20 Feb 2001, 12:52 UTC
Florida Study Recommends Wholesale Deregulation
- From
- SCIENTECH IssueAlert issuealert@scientech.com
- Date
- Tue, 20 Feb 2001 04:52:00 -0800 (PST)
Today's IssueAlert Sponsors: e-ProCom for Utilities and Energy - March 20-22, 2001e-Commerce and e-Business are concepts that offer the promise and expectation to deliver bottom line benefits, productivity enhancement, supply chain efficiencies and increased profitability to your business ) but what does the e-revolution mean in today's real energy world?The answers can be found at the e-ProCom for Utilities & Energy e-Business Conference & Exhibition, which is being held at the Baltimore Convention in Baltimore, Maryland on March 20-22, 2001 with a focus on the key issues, options, and alternatives from an industry based perspective. Please call (713) 463-9595 to obtain more information or visit our web site at: www.e-procomseries.com The most comprehensive, up-to-date map of the North American Power System by RDI/FT Energy is now available from SCIENTECH. The Wall Map measures 42" x 72"; the Executive Map Set consists of 18 11" x 17" maps. Visit our website at www.ConsultRCI.com for a detailed description of these valuable maps and complete ordering instructions. For advertising information, email Nancy Spring, or call (505)244-7613. Editor's Note: Yesterday's IssueAlert incorrectly identified Las Cruces as the town used for an energy management pilot project. The correct town is Laredo, Texas. [IMAGE] IssueAlert for February 20, 2001 Florida Study Recommends Wholesale Deregulation by Will McNamara Director, Electric Industry Analysis Florida's political and business leaders moved cautiously toward deregulating the state's electric industry in a move last week, while vowing to avoid problems such as those in California. Florida's Energy 2020 Study Commission unanimously recommended that the Florida Legislature consider deregulating wholesale electricity. The move could spark construction of a number of power plants in the state. Analysis: Florida Gov. Jeb Bush created the Energy 2020 Study Commission with the intent of submitting an initial deregulation proposal for consideration in this spring's legislative session. Florida's energy market represents a $13 billion industry, so obviously there has been great interest on the part of new energy suppliers that want to begin serving the state. Florida continues to move slowly toward deregulation across all levels. Competition on the retail side may take several more years, especially as the California crisis is causing many states to adopt a more cautious approach to removing state regulations. The commission's recommendation to initiate deregulation on the wholesale side is considered a small step toward reaching the ultimate goal of total deregulation in the state. Specifically, the commission has endorsed a plan that would allow out-of-state companies to build new merchant power plants in Florida and sell wholesale electricity to the state's utilities. Florida law forbids out-of-state electric utility companies from providing year-round service to utilities and customers, but merchant plants can provide backup service to existing utilities when energy reserves are stretched thin, to avoid power outages and rolling brownouts. Also under the commission's plan, in-state utilities would also be allowed to sell their regulated plants at depreciated values to affiliated companies that would compete head-to-head on the wholesale market. In addition, the state's utilities could engage in long-term power contracts with suppliers instead of relying on the open market (a major difference from California's original plan), and state regulators would still review all wholesale contract prices. The commission's plan must still be approved by the Florida Legislature, and the commission readily admits that approval may not be easily obtained due to the ongoing crisis in California. At the present time, no official start date for electric competition in Florida has been announced. The state's "go slow" approach is characteristic of other Southeastern U.S. states, many of which continue to enjoy comparatively low electric rates. Florida's renewed interest in deregulation is being driven by the belief among several commission members and other officials that competition eventually will result in lower rates for consumers. Or, at the very least, competition should prevent rates from continuing to increase as they reportedly would under a regulated structure. The commission's plan also is intended to prevent power supply problems in Florida similar to those in California, by allowing for new generation to be built in the state by external companies. Florida law requires power companies to hold 20 percent of their power supplies in reserve to that they can handle periods of extreme usage. However, both the commission's chair and Gov. Bush have suggested that Florida will face a shortage of electricity in the next decade unless out-of-state companies build new plants. Consumer groups and municipal electric providers have resisted the commission's recommendation. In general, such groups fear that deregulating Florida's wholesale market would lead to higher electricity bills since big utilities in the state would be allowed to earn higher profits that may or may not result in benefits for consumers. In fact, the Florida Municipal Electric Association recently argued that annual electricity prices in Florida would rise by between $700 million and $1.6 billion if the commission's plan to initiate wholesale deregulation is approved. In addition, Florida's utilities have been rather effective in persuading state officials to move slowly toward deregulation, perhaps out of concern about losing their monopoly status. Walter Revell, the chairman of the Energy 2020 Study Commission, denied that the group is considering any plan