16 Mar 2001, 11:34 UTC
WP-02 Data Response
- From
- Darcy Norville darcy@tonkon.com
- To
-
abuckley@wutc.wa.gov, alan@epud.org, ali.rodol@ci.seattle.wa.us, archive-power-ratecase@bpa.gov, aw_turner@pgn.com, bassl@sce.com, bessex@cowlitzpud.org, Bill Ferranti, bpadiscovery@merkellaw.com, ccopatrny@e-z.net, Debbie Throop, crow@millernash.com
and 94 more
cub@teleport.com, cwagers@dcpud.org, dan.meek@usa.net, Norville, darkills@popud.com, dbkinnard@pplmt.com, dfaulk@puget.com, discoveryparalegal@bpa.gov, dldorrell@stoel.com, dmacgregor@morganlewis.com, doney@doneylaw.com, doug_brawley@pngc.com, dparrish@prmllp.com, dws@keywaycorp.com, eauverde@hotmail.com, eboyd@ppcpdx.org, efinklea@energyadvocates.com, elisackf@aol.com, energlaw@aol.com, eric.larson@oremetwahchang.com, erick_johnson@pngc.com, ghuhta@cowlitzpud.org, huse@eesconsulting.com, ias@dvclaw.com, jack.speer@alcoa.com, jacksonc@ida.net, janet.prewitt@state.or.us, Jim Deason, NELSON Jeff, jhartso@enron.com, jlh@mc-power.com, johk@critfc.org, john.yanov@eweb.eugene.or.us, John Cameron, jolynnr@mresearch.com, Williams, John P. (JPW), jrb_ora@televar.com, jsaven@pacifier.com, jschlect@avistacorp.com, Kevin Clark, kknitte@gcpud.org, kmoxness@cencoast.com, kpom@mail.pacifier.com, kyle@ppcpdx.org, lawyer@teleport.com, lhamilton@avistaenergy.com, Lon L. Peters, Lincoln Wolverton, lyn_williams@pgn.com, HELLMAN Marc, Steve Marshall, matts1@atg.wa.gov, mershanlaw@aol.com, mhain@ect.enron.com, michaelearly@earthlink.net, mike.macdougall@powerex.com, mmetzler@ci.tacoma.wa.us, mschaff@worldnet.att.net, mthomas@mtpower.com, paul@kinergyllc.com, pete.forsyth@kaiseral.com, pete@ashland.or.us, Peter Richardson, pfox@bracepatt.com, Pamela Jacklin, pmurphy@mbllp.com, pnichols@idahopower.com, pobenchain@idahopower.com, pspi@dynegy.com, pvickery@tpud.org, rachel@rnp.org, ratecase@pngc.com, rates@ppcpdx.org, rbstrong@painehamblen.com, rdb@keywaycorp.com, rfoiani@gcpud.org, rkindley@schwabe.com, rle@givenspursley.com, rpierce@avistaenergy.com, scott.brattebo@pacificorp.com, seligman@teleport.com, simonf@atg.wa.gov, sjohnsto@wutc.wa.gov, skaravit@ci.tacoma.wa.us, stephens@eslerstephens.com, steve@nwenergy.org, Thomas DeBoer, Terry Mundorf, tgrim@chbh.com, townsend@chbh.com, tracigrundon@dwt.com, tstevenson@ci.burbank.ca.us, weavertr@yakima-wa.com, wmgt3@montana.com - Date
- Fri, 16 Mar 2001 03:34:00 -0800 (PST)
request_number: DS-GE:001-003 firstname: Darcy lastname: Norville e-mail: darcy@tonkon.com exhibit_wp-02-e-: JCG-01 and -02 page_numbers: not specified request_text: Request DS-GE:001 Please disclose and/or produce copies of any and all communications, from October 16, 2001 to the present, between any BPA representative and any representative of any other party, concerning any of the following subjects: a. The general structure of the Cost Recovery Adjustment Clauses (CRACs) described in the testimony of the Joint Customers; b. Any differences between the form of the CRACs described in the testimony of the Joint Customers and the CRACs contained in BPA,s Amended Proposal, or those contained in BPA,s Supplemental Proposal; c. The detailed mechanics of implementing the CRACs described in the testimony of the Joint Customers; d. Revenue effects of the CRACs described in the testimony of the Joint Customers, any modifications; or e. Any aspect of the Partial Stipulation and Settlement Agreement and the Parties, Proposal attached thereto. For purposes of this Request, &disclose and/or produce8 has the meanings described below. With respect to oral communications, &disclose and/or produce8 means to describe the time, date, approximate duration, and substantive content of the communication; the identity and organizational affiliation of the communicating individuals; whether the communication occurred in person or by telephone; the location of the communication if in person; the identity of any witnesses to the communications, including all individuals in the room if the communication occurred by speakerphone; and whether the communication was made in the presence of or after coordination with BPA counsel (if so, identify such counsel). For purposes of this Request, you need not &disclose and/or produce8 oral communications that occurred during meetings noticed in compliance with Rate Case Rule 1010.7(d). With respect to written communications, the Request includes communications in any recorded form, whether on paper, electronic (including, without limitation, e-mails), or whatever form. For such communications, &disclose and/or produce8 means to provide copies of all non-identical versions of any written communications and to describe with particularity the location where such communications were found and/or stored, including the identity of the individual with possession or control of the written communications; to describe with particularity the circumstances under which they were generated or referred to; and to fully &disclose and/or produce8 any oral communications made in connection with the written communications consistent with the preceding paragraph. For purposes of this Request, you