20 Apr 2001, 14:59 UTC
Energy Issues
- From
- Steven J Kean steven.kean@enron.com
- To
- Tom Briggs
- Date
- Fri, 20 Apr 2001 07:59:00 -0700 (PDT)
See natural gas price article below. Our buddy Paul Carpenter has turned on us (not to mention that he seems to be talking nonsense). How about giving him a call?
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
---------------------- Forwarded by Steven J Kean/NA/Enron on 04/20/2001 02:58 PM --------------------------- Miyung Buster@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT 04/20/2001 10:22 AM To: Ann M Schmidt/Corp/Enron@ENRON, Bryan Seyfried/LON/ECT@ECT, dg27@pacbell.net, Elizabeth Linnell/NA/Enron@Enron, filuntz@aol.com, James D Steffes/NA/Enron@Enron, Janet Butler/ET&S/Enron@ENRON, Jeannie Mandelker/HOU/ECT@ECT, Jeff Dasovich/NA/Enron@Enron, Joe Hartsoe/Corp/Enron@ENRON, John Neslage/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, John Sherriff/LON/ECT@ECT, Joseph Alamo/NA/Enron@Enron, Karen Denne/Corp/Enron@ENRON, Lysa Akin/PDX/ECT@ECT, Margaret Carson/Corp/Enron@ENRON, Mark Palmer/Corp/Enron@ENRON, Mark Schroeder/LON/ECT@ECT, Markus Fiala/LON/ECT@ECT, Michael R Brown/LON/ECT@ECT, Mike Dahlke/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, Mona L Petrochko/NA/Enron@Enron, Nicholas O'Day/AP/Enron@Enron, Peggy Mahoney/HOU/EES@EES, Peter Styles/LON/ECT@ECT, Richard Shapiro/NA/Enron@Enron, Rob Bradley/Corp/Enron@ENRON, Sandra McCubbin/NA/Enron@Enron, Shelley Corman/ET&S/Enron@ENRON, Stella Chan/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, Steven J Kean/NA/Enron@Enron, Susan J Mara/NA/Enron@Enron, Mike Roan/ENRON@enronXgate, Alex Parsons/EU/Enron@Enron, Andrew Morrison/LON/ECT@ECT, lipsen@cisco.com, Janel Guerrero/Corp/Enron@Enron, Shirley A Hudler/HOU/ECT@ECT, Kathleen Sullivan/NA/Enron@ENRON, Tom Briggs/NA/Enron@Enron, Linda Robertson/NA/Enron@ENRON, Lora Sullivan/Corp/Enron@ENRON, Jennifer Thome/NA/Enron@Enron, jkradin@marathon-com.com, rlichtenstein@marathon-com.com, syamane@marathon-com.com, ken@kdscommunications.com, hgovenar@govadv.com, sgovenar@govadv.com, bhansen@lhom.com, Carin Nersesian/NA/Enron@Enron cc: Subject: Energy Issues Please see the following articles: Sac Bee, Fri, 4/20: "State might balk on power: But refusing to pay 'ridiculous' prices could add to crisis" Sac Bee, Fri, 4/20: "SMUD directors vote to hike rates: A tentative increase of 19% to 27% is blamed on rising energy costs" Sac Bee, Fri, 4/20: "Lieberman to Bush: Help California solve power woes" SD Union, Fri, 4/20: "Escondido calls a halt to power plant ideas" SD Union, Fri, 4/20: "Inflated natural-gas prices add to energy costs, expert says" SD Union (AP), Fri, 4/20: "Davis, Congress members call for energy price controls" SD Union (AP), Fri, 4/20: "Regulators open investigation into alternative power providers" SD Union (AP), Fri, 4/20: "Attorney general taking two energy companies to court" LA Times, Fri, 4/20: "Legislators Unite Over Energy Price Issue" SF Chron, Fri, 4/20: "Small fry among big fish in PG&E bankruptcy Some unlikely businesses are listed as creditors against utility" SF Chron (AP), Fri, 4/20: "Developments in California" SF Chron (AP), Fri, 4/20: "California utility wants to boost Mohave power plant production" SF Chron (AP), Fri, 4/20: "PG&E owes money to several small businesses, unlikely creditors" SF Chron, Fri, 4/20: "Edison pushes lawmakers to accept deal" Mercury News, Fri, 4/20: "Who will pay the most for power?" Mercury News, Fri, 4/20: "Credit-raters put state on watch" Mercury News, Fri, 4/20: "Power company executives going without bonuses" Mercury News, Fri, 4/20: "Davis and US lawmakers call for price caps on power" Mercury News, Fri, 4/20: "Generators cutting electric output; regulators want to find out why" OC Register, Fri, 4/20: "FERC remains an unlikely rescuer The federal agency hews to a hands-off policy on power rates" OC Register, Fri, 4/20: "Lawmakers seek bigger rollbacks, can't agree on caps" OC Register, Fri, 4/20: "Energy notebook Assembly urges federal regulation of natural gas" OC Register, Fri, 4/20: "Shed light on costs" (Commentary) Individual.com (AP), Fri, 4/20: "End To Deregulation of Nevada Power" Individual.com (Business wire), Fri, 4/20: "PG&E Co. Issues Statements On the Increase in the State's Cost for Power" Indivdual.com (PR/newswire), Fri, 4/20: "J.D. Power and Associates Reports/ Nationwide Decline in Customer Satisfaction of Electric Utility Service Among Midsize Businesses" Individual.com (PR/newswire), Fri, 4/20: "Calpine to Purchase 46 General Electric Gas Turbines Turbines in Place for 70,000-megawatt Program" ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------ State might balk on power: But refusing to pay 'ridiculous' prices could add to crisis. By Dale Kasler Bee Staff Writer (Published April 20, 2001) Adding to the risk of summertime blackouts, the state water department said Thursday it might not pay "ridiculous" prices for electricity even if that leaves California short of power. The Department of Water Resources, which has been buying electricity for the state's two beleaguered utilities since mid-January, wouldn't spell out what it considers ridiculous. But if prices get too high, the state might be better off ordering blackouts or implementing proposed new conservation programs designed at cutting usage on short notice, said Raymond Hart, the department's deputy director in charge of power purchases. Gov. Gray Davis took a different view, saying: "We will continue to keep the lights on. When you're fighting a forest fire, you don't say, 'Let me see, how much is this going to cost me? Maybe I can't write the check, maybe I can't put the fire out.' You put the fire out and then worry about the cost later." But Davis' spokesman, Steve Maviglio, said the Governor's Office indeed is contemplating whether to refuse to buy power at any cost. "At what point does the state say, 'Enough is enough'? Those scenarios are certainly under discussion," Maviglio said. The water department until recently resisted buying all the power Southern California Edison and Pacific Gas and Electric Co. needed, refusing to purchase electricity it deemed too costly. But lately it's had to relax that stance because of an order by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, Hart said. That April 6 order said power generators can no longer be forced to sell electricity to uncreditworthy entities such as the Independent System Operator, which manages the state's power grid. Because the ISO -- which gets its money from the utilities -- can no longer buy the power, the water department is now buying all the electricity required by the utilities, Hart said. But he said the department could back off if prices get out of hand. "If the prices just get ridiculous altogether, there's a policy call to be made, and we'll cross that bridge when we get there," Hart said. The ISO has predicted that severe shortages could bring 34 days of rolling blackouts this summer. The potential refusal of the water department to buy ultra-expensive power could further strain the grid. "On a daily basis we're dealt a set of cards," said ISO spokesman Patrick Dorinson. "It sounds like ... we're going to be handed another set of cards, and we're going to have to try to maintain the reliability of the grid as best we can." Hart's comments came amid an increasingly rancorous debate between Davis and PG&E over the water department's power expenditures. State spending shot up following PG&E's April 6 filing for bankruptcy protection. Davis said generators began demanding a "credit penalty" from the water department because of the PG&E bankruptcy proceedings. As a result, the state's daily costs shot up last week to $73.2 million from $57.4 million in the week before PG&E went bankrupt, the governor's office said. Hart agreed, saying several generators raised their prices. "Every time there's a major hiccup in the market, such as PG&E bankruptcy or a staged alert by the ISO, there's a price run-up," Hart said. But prices have settled down this week. After peaking at $345 a megawatt hour April 12, prices for north state power were at $243 on Thursday, just below what they were prior to the bankruptcy filing, according to the Enerfax news service. PG&E, however, said its bankruptcy filing had nothing to do with the state's increased spending. "This claim is simply not accurate," the utility said in a memo to reporters. Rather, the increased spending is due solely to the fact that the water department is buying more units of electricity in the wake of the FERC order, PG&E said. Regardless of the cause, the increased spending by the water department could further strain the state's budget -- and complicate Davis' plan to finance the power purchases through a bond offering. The state has committed $5.2 billion from its general fund for power purchases since January. Those mounting purchases, along with PG&E's bankruptcy filing and other energy crisis uncertainties, prompted a third Wall Street credit rating agency, Fitch, to place the state on a "ratings watch" this week, meaning the rating might be downgraded. A downgrade could raise California's borrowing costs. All three of the leading Wall Street credit agencies now have California on a ratings watch. Meanwhile, the state Public Utilities Commission on Thursday ordered an investigation of why hundreds of cogenerators and other alternative energy providers haven't resumed production even though they've begun receiving payments again from Edison and PG&E. These generators, under contract to the utilities, provide more than 20 percent of the state's energy supply. Hundreds shut down, worsening California's power situation, because they'd received little or no money from the utilities since November. The PUC ordered Edison and PG&E to resume payments, starting this week, for new power deliveries. But the generators say the payments aren't enough to get them back online. So PUC President Loretta Lynch said the commission will investigate whether to order Edison and PG&E to begin repaying them the hundreds of millions owed for past deliveries. The Bee's Dale Kasler can be reached at (916) 321-1066 or dkasler@sacbee.com. Emily Bazar of The Bee's Capitol Bureau contributed to this report. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ -------------------------------------------------------- SMUD directors vote to hike rates: A tentative increase of 19% to 27% is blamed on rising energy costs. By Carrie Peyton Bee Staff Writer (Published April 20, 2001) Ten years of stable electricity bills vanished in a single unanimous vote Thursday night as directors of Sacramento Municipal Utility District gave tentative approval to rate hikes ranging from 19 percent to 27 percent. The new rates will go into effect immediately after a final vote, scheduled for May 3. "This is quite alarming to all of us," said director Peter Keat. But praising the value of "a community-owned electric company" that provides everything from shade trees to public votes on rates, Keat said he saw no choice. SMUD, which once hoped to lower electric bills this year or next as deregulation took hold, was caught up in the spiraling wholesale costs that helped send Pacific Gas and Electric Co. into bankruptcy proceedings. The price of natural gas, which fuels SMUD's cogeneration plants, has risen steeply. Wholesale electricity, which SMUD buys to supplement power produced by its own plants, nearly tripled between October and January. And the weather has been dismal. Rainfall and snowmelt that feed SMUD's hydroelectric plants on the upper American River are about 53 percent of normal to date. But during a two-hour hearing, a small contingent of consumers asked the board to reconsider. "I realize that rates have to go up, but this seems like a big percentage all at once," said Marian Ender. Several criticized a 6 percent surcharge that until only a few days before had been proposed at 3 percent. Among them was Duy Tu, an engineering manager at Intel who served on SMUD's advisory rate committee. The increase "cannot come at a worse time" for Intel, he said, although he understands the need for it. He urged the board to act now to make more electricity available in the future. "We are way too dependent on some external force to keep the lights on," Tu said. Overall, a base rate increase averaging 16 percent will raise about $124 million annually for SMUD, and a special 6 percent surcharge will raise about $48 million in its first year. Most of the surcharge, scheduled to drop to 3 percent annually for two subsequent years, will go into an emergency fund. "We have to build back our savings account. It's been gutted," said director Susan Patterson. The rate increases will fall most heavily on small commercial and large industrial power users, although households with very low electricity bills will feel a sharp bite from the addition of a $5 monthly service fee. The flat fee adds less than 10 percent to what was a "typical" residential SMUD bill of $67, but it's a 25 percent rate hike for someone whose monthly bill hovers around $20. "I just don't think that part is right," Ender said. "We should only pay for usage." Tom Reavey took the board to task for "unfair and unequitable" rates that charge agriculture and small businesses less than what they cost SMUD to serve, while charging homeowners and renters slightly more. But board members defended going easier on rates for the pumps that run farmers' wells and irrigation systems. "We all gain great benefits from living in a community that has nearby agriculture," Keat said. The new rates will apply throughout SMUD's service territory, which includes a narrow slice of southern Placer County and all but the southwestern tip of Sacramento County. They will not affect people who receive electric service from PG&E, which last month was granted a 29 percent hike by state regulators. "If you want to see a bunch of folks who are really facing some stark times, it's PG&E customers," said board member Howard Posner. While there is widespread speculation that PG&E's rate hikes are the first of many, Posner and other directors said they hoped Thursday's increases will be the last SMUD needs and that rates could decline in three to four years. To boost conservation, both SMUD and PG&E are trying to craft rates that fall hardest on the heaviest household users. SMUD's old residential rates were divided into a baseline tier charged roughly 8 cents a kilowatt-hour in the summer and one higher tier billed at 12.7 cents a kilowatt-hour. The new rates will start at 8.6 cents in the summer, rise to a middle tier of 14.5 cents and top out at 16.2 cents for those who use more than 1,000 kilowatt-hours of electricity. By comparison, PG&E has proposed to the state Public Utilities Commission that its residential rates be divided into four tiers, topping out at 27 cents per kilowatt-hour. A PUC decision is expected next month. Under the new SMUD rate structure, including the surcharge, large industries will see their electric bills rise by an average of 27 percent, agricultural rates will rise 22 percent, small commercial rates 27 percent and residential rates 19 percent. Households that qualify for special low-income or life-support rates will pay a smaller monthly customer charge of $3.50 and will not have to pay the surcharge on their baseline electricity usage. Information about qualifying for the reduced rates is available from SMUD at (888) 742-7683. The Bee's Carrie Peyton can be reached at (916) 321-1086 or cpeyton@sacbee.com. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ---------------------------------------------------------- Lieberman to Bush: Help California solve power woes By Emily Bazar Bee Capitol Bureau (Published April 20, 2001) On a brief visit to the capital Thursday, former Democratic vice presidential candidate Joe Lieberman called on President Bush to help rescue California from its deepening energy troubles. After attending an early-morning prayer breakfast with legislators and Gov. Gray Davis, the U.S. senator from Connecticut met with them to discuss the federal government's role in easing California's electricity woes. Lieberman, a potential Democratic presidential candidate in 2004, warned that if the Bush administration does not act quickly in California, the rest of the nation will succumb to economic ripple effects. "No American leader can disengage from a problem that so profoundly affects our largest state," Lieberman told reporters after meeting with the Democratic governor. "I call on the president to get involved. ... We can't sit back in Washington and let California suffer." Sacramento was the last California stop for the senator, who has spent three days at fund-raisers and speaking engagements across the state. In talks with lawmakers about the energy crisis, Lieberman told them he's strongly urging the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission to impose temporary caps on the wholesale price of electricity. But the commission's chairman, Curt Hebert, is a fierce free-market advocate who has long opposed price caps and has not indicated he will change his mind. If FERC doesn't act soon, Lieberman said he will support legislation sponsored by Sen. Dianne Feinstein, D-Calif., to force FERC to impose temporary caps. He expects Feinstein to introduce her legislation early next week. Lieberman's first stop Thursday morning was the California Prayer Breakfast, an annual springtime gathering of religious and political leaders. At the breakfast, speakers told Davis they would pray for him as he navigates the state's energy crisis. Before launching into a song from "The Scarlet Pimpernel," singer Steve Amerson called on the governor to tell Californians the truth throughout the ordeal. Davis was solemn in his remarks, and his calm demeanor belied his behavior Tuesday, when he reportedly erupted in an obscene tirade during a closed-door meeting with Senate Republicans. "I'm going to tell you the truth, Steve. We have a problem," Davis said to the singer. "But God has provided a path out of that problem if we all do our part." The Bee's Emily Bazar can be reached at (916) 326-5540 or ebazar@sacbee.com. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ -------------------------------------------------------- Escondido calls a halt to power plant ideas Temporary step will give it time for overall planning By Jonathan Heller UNION-TRIBUNE STAFF WRITER April 19, 2001 ESCONDIDO -- After being inundated with proposals to build power plants in the past few months, the City Council yesterday called a timeout. The council voted 3-2 to suspend consideration for 30 to 60 days of any proposals to build energy generating facilities in the city. During that period, city staff members will develop a comprehensive approval process that will factor in the cumulative effects of such plants. "We need to step back and look at the direction we're going in," City Councilwoman June Rady said. The city has been juggling four power-plant proposals since January: ?Sempra Energy Resources wants to build a 500-megawatt plant in the southwest part of Escondido. It has not yet filed formal plans with the city Planning Department. ?Ramco Inc. of San Diego has received approval to build a 44-megawatt plant on Mission Avenue in west Escondido. ?CalPeak LLC of San Diego has filed plans to build a 49.5-megawatt plant on Enterprise Street, not far from the Ramco plant. ?Another firm has expressed interest in building a 49.5-megawatt plant on city property on West Washington Avenue, but has not submitted plans yet. Yesterday's decision means that all the projects -- except the already-approved Ramco plant -- are now on hold, and no new proposals can be filed with the city. The decision halts a mad dash by developers to bring power plants on line by the summer to take advantage of special incentives offered by Gov. Gray Davis. Mayor Lori Holt Pfeiler and Councilwoman Marie Waldron opposed the move. They said it would only delay much-needed solutions to the region's energy crisis, which is expected to come to a head this summer. "If (plant developers) have a chance of getting power on line by the summer, we should not be the ones to stand in the way," Pfeiler said. Waldron argued that cities have to be more proactive at this time, not less. "The governor is not solving the problem," Waldron said. "It's up to local governments to try to do what they can." Joe Rowley, Sempra's project development director, said he doubted the council's decision would upset his plans. "Our timetable is still not fully defined," Rowley said. "Obviously there's a lot of work we have to do to get to the point where an application can be processed." Meanwhile, council members listened to two people who made impassioned pleas for the city to consider alternative power sources. David Drake, a service architect for SAIC in La Jolla, urged the council to think about solar power. There is more than enough available land -- and rooftop space -- to install enough solar panels to power the whole city, he said. "Escondido has 65 square miles," he said. "But 2,500 acres could be employed to power us forever without any reliance on imported energy." Local inventor Arnold Lund urged the council to consider energy generated from windmills. The council also voted to work with San Marcos in exploring ways to seek inexpensive, stable energy rates. The hope is that the two cities can forge a deal with Sempra for cheaper rates. Sempra officials have said they are willing to discuss possible rate deals with the city. To buy power directly, a city has to adopt a special legal arrangement, such as forming a municipal utility district. San Diego Gas & Electric is the only energy service provider in the county that buys and sells power from the regional energy grid. San Marcos has formed a municipal utility district but has not signed any deals to buy power. It would be a more lengthy process for Escondido to form such a district. San Marcos is a charter city and has more flexibility under the state Constitution. Escondido is a general-law city. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ----------------------------------------------- Inflated natural-gas prices add to energy costs, expert says Windfall-profits tax gets Davis' backing By Bill Ainsworth UNION-TRIBUNE STAFF WRITER April 19, 2001 SACRAMENTO -- Federal regulators' failure to stop what they described as anti-competitive practices in the natural-gas industry added $750 million to Southern California Edison's cost of electricity, a consultant estimated yesterday. The consultant, Paul Carpenter of the Brattle Group, spoke to an Assembly subcommittee investigating why California pays the highest natural-gas prices in the nation. Natural gas is a critical part of the electricity crisis because most of the state's generating plants run on natural gas. Natural-gas prices have soared throughout the nation, but the bench mark price paid at California's border has been double that paid at other bench mark locations throughout the nation for months, according to figures released by the Assembly Subcommittee on Energy Oversight. Next week, Carpenter plans to testify at hearings in Washington, D.C., on behalf of Southern California Edison and the California Public Utilities Commission, which are asking federal regulators to intervene. The giant utility and the state regulatory body contend that a sweetheart deal between El Paso Natural Gas and El Paso Merchant Energy gave the sister companies enough market power to artificially raise the price of natural gas that flows into Southern California from Texas. El Paso owns the major pipeline bringing natural gas from fields in New Mexico and Texas to Southern California. El Paso Merchant Energy is an unregulated sister company. Carpenter called the prices paid in Southern California "simply unprecedented" in the United States. He estimated that the sister companies manipulated the market enough to add $2.60 to the price of a million British thermal units of gas. In addition, he said, El Paso Merchant Energy owns part of 20 smaller power plants, "qualifying facilities" that get paid based on the price of natural gas in California. The higher natural-gas prices increase the company's revenues, Carpenter said. El Paso company officials are expected to testify in front of the Assembly subcommittee today, but in proceedings before the federal regulators they have denied any sweetheart deal. In a report they commissioned, the company blamed the higher natural-gas prices in Southern California on increased demand and constraints on pipeline capacity. Gov. Gray Davis, meanwhile, gave his strongest endorsement yet to a windfall-profits tax on generators as a Senate committee chaired by Joseph Dunn, D-Laguna Niguel, began a series of hearings to probe possible price gouging by generators. "I believe the Legislature would be well within its prerogative to insist that generators receive an appropriate reduction, whether it's 20 percent or any other number the Legislature hit upon," Davis said. Senate Democrats, Davis said, will form a special committee to help work on his plan for the state purchase of the transmission system of Southern California Edison for $2.76 billion, in exchange for state aid in paying off the utilities' debt. The governor said he told Senate Democrats, a number of whom are skeptical of the plan, that Edison's parent firm has agreed to back a $3 billion upgrade of the neighborhood distribution system retained by Edison and to return a $400 million tax refund to the utility. At the natural-gas hearing yesterday, state officials said that after El Paso Merchant Energy bought a significant part of the pipeline capacity from its sister company, it withheld natural gas to drive prices up. "Marketers have gamed the system and figured out how to hoard capacity and undermine competition," said Harvey Morris, an attorney for the California Public Utilities Commission. State regulators want the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, which regulates natural gas, to open the market to more competitors. But the commission has repeatedly rejected similar complaints in the past. On March 28, FERC ruled that the affiliates did not arrange a sweetheart deal. "The fact that El Paso Merchant controls a large volume of capacity does not, in and of itself, render the El Paso contracts unjust, unreasonable or unduly discriminatory," FERC ruled. In other cases involving natural gas, federal regulators acknowledged that certain contract provisions allowed anti-competitive behavior, but they approved those contracts anyway. Lawmakers said they were puzzled by the federal regulators' lack of action. "It baffles me that we've found the problem -- anti-competitive behavior and market gaming, but there's no cure because federal regulators won't take action," said Assemblyman Juan Vargas, D-San Diego. Staff writer Ed Mendel contributed to this report. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------- Davis, Congress members call for energy price controls By Gary Gentile ASSOCIATED PRESS April 19, 2001 LOS ANGELES ) Gov. Gray Davis and a bipartisan group of the state's congressional delegates agreed Thursday that the federal government must act to control the wholesale price of energy. "For us the big issue is how we address the unjust rates," said Rep. Mary Bono, R-Palm Springs. "I believe we are up to it and will handle it as soon as we can." Davis met behind closed doors with 27 congressional representatives, including Sen. Dianne Feinstein, D-Calif., at the Sheraton Gateway Hotel near Los Angeles International Airport. He said after the 90-minute meeting that the group discussed a threefold approach to the state's power crisis. The strategy includes requiring federal agencies in the state, including military facilities, to conserve energy this summer and asking the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission to find a way to control the wholesale price of electricity and increase the flow of natural gas into California. Davis repeated his criticism of federal regulators for not acting sooner to control the wholesale price of electricity and said he was hopeful the state's congressional delegation could work together to find a bipartisan solution. "We agreed there has to be a mechanism to reduce the wholesale price of electricity," Davis said. "We have agreed to work cooperatively across party lines to find ways we can reduce those costs. We're in this together. Party doesn't matter. Finding a solution does matters." "To have the price of moving natural gas go up by a factor of 10 or more is absurd," said Rep. Brad Sherman, D-Los Angeles. "So many of our colleagues are telling us it's California's fault, but California does not have the authority to regulate these two items." The group also talked about easing environmental regulations during power emergencies to allow small companies and even military bases to run small generators. "If you have generators in the state, regardless of what they run on, because we're entering this emergency period in the summertime and will be short of power, you should be allowed to turn them on," said Rep. Duncan Hunter, R-El Cajon. Hunter said small generators could produce about 500 to 600 megawatts during a power emergency if exemptions to various clear air requirements could be made. Officials discussed ways to allow FERC to control wholesale prices without violating ideological positions staked out by high-ranking Republican officials, including Vice President Dick Cheney, who oppose price controls and favor free markets. Rep Jane Harman, D-Torrance, said she would support a finding by FERC that power wholesalers should not be allowed to charge market rates, but rather rates more tightly pegged to the cost of generating power. "We're not talking about artificial caps," Harman said. "We should insist that the FERC not renew their market-based rate authority. And if we go that route, it takes us to the same place and avoids the ideological fight." The meeting did not result in any specific proposals but participants praised the bipartisan nature of the talks and said it would result in a unified approach in Washington. "We have a responsibility to make sure the federal government takes it's role seriously," said Rep Gary Condit, D-Modesto. "We clearly understand what our assignment is today and I think we're going to work together in a bipartisan way to get that done." ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ----------------------------------------------------------- Regulators open investigation into alternative power providers By Michael Liedtke ASSOCIATED PRESS April 19, 2001 SAN FRANCISCO ) Hoping to prevent California's bleak power outlook from becoming even darker, state regulators Thursday launched an investigation into why alternative energy providers aren't producing more electricity. With the action, the California Public Utilities Commission hopes to determine if legitimate business reasons or ulterior motives underlie the reduced output by an independent group of small generators that provides much of the state's energy. These alternative generators ) known in the industry as "qualifying facilities," or QFs ) have been scaling back or shutting down as debts owed by California's two largest utilities pile up. The QFs are owed an estimated $700 million by bankrupt Pacific Gas and Electric and financially crippled Southern California Edison. Some QFs say the unpaid bills have forced them to defer much-needed maintenance, leading to more equipment breakdowns that reduce electricity output. Other QFs say they simply can't afford to keep operating. The PUC is worried some QFs are trying to take advantage of the California crisis to get out of long-term contracts that require them to sell electricity at prices far below the current market rate. Several QFs are suing to get out of those contracts so they can cash in on the open market, said PUC Commissioner Carl Wood. All the QFs want is to be paid for bills that date back as far as November, said Jack Raudy, a spokesman for the Renewable Energy Creditors Committee, which consists of 10 alternative power producers owed a combined $410 million. Those 10 generators produce about 3,000 megawatts ) which Raudy said was enough electricity for 3 million homes. "We are outraged (by the PUC's investigation)," Raudy said. "We have heard so much rhetoric over the past five months and still haven't been paid a dime. That is what we are worried about." Raudy estimated his group is operating at about 95 percent of capacity. After the temporary closure of several QFs contributed to rolling blackouts around the state last month, the PUC ordered PG&E and SoCal Edison to begin paying the generators for the energy purchased since March 27. But the order has done nothing to help the QFs recover the past debts. The QFs are now in line in bankruptcy court with 30,000 creditors owed money by PG&E, which expects its unpaid bills to rise to $5.5 billion by the end of this month. If the QFs get desperate enough, they may decide to push SoCal Edison into an involuntary bankruptcy case, Raudy said. PUC Commissioner Geoffrey Brown defended the alternative energy providers during Thursday's hearing. "Any QFs that are not operating right now are doing so for financial reasons, not to game the system," he said. California will need all the power that it can get from the QFs this summer when rolling blackouts threaten to become a daily occurrence. Combined, the QFs account for about one-fourth of California's total power capacity, according to the PUC. The QF output will become even more essential this summer because California won't be able to import as much electricity from the Pacific Northwest as it has in the past. A lack of rain has left the Pacific Northwest's hydroelectric supply at its second-lowest level ever, and it could diminish to a record low if the recent drought continues. "We are not going to be able to look to the Pacific Northwest to meet our needs," Wood said after reviewing a new report on the hydroelectricity supply. The looming blackouts and electricity price increases caused by California's energy crisis is exasperating businesses and households across the state. Fearing the frustration could boil over into terrorism, the PUC Thursday installed metal detectors to screen everyone attending the agency's public meetings. In other moves Thursday, the PUC tabled a scheduled vote on whether the regulators should become more involved in PG&E's bankruptcy case. The San Francisco-based utility is challenging the PUC's authority in the case. The PUC now expects to take up the matter at a May 3 meeting. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Attorney general taking two energy companies to court ASSOCIATED PRESS April 19, 2001 SACRAMENTO ) Attorney General Bill Lockyer wants a judge to order two power generators to hand over documents he subpoenaed last month as part of his investigation into the state's electricity market. Reliant Energy and Mirant Corp. failed to produce certain documents by March 19, despite assurances that the sensitive documents would be kept confidential, Lockyer said Thursday. Lockyer filed the request for a hearing in San Francisco Superior Court. Lockyer says the companies are concerned the documents wouldn't be kept confidential, even though he says they've been assured the sensitive documents would not be released. The attorney general is investigating allegations of price manipulation in the state's electricity market that may have led to soaring power costs. Mirant spokesman Bill O'Neel said the company is cooperating with the attorney general's office. "At this moment, we have our legal team working to pull together the documentation the attorney general has requested," O'Neel said. Mirant Thursday joined a complaint filed by Reliant last week in Los Angeles Superior Court. That petition seeks assurance that the attorney general will keep proprietary information confidential to prevent any competitive damage, said Reliant spokesman Richard Wheatley. "We're committed to cooperating with the investigation that Attorney General Lockyer is conducting," Wheatley said. "It's the understanding of our management that we do not have the proper assurance that the information will be kept confidential." ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ---------------------------------------------------------------- Legislators Unite Over Energy Price Issue Power: Bipartisan congressional delegation called together by Davis says U.S. must step in to protect state from manipulation by suppliers. By MITCHELL LANDSBERG and MIGUEL BUSTILLO, Times Staff Writers ?????This may be the surest sign yet of the depth of California's energy crisis: A bipartisan cross-section of the state's congressional delegation, brought together Thursday by Gov. Gray Davis, not only agreed about the severity of the problem but also about the need for swift federal intervention. ?????"This meeting did not have the word 'Democrat' or 'Republican' used once," Rep. Darrell E. Issa (R-Vista), said of the unusual spirit of cooperation at the meeting near Los Angeles International airport. ?????Members of both parties said the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission must slash wholesale electricity prices so California utilities can once again afford to buy power. Since January, the state government has been buying electricity on their behalf, as skyrocketing wholesale prices put Pacific Gas & Electric Co. and Southern California Edison billions of dollars into debt and many power suppliers refused to sell to them; PG&E has since filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection. ?????Although the Bush administration has said repeatedly that it is strongly opposed to price caps, and FERC has refused to grant them, California Republicans at the energy meeting said they are optimistic that the administration will agree to some other form of price regulation. They brushed aside the notion that such regulations might conflict with their ideological belief in a free market. ?????"This is not a free-enterprise situation," Rep. Duncan Hunter (R-Alpine) said after the meeting. "In fact, it's just the opposite." ?????Specifically citing the huge disparity between natural gas prices charged to California and those charged in other Western states, he said California clearly has been the victim of unreasonably high energy costs. Under federal law, the FERC must regulate the prices of companies if it finds they are exerting "market power" to drive prices to unreasonable levels. ?????Executives from two Texas energy companies, meeting with legislators in Sacramento, denied Thursday that they had caused natural gas prices in California to artificially skyrocket by hoarding access to a critical pipeline into the state. ?????After the extraordinary meeting in Los Los Angeles, Rep. Brad Sherman (D-Sherman Oaks) said the biggest disagreement between California Democrats and Republicans appeared to be their relative faith--or lack thereof--in the ability of President Bush and his administration to help California. There has been much speculation that Bush, who lost California in November, has no political motive to help the state. ?????"We Democrats," said Sherman, "hope very much that our skepticism is proven wrong." ?????Davis--who sat flanked by Democratic U.S. Sen. Dianne Feinstein and the governor's newly appointed chief energy advisor, S. David Freeman--said he used the meeting mainly to discuss the importance of conservation by Californians this summer and to ask the congressional delegation to pitch in. Five Republicans and more than a dozen Democrats attended the gathering. ?????Feinstein said Thursday that she has asked for a third time to meet with Bush to discuss the energy situation. Meeting with Times reporters and editors Wednesday, she described a recent meeting with Vice President Dick Cheney in which, she said, he "ignored" her appeal for federal assistance. ?????Feinstein has been among those critical of natural gas companies, saying they appear to have constricted access to a California-bound pipeline to run up prices. ?????The Brattle Group, a respected consulting firm, alleged Wednesday before an Assembly committee that Dynegy Inc. and El Paso Natural Gas Co. had manipulated the market by charging so much for the rights to their pipeline capacity that they had, in effect, withheld access to it. ?????That action, the experts said, directly forced companies trying to deliver gas to California to look for alternatives, clogging other pipelines and causing a surge in prices. ?????The explanation, El Paso executives said, was simple: Demand for gas soared in California because generators that use gas to make electricity increased production last year in response to the energy crisis. ?????"We're not withholding capacity--no one is," said El Paso Merchant Energy President Ralph Eads. "With these prices, you want to sell every molecule." ?????In other developments Thursday: ?????* The agreement between Davis and Edison International to return its ailing utility arm to financial health is in "deep trouble and could be rejected by legislators," the Standard & Poor's credit rating agency said in a note to clients, citing legislative and other sources. A rejection of the deal "would be a humiliating setback for the governor," S&P said. ?????The agreement calls for, among other things, the sale of Edison's transmission grid to the state for $2.76 billion and the sale of $2 billion in bonds--both designed to pay off the utility's huge electricity debt. Edison agreed to several constraints, including the sale of electricity to the state at prices tied to the cost of producing power. ?????Since they returned Monday from a two-week recess, state legislators have been sharply critical of the Edison agreement and have indicated a desire to tinker with aspects of the deal. Some lawmakers have said publicly that a bankruptcy protection filing by Edison, like that of PG&E, might not be such a dire outcome. ?????But a senior Edison executive said it is "way too early" to give up on passage of the proposal, which legislators have not yet seen in official form. ?????"There is an education process to do here," the executive said of the highly detailed 38-page document. "The legislators should be asking questions. That is appropriate." ?????* The Public Utilities Commission voted to investigate whether alternative energy providers violated contractual agreements by withholding supplies from PG&E and Edison, which owe them hundreds of millions of dollars. ?????The action, Commissioner Carl W. Wood said, was prompted in part by lawsuits some providers have filed seeking release from their contracts with the cash-starved utilities. The producers of solar, wind and geothermal energy account for more than 25% of California's electricity supply. ?????"The question is whether we will be able to rely on them in the long, hot days of summer," Wood said. ?????Jack Raudy of the Renewable Energy Creditors Committee said the PUC needs to address the $700 million the producers are owed. "All we have gotten is rhetoric from the governor, the PUC and the utilities," he said. ?????* An $850-million plan to entice Californians to conserve precious megawatts appears to be running into roadblocks, compounding predictions by state officials of tighter than expected energy supplies in May and June. ?????Davis signed the conservation spending package last week, earmarking $242 million of the new funds for the Public Utilities Commission to distribute to the state's investor-owned utilities to support existing conservation programs. ?????But Barbara Hale, director of the PUC's Division of Strategic Planning, said Thursday that since Pacific Gas & Electric Co. filed for bankruptcy protection April 6, the utility has stopped releasing conservation funds. ?????Hale, testifying before a state Senate committee, said PG&E's decision--coupled with the threat that Southern California Edison could follow a similar route to U.S. Bankruptcy Court--has complicated her agency's efforts. ?????PG&E spokeswoman Staci Homrig said her company plans to petition the Bankruptcy Court to have the conservation funds designated as a trust and separated from assets tied up in the bankruptcy proceedings. She said if the court denies the request, PG&E would ask to be permitted to pay the expenses anyway. The process, she added, could take about a month--too long in the view of some legislators, given increasingly gloomy energy forecasts for late spring and early summer. ?????Deputy Director Bob Therkelsen of the California Energy Commission said his agency had been counting on a number of small power producers to bolster their output during that period. But he said some producers did not purchase the necessary equipment because PG&E and Edison have failed to pay them in full for earlier electricity deliveries. ?????"It's not a huge amount," he said of the anticipated production shortfall, "but every little bit helps." --- ?????Landsberg reported from Los Angeles, Bustillo from Sacramento. Times staff writers Nancy Rivera Brooks in Los Angeles, Carl Ingram and Julie Tamaki in Sacramento and Tim Reiterman in San Francisco contributed to this story. Copyright 2001 Los Angeles Times ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------- Small fry among big fish in PG&E bankruptcy Some unlikely businesses are listed as creditors against utility Steve Rubenstein, Chuck Squatriglia, Chronicle Staff Writers Friday, April 20, 2001 ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle URL: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/chronicle/archive/2001/04/20/M N185589.DTL A San Francisco ice cream parlor, a karate studio and a costume shop are all in the same boat, and that goes for a Divisadero Street psychiatrist, too. They're all in the fortunate position of having money coming to them. And they're all in the tough spot of having that money owed by the sort-of bankrupt Pacific Gas and Electric Co. Many of the 47,894 creditors that PG&E owes money to, according to a list filed with the bankruptcy judge, are banks, power companies, lawyers and the like. But a surprising number are businesses that, at first blush, might seem unlikely to be power company creditors. Many businesses -- like the ACT costume rental shop -- didn't know or had forgotten that PG&E had run up a tab. And since the list didn't say how much they're owed, businesses had to guess. "How about that?" said costume shop manager Callie Floor, when told she had PG&E money coming to her. Floor, checking her books, said it looks like PG&E forgot to pay its $100 bill to cover a costume rental for a corporate dress-up party in 1992. "We rent a lot of costumes for corporate events," she said. "That's probably what it was." Psychiatrist Richard Lieberman says he does not know why or how much PG&E owes him. "But I'll take it," he said. "PG&E has taken advantage of the consumer for so long. As far as I'm concerned, PG&E can go under and stay under." Of course, PG&E may wind up paying pennies on the dollar, if anything, because that's how bankruptcies work. The notion is depressing, which psychiatrists are used to. KARATE STUDIO GETS HIT Karate master Scott Morton, whose Karate One studio on Van Ness Avenue is also a creditor, said karate is all about fairness and integrity, which PG&E seems to be even shorter on than cash. "I think the bankruptcy stinks," Morton said. "All the money is going around and around, it's all the same company." The karate studio conducted a self-defense class for about a dozen workers at PG&E headquarters. Morton, a black belt who does not take treachery lightly, said he was "pretty sure" the check cleared, but maybe not. NO BIG DEAL FOR SOME At Beauchamp's Welding and Repair in Petaluma, owner Dean Beauchamp wasn't concerned. "They don't owe us enough to worry about," he said. "Less than $100, I'd guess." Beauchamp's shop does small jobs for the big utility. "They've been really good about sending us a check. Once in a great while, something will get misplaced, and I guess that's how our name got on the list." Yolanda Fletcher, the owner of Red Shoes Slide Service, says the utility probably owes her about $100 for preparing some photographs for a corporate slide show. Larry Mitchell, proprietor of the award-winning Mitchell's Ice Cream shop on San Jose Avenue, believes that PG&E may owe him $500 for a corporate ice cream social. "That would cover the ice cream, the toppings, the dishes and the spoons," he said. The utility's rocky road may be metaphorical, but an ice cream store's rocky road is the real thing, he said, and being owed $500 by a bankrupt company is not peaches and cream. UNEXPECTED NAMES The list of creditors also includes such strange bedfellows as the San Francisco Fire Department, the Yosemite Fund, The Chronicle and PG&E's own library petty cash fund. Perhaps the strangest bedfellow of all is the perpetual PG&E foe known as TURN, or The Utility Reform Network, which stands to lose thousands of dollars in state-mandated legal fees from PG&E for its work as an "intervener," or utility watchdog. Among the utility's more sensible business partners is the Beale Street sandwich shop a few steps from the main entrance to PG&E's headquarters building in San Francisco. Unlike the big banks and power companies that are on the hook for millions, proprietor Kenneth Chen does business with PG&E on a strictly pay-as-you-go business. Chen, the owner of Cafe Leah at 25 Beale St., is often hired to send up a $40 tray of sandwiches to PG&E corporate officers. When he does so, he insists on cash up front because PG&E, who is the restaurant's landlord, insists on cash every month from Chen. "That's the way we've always done it, payment right away," he said. "That way there's no hassle later on." E-mail Steve Rubenstein at srubenstein@sfchronicle.com and Chuck Squatriglia at csquatriglia@sfchronicle.com. ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle ? Page?A - 1 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ --------------------------------------------------------------- Developments in California's energy crisis The Associated Press Friday, April 20, 2001 ,2001 Associated Press URL: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/news/archive/2001/04/20/state1 004EDT0161.DTL&type=news , , -- (04-20) 07:04 PDT Developments in California's energy crisis: FRIDAY:< ?-- The state remains free of power alerts as reserves stay above 7 percent. ?-- Southern California Edison plans a 1:30 p.m. conference call with its ?creditors. ?-- Edison executives discuss the state's move to buy thier transmission lines ?at a 9:30 a.m. briefing in Sacramento. ?< ?THURSDAY:< -- The Public Utility Commission launches an investigation into whether a key block of independent generators are purposely keeping their plants off line. -- The commission tables until May 3 a vote on whether the PUC should become more involved in Pacific Gas & Electric's bankruptcy case. The San Francisco-based utility is challenging the PUC's authority in the case. -- Texas-based natural gas companies defend themselves before an Assembly subcommittee against accusations they created a virtual monopoly on gas flowing into California and used it to jack up prices sharply. -- Attorney General Bill Lockyer says he will go to court to force two electricity generators to hand over documents he subpoenaed as part of his probe of the state's electricity market. -- Gov. Gray Davis and a bipartisan group of the state's congressional delegates agree that the federal government must act to control the wholesale price of energy, but offer no specific proposals. -- The Assembly passes a resolution asking the federal government to regulate the price of natural gas, which has been deregulated since 1992. The Assembly also approves a bill to encourage natural gas exploration in the tidelands off Long Beach. Both measures go to the Senate. -- The Senate approves a resolution asking Congress and the president to let California use daylight-saving time year-round to help lower energy use. The measure now moves to the Assembly. A bill pending in Congress would give Western states the authority to expand daylight-saving time. -- The Electric Power Supply Association tells the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission that the California Independent System Operator, which runs the state's power grid, is not independent enough. The association alleges in a FERC filing that the ISO favors the state over electricity generators in its actions and rule-making. -- The California Energy Commission allows Pacific Gas & Electric Corp. to build a $350 million power plant in San Diego County capable of supplying electricity to 500,000 homes. -- The Escondido City Council votes to suspend for 30 to 60 days its consideration of proposals by developers trying to build plants before peak summer demand. The council wants to develop a comprehensive approval process that looks at the cumulative effect of such plants. -- Edison International's stock closes at $10.98, down 42 cents, while stock in PG&E's parent closes down 31 cents at $8.73. -- The state remains free of power alerts as reserves stay above 7 percent. < WHAT'S NEXT:< ?-- Davis' representatives continue negotiating with Sempra, the parent ?company of San Diego Gas and Electric Co., to buy the utility's transmission ?lines. Davis says he expects to have an agreement within two weeks. ?-- An Assembly subcommittee meets Monday to discuss bills aimed at improving ?California's natural gas market. ?-- Senate Select Committee to Investigate Price Manipulation of the Wholesale ?Energy Market continues its investigation next week. ?< ?THE PROBLEM:< High demand, high wholesale energy costs, transmission glitches and a tight supply worsened by scarce hydroelectric power in the Northwest and maintenance at aging California power plants are all factors in California's electricity crisis. Edison and PG&E say they've lost nearly $14 billion since June to high wholesale prices that the state's electricity deregulation law bars them from passing on to consumers. PG&E, saying it hasn't received the help it needs from regulators or state lawmakers, filed for federal bankruptcy protection April 6. Electricity and natural gas suppliers, scared off by the two companies' poor credit ratings, are refusing to sell to them, leading the state in January to start buying power for the utilities' nearly 9 million residential and business customers. The state is also buying power for a third investor-owned utility, San Diego Gas & Electric, which is in better financial shape than much larger Edison and PG&E but also struggling with high wholesale power costs. The Public Utilities Commission has raised rates up to 46 percent to help finance the state's multibillion-dollar power-buying. ,2001 Associated Press ? ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ --------------------------------------------------------------- California utility wants to boost Mohave power plant production Friday, April 20, 2001 ,2001 Associated Press URL: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/news/archive/2001/04/20/state0 926EDT0156.DTL&type=news (04-20) 06:26 PDT BULLHEAD CITY, Ariz. (AP) -- With many opposed to allowing Southern California Edison to increase power production at the Mohave Generating Station, the City Council wants Nevada regulators to meet here. The plant Edison operates is located across the Colorado River in Laughlin, Nev. Edison is seeking a variance that would allow it to exceed the current cap of 70 percent of the plant's capacity and to do so for more than 20 hours. ``We just want to do this in dire circumstances to avoid the rolling blackouts (California has experienced recently),'' Edison spokesman Steve Hansen said. Any is too much for former City Councilman Victor Urso. ``That plant is one of the worst air pollution violators in the United States already, and now they want variances to do even more damage,'' Urso said. Mohave County Supervisor Tom Sockwell, who presents the Bullhead City area, doesn't see it that way. ``They'll only run it up to full power for very short periods, and we need that for the power shortages,'' Sockwell said this week. ``We've already got pollution anyway, so what's another hour of a darker plume every now and then?'' Rick Moore of the Flagstaff-based Grand Canyon Trust, which monitors the plant's operation, said the plant exceeded its permissible emissions level 1,200 times during the last calendar year. The trust sued, and the company was fined $180,000. The City Council wants the Nevada Environmental Commission to meet in Laughlin next month rather than in Carson City so members can hear local opponents of Edison's request. Hansen said the commission approved a variance last year but that the plant exceeded the emissions limit for only six minutes. At peak capacity, the plant can produce 1,580 megawatts of electricity but is required to stay below that level because of air quality concerns Edison owns 56 percent of the plant. The rest is owned by the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power (20 percent), Nevada Power (14 percent) and the Salt River Project in Phoenix (10 percent). Nevada Power has been trying to sell its share in the generating station to AES Corp. of Arlington, Va., has been trying to purchase both Edison's and Nevada Power's shares but has run into snags. The Nevada Public Utilities Commission approve the Nevada Power sale in October but suspended that approval on Marcy 29 for at least 60 days. In January, the California Public Utilities Commission suspended sale of the Edison share and placed a five-year moratorium on such sales about the same time. ,2001 Associated Press ? ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ --------------------------------------------------------------- PG&E owes money to several small businesses, unlikely creditors Friday, April 20, 2001 ,2001 Associated Press URL: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/news/archive/2001/04/20/state0 503EDT0125.DTL&type=news (04-20) 02:03 PDT SAN FRANCISCO (AP) -- Several small fry are among the big fish in a pond full of creditors to which ailing Pacific Gas and Electric owes money. A San Francisco ice cream parlor, a costume store, a psychiatrist's office and a karate studio are among a number of small businesses that should be receiving payments from the near bankrupt utility. After checking her books, ACT Costume Shop manager Callie Floor was surprised to find that the utility owes her $100 for a costume rental for a corporate dress-up party in 1992. Karate One Studio on Van Ness Avenue may be owed for a self-defense class it conducted for about a dozen workers at PG&E headquarters. Of course, PG&E may only have to pay pennies on the dollar to the small fry, since that's how bankruptcies work. ,2001 Associated Press ? ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ --------------------------------------------------------------- Edison pushes lawmakers to accept deal David Lazarus, Chronicle Staff Writer Friday, April 20, 2001 ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle URL: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/chronicle/archive/2001/04/20/M N190213.DTL&type=news Although lawmakers are skeptical of the state's multibillion-dollar deal to acquire the power lines of Southern California Edison, the head of the utility's parent company warned yesterday that failure to approve the accord could lead to a "long and costly" bankruptcy. But John Bryson, chief executive of Edison International, told The Chronicle that he thought legislators would "want to do the right thing" by approving the multibillion-dollar agreement and preventing Edison from following Pacific Gas and Electric Co. into bankruptcy court. Bankruptcy for California's two largest utilities could have severe consequences for consumers. Financial analysts said a worsening of the state's energy mess would increase the possibility of higher electricity rates. Nevertheless, lawmakers are unlikely to accept the Edison deal -- at least not in its present form. "We are going to go through this thing extensively," said state Senate President Pro Tem John Burton, D-San Francisco. "There are a lot of concerns about the valuation." Still, he said, legislative backing for the accord remains possible as long as Edison is open to amending some of the terms. "The Edison people are smart enough to know that the Legislature is going to have its say," Burton said. Indeed, sources familiar with the matter said Edison expected a certain amount of tinkering with the deal and would not resist efforts to reach common ground with lawmakers. "The Assembly members do not view bankruptcy as a favorable alternative," said Assemblyman Herb Wesson, D-Los Angeles. "There will be a big effort to try and work something out." Edison's Bryson seems eager at this point to present himself and his company as reasonable business partners who are willing to negotiate in good faith. This contrasts sharply with the state's relations with PG&E, which turned acrimonious after PG&E blindsided the governor with its bankruptcy filing. Each side blamed the other for the collapse of earlier negotiations. "We made the decision at an early stage that this was a massive problem for the state and that the best course was to find a practical solution that would allow us to get on with operating our power system," Bryson said. Bankruptcy, he said, "is absolutely a last resort. It's a long and costly process." It is also the last thing Wall Street wants to see. On Wednesday, rating agency Fitch Inc. joined Standard & Poor's and Moody's Investor Service in warning that California's credit rating could be lowered because of the state's energy mess. "The state may be forced to issue junk bonds," said Carol Coale, an energy- industry analyst at Prudential Securities in New York. "This could lead to a surcharge on electricity bills to guarantee the bonds." Bryson, not surprisingly, defended Edison's agreement with the governor as a prudent alternative to bankruptcy. "This is a very good deal for the state," he said. "It is not a bailout. Edison gives up a lot to make all this possible." Southern California Edison will sell its power lines to the state for $2.8 billion. It also will provide low-cost power to California for 10 years and drop a federal lawsuit seeking full recovery of nearly $5 billion in past debt. Critics say the state is paying far too much for Edison's transmission system -- more than two times book value -- and that the power lines are of little use unless PG&E's grid also can be acquired. "It's a multibillion-dollar ratepayer bailout of Edison," said Doug Heller, a spokesman for the Foundation for Taxpayer and Consumer Rights in Santa Monica. "Edison gets off scot-free." Under the most likely scenario, lawmakers will seek to reduce the amount paid for Edison's power lines and to increase the role of the California Public Utilities Commission in regulating the utility. They also will try to come up with a workable contingency plan for the state if PG&E remains adamant in its refusal to sell off its part of the power grid. "The deal on the table is still salvageable," said Michael Shames, executive director of the Utility Consumers' Action Network in San Diego. "But Edison needs to understand that what it got from the governor is only a framework, not set in stone." For his part, Bryson signaled that plenty of room existed for give and take on the issue. "We're just at the initial stage," he said. "We always have accepted the notion that Edison is a California regulated utility and is subject to the laws of the Public Utilities Commission." E-mail David Lazarus at dlazarus@sfchronicle.com. ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle ? Page?A - 4 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ --------------------------------------------------------------- Who will pay the most for power? Posted at 9:46 p.m. PDT Thursday, April 19, 2001 JOHN WOOLFOLK AND MICHAEL BAZELEY Mercury News State regulators last month announced an electric rate increase that would average a whopping three cents per kilowatt-hour, hit bills beginning in May and punish power pigs while sparing energy misers. Now, much of that is up in the air. Higher rates are surely coming -- but not before June. And exactly which consumers and businesses will pay how much is uncertain as regulators rush to forge a rate structure from a tangle of more than 20 proposals. Their task has been complicated immeasurably by Gov. Gray Davis' decision to weigh in with a competing rate plan and Pacific Gas & Electric Co.'s move into bankruptcy court. ``Little details are moving billions of dollars around,'' said Nettie Hoge of the Utility Reform Network, a consumer advocacy group. All the proposals assume a ``tiered'' structure that forces the heaviest users of energy to pay the most. But key details yet to be decided mean consumers could see their average rates go up anywhere from 7 percent to 30 percent or more. Among them: ?How much of an overall increase? The Public Utilities Commission approved a three-cent per kilowatt-hour increase last month, which would boost utility revenue by $4.8 million. Davis' proposed increase -- left vague in his April 5 television address -- averages 2.8 cents for PG&E customers but only 2.3 cents for customers of Southern California Edison. ?What regions of the state will pay? The commission agreed to raise rates only for PG&E and Southern California Edison, but Davis would include the additional 1.2 million San Diego Gas & Electric customers. ?Should heavier users of electricity subsidize those who are exempt from the new rate increase? If so, those users will find themselves paying much more than any of the average increase figures being tossed about. ?How will utilities bill customers retroactively for the increase? At the time of the PUC vote on March 27, commissioners said their increase would take effect immediately. PUC vote May 14 Various plans are being presented this week to an administrative law judge working for the commission. The judge is expected to recommend a rate structure to the PUC on May 4. Public hearings would follow May 7-11, and the commission would vote on a plan May 14, condensing to a few weeks a process that normally lasts nearly a year. Each of the major proposals before the commission assumes that residential customers using less than 130 percent of their baseline -- which is the average basic level of use for each region of the state -- would be exempt from higher rates. That's mandated under a new law that allows the state to buy power. Customers already pay higher rates for exceeding their baseline. Each major proposal also sets new ``tiers'' with progressively higher rates for ``medium'' use at 130 to 200 percent of baseline and ``heavy'' use over 200 percent of that level. But that's where the similarities end. Differences The first distinction among the leading plans comes in the form of an assumption: How many residential customers will avoid any increase because they don't exceed 130 percent of their baseline? Davis says more than half, commissioners say a little under half and PG&E says less than a third. The second difference among the plans is a real difference: What happens to everyone else? Under the plan by utilities commission President Loretta Lynch, medium PG&E users would see average bills rise 9 percent and heavy users would see bills increase 36 percent. Davis' plan says medium PG&E users would see average bills rise 11 percent while heavy users would pay 37 percent more. But the average total bill increase for PG&E residential customers, including those who are exempt, would be 20 percent under his plan and 24 percent under Lynch's, according to a statement on the governor's Web site. Business customers would see proportionately greater increases, averaging 30 percent under Lynch's proposal and 26 percent under Davis'. The most consumer-friendly of the various proposals comes from consumer-rights group TURN. They suggest an overall average residential increase of 7.5 percent. TURN's plan assumes utilities cannot charge other customers more to make up for the energy misers shielded from rate increases under state law. PG&E disagrees with that interpretation. The utility wants other residential users to make up for any lost revenue from exempted customers through higher rates. Under the utility's plan, residential customers would see an average rate increase of nearly 30 percent. ``The proposal these folks are pushing rips the heart out of that law,'' said Matthew Freedman, staff attorney for TURN. Another issue affecting consumers is how the utilities can bill for electricity used in April and May, before the final plan is approved. Utilities want surcharge Utility officials have objected to making the rate structure retroactive. Instead, to recoup the revenue, they are proposing a flat surcharge that everyone would pay, regardless of how much they use. Edison proposes a higher surcharge added to bills for a shorter period of time -- in this case, June through August. PG&E officials are suggesting a smaller surcharge that would be spread out over 12 months. ``It'll probably be something closer to the PG&E proposal,'' said Paul Clanon, the commission's director of energy issues. All the rate increase proposals stem from a commonly understood problem: California's current, frozen rates don't generate enough money to cover the wholesale price of power. The PUC raised rates 10 percent -- or one cent per kilowatt-hour -- in January in an attempt to help, but that turned out to be far from enough. In March, the commission approved an additional three-cent increase. But Davis followed quickly with an alternative proposal. The next day, PG&E filed for bankruptcy, raising the specter that a federal judge could order even higher rates. Although the PUC has sole authority to raise rates under state law, Davis' proposal has complicated an already complex process. The governor appointed three of the five members of the commission, and his appointees seem inclined to show him deference. But Davis has been slow in filing the details of his plan, which has made it hard for the PUC to proceed. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ --- Credit-raters put state on watch Posted at 9:41 p.m. PDT Thursday, April 19, 2001 BY JENNIFER BJORHUS Mercury News All three of the nation's influential judges of credit risk now have California on a credit watch, saying they are deeply concerned about the economic impact of the state's power crisis. The Fitch credit rating agency made it unanimous Wednesday when it warned that the thickening electricity quagmire, as well as lower than expected tax revenues in February and March, could mean broader risk for the state's budget. The announcement is a signal that Fitch, too, may downgrade its ratings on California's nearly $30 billion in public debt, a move which could cost taxpayers millions. The announcement comes as state lawmakers consider a bailout plan for Southern California Edison, Pacific Gas & Electric Co. sits in bankruptcy and state officials bleed through the state's general fund as they buy expensive electricity for consumers. Earlier this week, Gov. Gray Davis announced that the average bill for electricity purchases has risen from $45.8 million a day in the last week of March to $73 million a day. Moody's Investors Service and Standard & Poor's have already issued their own credit warnings, although none of the three agencies has downgraded the state's very good double-A credit rating. Bond ratings are important yardsticks that bankers and investors use to price municipal and corporate bonds. A downgrade would force California to offer bond buyers higher interest rates going forward, costing taxpayers. The state was last at a lower A rating back in 1994. Moody's changed California's Aa2 general obligation bond rating outlook from stable to negative on April 6, the day PG&E filed for bankruptcy. Standard & Poor's has had the state's AA rating outlook at negative since January, when the state began buying electricity for the utilities. The deciding factor for Fitch, said Fitch vice chairman Claire Cohen, was the disagreement over how the money from the new electricity rate increase will be spent. The California Public Utilities Commission ruled in late March that money generated by higher electricity bills should go first to pay the state Department of Water Resources, which has been buying electricity for the utilities. PG&E has argued that if the state is paid first, there won't be any money left for the company. The utility is formally challenging the PUC decision, and the move threatens to hold up the estimated $12 billion to $14 billion of bonds the Department of Water Resources plans to issue to buy more electricity. ``With that being appealed, you don't have a clean authorization,'' Cohen said. ``It signals to me that it could delay the financing process.'' A second concern is that the state isn't collecting as much in taxes as expected, Cohen said. Tax collections for both February and March were below forecast. The amount of personal income tax the state collected in those months fell short by $455 million, or 14 percent less than expected. Cohen said she made her decision before hearing that the state's power costs now exceed $70 million a day. Cohen and David Hitchcock, the California analyst for Standard & Poor's, agreed those rising costs are a definite concern. ``It doesn't take much of a change in economic growth to make some of these projected fund balances disappear and so we're very worried about what the current economic activity is, particularly in Northern California with some of the problems with the high-tech area,'' Hitchcock told analysts and investors last week in a conference call. Other economy-watchers expressed concern. Sandy Harrison, assistant director of the state Department of Finance, said the move reinforced the importance of solving the power problems soon. Contact Jennifer Bjorhus at jbjorhus@sjmercury.com or (408) 920-5660. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ -------------------- Power company executives going without bonuses LOS ANGELES (AP) -- Senior executives at Southern California Edison and its parent company went without hundreds of thousands of dollars in bonuses in 2000 because of California's power crisis. Edison International's chairman and chief executive, John Bryson, was paid $950,000 in 2000, compared with salary and bonus totaling $2.16 million in 1999. Stephen Frank, the chairman and chief executive at Southern California Edison, was paid $617,000 in 2000, compared with salary and bonus totaling $1.3 million in 1999, according to the company's proxy statement filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission. The company also said Thursday it would not award merit increases to executives in 2001 because of the continuing crisis. In a similar statement released Tuesday, Pacific Gas and Electric Corp. revealed it also withheld bonuses for its top two executives, although they did receive raises. Edison and PG&E say they have lost nearly $14 billion since June to high wholesale prices that the state's electricity deregulation law bars them from passing on to consumers. PG&E, saying it hasn't received the help it needs from regulators or state lawmakers, filed for federal bankruptcy protection April 6. Edison is continuing to work with state officials and its creditors. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ----------------------- Davis and U.S. lawmakers call for price caps on power LOS ANGELES -- Half of California's congressional delegation gathered with Gov. Gray Davis on Thursday to pressure the federal government to impose energy price caps. Limiting wholesale prices, they argued, is essential if the state is to avert the energy crisis threatening California's economy. ``A big piece of this solution is federal. It's a four-letter word: F-E-R-C,'' said U.S. Rep. Jane Harman, D-Redondo Beach, referring to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, the agency that would have to approve price caps. The governor has blamed FERC for allowing energy producers to charge California stratospheric prices for electricity and natural gas. The delegation met behind closed doors at an Los Angeles airport hotel, but Davis and several legislators met with reporters afterward. ``The signal that has to come from FERC,'' Davis said, ``is, `You're charging too much for electricity. The electricity is not worth driving California into an economic grave.'?'' Curt H,bert Jr., the FERC chairman, has argued that caps would encourage generators to sell their power elsewhere and discourage them from building new plants in California. The bipartisan group of lawmakers agreed with the governor that the state is getting gouged on the open market. ``There is an anti-free market enterprise mechanism in play here,'' said U.S. Rep. Duncan Hunter, R-El Cajon, noting that natural gas in parts of New Mexico costs one-third what it does in California. The generators maintain that they are charging fair prices that are the simple result of supply and demand. Rep. Mike Honda, D-San Jose, and Rep. Zoe Lofgren, D-San Jose, attended, but left before speaking with reporters. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------- Generators cutting electric output; regulators want to find out why Published Friday, April 20, 2001, in the San Jose Mercury News BY MICHAEL BAZELEY Mercury News State regulators launched an investigation Thursday into why some alternative energy providers are withholding electricity from the state's stressed power grid. The California Public Utilities Commission in San Francisco said it wants to determine whether the small power generators -- which provide about one-fourth of the state's electrical power -- have legitimate business reasons for scaling back their output. Known as ``qualifying facilities,'' or QFs, many of the generators have been either scaling back output or shutting down entirely -- contending that the state's two largest utilities owe them $700 million. ``The critical question is: Will we be able to rely on these facilities into the high-demand summer months?'' PUC Commissioner Carl Wood said. The financially strapped utilities, Pacific Gas & Electric Co. and Southern California Edison, stopped paying the power generators several months ago. The PUC ordered the utilities to resume payments, and some generators started receiving payments this week. But many generators are still hurting because of all the back payments they are owed, said Jack Raudy, a spokesman for the Renewable Energy Creditors Committee, which consists of 10 alternative power producers. ``We're outraged,'' Raudy said. Contact Michael Bazeley at mbazeley@sjmercury.com or (408) 920-5628. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ --------------------- FERC remains an unlikely rescuer The federal agency hews to a hands-off policy on power rates. April 20, 2001 By DENA BUNIS The Orange County Register Washington - Californians who see federal re-regulation of the state's crisis-bound energy market as an answer to the impending summer emergency better look for some other solution. Even the possible short- term price fix that the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission may consider at its Wednesday meeting might be too little, too late. Lobbyists, lawmakers and other FERC-watchers say they have seen a slight shift in recent weeks among commission staff and at least one member. There is some willingness, they say, to consider some price controls, even though the Bush administration is adamantly opposed to such measures. And many are looking to see if President George W. Bush's choices for the two vacancies on FERC will provide a margin for change. But the commission's basic philosophy that open, unregulated markets are best is not likely to change soon, members say. "I've been championing a revamping of FERC's antiquated standards for determining market-based rates,'' Commissioner Richard Massey said Thursday. But with no success. " My agency is not on the verge of turning on a dime on this market-based pricing." The standards are a joke, Massey added, because the commission never turns down requests for such pricing authority. More than 600 power sellers have been given that authority, he said. For a power company to be allowed to charge whatever the market will bear, it must show FERC, for example, that it doesn't have the power to manipulate the market and drive prices up. "Any seller that can't pass our screen needs to fire their consultants and lawyers,'' Massey said. While the overall philosophy remains consistent, FERC staff has proposed to the commission that a Stage 3 electricity emergency in California should trigger cost-based rates, a form of price controls. Such triggers would be in place for one year, under the staff proposal. The commission may decide Wednesday whether to accept that proposal. It has to make some decision by May 1 on how the market will be monitored from now on. The theory behind controlling prices in Stage 3, says a FERC staff report, is that during such an emergency generators have the greatest opportunity to manipulate the market and drive prices up. But generators have that power during Stage 2 and Stage 1 emergencies, says Les Starck, Southern California Edison Co.'s manager of federal regulatory affairs. Price caps during Stage 3 might avert the rolling blackouts associated with that level of crisis, but they wouldn't do anything to stop generators from jacking up prices the rest of the time, he said. And it is not clear how long it would take for such price controls to take effect, should the commission go along with the staff recommendation. "We're close because summer is approaching,'' Commissioner Linda Breathitt said Thursday. Breathitt, who had firmly opposed any form of price controls, said in an interview last month that given the worsening crisis in California she was open to considering some short-term measures. "It's important to me that we address the summer,'' Breathitt said, but she said she could not predict what the commission would do Wednesday. Even if an order is approved, Massey said, there could be delays while the power sellers file their costs with regulators and disputes over those filings are handled. Sen. Dianne Feinstein said Thursday such a move by the commission would be "better than having no controls at all. There's no question that we're going to be in a Stage 3 emergency.'' Feinstein, D-Calif., and other Western lawmakers have been urging FERC to step in sooner and with price controls that extend beyond just the emergency period. Waiting for Stage 3 to intervene "is putting the whole grid at risk,'' said Roger Hamilton, a member of Oregon's Public Utility Commission. "We have a real stability problem when you cut it that close.'' Feinstein says the future could well rest with the new commissioners, particularly Patrick Wood, the head of the Texas PUC who many believe will replace Curt Heber as FERC chairman if he is confirmed by the Senate. Even if Massey and Breathitt agree on broader price controls, as chairman, Heber could block consideration of such a move. It's unclear what stance Wood would take as chairman. "The thing that deeply concerns me about Pat Wood is that he's from Texas,'' Feinstein said. "What's reassuring is that it appears from my personal discussion with him is that he appears to be pragmatic.'' But once again, timing could be a problem. Bush has said he intends to nominate Wood and Nora Brownell, a member of the Pennsylvania PUC, but has not formally sent their nominations to the Senate. "The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission is of vital importance right now, and to let the time go on without filling the spots makes no sense,'' Feinstein said. "Please, please, please, President Bush, process your nominees.'' ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ---------------------------------- Lawmakers seek bigger rollbacks, can't agree on caps They promise to meet in Washington with a plan that would require federal agencies to conserve power this summer. April 20, 2001 By DENA BUNIS The Orange County Register Los Angeles - Gov. Gray Davis and a bipartisan sampling of the congressional delegation put politics aside Thursday and agreed something must be done about runaway wholesale power prices in California. "We agreed that there has been unreasonable or unearned enrichment by the energy providers of natural gas and electricity" said Rep. Darrell Issa, R-Vista. "And we agreed that there needs to be significantly greater rollbacks than there already have been." The lawmakers did not, however, come to a consensus over the issue of price caps - something Davis and other Democrats, particularly Sen. Dianne Feinstein, D-Calif., have been pushing the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission to institute. Davis met behind closed doors for 90 minutes with Feinstein and 27 of the 52 House members at the Sheraton Gateway Hotel near LAX. Participants from the Orange County delegation included Issa; Rep. Christopher Cox, R-Newport Beach; Rep. Loretta Sanchez, D-Santa Ana; and Rep. Gary Miller, R-Diamond Bar. They emerged with a promise to meet again soon, this time in Washington, and with a four-pronged strategy to avert disaster this summer. The strategy includes requiring federal agencies in the state, including military facilities, to conserve energy this summer, and asking FERC to find a way to control the wholesale price of electricity and increase the flow of natural gas into California. Cox said much of the meeting was spent reviewing Davis' $850 million conservation program. Members promised to get the word out in their districts about conservation measures. Cox said he expects emergency legislation dealing with the energy crisis to pass the Energy and Commerce Committee in the coming weeks. That measure, he said, will include a direction to FERC to expand its investigation of whether existing rates are just and reasonable. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ----------------------------- Energy notebook Assembly urges federal regulation of natural gas April 20, 2001 From Register news services Sacramento - The California Assembly asked the federal government Thursday to regulate soaring natural gas prices once again. A resolution passed 48-7 asked President George W. Bush, Congress and the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission to restore the regulation of natural gas that ended in 1992. Natural gas rates at the California border have been as much as 11 times higher than elsewhere in the nation since November, an industry consultant told an Assembly subcommittee Wednesday. "I think it's only rational in one of the biggest crises to befall this country in the last 100 years. We're not seeing adequate action from the federal government," said the author, Assemblyman Dennis Cardoza, D-Atwater. Republicans refused to vote for the resolution, complaining that it was an attack on the GOP Bush administration. Top Edison officials forego bonus, take 45% pay cut Rosemead - Edison International's top officers received no bonuses in 2000 and generally took pay cuts of about 45 percent as the Southern California company's utility segment was forced to write off $4.2 billion spent buying overpriced power in the state's deregulated electricity market, according to SEC disclosures the company filed Thursday. Edison International Chief Executive Officer John E. Bryson received $1.62 million in salary and other compensation, compared with $3.04 million last year. Southern California Edison CEO Stephen E. Frank received $760,000 in salary and other compensation, compared with $1.35 million last year. And Edison Mission Energy CEO Alan J. Fohrer received $584,000 in salary and other compensation, compared with $922,000 last year. Edison's compensation committee did give Bryson an incentive to pull the company out of its quagmire, awarding stock options with a present-day value calculated at $7.26 million. But Bryson won't be able to profit from those options -- which vest over the next five years -- any time soon. The lowest price he can exercise the options at is $20 -- and Edison stock is trading at $11. PUC seeks to shed light on meager energy alternatives Sacramento - Hoping to prevent California's bleak power outlook from becoming even darker, state regulators Thursday launched an investigation into why alternative energy providers aren't producing more electricity. With the action, the California Public Utilities Commission hopes to determine if legitimate business reasons or ulterior motives underlie the reduced output by an independent group of small generators that provides much of the state's energy. These alternative generators - known in the industry as "qualifying facilities," or QFs - have been scaling back or shutting down as debts owed by California's two largest utilities pile up. The QFs are owed an estimated $700 million by bankrupt Pacific Gas and Electric and financially crippled Southern California Edison. In other developments: California's Public Utilities Commission delayed until May 3 a decision on whether it will investigate how Pacific Gas & Electric's bankruptcy is going to affect customers. Unbowed by Gov. Gray Davis' endorsement of Calpine's proposed power plant, San Jose officials said they may yet have the last word on the controversial project. The city could sue the California Energy Commission or attempt to block the project by refusing to extend water and sewer lines or annex several acres of needed land, they said. PG&E Corp. won final approval to build a $350 million power plant in San Diego County capable of supplying electricity to 500,000 homes. The Escondido City Council has decided to take a break from considering a rush of proposals by developers trying to build plants before peak summer demand. The council voted 3-2 Wednesday to suspend consideration for 30 to 60 days of any proposals to build energy plants in the city. Register staff writers, The Associated Press and Knight Ridder Newspapers contributed to this report. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ --------------------------------- Friday, April 20, 2001 Shed light on costs Unfortunately, California citizens will remain in the dark for at least another month about the details of Gov. Gray Davis' long-term contracts with power producers. This is the sort of crisis the public needs to scrutinize and for which the Public Records Act was designed. At a Tuesday hearing in a Los Angeles County Superior Court in Pasadena on whether the documents should be released under the California Public Records Act, Judge Michael J. Byrne said the case could better be heard in a Los Angeles court. The case was brought by Judicial Watch, a Washington-based public interest law firm with its West Coast office in San Marino. "The case was reset for May 22 in a Los Angeles County Superior Court in the city of Los Angeles although we're going to try to move it up a bit," Judicial Watch and General Counsel Larry Klayman told us. Mr. Klayman remains hopeful. "We're confident any judge who sees this will have to release the documents," he said. A similar but separate case, brought by several newspapers, will be heard May 18 in a San Diego Superior Court. "This is a huge financial burden on the taxpayers without an opportunity for the taxpayers to scrutinize the terms," Hal Fuson, chairman of the government affairs committee of the California Newspaper Publishers Association, told the San Diego Union-Tribune. "The general climate surrounding the governor's approach to this has been one of secrecy." The governor's position is that releasing the details now could make it harder for the state to get the best prices for electricity. But given that the governor has mismanaged this crisis so far, it's clear that this is precisely the sort of crisis the public needs to scrutinize and for which the Public Records Act was designed. The governor should end this legal wrangling and release the documents to which citizens are entitled. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ----------------------------- End To Deregulation of Nevada Power CARSON CITY, Nev. (AP) via NewsEdge Corporation - Gov. Kenny Guinn signed a bill Wednesday that would stop the sale of Nevada power plants, halt deregulation and bail out struggling utilities with a new rate system. The Senate and Assembly gave the measure final approval earlier in the day and rushed it to the governor. The bill was crafted to keep Nevada from suffering from a power crisis similar to California's. ``I must tell you this is a great relief,'' said Guinn, a former utility executive, as he signed the bill into law. ``Nothing can control escalating costs, but we're in the best position to protect ourselves.'' Legislators made a last-minute change to add language that ensured consumers would get a break on rates if utilities profit from sales of excess power to other states. Guinn said the bill takes care of the most pressing energy issues, but other deregulation-related bills are sure to follow. That includes a plan that would allow major power users, such as casinos and mines, to buy power on the open market. Legislators also are working on plans encouraging energy conservation and ensuring the poor can pay their utility bills. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ----- PG&E Co. Issues Statements On the Increase in the State's Cost for Power SAN FRANCISCO--(BUSINESS WIRE)--April 18, 2001 via NewsEdge Corporation - FROM: John Nelson, Director of the News Department Pacific Gas and Electric Company There seems to have been some confusion yesterday over the effect Pacific Gas and Electric Company's bankruptcy filing may have had on energy prices. I thought it might be helpful to provide a few useful facts and figures, to help you pin down the truth behind what may be driving the state's energy costs higher. Yesterday, Governor Davis claimed that the state was paying roughly $20 million more for electricity every day as a direct result of the bankruptcy filing by PG&E. While it's understandable, even laudable, that the Governor would want to fully explain the downsides of utility bankruptcy, this claim is simply not accurate. The Governor should know better. Consider the facts: -- On January 19, the credit ratings of California's two largest investor-owned utilities -- PG&E and SCE -- were downgraded to below investment grade by every major rating agency. Generators immediately raised concerns about continuing to sell power to such non-creditworthy entities. -- The state reacted by passing AB7x, which authorized the state Department of Water Resources to make $400 million in power purchases. Less than two weeks later, on February 1, the Governor signed AB1x, which authorized DWR to buy power on an ongoing basis at least through 2002, until the utilities could be restored to creditworthiness. The clear understanding in the legislative debate was that the DWR would purchase the full "net open position", which is the amount of additional generation needed, beyond what the utilities themselves own or have under contract, to meet customer demand. However, a few weeks later, in spite of the clear intent of state law, it was revealed that DWR was not buying the full net open position, and had no intention of doing so. It was only buying power that it considered "reasonably priced" and was leaving the ISO to buy whatever was necessary to keep the lights on -- an amount that most estimates place at 10- to 20-percent of the state's daily electricity need. -- The ISO, in turn, revealed its intention to attempt to pass along the costs of these last-minute, high-cost, spot-market purchases to the state's non-creditworthy utilities (despite existing FERC tariffs which precluded the ISO from doing so). PG&E has estimated that its share of these costs was roughly $10 million a day; SCE has a similar estimate. (We don't know for sure, because we haven't seen the bill. The DWR won't say how much power it's buying, and at what cost, and neither will the ISO.) -- On February 14, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission informed the Independent System Operator that it could not force generators to sell to non-creditworthy entities (namely, both PG&E and SCE). This order appeared to force the DWR to purchase the full net open after all. The ISO responded the next day with its own interpretation of the FERC order, saying the order was limited to "emergency" power only. The ISO also sought and obtained in federal court a temporary restraining order (issued by Judge Damrell), forcing generators to continue selling to it. -- On February 22, five power generators filed a complaint with FERC seeking to clarify that the ISO's interpretation of the February 14 order was contrary to FERC's intent. -- On April 5, the Ninth U.S. Court of Appeals reversed Judge Damrell's lower court order affecting one of the generators, Reliant, saying the generator was no longer required to sell electricity to the ISO without assurances of payment. Presumably this order would apply to other generators, if they sought such assurances. -- On April 6, PG&E noted in the announcement of its Chapter 11 filing that one of the reasons for the decision was the "financial exposure to unreimbursed wholesale energy procurement costs" caused by the state's failure to assume the full procurement responsibility. -- On April 6, unrelated to PG&E's bankruptcy filing, FERC issued an order responding to the generators' Feb. 22 complaint against the ISO. In this new order, FERC reaffirmed its February 14 order that the ISO could only buy power on behalf of creditworthy entities, meaning neither PG&E nor SCE. -- On April 9 in remarks reported in the press, the Governor's office acknowledged the State's "bill for energy purchases will increase by upward of $8 million a day after a ruling last week by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission," once DWR started buying the full net open position, rather than force the ISO to try to bill the utilities. It seems likely that the $8 million was an estimate based on only one of the utilities' costs, not the combination of both. -- On April 11, the ISO discontinued its daily practice of publishing the total amount it spent on energy the day before. -- Despite the history, the state continues to try to avoid buying the full net open position. On April 13, in response to the FERC order -- NOT the PG&E bankruptcy filing -- the ISO sent a "murky" notice to generators promising that "any bid accepted by the ISO will be deemed to have the financial support of another Qualified Party or DWR as specified in this notice." Generators were