12 Oct 2000, 17:58 UTC
Re: SDG&E Advice Letters
- From
- Roger Yang roger.yang@enron.com
- Date
- Thu, 12 Oct 2000 10:58:00 -0700 (PDT)
Mona, Your business instincts are correct. SDG&E's proposed treatment is inequitable. Overcollections recovered from all customer classes should not be used to fund the rate cap that benefit only some customer classes. I do not think this is necessarily a DA versus SO issue, but rather mor of a large versus small customer issue (however, to the extent that only large SO customers can opt in and benefit there is a disparity between large DA and SO). Can you please check with CLECA and CEMA to see what they are doing. Given that most of our customers are large customers, we should have an issue with this treatment. There is something extremely anti-competitive in over-collecting from all customers in a non-bypassable rate to subsidize small customers. I don't think that small DA and SO customers are being treated differently, because the utility is implementing a cap with a PX credit for small DA customers. But correct me if I am wrong. It may be viewed as a DA versus SO issue, since most DA customers are large and very few DA customers are small. Further, we should point this out in SDG&E's filing at FERC to use the FERC jurisdictional rate to overcollect and subsidize small customers. Obviously, SDG&E is trying to minimize the undercollections from the cap to mitigate shareholder risk of non-recovery in the future. We will need to be careful in our complaints, because of the issues that we are pursuing for PG&E and SCE. We want to cooperate with the Governor's programs, but only if the solutions for PG&E and SCE are equitable for DA as well. Roger
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
Mona L Petrochko 10/09/2000 05:22 PM To: Roger Yang cc: Subject: Re: SDG&E Advice Letters It is beginning to look like ANY overcollected balance goes into the subaccount to offset undercollected procurement costs. Wouldn't we have an interest in raising objections to RMR overcollections going into that account, to the extent that those costs were collected from all customers? ---------------------- Forwarded by Mona L Petrochko/SFO/EES on 10/09/2000 03:21 PM --------------------------- "Daniel Douglass" <douglass@ArterHadden.com> on 10/09/2000 12:21:08 PM To: <ryang@enron.com> cc: <Jeff_Dasovich@enron.com>, <marcie.milner@enron.com>, <mpetroch@enron.com>, <Roger_Yang@enron.com>, <susan_j_mara@enron.com> Subject: Re: SDG&E Advice Letters Here is AL 1262-E. >>> <ryang@enron.com> 10/09/00 11:17AM >>> We need to take a look at AL1262-E to ensure that those who do not benefit from the rate stabilization receive their fair share of the refunds. Roger "Daniel Douglass" <douglass@ArterHadden.com> on 10/09/2000 01:01:13 PM To:?? <Jeff_Dasovich@enron.com>, <marcie.milner@enron.com>, ????? <mpetroch@enron.com>, <Roger_Yang@enron.com>, ????? <susan_j_mara@enron.com> cc: Subject:? SDG&E Advice Letters Attached are summaries of three recent SDG&E advice letters.? Two? ought to be looked at, but may not rise to the level of protests. Dan (See attached file: 10-9-00 SDG&E AL Summary Chart.doc) - 1262-E_1.pdf