9 Apr 2001, 10:25 UTC
Energy Issues
- From
- Miyung Buster miyung.buster@enron.com
- To
-
Ann M Schmidt, Bryan Seyfried, dg27@pacbell.net, Elizabeth Linnell, filuntz@aol.com, James D Steffes, Janet Butler, Jeannie Mandelker, Jeff Dasovich, Joe Hartsoe, John Neslage, John Sherriff
and 38 more
Joseph Alamo, Karen Denne, Lysa Akin, Margaret Carson, Mark Palmer, Mark Schroeder, Markus Fiala, Michael R Brown, Mike Dahlke, Mona L Petrochko, Nicholas O'Day, Peggy Mahoney, Peter Styles, Richard Shapiro, Rob Bradley, Sandra McCubbin, Shelley Corman, Stella Chan, Steven J Kean, Susan J Mara, mike.roan@enron.com, Alex Parsons, andrew.morrison@enron.com, Laura Ipsen, Janel Guerrero, shirley.hudler@enron.com, Kathleen Sullivan, Tom Briggs, Linda Robertson, Lora Sullivan, Jennifer Thome, jkradin@marathon-com.com, rlichtenstein@marathon-com.com, Sandra Yamane, Ken Smith, Hedy Govenar, Scott Govenar, Bev Hansen - Date
- Mon, 9 Apr 2001 03:25:00 -0700 (PDT)
Please see the following articles: Energy Insight, Fri, 4/6: "PG&E files for Chapter 11" Sac Bee, Mon, 4/9: "Energy supply setback: Big generator can't be forced to sell emergency power to the state, a U.S. court rules" Sac Bee, Mon, 4/9: "Dan Walters: Hertzberg's oversight is looking more like a whitewash" San Diego Union, Sun, 4/8: "PG&E awards bonuses hours before filing Chapter 11" San Diego Union, Sat, 4/7: "PG&E looks to court for debt relief; Davis promises to expedite deal with Edison" San Diego Union, Sat, 4/7: "Utility argues for Otay power plant " San Diego Union, Sat, 4/7: "United at the start, lawmakers now split on how to clean mess " San Diego Union, Sat, 4/7: "GOP activists feel state is being snubbed by Bush" LA Times, Mon, 4/9: "With Power Price Surges, California's a Follower" LA Times, Mon, 4/9: "Judge in PG&E Bankruptcy Case Seen as a Problem Solver" LA Times, Mon, 4/9: "Bankruptcy Filing Threatens Tax Bases" LA Times, Mon, 4/9: "Others Learning from California's Energy Mistakes" LA Times, Mon, 4/9: "Generators Scrambled to End Pacts With Utilities " LA Times, Sun, 4/8: "PG&E Gave Bonuses Prior to Bankruptcy" LA Times, Sun, 4/8: "Shifting Action to Neutral Arena May Be Bankruptcy Filing's Upside" LA Times, Mon, 4/9: "Shock's Silver Lining" (Commentary) LA Times, Mon, 4/9: "Use Eminent Domain as a Power Tool " (Commentary) SF Chron, Mon, 4/9: "Governor, Utility In War Of Words Davis furious as PG&E defends bankruptcy filing " SF Chron, Mon, 4/9: "Power Grab -- Some Democrats Favor Seizing Plants" SF Chron, Mon, 4/9: "Davis Could Still Show Courage " (Editorial) SF Chron, Mon, 4/9: "Governor, bankrupt utility blame each other for power woes " SF Chron, Mon, 4/9: "Negotiations continue between state and SoCal Edison " SF Chron, Mon, 4/9: "SAN FRANCISCO PUC General Manager To Leave S.F. Post " Mercury News, Mon, 4/9: "Gov. Davis, bankrupt utility blame each other for power woes" Mercury News, Mon, 4/9: "Cheap, abundant coal eyed with new interest" Mercury News, Mon, 4/9: "Leaders threaten to seize power contracts, plants" Mercury News, Mon, 4/9: "Blackouts this summer?" (Commentary) Individual.com, Mon, 4/9: "Pacific Gas Files for Chapter 11" Individual.com, Mon, 4/9: "Davis endorses rate hikes, defends handling of energy crisis" Individual.com, Mon, 4/9: "Sempra Energy And SDG&E Reaffirm Strong Financial Position in Response to PG&E Bankruptcy" ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ -------------------------------------------------------------------- Friday, April 6, 2001 By Rick Stouffer rstouffer@ftenergy.com Pacific Gas & Electric Co., saddled with $9 billion in wholesale power costs it could not collect and with costs increasing by $300 million per month, filed Friday for protection from creditors under Chapter 11 of the U.S. Bankruptcy Code. Under Chapter 11, the utility unit of PG&E Corp. will be given time to reorganize its precarious financial situation, including the restructuring of its massive debt. The filing in no way impacts PG&E or its other subsidiaries, including National Energy Group. "We believe filing for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection is the best alternative to protect the legal rights of Pacific Gas & Electric and to allow us to continue serving our (13 million) customers," said Pacific Gas & Electric Chairman Robert D. Glynn Jr., during a Friday teleconference. Four primary reasons for filing In a teleconference on Friday April 6, Glynn listed four primary reasons for filing for Chapter 11, including: Failure by California to assume the full procurement responsibility for the utility's "net open position," which the company said was provided for. This resulted in Pacific Gas & Electric continuing to be exposed to purchase costs totaling an estimated $300 million-plus per month. "We don't actually know how much we owe the DWR (California Department of Water Resources) or the ISO (California Independent System Operator), because they've never told us," Glynn said. Actions taken by the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) on March 27 and April 3, which Pacific Gas & Electric said created new payment obligations and undermined its ability to return to financial viability. Those actions included mandating Pacific Gas & Electric pay the full amount of the bills presented by qualifying facilities, and that the utility "pay out more in cash to DWR than we collect in rates," according to Glynn. Lack of any progress in negotiations between the company and the state concerning the $9 billion in excess wholesale power costs spent since last June. "Talks were going nowhere; we would reach agreements that were then not followed up on," Glynn said. "We've heard a lot of words come out of Sacramento, but the challenge was to follow up with action." The adoption by the CPUC of what Pacific Gas & Electric called an illegal and retroactive accounting change that would appear to eliminate the company's uncollected wholesale costs. The CPUC ruled that the utilities offset their wholesale power costs against the transition costs collected from ratepayers. The order also requires the utilities to offset their operating costs with the money they make from selling power from their own generating units during the rate freeze. The companies believe that if the order isn't changed, they could not recover past purchased power expenses. PG&E PROFILE SPREADSHEET Many not surprised Analysts for the most part were not surprised that Pacific Gas & Electric took Friday's action, many saying they had expected a filing weeks ago. "I always believed this was the smartest way to deal with this debacle," said Bill LeBlanc, vice president of retail consulting for Boulder, Colorado research and consulting firm E Source*the retail-energy wing of FT Energy. "I expect Southern California Edison to follow suit; I had actually expected these utilities to file Chapter 11 about eight weeks ago." LeBlanc said he expected a Chapter 11 filing, because California will not bail out the utilities, and they have no way to recover costs in an expeditious manner in what they believe is economically fair to their corporation and customers. Governor's acquiescence didn't help Even a short press conference Thursday by California Gov. Gray Davis, in which he finally admitted a rate hike was needed, and his proposal to provide as much as $8 billion in bonds to pay the utilities' past power costs, could not deter Pacific Gas & Electric's filing. The governor's words had little effect on Glynn. "Did we hear the governor's speech last night? We heard a lot of words, but we have not seen the actions," Glynn told his teleconference audience. "Almost every day since this crisis began, we have looked at staying out of bankruptcy, vs. entering bankruptcy," Glynn said. "We expect the court to provide the venue needed to reach a solution which the state and regulators have been unable to achieve." "This (bankruptcy filing) really wasn't unexpected; this company has been making noise like this for weeks," said Dresdner Kleinwort Wasserstein energy analyst Linda Byus. "The governor probably expected that he made a big noise last night with his announcement, but these guys said no, not really." "It's a very unfortunate situation, extremely complicated," according to Jeffrey Holzschuh, managing director and head of Morgan Stanley Dean Witter's Global Energy Group. "There are just so many people involved in this that I don't think you can come to conclusion quickly or easily." Judge holds the power What bankruptcy offers is a utility "czar," a court judge with virtually unlimited power, legal scholars said. The judge will hold the situation in his or her hands*and the governor, shareholders and consumers be darned. "Bottom line is the judge has total control," according to Robert Nachtmann, professor of finance and executive associate dean of the Katz Graduate School of Business at the University of Pittsburgh. Preservation of the utility's assets is first and foremost in the judge's eyes*doing what needs to be done to keep the company operational. Who loses? Who loses? In particular, the power producers that have been vilified by Glynn and his counterpart at SoCal Ed will lose*as well as Gov. Davis. However, in reality, just about everyone in the state of California will suffer. Stocks of power wholesalers, including Duke Energy, Dynegy Corp., Williams Cos. Inc. and Reliant Energy Inc. immediately swooned once word spread concerning Pacific Gas & Electric's filing. "Creditors, including the state, wholesalers, equipment vendors, etc. will take something of a financial hit*probably get back something like 50 cents to 75 cents on the dollar for what they are owed," according to John Egan, E Source's director, strategic & marketing issues. Shareholders will be the big losers; typically they will be wiped out, Egan said. Glynn said he did not know how long the process would take, but expect it to be long and extremely costly. The University of Pittsburgh's Nachtmann said the average time frame for bankruptcy for a publicly traded entity is about 30 months. Huge monetary cost As for cost, the 1992 to 1996 bankruptcy of El Paso Electric Co. cost an estimated $100 million*and that was for a company many times smaller than the behemoth Pacific Gas & Electric. One thing is for sure: The problems and trials in the California energy market will only continue. "This will continue daily, weekly, hourly for the foreseeable future," Morgan Stanley's Holzschuh said. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------ Energy supply setback: Big generator can't be forced to sell emergency power to the state, a U.S. court rules. By Denny Walsh and Carrie Peyton BEE STAFF WRITERS (Published April 6, 2001) In a development that does not bode well for California's energy supply, a federal appellate court Thursday halted enforcement of a lower court order that a big electricity generator must sell emergency power to the state without guarantee of payment. State energy officials said the ruling wouldn't have any immediate effect but could precipitate a power emergency if the generator decided to take a plant off-line for maintenance. On March 21, citing "rolling blackouts (that have) darkened the California landscape," U.S. District Judge Frank C. Damrell Jr. imposed an injunction against Reliant Energy Services Inc., one of the nation's major generators. Houston-based Reliant controls approximately 3,800 megawatts, or about 20 percent, of the gas-fired generation capacity in the state, and Damrell found that loss of that production "poses an imminent threat." But Thursday, a three-judge panel of the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals granted an emergency stay of the injunction, saying Reliant has shown "a high likelihood of success on the merits" of its appeal. While not spelling it out, the panel apparently bases its finding on the question of the courts' jurisdiction over the energy market. The panel directed that a hearing on the appeal be scheduled for the second week in July. The decision leaves California's electric grid more fragile, at least temporarily, according to the state Independent System Operator, which maintains and controls power transmissions. It gives the agency no immediate recourse if Reliant chooses to shut down any of its plants for maintenance, said ISO Vice President Jim Detmers. "It's not going to change anything overnight, and it's not going to change anything over the weekend," said Detmers. "But if Reliant decided on a unilateral action to take their units off for maintenance ... we definitely could have a system emergency." Reliant officials, when told of the ruling, took a conciliatory tone but declined to specify their next move. "Reliant ... has pledged to keep the lights on in California," said company lobbyist Marty Wilson, and "is still of a mind to want to cooperate." Without further comment, the appeals court judges cited a 1980 U.S. District Court decision. In that case, 14 cities sued Florida Power and Light Co., alleging that it was violating a number of laws in its sales of power and production of electricity. The judge found, however, that the Federal Power Act reserves oversight of interstate utilities exclusively to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission. He ruled that only the commission may bring an action involving energy sales into federal court -- unless it is a request to review a commission order, and that goes directly to an appellate court. The lawsuit before Damrell was brought by the ISO to force Reliant and two other generators to respond to ISO's emergency orders for power, even though the agency is buying on behalf of two retailers that are broke and hopelessly in debt. Because Pacific Gas and Electric Co. and Southern California Edison can't pay their bills -- about $14 billion -- some wholesalers want to cut off sales to the utilities. The other three defendants in the ISO's suit -- Dynegy Power Corp. of Houston and Tulsa-based AES Corp. and its marketer, Williams Energy Marketing & Trading Co. -- have entered into written agreements with ISO to continue supplying emergency power until the FERC decides whether they are required to sell to companies that are not creditworthy. But Charles Robinson, ISO general counsel, points out that the generators can rescind those agreements with 48 hours' notice. "My hope is this is a temporary setback," said Robinson. He added, however, that the practical effect is "at least for now, we don't have a tool to compel them to do what we believe they're obligated to do" -- respond to emergency demands for power. Reliant has insisted since the suit was filed Feb. 6 that Damrell has no jurisdiction over the rate schedules that govern dealings between generators and the ISO, and that the Federal Power Act mandates that the FERC must settle any disputes about terms of those tariffs. In issuing the injunction, Damrell acknowledged that the FERC has special expertise concerning agreements between generators and ISO. "Absent the extreme exigencies of the California power crisis, the court agrees that a stay pending further action by the FERC would be proper," he said. "But those are not the facts here. Electricity is in critically short supply. The health and safety of the people of California are potentially at risk." Immediately upon receiving the 9th Circuit's order Thursday, attorneys for the ISO asked Damrell to set an accelerated schedule for its motion to amend the suit. The agency apparently has crafted a new complaint stressing its view that the matter is an ordinary contract dispute over which the judge has jurisdiction. Damrell scheduled a hearing on the motion for Thursday. In a further development that could complicate the state's dire need for energy, an alternative supplier won a court fight Thursday to bypass the big utilities and sell its power on the open market. Timber giant Sierra Pacific Industries, which operates four biomass plants that produce power for PG&E, obtained a temporary restraining order in Sacramento Superior Court that says Sierra Pacific is not required to sell its power to PG&E. The ruling means PG&E and Southern Edison could lose power as alternative energy generators, fed up with months of nonpayment, sue to be able to sell their comparatively cheap product elsewhere, including outside the state. The Bee's Denny Walsh can be reached at (916) 321-1189 or dwalsh@sacbee.com. Bee staff writer Dale Kasler contributed to this report. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ---------------------------- Dan Walters: Hertzberg's oversight is looking more like a whitewash (Published April 9, 2001) When Bob Hertzberg was elevated into the Assembly speakership a year ago, he pledged to make a priority of what's called "oversight" -- the much-neglected legislative duty to examine how administrative agencies operate programs. "We pass all these bills," Hertzberg said in a speech shortly after being elected speaker. "What do they mean? What did they do? We intend to do a great deal of oversight." Seemingly, Hertzberg made good on his pledge when the Assembly conducted an exemplary, bipartisan investigation of state Insurance Commissioner Chuck Quackenbush's questionable regulation of insurers. The Assembly investigation was the key factor in Quackenbush's decision to abandon his once-promising political career. Flaying Republican Quackenbush for his shortcomings was relatively easy for Democrat Hertzberg. Would he, many wondered, be equally eager to examine wrongdoing, or simple incompetence, by Democratic officeholders, especially Gov. Gray Davis? The answer, apparently, is no. While there are many potential targets for deeply probing legislative examinations, Hertzberg and his much-vaunted staff of investigators have not given them the same attention as Quackenbush received. Early this year, the Hertzberg hit team went to work on the energy crisis, and Assemblyman Darrell Steinberg, D-Sacramento, was appointed to chair a special committee that was to delve into how the crisis came to pass. But after fiddling around with the matter for several weeks and failing to pinpoint some easy villains, the investigation sputtered. The moratorium on oversight occurred just as the committee was moving into an area that could have been embarrassing to Davis and state Public Utilities Commission President Loretta Lynch -- what they did or did not do last summer when the crisis first became apparent. It's an area of inquiry whose importance was magnified by Friday's bankruptcy filing by Pacific Gas and Electric Co. Republicans complained about the investigation's shutdown, but to no avail. The hollowness of Hertzberg's oversight pledge was demonstrated again the other day when a subcommittee of the Assembly Governmental Organization Committee staged what it described as an "informational hearing" on what are arguably the state's two most dysfunctional agencies, the Department of Veterans Affairs and the California National Guard. The former is a mess from top to bottom and has been for years. Its two major functions, providing home loans to veterans and operating two residential facilities for aged and/or ill veterans, have been plagued by mismanagement and downright neglect. It's been a notorious dumping ground for political hacks through several gubernatorial administrations. Agency secretaries have come and gone in clouds of personal scandal. Revelations about the National Guard are more recent but equally disturbing. Its readiness for either active military duty or responding to state disasters has declined, and its non-military programs supposedly serving delinquent youths are marginally effective at best and riddled with financial irregularities. Under Adj. Gen. Paul Monroe, the Guard has become top-heavy with cronies while Monroe has feuded openly with his second-in-command, Ezell Ware. At one point this year, Monroe unilaterally dumped Ware from the slot to which he had been appointed by Davis, but within four days Ware was restored to his deputy's position. The subcommittee's chairman, first-term Assemblyman Ed Chavez, D-La Puente, conducted what can only be described as a sham hearing, allowing bureaucrats for both agencies to emit a blizzard of self-serving statements and data with little or no questioning, and then praising them for their appearances. Monroe, he said, "showcased the National Guard as we had hoped." If the aborted energy investigation and the Chavez hearing were what Hertzberg had in mind as "oversight," a better word might be "whitewash." The Bee's Dan Walters can be reached at (916) 321-1195 or dwalters@sacbee.com . ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ -------------------------------- PG&E awards bonuses hours before filing Chapter 11 ASSOCIATED PRESS April 8, 2001 SAN FRANCISCO ) As a reward for "staying the course" the parent company of Pacific Gas and Electric Co. awarded about 6,000 bonuses and raises to midlevel managers and other employees hours before the utility filed for bankruptcy, a newspaper reported. PG&E Corp. Chairman Robert Glynn issued an internal memo late Thursday that incentive payments denied in January would be awarded to eligible employees at the subsidiary utility. The payments were made in time for many of the bonuses to be deposited into workers' bank accounts before the utility filed for Chapter 11 Friday morning, the San Francisco Chronicle reported Saturday after obtaining a copy of the memo. Gov. Gray Davis issued a brief statement Saturday in response saying "PG&E's management is suffering from two afflictions: denial and greed." Glynn applauded the employees' "efforts, teamwork and dedication during the past year, and particularly throughout the ongoing energy crisis," he wrote. "Thank you for staying the course." The bonuses and raises were earned as part of the company's incentive program. In January, the amount owed to employees who met their department objectives was estimated at $83 million, Pacific Gas & Electric Co. spokesman Ron Low said Saturday. The amount paid out was less than the earlier estimate because top-level company executives were exempt from payment. Low did not have a dollar figure for the amount paid out but said it was based only on department objectives met by employees. Low said the money came from a combination of a $1.1 billion tax refund, paying power generators only what the company receives in rates and cash conservation within the company such as halting the installation of underground distribution lines. The raises and bonuses were given to secretarial staff, midlevel managers and other support staff. No money was distributed to rank-and-file union members who already received a wage increase earlier this year as part of their contract, Low said. The performance-based bonuses can equal up to four weeks of an employee's regular salary, said company spokesman John Nelson. Annual raises average 3 percent of an employee's salary and are meant to balance cost-of-living expenses, he said. Los Angeles lawyer David Huard of Manatt, Phelps & Phillips said the practice of compensating employees prior to filing Chapter 11 is not uncommon. In addition, the U.S. bankruptcy court in San Francisco granted approval for Pacific Gas & Electric Co. to make outstanding compensation payments to employees and to maintain related bank accounts. "It's not unusual for corporations anticipating bankruptcy to sweeten the pot and encourage management to stay," Huard said. But Assembly Republican Leader Dave Cox, R-Fair Oaks, said it's disgraceful to the state's ratepayers. "On the surface it's outrageous," he said. "Declaring bankruptcy and at the same time providing increases and bonuses for employees would just be in your face to the consumers of the state of California." ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------ PG&E looks to court for debt relief; Davis promises to expedite deal with Edison By Ed Mendel UNION-TRIBUNE STAFF WRITER April 7, 2001 SACRAMENTO -- California's electricity crisis entered a new phase of open combat yesterday when the state's largest utility, Pacific Gas and Electric, suddenly declared bankruptcy, blaming Gov. Gray Davis for delaying negotiations. Davis said San Francisco-based PG&E has "dishonored itself" and that he vows to complete an agreement with Southern California Edison soon to show that negotiation, not bankruptcy, is the best way out of the crisis. PG&E said routine service will continue and that no employees will be laid off. The bankruptcy filing halts attempts to collect debts from the utility as a judge begins a process that some think could be lengthy, with an uncertain outcome. Utility argues for Otay power plant United at the start, lawmakers now split on how to clean mess GOP activists feel state is being snubbed by Bush Continuing coverage: California's Power Crisis ? The utility filed for protection under Chapter 11 of the federal bankruptcy law, which means it plans to reorganize and pay off its debt over time. The bankruptcy judge, Dennis Montali of San Francisco, may seek a change in a big rate increase approved by the Public Utilities Commission last week for PG&E customers. Creditors form committees under the bankruptcy process to represent their interests. Angry consumer groups said they will form a committee of their own and attempt to become part of the process. The consumer groups accused PG&E of maneuvering to protect its parent firm, PG&E Corp., while forcing ratepayers to pay off an $8.9 billion debt, run up while rates were frozen under deregulation and wholesale power costs soared. "The holding company vacuumed all of the assets out of the utility and is perfectly willing to let it go bankrupt," said Nettie Hoge of The Utility Reform Network in San Francisco. Senate Energy Committee Chairwoman Debra Bowen, D-Marina del Rey, a lawyer who worked on the Chrysler bankruptcy, predicted one benefit of the bankruptcy will be that generators accused of gouging California will not get full payment. "There is no way generators expecting to get paid 100 cents on the dollar come out of a bankruptcy with 100 cents on the dollar," Bowen said. The surprise PG&E announcement came the morning after the governor used a statewide televised address to reassure the public that he had a plan for ending the crisis, which included paying off the utilities' huge debt. But PG&E, which has resisted state purchase of its transmission system in exchange for payment of its debt, said it concluded that the court offers the best way out while the utility continues routine service to customers. "The regulatory and political processes have not provided a solution, and now we are turning to the court," said Robert Glynn Jr., chairman of PG&E Corp. Glynn said Davis aides did not meet with PG&E for more than three weeks while they tried to wrap up the Edison deal and that they then did little in a meeting this week. "We have heard a lot of words from the Sacramento sources that simply have not come to fruition," Glynn said. The governor, who used the televised address to drop his opposition to a big rate increase and propose one of his own, was not happy to learn that he has lost his battle to keep the utilities out of bankruptcy. "I believe PG&E has dishonored itself," Davis said as he signed a bill in downtown San Diego yesterday. "It has created undue alarm among 34 million citizens of this state." Davis acknowledged that the PG&E bankruptcy may force him to alter his rescue plan based on the principle that the utilities must give the state something in exchange for aid in paying off their debts. To make the deal work, he said, he needs the transmission systems of all three utilities: PG&E, Edison, and San Diego Gas and Electric. The judge and the creditor committees presumably would have to approve the sale of the PG&E transmission system. If that is not possible, Davis said, he will negotiate for "comparable assets," such as the hydroelectric facilities owned by the utilities. The governor's plan would give the utilities part of the revenue from the monthly bills paid by their customers -- a "dedicated rate component" -- that could be used to finance an $8 billion bond to pay off their debts. In San Diego, the governor signed a bill that extends the SDG&E rate cap to businesses, retroactive to Feb. 7. He appeared earlier at an Escondido elementary school, where he praised student conservation efforts. Davis told reporters that PG&E chairman Glynn told him a week ago that the PG&E board was one vote short of filing for bankruptcy and that seeking a solution in the court was "a very real option." The governor said PG&E chose to further its own interests, not the best interest of Californians. In contrast, he said, PG&E's creditors have acted responsibly and shown faith in negotiations by not pushing the utility into bankruptcy. "I am pleased that Southern California Edison and San Diego Gas and Electric are allowing us to negotiate a settlement as opposed to forcing this matter into bankruptcy," he said. Davis said he planned to attend a previously scheduled meeting yesterday afternoon with John Bryson, Edison's top executive, to work on the final issues in the purchase of its transmission system. "We are down to a few remaining issues that we hope to work out within the next very few days," Davis said. Southern California's parent, Edison International, yesterday emphasized the importance of completing the sale of the transmission system quickly to prevent creditors from taking the utility into bankruptcy. Lynn LoPucki, a UCLA law professor who specializes in corporate bankruptcies, predicted that Edison will follow PG&E into bankruptcy. He said the two utilities have comparable business plans and have made similar decisions so far. "They have pretty much marched together on this," LoPucki said. PG&E and Edison say they ran up a combined debt of $13 billion when their rates were frozen under deregulation last year and wholesale power costs soared. After generators refused to extend the utilities more credit, the state was forced to begin buying power for utility customers in mid-January. The state has spent more than $4 billion so far, most of it on the expensive spot market. The state has signed more than $40 billion worth of long-term contracts to provide cheaper power during the next 10 years. The state general fund will be repaid by a bond of $12 billion or more, paid off by ratepayers over a dozen years. Glynn said PG&E decided to declare bankruptcy because the PUC, while raising the utility's rates last week, gave the additional money to the state for its power purchases and imposed new costs on PG&E by requiring the utility to pay small nonutility generators. In addition, said Glynn, the PUC adopted an "illegal and retroactive accounting change" advocated by consumer groups that would have counted transfers to the parent firm to offset the estimate of the utility's debt. But another important factor was that the state has not been paying for expensive last-minute power acquisitions made by the Independent System Operator to keep the grid at minimum levels. Glynn said the state has been improperly assigning the cost of this expensive emergency power to PG&E, increasing the utility's debt at an estimated rate of $300 million a month. Ironically, federal regulators ruled yesterday that generators cannot be forced to sell emergency power to the California grid if the utilities can't pay for it. Now the state may have to begin paying for the emergency power. PG&E contends that if the PUC had approved its request for a rate increase last fall, the utility would have raised rates less than the PUC and Davis have proposed, obtained cheap long-term power contracts, and thus the state would not have had to begin buying power. Under bankruptcy, PG&E said it will be able to pay all new bills, continue normal service to its customers, and provide health care and other benefits to its employees and retirees. But payments on bonds and loans may be suspended, the utility said. Glynn said he expected bankruptcy to aid shareholders by halting PG&E's mounting debt. But the surprising move caused the stock of all three California utilities to drop yesterday, and trading in PG&E stock was halted briefly. Some small nonutility generators that operate under the federal "qualifying facilities" program have formed a creditors committee, the first step toward taking Edison into bankruptcy. A spokesman for the creditors committee, Jack Raudy, said yesterday that PG&E's bankruptcy "underscores the state's critical need for a real solution without further delay." The generators who formed the creditors committee get power from "renewable" sources such as wind, solar, geothermal and biomass. Nonutility "co-generators" use natural-gas turbines and sell the waste heat to businesses. "None of the members that I represent are interested in putting Edison into involuntary bankruptcy," said Ann MacLeod of the California Cogeneration Council. Staff writers Bruce V. Bigelow, Karen Kucher and Eleanor Yang contributed to this report. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------ Utility argues for Otay power plant Rivals claim it would add to area pollution By Jeff McDonald UNION-TRIBUNE STAFF WRITER April 7, 2001 While attorneys for the state's largest utility were filing for bankruptcy protection in San Francisco yesterday, executives from its sister company were in San Diego lobbying state energy officials to push ahead with a huge investment. At a committee hearing in the County Administration Building yesterday, PG&E National Energy Group urged a California Energy Commission committee to approve plans for a 510-megawatt power plant on Otay Mesa. Operators of two power plants in the county opposed the request, saying it could result in dirtier skies. "We're focused on getting this plant on-line as soon as possible," project manager Sharon Segner told the panel. "Any (commission) delay, whether it's a week or a month, presents greater risk of this plant not coming online in 2003 .?.?. The schedule is already tight." The bankruptcy filing by Pacific Gas and Electric has no effect on the Otay Mesa project, Segner said. "It may be confusing to the public, but at the end of the day, we are separate companies," she said after the hearing. The Otay Mesa application, which has been in the works for more than three years, is expected to be considered by the full commission April 18. The plant would provide enough power for roughly 380,000 homes and businesses. The siting committee has indicated its support for the project, but the hearing yesterday was intended to give opponents and members of the public an opportunity to testify for and against the plant. Attorneys for the owners of the Encina and South Bay power plants urged the committee to reject the Otay Mesa project, saying the area's natural-gas pipelines could not accommodate enough fuel to supply another plant. What's more, lawyers for Duke Energy and Cabrillo Power said, the Otay Mesa plant could only run on natural gas. The two existing plants can run on natural gas or fuel oil, which causes more pollution. If there are natural gas shortages, the lawyers said their clients would have to burn the dirtier fuel. "We would be criticized for that publicly," said Jane Luckhardt, an attorney for Duke Energy, which operates the South Bay plant in Chula Vista. "We will be forced to purchase very expensive (smog) emission credits." A consultant for Cabrillo Power, which co-owns the Encina plant in Carlsbad, also told the committee that the Otay Mesa facility would hurt his clients. Robert Weatherwax of Sierra Energy and Risk Assessment told the panel that allowing the Otay Mesa plant would create as much as 800 tons of smog, although he did not specify over how long a period the extra smog would be created. The new power plant "will force Encina and South Bay to burn more oil," Weatherwax warned. The PG&E National Energy Group said it will get much of its fuel from a natural gas pipeline scheduled to be built between Blythe and Tijuana. Gas from that line would power both the Otay Mesa plant and another in Rosarito, Mexico, company officials said. "There's no nexus between our proceeding and their issues," Segner said of the complaints from Duke Energy and Cabrillo Power attorneys. The Otay Mesa power plant application won praise from several business groups as well as Supervisor Bill Horn, who urged the committee to approve the project as soon as possible. Horn said he received numerous complaints from area biotechnology firms after rolling blackouts hit San Diego County for the first time last month. Three companies in particular reported losing years of research, he said. The Otay Mesa project "will play a key role in solving the energy problem that's plaguing San Diego County," Horn told the committee. While the plant would brighten the West's electricity supply picture, there is no requirement that the power generated at the Otay Mesa plant be used in San Diego County. The project was opposed by some environmentalists, who chastised the California Energy Commission for relying too heavily on fossil fuels for the state's power needs. William Claycomb of the Save Our Bay nonprofit group said commissioners should focus more attention on lowering the price of photovoltaic systems, which use solar power to provide energy to homes and businesses. "We're going to spend a lot of time and money building power plants up to our ears that won't be needed" in the coming years, Claycomb said. "The sun is the ultimate source of energy." Ownership of the Otay Mesa plant will be transferred to Calpine Corp. of San Jose once final approval is granted by the state Energy Commission. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------- United at the start, lawmakers now split on how to clean mess By Toby Eckert? COPLEY NEWS SERVICE April 7, 2001 WASHINGTON -- Back in 1997, as California's experiment with electricity deregulation was about to get under way, the state's entire House delegation signed a letter assuring congressional leaders that the plan would "provide tremendous benefits to the citizens of our state." Now that the experiment is acknowledged as an abject failure, the delegation has yet to present a united front on what, if anything, the federal government should do to help out. Most notably, there seems to be no consensus on the wisdom of slapping federal price controls on the stratospheric cost of wholesale power in the West. While nearly all California Democrats have publicly embraced the proposal, including U.S. Sens. Dianne Feinstein and Barbara Boxer, only a handful of Republicans have joined them. "In terms of price caps, there are deep divisions," an aide to one top California Republican said. Many GOP members worry that price controls "would leave (power companies) disinterested in selling to the California market," aggravating the electricity shortage, the aide said. The feeling is not unanimous among Republicans, however. Republican Reps. Duncan Hunter of El Cajon and Randy "Duke" Cunningham of Escondido -- whose San Diego-area constituents were hit with huge power bills last summer -- have advocated wholesale price limits. And some Democrats suspect there are more California Republicans who are willing to support price controls but are wary of publicly challenging the Bush administration, which adamantly opposes the limits. "I think there are Republicans who are very supportive. And we hope that they will join us," said Rep. Susan Davis, D-San Diego. California consumer advocates, who favor price controls, are critical of the congressional response. "They all organized themselves when it came time to pushing for the utility companies (who favored deregulation). But they're not organized at all when it comes to (price) caps. They're AWOL," said Harvey Rosenfield, president of the Santa Monica-based Foundation for Taxpayer and Consumer Rights. But Tim Ransdell, executive director of the nonpartisan California Institute for Federal Policy Research, said the divisions in the congressional delegation reflect the complexity of the power crisis. "If there was a silver bullet for this, if there was a single obvious remedy, I think Californians would flock to it," Ransdell said. "Price caps may be the right way to go or they may not be. There are strong arguments in varying directions. They've got to do something. Nobody knows what the right something is." Congressional delegations from other states affected by the power crisis, such as Washington and Oregon, are similarly divided. Despite the rift over price controls, the GOP aide maintained that California Republicans and Democrats "have worked together in a number of ways to ensure that the (Bush) administration is paying attention to the problem and doing what it can." Members of both parties sent strong signals to the administration that the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission was not doing enough to address the power crisis, the aide said. That message played a role in President Bush's reported desire to replace FERC Chairman Curtis Hebert and the commission's subsequent flurry of threats to order power providers to pay refunds for overcharging California utilities, the aide speculated. Other observers say Bush merely wants to install his "own man" as head of FERC -- former Texas utility regulator Pat Wood -- and that the agency's actions amount to tokenism. Some Democrats believe that the pressure for federal electricity price controls will grow as consumers throughout California start seeing a recent retail rate hike show up in their bills. Widespread blackouts this summer could add more momentum. "I think we're going to be witnessing initiatives, referenda, recall efforts, a consumer revolution in California unless we find a way to put a tourniquet on this problem," said Rep. Jane Harman, D-Venice. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ - GOP activists feel state is being snubbed by Bush They fault administration's handling of energy crisis By George E. Condon Jr. COPLEY NEWS SERVICE April 7, 2001 WASHINGTON -- California Republican activists are starting to grow restive at what many see as President Bush's inattention to the nation's largest state in the opening months of his administration. Despite frequent assurances from the White House that the president has California concerns on his agenda, many Republicans believe that he has already missed an opportunity to rebound from his shellacking in the state in November's election. "It is a slow, day-by-day erosion of California confidence in the administration's understanding of the needs and desires of Californians. There are people here who are getting pretty nervous," said a senior Republican, who has been heavily involved in Republican administrations in Sacramento and Washington. "It's just slowly backing up in the California consciousness that these guys look like they're completely out of touch with mainstream California concerns," said the Republican, a longtime Bush supporter who would speak only on the condition that he not be named out of fear of being branded "disloyal" by the White House. Other Republicans are equally cautious about going public with their concerns. But they don't like what they have seen so far: ?By the end of next week, Bush will have visited 25 states, including 11 of the most populous 13, but not California. ?There is no Californian among the president's senior domestic advisers. The highest-ranking Californians on the president's domestic staff are Ruben Barrales, director of the office of intergovernmental affairs, and Lezlee Westine, director of public liaison. ?His early environmental and abortion actions have been at odds with majority California views. ?The administration's early positions on the energy crisis have come across to many Californians as aloof and uninvolved. Gerry Parsky, the Rancho Santa Fe investment banker who ran the Texan's California campaign last year, is the president's prime adviser in the state. He disagrees with the criticism now bubbling up and urges skeptics to take a second look. "My message is that from the moment that this president began his campaign for the presidency, he made it clear that California was important to him and that he was committed to helping change the face of the Republican Party in California and to reach out to people that felt left out," said Parsky. "That began with the campaign, it carried throughout the campaign. And since he's been president, he's demonstrated repeatedly, with appointments he has made and with his continual contact with the state, that he hasn't changed his position at all," added Parsky. Three Californians serve in Bush's Cabinet: Ann Veneman, Norman Mineta and Anthony Principi are, respectively, secretaries of agriculture, transportation and veterans affairs. At the White House, spokesman Ken Lisaius objected to tallies of presidential trips that have excluded California. "It's a little unfair to say that, because somebody is not there, that they don't care or they're ignoring the state," he said, calling administration officials "very engaged" in the state's issues. But other Republicans say there are few visible signs of that engagement. More troubling than the president's travel itinerary, they say, has been the administration's handling of the state's energy crisis. With staunch opposition to price caps and the appointment of a Dick Cheney-led task force, the administration has emphasized that the problem was caused by a bad California law and it is up to Californians to extricate themselves from the mess. Over and over, Democrats -- gleefully -- and Republicans -- ruefully -- say the impression left has been a paraphrase of the famous 1970s New York tabloid headline: "Bush to California: Drop Dead!" "Substantively, the administration has been saying all the right things," said veteran state Republican operative Dan Schnur. "But stylistically, the message that Californians hear is that George Bush doesn't care." Energy, he said, "is the only issue in California right now and the administration's distance represents a missed opportunity to make up lost ground." Garry Sragow, a Democratic consultant in the state, said his daily tracking polls since Bush's inauguration show his popularity remaining flat in California, evincing none of the honeymoon bounce evident nationally. But he said there has been a steady, daily increase in the number of Californians who say the president should "do more" about the energy crisis. That number now stands, he said, at two-thirds of Californians. "He is not feeling our pain the way Bill Clinton did," said Sherry Bebitch Jeffe, a political scientist at the University of Southern California. "There is a disconnect between George Bush and California." Democratic pollster Mark Mellman said the message is clear: "He doesn't care enough about the state to even show up. And on the issue most critically important to the state, he refuses to do anything. There couldn't be a bigger kiss-off." There have been no recent public polls. Surveys of California voters taken for the administration show Bush's popularity lagging below his national numbers. "He's got no place to go but up," said Sragow. "He started off with his hard-core base in California. He's not going to lose them. The question is, will he begin to attract swing voters? And he has made no effort to do that yet." It is with these voters that the environmental decisions have been damaging, said several analysts, who also noted the sharp contrast between the current approach to the state and that adopted by Clinton. "We got accused of throwing too much to California and ignoring the rest of the country. He's getting accused of the opposite," said John Emerson, the California lawyer who was a senior adviser to Clinton. Unless it is changed, he warned, Bush's hands-off approach to the state "almost fore-ordains a blowout" loss in 2004. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ----------------------------------------------------------------------- With Power Price Surges, California's a Follower Energy: Much of the nation is already being zapped by double-digit increases. Several states have higher rates. Deregulation, anti-pollution laws and distance from fuel sources are to blame. By ERIC SLATER, Times Staff Writer ?????CHICAGO--For all its energy notoriety and outrage over surging electricity rates, California has plenty of company. Much of the nation faces double-digit price hikes, and several states--especially in the East--continue to pay more for electricity than California. ?????Not even Gov. Gray Davis' reluctant proposal last week to kick rates up as much as 34.5% for the heaviest residential users would guarantee California the dubious honor of having the priciest electricity in the United States. ?????Overshadowed by the rhetoric, lawsuits and rolling blackouts is the fact that Californians have been paying less for electricity than residents in Rhode Island, New Hampshire, Vermont, New York, Alaska and, by a longshot, Hawaii. California, in fact, is barely in the top 10 when it comes to electrical prices. ?????One of the reasons that Californians have been paying less is because they conserve more, with the average resident draining 40% less from the grid than the average American. ?????Another reason, however, is that California's rates have been frozen by law, even as the lids have been coming off the prices in other states that are deregulating their utilities. ?????"I don't know about you guys," said state Sen. Sheila Kuehl (D-Santa Monica) at a hearing last week in Sacramento, "but my constituents don't think they suffered over the past several years because their rates didn't go up 45% and 50% the way they did in New York and Pennsylvania and other parts of this country." ?????These dramatic price spikes are driven by a strange, worst-case confluence of electrical-world forces. ?????A drought in the Northwest means that there's not enough water to turn the turbines in the great hydroelectric dams; massive price increases for natural gas come even as the country is moving toward more natural gas-powered electrical generators; and the deregulation of utilities--left largely up to individual states--has proved more complicated than almost anyone dreamed. ?????"We look at it as a perfect storm," Rep. Jay Inslee (D-Wash.) said of the improbably bad stew of circumstances. ?????In Boston, residential users face a possible 23% hike, industrial customers 69%. In Cheyenne, Wyo., some residential customers are insulating themselves against possible hikes of 57%, with some commercial customers looking at an 88% jump. In Idaho, they're talking hikes of between 34% and 63% for some customers. In Nevada, rate hikes scheduled at more than 1% a month, starting in September and continuing until September 2003, will raise residential rates about 75%. ?????All this after two decades of steadily declining electricity rates in the U.S.--with almost all of the price drops preceding the deregulation that was supposed to bring down prices. ?????Price of Power Fell Steadily for Years ?????In the early 1980s, one kilowatt hour of power cost residential customers about a dime. Over the next two decades, Americans began to employ more energy-efficient appliances, computers, even lightbulbs, and utilities produced their power more and more efficiently. ?????At the same time, utilities took advantage of low interest rates to help retire massive debt incurred during the high-cost, post-Chernobyl building of nuclear reactors, and they were thus able to pass on further savings to customers. ?????By last year, buying a kilowatt hour set the average American back just 7.5 cents. ?????The trend has suddenly stopped. ?????In a forecast released Friday, the Energy Information Administration predicts that a kilowatt hour will cost about 8 cents on average nationally by the end of this year and rise another half-cent in 2002. ?????"For the first time in a long time, the prices are going up," said administration forecaster Neil Gamson. ?????A one-cent increase in the price per kilowatt hour would boost the monthly bill of a typical California residential customer by about $10, to $117. For big industrial users, the extra monthly cost could be in the thousands. ?????Substantial regional differences have always existed, with the Northeast the longtime home of the highest prices in the continental U.S. Some Northeastern customers pay twice as much, or more, than consumers 3,000 miles due west. ?????One reason is that, although environmental laws in the Northeast are typically less stringent than those in California and the Northwest, growing concerns and tougher anti-pollution legislation have forced utilities to shift away from the higher-polluting coal-powered generators and toward cleaner-burning natural gas. The environmentally conscious move has left them, like several other areas, vulnerable to the recent price spikes of natural gas. ?????The Northeast is also farther from most major sources of fuel, including natural gas, oil and coal. ?????Several states in the Northeast, including Connecticut, Maine, New Hampshire, New York and Massachusetts, are actively deregulating. Like California, only with less drama, they are finding the birth of a free market painful and expensive. ?????Under Massachusetts' deregulation statute, the standard retail rate for a kilowatt hour was fixed at an average of just over 9 cents through 2005. However, the rise in natural gas prices has left utilities pleading with regulators to allow them to raise prices, lest they face California's problem of selling their power at a loss--precisely the circumstance that led the Pacific Gas & Electric Co. of San Francisco to declare bankruptcy Friday. ?????Kilowatt Hour's Average Cost Rising ?????Earlier this month, the Massachusetts Electric Co. got the go-ahead to charge 270,000 residential customers an additional 23%. Statewide, analysts say, the average price of a kilowatt hour is probably edging up from its already high October figure, the last available, of 11.2 cents. ?????In New York, the average cost of a kilowatt hour statewide was 14.1 cents in October. However, even under a deregulation plan that won't fully free the utilities from price controls until 2002, some New York City residents have seen their rates rise by nearly 20%, to 13.9 cents a kilowatt hour, in recent months. ?????Still, Cornell University economist Tim Mount said he would be surprised and "very disappointed if we mess things up in the East as badly as they messed it up in California. I think the regulators thought that it would be easy to run a market, and they didn't allow for very much malfeasance" on the part of newly untethered utilities or private power generators. ?????The South, with its coal reserves, has long hovered in the relatively cheap range of 6 to 8 cents per kilowatt hour and, along with the Midwest, is likely to be among the most stable areas in the near future. ?????Several states in the South and Midwest are also among the last to consider deregulation--for the very reason that their power is already cheap--and so may benefit the most from studying the daily jolt of news out of California. ?????The Midwest has, as with so many things, been a picture of moderation when it comes to electrical rates. A kilowatt hour goes for 7 to 8 cents or, in the case of Illinois, a bit over 9 cents. (Chicago, the country's third-largest city and the location of several infamous--although localized--blackouts in 1999, tends to raise the state's average considerably.) ?????Having continued to build power plants when states in the West and East had all but halted construction, and with Illinois home to 11 price-stabilizing nuclear reactors, the Midwest is expected to hold the line, at least in the near future. ?????The Northwest, long the land of cheap, clean hydroelectric power, is already beginning to see its 5- and 6-cent electric rates climb. ?????Many of the utilities in the Northwest receive huge portions of their juice from the Bonneville Power Administration, which oversees 29 dams in the Columbia and Snake River basins and provides 45% of the region's electricity. ?????However, the severity of the region's drought--and the accompanying electricity shortage--was illustrated last week when the BPA announced that it would stop spilling precious water over its dams to help the spring salmon run. ?????Announcing the news to residents who for decades have fought to restore salmon runs decimated by the dams was perhaps made a bit easier for acting BPA administrator Steve Wright because he had previously made another announcement. The BPA, Wright said, would likely be raising its own wholesale rates from 95% to 200% come October. ?????Some of the rate hikes around the country are surcharges, meant to fill utility coffers left empty by the leap in natural gas prices, for example. Many others, however, are viewed as permanent. In the West, especially, there is simply no reason to believe that costs will drop any time soon. ?????The bankruptcy move Friday by PG&E only solidified that widely held opinion. Among its other worries, Bonneville has been holding a $100-million IOU from California utilities--half of it owed by PG&E--and hoping that money would help to mitigate its rate hikes to other customers. ?????When PG&E became the biggest utility in U.S. history to seek bankruptcy protection, BPA became just another creditor likely to lose money. --- ?????Times staff writer Julie Tamaki in Sacramento contributed to this story. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------- Judge in PG&E Bankruptcy Case Seen as a Problem Solver Courts: Dennis Montali will face unprecedented legal complexities. By MAURA DOLAN, Times Legal Affairs Writer * Bankruptcy Judge Dennis Montali is called a "reasonable man." AP ?????SAN FRANCISCO--U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Dennis Montali, who will oversee Pacific Gas & Electric Co.'s bankruptcy reorganization, is a highly respected scholar and effective mediator known for persuading reluctant parties to reach agreement. ?????In a recent case, Montali achieved in only three days a settlement between a debtor and creditors in the bankruptcy of an international engineering firm. The case had been in bruising litigation for two years when another judge asked Montali to mediate it. ?????As a lawyer, Montali helped divert a statewide agricultural crisis 10 years ago by persuading warring factions to accept a deal in the bankruptcy of an agricultural cooperative, according to a lawyer in the case. ?????"He is very good at not embarrassing people but getting them to understand they are wrong," said lawyer Larry Engel, who has known and worked with Montali for two decades. ?????Montali, 60, the son of a winemaker, grew up in San Francisco and now lives in Berkeley. He is considered among the top tier of bankruptcy experts in the United States. ?????He will be calling the shots in one of the largest bankruptcy reorganizations in U.S. history. The case raises unprecedented legal questions and is expected to make new law. Some of the legal disputes may wind up before the U.S. Supreme Court, attorneys said. ?????Lawyers who know the easygoing, witty judge say he is probably relishing this legal challenge the way a golfer looks forward to playing a new and more difficult course. The court action begins today, when Montali is expected to decide whether PG&E can spend cash that others have laid claims to. ?????Right from the beginning, Montali will be in the limelight, and lawyers will be eagerly searching for any clues to his leanings. Montali declined to be interviewed, but those who know him say he is fair, smart, hard-working and thoughtful. He does not browbeat, but quietly negotiates to bring people around, lawyers said. ?????The judge is highly engaged in his cases. He is well prepared, intellectually curious and knows the hard questions to ask, lawyers said. He also is a relatively quick decision-maker, frequently ruling from the bench. ?????"Reality tends to come out" in his courtroom because Montali does not allow lawyers to evade his questions, Engel said. ?????There are few precedents to guide Montali in many of the novel legal questions he is likely to be asked to rule upon. Can he order electricity rate hikes? The law is unclear. Can he force energy suppliers to hold down their prices? Doubtful, bankruptcy lawyers said. Can he force PG&E's parent company to cough up some money? Possibly. Can he force PG&E to sell off assets? Yes, but probably not in the near term. ?????"This is going to be one of these cases where the envelope is going to be pushed, and I think there is a danger in making any categorical statements right now," said a bankruptcy lawyer who is involved in the case. ?????PG&E's Chapter 11 bankruptcy reorganization will be enormously complex legally, lawyers said. Montali will have to reconcile state utility law and federal energy law with bankruptcy law. Bankruptcy judges have broad discretion to decide disputes, and Montali will control PG&E's purse strings. ?????Lawyers who know Montali well say he is savvy about using the Internet to communicate court information, masters arcane legal subjects quickly, and probably is thrilled to be making the calls in a case that will be watched nationally. ?????Some people go on the bench to retire. Montali went on in 1993 to have more fun intellectually, lawyers said. ?????Montali "tends to be very constructive," said another lawyer who asked not to be identified by name because he may represent a creditor in the PG&E case. "He wants his cases to go somewhere, and he tries to encourage people to make progress." ?????Before he was appointed to the bench, Montali had practiced bankruptcy law for more than two decades. He began representing debtors but was doing primarily creditor work in his last law firm job with the city's venerable Pillsbury, Madison & Sutro. ?????The bankruptcy bar he was a part of is relatively small, and the lawyers who practice it know one another. Several lawyers interviewed about Montali referred to him by his first name. ?????Because these lawyers are likely to be players together in many cases over the years, trustworthiness is important, bankruptcy attorneys said. Effectiveness requires that other members of the bar trust your word and credibility. ?????The practice also requires knowledge of economics and economic terms, ease both with deal making and trial work, and above all else, practicality, lawyers said. ?????Whereas a business litigator may know exactly what he or she will be doing