3 Dec 2001, 05:32 UTC
Utilities Biweekly Report
- From
- Energy" @ENRON energy@1stgmc.net
- Date
- Sun, 2 Dec 2001 21:32:35 -0800 (PST)
Utilities Biweekly Report A news service for energy professionals December 4, 2001 To Remove, Substitute or Add an email address to our list, please send brief message to msid@ieee.org Enron's Collapse Has Experts Questioning Future of Electric Deregulation The collapse of energy company Enron has several experts questioning its impacts on the future of electric deregulation. Analysts say that the company's public championing of electric deregulation in Florida and its current financial situation might signal caution to state regulators. "Enron was the most visible and ardent cheerleader of deregulation, and I think what's happened to them is going to raise all these questions about deregulation," says Jim Owen, spokesman for the Edison Electric Institute. Another view comes from Steven Weiss of the Center of Responsive Politics in Washington, who says that politicians may step away from deregulation because they view Enron "like a rotten egg." Other insiders believe that Enron's situation may be another reason that Florida's Governor Jeb Bush has postponed any movement toward deregulation until after his 2002 re-election campaign. Jon Cartwright, a senior energy analyst with Raymond James & Associates, says that it will be difficult for deregulation plans to be completely halted, but Enron is going to give regulators something to think about in addition to California's problems with deregulation. Retail Choice Available in Massachusetts Dominion Retail Inc. has become the first residential supplier to enter Massachusetts' near-moribund competitive retail electricity market. Until now, no companies have attempted to enter the state's retail marketplace. Rob Wilson, a spokesman from Massachusetts Division of Telecommunications and Energy, said that low electric rates have made the market unattractive for new power providers. He also said suppliers were deterred by the nature of the default/standard-offer system that tends to spread potential customers in the default group over a broad area. Dominion will offer an alternative choice of power supply to Massachusetts Electric's 270,000 residential customers who are now receiving their power on default service. Default customers can receive their power from Dominion at $66.31 per month if they commit to a three-year deal, which is slightly less than the $67.75 average cost for Massachusetts Electric default customers. However, it is still more than the proposed $57.56 per month that an average Massachusetts Electric standard-offer customer will pay beginning January 1, 2002, pending state approval. Currently there are already several companies competing for commercial and industrial customers in the state's electric marketplace. Consumer Choice Drives Green Power Market A new study from the National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL) and the Lawrence Berkeley National Lab's Environmental Energy Technology Division has found that consumers prefer to receive their power from clean energy sources. If consumers are given the choice, they will choose power from cleaner sources such as wind, solar, geothermal, and biomass. The study says that in order for green power to gain full support in the marketplace, restructuring should proceed without delay and that market rules in restructured markets should be conducive to competition. "Our study shows that giving consumers energy supply choices can be a powerful mechanism for moving renewable energy into the marketplace," says Blair Swezey of NREL, coauthor of the study entitled "Forecasting the Growth of Green Power Markets in the United States." Under the best conditions, use of green power could grow 40 percent in less than a decade, to a capacity of 7,000 megawatts. However, the study concludes that it is more likely that renewables will experience a slow growth in the market. In addition to a competitive marketplace, vigorous promotion and education will also be necessary to ensure the success of green power. Electricity Bill Will Be Put Off Until Next Year The House Energy and Air Quality Subcommittee is preparing an electricity bill that will focus on increasing power supplies and improving electricity transmission from one part of the country to another. Subcommittee Chairman Joe Barton (R-TX) has not set a date for markup, an aide said, but aims to consider the bill during the first two weeks of December. Accordingly, Energy and Commerce Committee Chairman, Billy Tauzin (R-La) announced at a news conference yesterday that he expects to receive the bill for consideration by the year's end. Chairman Tauzin told reporters that Congress should allow states to make their own decisions regarding siting transmission facilities within their boundaries, but that interstate projects might require Federal intervention. He also noted that grid connections among states are necessary for regional transmission organizations as a means to expand the grid and eliminate electricity bottlenecks. Separately, Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle (D-SD) is expected to introduce a Senate energy bill that includes an electricity