24 Jan 2001, 11:10 UTC
Staff Conference on Market Monitoring in California
- From
- Joe Hartsoe joe.hartsoe@enron.com
- To
- Alan Comnes, Mary Hain
- Date
- Wed, 24 Jan 2001 03:10:00 -0800 (PST)
Alan and Mary -- Below are my comments and attached documents for the Conference on Market Monitoring in California at the FERC. I will call later to discuss further. I suggest filing comments and would propose something along the lines of PJM's market monitoring program for Enron's Proposal. Please forward to anyone else you think appropriate. Comments and documents -- Attached are the four proposals discussed at the conference. Comments are due February 6. Staff intends to issue its report/recommendations to the Commission March 1. We can comment on the Staff recommendations in March and Commission action is anticipated around May 1. Conference -- Scott Miller chaired this informal Staff conference. The morning was spent discussing principles and the afternoon on specific proposals. This included the explanations of the attached plans, as well as a discussion of the PJM Market Monitoring Program. The conference can be summarized as follows -- screens can be developed to determine if market power exists and is being exercised. an appropriate role of the market monitor is to suggest structural reforms. Independence is necessary, but undefined. due process is necessary for any person under scrutiny. the debate on mitigation continues -- if mitigation, by whom and when are the hot topics. one key is to get the market structure right -- mitigation becomes unnecessary. California is different -- too much dependence on spot market/limited long term contracts; and insufficient demand response. The good news is that -- Staff does not consider the ISO proposal as a starting point, but as a vehicle to generate discussions (Staff succeeded -- Duke and Dynegy went to great lengths to critize it). Staff has an open mind on the appropriate approach to market monitoring and are soliciting written proposals and comparisons to existing programs. Staff is not trying to fix the structure of the California market here -- ISO should do so under the December 15 order. Regional scope and access to information are legitimate questions for comment.