that would be partial to the state's largest investor-owned utilities, which include Florida Power & Light, Tampa Electric, Florida Power Corp. and Gulf Power. The commission's recommendation supports what is already a fast-growing wholesale business in the state of Florida, with outside power companies such as Duke, Enron, Calpine Corp. and others aggressively trying to penetrate the state and gain a foothold for when deregulation emerges in full force. Such power suppliers may be accurately surmising that Florida is headed toward a supply / demand imbalance, as has occurred in California. An imbalance of this sort would offer competitive opportunities for power suppliers in the state. According to a report in the St. Petersburg Times, merchant power companies have announced plans to build some 20 plants across Florida just over the last year or so. However, the article stated that the Florida's big utility companies still have enough clout to block any plant proposal. For instance, Florida Power, Florida Power & Light and Tampa Electric joined forces last year to block Duke Energy from constructing a plant near Daytona Beach. Yet, Duke pushes forward and recently said that it would revive plans to build a merchant plant in New Smyrna Beach, Fla. Duke's plans to build the plant had previously been blocked by a Florida Supreme Court ruling that such plants were prohibited under state law. Enron unveiled plans for two "peaker" plants in Pompano and Deerfield Beach, Fla., several weeks ago. Construction on both sites is pending city and state environmental department approval, but Enron hopes to have both 500 MW facilities running by summer 2002. Enron expects the Department of Environmental Protection to license each peaker plant for 125 days each year, with roughly 83 days powered by natural gas and the rest by oil. Enron is also in the preliminary stages of planning a 90-mile liquefied natural gas (LNG) pipeline between the Bahamas and Port Everglades, Fla. The company has an option on a 90-acre site in the harbor of Grand Bahamas Island, where it hopes to build a conversion and treatment terminal for LNG. Calpine received approval to build a 529-MW natural gas-fired plant to supply electricity to Seminole Electric Cooperative. The plant will be part of the proposed Osprey Energy Center in Aurburndale, Fla., next to an existing Calpine 150-MW cogeneration plant. According to Calpine, beginning in June 2003, Seminole Electric Cooperative will distribute electricity from Osprey for 17 years to 10 member electric cooperatives. Reliant Energy is also finding its own way to penetrate the new openings into the Florida market. Just last week, Reliant Energy Services, an unregulated wholesale power subsidiary of Reliant Energy, announced that it has entered into agreements with affiliates of El Paso Energy Corp. to purchase future supplies of power from several new facilities to be built in Florida. Under the tolling agreements, Reliant Energy Services has secured the right to utilize and dispatch electric generating capacity totaling approximately 1,100 MW. The electricity will be generated by two new natural-gas fired simple-cycle peaking plants, to be owned by El Paso Energy, that will be located in Pasco and Hardee counties. The new plants are scheduled to be completed by the spring and summer of 2002. These are just a few examples of the many companies that plan to take competitive advantage of the anticipated opening of Florida's market. While Florida clearly has no plan to open deregulation on the consumer level any time soon, competition in the state does appear to be gaining momentum, at least on the wholesale level. Of course, the commission's plan has not yet been fully approved by the Florida Legislature, and critics claim that the state's big utilities still wield a great deal of influence over the extent to which competing power suppliers will be allowed to participate in the state's market. There are many debatable nuances within the Florida commission's plan. Yet, one positive thing is that Florida does appear to be making valuable steps to increase its own power supply, addressing a problem that many have accused California of ignoring. Having learned the lesson from California, Florida seemingly acknowledges that there is simply no guarantee that power will be readily available at tolerable price levels on the open market. Thus, this plan to increase the availability of power supply within the state through increased merchant plants seems to be a prudent approach. An archive list of previous IssueAlerts is available at www.ConsultRCI.com Reach thousands of utility analysts and decision makers every day. Your company can schedule a sponsorship of IssueAlert by contacting Nancy Spring via e-mail or calling (505)244-7613. Advertising opportunities are also available on our website. SCIENTECH is pleased to provide you with your free, daily IssueAlert. Let us know if we can help you with in-depth analyses or any other SCIENTECH information products. If you would like to refer a colleague to receive our free, daily IssueAlerts, please reply to this email and include their full name and email address or register directly on our site. If you no longer wish to receive this daily email, send a message to IssueAlert, and include the word "delete" in the subject line. SCIENTECH's IssueAlerts(SM) are compiled based on the independent analysis of SCIENTECH consultants. The opinions expressed in SCIENTECH's IssueAlerts are not intended to predict financial performance of companies discussed, or to be the basis for investment decisions of any kind. SCIENTECH's sole purpose in publishing its IssueAlerts is to offer an independent perspective regarding the key events occurring in the energy industry, based on its long-standing reputation as an expert on energy issues. Copyright 2001. SCIENTECH, Inc. All rights reserved.