reportedly underwhelmed by the assurances contained in the letter. -- Yesterday, in response to the Governor's claim that bankruptcy was driving up the state's costs, Gary Ackerman, spokesman for the Western Power Trading Forum, said "I don't believe, nor have I ever heard, of a bankruptcy surcharge being added to the cost of power.... If anything, I think that generators and marketers would take solace in the fact that bankruptcy brings order to an otherwise volatile situation." What does it all mean? Clearly, the increase in the state's costs have come as a result of the DWR finally covering the state's energy needs, as promised in AB1x. This change in DWR's buying habits has come as a direct result of the February 14 and April 6 FERC orders that the ISO only sell to creditworthy entities. These orders were issued independent of PG&E's bankruptcy filing and apply equally to PG&E and SCE. Neither PG&E nor SCE have been creditworthy since mid-January, when their credit ratings were reduced to below investment grade, and the DWR, ISO and Governor's office have been aware of the effect of the FERC order since mid-February. Some generators have suggested that California has been paying a credit penalty since December, when the utilities' deteriorating financial situation gave rise to payment concerns. There appears to be far more evidence that the state's coy approach to AB1x implementation has created far more uncertainty in the marketplace than has PG&E's Chapter 11 filing. CONTACT: PG&E Co. | News Department, 415/973-5930 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------- J.D. Power and Associates Reports/ Nationwide Decline in Customer Satisfaction of Electric Utility Service Among Midsize Businesses Price and Value Performance Hit Hard Across Nation; Satisfaction in California Continues to Plummet AGOURA HILLS, Calif., April 19 /PRNewswire/ -- Midsize business customers, who are responsible for approximately fifteen percent of the nation's electricity consumption, are very critical of electricity prices, according to the J.D. Power and Associates 2001 Electric Utility Midsize Business Customer Satisfaction Study(SM) released today. Consequently, the study's nationwide customer satisfaction index fell -- from 100 points in 2000 to 97 in 2001. (Photo: http://www.newscom.com/cgi-bin/prnh/20010419/LATH066-a http://www.newscom.com/cgi-bin/prnh/20010419/LATH066-b http://www.newscom.com/cgi-bin/prnh/20010419/LATH066-c http://www.newscom.com/cgi-bin/prnh/20010419/LATH066-d http://www.newscom.com/cgi-bin/prnh/20010419/LATH066-e ) "The entire country was affected by higher natural gas prices this winter, and with more states re-evaluating deregulation, midsize business customers are especially sensitive to electricity prices," said Jeffrey Conklin, senior director at J.D. Power and Associates. The 2001 study shows that average overall customer satisfaction with California's "big three" investor-owned utilities -- Pacific Gas and Electric, San Diego Gas and Electric, and Southern California Edison -- fell an astonishing 14 index points among midsize businesses compared to the 2000 study. "In California, electric utility satisfaction among midsize business customers has virtually fallen into the Pacific," said Alan Destribats, executive director of the utility practice at J.D. Power and Associates. The study finds that the chief determinants of satisfaction among electric utility midsize customers are a provider's company image, price and value, and power quality and reliability. As expected, midsize business customers were extremely critical of performance in the areas of company image and price and value. Even outside of California, satisfaction in the price and value component fell more than any other factor -- from an index score of 100 in 2000 to 93 in 2001. Power Quality and Reliability Utility performance in power quality and reliability is improving, with the national index increasing by 3 points. Although the number of interruptions and outages experienced was relatively the same in 2001 as it was in 2000, midsize businesses report much shorter outage durations, falling from an average of seven hours for the longest outages in 2000 to four hours in 2001. Retail Competition "Opening utility markets to competition has proven to be a difficult process and, so far, midsize business customers are giving the industry poor marks," said Destribats. The study shows that midsize business customers located in states with competition not only are less satisfied than are customers in other states, but they are also significantly less satisfied now than last year. The study also shows that more midsize businesses have switched electricity providers. Of midsize businesses eligible to switch power suppliers, 9 percent have done so, up from 5 percent in 2000. J.D. Power and Associates interviewed representatives from more than 7,200 midsize businesses, including manufacturers, retailers, business and consumer services firms, health care providers and other midsize businesses throughout the United States. Midsize business owners are defined as those who normally spend $1,500 to $25,000 per month on electricity. The study shows that midsize businesses are now spending an average of $4,827 per month on electricity. The study shows that utilities in the south region of the United States consistently receive higher ratings across all factors of customer satisfaction. Likewise, these midsize business customers also report the lowest levels of monthly electricity expenditures, on average. Midsize businesses in North Carolina spend the least for electric usage ($3,885 per month on average), while those in New Hampshire, Nevada and Utah spend the most ($5,700 to $5,800 per month on average). The study also shows that midsize businesses in Alabama and Florida report the most service interruptions and outages within the past 12 months, and those in Washington report the fewest. East Region PPL Utilities, serving east Pennsylvania, ranks highest in overall customer satisfaction with midsize businesses in the eastern United States. PPL Utilities ranked highest in the East Region in four of the six factors that comprise customer satisfaction, with its primary strength in price and value. Other solid performers in this region include Public Service Electric and Gas, Allegheny Power and GPU Energy. Midwest Region LG&E Energy, the parent company of Kentucky Utilities and Louisville Gas and Electric, ranks highest in overall customer satisfaction with midsize business electric service in the Midwest. LG&E Energy midsize business customers give high ratings for power quality and reliability, customer service, and billing and payment. Alliant Energy, AEP-Midwest and Xcel Energy-NSP also rank high in midsize business customer satisfaction in the Midwest Region. South Region Southern Company ranks highest in overall customer satisfaction for midsize business electric service in the South Region and received the highest customer satisfaction index score among all utilities included in the study. Southern Company dominates all other electric utility service providers, achieving the highest ratings in the nation in five of the six components (2 in a tie). Other strong performers in the South Region include Duke Power, Florida Power & Light and Progress Energy (Carolina Power & Light and Florida Power). West Region Sierra Pacific Resources ranks highest in overall customer satisfaction with midsize business electric service in the West Region. This utility significantly leads the region by rating highest in all six components (1 in a tie). The Los Angeles Department of Water and Power also ranks high in this region. Headquartered in Agoura Hills, Calif., J.D. Power and Associates is a global marketing information services firm operating in key business sectors including market research, forecasting, consulting, training and customer satisfaction. The firm's quality and satisfaction measurements are based on actual customer responses from millions of consumers annually. J.D. Power and Associates press releases and media information can be accessed through the Internet at www.jdpa.com. Media e-mail contact: michael.greywitt@jdpa.com. This press release is provided for editorial use only. No advertising or other promotional use can be made of the information in this release or of other J.D. Power and Associates survey results without the express prior written consent of J.D. Power and Associates. SOURCE J.D. Power and Associates CONTACT: Michael P. Greywitt, 818-707-9526 or John Tews, 248-267-6800, both of J.D. Power and Associates Photo: NewsCom: http://www.newscom.com/cgi-bin/prnh/20010419/LATH066-a http://www.newscom.com/cgi-bin/prnh/20010419/LATH066-b http://www.newscom.com/cgi-bin/prnh/20010419/LATH066-c http://www.newscom.com/cgi-bin/prnh/20010419/LATH066-d http://www.newscom.com/cgi-bin/prnh/20010419/LATH066-e AP Archive: http://photoarchive.ap.org PRN Photo Desk, 888-776-6555 or 201-369-3467 Web site: http://www.jdpa.com ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ----------------------------- Calpine to Purchase 46 General Electric Gas Turbines Turbines in Place for 70,000-megawatt Program Turbines in Place for 70,000-megawatt Program SAN JOSE, Calif., April 19 /PRNewswire/ -- Calpine Corporation (NYSE: CPN), the nation's fastest growing independent power producer, announced today it will purchase 35 model 7FB and 11 model 7FA gas-fired turbines from GE Power Systems. With this announcement, Calpine has firm orders in place for the delivery of 203 turbines. When operated in a combined-cycle application, this represents 50,000 megawatts of baseload capacity. The agreement marks the company's second large volume turbine acquisition from GE and is an important component of Calpine's five-year strategic plan to have 70,000 megawatts of generation on line by the end of 2005. Calpine will take delivery of 5 turbines in 2002, with the remainder of the contract to be filled by the end of 2005. "This purchase significantly strengthens Calpine's leadership position in project development," said Doug Kieta, senior vice president-construction for Calpine. "Calpine's aggressive turbine procurement program also strengthens Calpine's first-mover advantage as we expand our development program and enter new electricity markets across the country." "GE Power Systems is pleased to provide Calpine today's technology of choice for power generation," said Delbert Williamson, President of GE Power Systems Global Sales. "Our FA technology is the most proven advanced technology available, and we're confident our evolutionary FB technology which has been designed using GE's Corporate-wide Six Sigma initiative will provide Calpine highly competitive power generation." GE's current fleet of F technology gas turbines recently surpassed 3.8 million hours of operation around the globe. GE's 7FB turbine is an evolution of the current 7FA model and is designed for higher efficiency, lower life-cycle cost power generation. By employing this new technology, Calpine will continue to generate electricity competitively while consuming less natural gas and producing fewer emissions than a typical power plant of comparable size. GE Power Systems (http://www.gepower.com) is one of the world's leading suppliers of power generation technology, energy services and management systems with 2000 revenue of $15 billion. The business has the largest installed base of power generation equipment in the global energy industry. GE Power Systems provides equipment, service and management solutions across the power generation, oil and gas, distributed power and energy rental industries. Based in San Jose, Calif., Calpine Corporation is dedicated to providing customers with reliable and competitively priced electricity. Calpine is focused on clean, efficient combined-cycle, natural gas-fired generation and is the nation's largest producer of renewable geothermal energy. To date, the company has approximately 31,200 megawatts of base load capacity and 6,800 megawatts of peaking capacity in operation, under construction and announced development in 28 states and Alberta, Canada. The company was founded in 1984 and is publicly traded on the New York Stock Exchange under the symbol CPN. For more information about Calpine, visit its Website at www.calpine.com. This news release discusses certain matters that may be considered "forward-looking" statements within the meaning of Section 27A of the Securities Act of 1933, as amended, and Section 21E of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended, including statements regarding the intent, belief or current expectations of Calpine Corporation (the "Company") and its management. Prospective investors are cautioned that any such forward-looking statements are not guarantees of future performance and involve a number of risks and uncertainties that could materially affect actual results such as, but not limited to, (i) changes in government regulations and anticipated deregulation of the electric energy industry; (ii) commercial operations of new plants that may be delayed or prevented because of various development and construction risks, such as a failure to obtain financing and the necessary permits to operate or the failure of third-party contractors to perform their contractual obligations (iii) cost estimates are preliminary and actual cost may be higher than estimated, (iv) the assurance that the Company will develop additional plants, (v) a competitor's development of a lower-cost generating gas-fired power plant, (vi) receipt of regulatory approvals or (vii) the risks associated with marketing and selling power from power plants in the newly competitive energy market. Prospective investors are also referred to the other risks identified from time to time in the Company's reports and registration statements filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission. SOURCE Calpine Corporation CONTACT: press, Kent Robertson, 408-995-5115, ext. 1144, or investors, Rick Barraza, 408-995-5115, ext. 1125, both of Calpine Corporation Web site: http://www.gepower.com Web site: http://www.calpine.com (CPN)