9 Mar 2001, 11:10 UTC
CAISO Market Stabilization Plant
- From
- Alan Comnes alan.comnes@enron.com
- To
- smara@enron.com, Jeff Dasovich, rick.shapiro@enron.com, Tim Belden, mhain@enron.com, Steve Walton
- Date
- Fri, 9 Mar 2001 03:10:00 -0800 (PST)
Here are some initial reactions and questions to the CAISO market stabilization plan, which is attached. Give me or Sue Mara your comments and then we can turn it into message points for media / advocacy folks. In addition to reviewing the plan, I listened in to part of a stakeholder call that occured Friday 10 a.m. PST. DRAFT MESSAGE POINTS: With limited exceptions, the plan does nothing to increase supply or decrease demand. It primarily addresses costs and market "stability" INTERESTING QUOTES: "Over the edge into cost based regulation" Duke Power Although the plan provides for cost control and for improving market "stability" (whatever that means), the ISO staffer (Byron Wortz) who presented the study admitted it "Will do nothing to increase supply this summer" A staffer, Lorenzo, stated (paraphrased)" all out of state suppliers are cost of service based and do not need to recieve market based rates ON SPECIFICS The Ugly: Resource-specific cost based bid caps (RSBC or bid caps): cost of service regulation that disincent supply The ISO will hold in-state resources hostage--cuts any exports when reserves fall below a stated critera Imports can only participate as price takers. Thus if the highest-cost in-state resource is below the opportunity cost of power, needed imports will not come in:
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
>>this will decrease supply!! >> Staffer stated ISO hopes to sign "longer term deals" if necessary to secure out-of-state power but acknowledged the proposal needs more work. The Bad: The ISO is considering pay as bid, which is complex and does not increase supply. However, on the call they said they are leaing to a single price auction. However, with bid caps the market will still be distorted. The Good?: The ISO wll implement an hourly day-ahead and hour-ahead market, essentially filling a void created by the PX's demise. >>( Enron has strongly advocated market seperation in the past but do we want to consider supporting a day ahead market?) Market separation rules (MSR). ISO is leaning towards option 2 in which SCs submit bundled schedules but that market seperation would be suspended after congestion process is conducted; i.e., final schedules may be imbalanced. >>What do we think of this? .