20 Nov 2001, 11:10 UTC
Utilities Biweekly Report
- From
- Energy" @ENRON energy@1stgmc.net
- Date
- Tue, 20 Nov 2001 03:10:25 -0800 (PST)
Utilities Biweekly Report A news service for energy professionals November 20, 2001 To Remove, Substitute or Add an email address to our list, please send brief message to msid@ieee.org Electricity Restructuring Gets Push From Republicans Republican members of the Energy and Air Quality Subcommittee of the House Energy and Commerce Committee have agreed with Subcommittee Chairman Joe Barton, R-Texas, that restructuring legislation should move forward now that Congress has a few more weeks in session. In an 8-2 vote last week, Republican Committee members decided to continue drafting electricity restructuring legislation. Electricity restructuring provisions were excluded from the energy bill approved by the House earlier this year. The issue was to be readdressed in the fall but was delayed due to the events on September 11th. No action has been taken to date in the Senate. Green Mountain Energy Expands Into Ohio's Restructured Market Green Mountain Energy Company has entered into an agreement with the Northeast Ohio Public Energy Council (NOPEC) to service northeastern Ohio with solar and wind-generated electricity. NOPEC was formed last year under Ohio's utility deregulation statute Senate Bill 3, which allows local governments to serve as aggregators for electricity customers. NOPEC consists of 100 local communities with approximately 500,000 energy customers. Under the agreement, Green Mountain Energy will construct a 25-kilowatt solar array at Lake Farmpark in Kirtland, Ohio, and will conduct a study to determine the feasibility of siting a wind generating facility in Ohio. The Green Mountain Energy solar array will be the largest in the state and the first commercial solar array in Ohio built for the competitive market. The proposed wind study will be the first commercial wind analysis executed solely for the competitive market. Debate Over Deregulation Impacts in Oklahoma Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) has reported, in a first-of-its kind study, that restructuring Oklahoma's electric industry can benefit consumers, but problems and potential pitfalls do exist. The report has been met with some opposition however. Pete Churchwell, president of Oklahoma's second largest electric utility AEP/PSO, stated on November 16th that he does not support the study's findings, one of which indicates that Oklahoma's energy costs could rise between 5 and 25 percent if the retail electricity market is opened to competition. The study results indicate that lower electric prices may be available in the short term, but restructuring will ultimately bring higher prices. Under the state's restructuring plan, existing generating plants will have a competitive advantage over new plants. This advantage will result in higher prices in the long term because newer, higher-cost plants may be forced out of the marketplace. Churchwell contests that it is too early to know for certain how consumer rates will react in a deregulated market. While admitting that the nation's grid was not designed for retail competition, Churchwell said that improvements in state transmission systems would allow a successful retail competitive market. Utility still looks to be freed of generators Clark Public Utilities has been trying in vain for two months to unload some of the 50 portable generators that have become a multimillion-dollar white elephant. The units, wired in rows near the River Road Generating Plant, were leased for a year for $19.5 million. The deal was signed with General Electric early this year, at a time when there were dire predictions about this summer's power supply. In addition to the equipment lease, there is a $15 million natural gas contract to power the generators and a roughly $12 million expense to transport the gas. While Clark has been able to resell some of the gas at a loss, the transportation costs can't be recouped. For weeks, electricity on the open market has been much cheaper than that produced by the generators. In place since July, the generators, each producing 1 megawatt of power, have run for just 39 days. Electricity prices have plunged, from a high of $325 per megawatt-hour this summer to less than $30 today. The price has to be about $95 to make operating the generators feasible. So utility officials have had no choice but to let them sit idle. In September, the net expense for the generator farm gas, generator lease and so on was $3.5 million. For no electricity. Utility officials have tried to get GE to find customers for at least some of the generators. Tuesday morning, Andy Huck, Clark's operations director, said he had heard from GE about a "pretty serious inquiry" for two generators for two months. And that, he said, "is the best inquiry they've had so far." Now, utility officials are trying to decide whether to keep spending $62,000 a month for three GE employees and other expenses associated with maintaining the generators. The theory is that the equipment should be tested, a few at a time, to ensure they will be ready if needed. "They told me the generators need to be 'exercised,'" said Huck. "I told them they spent two months on a ship