Enron email

Algorithmic Indexing

29 Nov 2000, 06:03 UTC

FW: FYI two articles from Tuesday (in case you missed them)

From
Carla Hoffman carla.hoffman@enron.com
To
Tim Belden, Robert Badeer, Jeff Richter, Phillip Platter, Mike Swerzbin, Diana Scholtes, Sean Crandall, Matt Motley, Mark Guzman, Tom Alonso, Mark Fischer, Monica Lande
Date
Tue, 28 Nov 2000 22:03:00 -0800 (PST)

The sender added no text of their own; everything below is quoted or forwarded.

Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
---------------------- Forwarded by Carla Hoffman/PDX/ECT on 11/29/2000 06:12 
AM ---------------------------
   
	Enron Capital & Trade Resources Corp.
	
	From:  "Pergher, Gunther" <Gunther.Pergher@dowjones.com>                      
     11/29/2000 06:05 AM
	

To: undisclosed-recipients:;
cc:  
Subject: FW: FYI two articles from Tuesday (in case you missed them)




> -----Original Message-----
> From: Golden, Mark
> Sent: Tuesday, November 28, 2000 6:56 PM
> To: Pergher, Gunther
> Subject: FYI two articles from Tuesday (in case you missed them)
>
> FERC Unclear On Pay For Must-Run Units, Capital Return
>    By Jason Leopold and Mark Golden
>    OF DOW JONES NEWSWIRES
>
>   NEW YORK (Dow Jones)--The U.S. Federal Energy Regulatory Commission,
> which is
> working on its final order to fix California's broken electricity market,
> isn't
> clear on how the new rules will price power from must-run generators or
> how
> generators will be paid a return on their capital investments, a FERC
> commissioner said Tuesday.
>   In its preliminary proposal Nov. 1, FERC said that  California's
> wholesale
> electricity market price could have a "soft cap" of $150 a megawatt-hour,
> but
> the state could purchase additional power at more than $150/MWh if needed.
> Suppliers would be paid the price at which they bid in their power would
> have to
> justify why their costs exceed $150/MWh. Further, the FERC could lower the
> sales
> price upon review.
>   As reported Monday, FERC commissioners likely will set the "soft cap" at
> $100/MWh in the final ruling, which is expected in the middle of December,
> instead of the initially proposed $150/MWh.
>   The FERC, however, still doesn't know how generators selling power above
> the
> cap will be reimbursed for investment in addition to marginal generating
> costs.
> When generators are paid only their marginal costs, they have no money
> left to
> pay off fixed costs and go broke. Fixed-cost recovery as a percentage of
> per
> megawatt-hour sales price varies widely based on how many hours a year a
> generator operates. Inefficient peaking units that run only a couple
> hundred
> hours a year, for example, need to be paid very high prices per hour to
> cover
> fixed costs.
>   In addition, the state has contracts with several independent power
> producers
> whose generators must run - or at least be available to run - all the time
> for
> system reliability. Currently, these "resource must-run" units get paid
> the
> market clearing price, but a clearing price of $100/MWh won't cover the
> fixed
> costs of gas-fired units at current prices for natural gas in California.
>   "We're not clear on these issues, and we're seeking comments on them,"
> said
> the commissioner, who spoke on the condition of anonymity.
>   Others in the industry are also skeptical about how the new "soft cap"
> will
> work.
>   "I don't think the FERC knows what it's getting itself into. Maybe they
> will
> just take all these documents and sit on them for years, and never change
> the
> prices," Dynegy (DYN) Marketing & Trade senior vice president, Lynn
> Lednicky
> said Tuesday while attending a CalPX conference in New York City.
>   -By Jason Leopold and Mark Golden, Dow Jones Newswires; 201-938-4604;
> mark.golden@dowjones.com
>
>   (END) Dow Jones Newswires  28-11-00
>   2333GMT(AP-DJ-11-28-00 2333GMT)
>
>
> Cal PX Panel: Building Forward Market Key To Power Woes
>     By Mark Golden
>    Of DOW JONES NEWSWIRES
>
>   NEW YORK (Dow Jones)--A panel of market economists assembled by the
> California
