Enron email

Algorithmic Indexing

17 Jul 2001, 16:16 UTC

Resolution E-3726 Approved by CPUC - SDG&E surcharge -- exempts DA

From
Susan J Mara susan.mara@enron.com
To
Wanda Curry, Tamara Johnson, Jeff Richter, Harry Kingerski, Don Black, Scott Stoness
Cc
Jeff Dasovich
Bcc
Jeff Dasovich
Date
Tue, 17 Jul 2001 09:16:00 -0700 (PDT)
Looks like current and returning DA customers are exempt from the San Diego 
surcharge

Sue Mara
Enron Corp.
Tel: (415) 782-7802
Fax:(415) 782-7854
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
----- Forwarded by Susan J Mara/NA/Enron on 07/17/2001 02:11 PM -----

	"Dan Douglass" <douglass@energyattorney.com>
	07/17/2001 09:57 AM
		 
		 To: "ARM" <arem@electric.com>
		 cc: 
		 Subject: Resolution E-3726 Approved



The Commission approved Resolution E-3726 on a 5-0 vote at the July 12  
meeting.? A copy of the final resolution, which has several changes from  the 
draft issued a few weeks ago, is attached for your information.? The  
Resolution explicitly states that DA customers are exempt from the AB 265 
rate  surcharge, as AReM advocated in its July 9 comments.? It also states 
that  any DA customer returning to bundled service will not be exempt from 
the  surcharge.? However, a subsequent return to DA appears to make the 
customer  exempt again.? The following are some excerpts from the Resolution 
relating  to these issues.:
?
?"Two parties filed comments on the re-circulated resolution,  SDG&E and ARM, 
both on July 9, 2001.?  Some of the implementation issues raised by SDG&E 
require  clarifications as discussed in the remainder of this section. . . . 
. . .  

?SDG&E next maintains that the draft  Resolution resolves two issues that 
instead should be resolved in A.00-10-045  and A.01-01-044:? changes in the  
definition of &small8 customers and the treatment of DA customers.? (We note 
that the Commission has not  publicly issued a Proposed Decision or draft 
Alternate Decision in those  proceedings addressing the treatment of DA 
customers or the definition of small  customers.) . . . . . 

With respect to the treatment of DA customers we see no  reason why it is 
improper to address that issue here, as that issue has been  addressed by the 
participants in this informal proceeding.? Accordingly, we determine that DA  
customers are exempt from recovery of the undercollection that results from 
the  AB 265 energy price ceiling based only on the record established for 
this  Resolution.? That is we base this  determination on relevant 
information contained in protests and responses to  protests on the advice 
letters addressed by this Resolution and comments and  reply comments on 
drafts of this Resolution that were circulated for public  comment . . . . . 
. . .?

?SDG&E also asserts in its July 9, 2001 comments  that the draft Resolution 
finds DA Issues moot but addresses them anyway.?? SDG&E also argues that it  
withdrew AL 1264-E and that the draft Resolution inappropriately addressed 
two  issues:? exempting DA customers from  any future cost recovery 
obligations associated with AB 265 rate ceiling  benefits, and determining 
what the obligations are of DA customers who return to  utility bundled 
service.? SDG&E  also maintains that the Resolution must be revised to avoid 
gaming by customers  who attempt to avoid paying their share of the 
undercollection.

We first note that the draft Resolution clearly noted at page  6 the 
continued relevance of DA issues despite SDG&E,s withdrawal of AL  1264-E.? 

The passage of Assembly 1X 1 and the potential for the  Commission to suspend 
Direct Access reduce the potential for gaming.? With no individual tracking,  
miss-matches between benefits and repayment obligations are inevitable.? 
Limiting rate ceiling cost recovery  responsibility to bundled service 
customers is an expedient way to mitigate such  mismatches and is supported 
in the discussion section of the resolution by the  ADJ's intent to not 
discriminate against DA customers.? 

SDG&E states in its July 9 comments that the draft  Resolution? must be 
changed to  clearly state that customers cannot avoid paying for costs simply 
by switching  back and forth between bundled service and DA, and that the 
only customers who  will avoid paying for costs are those who never caused 
them to be incurred in  the first place.? But the reverse  could also be 
true.? Some DA  customers that were returned to bundled service in early 
2001, not having  received the largest part of the rate ceiling benefit, 
might have the same  repayment obligations as bundled SDG&E customers that 
received the benefit  back to June 2001, as well as those that just move into 
SDG&E service  territory when the benefit ends and the repayment begins.?? We 
do not address these issues in  this Resolution.? In the Resolution, we 
determined that the complexity of individual  tracking at this point is 
likely to outweigh its benefits. . . . . . .  

ARM, in its comments on the re-circulated resolution, supports the order  
that DA customers should not be liable for any SDG&E undercollection  
balancing account.? However, ARM  proposes a single change to the draft 
Resolution, regarding the treatment of  customers who spend some time on, and 
sometime off, direct access (DA), and who  find themselves, for whatever 
reason, off DA when SDG&E recovers  under-collections arising from AB265.?  
If the Commission is unwilling to require individual customer tracking,  and 
if these customers are for whatever reason off DA when SDG&E assesses  
under-collection obligations arising from AB265, the Commission should treat  
them as DA customers.? 

We will not adopt ARM's proposal on this record.? Customers in the position 
described by  ARM would have at least received a portion of the rate ceiling 
benefits and are  not differently situated from new customers in the SDG&E 
service  territory.??? 

ARM argues that a DA customer who has not received the  benefit of the rate 
cap has not contributed to the utility,s purchased power  undercollection.? 
If that customer  later finds herself, for whatever reason, on bundled 
service and subject to the  AB265 rate cap, she should be liable for her 
share of undercollections incurred  during the period when she was on bundled 
service.? But since SDG&E contends that it  cannot support individual 
tracking, ARM proposes that customers that were DA  during the period since 
June 2000 be exempt from the repayment obligations.? 

As further support, ARM also cites the ACR issued on July 2,  in A.00-11-038, 
seeking comments by July 10 on a &proposed settlement of pending  litigation8 
between the Commission and SDG&E.? As part of the settlement, SDG&E  would 
write off $219 million plus interest from its Energy Rate Ceiling Revenue  
Shortfall Account (ERCRSA), where SDG&E tracks AB265 undercollections.? ARM 
notes that the proposed write-off  would benefit bundled customers, but not 
DA customers.? 

ARM contends that if the Commission were to adopt the  &proposed settlement 
of pending litigation,8 DA customers below 100 kW would  lose out on their 
share of the $219 million write off.? That is the very kind of 
discrimination  described in the Assembly Daily Journal, and the draft 
Resolution seeks &to  guard against such inequities.8? In  view of the harm 
that would be imposed on DA customers if the Commission were to  adopt the 
&settlement,8 and to simultaneously avoid tracking individual AB265  
benefits, ARMargues that the Commission should direct that any customer who 
was  ever a DA customer be exempt from cost recovery obligations associated 
with AB  265 rate ceiling benefits.? 

As discussed in other parts of this Resolution? we have addressed these? 
issues by our treatment of DA customers  with respect to the recovery of the 
undercollection that results from the AB 265  energy rate ceiling."?  


Dan

Law Offices of Daniel W. Douglass
5959  Topanga Canyon Blvd.? Suite 244
Woodland Hills, CA  91367
Tel:?? (818) 596-2201
Fax:? (818) 346-6502
douglass@energyattorney.com
 - Resolution E-3726 - Final 7-12-01.doc