5 May 2001, 01:24 UTC
RE: Enron Online case
- From
- Kal Shah kal.shah@enron.com
- Date
- Fri, 4 May 2001 18:24:00 -0700 (PDT)
Chris -- In response to your e-mail, here are some quantitative facts that will give your students some insights about the scope of the economic return created by EnronOnline. 1. EnronOnline supports Enron's Wholesale Services division. In 2000, IBIT (Income before interest, minority interests and taxes) for Enron Wholesale Services division rose 72% to $2.3 billion, with record physical energy volumes of 51.7 trillion British thermal units equivalent per day (TBtue/d) -- a 59% increase over 1999. Both of these growth rates were very significantly higher than growth rates we experienced in previous years. For example, for the past five years, wholesale services earnings have grown at an average compunded growth rate of 48% annually. 2. It took nearly a decade for Enron's daily gas transactions in North America to reach 13.9 bcf in 1999. Just 12 months later, EnronOnline had helped to practically double daily transactions to 24.7 Bcf. If you have any questions on this, please call me at 713 853 9354. Thanks Kal Shah EnronOnline
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
-----Original Message----- From: Kitchen, Louise Sent: Friday, May 04, 2001 8:39 AM To: Patrick, Christie Cc: cbartlett@hbs.edu; Kal Shah/HOU/ECT@ENRON Subject: Re: Enron Online case Hello Chris and Christie, I have asked Kal Shah to run with getting you what you need to ensure that you will have a contact during my absence. I have copied Kal on this email and hope that this works for everyone. Thanks Louise Christie Patrick 05/03/2001 01:12 PM To: cbartlett@hbs.edu cc: (bcc: Louise Kitchen/HOU/ECT) Subject: Enron Online case Hi Chris! Thanks for the message and the great experience at Harvard last week! Harvard's hospitality was the best!! I'm travelling right now and only have a minute, but I've passed along your request to Louise and will follow up with her and the totality of your request on Monday. ( I also told Louise she was a "star in absentia" at Harvard last week!!!) Take care and we'll speak soon! Best! --Christie. ---------------------- Forwarded by Christie Patrick/HOU/ECT on 05/03/2001 01:02 PM --------------------------- Christopher Bartlett <cbartlett@hbs.edu> on 05/03/2001 09:33:48 AM To: christie.patrick@enron.com cc: Subject: Enron Online case Christie: Following up on my message of last week, I have now finished the minor edits required to clarify the Enron Online case (correcting the stock price, clarifying the "One to Many" versus "Many to Many" models of trading, etc.). The one piece that remains for me to insert is some information that will allow the students to make some estimates about the economic risk involved in this bold move. I know that wholesale services contributed about 89% of Enron's total profit in 1999, but it is unclear what extent of this was provided by the traditional trading activities that subsequently were enhanced by Enron Online. My suspicion is that it is the majority of the sales volume, and perhaps the majority of profitability, but if we could give some clue to that in the case, it would be helpful. This might simply be that "trading activities constituted the majority of wholesale services profits" or "the vast majority" or "over 80%" or whatever you think would give the students some sense of quantification. The alternative might be to provide data that was disguised and could be footnoted as such. For example, we could identify that trading contributed "over $750 million to Enron's net profits" with that number footnoted as a disguised figure. The other thing that would be very helpful would be again to provide some data on the profitability of operations in 1999 versus the profitability in 2000 when Enron Online became a dominant part of its activities. Once again, we could include broad-level generalizations or disguised data. It's your choice, but it will give the students a sense of the size of the issue facing them. If it is helpful to talk about this in person, please feel free to call me on 617-495-6308 today (Thursday); or tomorrow (Friday) in the afternoon at 802-457-1880. Once again, thanks so much not only for the cooperation on the case, but also for the terrific organization you did in getting your executive team up here for last week's classes. I think you probably realized that it was a "home run" with the students, who are still talking about it. Best wishes, Chris <Embedded Picture (Device Independent Bitmap)> <Embedded Picture (Device Independent Bitmap)>