7 Nov 2000, 23:53 UTC
Sen. Peace's Letter to FERC
- From
- V.John White vjw@cleanpower.org
- Date
- Tue, 7 Nov 2000 15:53:00 -0800 (PST)
The sender added no text of their own; everything below is quoted or forwarded.
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
>MR-Received: by mta SENAT2; Relayed; Fri, 03 Nov 2000 08:40:42 -0700 >MR-Received: by mta LINET; Relayed; Fri, 03 Nov 2000 08:41:01 -0700 >Alternate-recipient: prohibited >Date: Fri, 03 Nov 2000 16:40:40 -0700 (PDT) >From: John Rozsa <John.Rozsa@SEN.CA.GOV> >Subject: Re: Re: >To: "V. John White" <vjw@cleanpower.org> >Posting-date: Fri, 03 Nov 2000 16:40:41 -0700 (PDT) >Importance: normal >Priority: normal >Sensitivity: Company-Confidential >UA-content-id: B1638ISH1UZZP >A1-type: MAIL >Hop-count: 2 > >I pasted it in. > > > > > > > >November 1, 2000 > > > >Chairman James Hoecker >Federal Energy Regulatory Commission >888 First Street, N.E. >Washington, DC 20426 > >Dear Chairman Hoecker: > >I want to compliment you and your fellow Commissioners and staff on >the substance of your initial proposed order concerning the California >market. I am writing to share my initial reaction and expect to >provide more detailed comments in the near future. > >While the proposed order is not as clear and unambiguous as I would >like it to be, your call for sweeping changes in the FERC-approved >tariffs which were filed in December of 1995 is an important >contribution to at least partially mitigating the exercise of market >power as well as helping to establish the legal basis for what will >surely prove to be a vigorous court fight. > >Your unambiguous declaration that the rates being charged in the >wholesale market are, and have been, "unjust and unreasonable", would >have restored credibility to the wholesale market. But your action is >more than adequate for the California Public Utilities Commission to >deny the applicability of the filed rate doctrine to the wholesale >prices produced by a FERC-approved tariff, which FERC has now ruled >failed to produce "just and reasonable" rates. > >For California consumers, it means that there is now a legal >justification for these unjust wholesale costs to not be passed on to >the retail ratepayers. In turn, the State and consumers should >support utilities in litigating for relief against those parties who >profited from "unjust and unreasonable" wholesale rates which, of >course, will likely require action against FERC itself. > >As I have indicated in prior correspondence, we disagree with your >counsel's opinion that you are constrained from acting retroactively. >If the tariffs produced "unjust and unreasonable rates" and were, >therefore, illegal in October, they were similarly illegal in prior >months in which the effect of market power was even more evident. > >However, we appreciate both your stated desire to act retroactively >and your request to Congress to clarify this authority. While we would >certainly prefer that Congress act on your request, we are also >confident that the Federal Court will confirm our legal analysis. In >the interim, your invitation to California to suggest equitable >remedies for earlier periods, is most welcome. As a threshold matter, >a statement by you of your intention to host a settlement conference >in San Diego would be most useful in moving such a remedy forward. > >I support your present proposals to restructure the previously >FERC-approved tariffs to address the ability of parties to exercise >market power as far as they go. However, I do have concerns that >enhancing the ability of California utilities to make forward >purchases will not mitigate market power. Since forward contracts >will be based upon sellers expectations regarding real- time markets >and since real-time market prices will still be distorted by the >exercise of market power, forward contract prices will themselves be >distorted. > >Finally, I will take particular satisfaction in the conversion of the >discredited ISO and PX stakeholder boards into non-stakeholder boards. > I do question, however, the wisdom of allowing these dysfunctional >boards to have a last hurrah and choose their non-stakeholder >successors. > >Mr. Chairman and Commissioners, these are difficult and complex issues >subject to the push and pull of gigantic economic interests. There >will be much regulatory work as well as litigation to follow. >However, your action -- coupled with appropriate action by the >California PUC -- will help assure that, as these gigantic interests >fight over economic theory and their balance sheets, consumers will >not foot the bill. > >Thank you. > > >Sincerely, > > >Steve Peace > >Cc: Commissioner Linda K. Breathitt > Commissioner Curt Hebert Jr. > Commissioner William L. Massey > >