25 May 2001, 17:53 UTC
Briefing on FERC CA Natural Gas Infrastructure conference
- From
- Donna Fulton donna.fulton@enron.com
- To
- Steven J Kean, Richard Shapiro, James D Steffes, Sarah Novosel, Ray Alvarez, Christi L Nicolay, Jeff Dasovich, Leslie Lawner, Rebecca W Cantrell, Susan J Mara
- Date
- Fri, 25 May 2001 10:53:00 -0700 (PDT)
The sender added no text of their own; everything below is quoted or forwarded.
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
----- Forwarded by Donna Fulton/Corp/Enron on 05/25/2001 05:36 PM ----- Nancy Bagot 05/25/2001 05:11 PM To: Shelley Corman/Enron@EnronXGate, Mary Kay Miller/ET&S/Enron@ENRON, Drew Fossum/Enron@EnronXGate, Robert Kilmer/Enron@EnronXGate, Janet Butler/Enron@EnronXGate, Dari Dornan/ET&S/Enron@ENRON, Glen Hass/ET&S/Enron@ENRON, Bambi Heckerman/Enron@EnronXGate, Frazier King/Enron@EnronXGate, Teb Lokey/Enron@EnronXGate, Dorothy McCoppin/Enron@EnronXGate, Ray Neppl/Enron@EnronXGate, Maria Pavlou/Enron@EnronXGate, Janet Place/Enron@EnronXGate, Michele Winckowski/Enron@EnronXGate, Donna Fulton/Corp/Enron@ENRON, Linda Robertson/NA/Enron@ENRON, Tom Briggs/NA/Enron@Enron, John Shelk/NA/Enron@Enron, Carin Nersesian/NA/Enron@Enron, Steven Harris/ET&S/Enron@ENRON, Joe Hartsoe/Corp/Enron@ENRON cc: Subject: Briefing on FERC CA Natural Gas Infrastructure conference This memo by Nancy Bagot, ETS, and Donna Fulton, Enron Corp, summarizes what we heard at yesterday's FERC conference and gets to the heart of the issue in California on the gas side. The FERC Technical Conference yesterday was held by FERC staff and was kept to very technical, facility and service issues. Staff did not allow any discussion of pricing, because that would be handled in other forums. Commissioners did not make an appearance at the conference, though some of their staffers were in attendance. Like many FERC Technical Conferences, the May 24th conference on California Natural Gas Transportation Infrastructure boiled down to parties blaming other parties for the situation in the California market. Generally, (1) interstate pipelines and others believe more infrastructure is needed, both to California and within California (and some blame SoCalGas, lack of adequate take-away capacity, failure to provide open access transmission, and allocation procedures), (2) SoCalGas blames the CPUC and believes that, although this is a tight year, service commitments will be met and things are fine, and (3) the CPUC and CEC believe things are not out of control going forward, that their own open proceedings are adequate to handle any gas issues in California, and that CPUC &decisions are coming.8 For FERC Staff, there are two issues at hand: is the problem the mismatch between interstate and intrastate capacity (and what amount of infrastructure should be added into and within California), and/or is it the allocation methodology at a few highly-constrained delivery points into the state. Overall, there is basic agreement that there are problems with both. The State Both the CPUC and the CEC described the intrastate pipeline system as adequate with just minor changes and enhancements, certainly to serve core customers and likely to serve non-core customers. Like the LDCs, the state representatives are concerned that building to develop a cushion in a difficult year may not bode well for facilities in &normal8 years in the future, leaving intrastate capacity stranded. Also, both agencies ticked off a laundry list of proposed LDC enhancement projects and regulatory changes that are designed to improve the delivery system. According to the CPUC and CEC, demand in the state is not going to explode ) getting LDC storage back up to normal levels should make the difference. FERC Staff questioned the CPUC and CEC speakers at length on the operations of the state LDC systems, allocation methods, and the availability of firm capacity on SoCalGas in particular. There was great concern among Staff about the inability for a non-core customer to contract for specific capacity for primary firm service on SoCal. The CPUC noted that there is a comprehensive settlement before the Commission to unbundle SoCal capacity and allow for tradable primary capacity on an open access system, but the Commission has not yet acted on that settlement. When asked why the CPUC has not acted on the settlement that has been pending for a year, the witness said that there were not three votes. The LDCs Only PG&E and SoCalGas appeared before FERC. Both were adamant that there was adequate capacity for current demand, as proven by the lack of curtailments over the past year. They also agree that a primary question is how to agree on the adequate amount of capacity ) though it,s generally held there should be a 15-20% excess, is that for a normal weather year or a dry hydro year? For SoCal in particular, Lad Lorenz claimed that demand would drop in the next five years, with normal weather and a reduction of EG load which would bypass their system (being built directly along interstates pipelines). If capacity were built to match an excess reserve margin, he wanted to know who would pay for the capacity. The central policy question for SoCal comes down to defining excess capacity and modeling for excess based either on matching interstate capacity or customer demand (based on contracts). SoCal believes it should respond to the latter. However, the LDC cites the CPUC as an obstacle for responding to customers, and is looking to the CPUC to accept its comprehensive settlement which