12 Sep 2000, 08:19 UTC
Price Gouging in CA
- From
- Gavin Dillingham gavin.dillingham@enron.com
- Date
- Tue, 12 Sep 2000 01:19:00 -0700 (PDT)
Former Lawmaker Fingers Federal Agencies and LADWP in Class-Action Suit on Price Gouging Sept 11 (California Energy Markets) Larry Stirling, a candidate for the California state Senate seat now occupied by Senator Dede Alpert (D-Coronado), has filed a federal lawsuit against nearly everyone under the sun, alleging that hydro-electricity from federal power agencies was illegally marked up and resold into California at illegal and excessive rates. Stirling, a former state legislator in both the Assembly and the Senate from 1980 to 1989, has been a judge at the Superior Court level since 1989. The suit, filed August 31 in Federal District Court for Southern California, names a variety of defendants--including Secretary of Energy Bill Richardson, the Western Area Power Administration, the Bonneville Power Administration, the Los Angeles Department of Water & Power, San Diego Gas & Electric, the California Power Exchange, the California Independent System Operator and a host of unidentified "John Doe" individuals deemed responsible for the situation [Stirling et al. v. Richardson et al.; CU1745-W-NLS]. However, the suit specifically alleges that LADWP engaged in price gouging by purchasing federal power and reselling it to the CalPX and Cal-ISO at higher prices. In particular, Stirling's complaint cites Federal Code 16 USC Section 825s, "which provides that Secretary of Energy shall transmit and dispose of excess power and energy in such manner as to encourage the most widespread use thereof at the lowest possible rates to consumers." The case was filed as a class action, putting the number of plaintiffs at more than one million--essentially all consumers of electricity in SDG&E territory--and seeks damages that might include a refund of power prices charged this past summer. Richard Wildman, a San Diego attorney who represents Stirling, told CALIFORNIA ENERGY MARKETS, "What we reasonably hope to accomplish is to have the parties agree that the purpose of the federal code section is that consumers receive this low-cost energy." He said that LADWP was specifically identified in the suit because it is "sending power through the grid and making substantial profit off this energy." While LADWP does not deny doing well in wholesale energy transactions this summer, it rejects allegations of wrongdoing. Stan Snyder, assistant Los Angeles city attorney, this week responded that the suit "frivolously" named LADWP as a defendant. "The department does not sell federal hydro," Snyder told CEM. Even if the department purchased energy from WAPA or BPA, it would not be selling the same energy at wholesale. "Hydro is reserved for consumers in Los Angeles. The department sells excess coal and gas power. We always keep cheaper power in the basin to sell excess power," Snyder said. He cited the department's own Haynes, Scattergood and Valley gas-fired plants, the Mohave and Intermountain coal projects and the Castaic pumped-hydro facility as possible sources of excess power sold into CalPX and Cal-ISO markets. There is no prohibition against reselling of federal power, although it is unlikely that any California entity could make a profit off repackaging BPA surplus energy, which, when available, is usually indexed to the CalPX import price. In addition, BPA said it was unaware of any long-term contract to sell to LADWP. "I think they are confusing us with WAPA," BPA spokesperson Perry Gruber said. Stirling's "facts do not support the lawsuit," LA's Snyder said, and the official response from the city puts Stirling on notice that if he pursues the case, he could be liable for sanctions. Stirling has been making energy price hikes part of his campaign for Alpert's seat in the California Senate. Alpert is a coauthor of recently signed legislation to cap SDG&E retail bills (see story at [17]). In a position statement on his Web site, Stirling said Alpert and other Democrats "voted to butcher our power-supply system," putting San Diego consumers "at the mercy of every producer including the venal conduct of our neighbor to the north, Los Angeles Water and Power Department [sic] that is profiting mightily at our distress along with the Federal Western Area Power Administration." Stirling railed against federal power agencies and state regulators alike for the mess. "Were there no California Public Utilities Commission and no federal government WAPA controlling federal hydropower and no California State Energy Commission, there would have long since been an adequate supply ofreasonably priced energy available to the people of San Diego," he wrote [Arthur O'Donnell].