16 Apr 2001, 10:10 UTC
Energy Issues
- From
- Miyung Buster miyung.buster@enron.com
- To
-
Ann M Schmidt, Bryan Seyfried, dg27@pacbell.net, Elizabeth Linnell, filuntz@aol.com, James D Steffes, Janet Butler, Jeannie Mandelker, Jeff Dasovich, Joe Hartsoe, John Neslage, John Sherriff
and 39 more
Joseph Alamo, Karen Denne, Lysa Akin, Margaret Carson, Mark Palmer, Mark Schroeder, Markus Fiala, Michael R Brown, Mike Dahlke, Mona L Petrochko, Nicholas O'Day, Peggy Mahoney, Peter Styles, Richard Shapiro, Rob Bradley, Sandra McCubbin, Shelley Corman, Stella Chan, Steven J Kean, Susan J Mara, mike.roan@enron.com, Alex Parsons, andrew.morrison@enron.com, Laura Ipsen, Janel Guerrero, shirley.hudler@enron.com, Kathleen Sullivan, Tom Briggs, Linda Robertson, Lora Sullivan, Jennifer Thome, jkradin@marathon-com.com, rlichtenstein@marathon-com.com, Sandra Yamane, Ken Smith, Hedy Govenar, Scott Govenar, Bev Hansen, Carin Nersesian - Date
- Mon, 16 Apr 2001 03:10:00 -0700 (PDT)
Please see the attached articles: Sac Bee, Mon, 4/16: "Tough talk on energy: Many Democratic lawmakers push to seize generators" Sac Bee, Mon, 4/16: "Dan Walters" Sac Bee, Mon, 4/16: "Up the creek without power" SD Union, Sun, 4/15: "SDG&E has rebates for conservers of energy" SD Union, Sun, 4/15: "State energy officials push for San Jose power plant" SD Union (AP), Sun, 4/15: "PG&E sent hard-nosed proposal to Davis demanding no regulation" SD Union, Sat, 4/14: "Some plants can, but won't, make power" SD Union, Sat, 4/14: "FERC orders release of energy contracts" SD Union, Sat, 4/14: "Escondido, San Marcos may be power partners" SD Union (AP), Sat, 4/14: "Davis promises energy crisis won't cost voters 'one penny' " LA Times, Mon, 4/16: "Utilities to Resume Paying Producers" LA Times, Mon, 4/16: "Tariff May Limit Flow of Natural Gas" LA Times, Sun, 4/15: "Experts Doubtful About Rush to Build Small Power Plants" LA Times, Sat, 4/14: "Davis Says All Power Costs to Be Recovered" LA Times, Mon, 4/16: "Long, Hot, Costly Days" (Commentary) SF Chron, Mon, 4/16: "Passing Along the Cost Many Bay Area businesses resort to surcharges to survive " SF Chron, Mon, 4/16: "Time Seems Bright for Solar Power Big companies bring financial clout to field" SF Chron (AP), Mon, 4/16: "Developments in California's energy crisis" SF Chron, Mon, 4/16: "Plan to Save Edison Faces Skepticism in Sacramento No legislative clamor for Davis' bailout deal" SF Chron, Sun, 4/15: "NEWS ANALYSIS Bush Administration Faces Static on Energy Policy Environmentalists criticize calls for more drilling" SF Chron, Sun, 4/15: "Bay Theaters Start Bracing for More Blackouts Larger venues buy generators" SF Chron, Sun, 4/15: "PG&E Took Hard Line, Dooming State Talks Secret plan shows utility demanded less regulation" SF Chron, Sat, 4/14: "Energy Efficiency Rules Scaled Back Bush official's move affects appliances" SF Chron, Sun, 4/15: "Power of Micro Vs. Macro Some firms crushed by energy crisis" Mercury News (AP), Mon, 4/16: "PG&E sent hard-nosed proposal to Davis demanding no regulation" Mercury News, Mon, 4/16: "Conservation drive fuels move to 'Cool Roofs' " OC Register, Mon, 4/16: "PUC president outlines the crisis" (Commentary) Individual.com (AP), Mon, 4/16: "Sierra Pacific to suspend quarterly dividend --Sierra Pacific cites energy crisis uncertainty" Energy Insighty, Mon, 4/16: "Low storage levels mean strong refill season" ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------- Tough talk on energy: Many Democratic lawmakers push to seize generators. By Jim Sanders BEE CAPITOL BUREAU (Published April 16, 2001) Here's what some California lawmakers see as a trump card in solving the state's energy crisis: Gouge the public, lose your power plant. Faced with growing bills and dwindling options, many Democratic lawmakers are pushing for the use of emergency powers or eminent domain to force power generators to negotiate lower wholesale electricity prices. "Step One is to seize a few power plants," said Senate President Pro Tem John Burton, D-San Francisco. "That would let (the generators) know we mean business." "There's no negotiation when generators say, 'Pay us what we want, or we'll shut off California's lights,' " said Phil Angelides, state treasurer. "We ought to levy an excess profit tax, and if they don't take their foot off our throat, seize a plant or two to sober them up." The increasingly tough talk about seizing assets, while motivated by an immediate desire to extract concessions, fits into a longer-term push for California to produce some of its own electricity to boost supply and protect against spiraling prices. Critics blast the notion of seizure, however, as a bargaining ploy or political grandstanding. "It's actually quite silly and a waste of time to consider these options," said Gary Ackerman, executive director of the Western Power Trading Forum, an association of wholesale generators. "Seizure would mean the state would pay top dollar for an Edsel -- old, tired plants that are past their prime," he said. "What happens if these people are wrong and they're taking the people of California down a dead end?" But others say the time is ripe for radical reform, with the state paying up to $50 million a day for electricity and facing prospects of rolling power blackouts this summer. "The generators will only respond when we take their golden eggs: the plants they own," said Douglas Heller of the Foundation for Taxpayer and Consumer Rights. "They're the ones cheating us, and they're the ones we must target." Lawmakers have raised the following two seizure possibilities, each aimed at ensuring that more electricity is available at lower than spot-market prices: Take over private power plants, perhaps contract with utilities to run them and let the courts decide what fair market price should be paid to the companies that now own them. Leave the plants alone, but seize their contracts with marketers, thus controlling where the power is sold while reducing price markups by eliminating the middleman in spot-market transactions. State Sen. Debra Bowen, D-Marina Del Rey, chairwoman of the state Senate's Energy Committee, recently suggested a third way for California to acquire existing electricity assets, without seizing them: Purchase the entire Pacific Gas and Electric Co. in Bankruptcy Court. Such a move could benefit the state and keep PG&E property out of the hands of private companies that already have too much influence over the electricity market, Bowen said. All sides agree that takeovers would be an extraordinary, unprecedented intervention into California's electricity industry. But Burton said his support for seizures is "very serious." The state could pay acquisition costs through revenue from electricity sales, he said. "People make money on power plants," he said. "It ain't like they're loss leaders." Gov. Gray Davis hasn't ruled out the seizure of power generators' assets or the acquisition of PG&E. But such possibilities raise a million questions, ranging from taxpayer exposure to technical issues regarding use of any asset acquired, Davis spokesman Steve Maviglio said. Seizure, in particular, can be a "risky gamble" that should not be done in haste, Maviglio said. Private companies targeted by the state could respond by withholding power or deciding not to invest in new plants at a time when California is scrambling for more electricity. "Clearly, the governor doesn't want to send a message that California doesn't want increased generation," Maviglio said. "Even though generators are gouging us now, they're also the people that build plants." While the Democratic governor has not committed himself to seizure, he supports legislation -- SB 6x -- written by Burton and supported by Angelides that would create a public power authority to construct state-owned plants and help finance conservation and renewable-energy projects. "The notion that we should let electricity be traded by profiteers like a sheer commodity is ludicrous and dangerous," Angelides said. "Public power is the public's defense against the greed and dysfunction of a market run amok." Power plants aren't cheap, but with the $5.2 billion it has spent or allocated since January to buy energy on the spot market, the state could generate enough electricity to serve more than 10 million homes. A 1,000-megawatt plant burning natural gas would cost about $500 million, according to the California Energy Commission. "We ought never again be in the position of having no ability to control at least part of the supply and hedge the market," said Darrell Steinberg, D-Sacramento, a member of the Assembly's Energy Committee. S. David Freeman, general manager of the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power and an adviser to Davis, said he solidly supports building public plants. He likes the idea of a windfall profits tax but is less enthusiastic about asset seizures. "All those things are worth considering and they're part of a common theme: The state has to take control of its own destiny," Freeman said. "We need to conserve and build our way out of this mess. The Lord helps those who help themselves." But Republican legislators, who have long opposed Davis' efforts to buy statewide electricity transmission, think the state would be making a big mistake by seizing private plants or building its own. "There's no reason to believe the state of California can run the power business or the transmission business as good as, or better than, the private sector," said Assembly Republican leader Dave Cox of Fair Oaks. The concept of seizure is particularly controversial. "How far can you take this?" Cox asked. "If we have a natural gas shortage, do we then seize those pipelines?" Jan Smutny-Jones of the Independent Energy Producers Association said state officials need to stop their "constant haranguing of generators." "Seizing private property didn't work in Cuba, and I don't think it would work in California," he said. Private electricity companies are investing billions to generate more power, and are running their plants as hard as possible to meet the crisis, Smutny-Jones said. Soaring electricity prices have been due largely to high demand, scarce supply, extremely high costs for natural gas to run turbines, and financial risks tied to the instability of PG&E and Southern California Edison, industry officials say. But state officials claim that market manipulation has contributed as well. The California Independent System Operator, which manages the statewide transmission grid, has accused power generators of overcharging Californians by $6.2 billion since May. In response, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission recently threatened to order generators to refund a portion of the contested charges, $134.8 million, mostly covering state purchases in January and February. Tom Williams, a spokesman for Duke Energy Corp., a North Carolina-based company that operates four California power plants, said the company is spending $1.6 billion to upgrade and expand those facilities in an attempt to ease the energy crunch. State seizures would discourage investment and hurt the industry, Williams said. "The governor has said that two things need to happen: The state needs more supply and lower prices," he said. "Seizing power plants would do nothing to help those two objectives." Any attempt to take Duke's property through eminent domain would spark a lawsuit, Williams said. "We would fight it vigorously, I can assure you, to ensure we got fair market value." But Duke would not object to the state building power plants of its own, he said. "We support any effort, public or private, to add generation to California," he said. "The state needs it -- and needs it fast." The Bee's Jim Sanders can be reached at (916) 326-5538 or jsanders@sacbee.com . ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ---------------------------------------------------------------- Dan Walters (Published April 16, 2001) Gray Davis is, by his own description, a cautious, incremental and consensus-oriented politician. One might expect, therefore, that he would be circumspect in what he says, as well as what he does. The state's energy crisis, however, is offering new evidence of Davis' odd, even inexplicable, penchant for saying things that don't square with either reality or sensibility. It's not the same as President Bush's malapropisms. Davis knows what he's saying; he just doesn't know, or doesn't care, how ludicrous his words strike others. Take, for example, something Davis said three years ago as he was announcing his candidacy for governor. In a feeble attempt to be inspiring -- not easy for a politician whose name captures his personality -- Davis quoted from an inscription engraved into a state office building. The inscription is "Bring me men to match my mountains," but Davis changed it to "Bring me people to match my mountains" as a gesture to feminists, and then placed it on the wrong building. To Davis, being politically correct was more important than being accurate. Davis had been governor for just six months when he uttered something so outrageous that it continues to reverberate. In a meeting with newspaper editors in San Francisco, Davis castigated the Legislature, which is controlled by his fellow Democrats, as having "a totally different view of the world than I do, totally different," and then added: "People expect government to reflect the vision that I suggested. Nobody else in the Legislature ran statewide. Their job is to implement my vision. That is their job." To put it mildly, legislators were miffed by this pungent whiff of megalomania, which also disregarded American concepts of government, and Davis had to do some serious fence-mending in subsequent weeks. But did he learn his lesson about saying things that implied he is the center of the political universe? Apparently not. Nine months later, Davis said much the same thing about the courts, telling reporters in Washington that he expects his appointees to the bench to follow his lead on the death penalty and other issues or resign. Davis said that "while they (judges) have to follow the law ( they're there because I appointed them and they need to keep faith with my electoral mandate." Another round of explanations and clarifications followed. The governor has uttered so many odd, and ultimately unrealistic, statements about the energy crisis this year that a Republican group now collects and distributes them. In January, he pledged that "there will be no rate increases," even though he and a state Public Utilities Commission controlled by his appointees now say hefty rate boosts are necessary. Repeatedly, he has declared that an end to the crisis was in sight, only to see the state plummet even further into the abyss. His promise of a short-term state power purchase program has now become an immense and prolonged drain on the state treasury. And projections of significant new power generation and conservation savings to get the state through the summer are being downgraded severely. During one particularly effusive period in late February, Davis said California is "on the back side of the crisis," pledged that "the combination of rapid efforts to put more megawatts on line and conservation will get us through the summer," and declared that the state is within a month of completing all the "legislative fixes" needed to settle the crisis. But perhaps Davis' most enduring February declaration was this one: "Believe me, if I wanted to raise rates, I could have solved this problem in 20 minutes." Maybe that was true in February. But Davis continued to dither and the rates are being raised now without any indication that the crisis will go away anytime soon. Given his record, we should view all of Davis' pronouncements with a strong sense of skepticism. The Bee's Dan Walters can be reached at (916) 321-1195 or dwalters@sacbee.com . ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ --------------------------------------------------------- Up the creek without power By Kevin Yamamura BEE CAPITOL BUREAU (Published April 16, 2001) Assemblyman Dennis Cardoza was headed to a federal energy hearing in Boise, Idaho, on Tuesday to help save California from rolling power blackouts. But hours before the scheduled departure came an unexpected twist: a blackout of his own. Cardoza, a Merced Democrat, resides on a 36-foot Gulf Star watercraft anchored along the Sacramento River during the week. He and other lawmakers had planned to take a 5:30 a.m. chartered flight to Boise, which meant Cardoza had to rise by 4 a.m., said staff member Doug White. Sometime during the night, however, the juice cut out. While Cardoza woke up on time -- thanks to a battery-powered alarm clock -- he faced other problems. "He had to take a really, really cold bath with bottled water," White said. In the end, Cardoza barely made the flight -- arriving at the airport just before the plane departed. White said Cardoza's boat, powered by a series of batteries like those found in cars, fell victim to vandalism. $%&#@@&%$ timecards!!! Tensions apparently remain high at the Office of Criminal Justice Planning between some employees and their bosses. So high, in fact, that members of the California State Employees Association distributed leaflets Tuesday in front of the agency's office on the K Street Mall, criticizing management for what they consider to be high turnover rates and failed leadership. Some are particularly incensed about a new computer timekeeping system that tracks when they leave and where they go. Union President Perry Kenny said the system treats workers like "inmates." OCJP Chief Deputy Director Allen Sawyer said it is a response to a state audit issued two years ago that showed the agency lacked accountability for workers' time. He added that he feels managers have a "great relationship" with staff. An arbitrator is scheduled to review the matter in mid-June. The latest dispute follows criticism in December of OCJP Director Frank Grimes for allegedly using profanity in a mandatory meeting with staff. Grimes denied the claim, calling it a "false allegation." Bigger than a bowl game The 1951 University of San Francisco football squad won nine games, lost none and is considered by many to be among the greatest college teams in history. But the Dons were snubbed by bowl game organizers because the team fielded two African American players. They stayed home while squads with blemished records -- including those they had beaten -- moved on to the postseason. To mark the team's 50th anniversary this fall, Sen. Barbara Boxer, D-Calif., has asked President Bush to honor the squad by inviting members to a White House ceremony. In particular, Boxer noted the team's integrity. "The team was offered the chance to compete without the African American players, but they unanimously refused on principle," she wrote. Jeff Logan, a Boxer spokesman, said the senator has not yet received a response from the president but expects to hear soon. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ----------------------------------------------------------- SDG&E has rebates for conservers of energy By Karen Kucher UNION-TRIBUNE STAFF WRITER April 15, 2001 Doris Tuley of El Cajon no longer switches on her TV during the day. She turns on so few lights she has to squint to read, and does her laundry only at night. "We are cutting back -- and yet the bill keeps going up," she said. Last week, Tuley, 63, found another way to save. She took six halogen torchiere lamps to La Mesa's Porter Hall to exchange for fluorescent lamps, which use less electricity. The replacements were free, provided by San Diego Gas & Electric Co. under an outreach program for seniors. It is one of many rebates and incentives offered by the utility, which is spending about $50 million to encourage residents and businesses to conserve energy. In the market for a new refrigerator? Consumers who purchase energy-saving models can pocket up to $125. Buying the right dishwasher could get you a $50 rebate, while $75 is available for those who purchase qualified clothes washers. SDG&E also offers rebates for homeowners who install insulation, energy-efficient windows, new gas water heaters or energy-saving swimming pool pumps. Apartment building owners can get incentives to retrofit appliances in units, and developers who build homes that don't waste power can get money, too. The utility has offered programs promoting efficiency and conservation since the 1970s, with rebates and other costs covered by ratepayer fees, said Yole Whiting, SDG&E's director of consumer programs and services. Surge in interest Such incentives have gained new importance in recent months, as skyrocketing prices and blackouts have become a reality for Californians. Consumers have been flooding the utility's Web site (http://www.sdge.com) and phone lines to find more information. "In the past, I can remember when it was hard to convince folks that they needed to save energy," Whiting said. "We are getting a lot of response and a lot of interest now." SDG&E is trying to encourage its customers to reduce total demand by 75 megawatt-hours or more during 2001. If it creates a 23 megawatt-hour reduction and meets other goals, it will receive a $2.7 million incentive payment from the state Public Utilities Commission, Whiting said. The 23 megawatt-hours are enough to meet the demands of 17,250 households. Managers of stores that sell appliances say they have seen a rise in refrigerator sales in the first quarter of the year, which they believe is related to California's energy crisis. Consumers are particularly interested in finding appliances carrying the Energy Star label of the U.S. Department of Energy and U.S. Environmental Protection Agency because those appliances save the most energy and qualify for rebates. "A lot of people don't understand Energy Star, but they do understand energy efficiency," said Harry Overlock, who manages the Sears store in El Cajon. Energy expert Michael Lamb said a 10-year-old refrigerator may use twice as much power as a new model. "Modern refrigerator technology has come a long way in 10 years," said Lamb, a certified energy manager at Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy Clearinghouse, a program operated by the U.S. Department of Energy. "As a general rule of thumb, a modern refrigerator of the same size with similar features will use about half the amount of power as one made about 10 years ago, and about a third of the power of one made about 15 years ago. "The technology has just gotten a whole lot better," he said. Lamb said newer models offer better compressor motors and evaporation fan motors, more intelligent controls and better insulation. Shop carefully Although those models can be more expensive, consumers like them because the rebate defrays some of the initial cost and because the long-term energy savings are attractive. However, a representative from the Utility Consumers' Action Network public-interest group warned consumers to research rebates before they shop for appliances. A UCAN intern who recently went to several local stores found that many salespeople seemed unfamiliar with rebate programs and didn't know what models qualified for them, said Jodi Beebe, an energy analyst with UCAN. "The best thing to do is do it with foresight," Beebe said. Sears' Overlock said he thinks rebates encourage consumers to replace inefficient appliances -- and he'd like to see more offered. Bill Walker, manager of the Home Depot in Grantville, says his customers are buying everything in the store related to energy efficiency. "Ever since the gas and electric bills have gone nuts, we are seeing a ton of energy-saving items from across the board (being bought). We can't keep insulation on the shelves," Walker said. "The energy-saving light bulbs are through the ceiling. We are up over 500 percent on energy-saving light bulbs," he said. "People are buying like 20 at a time and changing out their whole house." The Home Depot sales aren't unusual. SDG&E says regional sales of energy-efficient light bulbs, which are subsidized by the utility company, exceeded projections for the first three months of the year. Funds for several rebates also are being drawn down quickly, although Whiting said there is no immediate danger of the utility ending any of the programs. "I would love to run out of money this year," she said. "We are doing everything we can to get these funds into the hands of consumers." ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ----------------------------------------------- State energy officials push for San Jose power plant ASSOCIATED PRESS April 15, 2001 SAN JOSE ) In an effort to ease this summer's promised power drain, state energy officials are pushing for approval of a proposed power plant in San Jose's Coyote Valley, despite recommendations that other sites may be more environmentally suitable, a newspaper reported Sunday. California Energy Commission top administrators undermined a negative environmental assessment of the project and recommended approval of Calpine Corp.'s Metcalf Energy Center over other sites, the San Jose Mercury News found, citing internal documents and transcripts obtained through a California Public Records Act request. But commission deputy director Bob Therkelsen denied any impartial dealings concerning the plant. "I would not deny that some of the staff have strong feelings," Therkelsen said . "But I think the process allowed all perspectives to be heard." San Jose City Council opposes the project because the city had planned to save the property for high-tech campuses. Commission administrators and attorneys directed an analyst to downplay other sites' advantages and quieted him at a hearing when he tried to voice his concerns over the pressure that prompted him to alter his findings, the newspaper found. The commission also reversed a third analyst's recommendation that Calpine obtain a contract for recycled water prior to construction, which could have slowed building the plant. A 574-page Preliminary Staff Assessment released in May identified other more "environmentally preferable" sites, including two industrial sites in Fremont. Therkelsen said the report was a premature draft that changed as more information became available. "I was concerned that the alternatives were being portrayed more optimistically than realistically," Therkelsen said. Analyst Gary Walker, a 21-year veteran, reported other plant sites would be more suitable, but was later told his report was full of "bias" and "inconsistencies," the newspaper reported. In an e-mail, senior commission attorney Arlene Ichien said Metcalf must be cast in a better light or it would be hard for the commission to grant approval. "Staff is building a strong case for finding the alternative sites feasible," Ichien wrote. In a report last fall, Walker's discussion of other sites' advantages was ultimately replaced by a warning that the Silicon Valley is at risk for blackouts unless Metcalf is built. The final report recommended approval. Another analyst was told to change his report about how much noise the plant would create and the amount of insulation needed to quiet it, the newspaper reported. The analyst was taken off the project, and the final assessment released last October said insulation was not necessary because of the few homes near the plant. The five-member commission is expected to make its decision this summer during the power crisis' peak load. There is a push to build power plants in the technology-dominated Silicon Valley, which imports most of its electricity. The plant would use 3 million to 6 million gallons of water a day, but with San Jose officials opposed to the plant, it is unclear where that water would come from. Calpine and its development partner, Bechtel Enterprises, wants the plant operating by 2002. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ -------------------------------------------- PG&E sent hard-nosed proposal to Davis demanding no regulation ASSOCIATED PRESS April 15, 2001 SAN FRANCISCO ) Pacific Gas and Electric Co. officials demanded the utility be cut free from state regulation and be allowed to push huge rate increases onto its customers, two weeks before negotiations with Gov. Gray Davis broke off, the San Francisco Chronicle reported Sunday. "Perhaps we misjudged their primary concern," said Steve Maviglio, the governor's spokesman. "It wasn't resolving their credit issue. It was extracting vengeance on the PUC." In addition to insisting that it be released from the state Public Utilities Commission's regulatory grip, PG&E demanded it be allowed to buy back its power lines without competitive offers if the state ever decided to sell. In addition, it wanted to continue profiting from any telecommunications lines or antennas linked to the system, according to a Feb. 28 eight-page proposal obtained by the Chronicle. PG&E denies the document influenced the outcome between the utility and the state. "It is ludicrous to suggest that this document caused the negotiations to break down," said PG&E spokesman Ron Low. "There were negotiations that occurred later and other documents that followed." At the time of the utility's bankruptcy filing April 6, PG&E Corp. Chairman Robert Glynn said no talks had been held for three weeks. PG&E's proposal had been delivered about two before talks ceased. PG&E has said it's entitled to recoup $9 billion it paid for wholesale power because of PUC-regulated rate caps, which kept the utility from passing high costs onto customers. The proposal said this money "will be fully recovered in retail rates without further CPUC review for prudence or any other purpose," the Chronicle reported. The document went on to demand the PUC drop all proceedings concerning PG&E, including an investigation into whether the utility violated California law by transferring millions to parent company PG&E Corp. prior to filing bankruptcy. "They took a position on regulatory matters that was out of touch with reality," Maviglio said. PG&E Corp. spokesman Shawn Cooper declined to comment on the proposal. "That document is confidential," he said. Ratepayer advocates say they're baffled by PG&E's demands. "It's like the Japanese insisting that we surrender Hawaii after we beat them in World War II," said Harvey Rosenfield, consumer advocate for the Foundation for Taxpayer and Consumer Rights. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ----------------------------------------------- Some plants can, but won't, make power Too costly to run, they sit off-line By Jonathan Heller UNION-TRIBUNE STAFF WRITER April 14, 2001 While San Diegans are being asked to turn off lights and wash dishes by hand because of the energy shortage, three power plants capable of supplying power for about 155,000 homes have sat idle for up to two weeks. The cogeneration plant at the Iceoplex skating complex in Escondido has been off-line since April 1 because a state agency that regulates its prices has set them so low it can't afford to produce electricity, a plant official said yesterday. Three other cogeneration plants at the North Island Naval Air Station, the Naval Training Center and the 32nd Street Naval Station also are off-line. Together, they can produce 155 megawatts, or about 5 percent of the county's total demand at this time of year. A megawatt is enough energy to power 750 to 1,000 homes, depending on the time of year and other factors. Unlike conventional power generators, which can set their own prices under deregulation, cogeneration plants and other alternative power providers, such as wind and solar plants, sell power under a price formula set by the California Public Utilities Commission. The PUC changed the formula April 1, and since then cogenerators across the state have complained they can't recoup their costs under the new pricing system. "Anyone who can do math can figure out that losing money is no incentive to generate power," said Ann MacLeod, executive director of the California Cogeneration Council. This situation is different from the one that led Houston-based Dynegy Corp. to threaten to shut down its San Diego-area plants this week. Dynegy said it no longer wants to sell power because it is afraid the state is not able to pay the bill. The Iceoplex plant, operated by Purenergy Corp., produces just under 50 megawatts, nearly enough to supply a city the size of Escondido. Jim Hinrichs, Purenergy's general manager in San Diego, said he did not know how long it would be shut down. "Our plant in Escondido is currently off-line until such time as we can procure gas at a price where we can cover our fuel costs," Hinrichs said. The three plants on the Navy bases, operated by Sithe Energies Corp., produce between 23 and 45 megawatts each. It was unclear why those plants were shut down. A spokesman for Sithe Energies could not be reached for comment late yesterday. The Naval Training Center plant went off-line April 2, the North Island plant on April 3 and the 32nd Street plant on April 6, according to the Independent System Operator, which manages the state's power grid. Those outages were unplanned, according to the Independent System Operator Web site. Stephanie McCorkle, an ISO spokeswoman, said she could not comment on why the plants were shut down. She did say that about half of all alternative power generators, including cogenerators, wind and solar plants, are currently off-line in the state. That translates to 3,000 megawatts, or enough energy for about 3 million homes. The four San Diego cogeneration plants are under contract to sell electricity to SDG&E, which feeds it into the regional power grid. "If they don't run, they don't get paid," said Art Larson, an SDG&E spokesman. "That's one simple aspect of the contract." There are other cogeneration plants in the county that are still operating, although most of them are much smaller than the four that are off-line. "During this period of demand shortfalls, we think it's in the best interest of the community that every available power generating source be up and operating," Larson said. James Loewen, a PUC analyst, acknowledged that the PUC's decision has resulted in lower payments to the cogenerators. He said the pricing formula and payments to cogenerators are tied to the cost of natural gas imported into California. The PUC changed the formula to one that would factor in gas coming in from the Oregon border, where prices are historically cheaper, he said. But cogenerators contend the new formula has made it uneconomical to turn on their plants. "It defies common sense," said MacLeod of the cogeneration council. "We are hoping the PUC has become aware in the last month as how bad that decision was." ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ --------------------------------------------------- FERC orders release of energy contracts Regulators' demand for secret deals riles Davis administration By Toby Eckert? COPLEY NEWS SERVICE April 14, 2001 WASHINGTON -- Federal regulators have ordered power suppliers to turn over copies of their confidential short-term and long-term contracts with California, which the regulators intend to share with a congressional committee. In a letter sent to the power companies Thursday, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission said it would "treat these contracts as confidential" unless the supplier waives confidentiality. It is unclear whether the House Government Reform Committee is under the same obligation, though FERC said the information would be given to the committee "under confidential seal." Gov. Gray Davis has been keeping details of the contracts secret, arguing that revealing the information would weaken the state's bargaining position in negotiations with other suppliers. FERC's order angered the Davis administration, which fears the information will be leaked once it is in federal hands. "It just seems to me that FERC is trying to give generators more leverage," said Davis spokesman Steve Maviglio. "The more information we release, the more Californians are going to have to pay." FERC's letter to the 49 power suppliers came two days after Republican congressmen threatened to issue subpoenas for the contracts at a U.S. House Government Reform Committee hearing in Sacramento on the power crisis. "We want that information," Rep. Dan Burton, R-Ind., the committee chairman, told California Public Utilities Commission President Loretta Lynch. So do California news organizations -- including The San Diego Union-Tribune -- and Republican state lawmakers, who have filed separate suits to get it. The California Department of Water Resources has been buying power on behalf of the state's cash-strapped utilities. FERC said it wanted to see the contracts "to determine how successful efforts have been to fashion long-term contracts and to reduce reliance on spot markets," where electricity prices are typically higher. FERC issued an order Dec. 15 designed to encourage long-term contracts and bring some stability to California's chaotic power market. The letter to the power companies said FERC "intends to provide copies of the contracts to the Committee on Government Reform under confidential seal." A FERC spokeswoman said she was unsure whether that meant the committee would be obligated to keep the information secret. She referred the question to the committee. A spokesman for the committee could not be reached for comment. FERC gave the power suppliers until the close of business Monday to file the contract copies. Meanwhile, for the second time this week, Energy Secretary Spencer Abraham defended the Bush administration's response to the California crisis. Critics have blistered the administration for refusing to consider price controls on wholesale electricity. In a letter to members of Congress and California legislators released by the Energy Department on Friday, Abraham outlined 11 steps the administration and FERC have taken, such as ordering federal agencies to expedite permits for new power plants and asking power providers to do everything they can to avoid disruptions this summer. "Regrettably, our well-founded opposition to price caps has been claimed by some to suggest the administration either does not care about California and the West or is doing nothing to address the problem," Abraham wrote. Abraham made similar comments when briefing reporters Monday on the Energy Department's proposed budget for fiscal year 2002. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ---------------------------------------------- Escondido, San Marcos may be power partners Cities seeking way to forge rate deals By Jonathan Heller UNION-TRIBUNE STAFF WRITER April 14, 2001 ESCONDIDO -- After months of tiptoeing around the idea of working with San Marcos to buy cheap energy, the Escondido City Council might be ready to get serious. On Wednesday, the council is expected to direct City Manager Rolf Gunnarson to initiate a formal working arrangement with San Marcos officials on a project to seek inexpensive, stable energy rates. "The time for talking is over," said City Councilwoman June Rady. Rady approached San Marcos City Councilman Lee Thibadeau in January with the idea of the two cities working together. That was before Sempra Energy Resources made public its plans to build a 500-megawatt power plant in Escondido. Now Rady believes that the two cities can join forces and forge a deal with Sempra to nail down inexpensive electricity rates. Sempra officials have said they're willing to discuss possible rate deals with the city. If the council votes to move forward with the cooperative plan, Gunnarson would take the lead with San Marcos City Manager Rick Gittings. "I would propose to work closely with Mr. Gittings as well as the city attorney's office, and with legal and technical consultants, to develop policy options for the council to consider," Gunnarson wrote in a report to the council. To buy power directly, instead of through a utility such as San Diego Gas & Electric, a city has to adopt a special legal arrangement, such as forming a municipal utility district. San Marcos has done that, but it would be a more lengthy process for Escondido. San Marcos is a charter city and has more flexibility under the state Constitution. Escondido is a general law city. Escondido, however, might have the option of forming a joint-powers authority with San Marcos to buy power. Gittings said in a letter to Escondido officials that he believes the Sempra proposal is an excellent opportunity for both cities. "The project may possibly alleviate the power requirements of our two cities and provide a much-needed generating facility in the northeastern portion of the county," Gittings said. The Sempra plant would be built in Quail Hills in the southwestern part of Escondido, not far from the San Marcos boundary. Sempra has had several meetings with Escondido officials and residents, but has not yet submitted a formal proposal. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ --------------------------------------------------- Davis promises energy crisis won't cost voters 'one penny' ASSOCIATED PRESS April 14, 2001 LOS ANGELES ) Gov. Gray Davis promised that taxpayers will end up spending "not one penny" on the energy crisis because struggling utilities will repay billions of dollars the state treasury has spent to keep the lights on. "We will not only be paid for all our expenses to date, we'll have enough ... to continue buying power through this year and hopefully 2002," Davis told the Los Angeles Times on Friday. But the governor also admitted California still faces possible blackouts this summer, especially during hot spells when air conditioners will be running full blast. Davis has asked state lawmakers to approve spending another $500 million to buy power for bankrupt Pacific Gas and Electric and credit-poor Southern California Edison, bringing his total requests to $5.2 billion. The governor, however, said he expected the state money to be repaid by early 2003 under his plan to float $12.4 billion in bonds. The bonds, to be issued in June, would be repaid by utility ratepayers. The governor's plan, which was approved by the Legislature, was adopted with hopes that the state could negotiate long-term contracts with power suppliers and eventually stabilize prices. Those lower prices have yet to materialize, and state Treasurer Phil Angelides has raised questions about the plan in recent weeks. Davis also said he inherited the power crunch. He was state controller in 1996 when the state Legislature was discussing utility deregulation but "I basically wasn't asked to take a position and I didn't take a position," Davis said. "I didn't give it much thought." He also blamed the crunch on out-of-state wholesale electricity producers. They have gouged California utilities and are "the biggest snakes on the planet Earth," the governor said. But he reserved most of the blame for the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, calling it "the culprit" in the crisis. Davis said the commission has refused to cap wholesale prices, and as early as 1995 turned down state requests to build more power plants. On Friday, California's power grid operator called on the federal commission to increase the amount of money it ordered electricity generators to refund last month. The California Independent System Operator has said power generators have overcharged utilities billions of dollars more than the $124 million in January and February power sales questioned by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission so far. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ --------------------------------------------------- Utilities to Resume Paying Producers Electricity: Some small companies that provide power say the new rate plans are not enough to get them back online. By JULIE TAMAKI, Times Staff Writer ?????SACRAMENTO--The state's two biggest utilities are scheduled to resume paying hundreds of small power producers this week, but at least some producers say they plan to remain offline. ?????Jay Henneberry, an attorney representing a small gas-fired power plant in Oxnard, said his client does not plan to start generating electricity again for Southern California Edison today, because of a controversial new rate plan that he said would force his client to operate at a loss. ?????The company, EF Oxnard Inc., sued Edison last week, alleging that the utility owes it more than $13.5 million for past electricity deliveries. The lack of payment, according to EF Oxnard officials, prompted natural gas suppliers to cut them off in February, forcing Oxnard to stop producing electricity. ?????Henneberry noted that the new rate plan fails to address the utilities' past debt to producers, which who are collectively owed more than $1.8 billion. ?????"Those payments are only on a going-forward basis," Henneberry said. "They do nothing for $13.5 million owed to my client." ?????The situation underscores the problems the state faces as it tries to get California's nearly 700 producers of alternative and renewable energy paid and, in cases such as EF Oxnard, back in business. ?????These companies, which include producers of solar, wind and thermal power, provide more than a quarter of the electricity consumed in California. But their output has been cut by as much as half in recent weeks due in part to the payment problems. ?????A new rate plan approved by the Public Utilities Commission last month to help get those producers paid has triggered a growing number of gas-fired power producers to sue Pacific Gas & Electric and Edison to get out of their contracts with the utilities. The power suppliers say the new rate plan would force them to operate at a loss, because it does not adequately compensate them for rising natural gas costs. ?????"We are not going to run our plants if we can't run them profitably," said Marty Quinn, executive vice president and chief operating officer of Ridgewood Power LLC, which owns three small gas-fired generators in California that are not operating. ?????In a related matter, a hearing is scheduled today in a legal battle between Edison and a small geothermal producer. An Imperial County judge previously freed CalEnergy from its contract with Edison because of the utility's failure to pay the company, which has since been selling its supplies on the wholesale power market. ?????The court is expected to rule today on CalEnergy's request for roughly $100 million in payments it is owed by Edison, and could also act on an Edison request that Cal- Energy be required to resume selling power to the utility. ?????"If Edison shows that it is credit-worthy and capable of making payments on a going-forward basis, I'm sure the judge will take that into account," said CalEnergy official Jonathan Weisgall. "But one of our concerns is how long will Edison continue to make these payments." ?????An official with Sierra Pacific Industries, which received court permission earlier this month to sell power generated by six plants it owns in California to a buyer other than PG&E, said Sierra Pacific does not plan to resume transmitting electricity to the utility. ?????"From our point of view we have terminated those contracts," said Bob Ellery, Sierra Pacific's director of energy resources. ?????Henneberry said he doubts that Edison plans to pay EF Oxnard because the new rate arrangement covers only deliveries made in April and beyond. ?????An Edison spokesman said his company sent payments totaling $206 million to small producers Friday, but said he did not know whether checks were sent to producers that have gone offline. A spokesman for PG&E estimates that the monthly bill to small producers will total $200 million to $400 million. ?????Ridgewood, Oxnard and Sierra Pacific generate a total of 140 megawatts of electricity, or enough power to serve more than 105,000 typical homes. State officials have at times been forced to replace the lost deliveries by purchasing power on the pricey wholesale and spot markets. ?????The California Independent System Operator, which oversees the state's power grid, said it received about 3,800 megawatts of power Friday from small producers, compared to the 6,000 megawatts the small producers usually deliver. In recent weeks the group's output has dipped as low as 3,000 megawatts. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ---------------------------------------------------------------- Tariff May Limit Flow of Natural Gas Power: A tax designed to protect the Gas Co. may be stifling efforts to ship more of the fuel needed by many California generators. By CHRISTINE HANLEY, Times Staff Writer ?????Two projects aimed at boosting the capacity of California's natural gas delivery network are stalled by a little-known tariff that power companies would have to pay to use the new pipelines. ?????The tax was established six years ago by the Public Utilities Commission and requires electricity generators and other natural gas customers to pay an extra fee if they use pipelines not controlled by Southern California Gas Co. ?????At the time, officials as well as consumer advocates believed the tariff would protect the firm's residential and small business owners. ?????But amid California's energy crisis, some officials contend that the tariff is preventing the state from boosting pipeline capacity at a time when more natural gas is desperately needed to fuel power plants. ?????California, which makes more than half its electricity from natural gas, has not expanded its gas distribution network in eight years. Experts warn that the system is running close to capacity and that easing constraints is a crucial step in any rescue plan. ?????Two companies are trying to add capacity: Questar wants to convert an old oil pipeline that runs 700 miles underground from New Mexico to Long Beach, and Williams Co. wants to push its existing Kern River-Mojave pipeline farther west, also to Long Beach. ?????But both companies said they are having trouble signing up customers because power companies don't want to pay the tariff. ?????Watson Cogeneration Co., which operates a 400-megawatt generator in Los Angeles County, is considering using Questar's pipelines but said it cannot complete any deal until the tariff issue is resolved. ?????"With the state building all these new gas-fired plants, the question I have is, where are they going to get the gas?" said Pat King, executive director of the firm. ?????Questar, Williams Co. and other energy companies have been fighting the tariff in a series of hearings before the PUC. Last year, the commission concluded that the tariff may discourage the construction of badly needed new power plants in Southern California and asked the Gas Co. to develop a new pricing system. ?????But the issue was reassigned earlier this year to a new administrative law judge as the commission reshuffled its load to handle more pressing energy emergencies. That judge does not expect a final ruling any time soon. ?????"The case is in limbo," said Carol Brown, the judge, who must sift through years of transcripts before writing a draft decision. She predicted that "we might all be old and gray" by the time a final vote is taken by the full commission. ?????Enacted in 1995, the so-called Residual Load Service tariff can levy massive penalties against Gas Co. customers who choose an alternate distributor but later have to return to the company's network. ?????If service on a competing pipeline is interrupted, a power plant that had to switch back to the Gas Co. for a day of deliveries could be charged what it would cost to reserve that capacity for an entire year. ?????For many power plants, the risk of leaving the Gas. Co. with the tariff in place is simply too high. ?????"If there's any risk that that might happen, there's no way you're going to sign up for another pipeline, because you'd end up paying twice for natural gas service," said Tom Beach, a former PUC staffer and a consultant for Crossborder Energy who testified against the tariff. "It just shows how punitive this rate is and how it discourages people from bringing in new pipelines and trying to compete with SoCal Gas." ?????Critics charge that the tariff is so punitive that not a single power supplier has left Southern California Gas. ?????The tariff was approved with ratepayers in mind--and actually was heavily endorsed by consumer activists. Without it, they said, Southern California Gas could pass on any loss in business from competing pipelines to its residential and other core customers. ?????Still, Pacific Gas & Electric Co., California's other top gas utility, has never requested such a tariff to protect its Northern California territory from competitors. ?????But as PG&E itself points out, the market is more competitive in Southern California, where four of the five major interstate pipelines serving California cross the state border. ?????"We never felt we needed it," said Staci Homrig, a PG&E spokeswoman. "There's not the same competitive situation up here as there is down there." ?????The Gas Co. says the tariff is necessary to prevent power plants from shopping around for the best pipeline deal and then using the company's lines as a backup system during emergencies. The company said that could disrupt service to its regular customers. ?????"It's not really economical to have our facilities standing by--not being used--and not being paid for it," said Steve Rahon, a Gas Co. regulatory manager. "They want our facilities to be ready in case they can't receive all of their load from the Questar pipeline. We want this tariff to be able to charge a fair price for that." ?????Furthermore, the utility says, its customers need to be protected from higher rates and the utility needs to be able to compete on a level playing field with interstate pipelines that play by different pricing and delivery rules. ?????The pipeline companies agree that bypass customers should pay a price for swinging back and forth between providers. But they argue that the existing tariff is so high it is preventing fair competition. As proof of that, they say, energy companies have resisted siting power plants in the Gas Co.'s territory. What's more, the tariff has never been triggered. ?????"It's important to note that no one has ever taken service under this rate because it's such a risk," Beach said. ?????During a rate proceeding last year, the PUC found that "gas supply competition is critical to the economic survival of both existing and new electric generators" and agreed that the tariff may be discouraging the siting of new power plants in the Los Angeles Basin. ?????The commission ordered Southern California Gas to come up with a new pricing system that must "not be the equivalent" of the old one. The Gas Co. has proposed two alternative rate structures, both of which do not impress the pipeline companies. ?????It will be up to Brown, the administrative law judge, to choose between the Gas Co.'s proposals and those suggested by opposing parties. She could also suggest yet another rate, or repeal the existing tariff altogether. ?????"I need to write a decision. And that's kind of a daunting project," said Brown, who inherited the case in January. ?????"I really can't give you a projection," she said. "It's one of those things that if the commission decides it's incredibly important and needs it done, it will be moved to the top of my list. And that order could come at any time or it might never come." ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------ Experts Doubtful About Rush to Build Small Power Plants Energy: State wants ,peaker, units to fill 40% of summer gap. But various factors make that seem unlikely. By TIM REITERMAN, Times Staff Writer ?????Gov. Gray Davis has mobilized state government and invited developers to put dozens of small +peaker+ power plants online +at warp speed+ to help avert blackouts this summer. ?????But, as California races against time, industry experts say the logistics and uncertainties of power plant construction make it doubtful the state will have as much peaker electricity as it is seeking: ?????Generating turbines--which resemble giant jet engines--are in tight supply. Design, engineering, construction and testing take several months. And community opposition is sometimes a concern because the plants can be noisy and add to air pollution. ?????Without knowing how much people will conserve, state officials estimate the summer energy shortage at about 5,000 megawatts--enough to serve 3.7 million homes. They are counting on emergency peaking plants, usually providing 50 to 100 megawatts each, to make up about 40% of that shortfall. ?????But records and interviews with energy experts, state officials and potential plant developers show that: ?????* A contracting program the state hopes will bring in about 1,100 megawatts of peaking power has been stalled for weeks. Officials are still negotiating with about 10 developers and are uncertain how much power will be available for summer. ?????* An effort begun last year to issue plant permits within four months led to approval of only one 50-megawatt plant at San Francisco International Airport. Officials there say the deal is collapsing. Half a dozen other plant applications were withdrawn due to site problems, including pollution. ?????* The state,s new accelerated 21-day permit approval program is far from meeting Davis, goal of getting plants capable of producing an additional 1,000 megawatts in operation for the summer. ?????The California Energy Commission approved two projects, and five more are being reviewed, for a total of about 500 megawatts. State officials concede that not all the power will be available the entire summer because developers have until Sept. 30--after summer ends--to get plants online. ?????During a recent workshop to promote the construction of peaker plants, Roger Johnson of the energy commission said the panel is tracking an additional 900 megawatts worth of plant proposals that developers are expected to file in April. ?????+It is possible we can meet the goal,+ he said, adding that Southern California Edison has 20 requests for new power plant hookups totaling an additional 1,665 megawatts. ?????Can those proposed Southern California plants, most of them designed to run during times of peak electricity demand, be ready for the summer? ?????+We don,t think so,+ said Ronald D. Nunnally, director of federal regulation and contracts in Edison,s transmission and distribution unit. +There,s a lot of hurdles. . . . A workshop [like this] would be more useful for next summer. ?????+Anything not in the process now has [only] a remote chance of being online this summer,+ he said in a remark echoed by a number of plant developers. +Chances are slim.+ ?????,People Can,t Seem to Move, ?????The state reserved a cavernous auditorium at an Ontario hotel March 29 for what was billed as a workshop and +energy fair.+ About 50 potential developers, consultants and sellers of power turbines attended. And many, while praising the state,s efforts to encourage deal-making and streamline permitting, had no deals on the horizon, let alone in the works. ?????+People can,t seem to move,+ said Los Angeles consultant and developer Bob Hoffman, who attended the conference to sell a Japanese turbine that could power a peaker plant. +I talked to people with great projects. It doesn, t seem to be congealing.+ ?????After two weeks on the California market, the turbine was later sold for use in a plant in Nigeria. ?????To encourage plant development, the state has compressed the permit process. It has offered to quickly contract to purchase power. It has helped prospective developers find smog credits, which allow them to emit air pollutants for a price per ton. And it has enlisted major utilities in quickly hooking up proposed plants to natural gas lines that fuel them and to the grid that carries electricity to users. ?????+Nobody has ever moved this rapidly, still being mindful of all environmental standards, to put power online,+ Davis told The Times, editorial board Friday. ?????The energy commission has also developed a list of potential peaker plant sites that have a minimum of two acres and proximity to gas and electricity infrastructure. ?????The commission identified the San Francisco Bay Area, parts of the Central Valley and San Diego as the regions most in need of peaking power plants, but said the Los Angeles region could also benefit. ?????Thirty-two sites with a potential for producing 1,700 to 3,400 megawatts of peaking power passed the initial screening for suitability, according to a Feb. 21 report. They ranged from a soap factory in Sacramento County and a paper mill in Ontario to the former Ft. Ord army base near Monterey and the Pitchess Honor Ranch in Los Angeles County. ?????The only project approved under the four-month permitting program initiated after outages last summer was El Paso Merchant Energy Co.,s proposed United Golden Gate plant, which would provide about 50 megawatts to San Francisco International Airport. +The deal is not dead but it,s near dead,+ said airport spokesman Ron Wilson. +We,re looking for another supplier.+ Company spokeswoman Kim Wallace said the firm still hopes to make a deal. ?????The California Independent System Operator contracted with developers of about 29 peaker plants last year, but the state Department of Water Resources, which has been buying power since mid-January, is renegotiating longer pacts. +We will try to get as many as we can for this summer,+ said Vijay Patel of the department. +They are all in play.+ ?????The new contracts, he said, will be for five to 10 years and allow plants to run several thousand hours a year--far more than peaking plants commonly do. The companies, he said, would be free to sell power on the open market after they fulfilled their power sales contracts to California. ?????+These will run in peak periods and any time we need to call for power,+ said energy commission spokesman Rob Schlichting. +Maybe we should call them Stage 3 power plants.+ ?????When The Times contacted owners of about 20 plant sites on the state list, few said they had deals or solid proposals for construction. Many were fielding calls from owners of turbines and potential developers who had seen their names on a state Web site. ?????+We,re on the list but don,t belong there,+ said Dave Rib, manager of a solar plant in Boron. +We are the largest solar plant in the world. We,re here in the Mojave Desert. We do not develop plants, and we have no plans to. Maybe [the energy commission] will find a developer.+ ?????Exploring Several Sites ?????Several sites are being explored by Calpine, which has 11 turbines and a contract to provide 495 megawatts to the state, starting with 90 in August. The proposed peaker locations are in Northern California. Spokesman Bill Highlander said the company will not divulge more precise locations until a feasibility study is finished. ?????In Solano County, a peaker has been in planning since last summer at Lambie Industrial Park, named after nearby pastures with lambs. ?????Hal Mitchell, a principal of Sterling Energy, said the plant will produce 147 megawatts and could be running by September. +We have a client who wanted to put some assets in the ground,+ he said. +Coincidentally the big crunch came along. [It] would have been built despite the energy crisis. ?????+We,ve been getting all kinds of calls, people selling equipment, people trying to buy projects, and flakes,+ Mitchell added. +Some say, ,I got five acres on top of a mountain. How ,bout building me a power plant?, + ?????Phil Consiglio, vice president of Merit Energy Systems in Burbank, said he is close to contracting with a developer at Ft. Ord, a former military base that now houses Cal State Monterey, among other things. +There is an area scheduled for utility usage,+ he said. +We found an area where they are removing contaminated water [from the ground] and cleaning it. It,s not potable, but we can use it for a power plant. ?????+It will not be up and running for the summer.+ ?????Two oil production facilities in Inglewood and Montebello are on the list. Steve Rusch, manager of government affairs for Stocker Resources Inc., said three developers are interested in one of the sites. But he said he is skeptical that such sites can be turned into plants by summer. +The biggest issue is land use,+ he said. + ,Not in my backyard., . . . Another thing is that pollution offsets are tough to get. The reins need to be loosened up.+ ?????A Stocker site in San Luis Obispo County is on a list of more than 100 other potential sites that state officials say require further evaluation. These include a soup factory and a former nuclear power plant. ?????Some sites were found to have +fatal flaws+ because they were too near habitat of endangered species such as the fairy shrimp. Numerous sites are hydroelectric facilities owned by Pacific Gas & Electric Co. in mountainous areas far from gas lines necessary to fuel them. ?????Anticipated community resistance was listed as a problem with a site in Morro Bay, where Duke Energy is already expanding a full-size power plant. ?????+This [listing] is news to me,+ said Duke spokesman Tom Williams. +We can,t even burp in Morro Bay without a permit.+ ?????Mark Seedaal, Duke,s director of electrical modernization, said it would probably take the company nine months to design, install and get on the grid even a small peaker plant of 50 megawatts. +You don,t just drive up on a truck, put it down and drive away,+ he said. +I don,t see how you can do it by the summer of 2001.+ ?????The Sacramento Municipal Utility District has an existing cogeneration plant at a Procter & Gamble factory and is already building a peaker scheduled to begin operation in May. ?????+We,re a little confused as to why we,re on the state list,+ said spokesman Greg Fishman. So how long did the district,s peaker take to build? +It is a seven- or eight-month process to do the actual construction,+ he said. +And . . . getting the parts is often a yearlong process.+ ?????One site on the state list is in Redding, where the municipal utility district broke ground on a 43-megawatt plant that was two years in the planning and will not be finished much before summer of 2002. ?????+The state would like to take some credit, but it is all the city of Redding,+ said Pat Keener, group manager for energy services. ?????The first two projects approved by the energy commission under the 21-day program are Wildflower Energy LP peakers totaling 225 megawatts in Palm Springs and San Diego. Project manager John Jones said that they have been in development since last year, that construction started a week ago and that the plants should be running sometime in July. ?????+If [other developers] have not started [the permitting] already,+ he said, +it would be a real challenge to be up by the summer.+ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------ Davis Says All Power Costs to Be Recovered Crisis: Governor vows that under his plan, billions spent by the state will be recouped within months. He admits summer outages are an ominous possibility. By MITCHELL LANDSBERG and MIGUEL BUSTILLO, Times Staff Writers ?????Billions of dollars that have been drained from the state treasury to buy electricity so far this year will be fully repaid by June 30, and taxpayers will wind up spending +not one penny+ on the energy crisis, an optimistic Gov. Gray Davis pledged Friday. ?????+We will not only be paid off for all our expenses to date, we,ll have enough . . . to continue buying power through this year and hopefully through 2002,+ Davis said in an interview with Times editors and reporters. ?????The governor admitted that Californians face an uncertain--and possibly treacherous--summer. Already, he said, state officials have begun consulting with law enforcement officials around the country to develop a plan for dealing with the blackouts that could become a part of daily life during hot spells. ?????But he was nevertheless upbeat about the financial package he has crafted to rescue the state,s big private utilities. And he was unusually salty in his denunciations of those he considers responsible for the power shortages and price surges that have wreaked havoc in the state,s newly deregulated electricity market. ?????Davis described the out-of-state power generators and marketers who have raised the price of electricity by hundreds of percentage points as +the biggest snakes on the planet Earth.+ ?????He questioned what his predecessors in state leadership were thinking when they failed to plan for growth in electricity demand. But he saved most of his vituperation for the federal agency that has refused the state,s entreaties to place a cap on wholesale electricity prices. ?????+If you,re looking for a culprit, I,ll give you a culprit,+ he said. +The culprit is the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission.+ As far back as 1995, Davis charged, the commission was undermining California by overruling state agencies that were seeking permission to build more power plants. ?????+They,ve consistently turned a deaf ear to my pleas, Sen. [Dianne] Feinstein,s pleas, the pleas of the governors and representatives of Oregon and Washington,+ he said. +So if there is a villain, it clearly is the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission.+ ?????Davis said the state was forging ahead on its own to solve the crisis. Through a combination of an $850-million conservation plan and what the governor described as the fastest power plant construction program in California history, the state hopes to keep blackouts to a minimum this summer. ?????Asked what he would tell Californians who will be paying higher rates while suffering through outages, Davis said: +Look . . . we live in one of the best places on the planet at one of the most fortunate times. Virtually nobody alive had to go through the Holocaust, the Depression, any of the world wars. . . . In everyone,s life comes a little sun and a little rain. We have to just act like adults and work our way through this problem. That,s what I,d say.+ ?????Blaming Others for the Crisis ?????Davis expressed frustration at the hand he has been dealt, repeatedly insisting that he had inherited the power problems, not created them. ?????At the time that deregulation was being considered by the Legislature in 1996, Davis was state controller. +I basically wasn,t asked to take a position and I didn,t take a position,+ he said. +I didn,t give it much thought.+ ?????Since January, the state has been forced to spend $5.2 billion buying power that Southern California Edison and Pacific Gas & Electric have been unable to afford. ?????A Davis-sponsored plan approved by the Legislature calls for the state to float bonds to repay the state and help finance the purchases. The bonds, in turn, would be repaid by utility ratepayers through their monthly bills. ?????The plan was based on the premise that the state would be able to stabilize, and eventually lower, the price of electricity by entering into long-term contracts with power suppliers. Those lower prices have yet to materialize. ?????On average, California has been burning through $50 million a day on electricity--and that number will soon go up to about $57 million, administration officials say, because of a federal regulatory decision last week. That decision requires the state to buy power on behalf of cash-poor utilities, regardless of price. ?????Despite the mind-numbing figures, Davis and his financial advisors insisted Friday that they have created a plan that will make the utilities self-supporting--and take taxpayers off the hook--by early 2003. Here,s how: ?????* A record $12.4 billion in bonds scheduled to be issued in June would not only repay the budget, but would cover future state purchases of electricity and help the utilities repay their debts. ?????* New, higher electricity rates would give California about $6 billion this year. That money, along with the portion of the bond money left over after repayment of the state,s debts, would be used to finance future state power purchases. ?????The rationale behind those estimates is nearly impossible to scrutinize, because Davis, cadre of Wall Street advisors and utility experts has refused to make public the contract information on which the figures are based. ?????They have even kept the information from state Treasurer Phil Angelides--the elected official charged with implementing the bond deal that is the linchpin of the recovery plan. ?????In recent weeks, Angelides has made a series of public statements raising questions about the plan. ?????At the current rate that California is spending money on electricity, Angelides estimated, the bond issue will run out this fall--not, as Davis said, in 2002. ?????Davis and his advisors said Friday that Angelides did not understand the true status of California,s foray into the power business because the administration had not shared its numbers with him. Davis planned to share more information with Angelides in coming weeks as the bond deal grew nearer, they said. The state will also be required to disclose some information when its bonds are offered for sale. ?????Davis insisted Friday that he has crafted +a very well thought-through plan,+ adding that it had been given the +Good Housekeeping Seal of Approval+ by major Wall Street investment firms. ?????Davis complained that the energy crisis has diverted his attention from other pressing matters, and said that, since late December, he has spent a total of only 10 working hours dealing with issues other than energy. ?????+I realize I have to deal with it but it,s ridiculous,+ Davis said. +I can,t deal with education, the environment, health care, nothing. That,s all I do.+ ?????In other developments Friday: ?????* A key Davis aide, Communications Director Phil Trounstine, resigned his $113,000-a-year job +to spend more time with my family and pursue a variety of offers in strategic communications.+ ?????Trounstine, a former newspaper political writer who has written many of Davis, key speeches, had most recently been coordinating the governor,s energy conservation publicity campaign. The resignation will take effect at the end of the month. ?????* A state energy panel recommended Friday that AES Corp., a major power generator in California, should be forced to sell any electricity it makes from two now mothballed generators in Huntington Beach to the state in exchange for expedited review of the company,s operating permit. ?????The California Energy Commission,s licensing committee, which is overseeing the company,s pursuit of a fast-track permit, had previously stopped short of attaching such a condition to the project after being warned by commission lawyers that doing so would violate interstate commerce laws. ?????But in a revised decision, the committee found that without a sales provision guaranteeing that power will be sold to California, the state would be deprived of its ability to effectively respond to the energy crisis. ?????If adopted by the full energy commission, which is scheduled to consider AES, permit request Wednesday in Sacramento, the sales requirement would set a precedent. --- ?????Times staff writer Christine Hanley contributed to this story. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ -------------------------------------------------------------- Monday, April 16, 2001 Long, Hot, Costly Days With a power-hungry summer nearing, state leaders and other Californians aren't doing enough to prepare. And that's risky business. ?????It's going to be a long, hot, frustrating and expensive summer in California. Even a grim recent forecast that the state would endure 34 days of rolling blackouts could be optimistic. It could also be a dangerous summer. One energy expert says, "We need to prepare for this as if we're preparing for a natural diaster." But we're not, or not enough, perhaps because Gov. Gray Davis seems loath to admit that the state's immediate energy future is as bad as it is. ?????Look at it this way. A megawatt-hour is enough power to serve about 1,000 average homes for one hour. This August, some of those megawatt-hours may cost, wholesale, nearly 20 times what they cost two years ago--an increase from $40 in August 1999 to $750 in contracts already made for this August. ?????Peak summer demand in California is 55,000 megawatts or more. The state could fall 3,000 to 7,000 megawatts a day short of that, in part because drought in the Pacific Northwest will severely curtail hydropower. ?????Davis says the $850-million conservation program he signed into law last week, combined with existing programs, can cut at least 5,000 megawatts from peak demand this summer. But at this late date, it will be very difficult to get a persuasive statewide program into effect before the hot days arrive. ?????Higher electricity rates, pending before the Public Utilities Commission, and the governor's promise of a 20% rebate for power savings should spur some conservation. Again, those actions have yet to be implemented and are unlikely to have much effect in time for air conditioning season. ?????Even so, Californians can certainly understand that every kilowatt they save is a kilowatt that need not be scrounged at top dollar. Every thousand kilowatts add up to a megawatt that won't have to be bought from unscrupulous generators selling at villainous prices during the hours of high demand--prices that will be demanded even if they cripple the California economy that is laying such golden eggs for the sellers. ?????The biggest power hog is air conditioning, for both homes and businesses. Part of the state's conservation program is intended to help finance more efficient new systems, but considerable savings can be made through just a good inspection and repair and turning up the thermostat a few degrees. ?????When blackouts do come, the state and the utilities should put them on a set schedule rather than conducting them at random. This would help eliminate some of the uncertainty and panic involved. Cities with municipal power systems, including Los Angeles, will avoid blackouts but can help by conserving power and continuing to sell the resulting surplus to other parts of the state. ?????Gov. Davis says he expects to have perhaps four new plants up and producing by August. He spins a scenario of a tough summer followed by a continuous easing as more plants are built, prices come down and the state gets out of the power-buying business. He also says the state will be repaid every penny it has spent to buy power as Sacramento issues revenue bonds funded by the coming electricity price increases. ?????We can only take Davis at his word. He has not offered an accounting of the spending from the state's general fund to buy power, both daily and in long-term contracts, or revealed the assumptions that underlie his projections. Of course the money for repayment will come from higher rates paid by consumers. The public interest in how these billions are spent overshadows any fear that companies might find out the details of long-term contracts, which Davis cites as the cause for his secrecy. ?????Even if residents and businesses are wholehearted in their conservation, however, and even if the state does everything right to increase supply, there's still the obstinate Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, which seems not to understand the word "regulatory." FERC refuses to impose a reasonable, cost-based and very temporary price cap on wholesale power sales in the West. The main opponent of price caps, FERC Chairman Curtis L. Hebert Jr., says caps don't work because "the energy is going to go where the money is." That sounds just like legendary bank robber Willie Sutton, who said he robbed banks because that's where the money is. ?????Open markets are fine--when they work right. Power is a necessity of life. The federal government has an obligation to protect the public health and safety. A temporary cap that allowed for a healthy profit would not discourage energy companies from investing in new power plants. It would certainly prevent Californians from being mugged again and might help the state avoid a true calamity. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------- Passing Along the Cost Many Bay Area businesses resort to surcharges to survive Matthew Yi, Chronicle Staff Writer Monday, April 16, 2001 ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle URL: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/chronicle/archive/2001/04/16/M N52884.DTL Just outside the double doors of the Englander Sports Pub & Restaurant in San Leandro is a hand-written sign: "There will be a 5% PG&E surcharge added to all food served." It's more than just a sign of the times in these days of energy crisis in California. As gas and electricity bills skyrocket, many businesses around the Bay Area are resorting to adding energy surcharges to stay afloat. Hotels around the state already have started asking customers to pay more. Now, even everyday consumptions such as dining out and working out at the gym will cost more. "It was fun to do business. You go home, sleep at night time, get up the next day and say, 'Hey, we're gonna do it all over again,' " said Englander owner Jot Mangat, 46. "But now, you go home and you're wondering how much my PG&E bill is going to be. Where is this money going to come from?" Last year, his power bill was around $3,400 a month. But in February, it nearly doubled to $6,000, and that's even before the Public Utilities Commission decided to raise rates as much as 40 percent this year. Mangat thinks that by this summer, his power bills may eclipse his monthly rent, which is $8,000 for his downtown San Leandro establishment. "This is one of the nicest restaurants in San Leandro," he said. "San Leandro is proud of this place, but PG&E can put us out of business." Mark Cavalli, 34, and Donna Clark, 35, both of Oakland, said they had been caught off guard when they noticed the $1 energy surcharge added to their dinner bill on Friday at the Englander. "I felt I understood it, especially with all those TVs running," Clark said. "But I didn't like the place enough to come back here again and pay the surcharge. If I liked it more, maybe I wouldn't mind paying extra." SLIM MARGINS, HIGH PRICES Escalating power costs are particularly hard on restaurants because their profit margin is already slim, averaging 2 to 7 percent, said John Dunlap, president and CEO of the California Restaurant Association, a lobbying group in Sacramento. "If you're a restaurateur on the brink . . . or if you're not having a good year, this could push you over the edge," Dunlap said. "You're going to see hundreds of restaurants closing statewide because of this. . . . I can assure you, there will be a body count." And that's exactly what Martha Pena, manager at Fentons Creamery & Restaurant in Oakland, wants to avoid. The popular ice cream parlor started adding energy surcharges to customers' bills two months ago: 25 cents per $10 for takeouts and 30 cents per $10 for dining in. They also posted a sign near the front door to alert customers. "Sometimes people ask us why we're doing this, but after we give them the explanation, they say they understand," Pena said. Fentons' ice cream was still as sweet Saturday, even with the 30-cent bump in their lunch bill, said John and Theresa Strickland of Pleasanton. "Actually we didn't even notice," John Strickland said, adding that he was willing to pay the little bit extra if it meant keeping a place like Fentons in business. BUSINESS THREAT "The energy crisis is going to put smaller places out of business unless they add surcharges," Theresa Strickland said. "The little fish can't compete with the big sharks." Fentons' gas bill more than doubled from $400 to $1,000 a month since last year, while the electricity bill has stayed relatively stable at around $300. But that was during the winter season when the business doesn't have to blast its air conditioning. The power bill picture will likely look drastically different when the weather warms up this spring and summer, said Fentons bookkeeper Dan Tonelli. Bars and restaurants are not the only businesses to feel the pinch. At the Albany Sauna & Hot Tubs, owner Tim Adam has already raised prices twice since December. "It's really upsetting that we're passing this on (to our customers)," he said. "People who come in here are just ordinary people who care about their health. . . . People are saying they're paying more everywhere. . . . What we're frustrated about is that (our) cost of living is going up." For half-hour sessions, Adam raised the price from $9 to $10 last December, and then added another $1 starting April 6. The increases aren't arbitrary. Adam carefully calculated the figures to make sure the extra revenues just cover his PG&E bill, which has tripled. Adam already has tried to cut down by installing energy efficient light bulbs, shutting down unneeded lights and asking customers to use only one towel. But the bottom line is that his business needs energy to heat water for hot tubs, rocks for the dry sauna, and to run washers and dryers for towels. YMCA ADDS $1 SURCHARGE Across the Bay, the YMCA of San Francisco also has decided to add energy surcharges: $1 per month across the board for everyone. After six months, the YMCA will reconsider whether to stop, continue or increase the surcharges, spokeswoman Jane Holt said. At the Central YMCA in the Tenderloin, the gas bill has nearly tripled to $23,000 as administrators scramble for ways to save energy, she said. "We've put in fluorescent lights. . . . All the boilers and other systems are working as efficiently as possible . . . insulated the pipes, added digital timers for lights," Holt said. But that hasn't put a dent in the monthly bill. And despite the extra fees that will be collected from the Central YMCA's 3, 500 members, that will not cover increases in the PG&E bills, forcing the group to use reserve funds, Holt said. Jerry Englebardt, a runner and Y member from New York who visits San Francisco four months a year, said he noticed the increase but wasn't bothered because "the facilities here are so good." "In New York," Englebardt said, "they think people in California are going around with candles. It's being played up as if California is going out of business. But it's not true." HEALTH CLUBS RAISE FEES Health clubs that feature heated pools, with their high energy costs, are really feeling the pinch. Linda Hansen, general manager of Walnut Creek Sports & Fitness Club, said adding a $3.50 per month energy surcharge to her members' fees was difficult because they had just raised their rates by 7 percent at the end of last year. "We have one heated pool, and we keep it at 83 degrees," Hansen said. "When we had the cold spell, that was killing us. . . . But what else can we do?" "Inside, I'm screaming . . ." Hansen said. "I'm angry, really angry that the state of California has put the businesses in such a precarious situation." Tell Us What You Think -- Can you save 20 percent on your energy usage? Gov. Gray Davis' administration is offering rebates to Californians who save on power starting in June, and if you've got a strategy for conserving, The Chronicle wants to hear it. We'll be writing about the hardest-working energy savers in a future story. To get involved, write to the Energy Desk, San Francisco Chronicle, 901 Mission St., San Francisco CA 94103; or send e-mail to energysaver@sfchronicle. com. Chronicle staff writers Tyche Hendricks and Meredith May contributed to this report. / E-mail Matthew Yi at myi@sfchronicle.com. ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle ? Page?A - 1 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ --------------------------------------------------------------- Time Seems Bright for Solar Power Big companies bring financial clout to field Jim Doyle, Chronicle Staff Writer Monday, April 16, 2001 ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle URL: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/chronicle/archive/2001/04/16/M N28455.DTL On the sun-bleached floor of the Mojave Desert, solar-thermal plants are producing electricity to fulfill a long-term contract with Southern California Edison Co. Rows of parabolic mirrors focus the sun's rays into a high-energy beam that heats an element to make steam, which turns an electrical turbine. In all, nine solar-thermal units near Barstow generate enough daytime power for 350, 000 homes. "This technology has been around for 15 years," said Bob Cable, manager of KJC Operating Co., which runs five of the solar-thermal units for investors that include East Coast utilities and insurance firms. "It's very reliable. And with today's high fuel prices, we're a bargain. "There's really nothing like us in the world," Cable said. And for renewable energy advocates, that's the problem. Solar-thermal is just one of several renewable forms of energy that have languished for years. No new plants have been built in a decade, mainly because power produced using low-cost fossil fuels made alternative energy look pricey. But now that the price of natural gas has shot up, solar, wind and geothermal are more attractive to big energy suppliers. "There's a lot of consolidation in the field now. Big players are coming in and setting up divisions for solar and wind energy," said Dave Renee, a research analyst for the National Renewable Energy Laboratory in Golden, Colo., a division of the U.S. Department of Energy. Even before the power crisis, oil and gas companies were increasing their stake in renewables and buying up smaller energy firms because of rising fuel costs and tighter environmental restrictions on fossil fuel plants. Sharp, the Japanese electronics company, last year became the world's largest producer of photovoltaic solar cells, which convert sunlight directly into electricity. At the Sydney Olympics, BP Solar -- a division of British Petroleum's energy-producing empire -- powered a solar suburb of 650 homes to house the athletes. A year ago, Shell Oil created its Shell Renewables division, which formed a joint venture with Siemens Solar, another leading manufacturer of solar cells. Shell predicts that by 2050 half the U.S. energy mix will be renewable. Enron, the Texas supplier of natural gas, has bought Zond, a major wind power company. The oil companies have also invested in hydrogen fuel cell technology, which may soon be used to power cars, homes, offices and factories. "We think the new technologies are going to get better, and prices will come down," said George Douglas, a spokesman for the National Renewable Energy Laboratory. "And we think the price of conventional power plants, whatever fuel they're using, is going to come up." 12 PERCENT RENEWABLE POWER Today, only 12 percent of California's power comes from renewables, but advocates envision a future electrical grid with a diverse mix of nonpolluting energy sources, large and small. "California should be much more aggressive in pursuing the renewable energy options," said Dick Swanson, president of SunPower Corp., a Silicon Valley company that has developed new solar technology being used in power plants in Australia and Arizona. "We are leaving the state too vulnerable if we are too dependent on natural gas." Gov. Gray Davis wants to rush 5,000 megawatts of capacity into service by July through construction of large and small power plants. Renewable energy advocates say Californians should carefully consider which kind. "The investments we make this year and next year will stay with us for the next 30 years," said Kari Smith, a regulatory affairs manager for Powerlight, which makes photovoltaic systems for factories and office parks. "We need to promote as much renewable energy as possible so that we're not stuck again with a fossil fuel economy." Sixteen percent of the new 5,000 megawatts will come from renewables -- mainly from wind power, but also from biomass, energy created from organic waste. The California Energy Commission's $202 million subsidy program for renewable plants offers financing incentives of as much as 1.5 cents per kilowatt hour, or up to one quarter of cost, to help these systems compete. ECONOMIC INCENTIVES Environmentalists want more economic incentives for renewables, and also taxes on fossil fuel power plants to offset the pollution they cause. Since the 1970s, most government subsidies for renewable technologies have gone to solar power, although it accounts for less than 1 percent of the state's electricity -- less than geothermal (5 percent), wind (2 percent), small hydro plants (3 percent) and biomass (2 percent). Solar has proved costly to develop, but appears to be on the verge of paying off. "In the last 20 years the cost of producing electricity from solar cells has dropped tenfold," Douglas said. "We can expect it to drop at a similar rate over the next 20 years by raising efficiencies of solar cells and decreasing the manufacturing costs." The U.S. market for solar energy has grown steadily in recent years, but more than 70 percent of photovoltaic systems are exported to developing countries. Solar panels, used since the late 1950s on orbiting satellites, are only now becoming affordable. A household unit can cost $10,000 to $30,000, though in California, state rebates can reduce the cost by half. In December, the state Energy Commission received 50 applications from homes and businesses for its "buy down" program, which offers rebates of up to 50 percent for the cost of solar panels and small wind generators. In January, there were 250. In February, there were 245. WAIT LIST FOR HOME SYSTEMS In Sacramento, the local utility district sells solar panels to residential customers at reduced rates. The utility, which also installs the panels, has a waiting list of 700 homeowners for a total of 100 solar units available this year. "We foresee the day in the next five or 10 years when photovoltaics will compete with fossil fuel-generated power price-wise without subsidies," said Vince Schwent, who runs the Sacramento Municipal Utility District's solar energy program. "At that point, the market for solar will explode. Mass production will lead to lower prices." Independents that have tried to break into California's power market, however, have had difficulty obtaining investors and loans for unconventional technologies. "The investment market and engineers have been focused on the creation of large power plants," said Richard Harkrader, a North Carolina energy consultant. "How do you persuade people to make the higher investment in return for no emissions and (ending the uncertainty of) fuel costs?" But solar research scientist Jim Augustyn, a contractor for the U.S. Department of Energy, cautions against the federal or state governments pushing too hard for alternative energy systems. "The government could do more, but they have to be careful about how they do it," Augustyn said. "You can't just throw a lot of money at the technology and expect it to grow fast. You have to build this whole infrastructure. There are people who can install a photovoltaic system on your roof, but there are not a lot of them." Scientists disagree on how much fossil fuel the Earth holds. But few think this year's energy crisis will be the last. "I think that we should view this century as a transition away from fossil fuels," SunPower's Swanson said. "If we wait too long, it's just going to be that much more painful." Energy Economics With tax credits and rebates, wind power is already competitive in price with conventional energy sources, and solar power is fast becoming more affordable. . The cost of building a natural gas boiler runs about $1 million per megawatt of capacity. Wind generators cost about the same to build. Solar thermal units cost more than twice as much. But the fluctuating price of fuel must be factored into the cost of making electricity from natural gas. E-mail Jim Doyle at jdoyle@sfchronicle.com. ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle ? Page?A - 13 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ --------------------------------------------------------------- Developments in California's energy crisis The Associated Press Monday, April 16, 2001 ,2001 Associated Press URL: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/news/archive/2001/04/16/state0 946EDT0145.DTL&type=news , , -- (04-16) 06:57 PDT Here is a look at developments in California's energy crisis: MONDAY:< ?-- The state is under no power alerts as reserves stay above 7 percent. ?-- Gov. Gray Davis is expected to meet with legislative leaders over a plan ?to buy Southern California Edison's transmission lines. ?-- Edison and Pacific Gas & Electric Co. are scheduled to begin paying ?hundreds of smaller generators for future deliveries, under a plan by the ?Public Utilities Commission. ?SUNDAY:< -- PG&E officials demanded the utility be cut free from state regulation and be allowed to push huge rate increases onto its customers, two weeks before negotiations with Davis broke off, the San Francisco Chronicle reported. -- State energy officials are pushing for approval of a power plant in San Jose's Coyote Valley, despite recommendations that other sites may be more environmentally suitable, the San Jose Mercury News reported. The deputy director of the California Energy Commission, Bob Therkelsen, denied any impartial dealings concerning the plant. FRIDAY:< ?-- Davis asks state lawmakers to approve spending $500 million more to buy ?power for two struggling utilities, bringing his total requests to $5.2 ?billion. ?-- The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission orders generators who have sold ?electricity to the state to share power purchase information with the federal ?agency, which will then supply the information to a House subcommittee that ?held three days of hearings this week on California's energy problems. ?-- A business group, the California Alliance for Energy and Economic ?Stability, says a proposed restructuring of the state's electric rate ?structure by the PUC would hurt the state's economy by putting a greater rate ?burden on businesses. ?-- Edison is granted a stay in a federal lawsuit it brought against the PUC ?seeking to raise rates. Edison says both sides agreed to stop discovery and ?postpone hearings on all motions while the state considers an agreement ?brokered by Davis last week. Either side can request that the stay be lifted ?with five days notice. ?-- A Superior Court judge in Los Angeles agrees to consider whether the dozen ?or so cases filed against Edison by small power generators should be ?consolidated into one case. The companies say they have not been paid for ?power delivered to the utility since November. ?-- Edison says it has sent $206 million in payments to all small power ?generators that have provided the utility with estimates of their April ?bills. Under a PUC plan, Edison and PG&E were required to pay the so-called ?``qualifying facilities'' by Monday. ?-- The state is under no power alerts as reserves stay above 7 percent. ?WHAT'S NEXT:< -- Davis will lobby legislative leaders on Monday, Senate Republicans and Assembly Democrats Tuesday, and Senate Democrats Wednesday to support his agreement to purchase Southern California Edison's power transmission lines as a way of helping the company pay off its debt. The governor wants to buy the power lines for $2.76 billion, but lawmakers of both parties have challenged the plan. -- An Imperial County judge could rule Monday whether Edison must pay CalEnergy, a geothermal power producer, $140 million in past payments. CalEnergy has already been granted the right to break its contract with Edison and sell power on the open market. -- Edison and PG&E are expected to file their 2000 earnings reports April 17. -- The state Senate starts hearings April 18 in its inquiry into allegations that electricity suppliers illegally withheld power to drive up California's wholesale prices. Wholesalers deny such accusations. -- Also April 18, the Assembly plans to resume hearings in its inquiry into California's highest-in-the-nation natural gas prices. THE PROBLEM:< ?High demand, high wholesale energy costs, transmission glitches and a tight ?supply worsened by scarce hydroelectric power in the Northwest and ?maintenance at aging California power plants are all factors in California's ?electricity crisis. ?Edison and PG&E say they've lost nearly $14 billion since June to high ?wholesale prices that the state's electricity deregulation law bars them from ?passing on to consumers. PG&E, saying it hasn't received the help it needs ?from regulators or state lawmakers, filed for federal bankruptcy protection ?April 6. ?Electricity and natural gas suppliers, scared off by the two companies' poor ?credit ratings, are refusing to sell to them, leading the state in January to ?start buying power for the utilities' nearly 9 million residential and ?business customers. The state is also buying power for a third investor-owned ?utility, San Diego Gas & Electric, which is in better financial shape than ?much larger Edison and PG&E but also struggling with high wholesale power ?costs. ?The Public Utilities Commission has raised rates up to 46 percent to help ?finance the state's multibillion-dollar power-buying. ?Even before those increases, California residents paid some of the highest ?prices in the nation for electricity. Federal statistics from October show ?residential customers in California paid an average of 10.7 cents per ?kilowatt hour, or 26 percent more than the nationwide average of 8.5 cents. ?Only customers in New England, New York, Alaska and Hawaii paid more. ?,2001 Associated Press ? ?------------------------------------------------------------------------------?