29 Sep 2000, 18:01 UTC
Utilities, Electric: Deregulation: Consumer Outrage in California
- From
- Miyung Buster miyung.buster@enron.com
- Bcc
- Steven J Kean
- Date
- Fri, 29 Sep 2000 11:01:00 -0700 (PDT)
The sender added no text of their own; everything below is quoted or forwarded.
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
----- Forwarded by Miyung Buster/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT on 09/29/2000 06:01 PM ----- djcustomclips@djinteractive.com 09/27/2000 02:31 PM Please respond to nobody To: 86464@WCTOPICS.djnr.com cc: Subject: Utilities, Electric: Deregulation: Consumer Outrage in California Consumer Outrage in California Al Senia ? 09/30/2000 Utility Business Copyright 2000 by Intertec Publishing Corporation, a PRIMEDIA Company. All rights reserved. Sempra sits on the hot seat as California rides out the effects of its efforts at deregulation. Wild fires have swept the western United States this year, but they are nothing like the fire storm over energy deregulation that has engulfed San Diego's Sempra Energy. By a quirk of business fate, the 1.2 million customers of Sempra's San Diego Gas&Electric division in July became the first to experience fully deregulated electricity rates in California. Electricity bills instantly doubled and tripled. The expectation was that deregulation would cause prices to drop, not spike. The resultant outcry threatens to derail the state's fledgling deregulation program and shape the future of deregulation nationally. It also situates Sempra squarely on the hot seat at a time when its profits are on the rise. Does Sempra deserve to be in this position? Like many other deregulated utilities around the nation, Sempra is in the midst of transforming itself from a regulated utility business (SDG&E) to a broad-based energy company that offers a variety of value-added services. Under the direction of Sempra President and Chief Executive Officer Stephen L. Baum, that process has been especially robust. The company has launched a number of domestic and international strategic initiatives designed to accelerate earnings growth by an average of 8 percent to 10 percent annually and generate at least one-third of the earnings from unregulated businesses by 2003. Baum, who became chairman this month, intends to change the focus of Sempra's overall business to cope with deregulation. He wants to further diversify the company, create a strong retail energy business, pursue selective international investments and capitalize on emerging technologies. "I want the company...to have a large and diverse customer base nationwide and worldwide in which we're moving from an asset-intensive business to a customer- and products- and risk-management-intensive business," says Baum. So far, the strategy seems to be working - maybe a little too well. Profits soared 34 percent in the second quarter from $82 million last year to $110 million this year. One big contributor was the Sempra Energy trading subsidiary, which deals in electricity, natural gas and oil. Its profit soared in the second quarter this year to $40 million from $3 million in 1999. So far, so good, but the rosy revenues and profit propelled Sempra's San Diego Gas&Electric to become the first utility in the state to pay off all its bonds floated to pay for "stranded costs." These are expenses (such as past massive nuclear power plant investments) incurred in the previously regulated market that may not be fully recoverable in a competitive market. Those bond payoffs triggered the full force of the free market, since the artificial price caps on electricity prices, which were put into place as a transitional arrangement by the state legislature to make deregulation politically palatable, automatically expired with the bonds. Since California's deregulation law required the state's utilities to sell off their generation businesses and stick to delivering energy, SDGOnow buys its power in an open market through the California Power Exchange. That arrangement tends to favor large businesses that can more easily shop for their electricity supplies. With the bonds paid off, the Sempra division now passes the full cost of that power to its customers (California's other utilities are not expected to reach this point until 2002). And with the demand for power rising in the state while supplies fall short, the cost for Sempra customers is up. Way up. SDGOis paying as much as 10 times the regular cost for electricity every time a summer heat wave hits. Through its success, Sempra pushed the door open into a pure, deregulated market nearly two years before anyone in California expected it. What industry executives, politicians, consumer advocates and ratepayers quickly discovered is that energy demand is rising, there aren't enough power plants to meet demand and prices are skyrocketing. Even with the higher prices, there may not be enough electricity to go around. So during hot spells, rolling one-hour energy blackouts throughout the state became a possibility for the first time since World War II. Sempra claims it's merely following the state's deregulation orders, but consumer advocates are outraged that the parent company (through its trading subsidiary) benefits from energy price volatility. They want some of the company profits to go back to SDGOto lower customer utility bills. That isn't Sempra's (and the other state utility holding companies') only problem. Bill-burning protests are being organized in downtown San Diego. San Diego Mayor Susan Goldberg wants the state attorney general to probe whether there has been "collusion, price fixing or any other inappropriate behavior in the market price of electricity." The state legislature is being asked to consider reversing or postponing the deregulation effort. Some legislators have launched an effort to roll back utility rates. The architect of the deregulation law is under fire for alleged close ties to the utility companies. State Public Utility Commission member Carl Wood calls deregulation a mistake and accuses unnamed power players of profiteering at the consumer's expense. Even California Gov. Gray Davis has gotten critical. "Californians are willing to pay their fair share of the cost for a reliable supply of electricity, but I believe the current situation is unjust and totally unacceptable," Davis says. He successfully pushed the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission to investigate wholesale energy prices in the western United States, believing it would lead to short-term federal