30 Aug 2000, 16:44 UTC
Attorney Work Product
- From
- Mary Hain mary.hain@enron.com
- To
- Sarah Novosel, James D Steffes, Jeff Dasovich, Susan J Mara, Joe Hartsoe, Ronald Carroll, Tim Belden, Robert Badeer, Jeff Richter, Mike Swerzbin, David Parquet, Christopher F Calger
- Bcc
- Ronald Carroll, Lysa Akin
- Date
- Wed, 30 Aug 2000 09:44:00 -0700 (PDT)
I'd like to propose a conference call to discuss our response to multiple FERC cases detailed below. Section 206 Proceeding and SDG&E Complaint Case As you know, last week the FERC established a Section 206 proceeding to examine the justness and reasonableness of the rates of power sellers (including EPMI) in the California markets. The Commission consolidated this proceeding with its case involving the SDG&E's complaint against the power marketers (including EPMI) in California. This type of proceeding differs from the Staff's investigation of the wholesale market in several respects. (1) It establishes a formal evidentiary process where all parties have an opportunity to present evidence and arguments on the record before the Commission. In Section 206 proceedings, the FERC usually establishes a discovery and testimony schedule followed by a hearing before an administrative law judge (ALJ). Such proceedings usually take a long time. The Commission did not establish a schedule here, suggesting that it either would decide the case via a paper hearing or prompt its staff to try to settle the case. The Commission may wish to act by paper hearing to obviate the slow procedural schedules that usually result from using an ALJ or, as is often the case with California, the FERC may wish to avoid the political backlash that might result from issuing a controversial order by letting parties fight the case out at the bargaining table after the Staff does its discovery and recommends an outcome to the parties. (2) Although the Commission equivocated on whether it would use refund authority, it established a refund date of sixty days from the date the order is published in the federal register. This was apparently because Commissioner Hebert wrote a concurrence indicating his opposition to instituting a refund obligation that might predate the FERC's conclusion of its investigation (because it would prohibit wholesale providers from knowing what rates they will be able to recover). Ron Carroll has now raised the question of whether we should request rehearing of the FERC's order, challenging the Commission's authority to impose a refund effective date on the basis that no defendant has requested a refund. Cal PX Price Cap Filing As you also know, the California PX has filed to decrease its price cap to $350. Electricity Oversight Board Complaint Yesterday, the Electricity Oversight Board's (EOB) filed a complaint with FERC against "sellers" (including munis, federal power marketers and "sellers located beyond the border of the United States" (in other words PowerEx)) and scheduling coordinators that sell into the California wholesale market. It urges FERC to find that the California wholesale market is not workably competitive. It alleges that scheduling coordinators are particularly well positioned to take advantage of "gaming" opportunities because they often bid on behalf of more than one seller - undermining the benefits of divestiture. It alleges that sellers and SCs can exercise market power under two circumstances: 1. When all sellers and scheduling coordinators know with substantial certainty that the ISO will be accepting all bids or 2. When a number of sellers and scheduling coordinators know that they control enough capacity in relation to the system demand at that time and the resulting margin of residual supply that they have a high likelihood of being able to successfully set the price. It claims that once demand reaches or exceeds approximately 33,000 MW, sellers and/or scheduling coordinators have the ability, and do, exercise market power and that a bid cap is necessary during these periods. It urges FERC to take immediate steps to lower prices and ensure the bid caps (of $250 for energy and ancillary services and $100 for replacement reserves) remain in effect pending FERC action. EOB is concerned that if the FERC doesn't require continuation of price caps, the ISO could undo its price cap vote at any time. It asks FERC to take any and all actions necessary to ensure that California's wholesale rates are just and reasonable. Its asks to consolidate its filing into the FERC's section 206 proceeding. Assuming the FERC consolidates this cases, which I'm sure it will, this would create a defendant for refund purposes so I think Ron's rehearing idea has been overtaken by events. However, we need to decide what entities should make what filings in reference to the above. I recommend the following: EPMI doesn't need to intervene in the Section 206 proceeding because the FERC combined it with the SDG&E case so EPMI is already a party. I think we should use Seabron to develop a detailed analysis of problems with the California market and to draft responses to the data requests that we will undoubtedly be receiving soon from FERC. This analysis should include the points we presented to FERC but should also include all other important problems with the California wholesale market. We are parties of right in the Electricity Oversight Board's case because we are respondents and as such we are required to file an answer under the Commission's rules. I think we should agree that the FERC should consolidate this case with the Section 206 case because they are obviously the same case. We should oppose price caps in California and lay out the same arguments we made in our presentation to FERC. We also need to refute the contention that capping the PX price will encourage energy sales to move into the forward market. We will also need to develop an analysis of how we can't exercise market power under the circumstances alleged by the EOB. We should use Seabron for this. Although it would be convenient to work with EPSA in these dockets, I'm not sure that will work since I bet the FERC will combine these cases and will be seeking discovery individually from EPMI. On the other hand, we may wish to use EPSA for any of the less popular messages that we may want to deliver about the market in California. Lysa - Please set up a conference call about this ASAP.