Enron email

Algorithmic Indexing

15 Jun 2001, 15:26 UTC

ICC Study on Competition

From
Janine Migden janine.migden@enron.com
To
Richard Shapiro, James D Steffes, Daniel Allegretti, Harry Kingerski, Susan M Landwehr, Scott Gahn, jeff.ader@enron.com, Eric Letke, Mark Courtney, Marc Ulrich, Guy Sharfman, Charles Decker
and 19 more James W Lewis, Roy Boston, Scott Stoness, Mark Bernstein, James M Wood, Ress Young, roger.persson@enron.com, j.frazier@enron.com, Jeff Merola, greg.sharp@enron.com, ken.detina@enron.com, brad.snyder@enron.com, Christi L Nicolay, mike.roan@enron.com, Edward Baughman, john.burrows@enron.com, Terri Clynes, Jubran Whalan, Janine Migden
Date
Fri, 15 Jun 2001 08:26:00 -0700 (PDT)
I just had the opportunity to review a report issued by the ICC assessing 
retail and wholesale competition in Illinois.  If you would like a hard copy, 
let me know.  Salient facts/ conclusions are as follows:

1.  Switching rates are high in Com Ed territory only.  By end of 2000, 22% 
of eligible customers had switched, representing 62% of usage. Larger usage 
customers are switching with greater frequency than smaller usage customers.  
Approximately 40% of delivery service customers were using the PPO.  Approx. 
8 marketers are active in Com Ed with only 3or 4 acquiring significant 
numbers of customers.

2.  ICC believes retail prices may increase dramatically in 2005 by the time 
the general rate freeze expires.

3.  ICC is concerned about wholesale competition noting that utilization of 
the PPO evidences little physical delivery by suppliers.  ICC is also 
concerned about the ability of the Illinois transmission system to support a 
competitive wholesale market within and between utilities.  The number of 
TLR's attained record levels last years and there are concerns about managing 
load pockets.  If the situation remains unchanged, retail prices will be 
higher than they would have been had the market structure supported wholesale 
competition.

4.  Non-Coincident Peak demand in Illinois in 1999 was 29,561Mw and 28,040MW 
in 2000, however overall growth in demand is 1.4%.

5. The most successful suppliers are either Illinois utilities or affiliates 
of Illinois gas and electric utilities, raising market power concerns.

6.  ICC is investigating the capacity of the Illinois utilities' transmission 
and distribution systems.  As part of the study, the ICC will be developing a 
comprehensive computer simulation model of the regional transmission grid to 
identify problem spots on the grid including potential load pockets as well 
as inter-utility constraints that may limit wholesale deliveries during 
critical peak hours.  This will assist in state and federal proceedings.

7.  The ICC is concerned about the market power exercised by utilities and 
has been collecting data  on each utility's interconnection and transmission 
queues to watch for signs of favoritism directed towards their affiliates  or 
any other violations of FERC Order 888.

Hope this is useful.

Janine