price controls. The governor also proposed a plan in mid-August to the Public Utility Commission that would average consumers' bills over a 12-month period to make monthly statements predictable. He says deregulation can work, but not until supply and demand come into balance and "until electricity generators act responsibly." It's no wonder Davis wants the feds involved - the state doesn't have much power over power anymore now that deregulation has become state law. Despite Davis' hopes, a supply balance isn't likely to return to California anytime soon. The state's last major power plant, a nuclear facility at Diablo Canyon, went online 15 years ago. Since then, the state's population has grown by 8 million, and 3.5 million new jobs have been created. Four new plants are under construction, but that isn't enough to meet escalating demand, and the first plant won't come online for a year. Meanwhile, market uncertainty - and increasing calls for reregulation - aren't doing much to attract new power plant investment. Reliant Energy Inc., for example, has backed off a plan to build a plant in Barstow, Calif. Calpine Corp. wants to build a power plant in San Jose, the center of Silicon Valley, but the effort is strongly opposed by local businesses and residents. A 700-megawatt plant proposed for a desert area is mired down in a regulatory morass. However, Duke Energy North America, which purchased several state power plants in 1998, expects to invest more than $1 billion to build and expand power plants in California over the next four years. Sempra's Plans Sempra has its own view of the escalating imbroglio. Baum wants the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission to determine if the power market is being manipulated and then step in if necessary and set wholesale energy prices. He also believes utilities, with Public Utility Commission approval, should install time-of-use meters throughout the state so customers could control their own power load. Baum also suggests that the Public Utility Commission allow SDGOto purchase futures contracts for its customers. Baum wants the authority to aggregate SDGOcustomers (if they choose) into one "market" to get a better price. Meanwhile, he's hoping the controversy won't derail Sempra's business plans. These plans include six strategic directions: expanding the retail energy services business; exporting its traditional utility experience overseas; boosting the energy trading business; selectively developing supporting generation; capitalizing on emerging technologies like the Internet and the applications services business; and focusing the core utility company on energy delivery. Baum intends to spend $4 billion in capital investment during the next four years with delivery services getting half that amount and the international and retail operations equally splitting another $1.5 billion. Baum estimates Sempra's energy trading business will bring in $40 million to $55 million in profit by 2003. It's already well ahead of that pace for this year, but the business is highly volatile. International operations will generate another $40 million to $60 million in annual profit in four years. Sempra's retail energy business, operated as Sempra Energy Solutions, will generate between $30 million and $70 million, he estimates. "Ultimately, I think the big opportunity in the utility business we are in lies with this industrial, commercial residential mass market and the products and services business,"Baum says. International operations look to be another key strategic area for Sempra, in part due to the company's location near the Mexico border. It has made significant natural gas investments in northern Mexico. The division develops, owns and operates energy projects and provides natural gas and electricity energy services for 2.5 million customers in Argentina, Canada, Chile, Mexico, Peru and Uruguay. Baum says it is pursuing new opportunities in Latin America. "International is a much more traditional utility business (than other new businesses Sempra is getting into)," Baum says. "We look to (invest in) areas with a high rate of growth, 6 percent or more, in stable economies. We think those are good investments. We have more than $1 billion invested internationally, usually in partnerships." Some analysts view the international business as inherently risky given the possibility of political and economic change. Baum disagrees. "We think on a risk-adjusted basis this is a good, solid, growing business," he says. "All our (international) businesses are making money. We are not in a loss condition in any of our international operations. They make their expected returns and their cash flow. It's the kind of business we have done for years." Baum is optimistic that the new Sempra can deliver strong performance as it refocuses on a deregulated world. Analysts seem pleased. "They have a well-developed, well thought-out strategy," says David Maccarone, vice president of New York-based Goldman Sachs&Co. "The latest financial performance is impressive." Maccarone adds that the trading business is benefiting from "highly favorable market conditions that are not sustainable." Overall, the international business is doing well. The only dark cloud? The aftermath of California deregulation. "There's an uncertain regulatory climate in California," he says. "It's never been regarded as a favorable state to do business in from a utility perspective. Still, I'm optimistic there won't be a substantial negative impact." Meanwhile, the controversy is bringing back bad memories. In the 1970s, before Sempra existed, SDGOwas notorious for high rates. The utility was so unpopular that officials painted over the company logo on its truck fleet. Baum is trying to stop that from happening again. Maccarone believes Sempra is a victim of its own success. "They recovered their liability faster than other California utilities," he says. "Now they are getting branded for it." Folder Name: Utilities, Electric: Deregulation Relevance Score on Scale of 100: 98 ______________________________________________________________________ To review or revise your folder, visit Dow Jones CustomClipsor contact Dow Jones Customer Service by e-mail at custom.news@bis.dowjones.comor by phone at 800-369-7466. (Outside the U.S. and Canada, call 609-452-1511 or contact your local sales representative.) ______________________________________________________________________ Copyright (c) 2000 Dow Jones &Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved