3 Jan 2001, 15:38 UTC
USA Today Opinion - Electricity Prices
- From
- Richard Shapiro richard.shapiro@enron.com
- Date
- Wed, 3 Jan 2001 07:38:00 -0800 (PST)
The sender added no text of their own; everything below is quoted or forwarded.
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
---------------------- Forwarded by Richard Shapiro/NA/Enron on 01/03/2001 03:38 PM --------------------------- From: Ann M Schmidt 01/03/2001 03:31 PM To: Karen Denne/Corp/Enron@ENRON, Vance Meyer/NA/Enron@ENRON, Meredith Philipp/Corp/Enron@ENRON, Steven J Kean/NA/Enron@Enron, Eric Thode/Corp/Enron@ENRON, James D Steffes/NA/Enron@Enron, Richard Shapiro/NA/Enron@Enron, Damon Harvey/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, Gia Maisashvili/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, John Neslage/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT cc: Subject: USA Today Opinion - Electricity Prices http://www.usatoday.com/news/comment/debate.htm 01/03/01- Updated 02:37 AM ET ? Prices spike as Calif. bungles deregulation When Californians bought into the idea of deregulated electricity in 1996, they did so on the promise they'd get reliable power at cheap prices. Instead, they're facing power shortages and whopping bills. The state's public utilities commission is scheduled to decide Thursday whether to let two big utilities raise rates by up to 30%, ending a price freeze that was supposed to last until 2002. Financially strapped utilities, meanwhile, are threatening blackouts. With electricity deregulation underway in 23 other states, households nationwide should be wondering whether they'll be next to face California-style chaos. It is a red flag that electricity deregulation, which continues to hold promise for lower rates, must be approached cautiously and gradually. California made a series of remarkably large blunders, many encouraged by utilities, that set the state on a dangerous path to deregulation without the competition needed to hold down prices. Unless the state corrects those errors, matters will get worse when full deregulation comes in two years. Much of the state could be served by power monopolies free to hike prices. The good news is that other deregulating states have planned better, though the process in those states is less advanced than in California. Among California's failings: Utilities were barred from raising rates to consumers but had to cope with market prices from power plants. When deregulation began, the utilities heartily backed the arrangement, because the frozen prices were far higher than the market prices they paid. Now, with a national energy shortage pushing prices higher, they're worried about bankruptcy, threatening blackouts and pleading for relief. Some seek re-regulation to protect themselves from their own ineptitude. The state failed to bring enough new supply online before deregulating. No major plants were built in the previous decade, contributing to a supply crunch in a state where electricity demand has been growing 4%-6% per year. By contrast, Texas, which is rolling out its deregulation more slowly, has since 1996 built 23 new plants that have added 15% more power-generation. California tried to manipulate prices and blew it. The state required utilities to buy all of their power from a "power exchange" in short-term blocks. This prevented utilities from entering long-term contracts or adopting hedging strategies that could keep prices stable. After prices spiked, the government worsened the situation by trying to cap prices utilities could pay for power. Not surprisingly, power suppliers then sold their electricity to other states without price caps, where they could get a better return. Result: power shortages rectified only by an emergency federal order that some out-of-state plants in the West sell California electricity. Price controls were lifted. Other states have avoided this problem. New York, for instance, encouraged its utilities to enter into "transition contracts" under which plants have an obligation to sell them power. Similarly, Texas has long-term contracts, under which the utilities buy power for long periods at set prices, allowing them to hedge against short-term changes in price. The price of all this bungling will be huge for Californians, but households outside California may pay as well. The Western plants that the federal government has forced to supply California's thirst could in time have difficulty supplying their traditional customers, driving up their prices. In the extreme, the financial instability of California utilities Pacific Gas and Electric and Southern California Edison could roil markets and add to recession pressures. At a minimum, most Californians will soon face significant financial pain * unwarranted on their part * to pay for the botched deregulation either through taxes or higher rates. If this bailout isn't accompanied by new rules, the 2002 ending of price caps may bring the worst of all worlds: monopoly markets without price controls. Long term, the best hope for controlling prices is competition, but California has yet to come up with a convincing plan to make sure that exists. In fact, in the San Diego area, where controls were briefly lifted without significant new competition, prices more than doubled. Some advocacy groups and politicians are calling for more radical solutions, such as a state buyout of the utilities or simple refusal to pay the utilities on the grounds they must be hiding money somewhere. The utilities, having tasted their own medicine, now say they'd support re-regulation. But none of these fixes would save California's consumers from the dim-bulb management that has put the state at risk of power outages and financial catastrophe. California Gov. Gray Davis' said recently that "if deregulation fails in California, it is dead in America." To the contrary, as California does its repair work, the rest of the county will be taking notes on how not to deregulate as carelessly as California did. ? ? ? ? ? 01/03/01- Updated 02:38 AM ET ? Learn from California mistake By Harvey Rosenfield and Douglas Heller The myth of electricity deregulation has met reality in California, and the result is a $40 billion debacle. Awash in energy-industry campaign contributions, California lawmakers freed the state's utility companies of price controls in 1996. Consumers were ordered to pay off the utilities' debts, after which competition was supposed to kick in, guaranteeing a 20% rate cut by 2002. Deregulation proved a bonanza for the utilities. They sold some of their power plants and collected $19 billion in ratepayer subsidies. They used the money to purchase plants in other countries, reward their executives with huge pay raises, buy back stock and increase dividends. Profits reached record levels this year. Envious, the handful of unregulated companies that control nearly half of the state's electricity generation decided to cash in, too. This cartel began to withhold power, causing shortages that boosted the wholesale price of electricity that utility companies must buy by 3,900%. But, ironically, because of the way they wrote the deregulation law, the utilities are forbidden to pass the higher costs on to most consumers until 2002. Now the companies want to rewrite the law. When public officials resisted the utilities' demands for immediate rate hikes, the utilities threatened blackouts and bankruptcy. When that economic extortion failed, Wall Street issued an ultimatum: Order a 20% rate hike within 48 hours, as a first installment of an $11 billion ratepayer bailout, or Wall Street would itself force the utilities into bankruptcy. California has learned the hard way that electricity is too vital to be left in the hands of unregulated corporations whose sole interest is maximizing profits. Facing a ratepayer revolt, state officials have re-imposed regulation. To make electricity reliable and affordable once more, they are considering establishing a non-profit, publicly owned power system for the state. But, in the meantime, the deregulation disaster could end up costing each Californian $12,500. Meanwhile, elsewhere in the nation, corporate-funded ideologues and academics continue to promote electricity deregulation, much as they promoted loosening controls on savings and loans in the 1980s. Whenever you hear the word "deregulation," hold onto your wallets: Some industry is about to pick your pocket. Harvey Rosenfield and Douglas Heller are consumer advocates with the Foundation for Taxpayer and Consumer Rights. Its Web site: www.consumerwatchdog.org.