without being started." The units were built in Austria. GE, with a signed one-year lease in hand, has little incentive to find customers for the equipment, particularly when the company could presumably lease other generators from its inventory. "They say it's because we're such good client" that an effort has been made to find other users for the generators, said Huck. Clark's $120 million River Road generating plant features a giant GE turbine. Clark officials don't hold out much hope of getting out from under the generator lease expense, which runs about $1.3 million per month. "Where would they go?" asked Jim Sanders, Clark's director of energy resources. Meanwhile, the natural gas supply for the equipment is being resold at about half what it cost the utility. Gas prices also have fallen since the supply deal was inked. At their regular Tuesday meeting, utility commissioners decided to proceed with a $100 million bond sale that includes money to pay for the generator lease. In March, Rick Dyer, Clark's finance director, recommended that the utility cut a deal for a one-year, $100 million "bond anticipation note." The arrangement was made on the assumption that interest rates would fall in a few months, which they have to 1961 levels. The move Tuesday gave Dyer and utility General Manager Wayne Nelson the OK to approve a bond sale of up to 15 years at 6 percent interest although 5 percent or less is more likely, and the goal is a 10-year term, officials said. The bond sale likely will occur in the first week of December. The bulk of the $100 million borrowing is to cover a $63 million power purchase from Kaiser Aluminum. The deal, like the generator lease, was for power to cover an August-September gap in Clark's power supply, before the start of a Bonneville Power Administration contract. That Kaiser purchase was at $325 a megawatt-hour. The utility lost a bid to have a federal judge declare the price exorbitant and order a partial refund. AEP, Reliant Named as Last Resort Providers in Texas The Texas Public Utility Commission (PUC) has named American Electric Power (AEP) and Reliant Resources affiliates "providers of last resort" (POLR) for residential and small-commercial customers in all or part of 96 counties within TXU Electric's service area. The POLR becomes the electricity provider for customers who have been dropped by their past provider due to payment problems or if their provider has discontinued service in their s area. AEP and Reliant will offer a retail price that is expected to be 30-34 percent higher than base rates in the area taking effect January 1, 2002. By becoming the POLR, AEP and Reliant will acquire an additional 2 million Dallas-area customers and an expected 1-20 percent load increase. Due to the higher costs associated with such an increased load the PUC was agreeable to the higher rate. Consumer groups are opposing the higher rates, saying that low-income consumers will be unfairly hurt. Although many low-income consumers will qualify for a 10 percent discount advocates are arguing that POLR rates should equal the regular rates. Studies Show Changing Consumer Views Towards Deregulation A recent study by Deloitte and Touche Energy Resources Group finds that consumers are less aware of deregulation in the electric industry and more wary of its potential benefits. The survey considered the opinions of 657 consumers nationwide and found that the number of consumers who are aware of changes in retail electric markets has dropped to 39.7 percent, compared with 50.5 percent in 2000. This is a reversal in a five-year trend of increasing consumer awareness on deregulation. Analysts cited the terrorist attacks and the lack of federal legislation or debate on deregulation as reasons for the change. The survey also found that more consumers expect electric rates to increase with deregulation. Deloitte and Touche's Brank Terzi reports that a third of consumers expect no benefit from competition, while 26 percent expect prices to go down, 9 percent expect improved service, and 15 percent simply "don't know." Another study completed by RKS Research and Consulting similarly found that many consumers feel that "deregulation has been a colossal failure." Their study found that many consumers who have switched to new service providers have been disappointed because their service expectations were not met. RKS Senior Vice President Carmine Grastataro said, "customers of public power are more satisfied with the job their utility is doing than are customers of the IOUs. Although this finding has historically remained true, the difference in performance scores between public power and IOUs is exacerbated in states where competition is under way." The study also found that consumers are more interested in purchasing power through buying groups, voluntary energy curtailment programs, and on-site generation. FERC Postpones December 15 RTO Deadline The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) has officially decided to postpone the December 15, 2001, deadline for utilities to create four regional transmission organizations (RTO). FERC Chairman Pat Wood said of the decision, "RTO development is in very different stages in various parts of the country, and it is not possible for all RTOs to be