29 Jan 2002, 11:17 UTC
Utilities Biweekly Report
- From
- Energy" @ENRON energy@1stgmc.net
- Date
- Tue, 29 Jan 2002 03:17:12 -0800 (PST)
Utilities Biweekly Report A news service for energy professionals January 29, 2002 To Remove, Substitute or Add an email address to our list, please send brief message to msid@ieee.org Pepco to Supply Electricity in Maryland Beginning in July of this year, Pepco Energy Services will provide electricity to sixteen Maryland state agencies. The contract is worth nearly $65 million for 1.6 billion kilowatt-hours, to be provided over a two year period. Six percent of the total electricity supply will be generated from renewable resources. This award from the State of Maryland is the latest of $800 million worth of contracts for Pepco's services awarded within the last two years. New Mexico Passes Electric Energy Policy On January 8th, the New Mexico Public Regulation Commission (NMPRC) passed a resolution adopting a new electric energy policy for the state, despite the fact that the New Mexico legislature had earlier postponed deregulation until 2007. Principles of the NMPRC policy include requiring utilities to operate adequate distribution infrastructure, requesting an in-depth analysis of New Mexico's transmission system, redesigning retail rates, and considering alternative forms of regulation. Commission staff noted that "without legislative intervention to repeal the restructuring act, the commission's energy principles [can] be implemented only on a temporary basis." Seven New Power Plants for New Mexico Five power companies serving customers in New Mexico have committed to build seven new power plants in the state between now and the inception of deregulation. These seven plants are expected to generate 2,200 MW of new electricity supply. The power companies include Duke Energy, Public Service Company of New Mexico, Tri-State Generation and Transmission, Peabody Energy, and Cobisa Corporation, all of which have begun construction or are still in the planning stages. Exelon CEO Supports Continued Deregulation Efforts Speaking at an energy conference at the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago, Exelon co-CEO John Rowe said that the nation cannot return to the failed regulatory structures of the past. Referring to Enron's bankruptcy and California's energy crisis, Rowe noted that "The grand experiment has had some fairly substantial hiccups, [but] we can't go back to our grandfather's Oldsmobile." He also urged FERC to establish RTOs and disagreed with the agency's November decision to give up price setting responsibility for three large U.S. utilities. Deregulation ad campaign denounced The Ontario government will launch a $2.3-million series of television ads to publicize the arrival of competition in the electricity market, but the opposition denounces the campaign as "propaganda." "This isn't about public information; this is about brainwashing," NDP Leader Howard Hampton said yesterday. "It's just fundamentally wrong." Mr. Hampton said advertising industry sources told him the government was planning five different television spots to announce that private companies will be allowed to sell electricity to consumers starting May 1. The government responded that only one ad was produced, as part of a broader campaign to educate consumers about their choices under the new system. The brief piece resembles many of the other ads produced by the Progressive Conservative government, some of which have been criticized for trying to bolster public support for controversial policies. Soft-focus pictures of smiling people in everyday settings run underneath a voice track explaining why deregulation of Ontario's electricity is necessary. "As we grow, we're going to need more electricity," says the advertisement's voice-over. "And more companies generating electricity." "We're not trying to sell privatization," said Mike Krizanc, a spokesman for the Ministry of Energy, Science and Technology. He noted that the ads are part of an education campaign for which the government has handed out almost a million eight-page pamphlets about changes to the electricity system. Ministry officials are also holding public meetings around the province, particularly with seniors who might be confused about their new choices. "This is . . . a propaganda campaign to try to turn around public opinion," Mr. Hampton said. New Requirements for ESCOs in New York The New York State Public Service Commission has approved new financial requirements for energy service companies, or ESCOs. ESCOs doing business in New York will now have to meet a minimum bond rating from an independent rating agency before offering prepayment plans or requiring security deposits. ESCOs that do not earn the minimum rating will have to put security deposits in escrow or issue an irrevocable letter of credit; they will not be allowed to offer prepayment plans. PSC Chairwoman Maureen Helmer explained last week that, "the additional consumer protections balance key interests in the energy markets. Specifically, our administrative flexibility enables us to balance vital consumer interests with the interest in offering innovative competitive energy services." Problems in Texas Leave Customers Without Electricity Recent reports of pitfalls in Texas' newly deregulated electricity market note that some customers are being left without electricity for several days. Reportedly, deregulation is complicating the way that orders for new electricity service are placed and processed, in that consumers may select from a number of retail electricity providers (REPs) when they decide to order new service or switch to a different provider. After being notified by a customer, the provider must contact ERCOT, the Electric Reliability Council of Texas. ERCOT, which is responsible for managing the power grid, then notifies the current utility that its customer has opted to change service. Before January 1, 2002, only the regulated utility needed to be contacted; now there are three different entities involved with the change. The usual wait for a service change had been 24 to 48 hours. Now, it typically takes two to five days. The Houston Chronicle is reporting that one Houston family endured 10 days without electricity while waiting for power in their new apartment. Tom Noel, ERCOT's president and chief executive officer, explained that "we've traded off reduced rates for a little less convenience. In other words, in the past when there was a monopoly utility in this city, they [consumers] made