4 May 2001, 04:00 UTC
Re: Enron Online case
- From
- Christie Patrick christie.patrick@enron.com
- Date
- Thu, 3 May 2001 21:00:00 -0700 (PDT)
...FYI...cp.
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
---------------------- Forwarded by Christie Patrick/HOU/ECT on 05/03/2001 05:53 PM --------------------------- Christopher Bartlett <cbartlett@hbs.edu> on 05/03/2001 05:40:54 PM To: Christie.Patrick@enron.com cc: Subject: Re: Enron Online case Christie: Thanks for your fast response. I look forward to hearing back from you and/or Louise with the data requested. We have already had a large number of inquiries about the case, even though it's not yet officially listed for release. I have a feeling we have a "best seller" on our hands. Regards, Chris At 01:12 PM 5/3/01 -0500, you wrote: >Hi Chris! > >Thanks for the message and the great experience at Harvard last week! >Harvard's hospitality was the best!! > >I'm travelling right now and only have a minute, but I've passed along your >request to Louise and will follow up with her and the totality of your >request on Monday. ( I also told Louise she was a "star in absentia" at >Harvard last week!!!) > >Take care and we'll speak soon! > >Best! > >--Christie. >---------------------- Forwarded by Christie Patrick/HOU/ECT on 05/03/2001 >01:02 PM --------------------------- > > >Christopher Bartlett <cbartlett@hbs.edu> on 05/03/2001 09:33:48 AM > >To: christie.patrick@enron.com >cc: > >Subject: Enron Online case > > >Christie: > >Following up on my message of last week, I have now finished the minor >edits required to clarify the Enron Online case (correcting the stock >price, clarifying the "One to Many" versus "Many to Many" models of >trading, etc.). The one piece that remains for me to insert is some >information that will allow the students to make some estimates about the >economic risk involved in this bold move. I know that wholesale services >contributed about 89% of Enron's total profit in 1999, but it is unclear >what extent of this was provided by the traditional trading activities that >subsequently were enhanced by Enron Online. My suspicion is that it is the >majority of the sales volume, and perhaps the majority of profitability, >but if we could give some clue to that in the case, it would be >helpful. This might simply be that "trading activities constituted the >majority of wholesale services profits" or "the vast majority" or "over >80%" or whatever you think would give the students some sense of >quantification. The alternative might be to provide data that was >disguised and could be footnoted as such. For example, we could identify >that trading contributed "over $750 million to Enron's net profits" with >that number footnoted as a disguised figure. > >The other thing that would be very helpful would be again to provide some >data on the profitability of operations in 1999 versus the profitability in >2000 when Enron Online became a dominant part of its activities. Once >again, we could include broad-level generalizations or disguised >data. It's your choice, but it will give the students a sense of the size >of the issue facing them. > >If it is helpful to talk about this in person, please feel free to call me >on 617-495-6308 today (Thursday); or tomorrow (Friday) in the afternoon at >802-457-1880. > >Once again, thanks so much not only for the cooperation on the case, but >also for the terrific organization you did in getting your executive team >up here for last week's classes. I think you probably realized that it was >a "home run" with the students, who are still talking about it. > >Best wishes, >Chris