9 Nov 2000, 11:59 UTC
PG&E News Articles dated Thursday, November 9, 2000
- From
- Joseph Alamo joseph.alamo@enron.com
- To
- Richard Shapiro, James D Steffes, Steven J Kean, Karen Denne, Mark Palmer, Joe Hartsoe, Sarah Novosel, Paul Kaufman, Mary Hain, dbenevid@enron.com, Christopher F Calger, Tim Belden
- Cc
- Jeff Dasovich, Susan J Mara, Sandra McCubbin, Mona L Petrochko, Ginger Dernehl, Maureen McVicker, Marcia A Linton, Lysa Akin
- Bcc
- Jeff Dasovich, Susan J Mara, Sandra McCubbin, Mona L Petrochko, Ginger Dernehl, Maureen McVicker, Marcia A Linton, Lysa Akin
- Date
- Thu, 9 Nov 2000 03:59:00 -0800 (PST)
Published Thursday, November 9, 2000, in the San Jose Mercury News PG&E seeks OK to recoup billions UTILITY ASKS COURT TO ALLOW COLLECTING EXTRA FROM CUSTOMERS Associated Press Pacific Gas & Electric Co., facing dramatic increases in the cost of wholesale electricity, asked a federal court in San Francisco on Wednesday for permission to recoup some $3.44 billion in excess charges from its ratepayers. The utility, which has 4.5 million customers across the northern part of the state, said court intervention was necessary ``to protect the company's legal rights.'' Federal regulators, the state Public Utilities Commission and other authorities ``have all acknowledged that the current wholesale power market is broken and not capable of producing competitive wholesale energy prices,'' said Roger Peters, a senior vice president with PG&E. ``However, there has not yet been any concrete action by regulators to provide for recovery of the costs we have incurred to purchase the power our customers must have,'' Peters said. PG&E earlier sought PUC authorization to obtain the costs, but was rebuffed. Consumer groups have opposed PG&E's cost-recovery plans, saying the utility, not its customers, should cover the costs. The utility operates under a rate freeze and is limited as to how much it can charge its customers. It has paid four- and fivefold higher costs for wholesale energy, and by law is unable to pass those charges on to its customers. The rate freeze will remain in effect until the company completes its transition to an open market utility under the provisions of a 1996 law that deregulated California's investor-owned electric utilities. The transition entails selling off assets and buying energy in a competitive, open market. San Diego Gas & Electric Co. completed its transition last year. The utility passed on the huge wholesale price spikes to its 1.2 million customers, prompting a political outcry and state, federal and local investigations, and legislation in Sacramento. PG&E sues to get costs ruling reversed By Carrie Peyton Bee Staff Writer (Published Nov. 9, 2000) Pacific Gas and Electric Co. sued state regulators in federal court Wednesday to try to recoup more than $3.4 billion from Northern California electric customers. The utility wants to collect, with interest, the money it has paid to wholesale power suppliers. State regulators are still studying the issue, but so far have ruled that certain collections are forbidden because electric rates were temporarily frozen under a 1996 state law. That line of reasoning is "in defiance of federal law," PG&E attorneys wrote, asking the U.S. District Court in San Francisco to order the state Public Utilities Commission to reverse its stand. PUC rulings have "caused PG&E severe financial harm and threaten the safety and reliability of the state's electrical supply," PG&E's request for a federal injunction said. Wednesday's action takes PG&E's drive to collect higher rates into a third arena, with a fourth -- the state Legislature -- widely expected to get involved soon. PG&E has already asked the PUC for permission to collect more money, and it has already appealed one unfavorable PUC decision as far as the state Supreme Court, where it is still pending. The latest step surprised no one. "It's the very suit we expected," said Timothy Sullivan, adviser to PUC Commissioner Henry Duque. PG&E said it still wants to work with policy makers to find ways to bring sky-high wholesale electricity prices back down to earth. "We have taken every step the state would allow to try to keep power costs down," general counsel Roger Peters said in a prepared statement, but the latest court action is critical for "protecting our financial viability." The legal theory that PG&E is using has not been tested under circumstances of a partly deregulated electricity market, said Nettie Hoge, executive director of The Utility Reform Network, a consumer group. "I think they're dreaming. Maybe they should go to the World Court next," she said.