one phone call, and that was the only party they needed to call." This issue had impacted enough consumers to cause the state's Public Utility Commission to place it on the agenda at last week's open meeting. Terry Hadley, a spokesman for the Austin-based commission, said that the delays are of concern to the commission and that it is looking to improve the process. Cost of Ontario Hydro subsidies revealed Fearful that competition would lead to sharply higher electricity prices, a group of Ontario industrial companies persuaded the province to give them a subsidy extension worth up to $197-million. Records on the size of the subsidy were obtained by Canadian newspaper "The Globe and Mail" through the freedom-of-information legislation. It is the first time the amount of the price break given by the Progressive Conservative government has been made public. The records also indicate that the Ministry of Energy viewed major electricity-consuming companies as hypocrites, because they publicly called for power-market competition while privately demanding a continuation of the subsidy that allows them to buy electricity at below-market prices. Big companies, such as Dofasco Inc., Bowater Pulp and Paper Canada Inc., and up to 79 other large electricity users, will continue to receive the subsidy when the Ontario electricity market opens for competition on May 1. The extension could last for up to four years. Subsidized power was first offered by Ontario Hydro in 1993, when the company was looking for ways to increase demand through what were termed "special rate" deals. Since then, about 7 per cent of Ontario's electricity has been covered by these deals, which were supposed to end when the electricity market was opened to competition. Companies receiving the subsidies would suddenly face price increases of up to 64 per cent, the records say. The cost of the subsidies will be carried by Ontario Power Generation, one of Ontario Hydro's successor companies, and Ontario Electricity Financial Corp., the body paying off Ontario Hydro's debts, according to the records. The documents show that senior executives at big companies began pressuring Premier Mike Harris, former finance minister Ernie Eves, and Energy Minister Jim Wilson in 1999, threatening that if the government didn't continue the subsidy, the company's investments in the province would be at risk. In June of 2000, cabinet approved continuing the subsidies through regulation, despite an assessment by the Ministry of Energy that said Ontario Power Generation could lose up to $190-million over four years, compared with selling the electricity at market prices. Ontario Electricity Financial Corp. would receive $7-million less in dividends over that period. "Price to Beat" Set in Virginia The Virginia State Corporation Commission announced this week that a "price to beat" electricity rate has been set as a benchmark for cost comparison in the state's developing deregulated electricity market. The rate will be reset on a yearly basis. Electricity suppliers wishing to compete in the market must offer service at a lower rate or provide a unique service such as a green power package. The actual price to compare for a particular customer will vary depending on usage and the rate schedule of the existing electric company, but the average price to compare is 3.3 cents per kilowatt-hour for residential customers. During the state's pilot customer choice program, some Virginia Power customers chose to switch to Dominion which charges between 4.35 cents and 4.97 cents per kilowatt-hour for electricity. At the time of the pilot, these rates were competitive with rates offered by other utilities serving customers in Virginia. The SCC is now cautioning those customers to reconsider their switch based on the new "price to beat" rate. A spokesman from Dominion said last week that the company has no immediate plans to lower its rates, but is pleased that new rates have been announced, stating, "We have a number we can shoot at. We welcome it." Customers who switch their electricity supplier in the new market must also consider the transition charge they must pay for the next 5 years. This charge was created to compensate utilities for losses on investments they made previously to serve those customers. Two licensed competitors, Old Mill Power Company and AES New Energy Incorporated, have requested that the charge be phased out. Some concern has been expressed that the low benchmark price makes it difficult for new retail electricity suppliers to enter the market. Eric Matheson, AES New Energy's director of new markets, is arguing that the low price makes it "impossible" for his company to compete with incumbent utilities in Virginia. Efforts to Deregulate Electricity Will Be Slowed A top DOE official told reporters this week that efforts to deregulate the electricity market in the United States will be slowed for years due to the collapse of Enron Corporation and the well-documented energy crisis in California. Vicky Bailey, Assistant Secretary for International Affairs and Domestic Policy, said that the ramifications of California's crisis and the fall of Enron could slow the progress of electricity deregulation for two to three years. She does not expect this to end further developments in deregulation throughout the country however. Bailey, a former Federal Energy Regulatory Commission member, believes that Enron's absence may hurt the industry's push toward deregulation, but competition will ultimately prevail. The restructuring issue she added is "larger than Enron" and too much progress has been made in support of restructuring to go back to regulated markets. Long Island Opens to Retail Competition The Long Island Power Authority (LIPA) has announced that is has completely opened the island's electricity market to retail competition under the LIChoice Program. This achievement is seven years ahead of the schedule imposed by the Public Authorities Control Board (PACB) in May 1998 and a year in advance of LIPA's own 2003 deadline. Under LIPA's retail competition program, three Energy Services Companies (ESCOs) have been certified to supply electricity to residential and commercial customers on Long Island. Currently, 38,039 residential and commercial customers receive approximately 220.4 MW of electricity from ConEd Solutions, NIMO Energy Marketing or KeySpan Energy Solutions. LIPA has invited the Suffolk County Electrical Agency (SCEA) to formally participate in the customer choice program as well and hopes it will sell as much electricity as it can obtain under its ESCO provisions. LIPA Chairman Richard M. Kessel hopes that these efforts will encourage more ESCOs to join the market. LIPA has also increased the Energy Bill Credit, or shopping credit, from 3.5 cents per kilowatt-hour to 4.5 cents per kilowatt-hour to further encourage competition within the market. This credit is equal to the cost of generation-related energy and capacity costs that LIPA avoids when an ESCO takes over provision of electric service. The funds derived from the credit are returned to the ESCO to help cover its generation costs. It is hoped that the increase will provide ESCOs with a greater incentive to supply competitively priced electricity to consumers. Retail deregulation in the state began in May 1998 when LIPA first reduced electric rates by an average of 20%, resulting in savings of $1.5 billion. LIChoice began its phased-in approach to deregulation in April 1999, followed by a second phase in May 2000. Florida Loses Interest In Deregulation Interest in a deregulated electricity marketplace in Florida has waned considerably over the past few months. Despite the findings of the Florida Energy 2020 Study Commission's December report that recommended initiation of a competitive wholesale market, little additional discussion has occurred, and the state Legislature is not expected to act on the recommendations in the report. The Orlando Sentinel reported last week that the Legislature has other, more critical issues on its agenda, including the recession, reapportionment, and the state's response to terrorism. Sanford Berg, a 2020 Commission member who directs the Public Utilities Research Center at the University of Florida, explained that the Legislature is preoccupied as well with congressional redistricting and the state's budget crisis. He also mentioned that the Energy Commission's report will require substantial analysis which the Legislature does not have time to do. The bankruptcy of Enron Corporation has also contributed to a lack of interest in deregulation. The company's collapse has caused stakeholders in Florida to question the ability of electricity generators and transmission and distribution companies to supply uninterrupted flows of power at an affordable price. Despite the lack of deregulation in Florida, the electricity market in the state appears to be stable and healthy. The state's large power companies are consistently profitable and have been able to adjust customer prices as compensation for investments in new generating plants and fluctuations in fuel costs. The utilities do not expect wide variations in fuel costs in the coming year and believe they have sufficient generating capacity to cover the demand for power. Creation of a regional transmission organization (RTO) to serve the state is not planned, regardless of collaborative efforts during 2001 to form a statewide RTO, Grid Florida. This plan has been stalled due to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission's preference for interstate RTOs. North Carolina Study Commission To Resume The Study Commission on the Future of Electric Service in North Carolina will resume on February 6, 2002. Deliberations on electric deregulation are not expected to take center stage; rather, the Commission's work to resolve the debt burden of several towns and cities will likely be the focus of discussion. In April 2000, the Commission approved a set of recommendations that included moving to a fee-market system for all power sales in the state by 2006. California's energy crisis, however, resulted in the Commission's design to delay these plans. Commission Co-Chairman Senator David Hoyle (D-Gaston) told reporters this week that the he does not expect the panel to make any major recommendations before legislators convene May 28th for the 2002 session. He also noted that the Commission is expecting updates from other states on their electricity deregulation activities and plans in addition to a report on available power supplies for the state's 4 million electric customers. Senator Kay Hagan (D-Guilford) agrees with Senator Hoyle and does not expect the Commission to move forward with deregulation plans. "This is so complex that it's not easy to even figure out what questions to ask," she said. North Carolina regulators are expected to closely follow electricity restructuring in the neighboring state of Virginia. Pennsylvania Utility Denies Market Manipulation PPL Corporation, headquartered in Allentown, Pennsylvania, has denied charges that it set artificially high prices for wholesale products in its service territory. The Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission (PUC) is investigating PPL in the aftermath of charges leveled at it from PJM Interconnection LLC, the wholesale market operator, and NewPower Holdings Incorporated. PPL claims that a "readily foreseeable increase in demand" resulted in price increases during the first quarter of 2001 rather than an effort to control prices. The PUC is interested in the case because these price control charges pose questions about the success of the state's deregulated electricity market. PJM required that electric companies under its jurisdiction have the ability to meet 119% of their expected demand. Therefore, PPL's high prices have a negative effect on competing electric companies, which often purchase supplemental generating capacity from the utility. NewPower, which serves 192,000 Pennsylvania customers, called last year's market prices "unjust and unreasonable." Other electric companies and consumer advocates are following the case closely to judge its potential consequences for the future of electric competition. John Hanger, a former PUC commissioner and now head of PennFuture, a Harrisburg consumer interest group, said that "nobody believes that there wasn't market manipulation going on." PPL contests in its filing to the PUC that the price increases did not prevent alternative electricity suppliers from competing at the retail level nor did they affect consumers negatively. Most consumers in the mid-Atlantic region are protected from price fluctuations by rate caps so they did not directly feel the effects of higher wholesale prices. Hanger maintained that retail suppliers began leaving the market following the high prices in March of 2001. The PUC confirmed that only 72 of the original 97 electric companies operating in the Mid-Atlantic region last January are still in the market. Copyright ? 2002 Egnatia Research & Management. All rights reserved