10 Apr 2001, 10:40 UTC
Energy Issues
- From
- Miyung Buster miyung.buster@enron.com
- To
-
Ann M Schmidt, Bryan Seyfried, dg27@pacbell.net, Elizabeth Linnell, filuntz@aol.com, James D Steffes, Janet Butler, Jeannie Mandelker, Jeff Dasovich, Joe Hartsoe, John Neslage, John Sherriff
and 38 more
Joseph Alamo, Karen Denne, Lysa Akin, Margaret Carson, Mark Palmer, Mark Schroeder, Markus Fiala, Michael R Brown, Mike Dahlke, Mona L Petrochko, Nicholas O'Day, Peggy Mahoney, Peter Styles, Richard Shapiro, Rob Bradley, Sandra McCubbin, Shelley Corman, Stella Chan, Steven J Kean, Susan J Mara, mike.roan@enron.com, Alex Parsons, andrew.morrison@enron.com, Laura Ipsen, Janel Guerrero, shirley.hudler@enron.com, Kathleen Sullivan, Tom Briggs, Linda Robertson, Lora Sullivan, Jennifer Thome, jkradin@marathon-com.com, rlichtenstein@marathon-com.com, Sandra Yamane, Ken Smith, Hedy Govenar, Scott Govenar, Bev Hansen - Bcc
- Lynnette Barnes
- Date
- Tue, 10 Apr 2001 03:40:00 -0700 (PDT)
Please see the following articles: Sac Bee, Tues, 4/10: "State, Edison reach accord: California would pay $2.76 billion for the grid and let rates be used to defray debt" Sac Bee, Tues, 4/10: "Takeover of grid in doubt: PG&E's bankruptcy filing complicates the state's plan to acquire power lines" Sac Bee, Tues, 4/10: "PG&E clashes with regulators in court session " Sac Bee, Tues, 4/10: "Judge blasts FERC, renounces power dispute " Sac Bee, Tues, 4/10: "Dan Walters: Lots of words, but is the crisis finally coming to a climax?" San Diego Union, Tues, 4/10: "Davis closes in on deal for Edison's lines" San Diego Union, Tues, 4/10: "White House urges energy spending cuts" LA Times, Tues, 4/10: "Davis Arranges to Buy Edison's Share of Grid" LA Times, Tues, 4/10: "PG&E Bankruptcy Case Opens in Tense, Packed Federal Courtroom" LA Times, Tues, 4/10: "Oil Official Urges Eased Restrictions on Industry" LA Times, Tues, 4/10: "Give Power Buyers a Club in Cartel Wars" (Commentary) SF Chron, Tues, 4/10: "State's Financial Exposure Is a Growing Worry DAILY LOSSES: Experts say fiscal stability at risk " SF Chron, Tues, 4/10: "Davis Seals Power Deal With Edison to Buy Lines 10-YEAR PACT: $2.76 billion swap buys low-cost electricity " SF Chron, Tues, 4/10: "PG&E Stumps Math Whizzes GO FIGURE: Who knows how much this will cost us? " SF Chron, Tues, 4/10: "PG&E Moves Quickly to Involve Federal Court in State's Crisis Strategy could allow judge to authorize " SF Chron, Tues, 4/10: "Going Dark Extra Day to Save Power San Mateo County tries to cut costs " Mercury News, Tues, 4/10: "Davis forges deal to rescue Edison" Mercury News, Tues, 4/10: "Solar tech shines in market struggling with power problems" Mercury News, Tues, 4/10: "Getting a line on electricity" (Editorial) Mercury News, Tues, 4/10: "Price for gas surges again" Mercury News, Tues, 4/10: "Legislatures to plea for price cap" Orange County, Tues, 4/10: "Edison, state strike deal" Orange County, Tues, 4/10: "Davis' power plan is in doubt" Orange County, Tues, 4/10: "AES threatens to pull out of fast-track effort" Orange County, Tues, 4/10: "Electricity Notebook PG&E may use reserved cash to purchase energy" Orange County, Tues, 4/10: "State's power fees hinge on good credit" Individual.com (business wire), Tues, 4/10: "AES NewEnergy Offers Program to Help Commonwealth Edison Customers Reduce Electricity Costs and Increase Reliability This Summer" Individual.com (AP business wire), Tues, 4/10: "Feds Embroiled in Power Debate" Individual.com (AP business wire), Tues, 4/10: "Calif. Reaches Deal on Power Lines" Individual.com (AP business wire), Tues, 4/10: "California ISO Declares a Statewide Stage Two Electrical Emergency; Conservation Needed as Demand Surges and Supply Tightens" ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ -------------------------------------------------------------- State, Edison reach accord: California would pay $2.76 billion for the grid and let rates be used to defray debt. By Emily Bazar Bee Capitol Bureau (Published April 10, 2001) Just three days after Pacific Gas and Electric Co. filed for bankruptcy protection and cut off negotiations with the state, Gov. Gray Davis on Monday announced an agreement with Southern California Edison to buy the utility's transmission lines in exchange for helping it pay off billions of dollars in debt. Key points of the accord between state and Edison The agreement between the state and Southern California Edison must be approved by the Legislature and Public Utilities Commission. Some points, including details of the transmission grid sale, still must be negotiated. Edison agreed to: Sell its transmission system for $2.76 billion. Use its generation assets to provide low-cost regulated power to the state for 10 years. Dismiss lawsuits for higher electricity rates. Commit the entire output of a generating plant to providing power in California at a fixed price for 10 years. Grant perpetual conservation easements: 20,600 acres of precious lands related to the Big Creek hydroelectric facility and 825 acres related to the eastern Sierra. Invest $3 billion over five years in capital improvements, to be covered by a rate increase of undetermined size. Edison's parent company will refund $400 million to its subsidiary. The state agreed to: Continue buying power through Dec. 31, 2002. Allow Edison to issue $3.5 billion in bonds for all debt not covered by $1.5 billion net gain Edison realizes from transmission line sale. Bonds repaid by a dedicated portion of the rate. Allow Edison to continue receiving its current 11.6 percent rate of return for 10 years. The Democratic governor said the state would pay Edison $2.76 billion for its transmission lines, and would dedicate a portion of consumers' electricity rates to paying off the utility's debt, estimated at more than $5 billion. Davis praised Edison for its persistence in negotiations, but upbraided PG&E for filing Chapter 11. He added, however, that the state remains willing to offer PG&E a comparable deal if it wishes to resume talks. "It was hard, arduous work, but the result was positive for every consumer in this state," Davis said at a news conference in Los Angeles. "It proves you can solve problems of the state if you stay at the table, if you're responsible and (if) you're resolute." The deal came 47 days after Davis announced an "agreement in principle" with Edison. Monday's announcement was received coolly by the governor's fellow Democrats in the Legislature and criticized as a giveaway by consumer advocates. Harvey Rosenfield of the Foundation for Taxpayers and Consumer Rights branded it a "massive ratepayer bailout" that protects only the utility's shareholders and executives. "I'd call this a desperate deal by a panic-stricken governor," Rosenfield said. The deal is "designed to appease Wall Street and to redeem the governor in the eyes of the energy and utility industry." Rosenfield said he will fight the agreement, which must be approved by the state Public Utilities Commission, the state Legislature and the federal government before it becomes final. The process could take as long as two years. Rosenfield said he's prepared to put an initiative before voters in November 2002 that would undo the agreement if necessary. The deal announced by the governor would require the state to pay $2.76 billion for Edison's transmission lines, or 2.3 times book value. Edison is expected to profit by $1.5 billion from the purchase, and would use that money to pay off some of its debt. Edison's parent company would refund $400 million to its subsidiary, which would also go toward paying off the utility's debt. The utility would pay off the rest of its debt through corporate bonds, which would be repaid by consumers through a portion of their electricity rates. Before PG&E's bankruptcy-protection announcement Friday, Davis came out in support of an average 26 percent rate increase. In exchange, Edison has agreed to provide low-cost power to the state for 10 years from both regulated and nonregulated power plants, and to dismiss lawsuits seeking higher electricity rates. It also would grant perpetual conservation easements on more than 21,000 acres of forestland. In addition, Edison has pledged to do work on its lower-voltage distribution grid that would trigger a second, unspecified rate increase, to take effect in 2003, said Stephen Frank, chief executive of Southern California Edison. The utility would invest $3 billion in the poles and wires it still owns, and would collect that money from consumers under a formula it will propose later this summer, possibly in August. The formula would have to be approved by the PUC, which is overseen by a Davis-appointed majority. The legislative approval required for the entire agreement likely won't come without a fight. The bill that will contain the deal's provisions is expected to require only a simple majority for passage, which means 41 votes in the Assembly and 21 in the Senate. Though it could squeak through without Republican votes, it's not clear whether all Democrats will support the plan. Assembly Speaker Robert Hertzberg, D-Sherman Oaks, reserved judgment on the plan until he can see details for himself. "I am most anxious to review the protections the plan provides to California residential and business consumers," he said. Senate leader John Burton, D-San Francisco, was more blunt. Burton said he's concerned about dedicating a portion of consumers' rates to pay off Edison's debt. "I have always had a concern about a dedicated rate component that would have ratepayers picking up utilities' back debt that may have been built up fraudulently through price gouging or mismanagement," he said. "There is a question of whether ratepayers should have to gargle that." Sen. Debra Bowen, D-Marina Del Rey, suggested that power generators must also share the debt burden. "It sounds like the plan puts ratepayers on the hook for 100 percent of the rates charged by the power generators -- rates that even (the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission) found to be unjust and unreasonable." Frank, who heads Edison International's regulated utility, argued that the utility is entitled to collect the funds, and estimated that Edison ratepayers would be paying off $2 billion of the disputed "undercollection" for the next 15 years. "We do expect to recover all of our costs on this, but we also are contributing a great deal to the overall deal," Frank added, including giving up ownership of transmission lines. Davis said that he expects to work out a deal with San Diego Gas & Electric soon. The governor added that he still hopes to reach an agreement with PG&E. But in a statement, PG&E officials said they aren't planning on returning to the negotiating table unless they are directed by the judge handling their bankruptcy protection case. "Given our set of facts, we continue to believe that Chapter 11 reorganization is the most feasible means to reach a solution," the statement said. "We will proceed at the direction of the bankruptcy court." The Bee's Emily Bazar can be reached at (916) 326-5540 or ebazar@sacbee.com. Bee Staff Writers Carrie Peyton and Stuart Leavenworth contributed to this report. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------ Takeover of grid in doubt: PG&E's bankruptcy filing complicates the state's plan to acquire power lines. By Stuart Leavenworth Bee Staff Writer (Published April 10, 2001) Can California be nourished by part of a hot dog? A growing chorus of lawmakers, consumer activists and others say no. On Monday, the governor reaffirmed his plans to take over Southern California Edison's portion of the electrical transmission grid, an asset that Senate leader John Burton once called a "hot dog" in a pitch to reporters. But Pacific Gas and Electric Co.'s bankruptcy filing Friday throws into doubt whether California can take over PG&E's power lines, and now even one-time supporters are raising questions about the plan. "There may be some value in having the state own the entire transmission grid, but it's not clear to me what the benefit is to ratepayers if the state is only acquiring a quarter of it," state Sen. Debra Bowen, chairwoman of the Senate's energy committee, said soon after Gov. Gray Davis announced his agreement with Edison. For months, supporters of a grid takeover -- including Davis, Burton, State Treasurer Phil Angelides and consumer activists -- have pressed PG&E, Edison and San Diego Gas & Electric to give up their power lines in exchange for state help in bailing the utilities out of debt. Supporters say state ownership of power lines would give California more clout in dealing with the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission and would provide the state with an estimated $1.4 billion a year in fees collected from grid users. The transmission grid refers to the 32,000-mile network of power lines that supply California's electricity. Its total value has been estimated between $7.5 billion and $9 billion. On Monday, Davis said that talks were continuing with SDG&E and that the state may ask a federal bankruptcy court to relinquish PG&E's part of the grid to the state. "One way or the other, we hope to be able to get all three lines," Davis said. Some legal experts, however, say Davis is taking a big gamble. In a bankruptcy proceeding, any transfer of lines would have to be approved by a judge and by PG&E's creditors, who, in this case, include some of the state's biggest power generators. "It would have to be done through a plan of reorganization that the creditors would have to agree to," said David Wiggs, an energy consultant who has been advising Assembly lawmakers. "Now you have a whole other group that has to agree." Gary Ackerman, head of the Western Power Trading Forum, said generators aren't convinced Davis can take title to Edison's portion of the grid, much less one from PG&E. "Given this administration's sterling record for putting together deals, I am not sure this one will work any more than the others," Ackerman said. Another option is for the state to use its power of eminent domain to take over the PG&E grid. But such a move could trigger years of lawsuits and squabbles, analysts say. "In the end, they may have to pay the debtors or the utilities a whole lot more than book value," said Rich Ferguson, an adviser for the Sierra Club, which once supported the idea of a grid takeover. Now, Ferguson said, environmentalists are more worried about the utility selling off its vast hydroelectric plants and land holdings in the Sierra. "The state has to protect the hydroelectric assets," Ferguson said. "The idea of giving commercial control over the water and power in that system is so scary that people don't even want to think about it." Steve Maviglio, a spokesman for the governor, said Davis shares such concerns but is trying to salvage the best of a bad situation. "PG&E put themselves in some very uncharted waters so we will have to see where this leads," he said. Others fear the state could emerge from a summer of blackouts with higher rates and only part of a hot dog. It's an unappetizing prospect, said Harvey Rosenfield of the Foundation for Taxpayers and Consumers Rights. "Buying two out of three transmission systems is like buying a car with three out of four wheels," Rosenfield said. "There is no point in it." The Bee's Stuart Leavenworth can be reached at (916) 321-1185 or sleavenworth@sacbee.com. Bee Staff Writers Emily Bazar and Carrie Peyton contributed to this report. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------ PG&E clashes with regulators in court session By Carrie Peyton Bee Staff Writer (Published April 10, 2001) Electricity regulators and California's largest utility clashed in Bankruptcy Court on Monday in what a state lawyer warned is the first move of a plan to wrest control of electric rates from the state's hands. And in continuing fallout from Pacific Gas and Electric Co.'s filing for bankruptcy protection Friday, PG&E is notifying counties statewide that it will pay them just under half of the property tax funds they were expecting to receive today. The flare-up in federal Bankruptcy Court in San Francisco on Monday morning revolved around a technical issue -- how much time PG&E needs to give revised accounting documents to regulators at the state Public Utilities Commission. But by asking Judge Dennis Montali to order regulators to wait, PG&E is dragging the judge into an area he doesn't belong, said Gary Cohen, the lawyer for the PUC, which regulates electric rates. "This is the first volley in PG&E's legal strategy, which is to try to get the bankruptcy judge to subvert the PUC's regulatory authority," Cohen said after the hearing. "It isn't true; it isn't what happened today," said PG&E spokesman John Nelson. He said PG&E really just needs more time -- for now. Montali isn't expected to rule immediately on the accounting issue, which could be just one avenue PG&E might use to make a legal case for higher electric rates. Power sellers have said they hope Montali will ultimately order or pressure regulators to raise rates, and some bankruptcy experts say boosting rates, at least temporarily, could be within the court's power. It is "too early to speculate" on whether PG&E plans to ask the judge to raise rates or to undo any PUC decisions, Nelson said. The court also will be deeply involved in any ongoing payments by PG&E, which has short-circuited revenue flowing to dozens of California counties. The utility owed $79 million to California counties for its Jan. 1-June 30 property taxes, but it will pay only $37 million, covering the period from April 6 onward, Nelson said. That's because it needs court permission to pay any bills for the period just prior to its bankruptcy filing. PG&E plans to ask the court to let it pay counties the rest of the money. The Bee's Carrie Peyton can be reached at (916) 321-1086 or cpeyton@sacbee.com. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ --------------------------------------------- Judge blasts FERC, renounces power dispute By Denny Walsh Bee Staff Writer (Published April 10, 2001) A Sacramento federal judge Monday bowed out of the bitter financial dispute between energy generators and their California buyers but not before he leveled a blast at the performance of federal regulators. Political party Here are the annual salaries of state officeholders before the California Citizens Compensation Commission was formed in 1990 and at present. Governor 1990: $85,000 Current: $175,000 % increase: 106% Lt. Governor 1990: $72,500 Current: $131,250 % increase: 81% Attorney General 1990: $77,500 Current: $148,750 % increase: 92% Controller 1990: $72,500 Current: $140,000 % increase: 93% Treasurer 1990: $72,500 Current: $140,000 % increase: 93% Sec. of State 1990: $72,500 Current: $131,250 % increase: 81% Supt. of Public Instruction 1990: $72,500 Current: $148,750 % increase: 105% Insurance Commissioner 1990: $95,052 Current: $140,000 % increase: 47% Bd. of Equalization 1990: $95,052 Current: $131,250 % increase: 38% Legislator 1990: $40,816 Current: $99,000 % increase: 143% Assembly Speaker 1990: $40,816 Current: $113,850 % increase: 179% Senate President 1990: $40,816 Current: $113,850 % increase: 179% Source: California Citizens Compensation Commission. Percentages are rounded. The blistering remarks came as Gov. Gray Davis' spokesman, Steve Maviglio, said the federal government stance could add $5 million to $8 million more a day to the state's power purchases for its two largest utilities this summer. The cost will rise substantially during periods of high demand in summer unless the state fights rulings last week by a federal appeals court and the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, Maviglio said, adding that no decisions have been made on appeals. U.S. District Judge Frank C. Damrell Jr. canceled Thursday's hearing on a motion by the state's transmission grid operator to amend its lawsuit against one of the nation's major energy suppliers. Citing Friday's ruling by FERC that cash-strapped buyers of emergency power must be able to pay for it, no matter how dire California's energy crisis becomes, Damrell said in a short but stinging order that further action in his court would be "futile." The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, hinting at jurisdictional problems, stayed Damrell's injunction forcing Reliant Energy Services to sell emergency power to the Independent System Operator. The ISO then sought to convert its suit to breach-of-contract litigation in an attempt to overcome the appellate court's concerns. As he backed out of the brawl Monday, Damrell accused FERC of dragging its feet and talking out of both sides of its mouth. Meanwhile, the state Department of Water Resources, which has been acquiring energy since Jan. 19 with the backing of legislative appropriations, is "buying the power necessary to keep the lights on," said Ray Hart, the department's deputy director. And three top state lawmakers will travel to Boise, Idaho, today to attend a FERC hearing on price volatility in the West. They will ask the commissioners to impose a temporary price cap on wholesale electricity in Western states. In a March 21 injunction, Damrell ordered Reliant to continue selling emergency power to ISO, even though it would not be paid for purchases on behalf of Pacific Gas and Electric Co., which has filed for bankruptcy protection, and Southern California Edison Co., also heavily in debt. Reliant said its agreement with the ISO requires buyers to be creditworthy and sought to back away from the two investor-owned utilities. The ISO sued to halt the retreat of the Houston-based firm along with other generators. FERC issued an order Feb. 14 generally siding with generators on the creditworthiness question. FERC on Friday said the ISO "misinterpreted our order." It "required a creditworthy counterparty, such as the California Department of Water Resources." That did not please Damrell. In his Monday order, the judge wrote that FERC said Feb. 14 it would address the creditworthiness question as it applies to emergency purchases in the future. "The FERC explicitly acknowledged this fact five days ago in a brief" submitted to the 9th Circuit challenging the March 21 injunction, he said. The judge said it was FERC's own words in the Feb. 14 order that he relied on in issuing an injunction pending the agency's decision on creditworthiness. The Bee's Denny Walsh can be reached at (916) 321-1189 or dwalsh@sacbee.com. Bee Staff Writer Carrie Peyton and the Associated Press contributed to this report. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ --------------------------------------------- Dan Walters: Lots of words, but is the crisis finally coming to a climax? (Published April 10, 2001) Last Thursday, Gov. Gray Davis abandoned his oft-voiced, albeit unrealistic, "hope and expectation" that consumers' electric utility rates would not rise sharply to cope with soaring wholesale power costs, backing a hefty boost in rates he said would provide utilities with enough revenue to avoid bankruptcy. A day later, the state's largest utility, Pacific Gas and Electric Co., thumbed its nose at Davis by filing for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection, with PG&E executives blaming Davis and other state politicians for prolonging a financial drain on the company. Davis immediately denounced PG&E's action, saying the venerable company "has dishonored itself," and declared that his negotiations with the smaller but similarly distressed Southern California Edison on a state buyout of the intercity transmission system would continue. Over the weekend, as Davis and his aides conducted nearly round-the-clock talks with Edison executives, he and PG&E traded sharp barbs over who was to blame for bankruptcy. "PG&E management is suffering from two afflictions: denial and greed," the governor declared in a statement Saturday, followed by an equally testy response from PG&E. The utility said that "instead of focusing all his attention on solving the state's yearlong and ever-worsening energy crisis, the governor has launched a campaign-style attack on our company." On Monday, Davis and Edison Chairman John Bryson -- a former colleague from the Jerry Brown administration two decades ago -- announced agreement on a deal for the state to acquire Edison's share of the power transmission grid for $2.76 billion and obtain low-cost power from the utility for the next 10 years. Net proceeds of the sale, about $1.5 billion, would be used to reduce Edison's $5 billion debt, with the rest being covered by bonds, to be repaid from a share of the utility rate hike Davis now supports. Davis continued his sniping at PG&E, albeit indirectly. "This is a clear example of the good that can come when parties are responsible, resolute and remain at the bargaining table," Davis said -- adding that PG&E could have a similar deal if it wants. But PG&E, whose debt is half-again as large as SCE's, has declared it doesn't want to sell its share of the grid. That's five days of fairly intense activity. And the flurry may indicate that the state's lengthy crisis involving electric supplies that fall short of demand, escalating wholesale and retail power prices and the shaky financial health of the state's utilities may be coming to a climactic point. But are matters really improving, as Davis insists, or are there more curves and bumps ahead? And will the road lead to some sort of crash-and-burn conclusion? The harsh truth is that no one knows for certain, and that includes Davis. Not only is this energy crisis an unprecedented event, but it's one that has been stubbornly resistant to the sort of give-and-take, something-for-everyone approach that politicians instinctively favor. It's part politics, part economics, part technology and part psychology -- a volatile mixture whose exact composition changes constantly. And no one knows what role the bankruptcy judge will play in setting rates or compelling PG&E to reopen negotiations on the sale of its share of the grid. Even the steps that Davis hails as positive, such as state acquisition of the power grid, could turn negative. Is the state capable of owning and operating, even indirectly, such a thing? Will the much-needed expansion of the system now become another bit of political pork? And what happens if, as Davis now wants, the state moves even more deeply into the power business by building and operating generating plants? Will rates be manipulated for political purposes? It's well known that Davis' pollsters have been testing voters' tolerance of rate boosts. This is a wild ride, and no one -- absolutely no one -- knows where it will end. The Bee's Dan Walters can be reached at (916) 321-1195 or dwalters@sacbee.com . ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------ Davis closes in on deal for Edison's lines But several hurdles still stand in the way By Ed Mendel UNION-TRIBUNE STAFF WRITER April 10, 2001 SACRAMENTO -- Gov. Gray Davis, scrambling to save his utility rescue plan, announced a $2.76 billion agreement yesterday for the state to purchase Southern California Edison's transmission system. The long-delayed acquisition is what Davis wants in exchange for helping Edison pay off its huge debt. But the deal is far from done. Assembly Republicans are threatening to block the purchase in the Legislature, approval by federal regulators is uncertain, and disputes could arise as details of the agreement are worked out. White House urges energy spending cuts Continuing coverage: California's Power Crisis ? Negotiators worked through the weekend to swiftly complete a memorandum of understanding after Pacific Gas and Electric surprised Davis by filing for bankruptcy Friday, a day after the governor made a statewide televised address to report progress on the rescue plan. Davis praised Edison for being concerned about "the fate of the consumers they serve" and criticized PG&E for acting "arrogantly and selfishly." He said the Edison offer is available to PG&E if it returns to the bargaining table. But PG&E, without elaborating, issued a statement saying that it must deal with a different "set of facts" than Edison and continues "to believe that a Chapter 11 reorganization is the most feasible means to reach a solution." A U.S. bankruptcy judge in San Francisco, Dennis Montali, began work on the PG&E bankruptcy yesterday. He ruled that PG&E's assets can continue to be used to back the purchase of natural gas. Edison Chairman John Bryson, joining Davis at a news conference in Los Angeles, said his utility believes that a negotiated resolution of the issues is "far preferable" to bankruptcy. "It serves the state," Bryson said. "It serves our customers. It serves our employees and our companies to achieve a practical resolution." Davis said the administration would resume negotiating for the purchase of the transmission system of San Diego Gas & Electric. He said he is optimistic because SDG&E has agreed "in principle" to sell its transmission system. SDG&E said in a statement that it was "very encouraged" by the Edison agreement and looked forward to continuing negotiations with the Davis administration. Under the governor's rescue plan, the transmission system is the main thing that the utilities give the state in exchange for aid in paying off the massive debts that drove PG&E and Edison to the brink of bankruptcy. The rates they charge customers were frozen under deregulation as the price of wholesale power soared, producing a combined debt of $13 billion. The state was forced to begin buying power for utility customers in mid-January when generators refused to extend further credit to the utilities. It has spent more than $4 billion so far. The governor's plan would give the utilities part of the revenue from the monthly bill paid by their customers -- a "dedicated rate component" -- that could be used to finance bonds that would pay off the utility debt. Davis has said that state ownership of the transmission system would allow improvements of bottlenecks that led to blackouts last year. The governor said yesterday that if there are purchase agreements with two of the utilities, the bankruptcy judge might be persuaded to allow the sale of PG&E's transmission system or to permit private mediation. "One way or the other we hope to get all three lines," Davis said. But there is a fallback position. If the transmission purchase does not occur within two years, the state could make up the shortfall by buying Edison's hydroelectric power plants and obtaining low-cost power. The governor has previously said there is a question about whether the state purchase of utility transmission systems would be approved by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission. Republicans, who must provide at least five votes for the purchase of a transmission system to pass the Assembly, oppose the plan and have suggested that the utility parent firms pay off the debt. "I think the governor will be hard-pressed to find the votes he needs in the Assembly to complete the Southern California Edison bailout," said Assembly GOP Leader Dave Cox of Fair Oaks. Senate President Pro Tempore John Burton, D-San Francisco, said he is concerned that a "dedicated rate component" may cause ratepayers to pay off utility debt that resulted from price gouging, stock buybacks, executive bonuses and transfers to the parent companies. "There is a question of whether ratepayers should have to gargle that," said Burton, who promised in-depth legislative hearings on the Edison agreement. Edison officials say they have a debt of $5.5 billion from the "undercollection" on power costs, some of which is owed to the generating branch of Edison. The state purchase price of $2.76 billion is 2.3 times the book value of the transmission system. Edison said it will pay off its debt with money from the transmission sale and a $2 billion bond backed by its share of the ratepayer's monthly bill. The state expects to recover the purchase cost from the current transmission fees on monthly ratepayer bills. Edison would continue to operate the system under a contract with the state. The deal announced by Davis yesterday added some of the details to an agreement "in principle" to buy the Edison transmission system announced Feb. 23. Davis said then he hoped to finish the agreement in a week. One of the things that caused PG&E to file for bankruptcy, its executives said Friday, is that the Davis administration did not negotiate with them for more than three weeks while trying to wrap up the Edison deal. The complex Edison agreement requires the utility to provide low-cost power to the state from its remaining regulated generators for 10 years and to drop a lawsuit seeking a rate hike to pay off its debt. Edison also agreed to give the state low-cost power from its new unregulated Sunrise power plant for 10 years. If the plant is not operating by Aug. 15, Edison will pay a $2 million penalty. The Edison parent firm will give the utility $400 million, returning a tax refund that the utility transferred to the parent firm. Edison agreed to spend $3 billion over five years to improve its distribution system, the local lines and equipment retained after sale of the long-distance transmission system. A rate increase to pay for the work may be proposed in 2003. The goal of the governor's plan is to get the utilities back into the power-buying business by the end of next year, freeing the state from the burden it assumed nearly three months ago. The state general fund, which has been paying for the power, is expected to be repaid by a bond of perhaps $12 billion or more that would be paid off by ratepayers over a dozen years. But as the state spends $1.5 billion a month to buy power, with the fear that spending will accelerate this summer, some are concerned that the PG&E bankruptcy may delay or halt the bond, causing funding cuts in other programs. The chairman of the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, Curt Hebert Jr., said again yesterday that the Bush administration does not want to impose federal caps on wholesale power, something sought by Davis since last fall. Assembly Speaker Robert Hertzberg, D-Van Nuys, plans to lead a legislative delegation to a FERC hearing in Boise, Idaho, today to make another plea for caps on wholesale power prices. Davis said that California, which has not built a major new power plant in a dozen years, will continue to have power shortages until about a dozen new plants are operating. "We will have capacity exceeding demand by some time in mid to late 2003," said Davis. "But to help us get there without blackouts, we are going to need a lot of conservation on the part of consumers and business." Staff writer Dean Calbreath, Copley News Service reporter Matt Krasnowski and wire services contributed to this report. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ---------------- White House urges energy spending cuts By Toby Eckert COPLEY NEWS SERVICE April 10, 2001 WASHINGTON -- Despite dire warnings of a new energy crisis, the Bush administration yesterday proposed slashing federal spending on conservation programs and renewable energy. Energy Secretary Spencer Abraham defended the proposal, saying the targeted programs were not producing enough benefits and that the administration wanted to bolster more successful initiatives, like home weatherization. Energy conservation groups said the cuts would gut programs that are saving billions of dollars a year in energy costs and would worsen the very power shortages Abraham and President Bush have been warning the country about. The administration also reportedly is weighing whether to delay or roll back new energy-efficiency standards for air conditioners and other appliances. Experts have said conservation efforts are a key to lessening the blackouts that are expected to hit California this summer, and state officials have urged residents to cut power use. The detailed budget blueprint for fiscal year 2002 that Bush submitted to Congress would cut federal energy efficiency and renewable energy programs by more than $200 million from current levels. Some of the programs affected include solar and wind-power development and efforts to cut energy consumption at commercial and government buildings. "We decided that it made little sense to continue forward with programs that had not helped us avert the energy crisis we confronted," Abraham said in unveiling the Energy Department budget. "Instead of spending a huge amount of additional taxpayer money in areas we did not see as being highly productive at this point, we thought it made sense to step back." Critics said Abraham was understating the benefits of the programs to further the Bush administration's strategy of expanding development and use of fossil fuels such as oil, gas and coal. They also suggested the programs were being sacrificed to make way for Bush's proposed $1.6 trillion tax cut. "It is bald-faced hypocrisy to argue that we are worried about an energy crisis and to cut the programs that have had the single biggest effect on reducing energy consumption," said Hal Harvey, president of The Energy Foundation, a San Francisco-based group that promotes alternative energy sources and conservation. The Alliance to Save Energy estimated that the targeted programs cut energy costs by more than $25 billion a year. Abraham said the administration was "absolutely committed" to conservation and efficiency measures and that they would "play a key role" as a White House task force devises a national energy policy. He characterized the proposed cuts as "a transitional step that gives us the opportunity to come back in future budgets with a new set of priorities that will help us to overcome the energy crisis we face." The administration has proposed boosting alternative energy programs by $1.2 billion beginning in 2004 -- but only if Congress approves oil and natural gas drilling in Alaska's Arctic National Wildlife Refuge. There is strong opposition to that in Congress. Abraham touted the administration's proposal to increase funding for a grant program to make homes more energy efficient. The program would grow by $120 million next year and by $1.4 billion over 10 years under Bush's plan. The administration also has proposed extending tax credits for wind and solar power projects, increasing research into energy derived from organic biomass material by $30 million and spending $150 million on a new clean-coal technology program. Just as Bush has in the past, Abraham cautioned that there are no quick fixes to the nation's energy woes. He also defended the administration's response to the crisis in California, saying the problem had festered under the Clinton administration. "In the one month in which a Bush-appointed chairman was in charge of (the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission), they began making refunds," Abraham said, referring to FERC's threat to order power providers to repay California utilities for alleged overcharges. California officials say FERC consistently has underestimated the amount that should be refunded and that it has taken far too long to act. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------- Davis Arranges to Buy Edison's Share of Grid Power: State would pay $2.76 billion and let the company recover from some of its debt. By DAN MORAIN and ROBIN FIELDS, Times Staff Writers ?????SACRAMENTO--Gov. Gray Davis announced a deal Monday to buy Southern California Edison's transmission lines for $2.76 billion, and to allow Edison to recoup part of its multibillion-dollar debt from consumers. ?????With Edison International Chairman John Bryson at his side, Davis announced what he called a historic agreement with the near-bankrupt utility, and vowed to press ahead with negotiations to buy San Diego Gas & Electric's share of the transmission system. ?????Coming on the first business day after Pacific Gas & Electric filed for bankruptcy, the deal's significance was clouded by the difficulty of extending its provision to the state's largest utility, whose finances will now be untangled in court. Without acquiring PG&E's share of the transmission grid, experts said the purchase would be of little practical value to the state. Still, the deal represented a victory for Davis and Edison in their efforts to avoid another bankruptcy, and the troubled utility's stock jumped as much as 40% on the news. ?????Davis renewed his attack on PG&E as the bankruptcy proceeding officially opened, saying it acted "arrogantly and selfishly" by filing for bankruptcy. ?????He went out of his way to praise Edison: "We have come to terms with a utility that was on the verge of bankruptcy, because they are people of goodwill and are concerned about the fate of the consumers they serve, and they stayed at the bargaining table." ?????Calling the deal preferable to bankruptcy, Bryson said: "It serves the state, it serves our consumers, it serves our employees and our companies to achieve a practical resolution." ?????The deal is far from done. The Legislature and the California Public Utilities Commission must approve major parts of it. Senate President Pro Tem John Burton (D-San Francisco) said he intends to hold "complete hearings, and then some." ?????"We have to take a very thorough, careful, detailed look at it," Burton said Monday. ?????Assembly Speaker Bob Hertzberg (D-Sherman Oaks) said in a statement that he had not seen any details, "including the costs to the state." Lawmakers will begin work promptly on legislation to implement the deal, he said. ?????Consumer advocates were not enamored of the deal. ?????"It's hard to imagine that PG&E would walk away from a deal like this because it seems to give Edison everything they want," said attorney Mike Florio of the Utility Reform Network, a consumer group in San Francisco. ?????In what probably will be the most controversial element, Davis agreed to allow Edison to recover at least part of its debt--$3.5 billion--from consumers. The company would use part of ratepayers' money to back the sale of bonds to investors, taking the proceeds to refinance its debt. ?????To sell bonds, the utility must be able to assure investors that it has a dedicated source of revenue from ratepayers' bills earmarked to repay the principal and interest on the bonds. ?????Davis was not specific about whether the so-called dedicated rate component would require a rate hike beyond what amounts to the 37% increase the governor is advocating, or the roughly 40% boost that the PUC approved last month. ?????However, the Legislature would have to approve the provision, and Burton said it could result in a rate hike. Burton added that he opposes a dedicated rate component, noting that Edison's debt might have occurred because of illegal actions by independent generators that have been charging record wholesale prices for electricity. ?????"This deal by our panic-stricken governor is going to raise rates enormously," said Santa Monica consumer advocate Harvey Rosenfield, who is expected to promote an initiative to block the agreement. "He acted to protect his political career at the public's expense. It is a desperate attempt by the governor to redeem his credibility with Wall Street." ?????Davis, clearly stung by PG&E's decision to file for bankruptcy, told his negotiators to jump-start talks with Edison and to work through the weekend to resolve differences. ?????Davis and Bryson met for 4 hours Friday, and teams of lawyers worked through the weekend until 5 a.m. Monday to craft the deal, Davis said. Edison's board of directors ground through the fine print for 5 hours Monday before giving its stamp of approval. ?????Also as part of the deal, Edison's parent company agreed to pay back approximately $420 million to the utility. Also, Edison will withdraw all pending lawsuits seeking to recoup losses by the imposition of higher rates. ?????Bryson appeared hollow-eyed with fatigue as Monday's deal was announced, reflecting strain of negotiations. ?????In the centerpiece of the deal, Davis agreed to buy Edison's transmission lines for $2.76 billion. Edison would use proceeds from the sale to refinance its debt, which it estimates to be $5.5 billion. ?????Additionally, the state would receive conservation easements to roughly 20,000 acres of Edison land in the Sierra, assuring that the wilderness areas would not be developed. ?????Edison also agreed to sell power at cost from its plants in California for 10 years, including electricity from a plant called Sunrise being built in Kern County. ?????The governor's announcement raised many questions--not the least of which is the wisdom of owning only a part of the 32,000-mile transmission system. Davis himself said Feb. 23 that it makes little sense for the state to buy only Edison's share of the grid. ?????With PG&E in bankruptcy court, chances are slim that the state will be able to take over its share of the transmission grid. Without the entire grid, the public benefits are questionable. ?????"It's like buying a car with three wheels," Rosenfield said. ?????Davis said his negotiators will turn their attention to striking a deal with San Diego Gas & Electric. San Diego's situation is far different from Edison's or PG&E's. The utility's debt is about $680 million--far less than the combined debt of more than $13 billion claimed by PG&E and Edison. ?????"We have been negotiating on good faith with the governor for several weeks now, and we will continue that process," said Art Larson, spokesman for Sempra Energy, parent of San Diego Gas & Electric. ?????Davis said that after he has deals with Edison and San Diego, he hopes to ask the Bankruptcy Court to allow the state to buy PG&E's portion of the grid. He also held out hope that PG&E might agree to negotiate with the state--even though PG&E executives say that one of the reasons they filed for bankruptcy was that the state had gone three weeks without meeting with them. ?????"Even though PG&E acted arrogantly and selfishly--they walked away from the bargaining table--if they come back, we are certainly willing to submit this offer to them as well," Davis said. ?????PG&E spokesman John Nelson replied: "We are proceeding under the direction of a federal bankruptcy judge." ?????Davis says that after the state owns the transmission lines, itwill improve the long-neglected system to make the distribution of power more efficient. The cost of overhauling the system has been placed at $1 billion. ?????The state also may be able to exercise some control over prices for electricity charged by generators--though the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, which must approve the sale, likely would oppose such state action. ?????Investors cheered Edison's deal with the state on grounds that it would pull the utility further from the precipice of bankruptcy--whether filed voluntarily or by creditors unwilling to trust a bureaucratic solution. ?????"This absolutely helps Southern California Edison prevent an involuntary bankruptcy," said Paul Fremont, an analyst with Jefferies & Co. in New York. "Depending on the details, it makes them viable." ?????Edison's stock, which gained 67 cents to $8.92 a share in regular trading Monday, soared another 40% after hours to a high of $12.50 a share after the deal was announced. PG&E's stock, meanwhile, fell 30 cents to $6.90 a share. ?????Most analysts deemed the purchase of Edison's transmission system more valuable for the state strategically than practically; without PG&E's holdings, the state cannot achieve the control over delivery it had sought, they agreed. ?????But the deal means Davis and California lawmakers will retain a role in resolving the power crisis, rather than being preempted by court proceedings. ?????"If both of them had said it's futile, we can't deal with the state; we'd rather go to court, it would speak loudly," said Douglas Christopher, an analyst at Crowell, Weedon & Co. "The governor had to come back, and with the kind of details that were missing from his speech." ?????Edison's agreement to the deal does not necessarily mean it will avoid bankruptcy. Gary Ackerman, who represents power producers and marketers as the executive director of the Western Power Trading Forum, said creditors still could force Edison into bankruptcy. ?????"Creditors will be motivated to push Edison into bankruptcy sooner," Ackerman predicted. "We don't see this as being 100 cents on the dollar, because the amount of money for the transmission system is not enough to pay for Edison's debt." --- ?????Morain reported from Sacramento and Fields from Los Angeles. Times staff writers Miguel Bustillo, Nancy Vogel and Julie Tamaki in Sacramento and Nancy Cleeland in Los Angeles contributed to this story. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ -------------------------------------------- PG&E Bankruptcy Case Opens in Tense, Packed Federal Courtroom Hearing: Reorganization gets underway as routine motions are made, and judge approves utility to pay many of its bills. By MAURA DOLAN, Times Staff Writer ?????SAN FRANCISCO--In the opening of the largest utility bankruptcy case in U.S. history, dozens of high-priced lawyers squeezed into a packed courtroom Monday to have a say in how Pacific Gas & Electric Co. will be allowed to spend its cash. ?????Attorneys for gas suppliers told U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Dennis Montali that they are worried that PG&E might not pay their gas bills, which run into the tens of millions of dollars. Montali, who had read all the legal documents before the hearing, pointedly advised lawyers for PG&E to spiff up their legal briefs and get their court citations right. ?????As Montali addressed a PG&E lawyer, a consumer activist marched uninvited to the court podium to read the judge a letter. Montali told her to sit down. ?????Although the motions before the court were relatively routine--Montali approved temporary orders that allow PG&E to pay many of its bills--the atmosphere was tense as the high-stakes bankruptcy reorganization got underway. ?????PG&E asked the bankruptcy judge for an injunction against accounting changes ordered March 27 by the Public Utilities Commission. The utility said the changes prevented a customer rate freeze from being lifted. The skirmish, scheduled to be heard on April 18, represents the utility's first attempt to get higher electricity rates through the bankruptcy proceeding, attorneys said. ?????In the coming months, the huge, complicated case will bring hundreds of seasoned lawyers together as they try to restructure the finances of a company that is more than $9 billion in debt. ?????Consumers are watching closely to see whether Montali allows PG&E to raise electricity rates, which state regulators have already increased by as much as 46% for some customers. The state has predicted more blackouts, and gas charges have spiraled upward for months. ?????Monday's hearing was held in the federal Bankruptcy Court, blocks from the federal courthouse, on a top floor of a high-rise in the city's busy financial district. ?????Lawyers for a variety of creditors were led into the courtroom first and filled the front rows. Activists filled the rear and seats in the jury box. ?????Even without the seating plan, it was easy to tell who was who. The activists, many of them women, were distinctly less formal than the lawyers and appeared less impressed by the proceedings. Some of them glared at the lawyers. ?????The hearing began when Montali heard from an East Coast attorney, who spoke by telephone to the courtroom representing Bank of New York for PG&E bondholders, who are owed more than $2.2 billion. ?????The proceeding on the emergency motions was intended to allow PG&E to pay its suppliers and other creditors without interruption. The judge will make a final decision on the motions May 9, a day after the first major court session of PG&E's creditors. ?????Early in a bankruptcy proceeding, it is rare for a judge not to allow the debtor to spend cash that is pledged to others as collateral. It is usually the only way for the company to continue operating. But as the case wears on, the standards for allowing expenditures become increasingly stringent, lawyers said. ?????PG&E attorney James L. Lopes, speaking in court, sought to reassure the public and creditors of the utility's good faith. ?????He said PG&E believes the state PUC erred in calculating how much the utility must pay the state for the electricity it is buying for customers. ?????Lopes added that PG&E continues to make payments because "it's very important to the state and their ongoing procurement of power." However, he said the utility reserves the right to challenge the formula for the payments at a later date. ?????The attorney also stressed that gas suppliers will be paid because the utility can pass on to consumers higher gas prices. Only electrical prices are capped. He said the utility is confident of a steady supply of gas for the next several months. ?????"There isn't going to be a default," he insisted. ?????Montali said that PG&E's "sanguine" reassurances may not be enough to comfort creditors and told the utility lawyer that he expected PG&E to provide many more specific numbers about its financial affairs. However, he approved a temporary order allowing the utility to pay its gas suppliers. ?????Adam A. Lewis, a lawyer for a gas supplier, underscored the concern of creditors when he talked about the enormous sums involved. ?????Lewis, who represents El Paso Merchant Energy, said its bill to PG&E just for March and part of April was $50 million. The monthly payment before that was $60 million, he said. ?????Considering the staggering amounts, "it doesn't take very long for something to go drastically wrong," Lewis said. ?????Montali, addressing these concerns, made it clear that he cannot single-handedly solve the energy crisis. "I have no control" over the future price of gas, he said. ?????Elsewhere on Monday, PG&E announced it would pay only half the nearly $80 million in utility property taxes due today to 49 California counties. A PG&E spokesman said bankruptcy laws allow the utility to pay only for the period following its bankruptcy filing and that the utility will ask the court in a few days for permission to pay the rest of its bill. ?????One of the nation's major debt-rating agencies, Standard & Poor's Corp., lowered its rating Monday on PG&E's unsecured debt--money owed that is not secured by any collateral--to "default" status. Another major debt-rating company, Moody's Investors Service, took no immediate action as a result of the bankruptcy filing. ?????Monday's court hearing attracted many lawyers curious about Montali's debut as the ringmaster of the gigantic case and to see who was representing other parties in the case. ?????"People were really there to do the talking in the hallways," one lawyer said later. ?????Montali, a former bankruptcy lawyer appointed to the bench in 1993, was extremely active during the hearing, peppering lawyers with comments and questions. ?????When he complained of ambiguities in PG&E's legal documents, he prefaced his remarks by saying he did not mean to criticize. He said he understood the time pressures the lawyers were under. ?????Asking for clarification of some numbers, Montali told PG&E's Lopes: "That is something to put on your short to-do list." Montali added to that list as the hearing wore on for more than an hour. ?????The judge also expressed weariness with PG&E's recitation of the history of the crisis in legal document after legal document. Could the lawyers indicate that background in italics or something "so the poor judge doesn't have to read it 175 times?" Montali asked. ?????"Your Honor," Lopes replied, "I am getting tired of reading it as well." ?????At one point, a cell phone rang in the courtroom. Montali sternly announced that it would be removed if it rang again. ?????Lopes quickly bent down and began to rummage in his briefcase. "You scared me," he said, confessing he could not remember whether he had turned off his phone. ?????He had. "It's off," he said, relieved. ?????Without missing a beat, Montali told his clerk: "Get me Jim Lopes on the phone." ?????For many of the spectators, being in the courtroom was like being in a foreign country. The judge and lawyers spoke in bankruptcy jargon that consumer activists later complained they could not understand. ?????When Montali noted that he might move the case to a larger courtroom to accommodate the crowds, Lopes said the numbers would fall off once people see "how boring these hearings are." ?????Just as Montali and Lopes began to discuss future hearing dates, consumer activist Medea Benjamin jumped from her seat and strode over to the podium to address the judge. ?????"You interrupted me," Montali admonished her. "Now go back and sit down, and I'll let you make a statement in a minute." ?????When he allowed her to speak later, she asked whether there was some way consumers could be briefed about what was happening at the hearing because it was "a little bit above our heads." ?????"Yes," Montali said. "Hire a bankruptcy lawyer." ?????Benjamin, of the Coalition for Public Power Now, then read her letter. She begged Montali not to raise utility rates and urged him to force PG&E's parent company to assume the financial burden. ?????"We have great faith in you," she concluded. "Please don't let us down." --- ?????Times staff writers James Peltz and Tim Reiterman contributed to this story. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ --------------------------------------------- Oil Official Urges Eased Restrictions on Industry Environment: Geologist advocates resuming offshore drilling and providing tax breaks in response to energy crisis. By KENNETH REICH, Times Staff Writer ?????A call for relaxation of environmental laws, an end to moratoriums on offshore oil drilling and more favorable tax treatment for oil and gas drillers was made Monday by an industry geologist at a meeting of scientists and petroleum engineers in Universal City. ?????G. Warfield Hobbs, a divisional president of the 30,000-member American Assn. of Petroleum Geologists, said it is high time the public and Congress recognize facts in the energy crisis. ?????"You can talk until you're blue in the face," Hobbs said. "They don't want to hear it. . . . How do we get the public's attention?" ?????Citing statistics provided by the U.S. Energy Information Agency, Hobbs told a joint luncheon of his group and the Geological Society of America that energy demand in the United States has grown by 20% since 1979, but domestic supply has increased by only 4.3%. ?????In the next 20 years, the agency's projections show, overall energy consumption will increase by 32%, petroleum demand by 62%, natural gas demand by 45%, coal demand by 22% and electricity demand by 45%, Hobbs said. ?????"Despite a 37% increase in energy efficiency, crude oil imports will increase 40% by 2020 to a total 64% of domestic supply," he said, even if curbs on domestic reduction are eased. ?????Suggestions for Increasing Production ?????Accordingly, Hobbs urged: ?????* Clearing the way for drilling off the East and West coasts and in the Gulf of Mexico, which he said could add 46 billion barrels of oil to the nation's officially projected 110 billion in onshore reserves and 268 trillion cubic feet of gas to the projected onshore 1,074 trillion. ?????* Amending the Federal Antiquities Act to "prevent its misuse in restricting access to public lands." The act protects some fossils and authorizes the president to set aside land for national monuments without going to Congress. ?????* Reforming the Clean Water Act and the Endangered Species Act, especially sections pertaining to wetlands. This would not lessen protections for "caribou and grizzly bears," he said, but would "stop searches for the black-tailed ferret two counties from where it is known to exist," and "stop protecting each separate subspecies of salamander." ?????* Restricting the federal Environmental Protection Agency's ability to regulate drilling muds as hazardous wastes. These have been implemented as additional protections from drilling excesses. ?????* Reducing taxes for the oil and gas industries by such changes as restoring the write-off of intangible drilling costs for passive investors, eliminating the "onerous alternative minimum tax" and raising depletion allowance provisions to previously high levels. ?????* Opening portions of the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge to oil drilling as President Bush has urged. Hobbs argued that most of the land to actually be used for drilling is swampland, not caribou grazing territory. ?????"We must assure the public that we have the energy resources to meet the demand and that these resources can indeed be developed in a responsible manner in environmentally sensitive areas of the Rocky Mountains, the north slope of Alaska, the eastern Gulf of Mexico and the Pacific and Atlantic outer continental shelf," Hobbs said. ?????A resident of Connecticut, he said, "I frankly don't want oil washing up on my family's beach, but I'm prepared to take that risk to help resolve the nation's energy problems." ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ----------------------------------------------- Tuesday, April 10, 2001 Give Power Buyers a Club in Cartel Wars By MICHAEL SHAMES, PETER NAVARRO ?????Last week, Gov. Gray Davis proclaimed that conservation and new energy supplies will allow California to make it through this summer without additional rate increases. On Monday, he announced a "sweetheart deal" to save one of the state's largest utilities even as the other slunk behind the protection of a bankruptcy court. ?????In fact, none of these actions will change this basic reality: An unscrupulous "seller's cartel" now manipulating California's electricity market is likely to make this summer unbearable. This cartel consists of the major companies controlling most of the uncommitted electric generation and natural gas transmission contracts in the Western United States. ?????To fight this cartel, we propose a plan with a stiffer backbone--a hard-nosed "buyers' cartel" and, if necessary, the forced purchase of in-state generating plants. Failing such actions, Californians face a blackout-riddled summer with a potential electricity bill of nearly $50 billion. ?????The governor's plan to beat the sellers' cartel is built on too many "ifs": If the West escapes a hot summer, if the increasingly unreliable power plants suffer no outages, if 20% conservation gains materialize, if there's enough natural gas to fuel new plants, if the cartel doesn't withhold supply. ?????Failing any one of these "ifs," and with forecasts warning of Stage 3 alerts that could stretch a full six months, the sellers' cartel would gorge as it never has before. Wholesale prices could double or triple from already exorbitant rates of 25 and 50 cents per kilowatt-hour to a dollar or more. This power costs no more than 15 cents to produce. ?????Unfortunately, Davis' strategy to negotiate long-term power contracts does little to reduce California's short-run vulnerability. Most contracts don't even begin until 2002. President Bush and federal regulators could end this crisis tomorrow by imposing hard price caps and ordering the cartel to supply power to the market. They have steadfastly refused. The results are staggering. ?????The sellers' cartel first took utility shareholders on a $13-billion ride to insolvency. After bleeding them dry, it was the taxpayers' turn. Indeed, after state government took over purchasing power in January, California's healthy budget surplus dropped by more than $5 billion. This led the Public Utilities Commission to approve the largest rate hike in California history. ?????However, if the governor's "Hail Mary" strategy fails, we project additional rate hikes of 100% or more. To avert this disaster, we propose that California join with the other "victim states" of Oregon and Washington to form a "buyers' cartel"--in essence, a buyers'-side monopsony to fight the sellers' price-fixing oligopoly. ?????In particular, we propose offering a "fair price" to the sellers' cartel, but not a penny more. This fair price would be cost-based--not market driven--and calculated daily on natural gas prices and other factors. It would include a generous profit margin to ensure sufficient incentives for investment in the Western market and result in an average price of 15 to 20 cents. ?????As an ancillary weapon, California must force the sale of all in-state plants owned by any member of the sellers' cartel refusing to provide ample power at the fair price. Under a declared state of emergency, the state has the authority to purchase the plants at reasonable prices, and they can be run by qualified utility operators. ?????Forming a buyers' cartel will almost certainly spark retaliatory blackouts as the sellers test the political will of our legislators and governor. To prepare, we must end highly disruptive random rolling blackouts. Instead, divide the states into identifiable blackout zones and, with sufficient notice, flip switches off as need be. The benefits to businesses and residents of knowing when the power will be turned off are considerable. Increased crime risks can be offset by targeted police deployment. ?????The state should also buy literally truckloads of new, efficient air conditioners. Utility employees, youth groups and other volunteers must move systematically through the hot valley spots throughout the California offering to replace old air conditioners--our Achilles' heel during the summer time peak. ?????On the energy supply front, the state should continue its effort to build emergency power plant capacity far from population centers but near the transmission grid--no-frill plants built quickly. There will be no better weapon against the cartel than standing reserves. ?????We do not understate the challenge of staring down a group of well-financed energy companies. There are no other reasonable options, and the stakes are too important to succumb to the generators' "rolling blackmail." - - - Michael Shames Is the Executive Director of the Utility Consumers' Action Network. Peter Navarro Is a Business Professor at Uc Irvine. This Article Is Based on a More Comprehensive Ucan Report Available at Www.ucan.org ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------- State's Financial Exposure Is a Growing Worry DAILY LOSSES: Experts say fiscal stability at risk Christian Berthelsen, Lynda Gledhill, Chronicle Staff Writers Tuesday, April 10, 2001 ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle URL: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/chronicle/archive/2001/04/10/M N161819.DTL California's financial exposure to the energy crisis continues to grow, causing government and finance experts to question how long the state can keep pace. A spokesman for Gov. Gray Davis said yesterday that California's bill for energy purchases will increase by upward of $8 million a day after a ruling last week by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission. The unexpected rise could push the state's daily electricity tab to as high as $58 million. Coupled with a negative credit report issued late last week, the federal ruling spells trouble for the state as it continues to stand in for the bankrupt utility Pacific Gas and Electric Co. and buy high-priced, open-market electricity, according to state officials and financial experts. "The state is taking a loss right now in spending this money," said Sandy Harrison, a spokesman for the state's Department of Finance. "It's a significant loss. The state is paying much more than it's receiving in return." Since the state government stepped in as the power buyer of record in January to help California's ailing utilities, the financial community has become increasingly concerned. Moody's Investors Service put the state on negative credit watch Friday, which could lead to a possible credit-rating downgrade. In a letter, Moody's said that the deepening financial crisis, compounded by PG&E's bankruptcy filing, "has increased the risks to the state's otherwise strong fiscal and economic condition" and that steps so far have been inadequate -- including the state's attempts to buy low-cost power on long- term contracts, leaving it reliant on sky-high spot market prices. "The spot market price has remained very high and is likely to continue to be so for the remainder of this year, increasing the risk that the state's financial exposure will persist beyond the period previously expected," the letter said. 1 STATE REQUIRED TO Pay The Energy Regulatory Commission's order -- released late Friday afternoon - - could make matters worse. It requires the state to pay for all the electricity it has been buying on the expensive spot market. The California Independent System Operator, a nonprofit organization that oversees the state's power system, has been balking at paying for some of those purchases and has been passing the bill along to utilities. On Friday, the commission ruled that because the utilities are broke, the state must pay for the electricity itself. The state estimates that cost at $8 million daily. "It's amazing how quickly FERC can act when it will cost Californian ratepayers more, but how slow they are to bring relief," said Davis spokesman Steve Maviglio. On a daily basis, PG&E is paying California the retail rate for power it sells to its customers, and it has passed on some $110 million to the state so far, the utility said yesterday. But that is, obviously, much less than what the state is paying to buy the power. Through the California Department of Water Resources, the state has spent more than $4 billion on electricity since January. Moody's downgrade came as the state continues to pursue a bond measure of as much as $14 billion to repay the general fund for money it has already spent buying electricity and to cover the cost of those payments into the future. But at current rates, state officials acknowledge, even that much money would not last long -- perhaps not even the year. The state treasurer, Phil Angelides, doesn't favor securing more debt if it will not fix the core problem of spiraling prices. "It is very possible that continued borrowing for DWR purchases might only delay by a matter of months the reality of runaway energy prices which generators have imposed on California," Angelides said in a letter to Davis last week. LOOK FOR LONG-TERM SOLUTION Matt Freedman, of The Utility Reform Network, a consumer advocacy group, said the state should not be looking for a quick exit but should build on its beginnings as an electricity buyer to slowly create a state power authority. The sale of bonds would spread out payment of the huge costs of short-term purchases on the wholesale market through the rest of the year. Meanwhile, the state can help finance construction of new power plants with commitments to sell electricity to the state at reasonable rates. Prices should drop as long- term contracts negotiated by the state start to kick in and new power plants come online. "This is a positive vision," Freedman said. "This is the opposite of looking at it as a morass." But as the ratings agencies see it, California's financial situation has given them little to be positive about. STATE ON NEGATIVE WATCH Standard & Poors, another credit rating agency, placed the state on negative watch in January shortly after it entered the agreement with PG&E to become power procurer of record. Their reasoning at the time indicated a belief -- which the agency still appears to hold, since the negative watch has not been removed -- that California has no exit strategy from a deepening quagmire. "First of all, it seemed like an open-ended commitment, and we didn't know when it would end or what the cost would be ultimately," said David Hitchcock, the agency's chief California analyst. "Secondly, we didn't know what the effect on the state economy would be with the blackouts. The reasoning still holds now more than ever." The ruling by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission will just make matters worse, Maviglio said. The cost of buying electricity will rise substantially during periods of high demand in summer unless the state fights rulings last week by a federal appeals court and the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, Maviglio said. No decisions have been made on appeals. . DAILY GRIND The state's tab to keep the lights is heading above $50 million per day. By comparison, here's how much the state spends per day in other areas: . Grants for high-tech crime task forces and a crackdown on identity theft: 30,000 . Funding for a new, aggressive anti-smoking campaign targeting teenagers and college-aged young people: $55,000 . An incentive program to attract and retain qualified algebra teachers and prepare students for the new algebra requirement: $82,000 . Commitment to the war on methamphetamine: $110,000 . Coastal access and restoration: $137,000 . Program to Support and encourage development of Zero Emission Vehicles: $137,000 . Health coverage for 290,000 working parents through the Healthy Families program: $208,000 . Local law enforcement equipment grants: $205,000 . Source: State Budget Chronicle staff writer Bernadette Tansey contributed to this report. / E-mail Christian Berthelsen at cberthelsen@sfchronicle.com Lynda Gledhill at lgledhill@sfchronicle.com. ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle ? Page?A - 1 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ --------------------------------------------------------------- Davis Seals Power Deal With Edison to Buy Lines 10-YEAR PACT: $2.76 billion swap buys low-cost electricity David Lazarus, Chronicle Staff Writer Tuesday, April 10, 2001 ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle URL: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/chronicle/archive/2001/04/10/M N162790.DTL Gov. Gray Davis and Southern California Edison reached final agreement yesterday on a $2.8 billion bailout deal that includes the state taking possession of the utility's 12,000 miles of power lines. As part of the accord, Edison will provide low-cost power to the state for 10 years and drop a lawsuit asking for full recovery of past electricity costs. For California, restoring Edison to financial health represents an important step toward stabilizing the state's dysfunctional energy market. But with Pacific Gas and Electric Co. pursuing bankruptcy protection, the state's two largest utilities are now traveling completely different roads, and it remains to be seen what effect this will have on consumers. Announcement of the Edison deal came just hours after PG&E's first bankruptcy hearing was held in a San Francisco courtroom. PG&E filed for Chapter 11 protection Friday after deciding its own bailout talks with the governor were going nowhere. "This is a historic moment," Davis said at a Los Angeles news conference yesterday. "This is a good deal for consumers of the state." PG&E PROBLEMS However, critics said it is unclear how much things have improved without PG&E's participation in a statewide accord. "It's like buying a car with only three wheels," said Doug Heller, a spokesman for the Foundation for Taxpayer and Consumer Rights in Santa Monica. "It doesn't get you anywhere." Davis again chided PG&E for having paid out $50 million in bonuses and raises to employees before filing for bankruptcy, as reported by The Chronicle on Saturday. He called the action "arrogant and selfish." "But if they come back to the bargaining table, we'll offer them the same agreement," Davis said. PG&E said in a statement last night that a deal with the state is positive for Edison, "given its set of facts." "Given our set of facts, we continue to believe that a Chapter 11 reorganization is the most feasible means to reach a solution," it said. The governor and Edison reached a tentative pact on the bailout deal in late February. Subsequent weeks were spent settling on the fine print. Parallel talks with PG&E produced no results -- a point that Davis repeatedly implied yesterday was the fault of the Northern California utility rather than his own negotiators. "If you walk away from the table, nothing gets done," the governor said. "If you stay at the table, good things do and will get done." The agreement still requires approval from the state Public Utilities Commission and the Legislature. Among the terms of the Edison deal: -- The utility will receive $2.8 billion from the state in return for its transmission network. This is more than twice the network's book value. -- Edison will provide low-cost power to California for the next 10 years. The rates have yet to be determined. -- The utility will drop a federal lawsuit that attempted to force state regulators to allow recovery of about $5 billion in power debts. EDISON UPGRADES Moreover, Edison will invest $3 billion into upgrading distribution lines that connect with the newly purchased transmission network. The company will retain possession of the distribution lines, which run from transmission hubs to customers' homes. The utility also committed to new environmental-protection measures affecting more than 21,000 acres of land near its dams. "A negotiated, practical, comprehensive resolution is far preferable to bankruptcy," said John Bryson, chairman of Edison International, parent of the Southern California utility. "We have achieved a practical approach that is preferable to years of litigation," agreed Steve Frank, Edison's chief executive. Edison will issue at least $2 billion in bonds to help pay off its debts. Bondholders will be paid off by a surcharge tacked onto the bills of Edison customers. PG&E customers will be unaffected. LEGISLATIVE SCRUTINY "We need to find out how much of this back debt is really the responsibility of the ratepayers," said Senate President Pro Tem John Burton, D-San Francisco. "The devil is in the details," he said. "We're going to have very, very thorough hearings on it and find out how much it costs the ratepayers." Assemblyman Fred Keeley, D-Boulder Creek, hailed the fact that Edison has committed itself to provide power to the state at bargain-basement rates. "Not having the whole transmission system is not as good as having the entire system," he noted. "But it is an asset of substantial value that would be in the hands of ratepayers, and that's positive." However, Heller at the Foundation for Taxpayer and Consumer Rights said any lawmaker who supports the Edison deal "is a turncoat." If it is granted legislative approval, he threatened to undo the accord with a future ballot initiative. "Gray Davis gave away the store," he said. "This is a complete and unadulterated bailout of Edison." "It's way too rich," said Nettie Hoge, executive director of The Utility Reform Network in San Francisco. "It makes PG&E look like a fool for going to bankruptcy court when you can get everything you want from the governor." Davis said his negotiators would have preferred working at a more leisurely pace but scrambled to get the deal done as quickly as possible once PG&E filed its bankruptcy papers. "This transaction kept people up until 5 this morning," he said. The agreement was approved by Edison's board yesterday afternoon. SAN DIEGO NEGOTIATIONS Davis said he hopes to begin negotiating with San Diego Gas & Electric for its power lines today, and is "very optimistic" that a second accord will be negotiated in short order. He still has his eye on PG&E's transmission system, although it will be up to Bankruptcy Judge Dennis Montali to decide whether any of the utility's assets will be placed up for sale. "One way or another, we hope to get all three lines," the governor said. . EDISON STRIKES A DEAL What's at stake for the major players in the energy cruch: -- -- Edison: Southern California Edison receives $2.8 billion for its power lines and has customers pay for at least $2 billion in bonds. This will restore the utility to creditworthiness and allow it to borrow money to pay off outstanding debts. -- The governor: Gov. Gray Davis can claim progress in solving California's energy woes after PG&E filed for bankruptcy last week. It is unclear, however, how purchasing Edison's power lines will improve things if PG&E refuses to sell its lines as well. -- PG&E: The utility is largely unaffected by Edison's deal with the state. However, PG&E still may be forced to part with its power network if the bankruptcy court decides to place the company's assets up for sale. -- Consumers: California consumers will benefit from Edison's commitment to provide low-cost electricity to the state for 10 years. However, Edison customers face higher electricity bills to help pay for the deal. Chronicle Graphic Chronicle staff writer Greg Lucas contributed to this story. / E-mail David Lazarus at dlazarus@sfchronicle.com. ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle ? Page?A - 1 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ --------------------------------------------------------------- PG&E Stumps Math Whizzes GO FIGURE: Who knows how much this will cost us? Steve Rubenstein, Chronicle Staff Writer Tuesday, April 10, 2001 ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle URL: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/chronicle/archive/2001/04/10/M N159853.DTL Mathematics, the PG&E kind, came to a San Jose classroom yesterday, and utility bills turned out to be even more complicated than Euclidean geometry. "This," said a kid, "is tough stuff." Two dozen of the brightest math whizzes in California struggled for an hour to figure out exactly what the giant utility is up to with its all-new rate plan, its all-new bankruptcy and its four-page utility bills full of such stuff as CTCs, TTAs and PPPs. When the third-period honors math class at Joaquin Miller Middle School was over, two plus two seemed to equal whatever PG&E says it does. In recent days, Pacific Gas and Electric Co. announced that rates were going up and that baseline amounts -- the cheapest electricity offered -- were going down. It also announced it was bankrupt, but not too bankrupt to pay $50 million worth of bonuses to 6,000 employees. Students were invited to bring their family's utility bills to class and attempt to calculate, using PG&E's formula charts, how much the bills would increase. A lot of pencil points broke in the process. Oreo, a black-and-white rabbit who is the class mascot, took one look at the charts, thumped his foot and scampered for cover beneath a desk. "I really did not understand it," Heather Chou, 12, said after punching her calculator buttons. "It would be easier if your mom or dad was from PG&E," said Harry Jiang, 11. "I found the rate tier and multiplied my total by the rate per kilowatt hour," Brian Huh, 11, said. "This was complicating." A typical bill charges up to four different prices for the same electricity, depending on whether -- and by how much -- it exceeds the so-called baseline amount. Those prices are changing. The number of rate tiers is changing. And the baseline amounts are changing. Go figure. Deciphering a typical bill involves dozens of calculations. And that is not counting the myriad mysterious charges such as Public Purpose Programs (PPP), Competition Transition Charge (CTC) and Trust Transfer Amount (TTA), along with transmission and distribution fees, that cling to every bill the way Oreo's fur clings to a student's fleece pullover. The only easy things to calculate, the students of Room 34 said, were the bonuses paid out by the company the day before it filed for bankruptcy. You divide $50 million worth of bonuses by 6,000 PG&E managers, 11-year-old Diane Ngo said. What you get is $8,333, the amount of bonus that each manager gets. "I don't think PG&E is really bankrupt," she added. "I think they're just scared about the economy and are trying to worry the government and the public. " "I think that PG&E is actually not bankrupt because they're making more money now," said Jonathan Ou, 11. "I also think that PG&E is messing up the government." "They just want to keep a whole ton of money," Heather Chou said, "so they can get rich." If figuring the bonuses was easy, the hard part was figuring out how a bankrupt company can afford to pay them. Not even Miller students, who scored higher than all other middle school students in the Bay Area in last year's Stanford 9 math test, could make sense of that. When third period ended, only Oreo had failed to find the problem exhausting. Teacher Lise Stull called the calculation challenging, even though her students routinely spend their days tinkering with quadratic equations, polyhedrons, plane geometry and the scourge known as fractions. And an assistant principal said the problem looked like a handful. He declined to pick up a pencil. "If the average person tried it," Stull said. "it would be extremely difficult." E-mail Steve Rubenstein at srubenstein@sfchronicle.com. ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle ? Page?A - 1 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ --------------------------------------------------------------- PG&E Moves Quickly to Involve Federal Court in State's Crisis Strategy could allow judge to authorize David Lazarus, Chronicle Staff Writer Tuesday, April 10, 2001 ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle URL: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/chronicle/archive/2001/04/10/M N199730.DTL San Francisco -- Pacific Gas and Electric Co. wasted no time at its first bankruptcy hearing yesterday in attempting to force the federal court to intervene in a state regulatory matter. The move, which provoked a clash with state lawyers, indicated that part of the San Francisco utility's legal strategy over months of bankruptcy proceedings will be to establish the federal court's authority over state issues. PG&E wants the bankruptcy court to have such authority so it can order an increase in consumers' rates and permit the utility to recoup about $9 billion in debt, lawyers said. "This was a way to test the judge's attitude," said Gary Cohen, general counsel for the California Public Utilities Commission. If so, Bankruptcy Judge Dennis Montali offered no hint of how he feels about his potential role in sending consumers' bills through the roof. He instructed the two sides to work out a compromise themselves. If they could not, Montali said, he would take up the matter this afternoon. PG&E filed for bankruptcy protection on Friday after deciding that months of bailout talks with Gov. Gray Davis were on the verge of collapse. The first hearing in what promises to be a long, complex and frequently tedious process clearly illustrated that California's energy mess has entered a new phase. SPARRING OVER SMALL POINTS Legal jargon has replaced protesters' chants as the lingua franca of debate, and the players now uniformly wear blue or gray suits, and eagerly spar over the most microscopic of points. The change in tone was made evident when consumer activist Medea Benjamin, who was thrown out of recent PUC meetings for leading boisterous protests, approached the podium yesterday and said she wanted to address the bankruptcy court. Montali, who was in the middle of scheduling future actions with PG&E's attorneys, looked amazed that Benjamin had spoken out of turn. "I'd like to read an open letter to you," she said. "You've interrupted me," the judge replied with an icy glare. "Now go back and sit down." Benjamin promptly retreated to her seat. TECHNICAL TERMS Much of the bankruptcy hearing was peppered with technical terms like "cross collateralization" and "postpetition liens," and most nonlawyers in the courtroom gazed on with blank expressions. "A number of people, after seeing how boring this is, may not want to come back," PG&E lawyer James Lopes joked at one point. The only fireworks came when a PG&E lawyer, Jerome Falk, requested that Montali issue a temporary restraining order to block a recent PUC decision concerning the utility's accounting methods. The accounting change, which the PUC voted on in March, effectively reduced the amount of debt PG&E can claim to have accrued as a result of runaway wholesale power costs -- a total the utility says is about $9 billion. Cohen and another PUC lawyer, Alan Kornberg, immediately jumped up and insisted that there was no need for the bankruptcy judge to intervene in the matter. PUC MAY EXTEND DEADLINE They said the PUC was prepared to extend its deadline for PG&E to file related paperwork, thus making federal intervention unnecessary. Outside the courtroom afterward, Cohen made clear that the PUC will act to block any attempt by PG&E to give Montali jurisdiction over state regulatory affairs, especially rate setting. "The bankruptcy in no way affects the PUC's regulatory authority over PG&E, " he said. "It is our understanding that there is no precedent for a bankruptcy judge to raise rates." Legal experts are divided on this point. Some say federal law supersedes state law, but others say a bankruptcy judge has no power to force a state agency to raise electricity prices. However, many experts believe that if Montali decides consumers' rates must be increased to pay off PG&E's debts, the PUC may willingly decide to go along. E-mail David Lazarus at dlazarus@sfchronicle.com. ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle ? Page?A - 9 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ --------------------------------------------------------------- Going Dark Extra Day to Save Power San Mateo County tries to cut costs Mark Simon Tuesday, April 10, 2001 ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle URL: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/chronicle/archive/2001/04/10/M NS23191.DTL San Mateo County will shut down one of its buildings an extra day every week next month as an energy-saving measure that officials hope will prove contagious. The building, a five-story, 116,000-square-foot facility in the county's four-building government complex in Redwood City, will be closed every Friday starting May 4. The 400 employees in the building will go to a four-day, 10-hour-a-day workweek. Hours of business at the building will be extended from the current 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. schedule to a 7 a.m. to 7 p.m. schedule. The four-day week will be in place for at least a year, after which its effectiveness and its effect on public services will be assessed, said Supervisor Mike Nevin, who proposed the once-a-week shutdown. Closing the building for an extra day per week should reduce the building's energy usage by 17.5 percent, said Nevin. The county should save at least $80,000 in electricity and energy costs the first year. Nevin hinted broadly that the state's Department of Real Estate ought to take the hint and look for ways it can shut down portions of its vast statewide complex of office buildings. The county building houses planning, parks and recreation and personnel departments -- all of them nonemergency entities, Nevin said. The public most frequently uses the Planning Department, and the principal customers are contractors asking for approval of building plans. They're likely to benefit from the expanded-hours schedule, which allows them to go to county offices early or late in the day, Nevin said. Meanwhile, county employees appear enthusiastic about eliminating one day from their commute schedule, he said. "They cross two bridges today and they come from 100 miles away," Nevin said. "You're taking the employees off the freeway one day a week, reducing the pollution and making their quality of life better." ON THE CIRCUIT: The 2001-02 lineup for the 12th season of the Peninsula Lecture Series in San Mateo contains the usual list of people it would be fun to hear. But the list also carries with it a subtle ethical question. The eight speakers include "60 Minutes" mainstay Mike Wallace, former Secretary of State Madeleine Albright, former Interior Secretary Bruce Babbitt, TV documentarian Ken Burns, comedy king Carl Reiner, columnist and TV commentator Mark Shields, Fox News talk-show host Bill O'Reilly, and NPR legal affairs correspondent Nina Totenberg. The series begins Sept. 5 with Totenberg. Tickets for the entire series are $330 for reserved seating, $230 for open seating. For information, call (650) 348-0820. Last year's series was a sell-out and there's no reason to think that won't happen again, and soon. The subtle ethical question arises in the fact that four of participants are journalists. There long has been criticism when journalists accept speaking fees to appear before organizations they cover. But aside from the lapse in objectivity that might arise from speaking to a group, there remains the larger question whether journalists should be paid for pontificating, when it's their job to listen to the pontificators. LOVE ON THE COASTSIDE: They're not exactly San Mateo County's official sweethearts, but Controller Tom Huening and former business leader Denise de Ville have had one of the longer engagements. They are engaged no more. On March 31, they tied the knot at a private ceremony at the Ritz-Carlton Hotel in Half Moon Bay, the first wedding at the hotel. They also honeymooned overnight at the hotel, making them among the first guests