---------------------------------------------------------------?Plan to Save Edison Faces Skepticism in Sacramento ?No legislative clamor for Davis' bailout deal ?Greg Lucas, Sacramento Bureau Chief?Monday, April 16, 2001 ?,2001 San Francisco Chronicle ?URL: ?http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/chronicle/archive/2001/04/16/M?N138633.DTL&type=news ?Sacramento -- Gov. Gray Davis may have a hard time persuading skeptical ?lawmakers to approve the deal he reached last week to rescue Southern ?California Edison. ?It's a sell job with the highest stakes. Without legislative approval, the ?deal collapses, and Edison probably joins Pacific Gas and Electric Co. in ?bankruptcy court. ?"I don't feel there is a gun to my head to pass this deal with Edison. This ?is going to be pounded like a cheap steak," said Sen. Don Perata, D-Oakland. ?"It's the governor who is going to have to come in and sell it to us," Perata ?said. "I don't intend to deal with intermediaries." ?That's the central tension as lawmakers return today from a one-week spring ?break. ?There is also a mountain of bills on other issues that have languished for ?months while the Legislature wrestled with the state's energy mess. ?But it is Davis' $2.7 billion dollar deal -- and its bankrolling of a hefty ?chunk of Edison's financial recovery with ratepayer dollars -- that could ?elevate some Democrats' private grumblings about the governor into open ?rebellion. ?WHOLESALE APPROVAL SOUGHT?Magnifying that legislative grumpiness, Davis wants lawmakers to rubber- ?stamp his deal. ?"The governor would prefer if they took the negotiation lock, stock and ?barrel but they have the right to amend it as needed," said Steve Maviglio, ?Davis' press secretary. "We don't want them to, but they can." ?In an April 10 filing with the Securities and Exchange Commission, Edison ?suggests that if the Legislature changes the deal or balks at voting for it, ?all bets are off. ?"They can have it that way, as long as they're comfortable with the answer ?not being yes," said state Sen. Debra Bowen, D-Marina del Rey, chairwoman of ?the upper house's energy committee. "Last time I checked, the Senate don't ?cotton much to ultimatums." ?Bowen, who will lead the Senate's review of the deal, opposes it. ?"I don't understand why this is a good deal for ratepayers. It looks like a ?deal for Edison shareholders and the creditors," she said. "And I don't ?understand what the rush is, because it does nothing to help us this summer." ?UTILITY CAN WALK AWAY?The deal itself says that if legislative approval is not given by Aug. 15, ?Edison can walk away. ?Maviglio said Davis plans to be in Sacramento this week to meet with ?lawmakers and pitch his deal. But he did not know when Davis would present ?proposed legislation. ?Frustrated by the governor's past refusal to present a comprehensive package ?of bills to address the energy crisis, lawmakers have said they won't do ?anything about the Edison deal until Davis gives them a bill to introduce. ?There are already signs that Davis' proposal is anything but a legislative ?slam dunk. ?Senate President Pro Tem John Burton, D-San Francisco, said last week that ?the plan needs to be subjected to "extensive" legislative hearings by the ?Senate energy and appropriations committees and possibly the judiciary ?committees. ?Extensive hearings is often legislative code for death by 1,000 cuts. ?Lawmakers have also questioned the cost of buying Edison's transmission ?lines. More lawmakers are also wondering what benefit the state gets from ?owning a portion of the grid instead of all of it. ?Before PG&E's bankruptcy, much of the Legislature's and governor's actions ?were driven by a desire to prevent bankruptcies for fear it would cut ?consumers off from power. ?But more than a week after PG&E filed for bankruptcy, the lights are still on ?and, increasingly, lawmakers are saying that perhaps a bankruptcy court is a ?better venue than the political process to sort out the problems of PG&E and ?Edison. ?"There is a re-evaluation happening," said Assemblywoman Helen Thomson, D- ?Davis. ?NOT A REGIONAL PRIORITY?Thomson also said bailing out Edison is not a top-of-the-list priority for ?Northern California lawmakers. ?"What are those Southern California power lines going to connect up to? How's ?this deal going to benefit electricity in the north?" Thomson said. "You can ?buy a lot of health care, school books and traffic relief for $2.7 billion. " ?The state has already spent about $5.2 billion to buy electricity on behalf ?of California's two largest investor-owned utilities. ?Democrats also can vote against the Edison deal with the blessing of consumer ?groups that brand Davis' deal a gargantuan giveaway to Edison, with the ?bailout coming mainly at the expense of ratepayers. ?"It's dead on arrival. It's a complete capitulation to Edison that will cost ?ratepayers billions of dollars," said Harvey Rosenfield, head of the ?Foundation for Taxpayer and Consumer Rights. ?"If the governor says the Legislature stopped me from forcing you, the ?ratepayer, to bail out Edison I don't think legislators have much to fear ?from that criticism," Rosenfield said. ?Besides the price, there are many other aspects of the deal to which ?Democrats may object. According to an analysis by legislative staff members: ?"It will take a while to elevate the comfort level," said Assemblyman Herb ?Wesson, D-Los Angeles. ?E-mail Greg Lucas at glucas@sfchronicle.com. ?,2001 San Francisco Chronicle ? Page?A - 1 ?------------------------------------------------------------------------------?---------------------------------------------------------------?NEWS ANALYSIS ?Bush Administration Faces Static on Energy Policy ?Environmentalists criticize calls for more drilling ?Carolyn Lochhead, Chronicle Washington Bureau?Sunday, April 15, 2001 ?,2001 San Francisco Chronicle ?URL: ?http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/chronicle/archive/2001/04/15/M?N238312.DTL&type=news ?Washington -- The new national energy policy that President Bush will roll ?out in a few weeks is intended as a bold call to address a crisis made vivid ?by California's blackouts. ?The hope has been that California's woes -- and soaring energy prices ?nationwide -- have whetted the appetite for key elements expected in the Bush ?plan: more nuclear power, more coal and more drilling for oil and gas. ?It's not turning out that way. ?Instead, the administration finds itself under attack as rabidly anti- ?environment and is losing GOP support on Capitol Hill for its proposal to ?open the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge to oil exploration. ?"Their vision for the American West begins in the oil field and ends at the ?gas pump," said Jay Watson, regional director of the Wilderness Society. ?And as summer threatens to darken California -- with shortages spilling ?across the Northwest -- the administration is fending off calls for ?electricity price controls fueled by a coordinated Democratic drive to blame ?Bush for the blackouts. ?Even before taking office, the Bush camp had feared that California's ?electricity mess could become a political and economic sinkhole. So far, it ?has. ?While Bush, a Texas oil veteran, campaigned on reversing the Clinton ?administration's energy "neglect," California's crisis made energy an ?unwelcome early priority, consuming vast quantities of White House attention ?during Bush's critical first months in office. ?Bush tapped Vice President Dick Cheney, another oil veteran, to head a ?Cabinet-level task force to plot out a plan. While California posed risks, ?the administration calculated that the state could also serve as a poster ?child for what happens when energy needs are ignored. ?But so far, a proposal to drill in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge has ?become the poster child. ?As the plan's outlines take shape, there is more that will send ?environmentalists to the barricades: more use of coal, more nuclear power, ?more drilling for oil and gas on public lands, more power lines and ?pipelines, and easier licensing of hydroelectric dams. ?"We're looking at all different approaches to it and want to present a ?balanced approach," Interior Secretary Gale Norton said Thursday. ?DEFENDING A POSITION?Top Bush officials are playing defense, listing ways they are helping ?California and explaining why their strategy does not include price controls. ?Yet as California's crisis spreads across the West, so does the call for ?price controls, even as support for more production fails to build. ?"Unfortunately the national focus . . . has been diverted away from the ?challenge of inadequate supply to price controls," said Energy Secretary ?Spencer Abraham recently. ?Meanwhile, high energy prices are undermining the economy. Indeed, the reason ?the White House so resists price caps is its conviction that caps would make ?the shortages -- and the economic damage -- worse. ?Bush's answer is to boost supply. But the combination makes for dangerous ?politics: an energy policy that is portrayed as both anti-environment and ?anti- California. ?Fred C. Smith, head of the Competitive Enterprise Institute, one of many ?conservative policy groups closely allied with the administration, thinks the ?public will come Bush's way. ?"When they're faced with a choice between no air conditioning and no lights ?and no jobs, or drilling in areas they have never been to . . . they're going ?to be crying for getting energy out there," he said. ?GAS-RICH FORMATION?Although drilling in the Arctic Refuge has drawn the most heat -- and is ?already losing Republican votes in the Senate -- Bush may focus more on the ?Overthrust Belt, a geological formation in the Rockies considered potentially ?rich in natural gas. ?President Bill Clinton blocked large portions of the area to drilling when he ?put roadless designations on 58 million acres during his last days in office. ?A Bush reversal of Clinton's move is "virtually guaranteed," said Robert ?Nelson, a University of Maryland professor close to the administration. "The ?Overthrust Belt is one of the major prospective gas areas in the country." ?Studies estimate it might hold 137 trillion cubic feet of gas, enough to meet ?all current U.S. needs for nearly seven years. But 40 percent of that is on ?federal land that is closed to drilling. ?A draft Interior Department report indicates a broad-ranging review of all ?such land policies. The administration might even look at Clinton's new ?national monuments designations, such as the Carrizo Plain between ?Bakersfield and Santa Maria that is thought to have gas potential. ?The administration says 90 new power plants must be built each year to keep ?up with demand, and it sees nuclear power, which now provides 20 percent of ?the nation's electricity, as an alternative to over-reliance on the natural- ?gas generators. ?Cheney also advocates nuclear power -- which does not produce the carbon ?dioxide emissions many scientists believe cause global warming -- as a ?response to the barrage of criticism for the administration's exit from the ?Kyoto Protocol, which calls for large cuts in carbon dioxide emissions. ?The United States has not built a nuclear plant since the Three Mile Island ?accident a generation ago. But proponents contend that new plants are ?smaller, safer and cheaper and can be built in months, not years, although ?Cheney concedes that the problem of waste disposal is unsolved. ?Although many environmentalists cut their teeth on the anti-nuclear movement, ?up to now they have not actively opposed nuclear power plant relicensing. ?Whether they will accept new construction is another matter. ?At the same time, the administration is planning a big push for coal -- which ?does produce large amounts of carbon dioxide and other emissions. Coal- fired ?generators, which produce 52 percent of the nation's electricity, are ?increasingly being supplanted by cleaner natural gas plants. Bush's budget ?calls for a new $150 billion "clean coal power initiative," and Abraham ?emphasized that the United States has a 250-year supply of coal at current ?use levels. ?CONSERVATION LACKING?But even environmental groups that resisted criticizing Bush when he took ?office now blast him for rejecting conservation as an alternative. ?"Leading people to believe that America can drill its way out of its energy ?dependence is just silly," said Philip Kavits, spokesman for the National ?Wildlife Federation. ?Lynn Scarlett, president of the libertarian Reason Foundation and nominated ?by Bush to a top Interior Department post, maintains that U.S. environmental ?standards and technology argue for meeting more energy needs here. ?"If anyone in the world is going to do it in an environmentally sensitive ?way, it's going to be the United States," she said. "Not Russia, not Iraq, ?not China." ?Scarlett also said the administration "has every intention" of using ?alternative fuels, especially biomass. ?Bush and his top officials have warned from the outset that the new energy ?policy will offer few direct remedies for California. ?"Those who wish for overnight solutions I think are not going to find us able ?to solve every problem in a matter of days," Abraham said. ?Indeed, Bush himself has said that California's electricity meltdown is a ?problem that California has to fix, and that his energy policy will be aimed ?more broadly. ?When the policy emerges, however, it may only heap fuel on the fight with ?environmentalists, and face criticism for doing little to aid California. ?E-mail Carolyn Lochhead at clochhead@sfchronicle.com. ?,2001 San Francisco Chronicle ? Page?A - 15 ?------------------------------------------------------------------------------?---------------------------------------------------------------?Bay Theaters Start Bracing for More Blackouts ?Larger venues buy generators ?Jesse Hamlin, Chronicle Staff Writer?Sunday, April 15, 2001 ?,2001 San Francisco Chronicle ?URL: ?http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/chronicle/archive/2001/04/15/M?N233430.DTL&type=news ?Conductor Murray Perahia and the orchestra of the Academy of St. Martin in ?the Fields were rehearsing at Davies Symphony Hall a few weeks ago when the ?stage suddenly went dark. A rolling blackout had hit, just 90 minutes before ?the performance. ?With a flashlight, a stagehand led the musicians backstage, where the hall's ?emergency generator provided just enough light for them to finish the ?rehearsal -- standing on the loading dock. As the patrons arrived, they were ?kept outside the hall -- the San Francisco Symphony kindly provided chairs ?for ticket holders, if not the performers. The show started 30 minutes late, ?after the power had returned. ?Anticipating more blackouts this summer, the Symphony has rented a $1,500-a- ?month generator just to power the Davies stage lights. And that's cheap ?compared to the $10,000 to $13,000 monthly rental fee Bill Graham ?Presents/SFX expects to pay for each big generator to be installed at ?Shoreline Amphitheater, the Chronicle Pavilion and other concert venues. ?California's energy crunch is putting the squeeze on arts and entertainment ?organizations and recreational facilities around the Bay Area, most of whom ?have seen their power bills soar this year. ?A few have already raised prices to cover higher energy costs. Others are ?swallowing the increases but may have to boost prices if power costs keep ?rising. The bigger venues are preparing for rolling blackouts. ?"We are exploring the possibility of surcharges for areas that are costing us ?more to operate, specifically higher utility costs," said Neal Pinkser, ?executive vice president of theater operations for United Artists Theater ?Circuit Inc., which owns 25 movie theaters in California. ?Concert promoter Bill Graham Presents has been hit by skyrocketing power ?costs, but is concerned also about public safety. ?"If a rolling blackout comes and you have 25,000 people in your venue, you ?might have a safety issue," said Sherry Wasserman, a Bill Graham senior vice ?president. That's why the company is getting those monster generators. ?"The power necessary to continue running your standard rock show -- the ?lights, the sound -- is enormous," Wasserman said. ?BGP is not raising prices. But, "If utility prices continue to rise, it would ?be naive to think that the cost wouldn't be passed on to the consumer, one ?way or another." ?The big nonprofit groups have no immediate plans to raise ticket prices. But ?they're doing what they can to conserve. ?The staff at Walnut Creek's Dean Lesher Regional Center for the Arts has shut ?off decorative lights around the building and on the trees. Stage lights no ?longer stay on after lighting checks. ?In San Francisco, American Conservatory Theatre, whose $8,373 January PG&E ?bill was 50 percent higher than last year, has dimmed the lobby lights at the ?Geary Theater and is using the air cooling system more judiciously. ?The War Memorial Performing Arts Center, which manages the city-owned Davies ?Hall, Opera House and Veterans Building, has switched off or toned down ?lights throughout the buildings. The Opera House columns, once illuminated ?nightly, are only lit up on performance nights by bulbs whose wattage has ?been reduced from 500 to 300. The 1,000 or so lights in the Davies lobby have ?been dimmed by 15 percent. ?The War Memorial gets its electricity from the city's Hetch-Hetchy project ?but has been hit with whopping increases on its gas bill. It expects to be ?able to pay its power bills this year, but "I am concerned about the budget ?implications if energy prices should continue to go up," said War Memorial ?Managing Director Beth Murray. "If they do, and we cannot accommodate it ?within our revenue capability, we would have to consider increasing rental ?rates." ?The San Francisco Ballet, which performs at the Opera House, worries more ?about rolling blackouts than rent hikes. ?"We're much more concerned about the impact on performances should the power ?go out at the Opera House," said Ballet General Manager Glenn McCoy. "We ?can't avoid it, but we've planned for the evacuation of audiences and ?employees. There are lots of flashlights around." ?The power at the Opera House comes from several substations so the entire ?building wouldn't go dark during a blackout, but the stage lights, rigging ?and some auditorium lights would shut down. An emergency generator would ?power the exit signs. ?Like everyone else, movie theaters are conserving energy by turning off ?lights whenever possible. But you can't flip off the 4,000-watt projector ?bulbs. And with summer coming, the high cost of air-conditioning is bound to ?put a chill on profits. ?"It's going to be a nightmare this summer because of the added costs," said ?Alan Michaan, owner of the Renaissance Rialto chain, which owns the four- ?screen Grand Lake Theatre in Oakland and three other East Bay movie houses. ?Michaan, who hoped not to have to raise prices, is paying $5,000 more a month ?for power than he did a year ago. His February PG&E bills totaled $16, 048. ?"It's taking a significant chunk out of our profit," he said. He won't cut ?down on the air-conditioning this summer, but he has turned off chandeliers ?and reduced the hours the marquee is on. ?Smaller facilities are being squeezed, too. San Francisco's The Marsh has ?goosed up prices to pay for power. The small nonprofit group, which presents ?plays and performance art, has bumped its Monday night ticket up a buck and ?its weekend comedy shows from $5 to $7. ?At the Paddock Bowl in Pacheco, prices are going up to pay for power. The ?$1-a-game Monday night special just went up 50 cents. The regular $2.50 rate ?will soon be $3.50. ?"My gas bills have gone up over 300 percent in the last few months," said ?manager Mark Willard, who was expecting a big jump in his electricity bill. ?During the summer, the alley runs the air-conditioning 16 hours a day. The ?price increase "is unfortunate, but we have no way around it to keep the ?business going." ?E-mail Jesse Hamlin at jhamlin@sfchronicle.com. ?,2001 San Francisco Chronicle ? Page?A - 17 ?------------------------------------------------------------------------------?---------------------------------------------------------------?PG&E Took Hard Line, Dooming State Talks ?Secret plan shows utility demanded less regulation ?David Lazarus, Chronicle Staff Writer?Sunday, April 15, 2001 ?,2001 San Francisco Chronicle ?URL: ?http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/chronicle/archive/2001/04/15/M?N176098.DTL&type=news ??PG&E's bailout talks with Gov. Gray Davis fell apart after the utility ?demanded unprecedented freedom from regulatory oversight and the ability to ?pass along huge rate increases to consumers, The Chronicle has learned. ?Pacific Gas and Electric Co. claimed that its decision this month to file for ?bankruptcy protection in San Francisco resulted from the governor's ?unwillingness to negotiate a fair deal. ?But a confidential proposal submitted by PG&E during the talks shows that the ?utility was the more ambitious and stubborn negotiator and that the deal ?sought by the company was doomed to fail from the outset. ?"It's like the Japanese insisting that we surrender Hawaii after we beat them ?in World War II," said Harvey Rosenfield, head of the Foundation for Taxpayer ?and Consumer Rights in Santa Monica. ?He described PG&E's demands as "breathtaking in their level of self- ?delusion." ?A copy of the eight-page, single-spaced proposal was obtained by The ?Chronicle. ?"PG&E was arrogant and defiant, and acted like we owed them something," said ?Steve Maviglio, a spokesman for the governor. "That's not how you enter into ?a negotiation." ?UTILITY MAKES DEMANDS?Among the utility's demands: ?-- PG&E insisted that it be cleared of any wrongdoing when it transferred ?millions of dollars to its parent company. ?-- In a sale of its power grid to the state, PG&E still wanted to retain ?possession of valuable assets, including the right to profit from any ?telecommunications lines or antennas linked to the system. ?