two months from now, bankruptcy lawyers tend to operate on tight deadlines with little notice. Many of these lawyers were at their desks over the weekend preparing for the PG&E case. ?????"There is no one in town who is not part of this case," said Engel, who is representing a municipal utility. "Everyone is involved." ?????Montali is tall, lanky and balding. His trademark is his handlebar mustache, which he has worn for decades and which reflects his gregariousness and humor, other lawyers said. He cooks Italian food expertly and likes to sail around San Francisco Bay and walk his dog during his time away from work. His wife, Mary, is in the real estate business, and they have three grown daughters. ?????As a lawyer, Montali was masterful at bringing about a compromise in the bankruptcy of a major agricultural cooperative a decade ago, Engels said. At the time the co-op went bankrupt, farmers had picked their crops, but there was no money to operate the canneries and no money to pay the growers. Montali was representing a bank in the case. ?????"We could have had a disaster," Engel said. "Literally, imagine if 5,000 farmers lost their entire crop because there was nobody to take it. Each of them would have gone into bankruptcy." ?????The parties locked themselves together in one place for a week and half. Montali was "at the core of it," Engel said. He persuaded all parties to agree to a plan that involved selling the cooperative. "He would take someone who was being a problem over to the side and explain that it wasn't going to work if they persisted that way," Engel said. ?????"He is the ultimate reasonable man who convinced them that this path is the one they needed to be on in their own self-interest." ?????Richard Levin, a Los Angeles bankruptcy lawyer, said Montali has "tremendous integrity." As a lawyer, he was cogent and forceful in arguments and would make simple, clear statements that would cause everyone in the courtroom to pause and think, Levin said.?????Montali earned a bachelor's degree in English from Notre Dame University and then entered the Navy to fulfill a Reserve Officer's Training Corps commitment. ?????He served in various officer positions on two destroyers and taught briefly at the United States Navy Reserve Officers Candidate School in Newport, R.I., before entering law school. He obtained his law degree from UC Berkeley's Boalt Hall School of Law in 1968. ?????Montali has been elected to the National Bankruptcy Conference and the American College of Bankruptcy, both elite bodies reserved for those at the top of their field. ?????Last year, he was appointed to hear appeals in bankruptcy cases for the U.S. 9th Circuit Court of Appeals in addition to his trial duties. ?????One of his first cases on the bench ended in disaster. Shortly after he became a judge, he ruled in favor of a landlord who was trying to evict a tenant. The tenant had a bankruptcy case before Montali. ?????The tenant later went to the landlord's office, shot and killed him, wounded the landlord's son and tried to kill himself. ?????"I didn't have any regret about the decision," Montali told the Daily Journal, a legal newspaper, several years ago. "But it reinforced in the real world that I'm making decisions that affect people. It put some real meaning into things." ?????In 1997, Montali ruled that a gay man was liable for damages because he failed to warn his former lover that he was infected with HIV before they had unprotected sex. ?????The case had wound up before Montali because the defendant filed for bankruptcy to avoid paying monetary damages if he lost the sexual battery lawsuit. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ -------------------------------------------- Bankruptcy Filing Threatens Tax Bases PG&E: Counties, particularly small ones like Plumas, depend on revenue for schools and other services. By RONE TEMPEST, Times Sacramento Bureau Chief ?????QUINCY, Calif.--The PG&E bankruptcy protection filing Friday came only four days before the state's largest utility is to make $80 million in property tax payments to 49 California counties. ?????In Northern California's remote Plumas County, this was especially bad news. Because of its large hydroelectric holdings, Pacific Gas & Electric is Plumas' largest taxpayer, accounting for about 18% of the county's $2.3-billion tax base. ?????Bankruptcy laws usually require that government obligations, including taxes, be paid first. But the uncertainty over financially crippled PG&E's ability to pay sent tremors through government offices in the High Sierra county south of Mt. Lassen. ?????"If we took a hit like that, we were probably looking at job layoffs and program curtailments," said County Assessor Chuck Leonhardt. He said things ranging from library books to police salaries could be affected. ?????The state's two biggest private utilities, PG&E and Southern California Edison, annually pay more than a quarter-billion dollars in property taxes, including $70 million levied on Edison by Los Angeles, Orange, Riverside and San Bernardino counties. Edison officials said their company intends to meet the Tuesday property tax deadline. ?????The biggest impact of unpaid taxes falls on the state, which is legally required to supply most uncollected money that is for schools--which is most of the property tax load. In smaller, rural counties like Plumas, which has a permanent population of only 22,000, a utility tax default would seriously reduce funding for other local services. PG&E pays Plumas almost $4 million a year in taxes. ?????A large county that could be seriously hurt by a PG&E default is San Luis Obispo on the central coast, where the utility's Diablo Canyon nuclear plant generates $28 million in property taxes, about 15% of the county's tax revenue. ?????"This is not catastrophic for us, but it is significant," said county Auditor-Controller Gere Sibbach. Sibbach said one large school district, San Luis Coastal, could come up $2 million short as a result of a PG&E default. ?????"That school district gets $10 million in taxes from PG&E," Sibbach said, "but the state will only backfill for $8 million, so they would have to cut programs if PG&E doesn't pay." ?????Plumas County faces a double threat in the PG&E bankruptcy filing. ?????Here, beautiful Lake Almanor and other hydroelectric reservoirs are strung along the north fork of the cascading Feather River. The "PG&E lakes," as the reservoirs are known here, are what attract retirees and tourists--mainstays of the fragile local economy since the timber industry went into decline. ?????The landscape here is rich in broad, green valleys and more than 100 lakes. In addition to boating and fishing, the county has 10 golf courses--one for each 2,200 residents. ?????Because hydroelectricity is at such a premium this year, the utility is expected to suck all the water it can from Lake Almanor and nearby Bucks Lake, bringing potential ruin to the area's tourism and recreation industry. ?????"They are probably going to draw every drop of water out of the lake they can," said Marvin Alexander, one of the retirees who lives on Lake Almanor. "The boat ramps won't even reach the water." ?????The equation here is simple: When lake levels fall too low, the fish don't bite, the tourists don't come and the property values decline. According to real estate agent Tim O'Brien, Lake Almanor homes have sold in recent years for $500,000 to $1 million. ?????These days the housing market is slow. "This community basically lives and dies by the lake levels," explained Chris Luna, a Chester civil engineer and home builder. ?????The energy crisis is disrupting what had become a comfortable relationship in recent years. For most of the last decade, Plumas County homeowners and businesses have evolved a modus vivendi with PG&E. ?????With electricity in good supply, PG&E officials kept the lake high in July to keep boaters and fishermen happy. Residents agreed not to make too much fuss when the lake level declined in late August so the utilities could generate power. ?????But now that the specter of rotating blackouts is haunting the populous and politically powerful California lowlands this summer, few here hold out much hope that PG&E will continue to be the benign water lord they have come to know. ?????"I have a feeling," said Alexander, a former college administrator who is on a local committee that deals with water rights, "that this year the need for public power is going to take priority over the need for recreation." ?????PG&E spokeswoman Lisa Randle would not say how much water the utility is drawing from the upper lakes. But Plumas County residents took it as an ominous sign when the Buck's Creek Power House recently began gushing water from its four big turbine discharge gates late every afternoon during peak power periods. They are not accustomed to seeing that so early in the year. ?????The Buck's Creek station, amid flowering dogwood and redbud trees on California 70 in the heart of Feather River Canyon, is one of the most accessible and visible PG&E facilities along the Plumas County watershed that engineers call the "stairsteps of power." ?????When all four discharge gates are open, as they were on a recent afternoon, the station generates enough electricity to light 65,000 homes. The power is produced by the force of water that falls through pipes 2,500 feet from Buck's Lake to the bottom of the canyon, where it drives two huge turbines. ?????According to Plumas County Supervisor Bill Dennison, the lakes are already 17 feet below normal capacity for this time of year. Even with additional snowmelt, he said, the lake levels are likely to be nine feet below normal. "It looks like a very bleak summer for Plumas County," Dennison concluded. ?????When the lakes get too low, Alexander said, remembering the 1987-92 drought years, the sandy beaches around the Lake Almanor Country Club become mudholes and, as water in the shallow lake heats up, fishing becomes terrible. ?????"For the past seven to eight years the people up here have been lulled into complacency," said Alexander. "People were in denial. They knew that PG&E owned the lake and can do anything it wants. ?????"But the prospect of living up here is so attractive they just kind of throw caution to the wind and hope it will all work out." ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ -------------------------------------------- Others Learning from California's Energy Mistakes By JAMES FLANIGAN, Times Staff Writer ?????For all the agony and anger about energy in California, compounded now by the bankruptcy filing of Pacific Gas & Electric, deregulation and the transformation of the electric power industry is moving forward nationwide--and worldwide. ?????Many electric companies elsewhere are thriving and being recommended by investment analysts even as the regulated utility division of PG&E Corp. surrenders its management to a bankruptcy court and Southern California Edison, a subsidiary of Edison International, remains under heavy threat of being forced to do the same. ?????Companies and regulators everywhere cite California's troubles as stemming from mistakes they will avoid. ?????For example, American Electric Power, a Columbus, Ohio-based leader of the utility industry, told shareholders in its annual report that California's blunders of "insufficient power supplies, total reliance on spot pricing and capping of rates for retail consumers even as costs of wholesale power multiplied, are not likely to be replicated elsewhere." ?????Indeed, many of deregulation's dangers may be avoided now simply because California and PG&E have put everybody on their guard. ?????California's horrible example has spurred recognition that power plants need to be built. ?????And PG&E's collapse sends a message that utility companies operating partly in regulated and unregulated environments need to separate their accounts so as to better understand the different businesses they are managing. ?????Wall Street sees electricity as a growth industry just because power is in relative short supply in many parts of the country. ?????"The United States has not built enough power plants over the last 10 years to meet demand," says analyst Brian Youngberg of Edward Jones & Co., a St. Louis-based investment company. ?????That spells opportunity for companies able to produce low-cost power and market it in different regions. ?????Promising Investment ?????Today's favored utilities are those moving to acquire power plants and sell power as an unregulated commodity in different areas, even as they cope with deregulation and competition in their home territories. ?????The examples of two leading companies will explain a lot about the utility business today, why investors regard it as promising and how companies and state regulators elsewhere are taking steps to avoid the blunders of California. ?????Utilicorp United, based in Kansas City, Mo., is the modern outgrowth of a family-owned electric company dating to 1902. Under Richard Green, the founder's great-grandson who has been chief executive since 1982, Utilicorp went eagerly into wholesale marketing and trading of electricity around the world, acquiring companies in Australia and New Zealand, even as it continued to operate regulated utilities in Missouri--where electricity remains regulated--and six other Midwestern states. ?????Utilicorp, helped by the growth of its Aquila Energy subsidiary that trades electricity contracts, has expanded to $29 billion in revenue in 2000 from just over $1 billion a decade ago. "I've got two companies," Green says, "one is a regulated utility, growing 3% to 5% a year and paying a dividend, and the other is Aquila, which is growing 20% a year." ?????So he is separating the two, issuing stock in 19.9% of Aquila now and intending to spin it off as an independent company within a year. "Investors can then have their choice of growth or stability and dividends," Green says. ?????American Electric Power is a venerable pioneer of the utility industry. It originated the practice of siting power plants atop coal mines so the fuel could be transferred efficiently to the steam turbine boilers. ?????Now its home state of Ohio is going through a three-year process of deregulating electricity. So AEP is going aggressively into wholesale electricity generation and marketing. ?????Last year it acquired Dallas-based Central & Southwest Co. and now markets in Texas, Louisiana and Oklahoma as well as its traditional bases in Ohio and Michigan. ?????AEP, too, is going to separate its unregulated and regulated businesses. ?????It's doing this, the company told shareholders, because "it will enable investors to value our businesses separately and will improve our ability to manage the realities of electric deregulation and to focus on the differing capital requirements of each business." ?????Why is that significant? Because PG&E, the holding company that owns Pacific Gas & Electric, also has thriving energy trading and out-of-state electricity operations within its corporate structure. ?????It built up the unregulated business in recent years by transferring proceeds from sales of California power plants and cash flow accruing from the state's complex deregulation scheme. ?????But PG&E didn't separate the unregulated and regulated businesses for shareholders. And now PG&E's publicly traded stock has lost 77% of its value and the company faces a battle in bankruptcy court to keep its unregulated assets out of the hands of creditors. ?????Avoiding Mistakes ?????As companies elsewhere try to avoid PG&E's errors, so other states take pains not to make California's big mistake of going into deregulation without a reserve of electric generating capacity. Ohio is making sure that it has a surplus of generating capacity. ?????The Northeastern states of Massachusetts, Connecticut, New Hampshire and Rhode Island, which have deregulated, also have plenty of spare capacity, reports Cambridge Energy Research Associates. ?????With electricity in surplus, those states and regions can encourage price competition in electricity. But when there are shortages, as began to occur last year in California, desperation buying by customers and price gouging by suppliers are all but inevitable. ?????A point to keep in mind in the wake of California's disaster and PG&E's downfall is that the electric utility industry and the U.S. system are at the outset of a long process of transformation. ?????It's not unlike the telephone business that has changed so much in the last 30 years, starting from, say, the rise of MCI in the 1970s or the breakup of AT&T Corp. in 1984. ?????Yet those years also saw the rise of whole new technologies and new companies, even as giants of another age faded and failed. ?????California and California companies may yet find success in this new age of opportunity--and peril--for electricity. --- ?????James Flanigan can be reached at jim.flanigan@latimes.com. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------- Generators Scrambled to End Pacts With Utilities Energy: Even before PG&E filed for bankruptcy, alternative plant owners who hadn't been paid in months pursued court actions. By JULIE TAMAKI, Times Staff Writer ?????SACRAMENTO--In filing for federal bankruptcy protection last week, Pacific Gas & Electric Co. determined what other power producers had already concluded: The state had failed to solve their payment problems and the time had come for the courts to step in. ?????In the days leading up to PG&E's Bankruptcy Court petition, a growing number of alternative energy producers had also been filing lawsuits, seeking to be freed from their contracts with PG&E and Southern California Edison. The litigation was triggered in part by a controversial new rate plan imposed last month by the state Public Utilities Commission in addition to millions of dollars of debt owed to the producers by the utilities. ?????On Tuesday, Dynamis Inc. filed suit in Fresno, saying PG&E owes it $3 million. ?????Carson-based Watson Cogeneration Co., one of the state's largest alternative energy producers, also had filed suit to have its contract with Edison suspended. So did Delta Power, which owns five small gas-fired plants in California. Both producers are owed tens of millions by Edison. ?????At least a dozen such suits have been filed in civil courts, and lawyers warn that more could be on the way. ?????"Tough solutions were not being brought to the equation, which left PG&E and others feeling they were better off in the court system," said Jerry Bloom, an attorney for the California Cogeneration Council. ?????The court actions come on the heels of an order by the PUC last month that Edison and PG&E begin fully paying hundreds of small alternative energy producers. But some producers say that a new rate plan issued by the PUC would force them to operate at a loss and that nothing has been done to address the about $1.5 billion owed to members of the group by PG&E and Edison. ?????Lawyers say other producers have served Edison with notices that they plan to cancel their contracts. ?????Gas-fired generators account for about two-thirds of the electricity produced by the alternative energy group. ?????The California Independent System Operator, keeper of the state's power grid, reports that there continues to be a roughly 3,000-megawatt reduction in output from the alternative energy producers. The daily sum is enough power to supply 2 million to 3 million typical homes. ?????"It clearly shows the problem hasn't been fixed," said Jan Smutny-Jones, executive director of the Independent Energy Producers. ?????California is home to nearly 700 producers of alternative and renewable energy, which as a group provide more than a quarter of the electricity used by consumers. ?????Some of the producers have gone offline or reduced supplies for maintenance reasons, but others have cut back because they have not been paid by Edison since November or have received only partial payments from PG&E. ?????The drop in output has at times forced the state to purchase replacement supplies on the pricey spot market for electricity and contributed to rolling blackouts last month. The latter event prompted Gov. Gray Davis to propose a plan to get the generators up and running again. ?????Consequently, the PUC established a new rate plan for the producers and ordered the utilities to begin fully paying them beginning this month. The payment goal would be accomplished in part by slashing the rates that PG&E and Edison must pay the producers. ?????But the PUC action appears to have compelled a growing number of gas-fired generators to file lawsuits in an effort to be released from their contracts with the utilities and be paid the millions they are owed. ?????Bloom contends that the new rate plan will force some producers to operate at a loss because it does not adequately compensate for their gas expenses. He said he expects generators to challenge the plan in court or before the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission. ?????Smutny-Jones contends that the plan wrongly assumes that all natural gas used by his members can be piped in from the Oregon border, where the price of natural gas is cheaper. The producers, he added, are seeking assurances that they will be paid realistic rates by the utilities for future deliveries. ?????Utilities are scheduled to pay the first round of reduced rates, as ordered by the PUC, early next week. Both utilities have indicated that they plan to make the first round of payments. ?????Edison officials said Friday they have been served with 10 producer lawsuits. They say they fear that if the generators are let out of their contracts, they could sell their supplies out of state, which could in turn cause rates to rise for California consumers because it would reduce supply. ?????PG&E spokesman John Nelson said in an interview last week before the bankruptcy filing that PG&E has been served with two such lawsuits. He said his company is also concerned about the PUC rate plan and whether it truly lowered the rates PG&E must pay the alternative producers and whether there would be enough money in the rates paid by customers to turn around and pay the producers. ?????"We're concerned that the commission decision does not solve the problem," Nelson said. ?????A Davis spokesman said last week that the administration is still working on the issue of money owed to the producers and that the administration is continuing to work with the PUC to get more generators back online. ?????Observers believe the number of producer lawsuits will grow because most cases to date have been aimed at Edison. The utility has not paid its producers since November and has fought to have its rates slashed. ?????By comparison, PG&E has made efforts to partially pay its producers in recent months and to keep them informed of their financial situation. ?????A Bankruptcy Court is expected to decide whether to affirm the contracts of producers who sell to PG&E or to free them to sell their power elsewhere. ?????An Imperial County judge has already freed CalEnergy, a small geothermal producer, from its contract with Edison because of Edison's failure to pay the company. The court has delayed ruling on CalEnergy's request for $99 million in back payments until April 16--the day the utility is expected to begin paying its alternative generators. ?????Since it quit transmitting 270 megawatts to Edison last month, CalEnergy has been selling its electricity to El Paso Energy, a marketing company that resells power on the spot market. If other generators are able to repeat the pattern, it could further reduce state energy supplies, particularly this summer, when every megawatt will be needed to avoid blackouts. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ----------------------------------------- PG&E Gave Bonuses Prior to Bankruptcy Before its filing, the utility also had $2.5 billion on hand and had restarted services suspended earlier because of shaky finances. By TIM REITERMAN, Times Staff Writer ????? SAN FRANCISCO--In the days approaching Pacific Gas & Electric Co.'s bankruptcy filing, the debt-ridden utility had more than $2.5 billion in cash on hand and was restarting services suspended earlier this year because of its shaky finances. ?????Then, the day before the filing, the utility awarded 6,000 managers and other employees more than $50 million in annual bonuses and announced that long-delayed merit increases had kicked in for the same workers. ?????The timing of the bonus payments in particular raised an outcry from consumer groups and state officials. ?????"Management is suffering from two afflictions: Denial and greed," Gov. Gray Davis said in a statement. ?????"It does not look good," said state Senate President Pro Tem John Burton. "They [already] have a business and a P.R. problem." ?????The bonuses and raises were announced in an e-mail sent Thursday by Chief Executive Robert Glynn to employees. The payments cover about a third of the company's 19,000 workers, ranging from nonunion clerical staff to all but the very top management. ?????On Friday, hours after PG&E had filed for reorganization of its debts under Chapter 11 bankruptcy laws, a San Francisco judge approved the company's overall employee compensation plan. But PG&E officials said the ruling did not specifically cover the bonuses or merit raises. ?????Harvey Rosenfield, president of the Foundation for Taxpayer and Consumer Rights, said the bonuses should not be allowed. ?????"Talk about manipulating the corporate finances to benefit management prior to bankruptcy," he said. "It is the kind of arrogant mismanagement that is responsible for the ruin of this company." ?????Richard Levin, a Los Angeles bankruptcy attorney, said such payments to employees are not unusual, especially after the filing of bankruptcy. ?????"A company trying to reorganize has to take pretty strong action to keep employees," he said. "If they did not do it, who is going to keep the electricity flowing?" ?????PG&E, the state's largest utility, declared in its filing for bankruptcy protection that it is more than $9 billion in debt--several times more than cash on hand--and was getting nowhere in negotiations with the governor for state purchase of its power lines and other assets. The filing, which includes a list of creditors, allows the company to continue to operate while it reorganizes its financial affairs. A judge, working under federal bankruptcy law, will determine who will be paid and in what order. The first hearing is scheduled for Monday. ?????Company officials defended the payments, which were reported in Saturday's San Francisco Chronicle, and fired back at Davis. "Instead of focusing all his attention on solving the state's yearlong and ever-worsening energy crisis, the governor has launched a campaign-style attack on our company," PG&E said in a statement Saturday. ?????The payments, officials said, are awarded each year to employees who meet the company's performance goals and objectives. "They are smaller this year because of the larger financial crisis the company is going through but, it is safe to say, more deserved this year than in years past because of the challenges facing our employees this year," said PG&E spokesman John Nelson. ?????The payments came after the company began reversing some of the cost-cutting measures imposed early this year after its finances worsened, PG&E officials said. ?????PUC Orders End to Some Cutbacks ?????Among other things, PG&E had suspended projects involving the underground placement of power lines, prompting cities and residents to protest to state regulators. The company also eliminated about 325 jobs earlier this year and was planning layoffs of almost 700 more. But the California Public Utilities Commission last month blocked the layoffs and ordered the company to rescind any cutbacks affecting service. ?????Company officials said that, thanks in part to a tax refund of $1.1 billion, the company now has about $2.5 billion to $2.8 billion on hand. ?????"We are now in a position to start relaxing some of those cash-conservation measures," Nelson said Saturday. "About a week ago we started doing undergrounding again and [performing] new installations of electrical service" in business parks and elsewhere. ?????"This compensation package was one of those measures reinstated," he said. ?????Officials said the payments exempted the company's 25 officers, as well as about 12,000 union workers who received raises in January. ?????They said the total of the bonuses, estimated roughly at more than $50 million, is substantially lower than the $83 million in payments suspended in January when the utility announced cost-cutting measures. ?????That $83 million included bonuses for employee performance and a bonus based on the company's success. ?????"As we close the books for 2000, we have determined that we are unable to make [that] portion of the incentive payment due to the negative financial impact of the ongoing California energy crisis," CEO Glynn said in his e-mail. ?????He said the incentive bonuses were awarded along with merit increases averaging 3% for all employees, effective April 1. Bonuses commonly are about four weeks of salary, officials said, but can vary according to performance and other factors. ?????Mike Florio, senior attorney at the Utility Reform Network, said, "That is going to be a little hard for the public to swallow. . . . I feel better that the 25 [top executives] are not included. Those are the people that have run this company into the ground." ?????On Saturday, Davis administration negotiators redoubled efforts to keep the same fate from befalling Southern California Edison. ?????Davis hopes for a state takeover of the massive system of electricity transmission lines owned by PG&E, Edison and San Diego Gas & Electric. However, the bankruptcy complicates that effort, which already has proved to be daunting. A federal bankruptcy judge will have to approve any deal that involves PG&E. ?????Edison executives and Davis' aides met in San Francisco in an effort to strike a deal by which the state would purchase Edison's share of the transmission system for $2.76 billion. The company would use the money to restructure its debt. ?????Edison has agreed in principle to sell the state its transmission system. However, the company is seeking relief from some PUC regulations that could later undermine aspects of the deal and could jeopardize the company's future financial stability. ?????On Saturday, Burton reiterated his call for the governor to "commandeer" two or three power plants owned by out-of-state producers. "These people have us by the throat and are making more money than God," he told a news conference here. "You have to fight back." ?????Steve Maviglio, the governor's press secretary, said Davis has not ruled out such a seizure. --- ?????Times staff writer Dan Morain in Sacramento contributed to this story. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------- NEWS ANALYSIS Shifting Action to Neutral Arena May Be Bankruptcy Filing's Upside Court might be a forum in which the state, PG&E and creditors could break impasses. But there are many uncertainties. By MICHAEL A. HILTZIK, Times Staff Writer ?????By forcing almost all the deadlocked parties in California's energy crisis to meet in a neutral public forum, the bankruptcy filing by Pacific Gas & Electric Co. on Friday may actually help clear the path to a solution, some experts say. ?????But along that path lie numerous uncertainties, including questions about the powers of the Bankruptcy Court that have never been resolved in practice. Among the most serious booby-traps confronting PG&E is that its financial books will be placed under a microscope. ?????"When you initiate a bankruptcy," said Daniel J. Bussel, a bankruptcy specialist at UCLA School of Law, "you don't have compete control over what happens." ?????The bankruptcy filing removes many of the thorniest questions revolving around the energy crisis from an arena that has been hard-pressed to deal with them: the political. Because utility policy is important to so many constituencies--including taxpayers, ratepayers, consumer activists, regulators, and legislators--solving the crisis in a way that is not only equitable but meets everyone's political goals has been a daunting task. ?????That is especially so because the crisis actually encompasses two separate problems. One is how to restructure the state's energy program so that deregulation can be made to work and costs and rates can be brought into line; the second is what to do about the billions in debt PG&E and Southern California Edison accrued last year from the purchase of wholesale power at prices higher than they were permitted to pass on to customers. ?????The attempt to settle both issues in concert has confounded the state's leaders--especially since the question of whether the state should bail the utilities out of their debts at all is itself a contentious one. ?????"I've thought for quite some time that our primary focus ought to be on how you solve the [long-term] problem, as opposed to how you adjudicate a dispute between the utilities and the generators," said state Treasurer Phil Angelides in an interview. "Too much time in Sacramento is being spent trying to figure out how to ransom the generators' bill. In some ways, the [bankruptcy] filing takes those past debts off the table." ?????Angelides said the court might represent a forum where the state, the utility and its creditors could examine and challenge those generators' bills. That is something that federal regulators, who have jurisdiction over wholesale power rates, have been loath to do, despite complaints from PG&E and Edison that they have been overcharged billions by profiteering power plant owners. ?????There is no question that the filing does complicate matters for many participants in the drama over California's energy supply. ?????PG&E's filing, in which it sought protection from creditors under Chapter 11 of the federal Bankruptcy Code, could place more pressure on Southern California Edison, the state's second cash-strapped utility, to enter bankruptcy as well. That's because electricity generators will be more assured of getting paid for their post-bankruptcy sales to PG&E, for which all pre-bankruptcy debts are temporarily in abeyance. By contrast, Edison creditors have no guarantees that the utility will be able to pay them. Edison executives said Friday they had no plans to file for bankruptcy protection. ?????On the other hand, it might also inspire Gov. Gray Davis to rapidly reach a bailout agreement with Edison, as though to prove that PG&E's move was unnecessary or premature. Davis has been hinting that a deal is near. The state would buy Edison's electric transmission grid, providing the utility with desperately needed cash, but there have been few public signs of progress. PG&E had been balking at such a resolution. ?????Among the most serious perils of the bankruptcy filing are those facing PG&E itself. Although company executives clearly hope to limit the Bankruptcy Court's jurisdiction to the utility alone, that may not be possible, experts say. It is likely that the utility's creditors will insist on examining its controversial relationship with its holding company, PG&E Corp.--a scrutiny that might drive that company into bankruptcy too. ?????Although PG&E had long threatened to resort to bankruptcy, the abruptness of the utility's filing at 9:04 a.m. Friday took aback almost everybody involved with the energy crisis, coming as it did less than 15 hours after Davis delivered a statewide television and radio address proposing a program to bring rates into line with wholesale energy costs. ?????Even normally well-connected professionals were caught short. The research department of the investment bank Goldman Sachs told clients Friday morning that PG&E and Edison were on the way to a "return . . . to financial health" and hinted their parent companies' shares were poised to more than double in price. The research report was released Friday by Davis' office. ?????Instead, PG&E filed for bankruptcy. By the end of the day both companies had lost more than 35% of their value. ?????By giving PG&E's creditors legal standing to directly scrutinize its finances, the filing leaves the utility's recent business decisions open to challenge. ?????Chief among these is the utility's record of "upstreaming" to its parent revenues it received from ratepayers in the first two and a half years of deregulation. Critics have argued that those payments left the utility starved for cash when wholesale rates soared beginning in May 2000. ?????In announcing the bankruptcy filing Friday, PG&E Chairman Robert Glynn laid nearly all the blame for his company's perilous condition at the feet of the Public Utilities Commission, the governor and other state officials. ?????The company had been "raising the crisis flag [about high wholesale power prices] since last summer," he said. ?????Yet an independent audit of PG&E commissioned by the PUC and released in January documented that the utility did not implement any cash conservation measures until December. The utility even paid a cash dividend to its parent company for the third quarter of 2000, covering the months of July through September, of more than $200 million. ?????In all, PUC documents show, Pacific Gas & Electric disbursed $9.6 billion to PG&E Corp. from January 1998 through September 2000. That money benefited shareholders, from whom some $2.8 billion in shares were repurchased and who received another $1.5 billion in dividends; and bondholders, for whom $2.8 billion in debt was paid off. ?????Glynn insisted Friday that the company has "assiduously complied" with PUC rules governing the relationship between the utility and the holding company. But creditors are sure to give the transactions another look. ?????"Those transactions will now certainly be scrutinized," said Bussel. Bankruptcy court represents "a forum to bring a lawsuit to unwind those transactions and get a full airing of circumstances of the transfers." ?????Filing Could Threaten Parent Company ?????While PG&E executives took pains to note that the holding company and its unregulated subsidiaries are not subject to the bankruptcy filing, experts say that could change if Bankruptcy Judge Dennis Montali is persuaded that the transactions were improper and the money should be returned to the utility. ?????"There will be a lot of sophisticated lawyers looking at this," Bussel said. "If distributions to the parent are deemed fraudulent transfers and are voidable, the holding company would have a huge liability and would probably have to file" for bankruptcy. ?????A broader threat to PG&E and the state's energy future is that state regulators and Montali might be unable to agree on the rates to be charged by the utility. A provision of the bankruptcy law requires that any rates that are part of a recovery plan for a regulated utility must be approved by that utility's regulators. ?????Although that provision would leave rate-setting authority in the hands of the California PUC, in practice the the commission will have to negotiate with the judge. Any failure of those negotiations would raise issues that have never been resolved by higher courts. ?????"The judge doesn't have the power to set rates [unilaterally]," said Kenneth Klee, a prominent Los Angeles bankruptcy lawyer, "but there are only a handful of cases on this." ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ----------------------------------------------------- Monday, April 9, 2001 Shock's Silver Lining ?????That California's power crisis has been dealt another huge shock is not all bad. The bankruptcy of Pacific Gas & Electric has legal scholars puzzling over how federal court supervision of the debt-ridden utility will affect rate-setting, sale of assets such as the transmission system and the state's role in the crisis. And that's apart from figuring out how it affects Southern California Edison, the chief private utility in the southern part of the state. Despite executives' denials of any bankruptcy plans, will Edison be forced into the same boat? Even with all these questions, a good shake can have benefits. ?????There's no doubt that a federal bankruptcy judge has the power to sort out at least some of the befuddling problems of the state's energy crisis. Few tears will be shed, for instance, if a court-ordered restructuring of PG&E's debt trimmed some of the outlandish profits reaped by private generating companies that sold power to the utility over the past six months. Federal involvement could also force the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission to abandon its hands-off stance on regulating wholesale prices. There is bipartisan support in Congress for FERC to conduct a thorough investigation of the price spikes that pushed the utilities into default and forced the state to spend billions as the power purchaser of last resort. ?????And what of the utilities themselves? PG&E's award of more than $50 million in employee bonuses the day before it filed for bankruptcy was a terrible political move, but it is not the jackpot issue. The utility's transfer of billions of dollars to its parent company even as cash flow problems worsened will be a more likely and fitting target of scrutiny by bankruptcy overseers. ?????Not least, the shock of the bankruptcy may also convince Californians to take urgent conservation action before the hot summer months. The state must also expedite a $1-billion conservation program passed by the Legislature late last week. No matter who is at fault, summer blackouts are a certainty unless both business and residential customers take energy savings much more seriously. ?????The bankruptcy certainly pulled the rug out from under Gov. Gray Davis, who had been trying without success to make a deal with PG&E, Southern California Edison and San Diego Gas and Electric to buy their transmission systems in exchange for state assistance with debts. Just Thursday night, Davis had bowed, in a television address, to the necessity for big rate increases. He no doubt meant to assure Californians that he was taking strong action to solve the crisis and keep the utilities from bankruptcy, but he disappointingly offered no new initiatives. In the clearest possible slap at Davis, PG&E was at the steps of the Bankruptcy Court the next morning. ?????However embarrassed Davis must have been by the sideswipe, he should not allow anger to dictate his response. He needs to demonstrate he's above such pettiness and perhaps even acknowledge that his snail's-pace progress was part of the problem. Davis redoubled efforts over the weekend to strike a deal with Edison for its part of the transmission system, but PG&E's bankruptcy certainly complicates the transaction. ?????Perhaps it was never possible to deal with the utilities' past debts and restructure the state's power at the same time. Bankruptcy is a rough but effective tool for dealing with debt, one that might help legislators and the governor focus more sharply on future reforms. ?????Much now depends on the federal bankruptcy judge, Dennis Montali, who is known as an effective mediator able to persuade reluctant parties to settle. California's economy has survived the power crisis so far, but it is not endlessly resilient. If PG&E's bankruptcy speeds debt resolution and focuses the governor and Legislature on reforming the state's power generation, transmission and pricing systems, business will welcome any increase in predictability. ?????Californians are starved for answers. The federal court's involvement, despite the grave circumstances, could provide some. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------- Monday, April 9, 2001 Use Eminent Domain as a Power Tool By MICHAEL J. AGUIRRE ?????Gov. Gray Davis should follow Pacific Gas & Electric's example and admit that his electricity program is also bankrupt. The governor's primary objective was to keep the utilities from bankruptcy. He has failed. He should admit his failure and reformulate his policy. Whatever he does must be based on a clear understanding of the problem. ?????The people of California have a right to buy electricity at fair prices. Producers of electricity are entitled to a fair return on their investment. Before 1998, a balance between these two points was struck by the Public Utilities Commission using cost-of-service pricing. Utilities presented their production bills, the PUC reviewed them, determined a reasonable rate of return and set a rate high enough to cover both. California became the second most efficient user of electricity in the country under this system, and its utilities prospered. ?????In 1996, the electric power industry, with promises of lower prices, induced Gov. Pete Wilson, the PUC and the Legislature to reduce the commission's power to ensure just and reasonable electricity prices. Under the power industry's system competition, not regulation, would set prices, and prices would go down. PG&E head Robert Glynn represented it to be a "huge opportunity for consumers to lower their energy costs." PG&E, San Diego Gas & Electric and Southern California Edison, with PUC approval, then sold California's most significant generation plants, its gas-fired units, to five multinational corporations. ?????These five companies led the onslaught on California consumers, raising electricity prices from $7 billion in 1999 to a projected $70 billion in 2001. California authorities have determined that 98% of the price bids submitted by these five companies--some 25,000--were based on monopoly, not competitive, pricing. Gov. Davis is right: "California's deregulation scheme is a colossal and dangerous failure." ?????No one--not Wilson, the PUC or the Legislature--provided an exit strategy if deregulation did not work. Davis has been unable or unwilling to come up with one. He failed to get on top of the problem when he took office, despite clear warning signs. He failed to see that he cannot finance ever higher prices with public funds, and he lacks the resolve to do what he must to stop them. His one effort to use tax funds to keep the utilities out of formal bankruptcy has failed, with PG&E's filing for Chapter 11 last week. ?????There are no good choices now. However, we cannot continue down the road Davis has chosen. It leads to financial ruin. We cannot rely on private companies building new generation plants because the same price gougers will control how the new electricity gets priced. We cannot rely on the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission or President Bush. California can only rely on California to solve this problem. ?????As a first step, Gov. Davis should do what he threatened to do in his State of the State address: use the power of eminent domain to recover the gas-fired generation plants that the price manipulators are using to set monopoly prices. He can pay "just compensation" to the owners but not one dime more. ?????The governor should now recognize California's vital interest in protecting itself from these prices. Eminent domain is a reasonable tool to use to achieve that goal. It has been used in less compelling circumstances. For example, eminent domain was used in the early 1980s for George W. Bush's investment team to assemble the land on which the Texas Rangers' stadium is built, from which he and his partners profited handsomely. If eminent domain can be used for private profit, it can be used to protect the vital interests of the state of California. The plants should be divested to private ownership, but only to companies that are under PUC jurisdiction. ?????The PUC also should be used to plan how California can move forward to an improved cost-based system of regulation. What we cannot do is to continue on with the current plan, which is to have the governor set electricity prices behind closed doors, working with the very people who are suspected of unlawful price fixing. PG&E's bankruptcy provides the governor with a new opportunity to move to a more effective program. ?????The governor should now stop using public funds to buy electricity. He should urge Edison to join PG&E in reorganizing under bankruptcy court protection. This will allow all parties to contest the unpaid billions of dollars of receivables owed to the power producers and their associates. This will send a message to Wall Street to stop funding such outrageous and predatory practices because they don't pay. ?????The state attorney general should conduct a criminal grand jury investigation into the alleged wrongdoing by the power generators. He should also join in the private litigation that asserts that the power producers violated the state's antitrust laws. He should follow the investigative trail to Houston, Tulsa, Atlanta and wherever else it leads. ?????Finally, Californians are going to have to make a short-term sacrifice to get a long-term gain. The governor's call last week for conservation does not go far enough. Each city council and mayor and all boards of supervisors should be required to come up with an emergency conservation plan. We need to cut consumption to the point where we can meet it with current supply. We cannot put an unfair burden on business because this will cost jobs. People with lower incomes and fixed incomes need to be protected. ?????PG&E's bankruptcy filing removes the foundation of the governor's plan. He should remember the example of FDR, who likened himself to a football quarterback who tries one play and, if it did not work, then tries another. But for heaven's sake, try something. We must show our fellow citizens that we know how to act effectively in solving this crisis. - - - Michael J. Aguirre Has Filed a Private Attorney General's Lawsuit Against the Major Power Producers ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------- Governor, Utility In War Of Words Davis furious as PG&E defends bankruptcy filing David Lazarus, Chronicle Staff Writer Monday, April 9, 2001 ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle URL: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/chronicle/archive/2001/04/09/M N223519.DTL California's energy mess took an ugly turn yesterday as Gov. Gray Davis and Pacific Gas and Electric Co. traded barbs over who is to blame for the bankruptcy of the state's largest utility. In a series of tit-for-tat statements, each side laid claim to the moral high ground while insisting that the other had been dealing in bad faith. The governor spent part of his time yesterday giving television interviews in response to The Chronicle's report Saturday that PG&E awarded $50 million in bonuses and raises to 6,000 employees just hours before Friday's bankruptcy filing. "PG&E's management is suffering from two afflictions: denial and greed," Davis said in a brief statement Saturday night. In a testy reply, PG&E countered that "instead of focusing all his attention on solving the state's yearlong and ever-worsening energy crisis, the governor has launched a campaign-style attack on our company." PG&E said Davis was criticizing "thousands of men and women who have worked tirelessly and professionally through this crisis" and concluded that "California would be far better served if the governor turned his attention to the crisis at hand." Steve Maviglio, a spokesman for the governor, fired back yesterday: "PG&E waged a public relations war on Friday. If they're looking for somebody to blame, they should look in the mirror." Maviglio also said the governor was concentrating on reaching a final accord with Southern California Edison Co. for the state to purchase the cash- strapped company's power lines for nearly $2.8 billion. A last round of talks was scheduled to be held last night. "There are a few remaining details to be worked out, but it seems pretty close," Maviglio said, adding that an announcement of the deal could come as early as today. "The governor is spending his time negotiating with a responsible utility," he said. Along with the Edison deal, Davis spent the weekend huddling with energy advisers and lawyers trying to come up with an appropriate response to PG&E's bankruptcy bombshell. Efforts to stabilize California's dysfunctional electricity market suddenly have become much more complex. NOT MUCH CHANGED Nevertheless, while PG&E's bankruptcy is by far the most sensational aspect of California's long-drawn-out energy mess, at the end of the day, it doesn't really change a thing. Consider: -- PG&E's financial woes stem from a rate freeze that prevented the utility from passing along to customers runaway wholesale power costs. That rate freeze and sky-high electricity prices remain in place. -- California's energy shortage is primarily the result of the state not having built any major power plants for the past 12 years. PG&E's bankruptcy does nothing to affect that precarious situation. -- PG&E's foray into bankruptcy court does not alter the fact that electricity demand is outpacing available supply. California consumers still face a threat of daily blackouts when power usage spikes this summer. "The crux of the problem is still the same," said Loretta Lynch, president of the state Public Utilities Commission. "We face the same challenges we did before PG&E filed for bankruptcy." She added, however, that PG&E's bankruptcy "increases the uncertainty." The utility doesn't see it that way. PG&E spokesman Ron Low said California's energy woes are no more uncertain now than they were when the company ostensibly was negotiating with Davis to find an equitable solution to the state's troubles. "California remains in an energy crisis," he said. "As we head toward summer, resources are going to be very tight." WHAT COULD HAPPEN In the short run, consumers will notice no change whatsoever. Bankruptcy protection will allow PG&E to continue operating as usual while the company's creditors line up to receive at least partial payment of outstanding bills. Longer term, there is a very real possibility that electricity rates will soar if the bankruptcy judge agrees with PG&E that conditions for lifting the rate freeze were met a year ago and that $9 billion in subsequent expenses must be borne by consumers. How much people's bills would rise depends on how the rate increase is structured. It would probably come in the form of a surcharge on existing fees, but the monthly hit to consumers could be limited by spreading the total cost over a number of years. The big question mark now is how PG&E's bankruptcy will affect various political and legislative measures intended to keep California's lights on. The state's attempt to purchase PG&E's power lines is obviously finished, although a new deal could be negotiated in bankruptcy court. Meanwhile, the governor is pressing ahead with plans to purchase the transmission systems of Edison and Sempra Energy's San Diego utility -- although what the state would do with only a partial power grid has yet to be determined. "Does it make any sense to have the transmission lines of Edison and Sempra and not PG&E?" asked state Senate President Pro Tem John Burton, D-San Francisco. "I don't know the answer to that." A final accord with Edison this week would validate PG&E's apparent concerns that it would have had a harder time limiting backlash to its bankruptcy filing if the utility had acted after a breakthrough with Edison was unveiled. The Chronicle quoted PG&E insiders yesterday as saying that the decision to file for bankruptcy had been made early last week, even though senior company officials said the move followed the governor's Thursday night speech on solving California's energy issues. One reason PG&E opted to file on Friday morning was because a final deal with Edison was expected at any time, observers said. Paul Patterson, an analyst at Credit Suisse First Boston, noted that if PG&E had filed for bankruptcy after Edison came to terms with the state, "they would be seen as a spoiler." ENSUING CONFUSION In any case, PG&E's surprise filing has left all concerned scrambling for footing in the changed political landscape. Consumer advocates watched with dismay yesterday as the state's political and corporate powers slugged it out for supremacy. Nettie Hoge, executive director of The Utility Reform Network in San Francisco, said all this finger-pointing will do nothing to ensure that Californians have ample supplies of electricity this summer. "These guys should grow up and come up with a situation that works for the public," she said. E-mail David Lazarus at dlazarus@sfchronicle.com. ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle ? Page?A - 1 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ----------- Power Grab -- Some Democrats Favor Seizing Plants Bernadette Tansey, Chronicle Staff Writer Monday, April 9, 2001 ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle URL: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/chronicle/archive/2001/04/09/M N122655.DTL With the prospect that state power buyers could burn through more than $2 billion a month this summer, some state Democratic leaders are pushing for a takeover of private power plants to get soaring prices under control. Lawmakers concede that sending state agents to grab the keys of power generating plants would be an extraordinary measure. But now that Pacific Gas and Electric Co. has limited the state's options with Friday's bankruptcy filing and with little hope for stronger federal price controls, state Senate leader John Burton and others say seizing power plants makes financial and political sense. They say they've done the math: Since January, California has spent more than $4 billion buying power. That's about $1 billion more than private energy firms paid for the power plants PG&E and California's two other investor-owned utilities were forced to sell under California's botched deregulation plan. At those rates, California could soon look like a renter paying the full value of the house several times a year. Profits of 300 percent are not uncommon for large private generators, which provide about 40 percent of the state's power needs. The state could seize the assets, compensate the companies and then sell the electricity to consumers at cost, advocates of the plan say. "We have to do something," said Burton, D-San Francisco, one of a group of legislators who urged Davis at a meeting last week to condemn some of the plants. "These people have got us by the throat. They're making more money than God, and we've got to fight back -- not with words, but with actions." Davis himself raised the specter of using his emergency powers to take over power plants with a fiery flourish during his State of the State address earlier this year. "If I have to use the power of eminent domain to prevent generators from driving consumers into the dark and utilities into bankruptcy, then that's what I will do," he said in January. Davis still hasn't ruled out the possibility, but he says it's not high on his list of tactics. Generators say they would fight tooth and nail against such a grab, and state GOP lawmakers oppose condemnation, saying it smacks of underdeveloped countries' nationalizing key industries. But Burton and other Democrats, including state Senators Don Perata, D- Oakland, and Jackie Speier, D-Hillsborough, say the governor's strategy so far has left giant energy firms holding all the cards -- and a mounting pile of the state's cash. Davis had been trying to restore the financial stability of PG&E and Southern California Edison after their combined $14 billion debt for electricity purchases so damaged their creditworthiness that the state had to take over buying power. But now that PG&E has sought bankruptcy protection rather than accept Davis' plan to buy its transmission lines, the state may be stuck with the role of power buyer for years. POWERS OF EMINENT DOMAIN Sacramento lawyer Richard Desmond, an expert on state powers of eminent domain, said California could seize generating plants by demonstrating that it would put the properties to "a higher and more necessary use." "The government has almost unlimited power of eminent domain to acquire property," Desmond said. "The only thing the state has to do is pay 'just compensation,' as defined under the constitution." The state could file a formal suit for eminent domain, a time-consuming procedure if the owner mounts a fierce resistance over the transfer price, Desmond said. If the state wants to take immediate possession, it can deposit an estimate of the just compensation and fight it out later in court. But if the state loses, it could be stuck for interest, litigation costs and damages. Condemnation of power plants would raise a number of unknowns, such as figuring out who would manage and operate the facilities. The state might also be put into the position of having to seize contracts between the generators and natural gas providers. Davis spokesman Roger Salazar said the governor's first priority was building new plants to increase supply, rather than condemning existing plants. State Sen. Jim Battin, R-Palm Desert, said he thought seizing plants was a horrible idea. "We would become a third world country and start nationalizing things," Battin said. "Nobody would ever build a power plant in California again. I think that would be a really bad play." COMPANY WOULD FIGHT Tom Williams, a spokesman for Duke Energy, said the company would fight vigorously to protect its multimillion-dollar investment in four California plants, including Morro Bay and Moss Landing. "We would defend our interest and seek a fair market value," Williams said. Duke spent $611 million to buy or lease the four plants since 1998, and has embarked on a $1.6 billion program to upgrade and expand them. Some power companies, however, may find their claims for the fair market value of their plants undercut by their own tax filings. Energy firms, including Duke, told county assessors last year that the utility plants they bought were worth hundreds of millions of dollars less than they paid for them. Private companies including Duke, Dynegy, Southern Energy, AES Corp and Calpine spent a total of $3.2 billion to buy divested utility power plants that can produce as much as 20,000 megawatts. UNDERLYING PROBLEM UNSOLVED Williams said taking over the property of private companies would not solve the underlying problem behind California's high energy prices: rising demand and an inadequate supply of energy to fill it. Even if Davis seized only one plant, the move might spur other power generators to drop their prices, said Doug Heller of the Foundation for Taxpayer and Consumer Rights. "As soon as the generators recognize we're ready to go to a public power system and take their plants, they may start selling power at reasonable rates, and we won't have to go down that road," Heller said. Chronicle staff writers Tyche Hendricks, Patrick Hoge and Greg Lucas contributed to this report. / E-mail Bernadette Tansey at btansey@sfchronicle.com. ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle ? Page?A - 1 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ----------- Davis Could Still Show Courage ROB MORSE Monday, April 9, 2001 ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle URL: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/chronicle/archive/2001/04/09/M N61997.DTL This is Gray Davis' last chance. He can be remembered for something other than his vows that there would be no electricity rate hikes and no bankruptcies. But he has to show some guts, take his finger out of the wind, form it into a fist and stand up to PG&E. Go for it, Gray. Seize a power plant. That may discourage private investment in new plants, but if the state can build those institutions of darkness called prisons, it can build institutions that create light. PG&E Corp. Chairman Robert Glynn slapped Davis and all Californians in the face by saying Friday that PG&E would file for bankruptcy protection. Glynn supposedly took it personally a couple of weeks ago when the governor called his company "immoral." So he went out and proved he wasn't immoral by giving bonuses to 6,000 employees, mostly managers, just before he made the bankruptcy announcement. Glynn probably considers that loyalty. But unlike many of the great men who guided PG&E in the past, he has shown no loyalty to California or its citizens. Compare Glynn's behavior with that of Frank G. Drum, who was president of PG&E during the company's great financial crisis of 1907, when San Francisco was in ruins and PG&E was millions in debt. Lawyers told Drum that PG&E needed time to recover and should ask for the protection of the courts by being put in receivership. "There will be no receiver," said Drum. He then pulled PG&E through its financial crisis by levying a $10 assessment on each share of the company's stock, issuing bonds and using every means he could to keep the company afloat. Unfortunately, times are different and definitions of honor, morality and loyalty have changed. Is Glynn immoral? I don't know. But he isn't a worthy successor to Frank G. Drum. GROSS & Egregious: Chris Burns says that he remember's Herb Caen calling PG&E "Pigs, Greed and Extortion." Burns and others wrote their checks that way, and they all cleared. Patrick Driscoll says that during the '80s he paid his PG&E bills with checks made out to "Piggy." Says Driscoll, "They kept my power turned on anyway." You can call them anything, just don't call them to fix a gas leak. dept.: Karyn Hunt says that after hearing tirades about all the things people do while driving their cars, she's seen the ultimate. "I actually saw a woman adjusting her tongue piercing while driving down Folsom near Seventh Street," she says. "Ick." here: A biker parked his Harley outside the venerable Western Saloon in Point Reyes Station. Barroom conversation ensued. The biker complained about all the numbers in his life: his Social Security number, phone number, license number, e-mail address and passwords. "You can't have just one password," said the biker, "because some passwords require four numbers and some require five." Ah, for the days when the only password you needed was on the back of a sleeveless denim jacket. tunes: Maggie Lynch, magnificent Muni spokeswoman, was on the scene when an M-line car derailed last week. She heard one of the unsung heroes of the Metro Rail track crew say to another: "If you can drive that train back onto the tracks right away, I will kiss your (butt) right here in St. Francis Circle." Train back on tracks, but no busses on backside. Cool car: The Peter Witt Italian streetcar has a platform in the rear that really deserves a bar, and all the car's signs are still in 1920s Italian. The other day a young Italian marveled at "Vietato Fumare," "Vietato Sputare" and "Fermata Prenotata." He said the latter had something to do with "a bus stop and trying to make a reservation at a restaurant." success: Success magazine presents "Success 2001" at the Cow Palace in June. Among the successful speakers will be Larry King (numerous successful marriages) and Jeff Garcia (successful nonembarrassment to humankind). Bill Clinton also will appear, on tape, I presume from the low admission fee. "Reg. $225, now only $39." Includes pardon. Newspaper recounts are in, and hang the chads. Bush won and there's no chance of bringing in Al Gore to negotiate with the Chinese in a language they understand, English. You can get rid of those bumper stickers that say "Re- elect Gore." up: Last week I mentioned former San Francisco school board president JoAnne Miller, who was helping her friend Carol Schilling try to get her son Jeffrey Schilling released by terrorists in the Philippines. Miller called to say that Sen. Dianne Feinstein rose to the occasion, putting Carol in touch with the secretary of defense, helping her make a radio appeal to the young man's captors and arranging a conference call with the president of the Philippines. "We're keeping our fingers crossed," said Miller. Rob Morse's column appears Mondays, Wednesdays, Fridays and Sundays. His e-mail address is rmorse@sfchronicle.com. ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle ? Page?A - 2 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ----------- Governor, bankrupt utility blame each other for power woes GARY GENTILE, AP Business Writer Monday, April 9, 2001 ,2001 Associated Press URL: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/news/archive/2001/04/09/nation al0504EDT0447.DTL (04-09) 02:04 PDT LOS ANGELES (AP) -- Gov. Gray Davis and Pacific Gas & Electric executives traded acrimonious barbs -- but no solutions -- as the state's largest utility headed into bankruptcy court claiming $9 billion in debts. On Sunday, Davis appeared on two nationally televised news programs to berate PG&E for awarding an estimated $50 million in bonuses and raises to about 6,000 midlevel managers and support staff on the eve of its filing for bankruptcy protection Friday. ``Management at PG&E is just focused upon padding their own pockets, not in discharging their duty to serve their many customers in California,'' Davis said on ABC's ''World News Tonight.'' Earlier, Davis had issued a statement saying PG&E ``management is suffering from two afflictions: Denial and greed.'' In response, PG&E defended their employee bonus package and took a swipe at the governor. ``Instead of focusing all his attention on solving the state's yearlong and ever-worsening energy crisis, the governor has launched a campaign-style attack on our company,'' a PG&E statement read. The rancor came at the start of a hectic week. A San Francisco bankruptcy judge was to hold PG&E's first bankruptcy hearing Monday or Tuesday to determine, among other priorities, which creditors will be paid and in what order. Davis, meanwhile, was still locked in faltering negotiations with Southern California Edison, the state's second-largest utility, which also claims the state's flawed 1996 deregulation law is the cause of its financial woes. Davis is hoping to strike a deal to buy Edison's share of the power transmission system for $2.76 billion, which would provide Edison with a much-needed cash-flow to restructure its debt. SoCal Edison executives have said they would continue negotiations with Davis, but weekend talks in San Francisco failed to resolve any of the outstanding issues on the table, said Davis' spokesman Steven Maviglio. Edison was to file an update on its financial condition with the Securities and Exchange Commission on Monday. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ --------------------------------- Negotiations continue between state and SoCal Edison GARY GENTILE, AP Business Writer Monday, April 9, 2001 ,2001 Associated Press URL: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/news/archive/2001/04/09/financ ial0008EDT0200.DTL (04-09) 06:44 PDT LOS ANGELES (AP) -- California failed to keep its largest utility from bankruptcy but the state isn't giving up efforts to keep the second-biggest afloat. Talks were scheduled to resume Monday on California's bid to buy Southern California Edison's share of the power transmission system for $2.76 billion. That would provide the company with a much-needed cash-flow to restructure its debt. Weekend negotiations in San Francisco failed to resolve the ``few remaining issues,'' according to Steven Maviglio, a spokesman for Gov. Gray Davis. Edison also was expected to file an update on its financial condition with the Securities and Exchange Commission. Gov. Gray Davis' administration also had intended to buy power lines from Pacific Gas & Electric. The companies say they have lost more than $13 billion since June because of skyrocketing wholesale power prices they cannot pass on to customers under the state's 1996 deregulation law. On Friday -- in a political embarrassment to the governor -- PG&E filed for Chapter 11 federal bankruptcy protection from creditors. The company said the move wouldn't disrupt power for its 13 million customers. A San Francisco bankruptcy judge was to hold PG&E's first bankruptcy hearing Monday or Tuesday to determine, among other priorities, which creditors will be paid and in what order. PG&E has other legal challenges. Companies who sold electricity to the utility have filed at least a dozen lawsuits, seeking to be released from contracts so they can sell power elsewhere. The bankruptcy also may have an impact on the state's tax base. It wasn't immediately clear whether PG&E would meet its Tuesday deadline to pay $80 million in property tax payments to 49 counties. PG&E and Edison annually pay more than a quarter-billion dollars in taxes. Edison has said it intends to meet the deadline. Meanwhile, the governor and PG&E traded barbs over the utility's decision to award more than $50 million in bonuses and merit raises to about 6,000 midlevel managers and other workers the day before filing for bankruptcy protection. Davis issued a statement Saturday saying PG&E's management suffered from ``denial and greed,'' and the company replied in kind. ``Instead of focusing all his attention on solving the state's yearlong and ever-worsening energy crisis, the governor has launched a campaign-style attack on our company,'' a company statement read. ``Unfortunately, he has chosen to aim at the thousands of men and women who have worked tirelessly and professionally through this crisis to deliver gas and electric service to our millions of customers.'' Davis then went on two nationally televised news programs to blast the utility. ``Management at PG&E is just focused upon padding their own pockets, not in discharging their duty to serve their many customers in California,'' Davis said Sunday on ABC World News Tonight. The rancor comes at the start of a busy week, as federal and state officials plan hearings on the California's growing power crisis. Representatives of 11 Western states will gather in Boise, Idaho on Tuesday to discuss regional energy issues. The gathering is sponsored by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission. In Sacramento on Wednesday, the state Senate starts hearings in its inquiry into allegations that electricity suppliers illegally withheld power to drive up California's wholesale prices. Wholesalers deny such accusations. Meanwhile, no power alerts were in effect Monday morning as power reserves stayed above 7 percent. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ --------------------------------- SAN FRANCISCO PUC General Manager To Leave S.F. Post Monday, April 9, 2001 ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle URL: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/chronicle/archive/2001/04/09/M N1054417.DTL John Mullane, general manager of the San Francisco Public Utilities Commission for the past 15 months, has told Mayor Willie Brown he is retiring, even though Brown hasn't yet named a successor to lead the agency that could play a vital role in helping the city through the energy crisis. Mullane, a 37-year city employee, was director of the Water Department before he took the post at the PUC, which runs the city's vast Hetch Hetchy water and electric power system. He initially agreed to serve as acting general manager for only six months, succeeding Anson Moran, who also retired. But the PUC has not identified a candidate for the general manager's post who is acceptable to Brown. The mayor has said he wants to use the PUC's hydroelectric dams and vast land holdings as a basis for building more power- generating capacity and creating a regional power authority. ,2001 San Francisco Chronicle ? Page?A - 12 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ----------- Gov. Davis, bankrupt utility blame each other for power woes Posted at 6:38 a.m. PDT Monday, April 9, 2001 BY GARY GENTILE AP Business Writer LOS ANGELES (AP) -- Gov. Gray Davis and Pacific Gas & Electric executives traded acrimonious barbs -- but no solutions -- as the state's largest utility headed into bankruptcy court claiming $9 billion in debts. On Sunday, Davis appeared on two nationally televised news programs to berate PG&E for awarding an estimated $50 million in bonuses and raises to about 6,000 midlevel managers and support staff on the eve of its filing for bankruptcy protection Friday. ``Management at PG&E is just focused upon padding their own pockets, not in discharging their duty to serve their many customers in California,'' Davis said on ABC's ''World News Tonight.'' Earlier, Davis had issued a statement saying PG&E ``management is suffering from two afflictions: Denial and greed.'' In response, PG&E defended their employee bonus package and took a swipe at the governor. ``Instead of focusing all his attention on solving the state's yearlong and ever-worsening energy crisis, the governor has launched a campaign-style attack on our company,'' a PG&E statement read. The rancor came at the start of a hectic week. A San Francisco bankruptcy judge was to hold PG&E's first bankruptcy hearing Monday or Tuesday to determine, among other priorities, which creditors will be paid and in what order. Davis, meanwhile, was still locked in faltering negotiations with Southern California Edison, the state's second-largest utility, which also claims the state's flawed 1996 deregulation law is the cause of its financial woes. Davis is hoping to strike a deal to buy Edison's share of the power transmission system for $2.76 billion, which would provide Edison with a much-needed cash-flow to restructure its debt. SoCal Edison executives have said they would continue negotiations with Davis, but weekend talks in San Francisco failed to resolve any of the outstanding issues on the table, said Davis' spokesman Steven Maviglio. Edison was to file an update on its financial condition with the Securities and Exchange Commission on Monday. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------- Cheap, abundant coal eyed with new interest Published Monday, April 9, 2001, in the San Jose Mercury News BY JIM PUZZANGHERA Mercury News Washington Bureau WASHINGTON -- The skyrocketing price of natural gas, a major factor in California's electricity problems, is sparking renewed national interest in coal -- and the Golden State has a major stake in its potential comeback. Although California's small, coal-fired power plants account for less than 1 percent of its electricity production, about 20 percent of the state's total power comes from coal-burning plants, mostly elsewhere in the West. More coal plants are on the drawing board in the region as abundant and inexpensive coal has become increasingly enticing when compared with natural gas. Gas burns cleaner but is more than four times as expensive and is in short supply. The nation is hungry for options as the energy crisis threatens to spread. But coal's potential to produce more and cheaper power is offset by the impact that increased coal burning could have on the environment, from thicker haze to more mercury emissions to accelerated global warming. Coal, the fuel that powered the Industrial Revolution, fell out of favor over the past 30 years because of those environmental concerns. But President Bush has touted it as a key to solving the nation's energy woes. In the budget he sends to Congress today, Bush is expected to propose spending more money to research cleaner-burning coal. Some of the money for the 10-year, $2 billion program will come at the expense of research into renewable energy and energy efficiency. Optimism about the new administration and the high prices of other fossil fuels has led companies to announce plans for 23 new coal-fired power plants across the nation in recent months. That's more than were proposed in the past decade. The announcements, along with a more than doubling of coal prices, has fed surging stock valuations of coal companies. One of the leading producers, Peabody Group, is planning an initial public offering next month. None of the new plants are in California, although 10 are in the West. Those plants would add at least 4,800 megawatts of electricity to the Western power network in the next four years, enough to power 3.6 million homes. ``To the extent that they expand capacity anywhere in the Western grid right now, it's going to help,'' said Severin Borenstein, director of the Energy Institute at the University of California-Berkeley. ``But before coal can make a claim that it can be the energy source we can depend on, it's going to have to prove that it can be more environmentally friendly.'' Pollution concerns Environmentalists are highly skeptical. They, along with some taxpayer groups and the U.S. General Accounting Office, have criticized the Department of Energy's existing Clean Coal Technology Program as ineffective and wasteful. Although technological advances have nearly eliminated the characteristic black smoke of coal, burning it still releases large amounts of carbon dioxide, which contributes to global warming, and other chemicals that pollute air and water, environmental groups say. ``Coal is not part of our long-term future, unless our long-term future has San Jose underwater,'' said Carl Pope, executive director of the Sierra Club, alluding to the rising oceans predicted if global warming continues. Pope added that truly clean-burning coal ``is about as likely as cold fusion.'' Although there is much debate about the environmental ramifications of burning coal, there is no debate about one thing: The United States is the coal capital of the world. Coal is the nation's most abundant fossil fuel. There are about 250 billion tons of recoverable coal in the country's soil, a figure equal to the entire reserve of oil in the world. At the present rate of consumption -- coal supplies about 51 percent of U.S. electricity today -- there's enough coal in the country to last 250 years. Backing from Bush ``For the United States to ignore coal as an integral part of its energy policy is the equivalent of OPEC ignoring oil,'' said Jack Gerard, president of the National Mining Association, which represents the coal industry. The Bush administration doesn't plan on ignoring it. ``My job and the job of others will be to convince many in the country who don't believe we can have a clean air policy and burn coal at the same time. I believe we can,'' Bush said in a February speech in the coal country of West Virginia. Critics charge Bush is selling out to the coal industry. It contributed $3.8 million to federal candidates in the 2000 election cycle, with 88 percent of that for Republicans. The industry flexed its muscle last month when it pushed Bush to revoke a campaign promise to support requiring power plants to reduce carbon dioxide emissions. ``They seem to have the ear of important people in the White House and the Energy Department. It remains to be seen whether they're going to be able to fool the public,'' said David Hawkins, director of the air and energy program at the National Resources Defense Council and a former environmental official in the Carter administration. California's stricter air-quality laws have made building coal plants in the state unfeasible, industry officials said. Instead, California has looked to coal plants outside the state for power. Los Angeles officials last month urged that between 500 and 1,000 megawatts of generating capacity be added to the coal-fired Intermountain Power Plant in