5 Jun 2001, 11:28 UTC
RE: FW: M.1853 EDF/EnBW - EDF VPP Trustee
- From
- Peter Styles peter.styles@enron.com
- Cc
- pierre.gaulle@enron.com, ross.sankey@enron.com, Philip Davies, raphael.brun@enron.com, simon.brod@enron.com, Nailia Dindarova, Eric Shaw
- Bcc
- pierre.gaulle@enron.com, ross.sankey@enron.com, Philip Davies, raphael.brun@enron.com, simon.brod@enron.com, Nailia Dindarova, Eric Shaw
- Date
- Tue, 5 Jun 2001 04:28:00 -0700 (PDT)
Thanks for this clear update. Look forward to hearing outcome of Trustee's receipt and review of previous correspondence. From: Bruno Gaillard/Enron@EUEnronXGate on 06/04/2001 11:15 AM GDT To: Pierre de Gaulle/LON/ECT@ECT cc: Ross Sankey/Enron@EUEnronXGate, Philip Davies/Enron@EUEnronXGate, Raphael Brun/LON/ECT@ECT, Simon Brod/LON/ECT@ECT, Peter Styles/LON/ECT@ECT, Nailia Dindarova/LON/ECT@ECT, Eric Shaw/ENRON@EUEnronXGate Subject: RE: FW: M.1853 EDF/EnBW - EDF VPP Trustee All I talked to the Trustee late Friday. They are reluctant and not intending to meet with anyone. The want to keep their independence although they did say that at this point the process has been one sided. They are, however, very interested in getting as much information as possible for us and others. We should provide them copies of all the letters that we have sent to the MTF, EdF, and PWC as they have not received any of that information as of yet. With that we should include a cover note and points on the PIM that we have not covered. When questioned on what their role was, they explained that it was to monitor the execution of EdF's responsibilities, set up the auction process and perform the auction. They must insure that the product offered by EDF is reasonably coherent with the conditions agreed to with the MTF, and finally they must insure transparency. On the possibilities to changes certain terms conditions in the decision. Their role is to ensure that the remedy as agreed is followed through (they have no power to ensure that the greater purpose of the remedy - i.e. promote competition is fulfilled). Thus any fundamental changes on conditions that were precisely stated in the remedy (i.e. noon notification and price level - stated in the confidential version of the decision) will unlikely be changed, on these issues we can give it a go, but I see very little probability for success. Other issues that have not been well defined such as the schedule, type of auction (SMP vs PAB) could possibly be influenced. Bruno
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
-----Original Message-----
From: de Gaulle, Pierre
Sent: 03 June 2001 18:10
To: Gaillard, Bruno
Cc: Sankey, Ross; Davies, Philip; Brun, Raphael; Brod, Simon; Styles, Peter;
Dindarova, Nailia
Subject: Re: FW: M.1853 EDF/EnBW - EDF VPP Trustee
Bruno,
Let's send before meeting with the Trustee a letter similar to EdF and PWC
letters, but incorporating comments on the PIM.
Let's prepare a draft tomorrow, that we will circulate within the group.
Thanks
Pierre
From: Bruno Gaillard/Enron@EUEnronXGate on 01/06/2001 18:01
To: Pierre de Gaulle/LON/ECT@ECT, Ross Sankey/Enron@EUEnronXGate, Philip
Davies/Enron@EUEnronXGate, Raphael Brun/LON/ECT@ECT, Simon Brod/LON/ECT@ECT
cc: Peter Styles/LON/ECT@ECT, Nailia Dindarova/LON/ECT@ECT
Subject: FW: M.1853 EDF/EnBW - EDF VPP Trustee
FYI
-----Original Message-----
From: Nicole.Hacker@cec.eu.int [mailto:Nicole.Hacker@cec.eu.int]
Sent: 01 June 2001 17:55
To: Gaillard, Bruno
Cc: Dietrich.Kleeman@cec.eu.int; Gwenaelle.NOUET@cec.eu.int;
Ulrich.Diez@cec.eu.int; Ana.Arana-Antelo@cec.eu.int; pbreen@dc.com
Subject: M.1853 EDF/EnBW - EDF VPP Trustee
Dear Mr. Gaillard,
please find below the contact details for the EDF trustee of the VPP
auctions:
Patrick Breen
Deloitte Consulting
Stonecutter Court
Stonecutter Street
London EC4A 4TR
Telephone: +44 207 3038703
e-mail: p.breen@dc.com
Best regards,
Nicole Hacker
European Commission
DG Competition
Merger Task Force
Phone: +32 2 299 93 91
Fax: +32 2 296 43 01
e-mail: nicole.hacker@cec.eu.int