17 Oct 2001, 01:45 UTC
Utilities Biweekly Report
- From
- Energy" @ENRON energy@1stgmc.net
- Date
- Tue, 16 Oct 2001 18:45:34 -0700 (PDT)
Utilities Biweekly Report A news service for energy professionals October 17, 2001 To Remove, Substitute or Add an email address to our list, please send brief message to msid@ieee.org FERC Rejects Reasons for Suppliers Higher Prices In an order issued on October 5, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) rejected the cost justifications of several power suppliers that sold wholesale electricity above the proxy market-clearing price during July 2001. The electricity had been sold into the California Independent System Operator (CA-ISO) and Western Systems Coordinating Council (WSCC). FERC said that the justifications from Dynegy, Reliant Energy, Mirant, and Williams Energy were "either untimely filed and/or unsupported" and has ordered refunds on those transactions. The four suppliers submitted their cost justifications in compliance with FERC's April 26 order that established price mitigation for sales into the CA-ISO's spot markets starting in late May. That order required power suppliers and generators who submitted bids above the market-clearing price to file a justification for the higher prices within seven days of the end of the month in which the sale occurred. FERC did not disclose how much money would be refunded since the four companies requested that the matter be treated confidentially. In a separate case, FERC Administrative Law Judge Bruce Birchman has until March 8 to issue a report on whether California is entitled to refunds of nearly $9 billion for wholesale power purchases when prices skyrocketed in the past year. The report's recommendations will be considered by FERC commissioners for further action. Nuclear plant had long list of failings Inexperience, sloppy work habits and poor maintenance increased the chances of dangerous accidents at the Bruce nuclear power station in Ontario, the world's largest atomic facility, says a secret report obtained by The Globe and Mail. The report was compiled in 1998 by a group of highly trained, independent nuclear experts from the World Association of Nuclear Operators (WANO), an industry advisory group based in Atlanta. It was given to Ontario Power Generation, the provincially owned utility, the following year. Among its findings: Some operators were unaware of such important topics as the time it would take for water in reactors to begin boiling away if flows of cooling water were blocked. Nuclear-plant operators disconnected warning alarms they found too noisy. Operators sometimes did not watch instrument control panels, but had their backs turned to them, which could slow any response to a problem. "Should an inadvertent loss of primary heat transport coolant occur, operator response could be delayed, resulting in a loss of core cooling." More than 2,500 nuclear-plant modifications were not incorporated into design manuals, leading to confusion about how the plant actually runs. There was a backlog in preventive and corrective maintenance and some maintenance work was poorly done. WANO tried to block The Globe's access to the report, which listed dozens of other sloppy practices at the Bruce facility, and a second related report that found troubling safety lapses at the Pickering nuclear station. But the organization recently abandoned a court challenge seeking to have the documents remain confidential. It is the first time WANO reports assessing the performance of nuclear plants have been publicly released anywhere in the world. A Bruce station official said its performance has improved dramatically since the critical report was written. WANO now considers Bruce "one of the fastest improving nuclear plants in North America," said Duncan Hawthorne, chief executive officer at the site. One nuclear energy critic said concerns raised in the report about possible loss of cooling -- an interruption in the flow of water that keeps a reactor from overheating -- describes an event that could cause a serious mishap by allowing unwanted nuclear chain reactions. "It could result in some form of criticality accident, which could eventually lead to a meltdown," said David Martin, a nuclear safety consultant with the Sierra Club of Canada. The Globe and Mail requested the reports under Ontario's freedom of information act in 1999. Both Ontario Power and WANO opposed the releases. Ontario Power argued that public knowledge of the reports would jeopardize its finances and increase the cost of its liability insurance. The government utility completed a long-term agreement leasing the Bruce facility, located on the shores of Lake Huron, to a unit of British Energy earlier this year. WANO, in seeking to keep the records secret, asserted nuclear safety is enhanced if the public is kept in the dark about its findings because nuclear staff are more likely to be honest about mistakes if their remarks are kept confidential. But Ontario's Information and Privacy Commissioner ruled last year there was a "compelling interest" for the public to have the nuclear-safety information. Shortly after the newspaper made its request for the records, the Ontario government changed its information law to exempt provincially owned electricity companies from the act, blocking future public access to these safety reports. The WANO reports, known as peer reviews, were viewed at the highest level of the utility, with copies sent to Ronald Osborne, Ontario Power's president. During WANO reviews, a team of nuclear experts scours the plant, looking for sloppy work practices, poor maintenance and inadequate training, while also trying to discover the causes of these failings. At the Bruce plant, WANO officials reviewed four of the eight reactors. The officials