in operation by the December 15, 2001, deadline established in Order 2000." The commission has approved a rulemaking order, RM01-12, that addresses the development of RTOs in several steps. First, the Commission will develop a broader definition of the expected functions of an RTO and how they can be achieved. Second, FERC will seek improved input and communication from both state and federal agencies on RTO development. Third, FERC will conduct a formal cost benefit analysis of RTO systems. This comes in response to two conflicting studies: NY ISO reports that a large Northeast RTO could cause power rates to increase by $90 million, while Mirant contends that a Northeast RTO could save consumers $440 million. The rulemaking also calls for FERC to determine areas in which standardization can be improved. Lastly, a new "progressive" timeline will be developed that addresses RTO development in a region-by-region approach. While Chairman Wood said that the commission is holding to its original concept of four RTOs, he also noted that the new order suggests that three smaller RTOs may be developed within the Western region. These transmission groups would include RTO West, Desert Star RTO, and one based on the California ISO. The rulemaking also makes a call for comments in what Commissioner Nora Brownell noted as possibly the last opportunity for market participants and state regulators to make suggestions and raise concerns before final orders are issued. Ontario deregulation in doubt The planned deregulation of the $35-billion Ontario electricity sector has been thrown in doubt by a radical proposal that would shackle the province's electricity transmission company, preventing it from becoming a significant player in an open North American power market. The plan, known only to Ontario Premier Mike Harris and a few government and Bay Street insiders, would turn Hydro One into a not-for-profit entity instead of a fully commercial, privatized company. If this happens, Hydro One would lack the flexibility to raise equity capital, make acquisitions and form partnerships in an effort to become one of continent's premier transmission companies -- a goal plainly set out by chief executive officer Eleanor Clitheroe. David Lindsay, the president and chief executive officer of Ontario SuperBuild Corp., the government's privatization adviser, confirmed that turning Hydro One into a not-for-profit organization, similar to Nav Canada, the civil air navigation service, is under serious consideration. "We've been asked to evaluate all options for Hydro One's future, including this one," he said yesterday. He would not provide details, though it is thought that the government wants to make a decision on Hydro One's future ownership structure by the conclusion of the year. A senior official in the Ontario government, who did not want to be identified, said the proposal "is a step backward to the old days of Ontario Hydro." He was referring to the debt-laden utility that was split into Ontario Power Generation, the electricity generating arm, and Hydro One, whose network of high-voltage transmission lines spans 30,000 kilometres. The Premier's office would not comment. A spokeswoman for Energy Minister Jim Wilson would say only that "there are a number of options on the table." Sources on Bay Street and at Queen's Park said the idea of turning Hydro One into a not-for-profit entity is being propelled by Anthony Fell, the chairman of Royal Bank-owned RBC Dominion Securities, Bay Street's largest dealer. If the new Hydro One took this shape, it would raise about $10-billion through the sale of bonds to investors. The dealers' commission on the sale of the bonds, which would rank among the biggest debt issues in history, would range from $25-million to $40-million, one Bay Street executive said. Mr. Harris is said to be keen on the concept partly because all the money would go back to the government to help pay down the $21-billion in "stranded debt" racked up by the old Ontario Hydro. The generating and transmission giant's decades-long spending spree on nuclear plants and other assets tore a huge hole in the province's balance sheet. Hydro One's cash flow, derived from sales to electricity users, would be used to pay the interest on the $10-billion of bonds. Presumably, consumers would face higher electricity charges if Hydro One lacked sufficient cash to pay the interest. If Hydro One were a private company instead, its financial risk would be borne by shareholders, not ratepayers. The United States has embraced deregulation partly because it shifts the financial risk of the electricity market from taxpayers to shareholders. Executives at RBC Dominion declined to comment on the plan, citing client confidentiality concerns. Mr. Fell first proposed it to the government in the spring. The government wants to open up the Ontario electricity market, in which buyers and sellers can negotiate prices, by next spring. The market overhaul contemplated turning Ontario Power Generation and Hydro One, both of which are 100 per cent owned by the government, into commercial companies. In Hydro One's case, the leading options were thought to be an outright sale, in which the utility would be bought by another company (presumably a rival utility), or