy consumption patterns. ?????Environmentalists already have begun blasting the administration's energy plan--even before its details are made public--for what they characterize as a failure to emphasize energy efficiency and investments in renewable fuels. ?????Activists Say Crisis Isn't Real ?????At a Wednesday news briefing, a coalition of environmental advocates disagreed with the administration's assertion that the country is experiencing an energy "crisis," and accused it of crafting a plan designed to boost the profits of key campaign contributors. ?????"We cannot drill our way out of this situation," said Dan Becker of the Sierra Club. He and others argued that conserving fuel--with cars that use less gasoline and appliances that use less electricity, for example--is the best way to avoid energy shortages in the short term. ?????So far, it is not clear whether the energy crisis will work to either party's advantage. Many on Capitol Hill are bracing for an election year that could be brutal for incumbents of both parties if voters who endure high energy bills this summer vent their frustration in the voting booth next year. ?????Some House Republicans acknowledged that they have been pushing the White House to appear more engaged in finding near-term solutions. ?????When House Republicans met with Cheney last week, "they urged him and all the administration to at least make it clear that a lot of effort is going into finding a way to solve the problem," said Jim Specht, a spokesman for Rep. Jerry Lewis (R-Redlands), leader of the California GOP delegation. ?????Though some Republicans have offered ideas to address the immediate problem, it is not clear whether any will receive congressional approval. ?????Indeed, the emergency assistance bill being taken up today by the House energy subcommittee faces trouble, although it was drafted by the panel's chairman, Rep. Joe Barton (R-Texas). ?????Barton stripped out a number of provisions opposed by environmentalists. But Democrats plan to seek a vote on capping wholesale electricity prices, a proposal most Republicans oppose. Democrats also plan to introduce an amendment to target natural gas prices. ?????House Minority Leader Richard Gephardt (D-Mo.) said the bill "fails miserably" to address California's problems. "During the campaign, President Bush promised a sensible energy policy," Gephardt said. "In recent weeks, however, the president has responded to the gathering crisis by throwing up his hands and saying there's nothing we can do, there's no way to give people immediate relief from blackouts and sky-high increases of price of gasoline at the pump." ?????Lawmakers of both parties acknowledge that they are hearing a rising chorus of constituent complaints about the energy price spikes and supply shortages. ?????Rep. Chris Cox (R-Newport Beach) was caught in a blackout during a tour of a computer chip factory in his district. "They said it cost them $1 million if the power goes off even for five minutes," said Cox, who nonetheless opposes price controls. ?????Cox said he is worried about how the California electricity crisis might affect the national economy. He said that when he asks business owners about expanding in California, "they just look at you like you're nuts. They don't consider California an option because of this uncertainty." ?????"People come up to you and want you to help solve the problem," said Rep. George Radanovich (R-Mariposa). ?????He has explained that there is little the federal government can do in the short term. ?????"Californians want somebody to do something," said John J. Pitney Jr., associate professor of government at Claremont McKenna College. "When people are in a mood like that, politicians get nervous thinking that they're the ones who might get blamed." ?????Said Reed, the GOP strategist: "Every incumbent in California is vulnerable in the next election, in both parties. This is an issue that is not ideological. It's about action and solving a short-term problem. "Politics have taken over this issue, like it or not," he said. "They may have been raging in California for the last three or four months. It's now a national political issue." --- ?????Times staff writers James Gerstenzang, Edwin Chen, Elizabeth Shogren and Ricardo Alonso-Zaldivar contributed to this story. Copyright 2001 Los Angeles Times In Office Buildings, the Lights Are On, But Nobody's Home Energy: Analysts say metering individual tenants could encourage conservation. By JERRY HIRSCH, Times Staff Writer ?????Despite power outages and soaring energy prices, workers stream out of California's downtown and suburban offices each evening leaving lights blazing and computers humming. And there has been scant incentive to conserve, since commercial building leases typically include the cost of energy. ?????Energy experts and other analysts say metering of individual office tenants would encourage conservation by pushing companies to shut off lights, computer monitors, desk fans and other electrical devices at night, but state regulations and utility policies are in the way. ?????That conflict between policy and conservation efforts has drawn the attention of state Sen. Debra Bowen (D-Marina del Rey), who chairs the Senate Energy, Utilities and Communications Committee. On Tuesday, Bowen asked California Public Utilities Chairwoman Loretta Lynch to review what Bowen called "archaic" regulations governing how electricity meters are used in office buildings. Bowen said she also plans to take up the issue in her committee. ?????At issue is Rule 18, a regulation established by the commission two decades ago that prohibits landlords from using submeters to assess energy charges to tenants. ?????"It is quite old and dates back to a different era of electricity distribution in California," said Bowen, who was urged to take action by the Building Owners and Managers Assn. "I asked Loretta Lynch to open a proceeding to revise or eliminate that ban." ?????Lynch did not return calls for comment on the state's metering policies, but PUC regulatory analyst William Gaffney said more metering "would be a boon to energy conservation" because "you could see what you are using." ?????"Direct metering would ultimately foster greater energy savings . . . more permanent savings, because it would encourage capital investments in more efficient equipment, windows, etc., etc.," said Evan Mills, a scientist in the energy analysis department of the Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory in Berkeley. ?????Usually, the only tenants in office buildings with utility meters are retail and restaurant businesses, according to commercial real estate experts. Most tenants in California office towers sign what are called "gross leases" that include power. When electricity usage or rates go up unexpectedly, landlords can charge monthly or annual "escalation fees" to cover the extra cost. The fees typically are apportioned by the percentage of the building a tenant occupies. ?????This method of billing is counterproductive to energy savings, said Willet Kempton, senior policy scientist at the University of Delaware's Center for Energy and Environmental Policy. Energy hogs are subsidized by other tenants. Conversely, savings through conservation are only fractionally shared. ?????Two key obstacles block metering of individual tenants in a building. ?????One is economics--high-rise buildings get a far better rate with one utility meter than if each floor is metered. ?????"We can sell a lot of energy on just one bill," said Randy Howard, manager of commercial services at the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power. "If we had 200 meters there and had to do the billing and meter reading for each of them, each tenant would pay a higher rate." ?????Moreover, utilities aren't anxious to send meter readers to every floor of a building, going through private offices to find the meters. One alternative--locating all the meters in a central area where the main electrical line enters the building--would require massive rewiring of existing office towers that could cost several hundred thousand dollars or more, depending on the size of the building, said Ali Sherafat, senior vice president of the Los Angeles office of Syska & Hennessy, a consulting engineering firm. ?????A 1995 ruling by the PUC required that individual tenants in office buildings be placed on meters operated by a public utility (as opposed to landlord-managed submeters), but relatively few have been installed because of exemptions. ?????For example, Southern California Edison Co. officials typically meet with developers at the start of a building project to determine how many meters it might require, said Matt Deatherage, a planning support manager for the utility. But because developers build office space so that its configuration can change easily as tenants shift, the estimate is often wrong. A building designed with three meters for three tenants might find itself with six tenants or more by the time it opens. ?????"We don't require them to go back and rewire the building if it turns out to be wrong, that would be too expensive," Deatherage said. ?????The second obstacle is Rule 18, the 1981 ban on submetering originally intended to protect utility monopolies and to prevent landlords from getting electricity at a discount price and selling it at a markup to tenants. ?????"When you resell electricity like that, you function as a utility and that's not allowed," said Deatherage. ?????Nonetheless, Bowen believes that deregulation may have superseded those issues and that current policy should emphasize conservation. ?????Although the leasing model used in California is common, it's not universal, said Peter L. DiCapua, energy chairman of the Building Owners and Managers Assn. International. ?????Many New York tenants have individual meters. Others are on landlord submeters, a system that allows them to tap into the lower, high-volume rates paid by the building's operator but still pay for actual, rather than estimated, energy use. ?????Landlords would welcome a changed regulation to allow submetering for several reasons. There are the conservation benefits, said Dan Emmett, chief executive of Douglas Emmett & Co., one of the largest building owners and managers in Los Angeles County. It also would reduce some of the inevitable arguments with tenants who claim they pay more than their fair share for services at a building. ?????"I think submetering could be practical," Emmett said. "It is not that complicated and is fairly inexpensive." ?????Sherafat said it would cost about $2,000 per tenant for the submeter and the necessary software. Submeters could be installed at the electrical panel level without expensive rewiring for utility meters, he said. Better yet, the software allows data to be collected at a central point, eliminating the need for meter readers. Such a system also could allow big buildings to use one master meter to get the best rate . ?????Though submetering would foster conservation, it still is not a panacea, said Kempton of the University of Delaware. When it comes to energy conservation, changing the behavior of businesses and workers is notoriously tricky. ?????"Attorneys literally can't be bothered with the nuances of energy," said DiCapua, an executive at Atco Properties & Management in New York. "They are focused on things other than if the air conditioning was left on all night. ?????That is typical of professional