found the failure to keep accurate designs at the station, known as Bruce B, helped create confusion over three unplanned reactor shutdowns in 1997 that were caused by the triggering of automatic safety systems. Operators had a hard time figuring out why the shutdowns happened because the designs showed wiring layouts from the wrong nuclear stations. The report also noted that 10 forced reactor shutdowns were caused by equipment problems. These have arisen because the station had a "large and increasing backlog" in preventive and corrective maintenance tasks. Staff also conducted incompetent maintenance work. In one case, a pump needing an overhaul was taken from service, but it was later discovered that the spare parts for this work were unavailable. "The pump was subsequently returned to service without undergoing the associated maintenance," the report said. I1998, there were about 4,000 corrective maintenance tasks at the station. Mr. Hawthorne said that total is now less than 200, reflecting the plant's improving performance. However, there was a backlog of about 1,000 preventive maintenance tasks in 1998, a figure that has since grown to 1,200. Mr. Hawthorne said the total of preventive jobs is considered normal within the industry. Barton Adds Supports for FERC Authority and RTOs Senate Energy and Air Quality Subcommittee Chairman Joe Barton (R-TX) has revised his draft electricity bill to support the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission's (FERC) proposed requirement that forces utilities to participate in regional transmission organizations (RTOs). The proposal requires that all transmitting utilities form or participate in an RTO within 18 months. Barton's draft bill also gives additional authority to FERC by allowing the commission to propose changes to applications if minimum standards are not met. Utilities would have the right to appeal FERC's decision to the federal courts. While FERC is pushing for the creation of four RTOs, Barton's draft bill does not recommend a specific number of RTOs. The revised legislation requires a 40,000 MW generation minimum from any new RTO. This requirement was added to minimize the amount of inter-RTO transmission problems. The bill includes an incentive rate provision which opponents claim would undermine FERC's authority to determine just and reasonable rates. Proponents argue that incentive rates are necessary to account for the inherent risks that transmission companies face. FERC's Public Access Rulemaking is Questioned A Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) proposed rulemaking on public access of informational filings is generating mixed reactions. FERC is proposing that utilities and power marketers electronically file an "index of customers" on a quarterly basis with a summary of the contractual terms and conditions for market-based power sales, cost-based power sales, and transmission services. The proposed rule would require that the information be posted on a publicly available Internet website. State regulators see FERC's July rulemaking proposal as an opportunity to improve regulatory oversight of competitive markets. The National Association of Regulatory Utility Commissioners (NARUC) applauds the proposal, stating, "One of the most important and formidable tools in market monitoring is access to data that is readily available and useful to the public." However, utilities are warning FERC that making such "proprietary and commercially sensitive information" available to the public "could be harmful to the development of robust electricity markets." The Edison Electric Institute's Alliance of Energy Suppliers is requesting that FERC defer action on the rulemaking. Debate Over Use of PJM as Model for Northeast RTO Wholesale suppliers and the PJM Interconnection have recommended that PJM's market design and governance structure be used as a model for a Northeast regional transmission organization (RTO). They believe that using the PJM model would facilitate the quickest transition from the current system of independent system operators (ISOs) to one large RTO. Duke Energy North America reported to Platts Electric Power Daily that "The PJM market-building philosophy of cautious, incremental, modular building blocks which emphasizes market-driven solutions rather than command-and-control decision and frequent market interventions has worked far better than approaches taken in either New York or New England." Administrative Law Judge Peter Young recommended on September 17, 2001 to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) that PJM be used as a starting point. Young proposed an RTO plan that would have an operational RTO within 36 months of the FERC order. His recommendations resulted from the July 2001 mediation talks that discussed the creation of a Northeast RTO. FERC has since asked for comments regarding Young's plan. Enron and PJM contend that an RTO could be operational within one year if FERC acts expeditiously. New York ISO and New England ISO argue that FERC should consider another approach because using PJM as a model would ignore geographic and philosophic differences. The PJM utilities do not have divested generating assets, as do the two regions not covered by PJM. The ISOs also pointed out that PJM does not contain so-called load centers like New York City or Boston. Support for Delay in Arkansas' Deregulation Entergy, Arkansas' largest electric utility, has agreed with State Attorney General Mark Pryor to support a delay in the state's restructuring efforts. An amended restructuring statute in effect as of April 2001 pushed back the start date of deregulation to October, 2003. The Public Service Commission (PSC) was given the authority to delay deregulation further until 2005 if necessary to ensure that