30 Nov 2000, 17:16 UTC
AZ Superior Court Order
- From
- Marcie Milner marcie.milner@enron.com
- Cc
- Leslie Lawner, Tom Delaney, Sandra McCubbin, Jeff Dasovich, susan_j_mara@enron.com, Mona L Petrochko, Mary Hain
- Bcc
- Leslie Lawner, Tom Delaney, Sandra McCubbin, Jeff Dasovich, susan_j_mara@enron.com, Mona L Petrochko, Mary Hain
- Date
- Thu, 30 Nov 2000 09:16:00 -0800 (PST)
On Monday, November 27, the Arizona Superior Court issued a judgment to CV 97-03748 (consolidated) TEP vs. ACC. The judgment is against the Arizona Corporation Commission on all consolidated rules and CC&N complaints filed by the coops and pertaining to all CC&N decisions insofar as the Commission's Electric Competition Rules and Decisions enacted and issued pursuant to those rules are invalid for failure to provide for the Commission ascertaining the fair value of the property of public service corporations under Article 15& 14 of the Arizona Constitution and certain rules are invalid for lack of Attorney General certification. It was further ordered that the coops demonstrated as a matter of law that the Commission's rules and CC&N decisions are unlawful and unconstitutional under the Arizona Constitution. Commission Decisions 59942, 61071(Emergency Rules), 61272 (Emergency Rules made permanent) and 61969 and all Electric Competition Rules enacted under those decisions are vacated and set aside as unlawful and unconstitutional. All competitive CC&N's and tariffs approved under those decisions are also vacated and set aside as unlawful and unconstitutional.