-- PG&E required that it be given first right of refusal if the state ever ?chose to sell off the power lines, allowing the utility to buy back the ?system without competitive offers. ?"It is ludicrous to suggest that this document caused the negotiations to ?break down," said Ron Low, a PG&E spokesman. "There were negotiations that ?occurred later and other documents that followed." ?The company's proposal is dated Feb. 28. Sources familiar with the ?negotiations said PG&E did not significantly depart from its initial offer ?during follow-up meetings. ?Robert Glynn, chairman of the utility's parent company, PG&E Corp., said that ?when the bankruptcy filing was made April 6, no substantive talks had been ?held for at least three weeks. ?This would have made PG&E's proposal only about two weeks old when the ?negotiations unraveled. ?AT AN IMPASSE?Sources said the utility refused to budge during that interval and that the ?impasse centered primarily on PG&E's insistence that it be subject to less ?oversight by the California Public Utilities Commission. ?"They took a position on regulatory matters that was out of touch with ?reality," said Maviglio, the governor's spokesman. ?Indeed, the single most striking aspect of PG&E's proposal is its repeated ?references to a reduction in the state PUC's regulatory authority. ?For example, the utility argues that it is entitled to recoup from consumers ?about $9 billion in costs accrued because of runaway wholesale power prices. ?The proposal says this money "will be fully recovered in retail rates without ?further CPUC review for prudence or any other purpose." ?PG&E also insisted that virtually all official restrictions on its activities ?based on the 1996 legislation that deregulated California's electricity ?market be overturned. ?"The CPUC will terminate or modify the scope of existing commission ?proceedings and will not initiate new proceedings related to implementation ?of (the legislation) or issues pertaining to the reasonableness and recovery ?of costs," the proposal stipulates. ?This would include a current investigation by the state PUC into whether PG&E ?violated state law by transferring millions of dollars from the utility to ?its parent company before filing for bankruptcy. ?PG&E's proposal maintains that the state "will waive and release all claims ?arising out of the dispute," including the money transfer and a restructuring ?of the parent company that protected it from the utility's financial woes. ?Furthermore, it instructs that the state PUC "will issue an order finding ?that PG&E and PG&E Corp. have fully complied with state laws and CPUC orders ?. . . and that their conduct and transactions did not contravene public ?policy." ?"It's Bob Glynn thinking he's god of the universe," said Nettie Hoge, ?executive director The Utility Reform Network in San Francisco. "PG&E doesn't ?think they're beholden to state law. They think they're a law unto ?themselves." ?Shawn Cooper, a spokesman for PG&E's parent company, declined to discuss the ?contents of the proposal. "That document is confidential," he said. ?THE EDISON DEAL?No language concerning compliance with state laws was included in the accord ?reached last week between the governor and Southern California Edison. ?That agreement, which still requires final approval from lawmakers, would ?restore the utility to creditworthiness in return for acquisition of its ?power lines and other concessions. ?Sources said the deal reached with Edison is "very close" to terms offered by ?the state to PG&E. ?Yet, while PG&E's proposal seeks to diminish the regulatory role of the PUC, ?the Edison accord bends over backward to stress the PUC's authority over the ?utility. ?"It is expressly understood that there is no intention to change (Edison) ?continuing to be a public utility that is subject to the jurisdiction of the ?California Public Utilities Commission," it states on the first page. ?Maviglio said he did not sit in on the talks with either utility, but he ?learned from negotiators that both PG&E and Edison had misgivings about the ?PUC's role as a consumer watchdog. ?"Edison had some mistrust of the PUC, but they understood that they had to ?live with the regulators," he said. ?PG&E, on the other hand, harbored a deeper grudge, which Maviglio said was ?"very emotional" for the utility. He speculated that PG&E desired retribution ?for a past regulatory setback. ?"Perhaps we misjudged their primary concern," he said. "It wasn't resolving ?their credit issue. It was extracting vengeance on the PUC." ?TALKS GROUND TO HALT?Maviglio said the talks quickly hit a brick wall after PG&E submitted its ?deal terms. While state negotiators were prepared to discuss many of the ?points, he said, they could not yield on matters of regulatory oversight. ?"We were willing to negotiate the terms of the deal but not constitutional ?controls," Maviglio said. "They were attempting not just to set the course of ?the future but also to right the wrongs of the past." ?The first sign of trouble emerged when PG&E officials told The Chronicle in ?late March that it appeared the negotiations had collapsed. The governor's ?office, perhaps optimistically, maintained that all was well. ?Around this time, however, PG&E's Glynn made the fateful decision to abandon ?the talks and to instead file for bankruptcy protection. The company gave no ?indication of its move to the governor. ?April 5 would prove to be a pivotal date in California's energy saga. ?While PG&E was preparing to file for bankruptcy the next morning and was ?handing out last-minute bonuses and raises to thousands of employees, Davis ?was putting the final touches on a televised speech in which he would all but ?assure the utilities they would recover their costs through rate increases. ?Sources said the governor's negotiators called PG&E to brief the company's ?chief financial officer, Peter Darbee, on what Davis was about to say. ?They had to pull Darbee from a meeting of PG&E's board of directors, where, ?presumably, the official vote was being taken to file for Chapter 11. Darbee ?was informed about the intended speech but said little in response. ?The next day, after making the bombshell bankruptcy announcement, PG&E's ?Glynn laid blame for the collapse of bailout talks entirely on Davis. ?"We listened carefully to the (governor's) statement and the commentary that ?followed, and this decision is the result," he said. ?"The negotiations we have been involved in since last November have gone ?nowhere," Glynn added. "Over the last month, the kindest thing to say is ?progress has dramatically slowed." ?"There was no room for negotiation," countered Maviglio. "It was their way or ?the highway." ?Rosenfield of the Foundation for Taxpayer and Consumer Rights seldom sees eye ?to eye with the governor. But in this case, he finds himself defending Davis. ?"The document absolves the governor of responsibility for PG&E's bankruptcy, ?" Rosenfield said. "It's good to know there are limits beyond which even ?Davis wouldn't go." ?The governor's negotiators remain hopeful that a deal still can be reached ?with PG&E comparable to the state's accord with Edison. ?Maviglio said PG&E has several months in which to file a Chapter 11 ?reorganization plan. He said state officials are prepared to work with PG&E ?to produce a plan that meets both sides' goals. ?"It would be the smart thing for them to do," Maviglio noted. "When they come ?out of bankruptcy, they'll still be subject to regulation." ?E-mail David Lazarus at dlazarus@sfchronicle.com. ?,2001 San Francisco Chronicle ? Page?A - 1 ?------------------------------------------------------------------------------?---------------------------------------------------------------?Energy Efficiency Rules Scaled Back ?Bush official's move affects appliances ?Washington Post?Saturday, April 14, 2001 ?,2001 San Francisco Chronicle ?URL: ?http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/chronicle/archive/2001/04/14/M?N94172.DTL&type=news ?Washington -- The Energy Department announced yesterday the rollback of a ?Clinton administration rule mandating increased energy savings for central ?air conditioners and heat pumps in favor of a less stringent rule applauded ?by appliance manufacturers. ?Energy conservation advocates said the decision forfeits an opportunity to ?reduce electricity consumption by a vital margin in summer, when heat waves ?raise the threat of power blackouts. The Bush administration's plan is likely ?to face legal and congressional challenges, opponents predicted. ?The Bush administration said the rule it will propose, requiring a 20 percent ?increase in energy efficiency over the current standard, would produce major ?energy savings and air quality gains. Over the next 30 years, it would ?eliminate the need for 27 new electric power plants, officials said. ?The Clinton standard, mandating a 30 percent gain, would have offset the need ?for 39 plants of the same size, officials said. The difference in energy ?savings between the two standards over 30 years equals the annual electricity ?use by all American households today, Energy Department officials said. Both ?rules would take effect in 2006. ?Energy Secretary Spencer Abraham called the new rule a "realistic" and ?affordable standard. "We were particularly concerned that the Clinton rule ?placed too high a cost burden on consumers," he said. ?Conservation groups said the administration bowed to industry pressure. ?"California will now have to build an additional two power plants to make up ?for what President Bush did today," said Philip Clapp, president of the ?National Environmental Trust. ?"They're working very hard to make the nation more energy-inefficient," said ?David Nemtzow, president of the Alliance to Save Energy. ?Earlier in the week, the Energy Department approved a Clinton administration ?energy-saving rule for clothes washers and water heaters. ?The air conditioner rule, which divided manufacturers, was based on disputed ?calculations of how much new units would cost to make and how affordable ?consumers would find them. ?Energy Department officials concluded that new units meeting the 20 percent ?energy-saving standard would add $213 to the average models priced at $2,000 ?and more today, while the Clinton administration standard would cost $335 ?more. ?Proponents of the higher standard said that is a trivial cost difference ?spread over the nearly 20-year life of new air conditioning and heat pump ?units. ?Efficiency Requirements for Future Appliances Rules approved by the Bush ?administration this week will have these effects on future models: ?CLOTHES WASHERS?-- Energy usage cut: 35 percent ?-- Price increase: $249 per unit ?-- Utility bill savings: $48 per year ?WATER HEATERS?-- Energy usage cut: 5 to 9 percent ?-- Price increase: up to $100 per unit ?-- Utility bill savings: up to $182 per year ?AIR CONDITIONERS?-- Energy usage cut: 20 percent ?-- Price increase: $213 per unit ?-- Utility bill savings: $21 per year ?HEAT PUMPS?-- Energy usage cut: 20 percent ?-- Price increase: $144 per unit ?-- Utility bill savings: N/A ?Source: Chronicle News Services ?The Associated Press contributed to this story. ?,2001 San Francisco Chronicle ? Page?A - 4 ?------------------------------------------------------------------------------?---------------------------------------------------------------------?Power of Micro Vs. Macro ?Some firms crushed by energy crisis ?Sam Zuckerman, Chronicle Economics Writer?Sunday, April 15, 2001 ?,2001 San Francisco Chronicle ?URL: ?http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/chronicle/archive/2001/04/15/B?U152654.DTL&type=news ?When Bernard Marszalek talks about economists who say California's energy ?crisis is no big deal, you can almost see the smoke rising from his ears. ?Marszalek, marketing manager for Inkworks Press, a Berkeley printer, has seen ?his company's cost of natural gas go up about 60 percent. Now he's facing the ?prospect of a 40 percent increase in the cost of electricity, which powers ?Inkworks' two presses. The potential hit: $3,600 a year, no small sum for a ?business that grosses $2 million annually. ?"Economists are people in their ivory towers, looking at figures," said ?Marszalek. "You talk to individual businesses and they're hurting." ?One of the most striking paradoxes of the power crisis has been the vast gulf ?between the cries of pain of California's business community and the bland ?reassurances coming from the economics profession. ?Businesspeople say rising costs and power disruptions have them on the ropes. ?"We are absolutely getting hammered," said Mike Betts, co-owner of Betts ?Spring Co., a San Leandro manufacturer of industrial springs. But economists ?insist that overall damage to business in the state will be relatively ?slight. ?So, what gives? Are businesspeople overreacting, or are economists out of ?touch with reality? ?In their own separate ways, it seems, they may both be right. What's going on ?here is a classic illustration of the difference between macro and micro, the ?big picture and the individual portrait. ?"In a large macroeconomy, labor and other costs are more important than ?energy," said Mary Daly, an economist with the Federal Reserve Bank of San ?Francisco. "Our economy is going to be affected (by the power crisis), but it ?is not as large as it might sound when you talk with a manufacturer who uses ?a lot of electricity." ?Daly pointed to the Asian financial crisis of 1997 and 1998, which ended up ?doing little harm to the U.S. economy as a whole but walloped some sectors of ?U.S. business. "Apple growers in Washington were devastated" when Japan and ?other Asian countries cut back fruit imports, she noted. ?Ross DeVol, director of regional studies at the Milken Institute in Santa ?Monica, estimates that the energy crunch will cut the state's economic growth ?rate between 0.25 and 0.4 percentage points during the next five years, a ?relatively small amount. ?The limited economic damage reflects the fact that California has a higher ?proportion of white-collar businesses than most states, and they tend to be ?low energy consumers. "If you're an advertising agency, you probably won't ?care much about about energy costs," DeVol said. ?In California, which produces $1.25 trillion in goods and services annually, ?businesses that are big gas and electricity users -- manufacturers, dairy ?farmers, restaurants and the like -- may not dominate. But there are tens of ?thousands of them, and they say it's scant comfort to think of the big ?picture when they're fighting for survival. ?"We're focused on small- and mid-size manufacturers," said Leila Mozaffari, ?vice president of the California Manufacturing Technology Center, a nonprofit ?consulting firm in Los Angeles. "What we see on a micro level is that the ?energy crisis is hurting them in a bad way. The smaller companies -- their ?backs are against the wall." ?Take Foote Axle & Forge in Los Angeles. The company, which uses large amounts ?of energy to forge auto parts, has seen its monthly gas bill go from $8,000 ?to $23,000. That prompted owner Mike Denton to shut down his second shift ?earlier this month and fire six workers. Now he's reselling axles made in ?Asia in place of axles made in his own factory. ?"I had to let everybody (on the shift) go. I couldn't afford to run it ?anymore," he said. "It's now cheaper for me to buy products this company has ?been making since 1936. If things don't change, this will become a ?warehouse." ?Higher gas and electricity prices are hitting at the same time that big jumps ?in health insurance and workers' compensation premiums are taking hold, noted ?Betts. "We've had four strikes against us this year," he said. ?Contrast those stories with the conclusion of a recent report from the ?University of California at Los Angeles. The financial effects of the ?electricity crunch "will likely have a relatively small impact on the ?long-run health of the state's economy," wrote economist Christopher ?Thornberg, a visiting professor at the university's business school. ?Thornberg based his conclusion on an estimate that the state government might ?have to pay as much as $30 billion for electricity and infrastructure. That, ?he pointed out, is just 2.5 percent of the value of goods and services sold ?in California annually. ?When Thornberg presented his findings at UCLA earlier this month, he was ?confronted by an angry business representative who accused him of having his ?head in the sand. ?Asked about the incident, the UCLA economist conceded that the energy crunch ?is hurting some businesses. ?"I understand that businessmen are going through a tough time right now, but ?I wonder how much of that is the power crisis and how much is due to the fact ?that we are slipping into a recession," Thornberg said in an e-mail. "When ?sales drop, businesspeople tend to point at the first available target -- ?in this case, power. They may be losing sight of the forest for the tree." ?Thornberg's critics were particularly galled by comments in his report that ?power blackouts will probably have scant effect on California's productivity. ?"An hour without power can be viewed as an extended coffee break for most ?businesses," he wrote. ?Mark Roth, president of El Burrito Mexican Food Products in City of Industry ?near Los Angeles, took vehement exception. ?"One of my vendors that makes plastic cups. They were three hours into their ?workday when their power got cut off," he said. "The plastic in the ?(extruding) tubes all turned solid," ruining a full day's production. ?ANECDOTAL EVIDENCE?Of course, not all economists play down the plight of California businesses. ?"The business community's voice hasn't been heard," said Jack Kyser, chief ?economist for the Los Angeles County Economic Development Corp. "A lot of ?smaller businesses are looking into shutting down or laying people off." ?Still, Kyser said, he sympathizes with economists who don't yet have the data ?to support the business point of view: "If you're an academic economist, it's ?very hard. All the evidence is anecdotal." ?California businesspeople aren't inclined to be as understanding. They feel ?offended and slighted when they hear economists say the state's economy will ?shrug off the power crunch. ?E-mail Sam Zuckerman at szuckerman@sfchronicle.com. ?,2001 San Francisco Chronicle ? Page?B - 1 ?------------------------------------------------------------------------------?---------------------------------------------------------------?????PG&E sent hard-nosed proposal to Davis demanding no regulation ?Posted at 6:13 a.m. PDT Monday, April 16, 2001 ?SAN FRANCISCO (AP) -- Pacific Gas and Electric Co. officials demanded the ?utility be cut free from state regulation and be allowed to push huge rate ?increases onto its customers, two weeks before negotiations with Gov. Gray ?Davis broke off, the San Francisco Chronicle reported. ?``Perhaps we misjudged their primary concern,'' said Steve Maviglio, the ?governor's spokesman. ``It wasn't resolving their credit issue. It was ?extracting vengeance on the PUC.'' ?In addition to insisting that it be released from the state Public Utilities ?Commission's regulatory grip, PG&E demanded it be allowed to buy back its ?power lines without competitive offers if the state ever decided to sell. In ?addition, it wanted to continue profiting from any telecommunications lines ?or antennas linked to the system, according to a Feb. 28 eight-page proposal ?obtained by the Chronicle and published Sunday. ?PG&E denies the document influenced the outcome between the utility and the ?state. ?``It is ludicrous to suggest that this document caused the negotiations to ?break down,'' said PG&E spokesman Ron Low. ``There were negotiations that ?occurred later and other documents that followed.'' ?At the time of the utility's bankruptcy filing April 6, PG&E Corp. Chairman ?Robert Glynn said no talks had been held for three weeks. PG&E's proposal had ?been delivered about two weeks before talks ceased. ?PG&E has said it's entitled to recoup $9 billion it paid for wholesale power ?because of PUC-regulated rate caps, which kept the utility from passing high ?costs onto customers. ?The proposal said this money ``will be fully recovered in retail rates ?without further CPUC review for prudence or any other purpose,'' the ?Chronicle reported. ?The document went on to demand the PUC drop all proceedings concerning PG&E, ?including an investigation into whether the utility violated California law ?by transferring millions to parent company PG&E Corp. prior to filing ?bankruptcy. ?``They took a position on regulatory matters that was out of touch with ?reality,'' Maviglio said. ?PG&E Corp. spokesman Shawn Cooper declined to comment on the proposal. ?``That document is confidential,'' he said. ?Ratepayer advocates say they're baffled by PG&E's demands. ?``It's like the Japanese insisting that we surrender Hawaii after we beat ?them in World War II,'' said Harvey Rosenfield, consumer advocate for the ?Foundation for Taxpayer and Consumer Rights.??------------------------------------------------------------------------------?-----------------------------------------------------------------------?????Conservation drive fuels move to `Cool Roofs' ?At first, it sounds like an off-the-wall idea: resurface the roof of your ?business with white or light-colored coating or material, and you'll save a ?fortune on air conditioning costs. ?But as the state races to launch energy-saving efforts before the summer heat ?wave hits, ``Cool Roofs'' are suddenly one of the hottest conservation ideas ?around, and roofing contractors are spreading the word to their clients. ?Technology companies such as IBM, Solectron and Apple Computer Inc. have ?already added the roofs to some of their buildings. Gov. Gray Davis just ?signed legislation that will funnel an additional $30 million to the state's ?Cool Roofs program, which gives businesses rebates for installing the ?reflective and light-colored roofs. ?Research has shown the roofs reflect the scorching heat of the sun and lower ?building temperatures. In turn, the need to crank up air conditioning is ?greatly reduced. ?