will unbundle its capacity and allow for tradable primary capacity rights. For PG&E, the situation is different because it functions very much like an open access interstate pipeline. It does not have the allocation and scheduling issues that are on the SoCal system; however, there is still a mismatch between interstate and intrastate capacity. PG&E, like SoCal, claims that its system is adequate to meet current demand, though they are planning some enhancements. They do agree with SoCal on the difficulty in planning for uncertainty, but in general the northern California LDC is not facing the difficulties of its southern counterpart. Staff questions underscore the more difficult situation on the SoCal system, as nearly all questions focused on SoCal,s allocation method, firm capacity availability for non-core customers (which include industrials and electric generation) and possible disconnects between its local and backbone systems. FERC also queried about interstate and intrastate mismatches at Topock and Wheeler Ridge, and whether these would be worsened with the addition of more interstate capacity. SoCal consistently answered that its proposed comprehensive settlement on unbundling would resolve most issues, but the CPUC will not act on it. Interstate Pipelines With every interstate pipeline serving California planning expansions and four entirely new pipelines on the drafting table, the pipelines call to arms was for more capacity into the state. Demand projections by the pipeline representatives were vast and optimistic, an example being the Sonoran Pipeline prediction of a 3 ) 4 Bcf shortfall. And each pipe can point to booming open season results as proof of the need for more infrastructure. Posing an obstacle to this infrastructure development is SoCalGas, lack of capacity and the major problem of allocation ) SoCal currently can only offer secondary capacity to any new interstate capacity. FERC Staff agreed that the SoCal allocation is a problem and further proof that there is a mismatch between intra and interstate capacity. SoCal responded that any new interstate capacity at certain desirable points will only degrade existing service and again blamed the CPUC and the pipes, allocations. The other concern expressed by Staff is the divergent demand forecasts of the LDCs, CPUC & CEC, and the pipelines. Others The financial community (Credit Suisse and Merrill Lynch) pointed to a dysfunctional market in California and told FERC that pipelines must be given certainty on returns and the regulatory structure. The message was for FERC to stay the course, without price caps or changes to the marketing affiliate rules, and for California to fix itself, especially the CPUC (the weakest link). Producers and End Users are concerned that existing shippers, rights are protected and rates remain unaffected by expansions that may later be stranded. There is concern over additional capacity into constrained delivery points that are already pro rationed, especially in light of the recent nomination gaming debacle at Wheeler Ridge. The California Generators claimed that they were not convinced that SoCal will be unloaded by bypassing EG. They claimed that there are disincentives in California regulation to SoCal's building capacity - specifically the Performance-based Rate mechanism and the Gas Cost Incentive mechanism. Under these programs, SoCal gets to keep 50% of peaking service revenues, thus giving SoCal incentive to advantage their own storage services. SoCal gets to keep tens of millions annually under these mechanisms. Closing Staff Concerns To wrap up, FERC Staff asked why it is Topock in particular that is always discussed, and it was explained that access to multiple pipelines at Topock has set it up as the preferred delivery point into California. However, with allocation changes at Topock kicking in, the problems are moving to Wheeler Ridge. There was also a debate over which is the real problem ) intrastate capacity or intrastate scheduling. SoCal again emphasized that it is not a capacity issue but the mechanism (blame the CPUC for not approving the unbundling settlement), California Generators believe it,s all about capacity (blame SoCalGas). Future Comments Comments can be filed in this proceeding by June 25. Since the SoCal settlement received so much attention and continues to await action by the CPUC, should we get supporters of that settlment to file with the FERC stating that this was a fix to some of the problems on SoCal's system and the CPUC has sat on it? We should find out who is planning to file comments. Though much was said at the technical conference, many speakers brought slides, and there was a Court Reporter, Commissioners and their staffers will not likely read the whole transcript. We could file to emphasize the points that are made in Jennifer's gas talking points. Future Comments Comments can be filed in this proceeding by June 25. Since the SoCal settlement received so much attention and continues to await action by the CPUC, should we get supporters of that settlment to file with the FERC stating that this was a fix to some of the problems on SoCal's system and the CPUC has sat on it? We should find out who is planning to file comments. Though much was said at the technical conference, many speakers brought slides, and there was a Court Reporter, Commissioners and their staffers will not likely read the whole transcript. We could file to emphasize the points that are made in Jennifer's gas talking points.