> Power Exchange debated Tuesday whether the CalPX should move from a
> single-price
> auction for pricing electricity in the spot market to an "as-bid" market,
> which
> the U.S. Federal Energy Regulatory Commission has proposed.
>   The consensus, however, was that moving purchases out of the spot market
> into
> a forward market is more important to solving California's electricity
> crisis,
> and that if a forward market develops, the pricing mechanism of the CalPX
> spot
> market won't be that important.
>   "Dynegy favors an as-bid market, but it's not a matter of religion for
> us,"
> Dynegy (DYN) Marketing and Trade senior vice president, Lynn Lednicky,
> told the
> economists.
>   "If I could wave a magic wand and create a forward market for
> California, I
> wouldn't get all excited about whether the spot market is single-price or
> as-bid," Lednicky said.
>   Under its current single-price auction, the CalPX pays all suppliers the
> price
> for the last, most expensive megawatt taken for a given hour the next day.
> In
> the FERC proposed as-bid market, suppliers whose energy is taken would get
> paid
> only the price at which they offered to sell their electricity to the
> states'
> three main utilities.
>   The economists agreed that California legislators and regulators erred
> gravely
> in prohibiting utilities from entering into long-term forward contracts
> with
> suppliers when they began to deregulate the industry in 1996.
>   "What were they thinking? Were they thinking at all?" asked University
> of
> Maryland professor Peter Crampton.
>   Even though California utilities are no longer prohibited from
> participating
> in the spot market in general, the California Public Utilities Commission
> still
> hasn't approved any forward market contracts put before them by utilities
> that
> have reached agreements with suppliers, Lednicky said.
>   Crampton, nevertheless, thinks that keeping the single-price auction
> would
> help promote a forward market. Single-price auctions are more volatile
> than
> as-bid markets, Crampton said, and forward markets are used more when spot
> markets are more volatile. In addition, the single-price mechanism should
> be
> kept because an as-bid market is a disadvantage to smaller generators, who
> would
> have to spend a lot of resources relative to their size constantly
> figuring out
> how to bid in their power, Crampton said.
>   When asked, Lednicky agreed that the FERC proposal, which was issued
> Nov. 1
> and will result in a final order around the middle of December, isn't
> really an
> as-bid market anyway. FERC said that the clearing price could be capped at
> $150
> a megawatt-hour and that the CalPX could purchase additional power at more
> than
> $150/MWh as-bid, but suppliers would have to justify their prices by
> documenting
> costs, and the FERC could lower the sales price after the fact. As
> reported
> Monday by Dow Jones Newswires, FERC likely will set the "soft cap" at
> $100/MWh
> instead of $150/MWh in the final ruling.
>   Also, FERC would have to decide how more expensive generating plants
> would be
> reimbursed for investment in addition to marginal costs. Investment
> recovery as
> a percentage of sales price varies widely based on how many hours a year a
> generator operates.
>   "I don't think the FERC knows what it's getting itself into. Maybe they
> will
> just take all these documents and sit on them for years, and never change
> the
> prices," Lednicky said.
>   The panelists and other participants Tuesday seemed to agree that an
> as-bid
> pricing mechanism probably won't lower prices that much over the long
> term, but
> it may lower prices significantly in the short run. They also agreed that
> the
> constant changing of market rules and the regulatory environment in
> California
> is a disincentive to investment in building new power plants in and around
> the
> state.
>   By Mark Golden, Dow Jones Newswires; 201-938-4604;
> mark.golden@dowjones.com
>
>   (END) Dow Jones Newswires  28-11-00
>   2159GMT(AP-DJ-11-28-00 2159GMT)
>