title, but said that the Senate will not consider it until next year. FERC Underestimated Environmental Impacts of Competition The final environmental impact statement the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) completed for Order 888 underestimated the effects that a competitive wholesale power market would have on air pollutants, a new study says. Synapse Energy Economics, a Massachusetts-based firm, prepared the study for the commission. It reviewed the accuracy of FERC's predictions on the effects competition would have on the environment in the year 2000. The most important conclusion from the analysis is that FERC's modeling methodology was too narrowly defined to capture the effects, the report says. Synapse found that FERC did not fully consider the impacts from increases in electricity demand, improvements in nuclear plant efficiency, and the extension of nuclear and coal plant lifetimes. The study concludes that FERC's forecast of NOx emissions was roughly four percent lower than actual experience and its forecast of CO2 emissions was roughly eight percent lower. Also, the report finds that FERC underestimated actual national electricity demand through 2000 by 4.6 percent. The North American Commission for Environmental Cooperation, a panel created under the North American Free Trade Agreement, was expected to address these findings and other environmental concerns among the United States, Canada, and Mexico at a forum held November 29-30, 2001, in San Diego. Michigan PSC Protects Consumers from Retail Slamming The Michigan Public Service Commission (MPSC) has adopted standards to protect retail electric consumers from slamming and cramming. Slamming is the unauthorized switching from one electric customer from electric service provider to another, while cramming is the billing of a customer for unauthorized electric services. The Customer Choice and Reliability Act of 2000 requires that the Commission issue orders to protect Michigan's electric customers from slamming and cramming and authorizes the Commission to conduct contested proceedings to investigate any violations. Under the new measures, customers may authorize switching of their electric service provider through written authorization, a call to a toll-free telephone number voice response unit, a Web-based connection, notice to an appropriately qualified third party, or a three-way call between the new supplier, the customer, and the older supplier. New suppliers must notify customers and the existing provider within seven days of the requested change in service. Violators can be fined up to $30,000 for the first offense, up to $50,000 for the second offense, and up to $70,000 for repeated violations. Michigan PSC Approves Commonwealth Energy as Alternative Supplier The Michigan Public Service Commission (MPSC) has approved Commonwealth Energy Corporation's application to sell electric generation to Michigan retail customers. The commission approved Commonwealth's license to be the 12th alternative electric supplier in the state under the Customer Choice and Electricity Reliability Act of 2000. The state regulators concluded that approval of the alternative electric supplier license would expand the opportunities for retail electric competition in the state. The commission granted the license conditioned upon Commonwealth providing electric service within a reasonable time and indicated that failure to do so may result in revocation of the license. Commonwealth will operate in Michigan under the name ElectricAmerica. Hearing Held on Pennsylvania's Electric Deregulation The Pennsylvania House Democratic Policy Committee held a hearing on electric deregulation on November 28, 2001, during which witnesses testified on the state's future electricity needs and the impacts of deregulation. The committee is concerned about whether enough power plants will be built to meet the state's future demand. Robert Hinkle of PJM Interconnection, which manages the mid-Atlantic transmission grid and serves as a wholesale electricity market, said that 4,000 megawatts of increased electricity capacity are planned for the next three years. With this increase, the region's capacity would reach 60,000 megawatts, which is more than sufficient to meet the region's electricity needs for the foreseeable future, Hinkle said. Richard Maurer, of Local 29 International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers, testified that deregulation has resulted in layoffs and more burdens on an increasingly aging work force that his union represents. On the other hand, Duquesne Light Company President Victor Rogue told the committee that Pennsylvania's electric deregulation has been a success. Rogue said that Duquesne Light customers have been protected from steep rate increase and can expect an estimated 16 percent decline in the rates early next year. Northeast May See Increased Power Costs Energy Security Analysis (ESAI), a Boston-based consulting firm, reports that urban areas in the Northeast may experience increased power prices unless investments are made in regional power generation and transmission systems. ESAI director Ed Krapels said that, while electricity restructuring resulted in new power plant