an initial public offering, where the shares would be owned by private investors and traded on the stock exchange. The third option -- converting Hydro One into a not-for-profit organization -- has come as a surprise. There has been no debate on this option, though rumours of its existence have jolted Bay Street and Hydro One, both of which were working on the assumption that the transmission business would eventually become a commercial enterprise. Sources said that Hydro One management opposes the not-for-profit structure because it would deny Hydro One the flexibility and discipline of a typical commercial business. The not-for-profit structure would mean it would not have to pay taxes, which raises potential trade issues with the United States. American transmission companies might argue that Hydro One's non-taxable status gives it an unfair competitive advantage. It would also deny Hydro One management the benefit of potentially lucrative share options. Rod Taylor, Hydro One's executive vice-president, would not comment on the not-for-profitoption being contemplated by the government. He said, however, that the company's strategy hinges on its ability to become a major player in the deregulated North American electricity market. "Our vision of the company is to become a fully commercial entity, and become in the transmission sector what Canadian National is to the rail sector," he said in a phone interview. Stanley Hartt, the chairman of the Canadian office of Wall Street's Salomon Smith Barney, is among the Bay Street executives who opposes a not-for-profit structure for Hydro One (Salomon has a small role as an adviser to Hydro One's strategic business plan). In a three-page letter sent this week to the top executives of several large power-using Ontario companies, he said that "this idea is short-sighted and bad for Ontario." He argued that "the absence of an equity component in the capital structure of the not-for-profit corporation essentially transfers the equity risk to the ratepayers." He also said that, without financial flexibility, Hydro One would lack the resources to invest in "new bottleneck-eliminating connections" that would allow the company to become a significant electricity exporter. "Ontario would lose the prospect of becoming a true hub for North American Energy transmission," he said. In a recent report on the power industry, TD Newcrest analyst David McCracken wrote, "With its operating expertise and strong balance sheet, Hydro One is well positioned to act as a consolidator of transmission grids in the northern United States, where ownership tends to be fragmented." He noted that Hydro One is expected to be privatized in the next few years, and he said the utility has "the opportunity to lever strengths from traditional wires businesses into competitive high-growth initiatives." According to sources familiar with the not-for-profit proposal, Hydro One would be governed in the best interests of all electricity users by stocking the board of directors with appointees from corporations that are heavy power users, such as auto and steel makers and paper companies. Such a structure exists at Nav Canada, with airline executives on the board, and the company has been able to cut the fees it charges customers. Restructuring Hydro One with debt, rather than equity, is also presented as the most efficient way to capitalize the company. "The problem with a Canadian National Rail-style IPO is that equity is much more expensive than debt," said one financier familiar with the proposal. "With a debt-based structure, every dollar earned is available to pay interest, while an equity-based structure means you pay federal taxes, provide a return to shareholders and make debt payments." Dofasco Inc., the big Ontario steel producer that consumes about $100-million of electricity a year, supports the not-for-profit proposal. Gord Forstner, head of communications, said a bond sale would reduce Ontario Hydro's stranded debt by $10-billion immediately, paving the way for lower electricity charges. Currently, a special levy on all electricity bills is being used to whittle down the debt. The charge costs Dofasco alone about $15-million a year. "We want to see the stranded debt paid down first," Mr. Forstner said. "Until that happens, we don't favour Hydro One going to the expense of expanding outside of Ontario's boundaries." Retail Access Requested in California The Alliance for Retail Energy Markets (AReM) has asked the California Supreme Court to overturn the state Public Utilities Commission's September 20th decision that suspended direct retail access across the state. The consumer group, comprised of American Utility Network, the Alliance for Retail Energy Markets, California League of Food Processors, Western Power Trading Forum, Strategic Energy, AB&I Foundry, Tricon Global Restaurants and School Project for Utility Rate Reduction, has argued that the ruling was made without due process and that the Court had no right to abrogate contracts retroactively. "It is our hope that the Supreme Court recognizes the PUC has acted in complete disregard of our constitutional rights and has rushed to judgment on this issue, without hearings and without creating a proper evidentiary record," said AReM Attorney