need not produce papers served on all parties to the rate case and made part of the official file in the rate case. Request No.: DS-GE:002 Request: Exhibit: Direct Testimony of the Joint Customer Group Please disclose and/or produce any and all communications from October 16, 2001 to the present, between the BPA representatives listed below and any representative of any other party concerning BPA,s rates to be in effect for Fiscal Years 2002-2006, the interactions of such rates and customer contracts, or procedural aspects of these rate proceedings. Bob Proctor Tim McCoy Byrne Lovell Byron Keep Valerie Lefler Jon Wright Peter Berger For purposes of this Request, &disclose and/or produce8 has the meanings described below. With respect to oral communications, &disclose and/or produce8 means to describe the time, date, approximate duration, and substantive content of the communication; the identity and organizational affiliation of the communicating individuals; whether the communication occurred in person or by telephone; the location of the communication if in person; the identity of any witnesses to the communications, including all individuals in the room if the communication occurred by speakerphone; and whether the communication was made in the presence of or after coordination with BPA counsel (if so, identify such counsel). For purposes of this Request, you need not &disclose and/or produce8 oral communications that occurred during meetings noticed in compliance with Rate Case Rule 1010.7(d). With respect to written communications, the Request includes communications in any recorded form, whether on paper, electronic (including, without limitation, e-mails), or whatever form. For such communications, &disclose and/or produce8 means to provide copies of all non-identical versions of any written communications and to describe with particularity the location where such communications were found and/or stored, including the identity of the individual with possession or control of the written communications; to describe with particularity the circumstances under which they were generated or referred to; and to fully &disclose and/or produce8 any oral communications made in connection with the written communications consistent with the preceding paragraph. For purposes of this Request, you need not produce papers served on all parties to the rate case and made part of the official file in the rate case. Request No.: DS-GE:003 Request: Exhibit: Direct Testimony of the Joint Customer Group Please disclose and/or produce any and all communications from October 16, 2001 to the present, between any of the party representatives listed below and any representative of BPA concerning rates to be in effect for BPA,s Fiscal Years 2002-2006, the interactions of such rates and customer contracts, or procedural aspects of rate these proceedings. Terry Mundorf (WPAG) Lon Peters (PGP) Linc Wolverton (ICNU) Scott Brattebo (PacifiCorp) Kevin Clark (Seattle City Light) David Hoff (PSE) Geoff Carr (Northwest Requirements Utilities) Dennis Parrish (Market Access Coalition Group) Pam Jacklin (PacifiCorp) Peter Richardson (PPC) Kyle Sciuchetti (PPC) Ray Kindley (PGP) Jay Waldron (PGP) Doug Brawley (PNGC) Eric Johnson (PNGC) Darcy Norville (PGE) Lynn Williams (PGE) Steve Weiss (Northwest Energy Coalition) Mark Hellman (OPUC) For purposes of this Request, &disclose and/or produce8 has the meanings described below. With respect to oral communications, &disclose and/or produce8 means to describe the time, date, approximate duration, and substantive content of the communication; the identity and organizational affiliation of the communicating individuals; whether the communication occurred in person or by telephone; the location of the communication if in person; the identity of any witnesses to the communications, including all individuals in the room if the communication occurred by speakerphone; and whether the communication was made in the presence of or after coordination with BPA counsel (if so, identify such counsel). For purposes of this Request, you need not &disclose and/or produce8 oral communications that occurred during meetings noticed in compliance with Rate Case Rule 1010.7(d). With respect to written communications, the Request includes communications in any recorded form, whether on paper, electronic (including, without limitation, e-mails), or whatever form. For such communications, &disclose and/or produce8 means to provide copies of all non-identical versions of any written communications and to describe with particularity the location where such communications were found and/or stored, including the identity of the individual with possession or control of the written communications; to describe with particularity the circumstances under which they were generated or referred to; and to fully &disclose and/or produce8 any oral communications made in connection with the written communications consistent with the preceding paragraph. For purposes of this Request, you need not produce papers served on all parties to the rate