11 Jul 2001, 12:00 UTC
Re: Sher Shops Alternative Edison Bailout Plan
- From
- Jeff Dasovich jeff.dasovich@enron.com
- Date
- Wed, 11 Jul 2001 05:00:00 -0700 (PDT)
Thanks. 415.782.7854. Better or worse than ours? Dorothy Rothrock <drothrock@cmta.net> 07/11/2001 11:54 AM To: Jeff.Dasovich@enron.com cc: Ann.Cohn@sce.com, "'Barbara Barkovich (E-mail)'" <brbarkovich@earthlink.net>, "Dominic DiMare (E-mail)" <dominic.DiMare@calchamber.com>, "'John Fielder (E-mail)'" <fieldejr@sce.com>, "'Phil Isenberg (E-mail)'" <isenberg@hmot.com>, "'Jeff Dasovich (E-mail)'" <jdasovic@enron.com>, "'Keith McCrea (E-mail)'" <kmccrea@sablaw.com>, "'Linda Sherif (E-mail)'" <lys@a-klaw.com>, "'Linda Sherif (E-mail 2)'" <lysherif@yahoo.com>, "'Gary Schoonyan (E-mail)'" <schoongl@sce.com>, "'John White (E-mail)'" <vjw@cleanpower.org>, dhunter@s-k-w.com, Rick.Simpson@asm.ca.gov Subject: Re: Sher Shops Alternative Edison Bailout Plan I have the plan.....who wants it? send your fax number (and $10 for shipping and handling....just kidding) D Jeff.Dasovich@enron.com wrote:
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
> Folks: Please see highlighted sections. Anyone seen Byron's plan? Know > where it's headed, etc.? > > Best, > Jeff > ************************************************************************* > Power purchase bills exceed $7.5 billion > > Published Tuesday, July 10, 2001, in the San Jose Mercury News > BY MARK GLADSTONE, NOAM LEVEY AND DION NISSENBAUM > > Mercury News Sacramento Bureau > > SACRAMENTO -- Six months after jumping into the electricity business, the > Davis administration on Monday provided the first detailed glimpse of > California's daily power purchases, showing more than $5 billion in > payments, much of it to government-owned utilities and private companies > that state officials have branded as price gougers. > > The state spent an additional $2.5 billion on a variety of contracts and > other electricity services designed to stabilize the volatile energy > markets, according to documents that the state agreed to release last week > amid a legal dispute over public access to the data. > > In roughly the first five months of the year, the state shelled out $1.2 > billion to Atlanta-based Mirant, the most any company was paid for > electricity, followed by $1 billion to Powerex, the marketing arm of BC > Hydro in British Columbia. It also paid $331 million to the Los Angeles > Department of Water and Power. > > The documents raise questions about some of the common assumptions that > have arisen around the electricity crisis. For instance, almost 40 percent > of the state's purchases have come from government-run power generators in > California and elsewhere, but not Texas; some of the biggest suppliers are > from the Northwest. > > Gov. Gray Davis, who has ambitions to run for the White House, has put much > of the blame for the soaring costs of power on energy companies based in > President Bush's home state. > > The figures are tucked inside 1,770 of pages of invoices that Davis has > resisted divulging, saying disclosure would encourage suppliers to charge > more. The state, which last month released information on its long-term > electricity contracts worth $43 billion, agreed Thursday to release the > first quarter details. > > Short on explanation > > The figures were disclosed late Monday by the California Department of > Water Resources, which buys power for the state's financially strapped > major utilities, and seem to buttress the administration's contention that > the price of power is gradually dropping but offer little or no explanation > for what prompted the decrease. > > In January, for instance, the average price for power on the spot market > was $321 a megawatt hour. It peaked in April at $332 and dropped to $271 in > May. > > One megawatt powers about 750 homes. > > Davis spokesman Steve Maviglio said the price data supports the governor's > assertions that California has been gouged. ``The bad guys are clearly the > out-of-state generators,'' Maviglio said. ``There has been a significant > shift of money out of California.'' > > But the documents fail to shed much light on whether, as the administration > contends, the price drop was due to long-term power contracts negotiated by > the state earlier this year. Critics contend that the Davis administration > panicked and rushed into deals that commit the state to pay high prices for > many years. > > Used for support > > Republican officials used the price information to bolster their attacks > against Davis, a Democrat, for signing long-term contracts with power > generators even as the price of power on the spot market was coming down, > partly because of the declining price of natural gas used to fuel many > plants. > > ``It's more clear than ever that the long-term contracts are a bad deal,'' > said Assemblyman Tony Strickland, R-Camarillo. ``The governor's really hurt > the ratepayers for the next five or 10 years.'' > > The newly released bills highlight the volatility of California's energy > market, where the price per megawatt hour ranged from $70 to $1,000. On any > given day, the records show, the prices from seller to seller varied > widely, with some of the highest prices being charged by public utilities > and companies outside Texas. > > On one day in February, for example, San Diego-based Sempra Energy was > charging $165 per megawatt hour, the Eugene Water and Electric Board was > charging nearly $500 and Duke Energy, a North Carolina company, was > charging up to $575. > > The state's daily spending peaked May 10 at $102.4 million for all power, > including the spot market and contracted power. > > The state began buying power in mid-January on behalf of the state's major > utilities, which were unable to borrow money to buy power after amassing > enormous debts for electricity. > > San Jose-based Calpine Corp., which is building several new power plants > around California including one in South San Jose, did only $29 million > worth of business with the state in the first five months of the year, > according to the figures. > > The state began buying power in mid-January when Pacific Gas & Electric Co. > and Southern California Edison Co. were on the ropes financially. PG&E > later went into bankruptcy. > > On Monday, state lawmakers took another shot at trying to cobble together a > plan to rescue financially ailing Edison. > > While most concede that a rescue plan Davis worked out with Edison will not > win the necessary support in the Legislature, lawmakers have created > several working groups to come up with alternatives. > > Compromise plan > > On Monday, state Sen. Byron Sher, D-Redwood City, unveiled the latest > compromise proposal that seeks to protect average ratepayers and small > businesses from further rate increases and forces everyone else to help > finance the Edison bailout. > > The ``shared pain'' proposal would force power producers, owed about $1 > billion, to take a 30 percent ``haircut'' and agree to forgive about $300 > million in Edison debts. Edison would be asked to swallow $1.2 billion -- > about a third of its debt. And big users would be asked to pay off the > remaining $2 billion in debts, possibly by paying higher prices for power. > > In exchange, large companies would be given the opportunity to buy power on > the open market, a system that would allow many of them to sign cheap > energy deals. > > Sher presented the proposal to Senate Democrats Monday afternoon, but it > remains unclear how much support the framework will receive in the > Legislature. > > Contact Mark Gladstone at mgladstone@sjmercury.com or (916) 325-4314.