construction in many states, urban areas remain at risk for higher prices. ESAI's 10-year power price forecast report for New England says that 2003 and 2004 are "shaping up as years with premiums close to the double digits in both on- and off-peak markets" for the New York Power Pool unless additional power and transmission are developed. The report also concludes that Boston and southwestern Connecticut will require additional generation and transmission "to keep their urban premiums in check." The forecast estimates that premiums in the PJM region could increase by $10 per megawatt should no new generation be developed. However, new transmission projects will likely stimulate the development of the new generation projects that are currently stalled. New generation will help stabilize the New Jersey market as well as contribute to New York City's power needs. Ontario Power planning long-term debt offering in new year Ontario Power Generation is planning a long-term debt offering some time next year, the company said yesterday. "We do intend to tap the long-term market for the first time next year," Ronald Osborne, president and chief executive officer, told reporters following an industry breakfast in Toronto. Mr. Osborne could not provide details on the proposed offering, but said it would most likely be a long-term, or possibly medium-term, issue. This would be the first long-term debt offering for the company, which was spun off from debt-ridden Ontario Hydro in the 1990s. Mr. Osborne said the proceeds from the offering would be used to replace old Ontario Hydro debt that has reached maturity. By the middle of next year, Ontario Power expects to pay off $400-million of debt. Ontario Power is one of two main spinoffs of Ontario Hydro. The other is Hydro One,which is slated to become a publicly traded company following the planned deregulation of the market next year. Ontario Power is readying itself for the electricity market to open to competition next year. The province has already pushed back its original November, 2000, deadline for electricity-system deregulation by 18 months. Rates Decrease For Texas Provider of Last Resort The Texas Public Utility Commission (PUC) and Assurance Energy have agreed to reduce previously announced rates for guaranteed back-up electric service in the Houston area and south Texas when retail competition begins on January 1, 2002. Assurance Energy will be the provider of last resort (POLR) for residential and small non-residential customers in these areas of Texas. As a POLR, Assurance is required to assure continued service at a fixed non-discountable rate to consumers who have been dropped by their current electric provider. The new prices will be 9.5 cents per kilowatt-hour (kWh) for summer months and 7.4 cents per kWh for non-summer months, compared to the previous respective prices of 12.5 cents per kWh and 9.5 cents per kWh. The previous agreement was negotiated early this year when the price for natural gas, a major fuel for generating electricity, reached historical highs. Currently, natural gas prices are substantially lower. Louisiana Considers a Limited Deregulation Plan The Louisiana Public Service Commission (PSC) is considering a limited electricity deregulation plan that would allow large energy consumers to shop for competitive rates. Under the plan, companies that use five megawatts or more of energy would be allowed the option of leaving the regulated market every two years starting in 2003. The proposed plan does not include retail competition for residential or small business consumers. Not all commissioners support the plan, however; Commissioner Don Owen has said that he does not think deregulation will benefit electricity users in the state. Opposition to the proposal has also come from the Louisiana Energy Users Group (LEUG) and the Louisiana Midcontinent Oil and Gas Association, which maintain that large industrial users should be given the choice to leave the market annually. The groups also argue that the plan hampers large industrial customers from building cogeneration plants because of a provision that requires large industrial cogenerators to pay a stranded costs recovery fee. Industrial customers with new cogeneration facilities are allowed to apply for an exemption. The PSC has not yet determined the stranded cost fee structure under the proposed deregulation plan. David Dismukes, an associate professor of energy studies at Louisiana State University, says that this uncertainty may make companies hesitant to build cogeneration plants. State regulators had included the fee in the proposed plan so that stranded cost recovery would not be unfairly shifted to residential ratepayers who remain in the regulated system. The PSC is scheduled to vote on the plan next month. Deregulation in Mississippi Not Expected Soon In a recent speech to the Vicksburg Civic Club, Public Service Commissioner Nielsen Cochran said it is unlikely that Mississippi will soon open its electricity market to competition. Cochran explained that, in order for competition or deregulation to work, there must be a greater abundance of generation options in the state. After two years of hearings that ended in 1999, the Public Service