case and made part of the official file in the rate case. response_text: Response DS-GE:001 Portland General Electric (PGE) objects to this Data Request on the grounds that it (i) seeks information that is not relevant; (ii) seeks information that is privileged; and (iii) seeks information that is unduly burdensome to produce. Rules of Procedure Governing Rate Hearings, Section 1010.8(b). PGE further objects to this Data Request on the grounds that it is in improper form as it does not cite to specific testimony or indicate the specific use to which the information sought will be put. Special Rules of Practice, WP-02-01. Further, the Data Request PGE received in hard copy of March 9, 2001 covered communications from October 16, 2001 to the present, of which there were none. PGE hereby responds to the corrected Data Requests received March 14, 2001 covering communications from October 16, 2000 to the present. Without waiving the foregoing objections, PGE responds as follows: I reviewed my email archive (which is automatically emptied after two weeks), correspondence file and meeting notes and asked Lyn Williams to do the same. I also questioned Ms. Williams about her recollections of any communications described in this Data Request. Based on these inquiries and recollections, PGE reports the following communications: 1. On or about January 22, 2001, following a noticed settlement meeting, Pam Jacklin, Terry Mundorf and another party representative (I do not recall who) met with Alan Burns and Peter Burger in one of their offices to discuss whether BPA intended to file a supplemental proposal in this case. 2. During a Joint Customer Group testimony drafting session during the week of March 5, 2001 Lon Peters placed a telephone call to Bob Procter seeking clarification of BPA's intent with respect to treatment of transmission losses in the LB CRAC GRSPs. 3. Lyn Williams and/or Darcy Norville received the emails described below, copies of which are attached (emails that were sent or copied to the Service List are not included below or attached): a. From Dave Piper to Lyn Williams et al., dated 1/26/01, Subject: Re: Urgent: Potential Substantial Rate Increase; b. From Kyle Sciuchetti to A. W. Turner et al., dated 2/16/01, Subject: Settlement Signers. 4. On October 16, 2000 representatives of six Northwest Investor-owned Utilities sent a letter with comments on BPA's Proposed Amended FY 2002-2006 Power Rate Case to Syd Berwager, a copy of which is attached. 5. On October 16, 2000 representatives of five Northwest Investor-owned Utilities sent a letter with supplemental comments on the appropriate scope of the reopened WP-02 proceeding to Syd Berwager, a copy of which is attached. Response DS-GE:002 Portland General Electric (PGE) objects to this Data Request on the grounds that it (i) seeks information that is not relevant; (ii) seeks information that is privileged; and (iii) seeks information that is unduly burdensome to produce. Rules of Procedure Governing Rate Hearings, Section 1010.8(b). PGE further objects to this Data Request on the grounds that it is in improper form as it does not cite to specific testimony or indicate the specific use to which the information sought will be put. Special Rules of Practice, WP-02-01. Further, the Data Request PGE received in hard copy of March 9, 2001 covered communications from October 16, 2001 to the present, of which there were none. PGE hereby responds to the corrected Data Requests received March 14, 2001 covering communications from October 16, 2000 to the present. Without waiving the foregoing objections, PGE responds as follows: I am aware of no communications responsive to this Data Request other than those disclosed in response to DS-GE:001. Response DS-GE:003: Portland General Electric (PGE) objects to this Data Request on the grounds that it (i) seeks information that is not relevant; (ii) seeks information that is privileged; and (iii) seeks information that is unduly burdensome to produce. Rules of Procedure Governing Rate Hearings, Section 1010.8(b). PGE further objects to this Data Request on the grounds that it is in improper form as it does not cite to specific testimony or indicate the specific use to which the information sought will be put. Special Rules of Practice, WP-02-01. Further, the Data Request PGE received in hard copy of March 9, 2001 covered communications from October 16, 2001 to the present, of which there were none. PGE hereby responds to the corrected Data Requests received March 14, 2001 covering communications from October 16, 2000 to the present. Without waiving the foregoing objections, PGE responds as follows: I am aware of no communications responsive to this Data Request other than those disclosed in response to DS-GE:001. The following information is from the web server: 1. Logon: IUSR_GRANITE 2. Remote Host: 206.29.168.129 3. Remote IP Address: 206.29.168.129 4. Form URL: http://www.bpa.gov/power/secure/psp/ratecase/discovery/wp_02_response.html 5. Browser Client: Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSIE 5.0; Windows NT; DigExt)