services firms, because energy is just a small fraction of their expenses, Kempton said. ?????And individual metering sounds great in theory, Kempton added, but it is useless if the bill goes to a home office elsewhere or if the on-site manager of the firm never sees it. ?????In any push to change the rules, however, people should remember that the current system was developed for sound reasons, often based on reducing the expense of constructing buildings and finding tenants the lowest prices for energy, Howard said. ?????"Right now we are in a conservation mode, so everybody is talking about this," he said. "But that hasn't always been the case, so a single meter for a big building made sense." Copyright 2001 Los Angeles Times Thursday, May 10, 2001 Power Shifts to Congress ?????Wholesale electricity prices soared with the temperature this week, jumping to eight times the peak of only three weeks ago. No one knows how high the price may go when high summer hits. Which makes it all the more intriguing that one of the big power-generating companies is now calling for temporary price caps, which the Bush administration stubbornly opposes. ?????Authority over wholesale power prices rests with the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, which is charged by Congress with maintaining "just and reasonable" rates. But FERC refuses to impose what California desperately needs, a broad temporary price cap that allows companies to recover their costs plus a reasonable profit. The state's last hope for rate caps now rests with Congress. ?????Sens. Dianne Feinstein (D-Calif.) and Gordon Smith (R-Ore.) are sponsoring legislation that would require FERC to establish temporary maximum rates. Rep. Henry Waxman (D-L.A.) is scheduled to propose amendments to a House bill today to do the same. The support of three Republican House members from California, who are on the energy and air quality subcommittee, is crucial. They are Christopher Cox of Newport Beach, Mary Bono of Palm Springs and George Radanovich of Mariposa. The Waxman measure serves the best interests of California. Concern about losing seats in Congress may also help the GOP members make the right choice. ?????It was Feinstein who got a letter from Keith E. Bailey, chairman of Williams Cos., an energy producer, in support of temporary price controls. Perhaps some generators are tired of being labeled gougers, pirates and bloodsuckers, and they will settle for a reasonable profit through the rest of this crisis. But price caps would have to apply to all the producers. Congress must act, starting today with the subcommittee vote on the Waxman measure. Copyright 2001 Los Angeles Times Proud state forced to knees in power hunt Robert Salladay, Chronicle Sacramento Bureau Thursday, May 10, 2001 ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle URL: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2001/05/10/MN40227.DTL California has turned into the trailer park next door, the cash-only, deadbeat neighbor forced to beg for enough power to keep the swamp cooler running. Yesterday in Folsom, home of the state's energy managers, was another study in high-tech, air-conditioned humiliation -- punctuated by a frantic scraping and bowing for energy across the West. Poor people with "secured" credit cards can relate to the scene at the California Independent System Operator. This week began with Canada's BC Hydro threatening to shut off power again until the state actually wired cash to its bank account. "We got the money," an ISO engineer stood up and told another employee at the agency's semi-secret Folsom headquarters yesterday. "Yeah, we're good for another $14 million. Burn it up, huh, Lloyd?" Lloyd started burning it up, thanks to an OK from the Department of Water Resources and to several million California taxpayers' footing the bill. California narrowly missed a third day in a row of blackouts yesterday. The situation was tight when a power plant in Pittsburg shut down because its boiler was leaking, but cooler weather and increased supply from other generators helped keep the lights on. All week at the ISO, engineers have been fretting about facilities and finances. BC Hydro shut off 2,000 megawatts of power to the state Monday while it waited for a check from the water agency. The state has a line of credit with BC Hydro, but California is buying so much at such high prices that it was reaching the limit. The company already is owed about $307 million from the state's insolvent utilities, so it is impatient. "They wanted to make sure we were good for it before we could continue," said Oscar Hidalgo, a spokesman for the water agency, which is paying the bills. The power cutoff sent the ISO into a panic, since BC Hydro was providing enough to power an estimated 2 million homes. Two hours later, the state marched down to the bank and wired the money. Power was restored, and an agreement was reached yesterday for daily payments. The engineers in shirtsleeves at the ISO aren't used to this kind of treatment. Since the energy crisis drained the bank accounts of the utilities, it's been months of constant struggle to get power generators to fork over electrons. "We have to go into higher begging mode for generators out of state," said Jim McIntosh, director of grid operations for the ISO. "It scares the hell out of these guys. They've never been put in that position. . . . From the electricity standpoint, we're operating like the Third World." The ISO has no control over energy prices or even how the bills are paid. The bills are the job of the water agency, which has been spending about $50 million a day since mid-January. Not only have a near-record number of power plants been shut down for repairs this month, the hot weather is breaking records and causing energy use to spike. The state would probably be near blackouts even without the shaky financial situation. But the final insult is that some of the bills are getting paid late, in part because power generators are charging unprecedented rates on the daily energy market. That causes the people who work at power companies to get snippy sometimes and threaten to withhold power. That also leads to the same things that poor people face every day: higher prices, bad service and frustration. "We pay more for gasoline. We pay more for natural gas. We pay more for electricity than anywhere else in the country," said Larry Bellnap, shift manager at the ISO, a two-decade veteran in the power business. "I can't think of a reason except we're California, and they are taking advantage of us." Here's a conversation recorded a few months ago between an ISO engineer and a generating plant in El Segundo. At the time, the ISO needed the plant to go on line immediately to avoid blackouts. "You need to get somebody that has the authority to tell me how I'm going to get paid," the plant manager demands on the phone. "I have the authority to order these plants on," the ISO manager says, and then gets this back a few minutes later: "I still need clarification on how you're going to pay me if I get these things on." "OK. I can't give you that right now. That will have to wait until tomorrow. " "No, I need that now," the plant manager says. "That's unacceptable." The conversation is contained in court records compiled when several out-of- state generators threatened to cut off power, despite their contracts, and the ISO sued. The state lost its case essentially, but federal regulators backed them up last week in a ruling. McIntosh said he'd never in his 31 years working in the power industry had to get a lawyer on the phone to force a power generator to start up a plant to provide more power. But now they have two available if needed to remind generators of their commitment. GALLING POSITION The problem is especially irritating because power generators are charging the highest prices ever seen for power. McIntosh and others said the situation was much smoother now that California was the major creditor and was pumping billions of dollars into buying power. Most of the generators are confident enough they will get paid. Hidalgo said the BC Hydro situation this week was isolated so far, but he offered one solution for the future: "Maybe they shouldn't charge so much." E-mail Robert Salladay at rsalladay@sfchronicle.com. ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle ? Page?A - 1 Power bills set to skyrocket for heavy users Graduated rate increase would take effect in June David Lazarus, Chronicle Staff Writer Thursday, May 10, 2001 ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle URL: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2001/05/10/MN176943.DTL As state regulators outlined plans to raise residential electricity bills by as much as 40 percent, the head of the Public Utilities Commission warned yesterday that power rates could soar even higher. The PUC, which adopted an increase in March, is scheduled to approve details of the new rates in San Francisco on Monday. Consumers will see the higher rates in their June utility bills. State regulators say nearly half of all consumers will see no change in their power bills. The remainder will experience rate increases ranging from 3 percent to more than 50 percent, depending on the type of customer and the amount of power used. The increases would be added to an average 10 percent increase adopted in January. PUC President Loretta Lynch suggested that rates could rise yet again if wholesale electricity prices continue to surge this summer. "If the sellers decide to turn up the heat and raise prices, we'll have to look again at the numbers," she said. INCREASE WILL CONTRIBUTE LITTLE The proposed rate increase would bring in about $5 billion annually -- a fraction of the estimated $65 billion California will spend this year purchasing power on behalf of the state's cash-strapped utilities. Lynch said she expects the remainder to be made up by issuing bonds. The state Senate yesterday approved $13.4 billion in bonds to help cover California's power costs. However, those bonds would not be released until August, by which time California's energy tab would be billions of dollars higher. "There's huge cause for concern that this latest rate increase is a down payment rather than anything close to a final installment," said Bob Finkelstein, staff attorney for The Utility Reform Network in San Francisco. The PUC's Lynch stressed that while California's new rate structure would place a greater burden on the state's heaviest power users, the increases are intended to spread the pain among all consumers. "Energy is expensive for every hour of every day for every customer," she said. LINING UP TO GET PAID That includes the state Department of Water Resources, which is spending about $70 million a day to keep California's lights on. While the PUC is moving to have more money collected from consumers to pay California's power bills, it has yet to address the thorny question of how the proceeds will be distributed among the various parties lined up for compensation. The Water Resources Department wants all rate-related revenues to first replenish state coffers, while Pacific Gas and Electric Co. and Southern California Edison Co. insist that they be paid as well for their own expenses. The utilities' costs include payments to small power generators that can no longer afford natural gas to run their plants. The recent closure of hundreds of such facilities is a key reason California is experiencing