Utah, which already provides the city with a third of its power. No in-state supply Utah has an in-state supply of coal, as do Arizona and several other Western states. Lack of such a supply in California has made coal-fired plants a less enticing option here, said California Energy Commissioner Suzanne Garfield. Coal industry officials counter that their product is shipped across the country. About 3.3 million tons of coal travels by rail each year to Los Angeles, where it is shipped to Asia and other foreign destinations. A coal-fired power plant would face great opposition in California, even during this energy crisis, coal industry officials concede. But coal does have the potential to help solve the country's energy problems, Borenstein said. ``Coal, if it can be burned cleanly, is a very abundant source of power,'' he said. ``I hope that they can come up with a clean coal technology.'' Contact Jim Puzzanghera at jpuzzanghera@ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ -------------------- Leaders threaten to seize power contracts, plants Published Monday, April 9, 2001, in the San Jose Mercury News BY BRANDON BAILEY Mercury News While the governor's office continued talks aimed at preventing a second major utility from going into bankruptcy, other California political leaders said Sunday that it's time for drastic action to bring wholesale power prices down. With little prospect for federal price caps, some state officials are saying California must seriously consider such steps as seizing power contracts or even taking over the generating plants themselves. ``To this date, we haven't done enough'' to persuade suppliers that they need to lower their prices, Democratic state Treasurer Phil Angelides said Sunday. State Senate President Pro Tem John Burton, D-San Francisco, suggested seizing two or three power plants to ``send a shot across their bows.'' Angelides agreed it may be time to slap wholesale power providers with a windfall profits tax -- ``or take a couple of their plants, to give them a little dose of reality.'' Legislative leaders are also discussing a proposal for the governor to seize wholesale electricity contracts if federal regulators refuse to impose a regional price cap on power trading in the West. In effect, that would let the state buy some lower-priced power that generators had already promised to energy traders, who would otherwise resell the same juice on the spot market for higher prices. Shift in focus If the state goes forward with any of those efforts, analysts said it would mark a shift in focus. Rather than concentrating on bailing out the cash-strapped utilities, officials would be addressing the larger issues of what many consider to be a dysfunctional power market in which a handful of large, independent companies have earned huge profits by selling power to the utilities that provide energy to individual consumers. Attorneys for the state's largest utility, Pacific Gas & Electric Co., and its creditors are expected to appear in a federal courtroom in San Francisco this morning for a hearing on the bankruptcy petition that PG&E filed Friday. It is the third largest bankruptcy filing in U.S. history. PG&E says it has amassed $9 billion in debt, primarily because of a rate freeze that has prevented utilities from passing their wholesale costs on to California energy consumers. PG&E bonuses A spokesman, meanwhile, defended PG&E's decision to pay out millions of dollars in performance bonuses to about 6,000 non-union employees last week, before the bankruptcy petition was filed. Though critics said the utility shouldn't be making such payments at a time when it is crying poverty, PG&E spokesman John Nelson said the bonuses went to workers who weren't eligible for a pay increase that other workers received earlier this year under their union contract. The company had planned to award about $80 million in bonuses, but Nelson said that was reduced by an unspecified amount in part because PG&E decided not to include its top officers in the group receiving the awards. Also over the weekend, aides to Gov. Gray Davis continued negotiating details of a bailout plan for the state's other major utility, Southern California Edison. Under a tentative agreement announced a few weeks ago, the state would give Edison nearly $3 billion. In exchange, California would take over Edison's portion of the transmission grid. The governor had hoped to acquire both Edison's and PG&E's share of the statewide grid. ``It would be much easier if we could get the whole system, clearly,'' said Steve Maviglio, the governor's press secretary. But he said the state could still submit a proposal to acquire PG&E's portion as part of a court-approved plan to reorganize the utility's debts. Power producers have criticized the state's effort to acquire the transmission grid, and argue that raising taxes or seizing power plants would only discourage new plant construction. Spokesmen for several major generators have argued that the state should concentrate on reducing barriers to new plants or allowing utilities to raise their rates so they can pay off their debts. But adding to the calls for strong action, Assembly Speaker Pro Tem Fred Keeley, D-Santa Cruz, said Sunday that he doesn't believe the state's economy can survive what he called ``an undisciplined wholesale energy market'' for much longer. Contact Brandon Bailey at bbailey@sjmercury.com or (408) 920-5022. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ----------------- Monday, April 9, 2001 Blackouts this summer? Perhaps the timing was coincidental, but Friday's announcement by Pacific Gas & Electric that it will seek Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection served as a dim comment on the industry's confidence that California Gov. Gray Davis really has a handle on the state's looming electricity crisis. Unfortunately, Gov. Davis' speech Thursday evening, while a bit more realistic than previous statements in that he acknowledged the need for rate increases, suggests the governor is not considering a sensible way out of the problem. In a conference call with journalists Friday morning the governor fleshed out some of the bare bones he offered the public the night before. His proposed rate increase is slightly smaller than one the Public Utility Commission proposed last week and will hit heavy users harder. He promised that a revenue bond his office is still assembling would repay the general fund money the state government has spent and pay some utility debts too. He emphasized that increasing supply is the only long-term answer and said his office is working "at warp speed" to get permits for new plants approved. Four small ones should be online this summer. But he still sees state control rather than a freer market as the proper approach. He said the state would stop buying electricity directly in 2003 but would set up a new regulatory structure to supervise those who do. He acknowledged the need for rate increases but wants rates set by regulators rather than by buyers and sellers. We might eventually get stability under such a system. But it would be a needlessly expensive stability. Looming over all is the near-certainty of summer blackouts. The latest summer projections by California's Independent System Operator, the bureaucratic agency through which most energy transactions in the state are funneled, are more pessimistic and more realistic than previous estimates. But even these latest projections might understate the severity. The 2001 CAISO summer assessment forecasts resource deficiencies for June through September ranging from almost 3,700 megawatts in June down to about a 600 MW shortfall in September. The cover memo notes that "Given this forecast, the CAISO expects that load curtailments (blackouts) will occur this summer." Republican state Sen. Tom McClintock pointed out to us, however, that the governor took over the ISO board with a flurry of new appointments. Sen. McClintock says his staff has heard rumblings of political pressures to minimize doom-and-gloom projections. Last December the ISO estimated a different "peak power demand" (what's demanded with millions of air conditioners running) for each summer month - 49,462 MW for June, 48,759 for July, 50,829 for August and 47,047 for September. The March 22 report applies the same maximum peak load to every month "since the CAISO cannot accurately forecast when the system summer peak will occur." And the figure is at the low end of the previous estimates at 47,703 MW. The ISO says that "potential demand reductions and possible new supply resources are not considered," so conservation measures and price increases haven't been included. The report expects the new plants Gov. Davis mentioned to come online in June and later. Robert Michaels, the Cal State Fullerton energy economist, told us there are so many variables and so many reasonably valid forecasting models that the variances between the two reports might not be all that significant. "In any event, this report is plenty scary. Consumers, especially large industrial operations, are going to have to make big adjustments in how they use energy," he told us. A report from the respected consulting firm Cambridge Energy Research Associates (CERA), headed by author Daniel Yergin, estimat es 20 blackout-hours during the summer. Only four such blackouts have happened so far. A newspaper article by Mr. Yergin and Lawrence Markovich, after analyzing flaws in the misnamed 1996 "deregulation" scheme says, "Instead of fixing these flaws, the current policies from Sacramento are moving California down the road to an expensive public power setup and higher prices for consumers and businesses." Robert Michaels thinks industries are already making adjustments and will make more when they see the bills they get in May. By now almost all the reputed experts say there are likely to be significant power shortfalls and rolling blackouts this summer. Businesses that don't already have backup generators might do well to get them, and to adjust the hours in which they use power most intensively. This could be, as Mr. Michaels put it, "a summer like we've never seen before." CERA thinks it will take California two or three years to re-establish something resembling reliable energy. It just might take suffering in the summer to get state officials to revise their statist plans. Nobody welcomes suffering. But at this point it's prudent to expect the electricity situation to be worse rather than better this summer. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ------------------------ Pacific Gas Files for Chapter 11 By MICHAEL LIEDTKE AP Business Writer SAN FRANCISCO (AP) via NewsEdge Corporation - Pacific Gas and Electric, California's largest utility, filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection Friday despite months of efforts by state officials to bail out the cash-starved company. The utility's 13 million customers probably will be among the least affected, since bankruptcy proceedings allow companies to continue operating while trying to dig out of their financial hole. But lenders, bondholders and power generators may have to write off billions advanced to the utility as losses. And the company's financial reputation could be damaged for years, making it more difficult to raise money to upgrade transmission lines and plants. ``The regulatory and political processes have failed us, and now we are turning to the court,'' company chairman Robert D. Glynn Jr. said. ``We expect the court will provide the venue needed to reach a solution, which thus far the state and the state's regulators have been unable to achieve.'' The company, a subsidiary of PG&E Corp., had run up an $8.9 billion deficit buying electricity as of Feb. 28. Like other California utilities, it has been pinched by skyrocketing wholesale power costs and the state's 1996 deregulation law barring rate increases. As of March 29, the utility had $2.6 billion in cash and outstanding bills of $4.4 billion. Shares of PG&E Corp. were halted on the New York Stock Exchange, where they last traded at $11.36, down 2 cents. The company provides natural gas and electric service across Northern and Central California. It has 21,500 employees. The bankruptcy filing came one day after Gov. Gray Davis, in a statewide address, proposed relieving utilities' debts by giving them a share of a record rate increase approved last week and by continuing to negotiate the state's purchase of their transmission lines. PG&E Corp., however, said those negotiations were ``going nowhere.'' Davis spokesman Steve Maviglio said the bankruptcy filing was a complete surprise. He said aides were meeting with the attorney general's office and bankruptcy lawyers to discuss the implications. Consumer activists were quick to pounce on the news as more evidence that the utility is not getting enough help from its parent company, which has profited during California's energy crisis. ``The parent company has $30 billion, much of which it has siphoned out of the utility coffers. It would have bailed the utility out,'' said Harvey Rosenfield of the Foundation for Taxpayer and Consumer Rights. PG&E Corp. said its subsidiary was forced into bankruptcy because of ``unreimbursed energy costs, which are now increasing by more than $300 million per month,'' state regulatory decisions that are hurting the company and ``the now unmistakable fact that negotiations with Gov. Gray Davis and his representatives are going nowhere.'' Southern California Edison, the state's second-largest utility, was not affected by the filing. Officials at parent Edison International were meeting Friday to discuss the situation. Edison International's stock was down $3.63, or 29 percent, to $9.01 in trading on the New York Stock Exchange. The stock of Sempra Energy, the parent company of San Diego Gas & Electric that serves 3 million customers in the San Diego area, was down $2.17, or 9 percent, to $21.98 per share. The three utilities say they have lost more than $14 billion since June because of soaring wholesale costs. SoCal Edison and Pacific Gas & Electric are barred under the state's deregulation law from raising rates to recover the costs and are having trouble buying power and natural gas because of poor credit. In his five-minute televised speech Thursday evening, Davis said rate increases are needed to help pay for power purchased by the state on behalf of the utilities. The purchases have cost taxpayers $4.7 billion since January. Davis said his tiered rate plan would mean no increase for most residents and an average increase of 26.5 percent for the rest. The Public Utilities Commission has already approved rate increases of up to 46 percent for customers of SoCal Edison and Pacific Gas & Electric. The power crisis led to rolling blackouts in January and earlier this month as electricity supplies dwindled to nearly nothing. On Thursday, state power grid managers said California will see more than a month of rolling blackouts for as many as 5 million people at a time if residents use as much power this summer as last summer. The crisis is blamed a number of factors, including high demand, high wholesale costs and a tight supply worsened by scarce hydroelectric power in the Northwest and maintenance of aging California power plants. The governor has signed contracts and agreements in principle to secure the state's long-term power needs, committing $53 billion that eventually must be paid back by taxpayers and utility customers. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Davis endorses rate hikes, defends handling of energy crisis By JENNIFER COLEMAN Associated Press Writer SACRAMENTO (AP) via NewsEdge Corporation - Gov. Gray Davis for the first time endorsed rate increases for customers of two strapped utilities, while urging conservation and defending his handling of the state's energy crisis. Davis, addressing Californians in a televised speech Thursday, also lashed out at federal regulators for refusing to cap soaring wholesale electricity prices that have pushed the state's two largest utilities toward bankruptcy. ``In January, with the feds still refusing to do their job, California stepped in to purchase the power the utilities could no longer afford to buy,'' Davis said. ``We didn't take over to save the utilities. We took over to keep the power on and the economy strong.'' California has been hit by severe electricity shortages and rolling blackouts the past few months. The problem is blamed on a variety of factors, including deregulation of California's electric industry which does not allow utilities to pass on to customers sharply increased costs. Davis, who repeatedly has said the state can resolve the power problems without rate hikes, told viewers he now thinks rate increases are necessary. His new stance comes after the state Public Utilities Commission last week approved rate increases of up to 46 percent for customers of Southern California Edison and Pacific Gas & Electric Co. Davis said he will propose a tiered rate plan that will mean a 26.5 percent rate increase for the average Edison or PG&E customer. Under the governor's plan, the heaviest power users would see an average 34.5 percent rate increase. ``The more you use, the more you pay,'' he said. ``Conservation is our best short-term weapon against blackouts and price gouging.'' Davis said the state's power crunch and high wholesale costs are the result of a ``flawed deregulation scheme'' signed into law in 1996 by then-Republican Gov. Pete Wilson. Davis urged Californians to help cut power use 10 percent to fend off rolling blackouts this summer, when residents will turn on their air conditioners and demand will rise sharply. The Legislature on Thursday afternoon sent Davis proposals that would spend dlrs 1.1 billion on conservation programs for consumers and businesses. Davis said he plans to sign the measures. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ -------------------------------------------------------------------------- Sempra Energy And SDG&E Reaffirm Strong Financial Position in Response to PG&E Bankruptcy SAN DIEGO--(BUSINESS WIRE)--April 6, 2001 via NewsEdge Corporation - Sempra Energy and San Diego Gas & Electric (SDG&E) officials took the opportunity of today's Chapter 11 bankruptcy announcement by Pacific Gas & Electric (PG&E) to reaffirm their companies' strong financial position and the significant regulatory and legislative differences between SDG&E and PG&E. "We want to reassure our customers and shareholders that Sempra Energy and SDG&E remain very strong and financially viable companies," said Stephen L. Baum, chairman, president and chief executive officer of Sempra Energy, the parent company of SDG&E. "SDG&E is continuing its record of providing safe and reliable gas and electric service for our 1.2 million customers today, tomorrow and for years to come. There are several significant financial, legislative and regulatory differences that distinguish Sempra Energy and SDG&E from PG&E." SDG&E is covered under Assembly Bill 265, a law signed by the Governor last September which guaranteed that SDG&E will be able to collect the difference between the capped price of electricity and the wholesale cost of power, providing the power was prudently purchased. PG&E is not covered by AB 265 and that guarantee. At the end of February, the under-collection in the balancing account was $681 million. Since the state's power procurement agency, the California Department of Water Resources (DWR), has been purchasing power for SDG&E, the growth of the company's balancing account has slowed significantly. Unlike PG&E, SDG&E has been able to pay its wholesale electric bills to the DWR, the California Independent System Operator, the California Power Exchange and Qualifying Facilities that cogenerate power for the utility. Additionally, the Sempra Energy companies have no significant credit exposure to PG&E. "Sempra Energy and SDG&E have long advocated that the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission institute temporary regional wholesale price caps to help stem the financial problems such as those experienced by PG&E," Baum added. "We are also committed to promoting and instituting comprehensive energy conservation programs for all customers to help control bills and decrease the chances of rotating outages this summer." Sempra Energy (NYSE: SRE), based in San Diego, is a Fortune 500 energy services holding company with 12,000 employees and annual revenues of $5.4 billion. Through its eight principal subsidiaries -- SoCalGas, SDG&E, Sempra Energy Solutions, Sempra Energy Trading, Sempra Energy International, Sempra Energy Resources, Sempra Communications and Sempra Energy Financial -- Sempra Energy serves more than 9 million customers in the United States, Europe, Canada, Mexico and South America.