Dan Douglass. PUC Commissioner Carl Wood has maintained that the PUC issued the order because it believed that consumers have hastily signed contracts with competitive suppliers, leaving fewer customers to pay for the state's wholesale power costs. AReM is disputing the claim, saying that only a limited number of customers switched suppliers during the summer of 2001. Plant Construction Influences Florida's Wholesale Market California based Calpine Corporation announced that it has begun construction of a 530 megawatt power plant in Auburndale, Florida. The construction brings Florida closer to deregulation, as Calpine is one of the few out-of-state generating companies to successfully penetrate Florida's wholesale electricity market. Other companies, such as Enron, have attempted to construct new power plants in the state, but have been unsuccessful due to community and regulatory resistance. Florida's stringent Power Plant Siting Act makes it very difficult for out-of-state companies to enter the market. Calpine has succeeded by agreeing to sell the output from the Auburndale plant under a long-term contract to one of Florida's existing utilities, Seminole Electric Cooperative. In addition, Calpine has been working with the Florida Partnership for Affordable Competitive Electricity to persuade lawmakers and Governor Bush to deregulate Florida's wholesale market. Florida's Energy 2020 Study Commission, which is responsible for the state's competition plan, has endorsed a proposal to allow out-of-state companies to enter Florida's wholesale market by building new plants and selling power to the state's incumbent utilities. The Commission has also suggested eliminating the power of state government to approve power plant development and limiting the ability of local governments to block projects. The Commission is expected to issue a final report on December 1, 2001. Florida PSC Approves Independent Power Line Operations The Florida Public Service Commission (PSC) has approved the transfer of the state's power lines from utility jurisdiction to an independent company. The PSC has asked Florida's three main utilities, Florida Power and Light (FPL), Florida and Power Corporation, and Tampa Electric, to devise a proposal within 90 days that will turn over operation of the power lines to an independent system operator. Commissioner Michael A. Palecki said that the decision was made in the best interest for ratepayers, utility companies and independent power companies seeking a competitive market. Under an earlier proposal submitted to the PSC, the utilities proposed a statewide regional transmission organization, GridFlorida, that would have owned and managed the power lines. The PSC did not approve the plan, as it would have moved jurisdiction of retail rates to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission. New England Congressmen Seek Equal Representation on RTO Board Twenty-three U.S. congressmen from New England requested that their states be given adequate representation on the governance of the Northeast Regional Transmission Organization (RTO.) In an effort organized by Representative Edward Markey (D-Mass), the bipartisan delegation of congressmen wrote a letter to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) asking the regulators to create a governing board comprised of equal numbers of representatives from New England, New York, and the Mid-Atlantic. "We view an equally balanced governance structure as the only way in which a single market design can be implemented which would truly benefit the consumers of all the regions," Markey said. FERC has been considering several options for structuring the board that will oversee the unified Northeast wholesale power market. One proposal gives five seats for representatives from the Mid-Atlantic, three seats to New York, and two to New England. ISO New England and New York Independent System Operator joined the congressman in opposing that plan and requesting equal representation. California Wants Consumers to See Real Power Costs In a move that may prevent a repeat meltdown of the wholesale electricity market in California, the California Consumer Power and Financing Authority wants to install electricity meters that charge consumers the real cost of power. Currently consumers pay the same price for electricity throughout the day even though the wholesale price varies every hour. Therefore, consumers have no incentive to conserve during peak times. The meters will charge residential consumers more for power used during peak hours, when demand is highest and less during off peak times. The authority issued requests for proposals, due by November 15, for a minimum of 10,000 real-time meters, the cost of which varies between $200 and $1,000. The power authority plans to finance the purchase of the meters and will market them to customers of Pacific Gas & Electric, Southern California Edison, San Diego Gas & Electric and dozens of municipal utilities. As consumers have shown to be responsive to price signals in a pilot program in Washington, Californians too can expect to reduce their energy consumption. Project manger, Kevin Wood of Southern California Edison hopes his company will install meters for 11,000 customers by next summer. He said