``While Cool Roofs do not generally cost more than dark roofs, they have been ?shown to lower cooling costs by 20 percent,'' said California Energy ?Commissioner Art Rosenfeld. ``This simple change will eventually save ?California thousands of megawatts of power.'' ?In Florida and Arizona, whitewashed roofs are common. But in California, most ?commercial and residential roofs are black or dark in color. ?When Solectron, the Milpitas-based electronics manufacturing services ?company, recently purchased a new building in Fremont, the company knew the ?176,000-square-foot flat roof on Building 16 had to be replaced. ?``We thought it would be advantageous for us to put in a Cool Roof,'' said ?Bob Kula, a Solectron spokesman. ``It's worth the investment, and we wanted ?to do it because it's a very important conservation move.'' ?Cooling foam??On a hot summer day, the surface temperature of Building 16's roof can climb ?to 160 degrees. But earlier this week, contractors were busy spraying a ?light-colored polyurethane foam onto the roof's surface. Doing so both drops ?the temperature of the roof by more than 50 degrees and adds extra ?insulation, which enables Solectron to slash its energy costs. ?The coating also extends the roof's life expectancy, which makes it ?cost-effective in the long run. ?Because the systems usually include additional insulation, there shouldn't be ?an increased heating cost during the winter, according to Cool Roofs ?advocates. ?The cost of Solectron's Cool Roof is $750,000, but the company projects it ?will pay for itself in five years because of the energy savings. The company ?will also receive a state rebate of about $15,000 -- or 10 cents a square ?foot -- for the cost of the project. ?Though many commercial businesses have begun to embrace the idea, it will be ?awhile before Cool Roofs catch on in residential neighborhoods. ?Installing a Cool Roof requires using the right kinds of coatings or ?single-ply materials: A homeowner can't just slap a coat of white paint on ?top of asphalt shingles. Furthermore, many homeowners associations do not ?approve of white roofs for cosmetic reasons. ?``Because of architectural issues with residential homes, it's much more ?difficult for this to be used to the extent that it can in industrial ?buildings,'' said Bob Law of BUR Services, a Pleasanton company that is ?installing Solectron's Cool Roof. ?Homeowners need not apply??So far, there is no state rebate for homeowners who install Cool Roofs. ?Others hope the West's energy crisis will change that. Rosenfeld has ?researched Cool Roofs for decades. He worked at the Lawrence Berkeley ?National Laboratory for years, and became interested in energy-efficient ?building design during the energy crisis of the 1970s. ?``I would love to see a residential housing developer say they'd like to do ?the whole neighborhood with Cool Roofs,'' Rosenfeld said. ``We want everybody ?to do it. The Greeks and everyone else who has lived around the Mediterranean ?Sea has understood this for 2,000 years.'' ?Besides Cool Roofs, Rosenfeld and researchers at the Heat Island Group at the ?lab are pushing the larger idea of ``Cool Communities.'' By helping to reduce ?the overall temperatures in cities, Cool Roofs also cut smog. ?Planting shade trees on the south and west sides of a house or commercial ?building also helps to cool temperatures. The sun blazes the strongest in the ?late afternoon, when it begins to set. Deciduous trees that lose their leaves ?in the winter provide much-needed natural shade to buildings in the summer, ?cutting down on the need for air conditioning. ?Heat island syndrome??``With so much asphalt, many communities are becoming heat islands that are a ?few degrees warmer than usual,'' said Hashem Akbari, group leader of the Heat ?Island Group at the lab. ``Cool Roofs, light-colored pavement, and urban ?vegetation can reduce the temperature, and dramatically improve air quality. ?It saves energy. It's like creating an oasis.'' ?------------------------------------------------------------------------------?------------------------------------------------------------------------------?---------------------????????Monday, April 16, 2001 ????PUC president outlines the crisis ?California should make it through the summer electricity crisis in pretty ?good shape, Loretta Lynch, president of the Public Utilities Commission, told ?the Register editorial board in a meeting on Thursday. After Gov. Gray Davis, ?she probably is the second most powerful person in trying to solve the ?electricity crisis. ?She defended the price hikes her commission called for last month of up to 46 ?percent (depending on what the Legislature does when it comes back into ?session next week). She said the hikes, combined with Gov. Davis' ?conservation efforts, "could be enough" to get the state through the high ?demand in the summer months without a crisis. ?The Independent System Operator is predicting about 30 blackout days this ?summer based on last summer's usage and this summer's projected power supply. ?She didn't rule out blackouts, but believes conservation and other measures ?will minimize the damage. It will be a close call. We'll soon see whether Ms. ?Lynch's assessment proves too optimistic. ?Although some have criticized her for not being up to speed on the issues, ?she seemed to us a "quick read" on a difficult crisis in which almost ?everybody is scrambling for knowledge. And although we disagree with her ?emphasis on increasing government to solve the problem short- and long-term, ?she was open to our suggestions of looking into free-market solutions. ?Here are discussion highlights: ?Freezing prices. Ms. Lynch wants the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission to ?freeze the prices that power generators charge for electricity, which would ?give a break to ratepayers and utilities. We objected that price controls ?would put a damper on production, which in the long run could worsen the ?crisis. She countered that, when California still had price controls in 1999, ?"we still had 16 applications" to build new power plants. ?Cost-plus pricing. She also said it was a "necessity" to go back to cost-plus ?pricing, the system in place before "deregulation," in which utilities were ?allowed a specified percentage profit above their costs. ?We pointed out that such a system notoriously produced waste by the utilities ?and such contracts are considered poor business practice because they offer ?no incentive to economize. She countered that better regulation would prevent ?such waste and that, in any case, power surely was cheaper under that system. ?Power rotation. We offered an idea that local businesses have expressed to ?us: Rotating power shutdowns during peak periods, such as one company ?shutting down for a week, with guarantees of power at other times. "That is a ?great idea," she responded. "The question is implementation. We need to move ?there. We need business coordination with the ISO and the PUC." ?Basic view. Perhaps her basic view could be summarized in her criticism that ?the existing "system is for the market, not for the public interest." By that ?she meant the system in which power generators take advantage of the supply ?shortage to charge extremely high prices, which led to the bankruptcy of PG&E ?and rate increases. ?We pointed out that markets are in the public interest, but that what we have ?now is not a true free market, but a botched "deregulation." She countered ?that, because of the unique nature of the electricity market - the constant ?demand and difficulty of storage - some regulation is necessary. ?We agreed that, under the current crisis, instituting a real free market is ?very difficult. But we also believe that all moves to solve this crisis ?should be in the direction of a free market and away from government control ?and ownership. That once the immediate crisis subsides, the shape of the ?permanent recovery should be about a healthy market, not the government. ??------------------------------------------------------------------------------?------------------------------------------------------------------------------?--------------------??[B] FULL/ Sierra Pacific to suspend quarterly dividend --Sierra Pacific cites ?energy crisis uncertainty??????--Sierra Pacific reduces hiring, cuts exec bonuses????New York, April 13 (BridgeNews) - Sierra Pacific Resources Holding Co. will?not pay dividend for the first quarter due to continued uncertainty over the?energy crisis faced by its Nevada unit. The company will continue cost control?programs, reduce hiring and eliminate executive bonus.???--E. Gopakumar, BridgeNews?????* * *?????The following is the text of today's announcement, with emphasis added by?BridgeNews. BridgeStation links to company data have been inserted at the end:?????Sierra Pacific to Not Pay Quarterly Dividend?????LAS VEGAS, APRIL 13 -- CITING CONTINUED UNCERTAINTY OVER HOW??NEVADA WILL RESOLVE ITS ENERGY CRISIS, THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS OF SIERRA??PACIFIC RESOURCES (NYSE: SRP) TODAY ANNOUNCED IT WILL NOT BE PAYING THE?DIVIDEND HISTORICALLY PAID ON MAY 1ST. THE BOARD WILL ADDRESS THE COMPANY'S?DIVIDEND AND DIVIDEND POLICY AT THE BOARD MEETING SCHEDULED FOR MAY 21, IN?CONJUNCTION WITH THE ANNUAL SHAREHOLDERS' MEETING.???"THE DIVIDEND IS VITALLY IMPORTANT IN RETAINING INVESTOR CONFIDENCE IN?NEVADA AT A TIME WHEN NEW ENERGY INFRASTRUCTURE IS SO CRITICAL TO PROTECTING?CONSUMERS FROM THIS CRISIS," SAID WALT HIGGINS, PRESIDENT AND CEO. ?"HOWEVER,?IT IS EQUALLY IMPORTANT THAT OUR DIVIDEND REFLECT OUR CURRENT FINANCIAL?CONDITION AND THE CONTINUED UNCERTAINTY ABOUT THE ENERGY CRISIS."???"We recognize that this decision is painful to shareholders who have?already suffered an unprecedented drop in the value of their investment," ?said?Higgins. "However, it is really the only decision that can be made until we?can get a more definitive view of how and when this crisis can be resolved."???THE BOARD ALSO DIRECTED THE COMPANY TO CONTINUE A RANGE OF COST CONTROL?PROGRAMS THAT HAVE BEEN UNDERTAKEN TO REDUCE ALL EXPENSES OTHER THAN THOSE?ASSOCIATED WITH SAFETY AND CUSTOMER SERVICE. THE REDUCTIONS HAVE FOCUSED ON?NON-CRITICAL ACTIVITIES AND HAVE INCLUDED A SLOWDOWN IN HIRING, REDUCED?ADMINISTRATIVE EXPENSES, AND ELIMINATION OF INCENTIVE PAY THIS YEAR FOR?EXECUTIVE STAFF.???Headquartered in Reno, Nev., Sierra Pacific Resources is a holding company?whose principal subsidiaries are Nevada Power Co., the electric utility for?southern Nevada, and Sierra Pacific Power Co., the electric utility for most??of northern Nevada and the Lake Tahoe area of California, and a natural gas??and water distributor in the Reno-Sparks area. Other subsidiaries include the?Tuscarora Gas Pipeline Co., which owns 50 percent interest in an interstate?natural gas transmission partnership and Sierra Pacific Communications, a?telecommunications company.????This press release contains forward-looking statements regarding the??future performance of Sierra Pacific Resources. These statements are subject?to a variety of risks and uncertainties that could cause actual results to?differ materially from current expectations. These risks and uncertainties?include, in addition to those discussed herein, all of the factors discussed??in the company's Annual Report on Form 10-K for the year ended Dec. 31, 2000.?This report has been filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission and is?available without charge through the EDGAR system at its Web site,??www.sec.gov.???SOURCE Sierra Pacific Resources???/CONTACT: analysts, Rich Atkinson, 775-834-5300, or media, Faye I.Andersen,?775-834-4822, both of Sierra Pacific Resources/???End?------------------------------------------------------------------------------?------------------------------------------------------------------------------?------------------??Monday, April 16, 2001????By Kathleen McFall ?kmcfall@ftenergy.com ??It's springtime and thoughts that might have typically turned to fancy are, ?in this extraordinary gas market, already looking ahead to the refill season. ?National storage levels barely held out through this heating season, and the ?looming hurdle of restocking now takes center stage.??"With storage levels nearing record lows, the industry has its work cut out ?in terms of restoring supplies by November 1, the traditional start to the ?heating season," said Ronald Barone in a recent UBS Warburg research note. ??"Storage volumes of natural gas are low, and replacement of gas in storage ?will contribute to strong summer 2001 demand and higher gas prices that will ?make storage for next winter costly," said Beth Campbell of the Energy ?Information Administration (EIA) in testimony before a congressional ?subcommittee. ??Perhaps more interesting in this unfolding situation, however, is the ?longer-term influence of fundamental shifts in storage facility operations on ?gas markets and individual companies. Do these changes potentially render the ?sharp boundaries of the heating-refill season obsolete? ??"The increasing influence of high-deliverability storage may change the ?meaning of the inventory levels," wrote James Tobin and James Thompson, ?authors of the EIA report Natural Gas Storage in the United States 2001. ??Is past prologue? ?The return of colder temperatures across much of the country resulted in a ?net withdrawal of 49 billion cubic feet (Bcf) from underground storage during ?the week ended March 30, 2001, according to American Gas Association (AGA) ?estimates. Based on these trends, the expectation is that national natural ?gas storage will end this heating season at around 718 Bcf. That is 40 Bcf ?less than the previous record low set in 1996. ????Factors beyond surging demand influenced this record low. For instance, at ?the beginning of the heating season, natural gas-storage volumes were already ?at their lowest since 1976. Partly, this is attributable to the high natural ?gas prices during the first half of 2000. During this time, gas was sold ?rather than injected to take advantage of what was perceived to be a ?temporary price spike. On top of that, November temperatures were atypically ?low resulting in supply constraints. Now, getting storage levels back up to ?comfortable levels will require injection rates that are significantly higher ?than historical rates. ??As summarized by Barone, an injection rate of 70 Bcf per week will be ?required to reach the 2,800 Bcf mark (or 85% full) by November. This compares ?with the 54 Bcf average weekly injection rate during 2000 and the 61 Bcf ?average rates over the past six years. "Even with demand elasticity, this ?will be a tall order," said Barone. ??According to Tobin and Thompson, the resulting heightened competition for ?supplies will push up prices. "Prices, though dropping, are expected to ?exceed the average price level of the 2000 refill season." In other words, ?get ready for another thrilling refill season in terms of price volatility. ??Rethinking the meaning of inventory levels?This season, however, historical clues alone may be inadequate in predicting ?the refill season thrill ride. The situation may be moderated somewhat by ?changes in storage management over the past decade as a result of natural ?gas-market restructuring. ??"Many storage gas owners (marketers and other third parties) are minimizing ?inventories in an attempt to synchronize their buying and selling activities ?more effectively with market needs while minimizing their business costs," ?said Tobin and Thompson. ??In the United States, there are three principal types of underground storage: ?depleted reservoirs in oil and gas fields, aquifers and salt cavern ?formations. Salt caverns are characterized by high withdrawal and injection ?rates and can usually complete several full cycles per year. This is ?typically referred to as high-deliverability, multi-cycle (HDMC) storage. ??Nationwide, there are a total of 415 underground storage sites of which 27 ?are salt caverns and 348 are depleted oil or gas fields. The remainder are ?aquifers. All together, the storage capacity is 3,899 Bcf (including working ?gas) with a daily deliverability of 77,734 million cubic feet (mmcf) per day. ?The 27 salt cavern sites provide 11,416 mmcf of the daily deliverability, ?about 15% of the total. ??"Reflecting the change in focus within the natural gas-storage industry ?during recent years, the largest growth in daily withdrawal capability has ?been from high-deliverability storage sites, which are mainly salt cavern ?storage reservoirs," said the authors of the EIA study. ??Since 1993, when access to interstate underground natural gas storage became ?completely open, daily withdrawal capability from high-deliverability storage ?facilities has grown by 62% and the number of sites has increased from 21 to ?27. During this period, the average cycling rate at these facilities has ?increased from 1.66 to 2.10. ??"Because gas can be rapidly injected/withdrawn from these ?[high-deliverability storage] sites, how full they are on November 1 has less ?significance than inventory levels for depleted or aquifer storage, which are ?designed to cycle (deplete) inventories once a heating season," Tobin and ?Thompson said. For example, a high deliverability facility with a working gas ?capacity of 1 Bcf could possibly cycle 12 Bcf during the calendar year. ?Consequently, the storage operations are not dictated by the need for ?seasonal backup but rather are a function of customers needs. ??Storage assets grow in volume and value?While underground natural gas storage inventories can provide the means to ?meet peak requirements quickly, this can only work up to a point because ?there is not enough known salt dome storage in the country to accommodate a ?total change in strategy. Nevertheless, the storage industry is responding to ?these changes in demand profiles by acquiring, expanding and retrofitting. ??Falcon Gas Storage Co. recently acquired the Hill-Lake natural gas-storage ?facility 100 miles west of Dallas/Ft. Worth in Eastland County from TXU Lone ?Star Pipeline Co. The Hill-Lake facility has operated as a single-cycle ?natural gas-storage facility since the early 1960s. Falcon plans to add more ?compression, retrofit surface facilities and drill horizontal ?injection/withdrawal wells in order to convert the Hill-Lake facility into an ?HDMC facility capable of four to six annual inventory cycles with peak ?withdrawal capacity in excess of 300,000 million British thermal units ?(mmBtu) per day. ??"We are very fortunate to have had the unique opportunity to purchase an ?operating single-cycle gas storage facility that not only can be retrofitted ?for HDMC service at an acceptable cost, but also is in such a strategic ?location," said John M. Hopper, Falcon Gas Storage Co. president. ??Alberta Energy Co. Ltd. said recently it may increase its Wild Goose ?underground storage facility near Gridley in northern California from 14 to ?38 Bcf. Withdrawal capability could rise to 650 mmcf a day from 200 mmcf a ?day. ??"We have had numerous discussions with power generators, marketers and ?industrial users of natural gas who have told us they'd be very interested in ?seeing another open season at Wild Goose," Ben Ledene, Wild Goose vice ?president, said in a statement. ??In March, Aquila, a wholesale gas and power marketer, agreed to buy a salt ?cavern storage project from SG Resources of Houston. The storage facility ?will become operational in 2002. By 2004, the facility will have 12 Bcf of ?capacity. The facility is designed so that 100% of its inventory can be ?delivered in 10 days. ??Market Hub Partners LP (MHP), a division of Duke Energy Gas Transmission, ?filed with the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission for authorization to ?begin a $9 million expansion of its salt cavern storage facility in Egan, La. ?The company plans to incrementally expand from 12 to 16 Bcf, reaching 16 Bcf ?of working storage capacity by 2005. MHP also has plans to expand the HDMC ?services in Copiah, Miss. from 3 Bcf to 9 Bcf. ??"The development of the Copiah facility will greatly enhance our ability to ?meet the time-sensitive injection and withdrawal requirements of today's ?storage customers," said Gregory Rizzo, president of MHP. ??With the continued growth in natural gas-fired generation, Rizzo's comment ?may encapsulate the sentiment that demonstrates a slow but certain shift in ?injection-withdrawal patterns, at least for HDMC assets. As end-use needs ?shift, the concept of a refill and heating season may follow suit. ???