blackouts this week. Although PG&E said yesterday that most of the smaller generators with which it does business are now back online, it is not yet clear whether the utility will be able to keep paying for their power. "It appears that everything (from the rate increase) is going to DWR (the Water Resources Department)," said John Nelson, a PG&E spokesman. Lynch said the PUC will take up the matter of apportioning funds at an unspecified future date. CONSERVATIVE USE PAYS For the moment, state regulators have their hands full digesting two competing -- and highly complex -- proposals for how rates should be increased next week. One proposal was submitted by an administrative law judge working with the PUC and the other by Lynch. Commissioners will choose between them on Monday. The two proposals are largely identical. Under both, residential customers who can keep electricity usage within 130 percent of predetermined limits would experience no rate increase. The "baseline usage" figure -- included near the bottom of PG&E bills -- represents the minimal amount of power consumers require. It includes a number of variables, such as climate, time of year and type of fuel used. The PUC said about half of all utility customers statewide historically stay within 130 percent of baseline limits. Heavy residential users whose electricity usage tops 400 percent of baseline figures would see power bills rise by as much as 40 percent. Heavy commercial and industrial users would see bills rise by more than 50 percent. The average increase for all PG&E residential customers would be about 16 percent, the PUC said, although this number is skewed by the addition of all those customers whose bills would remain unchanged. Harvey Rosenfield, head of the Foundation for Taxpayer and Consumer Rights in Santa Monica, questioned whether these rate increases will be sufficient to motivate greater conservation among consumers and thus ease California's energy woes. He called instead for the state's political leaders to seize generating plants from out-of-state power companies and impose a special tax on the companies' "windfall" profits. "Unless our elected officials take action, this is just the beginning of our rate increases," Rosenfield warned. FEDERAL BUILDINGS IN SIGHTS One of the main differences between the two rate-increase proposals is Lynch's inclusion of a "real-time pricing program" for federal agencies. If enacted, she said, federal buildings in California would be fully exposed to the volatile wholesale power market and would pay whatever California pays to keep the lights on throughout the day. Lynch denied that this is an effort on the part of California officials to drive home to federal authorities the impact of sky-high wholesale electricity prices. "It's just an experiment," she said. While California officials have called on federal regulators and the Bush administration to assist the state by capping wholesale power prices, Washington has provided only limited relief to date. The Utility Reform Network's Finkelstein complained that the proposed rate increases place a severe burden on residential customers when commercial and industrial users account for the greater percentage of power consumption. "It was the commercial and industrial customers who were clamoring for deregulation," he said. "You didn't hear any calls for deregulation from residential customers." Lynch said she was aware that residential users are being asked to carry a high proportion of the load but said efforts to force industrial users to pay higher rates ran into political opposition. E-mail David Lazarus at dlazarus@sfchronicle.com. ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle ? Page?A - 1 Developments in California's energy crisis The Associated Press Thursday, May 10, 2001 ,2001 Associated Press URL: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/news/archive/2001/05/10/state0 948EDT0159.DTL&type=news , , -- (05-10) 06:48 PDT Developments in California's energy crisis: THURSDAY: -- Grid operators say cooler temperatures will help them meet California's electricity demands. Officials at the Independent System Operator say supplies are tight, but they don't expect blackouts. -- The PUC holds a public hearing on the proposed rate structure in Sacramento. -- Gov. Gray Davis is scheduled to sign a bill authorizing $13.4 billion in revenue bonds to pay for power for customers of the state's three largest utilities. The bonds will repay the state general fund for $6.7 billion authorized for power buys since January and will finance future electricity purchases. WEDNESDAY: -- After a difficult afternoon, grid operators are able to avoid blackouts after temperatures drop slightly. -- The Public Utilities Commission releases recommendations for rate increases, sparing about 9 million customers of Pacific Gas and Electric Co. and Southern California Edison, but socking residential customers who don't cut back with a 40 percent hike. PUC president Loretta Lynch says the plan is designed to encourage conservation and provides $5 billion more to help pay the state for the $6.7 billion it has spent so far providing electricity for the customers of PG&E and Edison. -- The state Senate approves a bill authorizing $13.4 billion in bonds for power buys, sending the bill to the governor. -- The governor meets with the CEOs of several major energy suppliers to discuss the money they're owed by the state's two largest utilities, the state's creditworthiness and how wholesalers can help the state during the energy crisis. Davis says he won't be discussing any of the investigations into price manipulation in the wholesale market. -- A consortium of business interests releases a study saying continued blackouts this summer could cost the state $21.8 billion in losses from sales, wages and production. -- PG&E says only eight of the 300 small power plants in its territory are still shut down for payment reasons. All eight are natural gas-fired plants that deliver a combined 109 megawatts of electricity, enough to power about 80,000 homes. Owners of these plants say they haven't been fully paid for millions of dollars in past power deliveries and that they would operate at a loss if they resume full operations. -- PG&E asks U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Dennis Montali to void the appointment of a committee representing ratepayers. The utility says that such a committee isn't allowed under bankruptcy law and that the state attorney general can represent ratepayers in the bankruptcy process. Montali also says PG&E can use hundreds of millions of dollars in payments from customers to buy gas, which the utility in turn sells to homes and businesses. That came as other creditors wait to recoup billions of dollars from the bankrupt utility. Montali rules that creditors lining up to collect from PG&E cannot use any money they secure to sue the utility's largest creditor, The Bank of New York. -- A major electricity generator starts an ad campaign that offers to sell power to the state for 2 cents per kilowatt hour -- as long as the state provides the natural gas to produce the power. Reliant Energy says the ads are necessary because their offer is being ignored by power buyers. Another energy producer, Mirant, has also kicked off a media campaign. WHAT'S NEXT: -- Davis' representatives continue negotiating with Sempra, the parent company of San Diego Gas and Electric Co., to buy the utility's transmission lines. THE PROBLEM: High demand, high wholesale energy costs, transmission glitches and a tight supply worsened by scarce hydroelectric power in the Northwest and maintenance at aging California power plants are all factors in California's electricity crisis. Edison and PG&E say they've lost nearly $14 billion since June to high wholesale prices the state's electricity deregulation law bars them from passing on to consumers. PG&E, saying it hasn't received the help it needs from regulators or state lawmakers, filed for federal bankruptcy protection April 6. Electricity and natural gas suppliers, scared off by the two companies' poor credit ratings, are refusing to sell to them, leading the state in January to start buying power for the utilities' nearly 9 million residential and business customers. The state is also buying power for a third investor-owned utility, San Diego Gas & Electric, which is in better financial shape than much larger Edison and PG&E but also struggling with high wholesale power costs. The Public Utilities Commission has approved rate increases of as much as 46 percent on average to help finance the state's multibillion-dollar power buys. The PUC is still determining how those increases will be spread among utility customers. ,2001 Associated Press ? PG&E says fewer small power plants offline KAREN GAUDETTE, Associated Press Writer Thursday, May 10, 2001 ,2001 Associated Press URL: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/news/archive/2001/05/10/state0 343EDT0125.DTL&type=news (05-10) 00:43 PDT SAN FRANCISCO (AP) -- Only eight of the 300 small power plants in Pacific Gas and Electric Co.'s territory remain shut down for payment reasons, the struggling utility says. That means more vital megawatts have come back online that could help prevent rolling blackouts. But operators of those so-called qualifying facilities say that's because they're required to run their plants during periods of high demand to get paid, not because of a change of heart over millions of dollars owed to them for past electricity deliveries. ``What I believe will start happening is you will see QFs operate for a minimal amount of time during peak times in order to get their capacity payments,'' said Jan Smutney-Jones, executive director of the Independent Energy Producers. ``They won't be fully available to California.'' All eight of the plants in PG&E's territory are natural gas-fired plants that deliver a combined 109 megawatts of electricity, enough to power about 80,000 homes. Lorie O'Donley, a spokeswoman with the Independent System Operator, which manages California's electric grid, said that more of so-called qualifying facilities had indeed come back online throughout the state. ``Right now we have 1,400 megawatts offline statewide,'' O'Donley said, though she didn't yet know how many QFs were offline in PG&E's territory and in other territories. QFs harness solar, biomass, geothermal or wind power, as well as natural gas, to generate environmentally friendly electricity, and provide electricity to the state's investor-owned utilities under contract. QFs contribute about 6,000 megawatts to the state's power grid, O'Donley said. A few weeks ago, around 3,000 megawatts were offline. Many plants were shut down in protest for not getting paid millions of dollars for past electricity deliveries. That lack of power contributed to rolling blackouts which swept the state. The past debt, as well as a new pricing system ordered by the Public Utilities Commission, would force QFs to operate at a loss if they start producing power at full capacity, said Smutney-Jones. The new PUC price structure ties how much they can charge for their electricity to the price of natural gas coming in at the Oregon border, where natural gas is cheaper. However, many plants can only ship and buy their gas at the Topock border in the south, where prices are much higher. ``I don't think we're anywhere near out of the woods with respect to the QF issue,'' Smutney-Jones said. PG&E and