that if these customers, who represent 20 to 30 percent of the load, respond to price signals during peak hours, this may in turn drive down wholesale prices for all users. While consumers may benefit, the decrease in consumption may cost power generators millions of dollars in revenue. Environmentalists and Union Coalition Oppose Deregulation in Indiana A coalition of union members from several groups showed their opposition to electric utility deregulation in Indiana during a peaceful demonstration on November 7. The coalition, know as People's Energy Campaign, includes members from UNITE Local 399, formerly the Ladies Garment Workers Union, the Central Labor Council, Valley Watch environmental group, and the Citizens Action Coalition. Denny Owen, an executive board member of UNITE Local 399, expressed the general concern of the coalition that deregulation should be discouraged. "We don't think it'll make prices lower, it'll make them go higher," Owen said. Indiana is considered to have low utility rates compared to other states. Indiana lawmakers are considering deregulation as newly introduced legislation proposes to create an Energy Policy Commission that would craft a comprehensive energy plan for the state. Senator Gard and other General Assembly members created the bill to address the state's need for a true energy policy and as a means to address future electric load growth. "Merchant power plants have been a divisive issue in the past year and a half," Gard said. "There are many people who feel if the state has a comprehensive energy policy, it might be better able to deal with this issue. And we also have to pay attention to what's happened in California." The bill would set up a temporary commission with appointed members representing various stakeholder groups including state government, industry, labor, and environmental groups. The commission is scheduled to present a final report to the governor in December 2002. While electric deregulation would not be a prime focus of the commission, the "specter of deregulation" would have to be examined in some fashion, Senator Gard said. SB 233 has been sent to the Senate Rules and Legislative Procedures Committee. Senator Gard predicts it will pass the Senate, although chances in the House of Representatives are less favorable. Debate Over Oklahoma Transmission System's Readiness to Serve Future Load The Electric Restructuring Advisory Committee met with industry officials on November 7 to discuss the future capabilities of Oklahoma's transmission system. The committee is responsible for researching the capabilities of the system, determining whether upgrades are necessary, and delegating the responsibility for paying for such upgrades. With new power plants being developed and proposals to open the state to a competitive electric market in progress, concern has risen as to whether the transmission system can handle the increased load. Stanton Hadley of Oak Ridge National Laboratory reported that electricity demand in Oklahoma is expected to grow 26 percent, to 14,350 megawatts by 2010. The transmission system currently is able to handle only 13,300 megawatts. Nevertheless, power companies are planning 13,500 megawatts of new power generation. Calpine Corporation is spending about $20 million on transmission improvements between its power plant near Coweta, Oklahoma, and the outlying region. Also, Public Service Company of Oklahoma plans to spend $40 million on transmission upgrades over the next few years. With the new power plants and a supply surplus expected, Hadley also said that consumers could expect lower costs. John Wright, one of the committee members questioning this assumption, said that in a deregulated market, the utilities are likely to sell their power out of state. If this were to occur, lower power prices would be unlikely. The Electric Restructuring Advisory Committee will deliver a report to the Legislature at the end of the year. Thirty New Power Plants Proposed for Virginia The latest news out of the deregulation of Virginia's electric power industry centers around thirty proposals for new power plants in the state. While the surge in supply is expected to prevent a California-like energy crisis, health and environmentalists argue that the air pollution and smog from the plants could damage the state's parks and forests. Since 1998, when the state announced its plans to open its energy markets to competition, 30 companies and utilities have asked for state approval to build new plants. Activists complain that the new power would not even benefit Virginia's customers, as the energy is intended for delivery in northeastern states. By building plants in Virginia, utilities avoid the Northeast's stringent environmental regulations. An advisory group composed of utility and industry representatives argues that new plants pose no significant risk. They stated that 28 of the new plants would run on cleaner-burning natural gas and that other federal regulations would require older plants to reduce harmful emissions by 65 percent by 2004. The representatives also expect that only a few of the plants will actually be built due to market conditions and cooling-water shortages. Copyright ? 2001 Egnatia Research & Management. All rights reserved