deregulation will benefit consumers. Several concerns still exist, according to local sources. A study by La Capra Associates showed that Arkansas consumers might experience higher, more volatile electric rates if the retail market is deregulated before October 2005. The study also reports that wholesale electric markets and operating electronic systems haven't developed, both are necessary for successful retail market competition. Entergy's President, Hugh McDonald, has also expressed concern that the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission's (FERC) push to create four regional transmission organizations (RTOs) may slow the move to retail competition. Additionally, State Attorney General Pryor has noted that two utilities serving the Arkansas market are experiencing difficulty meeting the January 2002 deregulation deadline in Texas. The governor, PSC, and the Arkansas Electric Cooperative Corporation consider repeal of deregulation to be the best choice for consumers. Entergy believes repeal is unnecessary and that delaying until 2005 will cause no harm to consumers. A PSC hearing on the topic is set for October 18, 2001. Entergy seeks deregulation delay in Texas Texas is experiencing a less than seamless transition to a competitive retail electric market. Entergy Corp. has asked the Public Utility Commission of Texas (PUC) to delay deregulation in the Southeast Texas service area for 8 ? months, transmission congestion is costing some Texas utilities millions of dollars, and reports show that Texas consumers have been subject to "slamming" (switching utility providers without their consent.) Entergy's request is a turnaround from the corporation's announcement in September that deregulation should move forward and that it was ready to move into a competitive marketplace. The corporation has now filed a memorandum along with the PUC staff, an industrial electricity users group, and the Office of the Public Utility Council, asking the PUC to delay deregulation for 8 ? months. Entergy's spokesperson says that the request stems from the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission's and Entergy's inability to come to consensus on an independent regional transmission operator. Problems For Texas on the Path To Deregulation Municipally-owned Austin Energy is among a group of Texas utilities that have experienced rising costs in a deregulated energy market. Their agreement to share transmission costs across the state for generated electricity is costing more than anticipated. The PUC and the Electric Reliability Council of Texas (ERCOT) estimated last year that a state program designed to ensure that enough electricity can move around the state during peak periods would cost utilities $20 million in the year starting July 31, 2001. Since each utility's share of the cost is based on its use of the grid, Austin Energy expected its 4 percent share to be $800,000 for the first year. However, Austin Energy has already been billed approximately $2 million for the period between July 31 and September 21. North Carolina Regulators Oppose Southeastern RTO The North Carolina Utilities Commission (NCUC) has expressed opposition to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission's (FERC) move to create four regional transmission organizations (RTOs). In September, an administrative law judge reported on closed-door mediation discussions aimed at developing an RTO in the Southeast. NCUC considers the 45-day long talks illegal. FERC supports the creation of a Southeast RTO, reflecting RTO proposals submitted by GridSouth, GridFlorida, and Entergy. NCUC objects that "...FERC is now attempting to strip retail customers of all rights to existing transmission capacity and make it available...to relatively new entities, such as Independent Power Producers and marketers. This attempt must fail." NCUC says that it will take its case to court to prevent FERC from moving forward on this issue. "Slamming" reported in Texas pilot program Problems arising from Texas' move towards a competitive retail electric market have also spread to the consumers. Under the state's pilot project, 5 percent of the market was opened to competition, allowing companies to compete for consumers by offering lower prices and different service plans. The Texas deregulation law strictly prohibits "slamming," electric providers switching consumer's service without obtaining permission. New Power Company received at least 14 complaints about slamming; Green Mountain, Reliant, First Choice and Shell each received one "slamming" complaint. The Fort Worth Star-Telegram reported that 68 complaints have been filed between March 1, 2001 and September 27, 2001 concerning billing procedures, delays in the pilot project, customer service and deceptive trade practices. On one positive note for consumers, the PUC has published a consumer education brochure, "The Electricity Facts Label: What it is and How it Will Help You Shop for Electricity." The brochure will help consumers understand the new electricity labels that Retail Electric Providers (REPs) are required to provide when retail competition begins. The label gives information on electricity prices, contract terms, generation sources, and emissions in a standardized format. The labels are intended to help customers make informed decisions about choosing their electric service. Texas' Power Supply to Increase Two new developments in Texas are expected to increase power supply in the state. American Electric Power Co. (AEP) is currently seeking approval from the Public Utility Commission of Texas (PUC) to provide energy supply services to large commercial and industrial customers if deregulation begins in January 2002. AEP has a total of about 1 million customers in Texas with its three subsidiaries: Central Power and Light Co., West Texas Utilities and Southwestern Electric Power Co. The company expects the PUC to act within two to three months. In addition, Steag Power, the Houston-based unit of Germany-based electricity utility Steag AG, plans to develop a 900 MW to 1,200 MW gas-fired power station in Ennis, Texas. The company submitted its application to the Electric Reliabilty Council of Texas and the Southwest Power Pool. Construction is planned to begin next year and reach commercial operation by 2004. The plant will increase Texas' generating capacity and may help to relieve the state's congestion problem of transmitting power from south to north. New power plants, as well as new transmission lines, are needed in the north to ease congestion. Bingaman to Resume Work on Comprehensive Energy Bill Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee Chairman Jeff Bingaman (D-New Mexico) will resume consideration of a comprehensive energy bill the week of October 14. The bill includes provisions related to electricity restructuring, including expansion of the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission's (FERC) authority over municipal and cooperative utilities. The proposed legislation would also allow regional transmission organizations to rely on FERC to rule when transmission projects are delayed or rejected by state officials. Federal Trade Commission Issues Report on Electric Power Regulatory Reform A new report has been issued by the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) that examines state retail electricity programs and their ability to provide consumer benefits. Competition and Consumer Protection Perspectives on Electric Power Regulatory Reform: Focus on Retail Competition compares state and federal authority on competitive issues and implementation of successful retail competition programs. The FTC report finds that most electric markets are in a transitional phase. The benefits of a competitive market will not be realized until the advent of full competition, without price regulation, has been achieved. The report also explains that competitive wholesale markets must accompany competition in retail markets. The report notes, "... as wholesale and retail markets become regional, governing policies and jurisdictional approaches also must move in that direction for wholesale and retail competition to be successful." The FTC report also cites that artificially low "standard-offer rates," which are provided to customers who do not choose a new supplier, may act as a barrier for new retail suppliers. These low rates reduce the incentive for customers to seek alternative suppliers. The report urges retail suppliers to offer competitive metering and billing services in addition to variable pricing for generation services. Standardized labeling of power products and services, enforcement of truth-in-advertising laws, and consumer education efforts will help consumers make informed decisions. Supreme Court Hears Arguments on Open-Access Rules The Supreme Court heard arguments on Wednesday on Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) jurisdiction to regulate wholesale transmission services and power sales. The Court's ruling will have an important impact on the U.S. power market. It could either open the transmission grid to retail competition or limit competition to the retail level. As Dow Jones reports, "The case has great ramifications for congressional debate on electric industry restructuring legislation and FERC's ongoing efforts to promote competition as a surrogate for regulation." Nine states, led by New York, argued that FERC overstepped its authority with Order 888, that required utilities to open their transmission lines to competing power merchants. Lawrence Malone, general counsel for the group, argued that the order preempted state authority to regulate retail sales and set rates. In 1999, FERC carried the order further by mandating that utilities turn over control of their power lines to independent regional transmission organizations, or RTOs. The states are appealing the District of Columbia Court of Appeals decision in June 2000 that upheld FERC's orders. Currently, FERC is working to establish four RTOs to control the nation's transmission system. Meanwhile, Enron, the largest U.S. wholesale power player, argued that FERC violated federal law because it did not require access to transmission lines when utilities kept transmission and retail sales as one operation. This bundled service remains in many states where competition is not yet allowed. Caught in the middle, FERC argued that its orders were issued to achieve a balance between giving competitors equal access to power lines and leaving retail market issues to the states. FERC Chairman Unveils Plans Pat Wood, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission's new Chairman, has proposed a set of issues on which he wants the Commission to focus. At the Commission's September 26th meeting, Wood proposed the following for FERC's upcoming agenda: ensuring adequate generation capacity; transmission constraints; regional transmission organizations (RTOs); energy infrastructure; standards of conduct for transmission providers; market monitoring and enforcement; and market based rates. One important proposal unveiled at this meeting would mandate that transmission owning utilities be given until December 15, 2001, to join an approved RTO or lose their right to charge market based rates. Additionally, Wood recommended that mergers would only be approved for power entities belonging to operational RTOs. "Once the entire country is covered by RTOs," he said, "states will have the option to deregulate on the retail level or not." Wood also proposed a rulemaking on market design and structure in order