Southern California Edison Co. have paid for QF electricity delivered since April under order by the PUC. However, PG&E had made partial payments on deliveries since last year, while SoCal Edison had paid nothing. San Diego Gas and Electric Co. says it never fell behind on its payments. www.pge.com ,2001 Associated Press ? A look at two rate designs before power regulators The Associated Press Thursday, May 10, 2001 ,2001 Associated Press URL: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/news/archive/2001/05/10/state0 338EDT0123.DTL&type=news , , -- (05-10) 00:38 PDT Key components of rate design proposals introduced Wednesday by Loretta Lynch, state Public Utilities Commission president, and Christine Walwyn, a PUC Administrative Law Judge. Both proposals suggest how to implement record rate increases passed by the PUC on March 27. Both rate plans use baseline -- an average amount of power used based on a customer's climate, geography and the time of year -- to help determine how much to charge customers. President Loretta Lynch's proposal: --Divides residential groups into five tiers Tiers 1 and 2 include low-income customers exempt from rate hikes and power use up to 130 percent of baseline. Tier 3 covers power use from 130 percent to 200 percent of baseline. Rate increase percentage was not released Wednesday. Tier 4 covers power use from 200 percent to 300 percent of baseline. Rate increase percentage was not released Wednesday. Tier 5 covers power use beyond 300 percent of baseline. Lynch said power used within these limits would receive an average 48 percent rate increase. Paul Clanon, head of the PUC's energy division, says that number is closer to 35-40 percent on average. --Commericial customers of PG&E would receive an average 37.5 percent increase on all electricity used. --Industrial customers of PG&E would receive an average 52 percent increase on all electricity used, depending what time of day they used it. --Agricultural customers of PG&E would receive an average 21 to 30 percent rate increase on all electricity used, depending what time of day they used it. Rates are capped at 30 percent. --Would adopt a pilot program to introduce real-time pricing to federal electric customers. Real-time pricing charges customers the full cost of electricity. Therefore, proponents say, customers should shift their electric use away from times of high demand and higher prices, thus lowering demand and eventually lowering wholesale prices. Administrative Law Judge Christine Walwyn's proposal: --Divides residential groups into four tiers Tier 1 includes low-income customers exempt from rate hikes and power use up to 130 percent of baseline. Tier 2 covers power use between 130 percent to 200 percent of baseline. Power used within these limits would receive an average 3 percent increase. Tier 3 covers power use betwen 200 percent to 300 percent of baseline. Power used within these limits would receive an average 10 percent increase. Tier 4 covers power use over 300 percent of baseline. This use would receive an average 34 percent increase. --Exact information on other classes was not provided. Source: Public Utilities Commission, Energy Division ,2001 Associated Press ? Lights stay on despite failure of big plant John Wildermuth, Joe Garofoli, Chronicle Staff Writers Thursday, May 10, 2001 ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle URL: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/chronicle/archive/2001/05/10/M N173855.DTL&type=news With temperatures still high and generating plants running full out, state power officials managed by the smallest of margins to prevent a third straight day of rolling blackouts yesterday. "It's been a roller-coaster of an afternoon," said a weary Stephanie McCorkle, spokeswoman for the California Independent System Operator. Demand was running slightly ahead of estimates early in the day, but the situation improved when the ISO asked its interruptible power users to cut their loads shortly after noon, McCorkle said. Those users, who agree to temporarily limit their power use when asked in return for lower rates, gave the system an additional 800 megawatts to work with. Temperatures again soared inland, but by 2 p.m. a slight break in the weather raised hopes that the emergency could be easing. Then, a 750-megawatt plant in Pittsburg broke down. "That wrecked my day," said Jim McIntosh, the ISO's operations director. While the ISO managed to beg, borrow and buy enough extra power to replace the Pittsburg plant for the afternoon, the generator's loss is another headache for a system already stretched to the maximum. The Pittsburg plant will be shut down for a minimum of 60 hours while crews repair a boiler tube leak, said a spokesman for Mirant Corp., the plant's owner. "I stress 'minimum' here, because that's usually the least amount of time it takes to fix one of these things," said Chuck Griffin, a company spokesman. The Pittsburg plant is the largest gas-fired generator in the state's power grid, McIntosh said. California already has plants that normally produce 12,000 megawatts of power out for maintenance and repair. "We knew May was going to be a tough month," McIntosh said. E-mail the writers at jgarofoli@sfchronicle.com and jwildermuth@sfchronicle.com. ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle ? Page?A - 12 PG&E fights consumer committee Obstruction feared in bankruptcy case Bob Egelko, Chronicle Staff Writer Thursday, May 10, 2001 ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle URL: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/chronicle/archive/2001/05/10/M N150518.DTL&type=news Pacific Gas and Electric Co. asked a judge yesterday to dissolve a committee appointed to represent consumers in the utility's bankruptcy case, calling its members "special interest groups" who could obstruct the proceedings. The nine-member committee, with representatives from businesses, government agencies and consumer organizations, was named last week by the Justice Department's bankruptcy trustee for Northern California and Nevada. Trustee Linda Ekstrom Stanley said her action was needed to give the public a voice because the state had declined to take part in the case. The appointment was significant because the committee can participate fully in the high-stakes case, conduct investigations, comment on PG&E's plan to settle its debts and propose an alternative plan. No past utility bankruptcy case has included a consumer committee. In papers filed late yesterday, PG&E said the committee was unauthorized by bankruptcy law and was potentially harmful. The law allows only unsecured creditors and equity security holders to be appointed to official committees, and consumers do not fit those categories, PG&E attorneys argued. A committee of the largest unsecured creditors, including banks and power generators, was appointed earlier. That committee has also opposed the appointment of the consumers' committee but has not filed legal objections. Even if individual customers qualified for appointment, "none of the special interest groups can claim a mandate to represent the interests of PG&E ratepayers generally," the utility said. PG&E said the two consumer organizations on the committee, The Utility Reform Network and Consumers Union, have "well-known political and policy agendas that have nothing to do with the reorganization principles of the Bankruptcy Code" and "a demonstrated history of aggressive lobbying and litigation." Noting that the consumers' committee would be funded by PG&E, the utility said the consumer groups' "proclivities could substantially retard the progress of this case and seriously prejudice its outcome." U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Dennis Montali has scheduled a May 18 hearing on PG&E's challenge. Stanley said she had met last week with PG&E representatives and lawyers, concluding "after significant research" that her action was both legal and necessary. "The public's interest is not being protected in the bankruptcy case," she said, noting that the state government was keeping out of the proceedings in order to avoid exposure to PG&E lawsuits. "The ratepayers are claimants here," Stanley said. "They have a right to expect performance from this utility. They have a right to be heard here." Committee member Nettie Hoge, executive director of The Utility Reform Network, said she was confident in Stanley's judgment. "You've got a monopoly utility and customers who are forced to pay rates for an essential service," Hoge said. "You've got to have customers involved in the discussions. "The trustee has done an admirable job, choosing a committee that is very diverse, folks who have a stake in every aspect of the economy." E-mail Bob Egelko at begelko@sfchronicle.com. ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle ? Page?A - 10 Generators silent on Davis plan He offers lower compensation to stave off Edison bankruptcy Lynda Gledhill, Chronicle Sacramento Bureau Thursday, May 10, 2001 ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle URL: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/chronicle/archive/2001/05/10/M N128963.DTL&type=news Sacramento -- Gov. Gray Davis, who has portrayed power generators as greedy villains in the state's power crisis, met face-to-face with industry officials yesterday, calling on them to forgive some of the debt racked up by an insolvent utility. In a three-hour meeting described as "businesslike," Davis said generators will have to accept 70 cents on the dollar of past debt as part of a solution designed to prevent Southern California Edison Co. from going bankrupt. At least one of the companies flatly rejected the idea after the meeting, putting the deal in jeopardy. If the two sides are not able to reach an agreement, Southern California Edison would probably follow Pacific Gas & Electric Co. into bankruptcy court, where creditors face a lengthy and uncertain resolution to recovering debts. Davis has run into legislative opposition to the original terms of the agreement he brokered with Southern California Edison, which includes the state's purchase of the utility's transmission lines as a way to help it regain financial stability. But the governor said he now believes that the deal can win passage in the Legislature if the generators "take a haircut." "I indicated that passage of the (agreement) that we signed with Edison would only work if they agreed to reduce the amount of money they claim the utilities owe them," he said. Edison owes generators, including municipal utilities, between $1.1 billion and $1.2 billion, Davis said. He said he agreed that talks would also take place with municipal utilities about taking less money on the dollar. Most of the generators refused to comment on the proposal, but a representative of Reliant Energy dismissed the suggestion. "That's simply an unreasonable number to start with," said John Stout, senior vice president of Reliant, who said that 67 cents on every dollar the company receives goes to pay the fuel bill, which doesn't include personnel and maintenance of facilities. "It doesn't get any supply built," Stout said of the idea. "I would much rather get that 100 cents on the dollar" to invest in new generation. The generators, who have reaped huge profits in the past year, said the main thrust of the meeting was on short-term issues, such as lining up more power for the summer. Davis asked which companies were not yet selling to the