4 Apr 2001, 12:34 UTC
Re: Davis' solutions may be in trouble: New plants built in California don't have to sell electricity here, state lawyers conclude
- From
- Steve C Hall steve.hall@enron.com
- To
- Alan Comnes
- Cc
- Ronald Carroll, Tim Belden, Sean Crandall, Susan J Mara, Jeff Dasovich, Steve Walton, Christi L Nicolay, Christian Yoder
- Bcc
- Ronald Carroll, Tim Belden, Sean Crandall, Susan J Mara, Jeff Dasovich, Steve Walton, Christi L Nicolay, Christian Yoder
- Date
- Wed, 4 Apr 2001 05:34:00 -0700 (PDT)
California is just figuring this out? As any second-year law student could tell you, the problem with conditioning fast-track permitting on selling electricity to California is that it violates the holding in the 1994 U.S. Supreme Court case Dolan v. City of Tigard (city could not require hardward store to "donate" land for a bike-path as a condition to granting a permit to expand the hardware's parking lot). Steve
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
Alan Comnes 04/04/2001 10:52 AM To: Rcarroll@bracepatt.com, Tim Belden/HOU/ECT@ECT, Steve C Hall/PDX/ECT@ECT, Sean Crandall/PDX/ECT@ECT, Susan J Mara/NA/Enron@ENRON, Jeff Dasovich/NA/Enron@Enron, Steve Walton/HOU/ECT@ECT, Christi L Nicolay/HOU/ECT@ECT cc: Subject: Davis' solutions may be in trouble: New plants built in California don't have to sell electricity here, state lawyers conclude At least one state agency says you cannot cut exports. We should probably cite this in our Reliant complaints response. Davis' solutions may be in trouble: New plants built in California don't have to sell electricity here, state lawyers conclude By Carrie Peyton Bee Staff Writer (Published April 4, 2001) California can't require builders of new power plants to sell electricity here, even as a trade-off for super-fast environmental review, lawyers at the state Energy Commission have concluded. Their position, reached despite Gov. Gray Davis' vow that new megawatts "will stay in California," emerged as part of a fast-track approval for expanding a south state power plant. It comes as the agency that oversees plant licensing is whittling away at the presumption that emergency "peaking" plants installed this summer will be temporary. Some of the peaking plants - to be used only at times of highest energy demand - are now proposed to stay in place 30 to 40 years. Both issues have bubbled up quietly during California Energy Commission reviews, sometimes addressed only indirectly in staff reports. "This is a major public policy issue for all of California. If we're building these plants on an expedited basis and we're not getting any electricity out of it, why are we doing it?" asked William Workman, Huntington Beach assistant city administrator. The answer, according to the Governor's Office and the Energy Commission, is twofold. First, the plants are needed no matter what, because the entire West is power poor. And second, it looks like a California sales clause would violate federal interstate commerce law. "We're not supposed to take protectionist action against our fellow states," said Bill Chamberlain, chief counsel to the Energy Commission. He said numerous Supreme Court decisions have held that a state can't use its regulatory powers - such as permitting processes - to give its residents an economic advantage. Although there is no guarantee, the Governor's Office, power plant builders and the state Environmental Protection Agency say most of the plants being rushed to life will probably end up selling to the state Department of Water Resources. "The people who are building these power plants know very well that we expect it to be used in California, and we're confident that it will be," Davis spokesman Roger Salazar said. Cal-EPA Secretary Winston Hickox said the "preponderance" of new peaking plants will devote their electricity to California. "We will do everything that we can to encourage that the energy produced as a result of our bending over backward to be accommodating is sold to California. We're not there yet, but I believe we'll get there," Hickox said. He also said the three-week reviews of peaking plants have cut no corners in terms of fundamental environmental standards. Two of those plants scheduled for Energy Commission votes today were praised by environmentalists as having relatively low emissions of smog-forming compounds, but they still were concerned by the 21-day review. "If you're having a quick review, a plant shouldn't be allowed to continue for more than the summer," said Gail Ruderman Feuer of the Natural Resources Defense Counsel. The first peaking plant approved by the commission, the United Golden Gate Project in San Mateo County, was given permission to run for three years. But the next two, in San Diego and Palm Springs, are being recommended for indefinite approval, and their builder, InterGen North America, said it intends to keep them running for 30 to 40 years. "There's no way affected communities can know what's going on with the processes that are so short," said Sandra Spelliscy, general counsel of the Planning and Conservation League. "I don't want to say negative things about that particular peaker (but) ( I think we're going to wake up in six to 12 months and realize we did a lot of stuff that we regret." In Huntington Beach, city officials say they are largely pleased with the fast-track process that protected most of their major concerns over a proposal by AES to quickly revive two mothballed steam turbines at its seaside plant. But a slower review process would have offered even more, Workman said. It would have delayed the plant for results of studies on sea life injured or killed by cooling water intakes and potential increases in ocean pollution. He worries that his city's residents gave up those protections without any certainty that California will benefit from the extra 450 megawatts AES will be able to crank out. Huntington Beach sought a California buyer clause in the AES permit, which is scheduled for an Energy Commission vote next week, but it was rejected in a cryptic report that only notes the commission staff has taken no stand on the issue. AES would have opposed such a provision, because it believes the Energy Commission has no authority to tell it where to sell, said Aaron Thomas, a manager at AES Pacific. "In our case, there is no need to have a shotgun to our head," he said. AES is negotiating to sell all 450 megawatts to the state. Meanwhile, the governor acknowledged what an Energy Commission report outlined last week - that his goal of 5,000 more megawatts online by July will not be met. "We have a real challenge in the early part of the summer," Davis said Tuesday. "We do have more than 4,000 megawatts coming online by late summer. Usually, the challenge is in August and September. This year, the challenge may well be in May and June." The Bee's Carrie Peyton can be reached at (916) 321-1086, cpeyton@sacbee.com. Emily Bazar of The Bee Capitol Bureau contributed to this report. NEWS SEARCH Search local and national political news. anyall of the search words. Problems? Suggestions? Let us hear from you. | Copyright , The Sacramento Bee