there. The day they spent there included a visit to what Huening called "the Roman baths" and some time in the chairs overlooking the ocean. Then it was back to work on Monday for both of them -- Huening to his job as county controller and de Ville to the consulting business she began a year ago after leaving her post as chief executive officer of a Peninsula business lobbying organization. Asked if it wasn't a short honeymoon, Huening said, "We're going to defer and take a number of honeymoons over the next 40 years." Huening and de Ville became engaged in 1998, making theirs a betrothal that lasted more than two years. "The controller is a very careful person," Huening said. Actually, de Ville has a teenage son who was preparing for college and she wanted to focus on that before getting married, Huening said. It was noted that if they had waited a day, they could have been married on April Fool's Day. "We thought it would be pushing our luck," said Huening. Simon can be seen 7:30 p.m. Fridays on The Chronicle's "Peninsula This Week" on cable Channel 26, and at other times on local access channels. You can reach him at (650) 299-8071, by fax at (650) 299-9208, or e-mail at msimon@sfchronicle.com. Write him c/ ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle ? Page?A - 15 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ --------------------------------------------------------------- Davis forges deal to rescue Edison Posted at 10:45 p.m. PDT Monday, April 9, 2001 BY JOHN WOOLFOLK, CHRIS DEVALL AND CHRIS O'BRIEN Mercury News On the heels of Pacific Gas & Electric Co.'s bankruptcy filing, Gov. Gray Davis announced Monday that the state has reached a $2.76 billion deal to prop up the state's other major utility by buying Southern California Edison's transmission wires. The deal, which still needs legislative and regulatory approval, would avert another embarrassing utility bankruptcy and would give the state its first piece of hardware in its bid to assume more control over the chaotic electrical system. The announcement came just three days after PG&E, blaming a broken political process, filed for bankruptcy, adding a new dimension to the deregulation debacle. Davis and PG&E executives have traded bitter accusations ever since. On Monday, Davis said PG&E ``has acted arrogantly and selfishly,'' but heaped praise on Edison. ``This is a clear example of the good that can come when parties are responsible, resolute and remain at the bargaining table,'' he said. But the complex deal drew fire from consumer advocates and lawmakers, who labeled it a costly bailout and questioned whether it would solve the state's energy problems. PG&E, reluctant to part with its own high-voltage wires, vowed Monday to press on in bankruptcy court, complicating the state's plans to buy the whole grid. Some experts, however, said the Edison deal could strengthen the state's hand in any effort to acquire PG&E's wires through court proceedings. ``PG&E no longer has the ability to say yes or no to a deal,'' said David Huard, an energy regulatory expert at the Manatt, Phelps & Phillips law firm in Los Angeles. ``It's now up to a bankruptcy court. The state now has the ability to work with a judge who has no preconceived notions of what the company should look like when it comes out of bankruptcy.'' The Edison deal largely mirrored a conceptual agreement Davis announced Feb. 23. Neither he nor Edison officials explained what took so long to complete the deal to buy Edison's transmission wires for a price that is 2.3 times their assessed value. Other details Also under the proposal: ?Edison will sell the nuclear and hydroelectric power it generates to the state at rates based on production costs for 10 years. The utility's parent company will also provide all 500 megawatts from its new Sunrise power plant to the state at similar rates for 10 years. ?Edison's parent will give the utility $400 million from a tax refund. ?Edison will grant the state conservation easements on more than 21,000 acres of watershed surrounding its dams. ?And Edison will drop lawsuits seeking to lift state control over its rates. Both Davis and Edison officials acknowledged PG&E's filing Friday for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection added urgency to firm up the deal. ``These were tough negotiations, but they've produced a good, balanced deal,'' Davis said, calling it ``a major step in the right direction.'' Edison International CEO John E. Bryson said the deal was a better alternative than years of litigation in bankruptcy court. ``This negotiated resolution with the governor is far preferable for our company and our employees and for our customers than is going into bankruptcy,'' he said. Edison serves 4.3 million customers. The Davis administration began negotiating to buy transmission wires from PG&E, Edison and San Diego Gas & Electric in January in a bid to keep them out of bankruptcy and stabilize the state's electricity market. Edison and PG&E have teetered on bankruptcy since last fall because they have paid some $13 billion more for wholesale power than they are allowed to charge customers under their state-frozen rates. San Diego Gas & Electric is similarly troubled. Together, the utilities serve some 10 million customers. But PG&E had been reluctant to sell the transmission wires, and talks with the state had been deadlocked for weeks. PG&E has declined to explain its opposition. On Friday, a day after Davis delivered a historic televised announcement in which he assured the public a resolution was soon at hand, PG&E rebuffed the governor by taking its case to bankruptcy court. ``Given our set of facts, we continue to believe that a Chapter 11 reorganization is the most feasible means to reach a solution,'' PG&E said Monday in a prepared statement. ``We will proceed at the direction of the bankruptcy court.'' Consumer groups criticized the proposed Edison deal as a bailout. Nettie Hoge, executive director of The Utility Reform Network, said the state is getting too little for its money. She had hoped the agreement would include tighter restrictions on sales of Edison assets and on the amount of profits the utility could earn. ``It's way, way too rich,'' Hoge said. ``We can't afford it. It's like a fun house mirror. You stare at it long enough and the distortion becomes apparent.'' Even some of Davis' allies in the Democrat-controlled Legislature agreed. Senator critical In a prepared statement, Sen. Debra Bowen, D-Redondo Beach, said she was disturbed that the deal might mean that generators could be paid for overcharging the utilities. ``It sounds like the plan puts ratepayers on the hook for 100 percent of the rates charged by the power generators -- rates that even FERC found to be unjust and unreasonable,'' she said. And Bowen, like other lawmakers, questioned whether a deal based on buying transmission wires still make sense. ``There may be some value in having the state own the entire transmission grid, but it's not clear to me what the benefit is to ratepayers if the state is only acquiring a quarter of it,'' Bowen said. One Democratic legislator said some lawmakers believe the governor, after being publicly humiliated by PG&E, may have been so eager to come to an agreement with Edison that he was too generous. For that reason, lawmakers will probably hold detailed hearings on the different provisions to ensure they protect the interests of California consumers and the state. But Assembly Speaker Pro Tem Fred Keeley, D-Santa Cruz, said the agreement ``was very consistent'' with the briefing the governor's staff gave to Assembly Democrats recently. Rated positive ``I think it's a positive turn of events,'' he said. ``It raises the likelihood that the state will submit a plan to the bankruptcy court that would mirror, in principle, the agreement reached with Edison.'' Power generators, owed billions by the utilities for electricity, said they needed more time to assess the deal. Edison says it owes $5.5 billion for power. The deal would bring Edison $3.5 billion from selling the wires and issuing bonds that would be repaid by ratepayers. The utility would have come up with the rest from its own profits. Jan Smutny-Jones, executive director of the Independent Energy Producers Association, said that with PG&E in bankruptcy and Edison agreeing to the deal, ``it's not clear how it all fits together.'' Mercury News staff writers Brandon Bailey and Hallye Jordan contributed to this report. Contact John Woolfolk at jwoolfolk@sjmercury.com or (408) 278-3410. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ --------------- Solar tech shines in market struggling with power problems California's power crisis couldn't have come at a better time for solar energy. The cost of producing solar power has been plummeting. The market for photovoltaics, or solar cells, is growing like gangbusters -- 44 percent last year alone. And promising new technologies under development for decades are just now coming online. Solar panels are showing up in unexpected places. The canopies over new BP gas stations consist of semitransparent solar modules. Cars in four Sacramento parking lots are shaded by photovoltaic-studded structures. Hundreds of buildings in California alone are shingled with solar roof tiles. Soon, scientists say, solar cells will be an integral and virtually unnoticed part of many buildings: Think windows that generate juice while providing a view. These are not wild dreams. The technology is out there now. And with it, researchers say, there is now a realistic possibility that solar energy could supply a substantial part of the nation's energy needs. ``I think people are going to be surprised by photovoltaics,'' said Ken Zweibel, a program manager at the National Renewable Energy Laboratory in Boulder, Colo. ``The 20 years of waiting for it to happen has caused people to take a jaundiced view. But it's the most real of the alternative technologies, in my opinion.'' At the same time, there is grave concern that the federal government will sharply reduce its support for solar -- funding that has played a key role in developing these technologies and making them increasingly more efficient and competitive. President Bush's budget proposal, released Monday, calls for a 54 percent cut in solar research and development. Solar is still a tiny part of the current energy market. Solar modules sold worldwide last year have the capacity to put out only 252 megawatts of electricity -- enough for up to 252,000 homes. That's a drop in the bucket of world energy consumption. But even before the current energy crisis, sales of solar modules had started to soar as demand grew overseas, said Bob Johnson, an analyst with Strategies Unlimited, a market research firm in Mountain View. Sales grew 38 percent in 1997, 18 percent in 1998, 30 percent in 1999 and 44 percent last year: ``That was a barnburner,'' Johnson said. They're expected to increase 30 percent to 40 percent this year. With the energy crisis, and the resulting sharp increase in the price of electricity, solar is suddenly more attractive, and companies that produce the cells can't keep up. Of the 55 companies now making solar cells, the biggest producers are BP Solar, which is starting to manufacture an innovative photovoltaic film at a plant in Fairfield, and Kyocera Solar of Japan. ``Supposedly we have an order for everything we can make here through the end of the year,'' said Douglas Skinner, manager of BP Solar's Fairfield plant, which is scheduled to start production in May. When the plant is in full swing, he said, it will produce 120,000 solar panels a year, each 2 by 5 feet, that generate 10 megawatts of power -- enough for up to 10,000 homes. There are plans to double that rate, Skinner said: ``Given the way demand is going up, I think everyone would like it to be sooner rather than later, let's put it that way.'' Cheap, simple The type of photovoltaic cell made there is known as ``thin film,'' a cheap and simple alternative to the silicon cells that dominate the market. Some experts think this is the technology of the future. Traditional cells are based on wafers of pure, crystalline silicon -- the same stuff that underlies most integrated circuits. They convert 12 percent to 14 percent of incoming sunlight into electricity. But the wafers are expensive. In contrast, thin films are based on cheap materials, such as ordinary window glass. Layers of semiconducting material are deposited on the glass, along with compounds that block or conduct electricity. Then lasers cut the film into individual cells and carve conductive channels to carry the flow of electrons through the film and into a circuit. The active layer in the film BP makes is cadmium telluride -- chosen because its electrons are readily knocked out of place by the exact wavelengths of sunlight that are most intense at the Earth's surface. Once bumped out of position, they're free to flow as current. Because the films are just 1/2,500th of an inch thick -- more than 100 times thinner than conventional silicon cells -- the cost of materials is low. And the cells are connected within the film, eliminating the need to wire them together. So while these cells are less efficient at harvesting sunlight -- they grab 5 percent to 11 percent of it, depending on their composition -- they generate electricity at about the same cost as conventional silicon cells, Zweibel said. The goal is to cut that cost an additional 80 percent. Part of the building Dave Carlson, chief scientist for BP Solar in Linthicum, Md., said he thinks the biggest application for thin films will be in windows for buildings, based on pieces of glass up to 9 by 12 feet in size. Almost all large office windows now have reflective coatings that make them look somewhat gray, he said. Photovoltaic windows look about the same. ``The photovoltaics can just piggyback along,'' he said. ``The glass and the frame are free. They're already part of the structure. If you do it all right, the costs should be significantly lower'' than installing the two separately. The company is now putting photovoltaic windows in a building at the University of Wisconsin-Green Bay, Carlson said. Two firms, Atlantis Energy Systems in Sacramento and United Solar Systems Corp. of Troy, Mich., are making solar shingles. With 300 to 400 of these shingles on the south-facing side of its roof, the typical home can generate about 80 percent of its electrical needs, said Todor Galitev, chief of design and engineering for Atlantis. ``You can tell that they're different, but it is a very attractive roof and very pleasant,'' reflecting the color of the sky above, he said. Galitev added that solar roofing can often be financed as part of a mortgage. A typical home system costs $32,000. With subsidies -- the city of San Jose, for instance, offers buyers $4 per installed watt -- the cost drops to $18,000. When spread over a 30-year mortgage, the cost of generating electricity with the system is about 12 cents per kilowatt hour, comparable to today's utility rates. Gathering sunbeams Yet another approach is to concentrate sunlight into a powerful beam and focus it on solar cells, which can then harvest the light with greater efficiency. The technology was invented at Stanford University in the 1980s and, after years of development, is just now being deployed commercially, in a small solar power station in the remote mining town of Broken Hill, Australia. ``It's taken much longer to work the bugs out than anybody thought,'' said the inventor, Richard Swanson, now president of SunPower Corp. in Sunnyvale, which makes optical products. He said his concentrator arrays have a couple of advantages: They use relatively cheap mirrors to focus sunlight from a wide area onto a small group of solar cells. This cuts costs. And the solar cells, based on silicon wafers, could easily be manufactured by fabrication plants that are no longer adequate for making the latest generation of chips. But concentrators do have drawbacks: They are suitable only for large installations, not for back yards and rooftops. And because the mirrored dishes move to track the sun, they require more care than conventional solar panels, which are motionless and virtually maintenance-free. ``In practice, there are engineering issues that crop up in terms of being able to focus the sunlight on the cell, and doing it reliably. To my personal satisfaction, those problems have not been solved,'' said Terry Peterson, manager of solar power and green power marketing at the Electric Power Research Institute in Palo Alto, which funded much of the early research on concentrators. He added that he thinks the problems will be worked out. A second concentrator array, using a different approach that focuses light with lenses, was dedicated last week at Glendale Airport in Arizona. Built by Amonix Inc. of Torrance in partnership with Arizona Public Service, the state's largest utility, it will feed 100 kilowatts of power into the grid. Funds for more research Much of current photovoltaic research is focused on making current technologies more efficient and less costly. But the field needs a steady infusion of cash if it's to become a significant part of the energy mix, researchers say. And on some fronts, prospects are not good. The Bush budget proposal puts half of current federal funding for solar in jeopardy. Utilities nationwide have reduced their research funding by 60 percent. And investors, burned in the dot-com meltdown, are not necessarily eager to get involved. ``The question is how do we make the next jump from here to commercialization?'' asked Vijay Kapur, president of International Solar Electric Technology in Inglewood, which has developed a potentially cheaper way to make thin films. ``Let's face the facts,'' he said. ``Until recently, when the dot-com guys got busted, every investor was just totally mesmerized by the dot-com money. Energy has not been looked at as a very attractive sector for investment. ``That situation is changing with the California energy crisis now. People are coming to talk to us. Unfortunately, I have not succeeded yet in getting money on the table, but we are trying.'' ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------- Getting a line on electricity Published Tuesday, April 10, 2001, in the San Jose Mercury News THE state has a deal, but what does it mean? With an agreement between Southern California Edison and Gov. Gray Davis, one piece of the electrical solution Davis wants to construct has been put in place. Had the agreement to buy Edison's transmission lines for $2.76 billion been announced last week, it would have been a clear indicator of progress, at least as the governor defines it. Now, its effect is muddied by the bankruptcy filing on Friday of Pacific Gas & Electric. Davis has been pursuing a utility rescue plan that centers on buying the long-distance transmission lines from Edison, PG&E and San Diego Gas & Electric. The utilities are to take the proceeds from the sale and pay the bills they ran up as they were forced to buy electricity at rates well above the price at which they were allowed to resell it. But Pacific Gas & Electric Co. crossed the wires Friday when it filed for bankruptcy and broke off negotiations with the state, saying they were ``going nowhere.'' With the Edison deal, the state has an agreement to buy some of the high-voltage wires that carry electricity around the state. But much of the logic of the purchase, beyond assisting the utilities, was to bring the transmission system under one ownership, for efficiencies of financing and operation. PG&E's bankruptcy and its longstanding resistance to the sale make acquisition of the whole system a big question mark. Monday's announcement is merely a first step. Both the Public Utilities Commission and the Legislature must act if the deal is to go forward. The Legislature in particular needs to examine it. Is the $2.76 billion for the transmission system fair? Is the ``low-cost'' power that Edison is promising to provide for 10 years as good as it looks? No easy paths lead out of the thicket that the state finds itself in. A huge challenge remains in finding enough electricity to get through the summer without rolling blackouts. Without knowing what else is going to happen, it is impossible now to judge the importance of the deal to buy Edison's lines. Let's hope that two weeks from now we can look back and call it a first step in an encouraging direction. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ---------------- Price for gas surges again Published Tuesday, April 10, 2001, in the San Jose Mercury News BY GARY RICHARDS Mercury News If you thought record-setting gas prices last fall were a shock, brace yourself again. Prices reached as high as $2.09 a gallon at some stations in Silicon Valley on Monday, rising 12 to 15 cents within the past week with the promise of going even higher. ``Wow!'' exclaimed motorist Cathy Martin of San Jose, who last visited the pump a week ago and paid more than $2 a gallon at a Shell station near Great America. ``It's crazy, and I've got to get gas again this afternoon.'' Many discount stations are now topping $1.83 for a gallon of self-serve unleaded in the South Bay, and at $1.99 along the Peninsula. More expensive brands are just that, such as the Texaco station off Saratoga Avenue in Saratoga, where prices climbed 20 cents in little more than a week to $2.09 a gallon for the cheapest blend on Monday. The San Jose average is $1.92, while San Francisco is at $1.97, according to figures released Monday by the California State Automobile Association. That's 5 to 8 cents higher than a year ago, when prices began their march to a record $1.98 average in the Bay Area by Labor Day. Tight supplies, rising crude costs and the expectation that demand will increase with the approach of summer are factors behind the latest price surge, energy experts say. Those same factors caused the Department of Transportation last week to issue a warning that prices in the nation's largest urban areas may spike to California levels this summer. ``This is not a good time,'' said Jerry Cummings, president of Coast Oil, adding that production had slowed for planned and unplanned maintenance at Arco, Chevron, Valero and Texaco refineries from Washington state to Los Angeles. ``There are a lot of them having problems.'' Inventory down It's showing up on inventory counts. Stocks of reformulated gas were down more than 19 percent at California refineries as of March 30, a decline of nearly 100,000 barrels from a year ago, according to the California Energy Commission. This comes at a time state motorists are burning up more gas than ever. They consumed nearly 15 billion gallons in 2000, about 1 billion more than in 1999 and almost twice the annual increase since 1995. Refinery supplies nationwide have fallen in eight of the past nine weeks, the American Petroleum Institute said, leaving them 5 percent below levels a year ago. That's when pump prices reached higher than $2 a gallon in the Midwest. ``We are definitely going to see prices above $2 again, and soon,'' Pat Pitoon, owner of a Citgo service station in Chicago, told Bloomberg News Service. Refineries nationwide are shifting production to reformulated gas required by various states, contributing to a 7-cent-a-gallon price increase nationwide to $1.54 a gallon. Here's more bad news if you're waiting to fill up the sport utility vehicle: Crude oil that will arrive in the United States next month rose as much as 61 cents to $27.67 a barrel -- 10 percent higher than this time last year. While they're unsure of the timing, some experts expect crude prices to fall to $21, which could mean to an easing for local motorists. And a cooling economy might bring prices down as well. But a number of California refineries use natural gas in the production of automobile fuel, and the fear of rolling blackouts next month and higher energy bills may keep prices high. Renewed anxiety ``There's speculation that prices are going to go higher,'' said Brownwyn Hogan, who tracks fuel prices for the California auto club. ``And just talking about higher prices can sometimes keep prices high.'' Bay Area motorists -- perhaps numbed by paying the nation's highest prices for five years -- have been silent. There's been no Internet talk of boycotts, as in past years. But some are starting to pay attention. Nearly two dozen cars were lined up Sunday at an Arco station in Campbell to buy gas for $1.73 a gallon, spilling onto busy Campbell Avenue, where a few blocks away the price was $1.99 at a Shell station. By Monday, the price had risen 2 more cents at the Arco station. This time, there was no line, and Millie Williams of Campbell zipped in for a fill. ``This seems like a bargain compared to every place else,'' she said. Mercury News wire services contributed to this report. Contact Gary Richards at mrroadshow@sjmercury.com or (408) 920-5335. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ --------------------- Lawmakers to make plea for price cap Published Tuesday, April 10, 2001, in the San Jose Mercury News BY HALLYE JORDAN Mercury News Sacramento Bureau As federal energy regulators and Western power officials gather today in Idaho to discuss the region's critical energy shortage, three top California legislators plan to deliver an urgent plea for a two-year cap on wholesale electricity prices. Assembly Speaker pro Tem Fred Keeley, D-Santa Cruz, Speaker Robert Hertzberg, D-Van Nuys, and Rules Committee Chairman Dennis Cardoza, D-Turlock, will board a $20,000 charter jet before dawn today for the flight to Boise. Though the Bush administration has rejected price caps before, Keeley said the lawmakers are holding out hope for reconsideration because circumstances have changed. Since January, when the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission last turned down the caps, energy prices have continued to soar. In Boise on Monday, FERC Chairman Curt H,bert Jr. reiterated that he generally opposes price caps because there is no assurance they will be temporary. He also said they can lead power brokers to sell at the cap price, rather than lower, or drive them to other markets. But H,bert did stop short of flatly ruling out caps. ``I'm willing to consider anything filed before me, as I must,'' he said. ``I don't rule anything out. It's a very difficult time.'' H,bert, who has served on the federal commission since 1997 and been chairman since January, said he'll have a question for the California lawmakers: ``I'd like to ask them, other than a price cap, what do you want FERC to do?'' Keeley said the group has two goals during the meeting. ``One is to make sure FERC understands that we are doing quite a bit to resolve this issue ourselves,'' he said. ``But we also want to emphasize to them that this is a problem that is larger than California, and it exceeds state government's ability to resolve it on our own.'' Mercury News staff writer Eric Nalder contributed to this report. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- Edison, state strike deal If OKd, the company would sell power lines and drop a suit against California. April 10, 2001 By KATE BERRY The Orange County Register Southern California Edison reached a deal Monday with Gov. Gray Davis to sell its transmission lines to the state for $2.76 billion, allowing the utility to avert bankruptcy through a consumer-financed bailout. The deal would allow the state to take possession of Edison's 12,000-mile network of power lines at a price more than twice its book value. Edison would use that money and issue $2 billion in bonds to pay off about $5.4 billion in debt, which it accumulated by purchasing power at high prices that couldn't be passed on to consumers under a rate freeze. Both Edison- and state-issued bonds will be paid off by ratepayers via their electricity bills. The Legislature and state regulators must approve the agreement, reached three days after California's largest utility, Pacific Gas & Electric, rejected the governor's efforts to negotiate a rescue and filed for bankruptcy. "If you walk away from the table, nothing gets done," Davis said at a press conference in Los Angeles. "If you stay at the table, good things do and will get done." The deal calls for Edison to drop a federal lawsuit against the state and requires the utility to provide power to California for 10 years from its own generation and one new power plant in exchange for a guaranteed return on equity of 11.6 percent. Edison also agreed to invest $3 billion over five years in improvements to the transmission lines. And its corporate parent would contribute $420 million to reduce the utility's debt. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------ Davis' power plan is in doubt Legislators say buying transmission lines doesn't do enough to ease the crisis. April 10, 2001 By JOHN HOWARD and KATE BERRY The Orange County Register SACRAMENTO Gov. Gray Davis' $2.76 billion agreement to acquire Southern California Edison's transmission lines faces hard times in the Legislature, where some lawmakers fear that it bails out the debt-riddled utility but does little to ease California's energy crisis. The governor's proposal entails the purchase of Edison's transmission network and gives the state control over 20,000 acres of Edison-owned land. It requires the utility to provide the state with a decade's worth of low-cost power, obliges Edison's corporate parent to refund $420 million it took from the utility, and whittles down the company's debt over time with money set aside from increased consumer rates. It also includes Edison's commitment to invest $3 billion in capital improvements over five years, financed with money from rates, and continues for 10 years a guaranteed return on equity of 11.6 percent for the utility. It does not call for new power-plant construction. "It's too rich, there's too much money, too many dollars," said Nettie Hoge, a consumer activist with The Utility Reform Network. "It's like a fun-house mirror. You look closer, and it's a total distortion." The plan must be approved by the Public Utilities Commission and the Legislature. "My guess is there isn't a single vote in my caucus for the purchase of the grid," said Assemblyman Dave Cox, R-Fair Oaks, the Assembly's GOP leader. "And I'd be surprised if the governor can find the people on the Democratic side of the aisle to vote for this. We certainly agree the utilities should be made creditworthy, but we don't think they should be bailed out." Sen. John Burton, D-San Francisco, the leader of the Senate, said using higher rates to help cover Edison's $5.4 billion power-buying debt would prove a major sticking point, because the debt "may have been built up fraudulently through price-gouging (by generators) or mismanagement. "There is a question of whether ratepayers should have to gargle that," Burton said. PUC President Loretta Lynch said she was encouraged by the deal, and suggested that it stood a good chance of winning PUC approval. She said the plan allowed "utilities to recover their reasonable costs and to earn reasonable profits." Davis said the agreement with Edison paves the way for a similar arrangement with San Diego Gas & Electric Co. Negotiations with SDG&E will begin in earnest today and could be wrapped up soon, he said. Pacific Gas & Electric Co., which has $8.9 billion in power-buying debts, spurned negotiations with Davis and sought protection Friday under federal bankruptcy laws. Unlike Edison, PG&E has been reluctant to relinquish its transmission lines. "All along, we've always felt that they never really wanted to sell them," Sen. Debra Bowen, the chairwoman of the Senate energy committee. Davis has opposed bankruptcy for the utilities, saying it gives the courts excessive control over electricity distribution and hamstrings the state's ability to resolve the crisis. One key lawmaker said PG&E's bankruptcy makes the Legislature's decision more difficult. "In light of PG&E's bankruptcy, there is a very large question of whether purchasing less than a third of the state's transmission lines makes any sense, other than to provide an infusion of cash to the utility," said Sen. Joe Dunn, D-Santa Ana, who heads a committee examining electricity market practices. State officials have said a purchase of the transmission lines would only make sense if all three investor-owned utilities were to sell. Otherwise, the state wouldn't enjoy the bargaining leverage with generating companies that would come from owning a majority of the grid. "We need to review the nitty-gritty details, and it (passage) is questionable," Dunn said. "We need to know why this is beneficial to the people of the state of California, and I'm not sure that case has been made yet." Michael Shames, of the San Diego-based United Consumer Action Network, said purchasing just part of the grid could prove to be of only marginal value. "The benefits that accrue for owning the grid do not become available if you only own a third or two-thirds of the grid. All three legs of the stool have to be there," he said. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------ AES threatens to pull out of fast-track effort The power company tells a state panel it wants a longer expansion license. April 10, 2001 By KATE BERRY The Orange County Register HUNTINGTON BEACH AES Corp. threatened Monday to pull out of a fast-track process to bring much-needed electricity into California by July, telling a state energy panel that it wants a license for the expansion of its Huntington Beach power plant to extend beyond five years. Huntington Beach officials objected to any extension of the license beyond the five years recommended by a committee of the California Energy Commission, saying the city has made several concessions to accommodate a fast-track permit for the project, including delaying environmental studies on air and water effects. The CEC on Monday held its final public hearing before it votes April 18 on AES' plan to restart two 40-year-old gas-fired generators at the plant. The hearing was at City Hall. A CEC committee has recommended that AES' application be approved, with conditions. The two units could contribute 450 megawatts of energy to the state - or roughly 10 percent of the 5,000 megawatts Gov. Gray Davis is trying to bring online by this summer to help avoid rolling blackouts. The commission is considering whether to limit the use of the refired units to five years, require any power produced by the two units be sold to the state, and require AES to pay $1.5 million to fund environmental studies of air and water quality. Ed Blackford, president of AES Huntington Beach, said the city was asking for too many concessions. "If some of these conditions become overbearing on the project, let's revert back to a 12-month permit process," he said. Permits for such projects normally take a year to get, but the CEC cut the process to two months for AES because of the power shortage. Bill Workman, an assistant city administrator, conceded that AES might win its battle against the city because it is currently in negotiations with the state's Department of Water Resources to sell power from the plant to the state. He said those negotiations are being used as leverage to get the license extended. "This facility is aged and obsolete and were it not for the energy situation we're facing, we would be looking at a totally different project for the city," Workman said. "We cut a lot of things out that would have normally been in a 12-month permit process.'' City officials estimated that AES would recoup its $150 million investment in the expansion in 12 to 18 months. The city made several last-minute recommendations to the commission, including asking that AES hire a noise technician to be on call after 8 p.m. so residents can contact someone if construction noise rises above 5 decibels -- the limit recommended by the CEC committee for nighttime work. Because construction on the plant's two units would be allowed for 20 hours a day under the committee's recommendation, the city also requested that residents receive off-site lodging, paid for by AES, if they are disturbed repeatedly at night by construction noise. The city also asked that construction workers be required to park six miles away from the plant and take a shuttle to the site, rather than use beach parking, which would affect tourists and recreation in the area. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------ Electricity notebook PG&E may use reserved cash to purchase energy April 10, 2001 SAN FRANCISCO PG&E Corp.'s Pacific Gas & Electric persuaded a bankruptcy judge to let it temporarily spend cash pledged as collateral to bondholders and gas suppliers so the utility can buy energy and keep operating. In a separate filing, Pacific Gas asked U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Dennis Montali to shift some control of the utility away from California's Public Utilities Commission. The company requested that Montali block a March 27 PUC order that requires the company to file certain accounting documents Wednesday. Alan Kornberg, an attorney for the PUC, said it seemed as though Pacific Gas was asking Montali to excuse the company from complying with the agency's orders. "It's the PUC's position that all orders must be complied with," Kornberg said. The utility's legal move comes as it begins jockeying for position in the United States' largest utility-bankruptcy case. Pacific Gas, California's largest public utility, sought bankruptcy protection Friday, saying it couldn't agree with California lawmakers on a plan to help it repay $9 billion in debt. Montali's interim order, issued Monday, allows the utility to continue to buy natural gas on the same terms it had before the bankruptcy filing. Pacific Gas in January gave 16 natural-gas suppliers liens on some of its assets to get better credit terms. Utility timed bankruptcy to gain ground, sources say SAN FRANCISCO Pacific Gas & Electric Co. insiders say the utility's bankruptcy filing was timed to put maximum blame on Gov. Gray Davis and avoid being disadvantaged by the governor's apparently successful negotiations with Southern California Edison. PG&E Corp. Chairman Robert Glynn decided days before Davis' televised address on the energy crisis Thursday evening to file for bankruptcy immediately thereafter, the San Francisco Chronicle reported Sunday, citing unidentified sources inside the utility. Davis was not made aware of the company's plans - which included giving last-minute raises and bonuses to 6,000 top PG&E executives and workers - until after it filed for protection Friday morning. After months of contemplating bankruptcy, sources told the Chronicle that this was the most-advantageous time for the utility to move forward with its plan. Any further delay, and it might have been pressured to forgo $9 billion it hopes to recoup from California ratepayers. "We had this thing ready to go long before that," PG&E spokesman Greg Pruett said of the bankruptcy filing and its timing to Davis' speech. Glynn told a different story Friday, blaming the filing on the inability of Davis and other state lawmakers to reach a political solution. "We listened carefully to the (governor's) statement and the commentary that followed, and this decision is the result," Glynn said. Drought-induced power shortage looms ahead PORTLAND The Northwest drought is so dire that the aluminum industry should virtually shut itself down for two years to save power, the acting director of the Bonneville Power Administration recommended Monday. Steven Wright said the second-worst Northwest drought in 72 years means the region faces a tripling to a quadrupling of wholesale electricity prices beginning Oct. 1 unless radical cuts in power consumption are made. "An increase of this magnitude would have widespread economic consequences," Wright said. "With such an increase, we'd surely see more businesses close and more job losses." At a news conference, Wright also asked public utilities in the region to voluntarily cut back their power purchases from Bonneville by 5 percent to 10 percent. He asked private utilities to do the same. Bonneville, based in Portland, is a federal agency that markets almost half the electricity in the Northwest. It produces about 8,000 megawatts of power, much of it from 29 hydroelectric dams along the Columbia and Snake rivers. Wright also recommended that aluminum companies accept "limited compensation" from Bonneville to cover some of their costs and pay laid-off workers to cushion the economic impact. Otherwise, the industry faces a huge rate hike, he said. "I wouldn't say they're happy about it," Wright said, but "it is our expectation that the companies would not be able to operate given a potential tripling of our rates anyway." Bloomberg News and the Associated Press contributed to this report. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- State's power fees hinge on good credit April 10, 2001 By DON THOMPSON The Associated Press SACRAMENTO Two federal rulings could add $5 million to $8 million more a day to the state's power purchases for its two largest utilities this summer, a spokesman for Gov. Gray Davis said Monday. The state Department of Water Resources has been spending $45 million to $50 million daily to buy power for customers of Southern California Edison and bankrupt Pacific Gas & Electric. The cost will rise substantially during periods of high demand in summer unless the state fights rulings last week by a federal appeals court and the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, Davis spokesman Steve Maviglio said, adding that no decisions have been made on appeals. Both ruled that the overseer of the state's power grid, the California Independent System Operator, must have credit-worthy buyers for the last-minute power it acquires to fill gaps in the supply and avoid blackouts. Cash-strapped Edison and PG&E are the major recipients of that emergency power, but haven't been paying suppliers for it. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- AES NewEnergy Offers Program to Help Commonwealth Edison Customers Reduce Electricity Costs and Increase Reliability This Summer CHICAGO--(BUSINESS WIRE)--April 9, 2001 via NewsEdge Corporation - In an effort to help reduce the risk of California-style electricity shortages this summer in the Chicago area, AES NewEnergy, the nation's leading competitive retail electricity provider, will be offering Commonwealth Edison (ComEd) business customers a way to make money this summer by voluntarily reducing unneeded power usage at peak times. AES NewEnergy is expanding on an existing curtailment program the electric marketer worked out with ComEd last summer as a way of dampening down the extremely volatile peak summer power prices and avoiding California-style rolling brownouts and blackouts. In a pioneering effort to maintain reliable electricity services in the recently deregulated Illinois market, AES NewEnergy will actually pay its customers to participate in this program, which is designed to stabilize the power grid and increase service reliability during times of peak use. The program will lessen the risk of hardships such as were seen in California. "This is a first in the power industry," said Phil O'Connor, Vice President of AES NewEnergy. "AES NewEnergy is providing our customers from coast to coast with the flexibility to reduce their power demands on hot days and get paid for it." Under its Incremental Incentive Curtailment Program, AES NewEnergy customers can earn curtailment credits via voluntary usage reductions during the course of this summer. Credits earned by businesses under AES NewEnergy's program will be in addition to those earned through ComEd's curtailment programs. This means increased savings for businesses and enhanced stability for the power grid at large. AES NewEnergy has developed its curtailment service in conjunction with ComEd. When a member of AES NewEnergy's curtailment pool agrees to participate in any curtailment period called by ComEd, both programs will automatically assess credits to the customer over the period. AES NewEnergy may also call for a curtailment period independently from ComEd, providing yet another opportunity for AES NewEnergy customers to participate and earn credit. Any AES NewEnergy customer with a minimum peak demand of 300 kilowatts and ability to curtail at least 100 kilowatts of demand is eligible to apply for the program. Members of AES NewEnergy's curtailment pool will be contacted prior to declared curtailment periods, and can participate in any given period at their discretion. If a business cannot participate when called, there is no penalty. Credits will be applied on a kilowatt-hour per hour reduction basis, and could mean significant credits above and beyond those available through the ComEd program. The savings will be made available many times over the summer. Advantages of this program extend beyond monetary value to its participants. AES NewEnergy wishes to provide proactive management and power grid stabilization as an additional service. Uncertain summer temperatures directly affect the volume of energy required, and curtailment programs buffer the impact of increased demand on the grid. Responsible use of curtailment programs and effective participation from businesses will alleviate such strain and provide a stable power supply throughout the summer. AES NewEnergy is America's leading retail electricity provider, serving commercial and industrial customers in competitive markets throughout the country. The company offers businesses energy-related products and services. AES NewEnergy is a subsidiary of The AES Corporation (NYSE: AES), a leading global power company comprised of competitive generation, distribution and retail businesses around the world. More information on AES NewEnergy's products and services can be found at www.newenergy.com. CONTACT: AES NewEnergy |Richard Spilky, 312/704-9200 | rspilky@newenergy.com ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ --- Feds Embroiled in Power Debate By H.JOSEF HEBERT Associated Press Writer WASHINGTON (AP) via NewsEdge Corporation - California's electricity debacle has embroiled an obscure federal agency in accusations that it is failing to confront powerful energy companies over allegations of price gouging. Free-market advocates argue that more aggressive intervention by the agency could make the West's electricity problems worse. But critics say the agency is too timid, raising concerns about its role as the watchdog over a $250 billion electricity industry. Scarcely known by the general public, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission _ its five members selected by the president _ can wield immense power as federal overseer of wholesale electricity markets and interstate natural gas transport. Its daily activities and public pronouncements rarely have attracted much attention outside the industry _ until now. Suddenly FERC, as it is commonly known among energy insiders, has become a boogeyman of deregulation-run-amok in the eyes of its sharpest critics _ among them members of Congress, state regulators and Western utilities saddled with billions of dollars in debt from power purchases at astronomical prices. ``It's high time FERC was called to account for its public-be-damned attitude,'' Rep. John Dingell of Michigan, the ranking Democrat on the House Commerce Committee, fumed recently. Aware of the discontent, especially in the West, the commission was taking the unusual step of holding a hearing Tuesday in Boise, Idaho, to listen to officials from 11 Western states on how it might help them cope with the wildly gyrating wholesale power markets expected this summer. Curtis Hebert, FERC's Republican chairman and a staunch free-market advocate, rejects claims the commission isn't doing its job but acknowledges that complexities brought on by open competition have put strains on the agency. He cites a string of FERC actions: _Its move in mid-December to order changes in the way California contracts for power and put wholesale electricity suppliers on notice that unusually high prices would have to be explained. _Its pursuit last month of two companies accused of withholding power to inflate prices, a case critics have applauded but note it stems from actions nearly a year ago. _Its investigation of thousands of January-February power transactions in California involving $124 million in alleged overcharges. FERC-ordered refunds, Hebert told a recent congressional hearing, ``demonstrate the commission's commitment to appropriate and reasonable prices'' in California and elsewhere in the West. Hebert, however, insists that a government-imposed dampening of prices wanted by many of the agency's critics will only keep people from investing in more power plants and make consumers less likely to conserve. ``Price caps are unworkable, unreliable and not a solution,'' says the former state utility regulator from Mississippi. On that, as well as the adequacy of FERC's push for refunds, Hebert's sharpest critic may be on the commission itself, which currently has two vacancies. By its inaction, argues William Massey, a Democratic member of the commission, the FERC has condoned ``unlawful'' pricing practices despite its mandate to ensure ``just and reasonable'' prices for consumers. The commission has an obligation ``to aggressively intervene'' when a market has become broken, says Massey. He has called for price caps and a broadening of FERC's investigation into refunds, saying thousands of questionable sales have been ignored. Each time he's been outvoted 2-1. It is Hebert's free-market approach, and not Massey's call for more action, that mirrors the views of the White House, where President Bush also has opposed price controls on the California electricity market. While some Democrats in Congress have introduced legislation ordering FERC to take more aggressive action, the agency's policies have the support of most Republican lawmakers. Beyond the issue of price caps, there have been questions about FERC's ability to adequately monitor and police the increasingly complex and rapidly moving wholesale electricity market. Its staff is now 15 percent smaller than it was four years ago. Last October, an internal FERC report raised concerns about the agency adapting to the rapidly changing electricity industry it is supposed to regulate. The report said the agency needs more staffers with market-oriented skills and noted the potential conflict in the agency's dual mandates: to further a pro-competition agenda and also regulate that competition. ``Right now my view is the FERC is overwhelmed by the task before it,'' says William Nugent, Maine's state public utility commissioner, expressing his frustration at what he views as FERC's slow response to alleged market abuses. A year-old price spiking case in New England involving tens of millions of dollars has yet to be fully investigated, he said. ``There's a sense of this being a trial by fire,'' says FERC's Massey. ``There's no question about that.'' --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Calif. Reaches Deal on Power Lines By LESLIE GORNSTEIN Associated Press Writer LOS ANGELES (AP) via NewsEdge Corporation - In a bid to pull the state's second biggest utility back from the brink of bankruptcy, Gov. Gray Davis announced a deal on Monday for the state to buy power lines from Southern California Edison for $2.76 billion. The deal is a key part of the governor's plan to keep the cash-strapped utility solvent. It would give Edison money to reorganize its debts and pay power generators, many of which have not been paid for power since last November. ``These were tough negotiations but they've produced a good, balanced deal,'' Davis said. The deal requires Edison to provide low-cost power to the state for 10 years and to dismiss a lawsuit seeking hikes in consumer rates, Davis said. Davis had originally proposed buying parts of the state's transmission grid owned by all three of the state's investor-owned utilities. That plan was dealt a serious blow Friday when Pacific Gas & Electric, the state's largest utility, pulled out of negotiations and filed for bankruptcy protection. Consumer advocate Harvey Rosenfield said the PG&E filing put immense pressure on Davis to cut a deal with Edison to keep the state's second-largest utility out of bankruptcy. ``He's trying to redeem himself with Wall Street,'' Rosenfield said. Edison and PG&E say they have lost more than $13 billion since June because of skyrocketing wholesale power prices. They cannot pass on their costs to customers under the state's 1996 deregulation law. Edison also was expected to file an update Monday on its financial condition with the Securities and Exchange Commission. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ----- California ISO Declares a Statewide Stage Two Electrical Emergency; Conservation Needed as Demand Surges and Supply Tightens FOLSOM, Calif.--(BUSINESS WIRE) via NewsEdge Corporation - At 7:50 a.m. today, Monday, April 9, 2001, the California Independent System Operator (California ISO) called a Stage Two Emergency as operating reserves dipped below five percent. This emergency status is partly attributable to higher electrical loads due to cold temperatures and meager winds, which has reduced available wind power generation from 1,000 megawatts to an estimated 250 megawatts. Additional conditions that are producing tight operating reserves include: -- A total of 12,421 megawatts worth of generation unavailable today with power plants off-line because of preventative repairs and plant malfunctions -- An additional 3,000 megawatts of generation from the state's qualifying facilities (QFs) remain unavailable due to continuing financial concerns -- Path 15 transmission congestion because of especially high demand and low supply in Northern California -- Low imported power due to higher loads in the Northwest -- a region also suffering from a cold snap With operating reserves hovering at critical levels, the California ISO requests that customers voluntarily reduce their use of electricity to prevent more severe curtailment measures. Peak demand on the transmission system is expected to reach 28,462 megawatts around 6:00 p.m. today. Today's Stage Two declaration, expected to be in effect until midnight, enables the California ISO to access emergency resources to help maintain operating reserves. If an operating reserve shortfall of less than one-and-a-half percent is unavoidable, Stage Three is initiated. Involuntary curtailments of service to customers including "rotating blackouts" are possible during this emergency declaration. The California ISO's Electrical Emergency Plan (EEP) is part of the state's enhanced reliability standards enacted by landmark legislation Assembly Bill 1890 that led to the restructuring of California's electricity industry. The California ISO is charged with managing the flow of electricity along the long-distance, high-voltage power lines that make up the bulk of California's transmission system. The not-for-profit public-benefit corporation assumed the responsibility in March, 1998, when California opened its energy markets to competition and the state's investor-owned utilities turned their private transmission power lines over to the California ISO to manage. The mission of the California ISO is to safeguard the reliable delivery of electricity, facilitate markets and ensure equal access to a 25,526 circuit mile "electron highway." Continuously updated information about the California ISO control area's electricity supply and the current demand on the power grid is available on the web at www.caiso.com. Other helpful contacts: Pacific Gas and Electric 415/973-5930 Southern California Edison 626/302-2255 San Diego Gas and Electric 877/866-2066 CONTACT: California ISO | Stephanie McCorkle, (888) 516-NEWS ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ -----------------------