state and said he would work to get the Department of Water Resources to sign agreements with them. He also asked the generators to support the Edison deal, reportedly asking them to try to win GOP support for it. Davis agreed to a proposal from the companies to form permanent working groups to deal with the crisis. A handful of protesters led by former Senate candidate Medea Benjamin condemned Davis for meeting with the companies. Dressed as pigs, with the names of the companies on their masks, the five protesters brought a small live pig into the Capitol, where it proceeded to defecate outside the governor's office before the group was escorted out of the building. Lawmakers have insisted that the generators must take a cut in the money they are owed as part of any deal ending the energy crisis. Senate President Pro Tem John Burton, D-San Francisco, said earlier in the day that at least a 30 percent "haircut" would be necessary before he would allow any deal to be approved. "What we have here is a problem caused by the unfettered greed of generators that has brought capitalism to a new low," Burton said. He said if the generators don't agree to some kind of cut, they will find themselves in bankruptcy court. Earlier in the day, the Senate approved a bill that allows the state treasurer to issue $13.4 billion in bonds. The money, which will eventually be repaid by ratepayers, will be used to replace the funds that have drained out of the state's general fund since January to buy electricity and pay for future power purchases. The state has spent about $6 billion so far -- money, Democrats argue, that has to be replaced in order to fund other state services. "Where do those revenues go?" asked Sen. Sheila Kuehl, D-Santa Monica, during the floor debate. "They create child care slots, pay in-home support services and provide medical benefits for the poor." But Republicans said the state's budget should take some of the hit, instead of pushing it all off on ratepayers. Sen. Tom McClintock, R-Northridge, said the average ratepayer will see a $2, 000 increase on their utilities bills over the next 15 years to pay for the bond. The final vote was 23 to 15. Because not enough Republicans supported the measure in either the Assembly or Senate to make the bill an urgency measure, the law will not take effect until 90 days after the end of the special session. Davis will sign the bill today. Chronicle staff writer Greg Lucas contributed to this report. E-mail Lynda Gledhill at lgledhill@sfchronicle.com. ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle ? Page?A - 10 Rate plans shield most households Posted at 11:05 p.m. PDT Wednesday, May 9, 2001 MICHAEL BAZELEY Mercury News State regulators on Wednesday painted the clearest picture yet of who will bear the brunt of the biggest electrical rate hike in 20 years: Commercial, industrial and agricultural users will be socked with power bills that could soar by 50 percent or more. But most residential customers will be shielded from huge rate increases, regulators said. In two proposals unveiled Wednesday by the California Public Utilities Commission and to be voted on Monday, only the heaviest residential users get hit with big hikes, potentially doubling their rates in an effort to push them toward conservation. ``The moderate users will be largely protected,'' said PUC chairwoman Loretta Lynch. The PUC has been grappling with designing a rate plan for customers since March, when it announced an across-the-board rate hike of 3 cents per kilowatt-hour. The PUC announced the increase -- designed to help the state climb out of its ongoing power crisis -- before deciding how the rate structure would work and considered at least 20 plans. Details of the proposals were criticized Wednesday by energy experts who said residential customers are not being charged enough to encourage conservation, and by business representatives who said business and commercial users are being unfairly targeted. ``This is not a real rate increase for the residential class and we need one,'' said Severin Borenstein, director of the University of California Energy Institute. ``This is ridiculous. This is not a way to respond. This will send no price signal to people at all.'' Both proposals create a five-tier billing system for residential customers, with heavy users -- nearly 10 percent of all households -- seeing their rates possibly double. Energy misers and moderate users -- the other 7.3 million households -- would either see no change at all in their bills or only modest increases of up to about $12 month. The consumer group the Utility Reform Network said it was generally satisfied with the rate plans and how they spread the increase across all customer groups. ``Yes, they've done a reasonable job of allocating the pain equitably,'' said Bob Finkelstein, a staff attorney with the organization. ``But we shouldn't be in this position in the first place. I think it's a shame we're even going to see a rate increase.'' Covering state's costs Lynch said this rate increase, along with a statewide bond recently approved by lawmakers, should cover the state's costs in purchasing power. But she left the door open for further rate increases, especially if energy suppliers raise the price of electricity. ``If the sellers decide to turn up the heat and raise rates,'' she said, ``we'll have to look at those numbers again.'' Lynch and an administrative law judge both submitted similar plans. Because Lynch is the commission president, her proposal would appear to be the most likely to gain the support of fellow commissioners. Industrial users appear to take the biggest hit under Lynch's plan. Those equipped with special meters could see their rates double or more for power they consume during peak demand periods. Small commercial users would pay about 45 percent more for their ``on-peak'' electricity, Lynch said. Lynch said she intentionally ``weighted'' the on-peak rates higher as a way to encourage conservation. ``By promoting energy conservation during summer peak hours,'' she said in her proposal, ``we attempt to limit blackouts and service interruptions in order to preserve public health and safety.'' But industry representatives cried foul. ``These costs make it impossible to operate at a profit,'' said Jack Stewart, president of the California Manufacturers and Technology Association. ``You can't add these kinds of prices to the product and try to sell it. This looks like the beginning of the ringing of the death knell for the economy.'' Agriculture caps For agricultural users, the proposals are a mixed bag. Agricultural groups were hoping the PUC would endorse a recommendation by Gov. Gray Davis to cap their rate increases at 5 to 15 percent. Agriculture groups did get caps, but they are higher than the governor's, ranging from 23 to 30 percent in both plans. Even before the rate increase, farmers and other agricultural businesses were bracing for a rough summer. Because of a statewide water shortage, farmers will need to rely more on groundwater pumps, significantly driving up their energy use. ``We are definitely going to be impacted significantly,'' said Michael Boccadoro, executive director of the Agricultural Energy Consumers Association. Federal buildings Lynch also slung an arrow at the federal government, proposing that federal buildings in California be forced to pay market rates for electricity. Her proposal that federal buildings be given real-time meters could drive up federal government energy rates by 10 times or more. Lynch is angry with the federal government's hands-off attitude toward the state's power crisis and its insistence that Californians pay market rates for electricity. Lynch's idea -- which she said would be studied in the coming weeks -- was derided by several critics. ``This is something you do in kindergarten,'' said fellow Commissioner Richard Bilas. ``All it's going to do is make matters worse'' with the federal government. The PUC considered rate proposals from utility companies, consumer groups and the governor. Gov. Davis' proposal was perhaps the most closely watched because three of the PUC commissioners are Davis appointees. Davis proposed a slightly smaller across-the-board rate increase, an idea that was rejected by both Lynch and the judge. But Lynch, a Davis appointee, stressed that the two plans embrace other aspects of the governor's proposal, such as the caps on agricultural rates. Contact Michael Bazeley at mbazeley@sjmercury.com or (415) 434-1018. Energy bond plan gets final legislative OK, faces delay Posted at 8:28 p.m. PDT Wednesday, May 9, 2001 BY DION NISSENBAUM Mercury News Sacramento Bureau SACRAMENTO -- Amid rising partisan attacks, state Democrats gave final approval Wednesday to a record $13.4 billion energy crisis bond plan to replenish the drained California budget and buy critical power for the state's impoverished utilities. Democrats blasted Republicans for their steadfast refusal to support the plan -- opposition that will force the state to continue to use its already strained budget to buy power through the summer. ``I think the Republicans are playing a perilous game with dire consequences,'' said Assemblywoman Carole Migden, D-San Francisco, after the Senate approved the bill on a 22-15 vote. Gov. Gray Davis plans to sign the bill today. Without two-thirds support in both houses, the bonds cannot be sold immediately, and the state will lose the chance to line up about $4 billion in short-term loans. Because Democrats could pass the bond plan by only majority votes, the Legislature will have to shut down its special energy crisis session Monday. Without the two-thirds support, the bond measure cannot become law until 90 days after the session comes to a close. Closing the session would force state lawmakers to reintroduce hundreds of other energy crisis bills when Davis, as expected, launches a second energy crisis special session. Zane Mann, publisher of the monthly California Bond Advisor newsletter, blasted Republicans for not throwing their support behind the bonds. ``I can't understand why the Republicans did what they did,'' Mann said. ``I find it totally obstructionist. They're willing to sell out the state in order to blame Davis.'' During Wednesday's floor debate, Sen. Tom McClintock, R-Thousand Oaks, said bonds would saddle each Californian with an extra $2,000 on their energy bills. ``This expense was incurred because of some very bad decisions by elected officials of California,'' he said. The state has just about used up its $6.6 billion budget surplus buying power for the state's cash-strapped utilities and will have to tap unused cash from state programs to continue to buy power this summer. There is still concern that the state will be unable to find buyers for the largest bond measure in U.S. history. Mann, as well as the bank behind the bonds, J.P. Morgan, insist there's a market for them. Mann said the state's two largest mutual funds are waiting to buy the bonds -- if they have a high interest rate. If not, he said, ``they'll go out the window.'' Mercury News Staff Writer Jennifer Bjorhus contributed to this report. Fusion research gets a boost Published Thursday, May 10, 2001, in the San Jose Mercury News BY JIM PUZZANGHERA Mercury News Washington Bureau WASHINGTON -- With California and the nation facing energy troubles, Rep. Zoe Lofgren introduced bipartisan legislation Wednesday to accelerate research into fusion power, a potential long-term solution that promises cheap, environmentally friendly power if major scientific hurdles can be overcome. Fusion is the way the sun and stars produce their energy. Unlike nuclear power, which is a product of fission, or the splitting of atoms, fusion produces energy by fusing atoms together -- with no high-level radioactive waste. If it works, 50 cups of seawater could produce as much energy as two tons of coal, advocates said. Fusion energy has been proven possible in laboratories, but a power plant using the technology is still decades away, experts said. The Department of Energy is spending $248 million on fusion research this year, with the Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory one of several facilities around the country receiving funding. Fusion research funds, however, have decreased about 40 percent in the past decade, and Lofgren wants to reverse that. Her legislation, the Fusion Energy Sciences Act of 2001, seeks an increase of $72 million over the next two years. It would also require the energy secretary to submit a plan by July 2004 for the next major step in fusion energy, a burning-plasma experiment. ``It is time for this country to move beyond caveman technology to the technology of the future -- fusion technology,'' said Lofgren, D-San Jose, as she announced the legislation in front of the Capitol Hill Power Plant, which burns coal, oil and natural gas to power congressional offices. She was joined by Reps. Mike Honda, D-San Jose, Randy Cunningham, R-Escondido, and Rush Holt, D-N.J., a physicist. The bill also is co-sponsored by Reps. Ellen Tauscher, D-Walnut Creek, and Barbara Lee, D-Oakland. Fusion requires intense heat and pressure. Under the proper conditions, like those inside the sun, the nuclei of two hydrogen atoms can be forced together so tightly that they fuse, forming a helium nucleus and releasing large amounts of energy that could be harnessed for electricity. The major source of fusion fuel is deuterium (heavy water), which is readily extracted from water. The other fuel source, tritium, is widely available from seawater and land deposits. Fusion is not to be confused with so-called ``cold fusion,'' a disputed theory that few scientists believe is achievable. In 1989 two Utah scientists reported cold-fusion success in the laboratory by immersing metal electrodes in a jar of heavy water. Their results were later discredited, but some scientists continue to experiment with cold fusion. Although research on ``hot'' fusion has been moving forward, it still has many scientific hurdles to overcome, said Robert Park, a physics professor at the University of Maryland. ``We're still a long way away. Thirty years ago they used to say it would be 30 years, and they're still saying the same thing,'' he said. ``We can fuse atoms every day, but the trick is when you produce more energy than it takes to get there.'' The head of one of the leading fusion research facilities in the country agreed that it will probably be the middle of this century before a functioning fusion power plant is operating, but he said the scientific advances ``have really been fantastic.'' Robert Goldston, director of the Plasma Physics Laboratory at Princeton University, said that as a graduate student there in 1974 he and other researchers were thrilled to produce one-tenth of a watt of electricity for one-hundredth of a second using fusion. In 1997, they produced 10 million watts of electricity for about a second -- a degree of advance that outstrips the phenomenal increases in computing power. ``The trick now is to make fusion as practical as computers are,'' he said. ``It's a grand scientific challenge.'' Power is money PUC details plan to raise Edison rates up to 34%. Half of users to see no hike. May 10, 2001 By KATE BERRY The Orange County Register JOHN MEE of Fullerton is focused at a PUC hearing Wednesday at Fullerton College. Photo: Daniel A. Anderson / The Register ? ? Customers of Southern California Edison would see their electricity bills jump as much as 34 percent under rate proposals unveiled Wednesday by the state's top energy regulator. The Public Utilities Commission designed two rate plans to encourage energy conservation and repay the state of California for wholesale power purchases. Though many customers would pay higher rates, half of all residential customers, or 4 million households, would not be subject to any rate increase at all. In January, the Legislature blocked rate hikes for customers who use relatively little electricity or have low incomes. Loretta Lynch, president of the PUC, blamed "unbounded and exorbitant wholesale electricity prices" for the proposed increases, which she disclosed at a news conference in San Francisco. "We all have to share the pain of that," she said. If either of the proposed plans is approved Monday by the commission, the higher rates will appear on electricity bills beginning June 1. The rate increase won't apply to customers of San Diego Gas & Electric or Anaheim Public Utilities. The burden of higher rates would fall primarily on the 2 million households that consume the most electricity. A household that pays $114 a month would, on average, pay $12 more. Bigger users with monthly bills of $213 would pay an additional $73 - a 34 percent increase. The hikes would come on top of a 9 percent increase approved by the PUC in January. Economic crisis in forecast May 10, 2001 By ANNE C. MULKERN The Orange County Register Rolling blackouts this summer could cost California $26.4 billion in lost production and income, a business report released Wednesday forecasts. "This isn't an energy crisis, it's an economic crisis,'' said Nancy Heffernan, spokeswoman for the group of retailers, manufacturers and other business groups that funded the $25,000 study. The report came as Orange County and California escaped a third consecutive day of rolling blackouts. Energy demand fell when the weather cooled. The report was released to coincide with a state Public Utilities Commission announcement on higher electricity rates. The highest rate hikes - up to 50 percent - will hit industrial customers. Although economists previously have said the energy crisis is unlikely to cause a recession, the report said blackouts could cut state productivity growth from current projections of 2.3 percent to less than 1 percent. If the energy crunch is more severe, economic growth could stop, the report said. The study, by New Jersey-based research AUS Consultants, is based on interviews with 34 businesses in 25 different industries. It assumes 110 hours of blackouts will darken businesses and homes this summer and that the average customer will experience about 20 hours of blackouts. Based on the state's so-far limited experience with rolling blackouts, that prediction may be overly severe. The report assumes statewide blackouts, but not every customer is blacked out during any given outage. On March 19, for example, when the most severe blackouts so far hit the state, only 14 percent of Orange County was affected. GOP stalls sale of bonds with vote The $13.4 billion measure is approved, but it lacks two-thirds support for immediate implementation. May 10, 2001 By JOHN HOWARD The Orange County Register For Gov. Gray Davis, the bond sale and the new state budget for the 2001-02 fiscal year beginning July 1 were linked. The governor had hoped to win Republican support for the bonds, and thus a two-thirds majority in both houses, which would have allowed the legislation to take effect immediately and the bonds to be marketed as early as this month. But Republican opposition meant the legislation was approved by only a simple majority, forcing a 90-day wait. "We think we're probably biting off more financing than we can chew," said Jaime Fis Fis, spokesman for Assembly Republican Leader Dave Cox. That means the bond-sale proceeds won't be contained in the state's spending plan until weeks after the new fiscal year begins, and if the market sours for such a large bond issue the state could be affected. "This greatly complicates the budget process," Davis said. Earlier in the day, the Legislature's financial expert said a slowing economy was causing a drop in incoming revenue that could force some $3.4 billion in cuts from the plan Davis proposed in January. The administration is going to announce its own view of the budget on Monday, but Davis signaled that the worsening economy would affect his spending plan. "I suspect it will have an impact," he said. The sole Democratic dissenter in Wednesday's 23-15 Senate vote was Sen. Joe Dunn, D-Santa Ana. He did not address the bond bill on the Senate floor, but earlier said he opposed the bond plan because it was not tied to aggressive action targeting profiteering power generators. Electricity notebook Davis asks power suppliers to accept 30% less than owed May 10, 2001 From Register news services SACRAMENTO Gov. Gray Davis asked generators to accept 30 percent less than they are owed for electricity sold to the state, saying the discount is the price of keeping Edison International solvent. Davis said power suppliers must accept less than they are owed in order to win legislative approval for a financial-rescue package designed to keep Edison, owner of the state's No. 2 utility, Southern California Edison, out of bankruptcy. PG&E Corp.'s Pacific Gas & Electric declared bankruptcy April 6. "I suggested that 70 percent now was better than anything they could get in bankruptcy three to four years down the line," the governor said during a press conference in Sacramento. Davis made his pitch during a meeting with executives from 12 of the largest U.S. energy producers. Air pollution rules to be modified for power plants DIAMOND BAR Southern California air regulators are close to slashing their market-based system for controlling power plant pollution, which for years has allowed plant operators to avoid installing emission controls. The move is designed to allow large power plants to operate at full capacity without facing stiff fines as they try to meet the demand for electricity. The change was prompted by an executive order from Gov. Gray Davis requiring air districts to let large generators run at the greatest capacity. Rules expected to be considered Friday by the South Coast Air Quality Management District Governing Board would curtail a program known as RECLAIM, which has allowed power plants to buy and sell unused emission "credits" controlled by other polluters. Edison, PG&E allege El Paso withheld natural gas supply SAN FRANCISCO California's two largest utilities have filed testimony with federal regulators alleging El Paso Corp. withheld natural gas from the state, leading to an overcharge of some $3.7 billion in energy costs over the past year and worsening the state's power crisis. "We believe El Paso has withheld significant amounts of natural gas from California and manipulated gas prices to the tune of $3.7 billion. ... PG&E also supports these findings," said Kevin Lipson, lead attorney for Edison International unit Southern California Edison, the state's No. 2 investor-owned utility. A spokesman for PG&E Corp. unit Pacific Gas & Electric, the state's No. 1 utility, confirmed Wednesday that it made a filing late Tuesday with federal energy regulators alleging that El Paso Corp. "clearly possessed the ability and incentive to raise (gas) prices." Natural-gas prices in California, the highest in the U.S. over the past year, have been a key reason for the surge in power prices in the state because gas-fired turbines are the single biggest source of electricity in California, providing more than a third of the power used by the state's 34 million residents. Regulator says more electricity rate hikes are likely PUC member tells a Fullerton audience that more increases may be necessary. May 10, 2001 By KATE BERRY The Orange County Register FULLERTON COLLEGE economics professor Arienne Turner brought students to Wednesday's PUC hearing on power-rate increases. Photo: Daniel A. Anderson / The Register ? ? A California energy official said consumers can expect more electricity rate increases beyond the proposals unveiled Wednesday. Carl Wood, one of five commissioners on the state's Public Utilities Commission, said at a public hearing at Fullerton College on Wednesday that raising electricity rates was a "hateful choice," but one the commission may have to revisit. "This may not be the end of the rate increases," Wood told about 250 people at the hearing, one of nine held by the PUC throughout California this week. The hearings were scheduled to allow consumers a voice on how the rate increase should be divvied up among different classes of customers. PUC President Loretta Lynch unveiled two rate proposals Wednesday. Under those plans, rate increases of as much as 34 percent would show up on the bills of customers of Southern California Edison and Pacific Gas & Electric starting in June. The increases would be retroactive to March 27. Consumers expressed anger and frustration at the hearing in Fullerton before Wood and Administrative Law Judge Michael Galvin. "Consumers did not create this mess, and we should not have to pay for it," said Ruth Shapin, a Santa Ana lawyer. Darrell Nolta, a systems engineer in Westminster, held up copies of the 1996 law that deregulated the electricity industry, which promised consumers a 20 percent reduction in retail electricity rates by 2002. "I want a refund of my money," Nolta said, referring to the roughly $19 billion in so-called "stranded costs" that the state's three largest utilities have collected in the past four years and transferred, in part, to their parent corporations. "I want to be able to sue the state of California and the PUC for this." The money transfers and salaries paid to executives at Edison and PG&E were the subject of most of the consumer vitriol. The PUC is investigating the utilities' connections with their parent companies. The utilities say their actions have been legal. Tom Martin, a representative of the Small Manufacturers Association of California, said the rate increases will cripple the state's economy. "Some people believe businesses can just raise prices to make up the difference," he said. "But they cannot." Under the proposals released Wednesday, nearly half of all consumers would pay no rate increase. The 2 million heaviest residential users would pay 10 percent to 34 percent more, or an extra $12 to $73 a month. The 2 million households that are medium users would pay just $2 more a month, a 3 percent increase. Small and medium-sized businesses, which pay lower rates than consumers, can expect a 35 percent increase, while farmers will pay 23 percent more. Industrial users face a 50 percent rate hike. The rates would be partly used to pay back up to $13.4 billion in bonds the state Senate approved Wednesday to recover state expenditures on power since January and future purchases. In just four months, the state has spent about $6 billion buying power for Edison, PG&E and San Diego Gas & Electric Co. customers. Lynch, the PUC president, said the rate proposals would raise $5 billion statewide this year. Under deregulation, consumers' rates were frozen at artificially high levels to allow the utilities to collect "stranded costs," mostly investments in nuclear power plants and contracts with small energy producers. The utilities thought those investments would be unprofitable in a deregulated environment. Starting a year ago, when wholesale electricity prices rose above the level of frozen retail rates, the utilities were stuck with losses on their power purchases. The losses amounted to more than $14billion for Edison and PG&E through January. "Most of the money in this crisis went to the power cartel," said Wood, referring to private power generators that purchased power plants from Edison and PG&E under deregulation. "In the long run, we have to move back to a regulated system because this is an essential commodity." PG&E declared bankruptcy April 6, saying it could no longer shoulder its debt. Starting all over again The Legislature's special sesion on the power crisis ends today -- with more work to do at an added cost. May 10, 2001 By HANH KIM QUACH The Orange County Register SACRAMENTO The state will have to restart a $3.2 million legislative process after lawmakers today adjourn the special session devoted to fixing the energy market. The energy crisis is by no means solved, but because of the rules of the Legislature, the special session must be gav eled to a close to ensure that the $13.4 billion revenue bond bill passed by the Senate on Wednesday can be enacted 91 days after Gov. Gray Davis signs it. But by abruptly ending the session, about 200 energy-related bills that lawmakers have been hashing out will die, said Jon Waldie, chief consultant for the Assembly Rules Committee. Lawmakers would have to reintroduce them in a new special session with a new bill number, he said. The non-partisan Legislative Analyst's Office estimates that it costs an average of $15,900 for each bill that moves through the legislative process. That accounts for printing and staff hours. Democrats are trying to make sure bills don't have to go through the trouble of being rescheduled for hearings and re-debated in committees, both time-consuming efforts, said an aide for Assembly Speaker Bob Hertzberg. But restarting the process has Republicans worried. "It's going to delay the process,'' said Assemblyman Tony Strickland, R-Ventura. "How can the process be delayed when people are going through rolling blackouts?" It's also more work for staff members who have spent countless hours drafting ideas into legalese. Bion Gregory, lead attorney for the Legislative Counsel's Office, said the attorneys need to recreate bills each time they're amended to show how the proposal would change from existing law. "It's not a matter of taking language and reproducing it,'' he said. The special session mechanism allows lawmakers to pass and enact bills more quickly than in the regular session. In special session, bills that pass with a simple majority vote take effect 90 days after the session adjourns, rather than the following Jan. 1, as with regular-session bills. Bills passed with a two-thirds majority in special session can be enacted immediately after the governor signs them. In regular session, such bills don't become effective until 90 days after signed. Having a second session on the same topic didn't concern Ron Roach of the California Taxpayers Association as much. He said the second session might even be more efficient because lawmakers will be more aware of each other's bills and not introduce similar ones. In fact, the second time around might streamline the process, he said. In addition, some of bills that have been largely passed over as legislative leaders search for more immediate fixes to the energy problem are probably not going to make it far anyway. "If they didn't get a hearing (and voted on by now) they never will - what's the point?'' Roach said. Davis is set to sign a $13.4 billion bond-issue measure today to cover electricity costs May 10, 2001 By JOHN HOWARD The Orange County Register SACRAMENTO Gov. Gray Davis is prepared to sign off on the biggest state loan in history today - a $13.4 billion bond sale to buy emergency electricity for California's beleaguered utilities and replenish a state treasury sapped by the energy crisis. The average residential utility ratepayer would pay $2.50 to $3 per month for up to 15 years to retire the debt. Some critics placed the figure at $10.55 per month for ratepayers of all sizes. The Democrat-ruled state Senate, like the Assembly earlier in the week, approved the bond-sale legislation along partisan lines Wednesday. The bill authorizes the state to borrow up to $13.4 billion by selling revenue bonds beginning in August. The money will be used to pay back the state for more than $6 billion worth of electricity it has bought since January on behalf of the utilities and to finance the purchase of new power in long-term contracts. Davis said he plans to use about $12.5 billion of the bond and keep the rest in an emergency reserve. Democratic supporters said the borrowing protected the state budget as California faces an economic downturn and dwindling revenue, and protected potentially threatened programs. Republican critics said the bonds would burden ratepayers for years. "If we don't pass this bill today, we're going to have to wipe out programs," said Sen. Tom Torlakson, D-Antioch, although he did not say which programs could be affected. But Republicans in both houses said the bonds were too high, and urged the governor and legislative leaders to strike a compromise. Thursday, May 10, 2001 Papering over state electricity problems Crisis management and recovery plans are the way to solve a crisis, not piecemeal programs and gimmicks. But even as new blackouts roll across the state, piecemeal is about all we're getting in the way of solutions from Gov. Gray Davis and the California Legislature. The latest one came Monday when the Assembly voted for a $13.4 billion revenue bond to pay for this year's high electricity bills. (Revenue bonds are paid by a service's users, in this case ratepayers.) The Senate is expected to pass the bill, Senate Bill 31X, today or Thursday. Because the two-thirds threshold was not met in the Assembly, the bonds could not be issued immediately, but instead will be issued in 90 days, in August. In the 49-29 vote, only Republican Assemblyman Anthony Pescetti of Rancho Cordova sided with the Democratic majority. The bonds will repay the state general fund for electricity purchases which, so far in the crisis, amount to at least $5 billion and will rise much higher later this year. Bonds will be repaid over 15 years. In a conference call Gov. Davis held with us and several other newspapers Monday, he explained that he hoped for bipartisan support for the bonds because the delay "would greatly complicate the budget process and could damage the economy. It's my hope that both parties can be part of the solution, not part of the problem. People elected us to be problem solvers." The Republicans' beliefs were summarized by Assemblyman Tony Strickland of Thousand Oaks. "Let me tell you what our caucus' philosophy is," he told the San Diego Union-Tribune. "If you have money today, you don't borrow against your children and grandchildren's future." The Republicans favor using the state budget surplus to pay for the state electricity purchases. Indeed, the bond sale will create more problems than it solves. "It's not needed," Adrian Moore, director of economic studies at the Reason Public Policy Institute, told us. "It helps cover up the costs of what Davis's overall policies are bringing about. It just stretches it out so it's not paid this budget cycle. Plus it adds interest [costs]." What's really needed, Mr. Moore said, is to "get back to a market-based solution." Retail