17 Jul 2001, 04:33 UTC
Meetings with EES Employees in Houston: Benevides, Whalon, Bresna n, Lewis
- From
- Molland, Michael E." @ENRON mmolland@brobeck.com
- Date
- Mon, 16 Jul 2001 21:33:20 -0700 (PDT)
Here is my report, attached as a word document, on my recent meetings with EES employees, Jubran Whalon, Neil Bresnan, Dennis Benevides, Jay Lewis, and Scott Stoness in Houston. A description of their account of the documents in Houston which appear to be called for by the AG's subpena to EES follows in the text of this e-mail: Discussion of Specific Document Requests No 1. All contracts for retail sale: These are both in California and Houston. Nos. 2 and 3: All contracts under which EES has purchased electricity on the western interconnection between 1998 and the end of 2003: About five percent of these contracts are for green power made with various entities. The vast majority, approximately 95%, are contracts with EPMI, which purchased all electricity load for EES. There may be also a few contracts with APX. EES has paper fax copies of all these deals. Their understanding is that EPMI charged EES exactly what the utilities would have paid on the California market. While they do not know how EPMI actually provided for the power, they believe EPMI probably did not buy most of it on the California market. They believe all these contracts are voidable if they are revealed to any third party. They characterize all this information as extremely sensitive. They believe with this information, if given enough time and a few other variables, parties could construct Enron's price curves. No. 4. Documents which identify the purchases of EES for power in the day ahead, hour ahead, or real time markets operated by the PX or Cal ISO: They say there are none. EES was a scheduling coordinator, but never used the function. No. 5. Documents relating to portfolio of energy supply sources relied upon EES to meet contractual obligations to NU's customers in California: There are no such documents. No. 6. Documents relating to the assessment of risks regarding: the cost of purchasing electricity in California: They do not believe there are such documents, but there may be presentations on this issue. No. 7. Documents relating to strategies or business plans designed to minimize risks with regard to the cost of purchasing electricity necessary to serve customers: All EES officers and traders receive daily reports to corporate goals for EES and show how EES was performing in conformity with these goals. They characterized these documents as extremely sensitive. They use these on a daily basis. Most of these goals are based upon the price curves. They also receive month end reports which show how each division is doing according to these corporate goals. They believe that a corporate function called Risk Control would have custody of these reports. Vladimir Gorny (sp?) was said to be the person in charge of these. No. 8. Documents relating to decisions to return direct access customers to default utility distributors in California, including documents relating to cost savings: They believe these documents exist in Houston. They believe there are spreadsheets which show the cost savings or revenue enhancements that EES would have received as a result of returning customers to utilities. They believe Don Black would have these. They believe all these documents would reveal price curves. No. 9. Communications relating to the return of direct access customers in California: There may be spreadsheets which exist on this subject: They believe that Don Black would have them. No. 10. Documents sufficient to identify persons most knowledgeable about decisions made to return direct access customers in California: These would be the same documents as No. 9. No. 11. Documents related to the assessment of the dramatic increases in electricity in California: They don't know if these documents exist or not. There may be some presentations on the subject. No. 12. All documents relating to strategy and business plans designed to maximize revenues from the sale of electricity in California: They construe this request to refer to origination documents. These would be with the person that was in charge of selling services in California during the period in question. They believe Doug Condon (sp?) or Harold Buchanan would have these documents. No. 13. Documents that show sales to California Department of Water Resources: They don't believe there are such documents. Nos. 14, 15. Contracts obligating them to either supply or purchase electricity which they prematurely terminated: They don't believe there are any contracts which they prematurely terminated. Some contracts were terminated but by agreement. The only possible exception may be the University of California contract. No. 16. Organizational charts which show the persons with authority for risk management. They believe Dave Delaney or Marty Sunde, Vice Chairman of EES, might have such charts. No. 17. Documents relating to risk management of trading activities on California markets for electricity or natural gas and pipeline capacity: These again may be guidelines which Delaney or Sunde might have. No. 18. Organizational charts regarding those who have responsibility for approving charters and objectives for making risk management decisions: They believe Jess Hewitt's department might have these. They believe these refer to risk management procedures to prevent conflict of interest among EES traders. No. 19. Documents relating to development approval of charters and objectives for making risk management decisions: They believe there is a master agreement on this subject. They believe Rick Byers (sp?) might have this agreement. They also believe this request refers to guidelines regarding conflict of interest for traders under their risk management policies. Nos. 20, 21. Documents which identify financial and ownership positions of natural gas or capacity to deliver and transport natural gas to California: Gas contracts are handled by a different department at EES. They believe that some of these gas contracts were purchased by EPMI, but had no direct knowledge of them. They believe EES may have purchased its own gas or pipeline capacity because EES has the necessary credit to accomplish this. EES had its own power desk that scheduled gas. However, they probably purchased most of it from Enron North America. <<ees houston meetings_.doc>> ======================================================= This email message is for the sole use of the intended recipient(s) and may contain confidential and privileged information. Any unauthorized review, use, disclosure or distribution is prohibited. If you are not the intended recipient, please contact the sender by reply email and destroy all copies of the original message. To reply to our email administrator directly, send an email to postmaster@brobeck.com BROBECK PHLEGER & HARRISON LLP http://www.brobeck.com - ees houston meetings_.doc