27 Sep 2000, 10:38 UTC
FW: Transmission curtailments - PG&E Proposal
- From
- Jess Galura jess.galura@enron.com
- To
- Jeff Nieland
- Bcc
- John Wack, Jeff Dasovich, Roger Yang
- Date
- Wed, 27 Sep 2000 03:38:00 -0700 (PDT)
Jeff, my understanding is that, various level of emergencies are declared by the CAISO because of power supply situations. Rotating outage plans are then required to be implemented by the Utilities in order to reduce their power supply requirements (i.e. electric loads). The utilities chose to implement their Rotating Outage Plans by dropping various distribution circuits, that do not have essential customers connected to them, on a rotating basis because it is cheap and easy to implement, less controversial, and less politically sensitive. The following are my comments: My main concern is with regards to the way they propose to handle Direct Access customers. Direct Access customers should not be included in PG&E's Mandatory Curtailment Plan (MCP) because the power that these customers are using is not coming from PG&E anymore. Their power supply requirements are being met by their ESP's. PG&E's proposal is treating transmission level customers like utilities. The only difference, this time, is that PG&E is acting like the regulator (controlling the customer). At a minimum, the cost of implementing their proposal should be paid for by PG&E and not the transmission customers. Non-firm customers, such as IBM, should not be included or be required to participate in their MCP anymore because their loads are dropped down to the minimum or essential levels, by the CAISO first, even before a state of emergency is declared. There is a minimum load level that facilities require in order to maintain human and environmental safety conditions. Please give me a call if you have any question. Thanks
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
---------------------- Forwarded by Jess Galura/HOU/EES on 09/27/2000 09:27
AM ---------------------------
John Wack
09/26/2000 07:57 AM
To: Jess Galura/HOU/EES@EES
cc: Jeff Nieland/HOU/EES@Exchange, Jeff Dasovich/NA/Enron@Enron, Roger
Yang/SFO/EES@EES
Subject: FW: Transmission curtailments - PG&E Proposal
Jess, what do know about this? If you have any info let Jeff Nieland
know.
Jeff N., I am not familiar with the Cal. EEP. In most state it is not
unusual for transmission customer (usually all the customers are involved)
to be part of the plans. Jeff Dasovich or Roger Yang may have more details.
---------------------- Forwarded by John Wack/HOU/EES on 09/26/2000 07:50 AM
---------------------------
From: Jeff Nieland/HOU/EES@Exchange on 09/25/2000 07:10 PM
To: Tom Riley/Western Region/The Bentley Company@Exchange, John
Wack/HOU/EES@EES, Ress Young/HOU/EES@EES
cc: Chris Holmes/HOU/EES@EES
Subject: FW: Transmission curtailments - PG&E Proposal
Gentlemen,
Do we have any influence over this issue with our direct access customers in
California? IBM San Jose is on an interruptible transmission tariff and is
concerned about the proposed Mandatory Curtailment Plan. I would appreciate
any comments.
Thanks
Jeff
Tom - Who would you recommend asking to comment from our regulatory
department?
-----Original Message-----
From: Nieland, Jeff
Sent: Monday, September 25, 2000 6:29 PM
To: '"Kumar De Silva/San Jose/IBM" <kdesilva@us.ibm.com>@ENRON@EES'
Cc: "lguest" <lguest@us.ibm.com>; "Gregory G Peterson/Raleigh/IBM"
<petegreg@us.ibm.com>
Subject: RE: Transmission curtailments - PG&E Proposal
Kumar,
I have distributed the plan to our commodity and regulatory departments for
comments. After receiving their comments, I will summarize and forward.
Please contact me with questions.
Thanks
Jeff
-----Original Message-----
From: "Kumar De Silva/San Jose/IBM" <kdesilva@us.ibm.com>@ENRON@EES
Sent: Wednesday, September 20, 2000 5:34 PM
To: Jeff_Nieland@enron.com
Cc: "lguest" <lguest@us.ibm.com>; "Gregory G Peterson/Raleigh/IBM"
<petegreg@us.ibm.com>
Subject: Re: Transmission curtailments - PG&E Proposal
Jeff,
We are concerned about the impact of the proposed Mandatory Curtailment
Plan.\ (Please see Lynn's Note below) Please review from a commodity
provider standpoint. In your opinion, is it fair for us to be subject to
such legislation while we are a Direct Access Customer?
I would appreciate your comments.
Regards,
Kumar
Facilities Engineering Manager
Department K3MA-124, Office 12-4A052
IBM Real Estate and Site Operations
5600 Cottle Road, San Jose, California 95193
Tel: (408) 256-1004, Tie Line: 8-276-1004, Fax: (408) 256-2699,
---------------------- Forwarded by Kumar De Silva/San Jose/IBM on
09/20/2000 03:03 PM ---------------------------
Lynn Guest
09/15/2000 11:28 AM
To: Kumar De Silva/San Jose/IBM@IBMUS, Ray Dias/Almaden/IBM@IBMUS, Aida
Maciel/San Jose/IBM@IBMUS, John Lattyak/San Jose/IBM@IBMUS
cc:
From: Lynn Guest/Almaden/IBM@ibmus
Subject: Re: Transmission curtailments - PG&E Proposal
Here is a soft copy of what I faxed you yesterday.
Lynn Guest
Site Operations Manager, Almaden Research Center
IBM Corporation
650 Harry Road, M/S - G2
San Jose, CA 95120-6099
(408) 927-1529 or Tie line 8-457-1529
Fax (408) 927-1230
E-Mail: LGUEST@US.IBM.COM
---------------------- Forwarded by Lynn Guest/Almaden/IBM on 09/15/2000
11:30 AM ---------------------------
Pam Ross <pross@camfg.com> on 09/14/2000 10:02:31 AM
To: Alan Amrhein <amrhein@ppg.com>, Allan Warman
<allan.p.warman@boeing.com>, Barry Hughes
<Barry.L.Hughes@boeing.com>, Bill Guernsey <bill.guernsey@trw.com>,
Bill Zobel <bzobel@mail.arco.com>, Bryan Campanaro
<bcampana@kcc.com>, Cameron Raether <paccoast@mctcnet.net>, Carl
Nordquist <carl.j.nordquist@boeing.com>, Carolyn Kehrein
<cmkehrein@ems-ca.com>, Dan Fink <daniel.L.fink@boeing.com>, Dan
Green <dgreen@ppg.com>, David Mills <david.m.mills@honeywell.com>,
"Denis St. Jean" <dstjean@tosco.com>, Dorothy Rothrock
<drothrock@camfg.com>, Ed Munoz <emunoz@west.raytheon.com>, Fred
Mazurski <fmazurski@usg.com>, Gene Hill <ghill@kcc.com>, Glenn
Sheeren <gsheere2@iccnet.com>, Jeff Byron <jbyron@us.oracle.com>, Jim
Schultz <Jim_Schultz@cargill.com>, Jim Wikenczy
<Jim_Wikenczy@mail.tmmna.com>, Joanne Horalek <jhoralek@smurfit.com>,
John Norris <John.Norris@HSC.com>, Karen Jarrell
<kjarrell@smurfit.com>, Karen Lindh <karen@klindh.com>, Keith McCrea
<kmccrea@sablaw.com>, Ky Kennedy <kkennedy@usg.com>, Larry Voronyak
<larry.voronyak@borax.com>, Lynn Guest/Almaden/IBM@IBMUS, Mark
Mithers <mithema@mail.northgrum.com>, Mark Nelson
<Mark_Nelson@hp.com>, Mark Skowronski
<mark.skowronski@honeywell.com>, Miles Keefe
<emkeefe@west.raytheon.com>, Noel Brown <noel.brown@ct.sgcna.com>,
Pam Ross <pross@camfg.com>, Richard Hall <richard.c.hall@intel.com>,
Roland Buchs <BUCHS@imcchemicals.com>, Russell Boston
<reboston@ppg.com>, Scott Potterack <Scott.Potterack@owens-ill.com>,
Stacy Roscoe <roscoesa@pg.com>, Steve Bloch
<steven.bloch@alliedsignal.com>, Steve Watson
<swatson@ballfoster.com>, Tim Treichelt <tntreich@gapac.com>, Tony
Fisher <tfisher@nummi.com>
cc:
Subject: Re: Transmission curtailments - PG&E Proposal
This is the item regarding mandatory curtailment Karen Jarrell
referenced to in her note.
Subject: Transmission curtailments - PG&E Proposal
Date: Thu, 14 Sep 2000 07:51:51 -0700
From: Dorothy Rothrock <drothrock@camfg.com>
Organization: CMTA
To: pross@cmta.net
From: Shaffer, Clyde [mailto:CWS1@pge.com]
Sent: Monday, September 11, 2000 5:34 PM
To: 'dgreen@ppg.com'; 'kohr@ppg.com'
Subject: Transmission curtailments - Proposal
Importance: High
Hi Dan and Tom,
Greetings. I hope all is well with both of you and PPG.
I recently received information that transmission voltage customers will
likely be required to be involved in the Electric Emergency Plan (EEP)
in the future. Currently transmission customers are not "required" to
curtail any load when distribution circuits are taken off line as a
result of a Stage 3 EEP operation.
Please take a look at the attachment below and if possible provide
comments to help shape the proposed change. I will need comments by
this Friday noon if possible. Thanks for the input.
Clyde Shaffer
Co.: 821-5549
Outside: (559)263-5549
Email: cws1@pge.com
(See attached file: MANDATORY CURTAILMENT PLAN.doc)
- MANDATORY CURTAILMENT PLAN.doc << File: MANDATORY CURTAILMENT PLAN.doc >>