prices to ratepayers, now capped, should be further freed. Higher retail prices then would bring about more conservation and power plant investment and, as less electricity is used, wholesale and retail prices would moderate. And, the governor and Legislature should stop attacking power producers with threats of seizures and taxes, especially given the intermittant price caps instituted by federal energy regulators. Leaders should instead encourage producers to build here. The longer California's leaders paper over the dimensions of the crisis, the longer it will persist and the more expensive it will become. Task Force To Propose Legislation By SCOTT LINDLAW Associated Press Writer WASHINGTON (AP) via NewsEdge Corporation - President Bush's energy task force plans to propose legislation allowing the seizure of private property to accelerate the construction of electrical power lines, three administration officials said Tuesday. The recommendation is contained in the final draft of a broad energy blueprint to be unveiled by President Bush next week, the officials said. The ``eminent domain'' authority allows the government to appropriate private property for public use; the property owners are usually compensated. The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission already has eminent domain authority over the siting of natural gas pipelines, but has no such power over long-distance electricity transmission lines. The lack of authority often requires electrical companies to get approval from several states and numerous local jurisdictions. Federal authority to locate transmission lines would quicken the approval process, supporters of the provision contend. The shortage of transmission lines has been cited by officials as one reason for bottlenecks in the electric grids and a shortage of power in areas of high demand. New lines also are needed to connect new power plants to the grid. Vice President Dick Cheney said on CNN Tuesday that the energy task force he heads will include a recommendation on eminent domain for power lines. ``The issue is whether or not we should have the same authority on electrical transmission lines'' as the government has on gas lines, Cheney said. ``That's never been granted previously.'' He did not say what the recommendation would be. But the administration officials, speaking on condition of anonymity, said the report would ask Energy Secretary Spencer Abraham to draw up legislation allowing utilities to obtain rights of way for transmission lines, presumably through FERC. The energy strategy report is going to the printers in stages this week. Officials said there was no talk of taking out the eminent domain provision, though they could not rule out that remote possibility. Utilities, not the government, would own the property, one official said. Earlier this year, a draft of a Republican energy bill in the Senate had included giving FERC eminent domain authority for power lines. But that provision later was deleted when it was introduced by Sen. Frank Murkowski, R-Alaska. The electric utility industry for some time has been lobbying for a federal role in siting electric power lines, which now must go through a maze of overlapping local jurisdictions and state agencies for approval. ``If FERC has the eminent siting authority, that will help facilitate siting of electric power transmission lines,'' said Jim Owen, a spokesman for the Edison Electric Institute, which represents investor-owned utilities. It especially would help in getting interstate transmission rights of way approved, he said. ``But it's still not a silver bullet because ... it can still be a cumbersome process,'' said Owen. Some natural gas pipeline cases before FERC have taken years to resolve, he said. Critics have questioned whether Cheney's task force will emphasize power production and transmission over conservation. Cheney said the report would use tax breaks to encourage conservation. ``Most of the financial incentives that we recommend in the report go for conservation or renewables, for increased efficiencies,'' Cheney said. The task force will likely recommend tax incentives for purchase of ``hybrid,'' ultra-efficient automobiles that run on gasoline and electricity, one administration official said. A similar provision was included in the budget Bush sent to Congress earlier this year. The report will also call for a new tax credit for builders of certain new power plants. Cheney outlined the energy plan at the weekly Senate GOP conference Tuesday. According to one Republican who was present, the vice president said that while he supported energy price controls when President Nixon used them three decades ago, he wouldn't advocate them now. Caps that are too high cause voters to blame politicians rather than the utilities, Cheney said, according to the Republican. Excessively low caps undermine the incentives for developing new power sources, Cheney said. After Cheney spoke, Sen. Gordon Smith, R-Ore., rebutted, saying he came from a state where energy prices have risen enormously in the past year, and he favors price caps. Stage 2 Electrical Emergency Declaration; SCE to Curtail 'Load' for Some Customers ROSEMEAD, Calif., May 9 /PRNewswire/ via NewsEdge Corporation - The California Independent System Operator (Cal-ISO) again declared a Stage 2 Emergency this afternoon, due to low power reserves and increased demand for power because of high temperatures. The agency called upon Southern California Edison and other investor-owned utilities to begin voluntary "load" curtailment programs for certain customers within their service areas. Cal-ISO said the Stage 2 Emergency would be in effect from 11:45 a.m. through midnight. Cal-ISO and SCE are making urgent appeals for all customers to immediately reduce their electricity consumption so that reserve levels do not deteriorate further. To achieve this load reduction during Stage 2, SCE is required to activate its voluntary load curtailment program, under which large industrial, commercial, and agricultural customers have agreed to temporarily curtail electricity usage during an electrical emergency in exchange for reduced rates. Should the situation worsen for any reason, and power reserves drop below 1.5%, Cal-ISO could declare a Stage 3 Emergency, the most critical status. Cal-ISO could direct utilities to "drop load," necessitating involuntary rolling blackouts for groups of customers across their service areas until sufficient reserve levels are achieved. SCE customers are asked to reduce power consumption by turning off any unneeded electrical appliances and lights, especially during the state's daily peak consumption period -- noon to 6 p.m. Following are some effective ways customers can reduce their power use and not be greatly inconvenienced: LARGE ENERGY USERS -- turn off all auxiliary or redundant machinery where possible; -- consider shifting or staggering operations outside the hours of highest electrical demand, typically noon to 6 p.m.; AIR CONDITIONERS -- set thermostats no lower than 78 degrees (F); -- use electric fans instead of air conditioning if practical; -- avoid using evaporative coolers or humidifiers at the same time an air conditioner is running; -- avoid cooling unoccupied rooms; -- open windows during evening hours to take advantage of cool breezes; APPLIANCES AND TOOLS -- delay until evening hours the optional use of appliances (dishwashers, clothes washers and dryers), chargers, power tools, and electrical equipment; REFRIGERATORS AND FREEZERS -- avoid unnecessarily opening refrigerators; -- keep your refrigerator or freezer set at the proper temperature; -- be sure to use the "power-saver" switch if your refrigerator has one; -- keep the condenser coils behind or beneath your refrigerator/freezer clean (refrigerators represent approximately 25% of the electric bill for a typical residence); ADDITIONAL TIPS -- run swimming pool equipment during early morning and evening hours; -- limit the reopening of a refrigerator, which is a major user of electricity in most homes; -- use drapes and blinds to keep out direct sunlight; -- replace incandescent light bulbs with ENERGY Star(R) qualified compact fluorescent bulbs; -- always wash a full load of clothes or use the variable water level adjustment for smaller loads; and -- be sure your home has adequate insulation. For more information about electricity conservation and SCE's energy efficiency programs, go to www.sce.com. An Edison International (NYSE: EIX) company, Southern California Edison is one of the nation's largest electric utilities, serving a population of more than 11 million via 4.3 million customer accounts in a 50,000-square-mile service area within central, coastal and Southern California. SOURCE Southern California Edison CONTACT: Corporate Communications of Southern California Edison, 626-302-2255 Web site: http://www.edisonnews.com Web site: http://www.sce.com (EIX) B] FULL/ Pacific Gas & Electric restores all Qualifying Facilities --Pacific Gas & Electric says 8 of 300 QFs still shut down May 10, 2001 New York, May 9 (BridgeNews) - Pacific Gas & Electric Co. restored nearly all of the Qualifying Facilities that had been shut down earlier in the year due to financial reasons. The company now has only eight of the more than 300 Qualifying Facilities under contract to it still shut down for payment-related reasons. --Adrian Viegas, BridgeNews * * * The following is the text of today's announcement, with emphasis added by BridgeNews. BridgeStation users will find links to company data at the end: Most of PG&E's Qualifying Facilities are Back On Line; Only 3% Still Shut Down for Payment-Related Reasons SAN FRANCISCO----May 9, 2001--PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY ANNOUNCED TODAY THAT NEARLY ALL OF THE QUALIFYING FACILITIES (QFS) THAT HAD SHUT DOWN EARLIER THIS YEAR FOR FINANCIAL REASONS HAVE RETURNED TO SERVICE, AND ARE AGAIN GENERATING POWER FOR PG&E'S ELECTRIC CUSTOMERS. ONLY EIGHT OF THE MORE THAN 300 QFS UNDER CONTRACT TO PG&E ARE STILL SHUT DOWN FOR PAYMENT-RELATED REASONS. THESE EIGHT REMAINING GENERATORS TYPICALLY DELIVER ABOUT 109 MW OF POWER, OUT OF THE ROUGHLY 2,500 MW TOTAL TYPICALLY DELIVERED BY ALL PG&E-CONTRACTED QF GENERATORS COMBINED. ALL EIGHT FACILITIES ARE GAS-FIRED GENERATORS. "We remain optimistic that these last few generators will come back on line in the next few days, and we are working with them to help make that happen," said Gordon R. Smith, president and CEO of Pacific Gas and Electric Company. "Ironically, our Chapter 11 filing has provided additional financial certainty to many QFs, since we are now able to pay them in full for power they are delivering, and since rates currently cover their costs. We will continue to work with the QF producers to assure that all of the power they are supposed to deliver will be available for our customers." The QFs under contract to Pacific Gas and Electric Company have been paid in full since early April, and received partial payments for prior deliveries. In addition to the facilities shut down for nonpayment, another 13 facilities that would ordinarily be delivering an average of 82 mw are out for scheduled maintenance or unplanned outages. This amount is fairly typical and not unusual for this time of year. For energy saving tips, please visit our website at www.pge.com/123 or contact the Smarter Energy Line at 1-800-933-9555. CONTACT: Pacific Gas and Electric Company News Department, 415/973-5930 End