to make a seamless national power marketplace. A new transmission tariff would replace the pro forma open access transmission tariff established by Order 888. Staff at FERC discussed changing the Commission's methodology for assessing market power for the purpose of approving market-based rate applications. While none of the proposals were voted on, the meeting was important for opening up discussion and addressing the Commission's key challenges and objectives for the coming year. A series of commissioner-led workshops will be held at FERC's headquarters from October 15-19, 2001. Congestion management, cost recovery, market monitoring, transmission planning, business and reliability standards, and the nature of transmission rights have been proposed for discussion at the workshops. Maryland and DC Blast FERC on RTO plan Both the Maryland and Washington DC public service commissions have expressed concern over the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission's (FERC) initiative to integrate the U.S. Northeast transmission network. In a new plan proposed by FERC Chairman Pat Wood, utilities would have to submit plans by December 15, 2001, to join a regional transmission organization (RTO) or lose the right to sell electricity in the wholesale market. Catherine Reilly, Chairman of the Maryland Public Utility Commission, is concerned about the plan's effect on the Northeast's economy and the potential for creating another California-type crisis. The Maryland Commission held hearings on RTOs in Baltimore on Wednesday and Thursday of this week. Southwest and Midwest Utilities Form Transmission Groups FERC's push for utilities to merge their networks into regional transmission organizations (RTOs) came one step closer to being realized this week. Six Southwestern utilities have signed an initial "Memorandum of Understanding" regarding the formation and operation of an RTO and plan to file with FERC by mid-October. The new RTO, WestConnect, will be created by Arizona Public Service Co., Salt River Project, El Paso Electric Co., Public Service Company of New Mexico, Tucson Electric Power Co., and Texas-New Mexico Power Co. In addition, six Midwestern utilities filed with FERC last Friday to create an independent, for-profit transmission company, TRANSLink. The utilities include Alliant Energy, Corn Belt Power Cooperative, MidAmerican Energy, Nebraska Public Power District, Xcel Energy, and Omaha Public Power District. "A for-profit entity, focused solely on the growth and enhancement of a robust transmission system over a large region, will be much more effective than either the current situation or transferring operational control to an independent system operator," said Wayne Brunetti, chairman, president, and CEO of Xcel Energy. The six companies have asked FERC to expedite their application so that TRANSLink can be formed by early next year. North Carolina's Restructuring Plans Still on Hold The North Carolina Study Commission on the Future of Electric Service has decided to place its restructuring deliberations on hold until early next year. Study Commission meetings were interrupted early in 2001 due to the length of the state legislative session, which occupied several Study Commission members. Members of the Commission have expressed concern about implementing electricity restructuring. Sen. Kay Hagan, D-Guilford, explained that, "I can't see us doing anything...There are so many people worried about...California." Hagan and Rep. Mary Jarrell, D-Guilford, also on the Commission, have urged North Carolina to take the steps necessary to avoid the same problems experienced in California. Neither legislator foresees the Study Commission resuming its deliberations until January 2002. Pennsylvania Retail Electricity Shopping Declines According to figures released last Tuesday by the Pennsylvania Office of Consumer Advocate, electricity retail shopping fell during the third quarter of 2001. The number of consumers buying from alternative suppliers dropped 8% from July 1st. This decline is less than the 32% drop that occurred between April and July; total electric load has declined by 10% since July. 337,918 or 6.4% of the customers in the state are buying 1,458 MW from other suppliers, or approximately 6% of the state's total load. Again, this is less than the 67% decline in electric load purchased from other suppliers that occurred between April and July. According to the Electric Power Daily Online, "Load fell more dramatically than customer participation in the spring because many of the expiring long-term contracts were held by large industrial and commercial customers." Pennsylvania opened its electricity market to competition in 1999. In April of 2000, 10% of the state residents chose alternative energy suppliers, subsequently, high gas prices and tight electric capacity drove up wholesale prices in the summer of 2000. Many alternative suppliers pulled out of the market, as they were unable to offer competitive prices. Participation in the retail electricity market has been declining since then. Texas' Electricity-Grid Operator Needs More Power Lines An annual report released on Monday by the Electric Reliability Council of Texas states that Texas needs more electricity transmission lines, raising concern as the state plans to open its electricity market to competition in January 2002. Without adequate transmission lines, congestion problems will likely arise and the flow of power may be interrupted. The report has identified six zones where more lines are needed to deliver power from south to north Texas and to bring electricity into the Dallas area. Eight major projects are being developed to address the problems and others are being considered. Copyright ? 2001 Egnatia Research & Management. All rights reserved