12 Jan 2001, 11:02 UTC
Performance Review Process
- From
- Enron Announcements enron.announcements@enron.com
- Date
- Fri, 12 Jan 2001 03:02:00 -0800 (PST)
With the extension of the PRC to all organizations, questions have arisen about the results of this process. This memo provides some details about the PRC process. First some context: The key to Enron,s success is the increasing quality and dedication of our talent. As we continue to attract and retain the very best people, we all have continued to raise the performance bar throughout the organization. At the core of our system are the following principles: ? Hire the best people. ? Provide challenging opportunities. ? Pay well ( and pay for performance (with bonuses based on merit, not entitlement). ? Evaluate performance through a rigorous review process. ? Provide clear feedback and direction to employees. The PRC is a critical component of our performance management system. The PRC is built on this foundation: ? 360 degree performance feedback. ? Review by a broad group, not just the supervisor. ? A relative ranking of performance across Enron to determine promotions and to allocate bonus money. In addition to understanding this broad philosophy, we all need to understand the following details: ? Relative ranking. Enron uses the descriptors &superior8, &excellent8, &strong8, "satisfactory", &needs improvement8, and &issues8 to group all employees. This year, &relative to his/her peers8 precedes each of these descriptors. This qualifier confirms what we have done and will continue to do in practice; that is, evaluate individual performers against their peers. It is possible, therefore, for someone to perform at the same or higher level compared to prior periods, yet receive a lower rating for the current period if other employees, performance raised the bar. ? Teamwork. A relative ranking may invite the view that for one employee to gain, others must suffer. However, feedback is explicitly solicited on teamwork when evaluating each individual,s performance. Anyone who attempts to gain by withholding information or refusing to collaborate with others in the organization will suffer in a relative ranking on this key performance criterion. ? Preferred distribution. In large part, the quality of our workforce has been driven by our willingness to make tough decisions. We have consistently captured business opportunities and overcome obstacles because we have made the choices that had to be made in order to constantly improve our employee talent base. The preferred distribution (5% superior, 30% excellent, 30% strong, 20% satisfactory, and 15% needs improvement or issues) forces PRC committee members to identify those who must improve in order to remain at Enron as well as to single out top talent for special recognition. There is some flexibility in the system, but every organization must ultimately face this difficult question: have we achieved the highest level of performance or are there still improvements that must be made? Few, if any, organizations adhere exactly to the preferred distribution. Rather, they exercise informed discretion in the individual categories and meet a distribution that reflects their groups, overall effectiveness and need for improvement. ? Communicating Ratings. Everyone rated &satisfactory8 or below should know his/her rating. Each organization has determined for itself whether to communicate ratings of &strong8 and above. In all cases, employees will receive feedback about their performance against expectations, areas of success, and areas that need improvement. We hope this answers most of your questions about the PRC process. We would like your feedback and ideas on how to improve the PRC process going forward. Therefore, we will be conducting an eSpeak in the near future, and there will be other methods we will create to let us know what you think. In the meantime, please feel free to consult with your HR Generalist if you have any immediate questions, comments, or concerns.