Enron email

Algorithmic Indexing

24 Jul 2001, 11:51 UTC

Dan Walters

From
Ken Smith ken@kdscommunications.com
To
Scott Govenar, smara@enron.com, Paul Kaufman, kdenne@enron.com, Jeff Dasovich
Date
Tue, 24 Jul 2001 04:51:00 -0700 (PDT)
Dan Walters: Blame game over  California's energy crisis will continue for  
years



(Published July 24, 2001)  

The wrestling match between politicians and Enron Corp. moved into a more  
intense arena over the weekend when a state Senate investigating committee  
sought contempt penalties because the huge energy company has refused to 
turn  over internal documents.  

Although Houston-based Enron owns no major power plants in California, it 
has  adopted the toughest stance of all energy companies against the 
multiple  investigations of why wholesale energy prices spiked so high. And 
it has become,  in turn, a whipping boy for California politicians.  

At one point last spring, state Attorney General Bill Lockyer said he wanted  
criminal charges against Enron and its chairman, Kenneth Lay. "I would love 
to  personally escort Lay to an 8-by-10 cell that he could share with a 
tattooed  dude who says, 'Hi, my name is Spike, honey,' " Lockyer said. With 
less colorful  language, Gov. Gray Davis has often castigated Texas-based 
companies as price  gougers -- even though Texas firms have been fairly minor 
suppliers to  California.  

Some of it is just buzzword politics. Lockyer and Davis know that  
Californians dislike anything associated with Texas, and Lay has been one of  
President Bush's major political supporters. Enron, meanwhile, cites the  
rhetoric as evidence that Lockyer, Davis and legislative investigators are  
interested less in finding the truth than in seeking scapegoats. Enron also  
filed a lawsuit challenging the legality of the Senate's subpoenas of 
trading  data.  

Most other energy companies have complied with the demands, creating  
Sacramento repositories of the data under elaborate confidentiality 
agreements  worked out with the special Senate committee headed by Sen. 
Joseph Dunn, D-Santa  Ana. But Enron has refused, and on Saturday, Dunn 
submitted a report asking the  Senate for "an appropriate coercive 
sanction."  

Does Enron have something to hide? Or does it sincerely believe that what's  
happening in California is political scapegoating? Are the companies' fears  
about the confidentiality of the data sought by the Senate justified? Would 
data  be selectively leaked to show the firms in the worst light? Would data 
be used  by competitors? Or could the information find its way into the hands 
of  class-action attorneys?  

Dunn, a prominent trial attorney himself, insists that confidentiality will  
be protected and that the information being sought is only for legislative  
purposes. But Enron and the other companies have some reason to be wary of  
turning over confidential information to politicians. Similar information 
was  leaked -- without penalty -- in last year's investigation of former 
state  Insurance Commissioner Chuck Quackenbush. And there are indications 
that private  lawyers are working closely with investigators.  

Mike Aguirre, the San Diego attorney seeking a "smoking gun" to prove  
collusion among energy companies, supplied Dunn's committee with a few 
dissident  Duke Energy workers who alleged, in highly publicized hearings, 
that the firm  had manipulated production at its San Diego plant to create 
artificial shortages  and drive up spot market power prices. Duke then 
refuted the charges by  releasing some excerpts from the records of the 
Independent System Operator, the  controller of California's power grid, 
indicating that ISO had ordered the plant  operational changes.  

Aguirre subsequently asked the governor's office to pressure the ISO -- now  
under Davis' direct control -- to release all of the Duke-related documents 
that  would show, he says, that the firm actually manipulated the situation. 
Duke and  other companies insist that the ISO-held documents are proprietary. 
Aguirre  pleaded with one Davis adviser in an e-mail that "we need your help 
in properly  getting this information out." But Aguirre, in an interview, 
said he had not yet  obtained cooperation from Davis aides.  

The political and legal struggle to affix blame for California's energy woes  
will continue for months, perhaps years. The crisis will cost ratepayers at  
least $50 billion, and they'll want to know why as they make out their 
utility  bill checks.  



The Bee's Dan Walters can be reached at (916) 321-1195 or dwalters@sacbee.com
.