Commission advised lawmakers that Mississippi was not ready for deregulation. Cochran said that deregulation would result in more expensive electricity rates for consumers across the state. Texas Electricity Provider Opposes Texas Deregulation Delay The New Power Company, an electricity provider that is participating in Texas' pilot deregulation program, said that it opposes delaying the January 1, 2002, start of electricity deregulation. New Power has been a major player in the pilot program, but has experienced its share of obstacles along the way. Computer glitches have caused the company to send out customer bills late and at times without appropriate charges. Representatives from the company say that the company needs information from companies that operate the electricity transmission and metering systems in order to issue accurate bills. New Power and the Electric Reliability Council of Texas, which is responsible for making the information available, have been communicating to improve the situation. New Power is confident that its problems will be resolved in time for the January 1, 2002, deregulation date. The Public Utility Commission requested comments from electricity companies on whether the state should move the date back from January 1, 2002. New California crisis: Too much electricity A man approaches a woman in a grocery-store aisle and asks whether she would rather have dinner with him tonight. Sorry, she replies, she'll be doing her laundry late this evening. And not tomorrow night, either, because she'll be doing her vacuuming in those off-peak hours. Energy conservation, you know. Californians have been forced to watch this state government TV commercial over and over in recent months, but are now rolling their eyes at its outdated message. The Governor ordered the ads advocating radical energy conservation after an unprecedented wave of blackouts that plagued the state earlier this year. But if ads were being ordered now, they might suggest that Californians turn on extra lights, plug in some heavy appliances and run their air conditioners at full blast. In only a few months, California has gone from an energy drought to a flood, in which the state is now forced to sell or give away a glut of excess electricity at prices far below those it paid. California's double-whammy energy crisis -- a shortage followed by an overstock -- serves as a cautionary tale for other jurisdictions looking to privatize their utilities. California led the way in placing its electricity on the open market, and last year fell prey to what some describe as a failure in its regulatory structure, and what Governor Grey Davis calls "a monumental scam" committed by power-generating companies against the state. One thing is certain: When electricity demand was driven up by poor weather last January, generators began charging the state prices hundreds of times more than what it had paid only months before. Because California bought its power on a day-by-day basis, prices fluctuated dramatically: One generator billed the state $3,880 (U.S.) for a megawatt that had cost $29 the previous year. And because most of the state's utilities had capped domestic rates, the price increase had to be borne by the state treasury. Mr. Davis now claims that the state is owed a refund of more than $9-billion from those generators. Federal regulators agree with him, although the amount of the refund still must be negotiated. However, the crisis left the state with debts in the tens of billions of dollars, consumer electrical rates were raised by 43 per cent and people were terrified by days of rolling, random blackouts that threatened to drive businesses away from California's already beleaguered economy. Now Mr. Davis is coming under fire for his solution to that crisis: As the blackouts were taking place, he signed $43-billion worth of long-term power contracts, some of them for many years, at rates averaging $69 a megawatt. These seemed to provide stability, but now they seem onerous: With demand for oil and natural gas dropping in the wake of Sept. 11, rosy weather forecasts and dozens of new generating stations coming on line, open-market energy prices have dropped below $20 a megawatt. Suddenly, California faces the prospect of paying tens of billions of dollars a year above market rates for electricity. "Our children and grandchildren will be the ones who have to pay for his mistakes," said Richard Riordan, former mayor of Los Angeles and Mr. Davis's chief Republican opponent. To make matters worse, those energy-conservation TV ads appear to have worked too well. Californians are now using less electricity per capita than any other state. While this is applauded by utility officials and environmentalists, it leaves California with contracts for far more electricity than it needs. Energy companies, which had rushed in to build or upgrade power plants during this year's crisis, have been scaling back dramatically. Since September, at least half a dozen planned generating stations have been cancelled. But experts warn that this, too, could backfire, warning that California could be hit by another round of blackouts in five years. Copyright ? 2001 Egnatia Research & Management. All rights reserved