30 Aug 2000, 18:29 UTC
Re: California Legislative Strategy
- From
- Roger Yang roger.yang@enron.com
- Date
- Wed, 30 Aug 2000 11:29:00 -0700 (PDT)
FYI To: Scott Stoness/HOU/EES@EES, Dennis Benevides/HOU/EES@EES cc: Kenneth Lee/HOU/EES@EES, Neil Hong/HOU/EES@EES Subject: California Legislative Strategy Per our discussions yesterday, SCE and PG&E are currently negotiating with customer groups to propose legislation that would result in a Rate Stabilization Plan that would extend beyond the AB1890 rate freeze. The purpose of the negotiations is to build inertia to move a bill at the legislature. The legislative session ends this week and will not reconvene until next year, unless there is a special legislative session. I hear from Government Affairs that the current negotiations has stalled. Unfortunately, customer groups would not know a good deal if it hit them in the face. SCE and PG&E threaten to artificially end the AB1890 rate freeze early and forego CTC recovery. The utilities would end the freeze as early as January 1, 2001, in lieu of incurring high procurement costs that would undue their CTC recovery thus far. Under the AB1890 freeze, the utilities are at risk for recovery of all costs under the frozen rates through March 31, 2002. There are two things that would prevent the utilities from ending the freeze early. Under the current political and market climate, artificially ending the rate freeze early would be perceived very poorly. Additionally, the utilities would have to forego recovery of hundreds of millions to a billion dollars for CTC, Transmission, Distribution and Procurement undercollections (in the TRA and TCBA) per a prior CPUC decision. It would be in the best interest of the utilities and customers to negotiate other mechanisms such as an extension to the AB890 rate freeze. One concept that has been discussed is an extension to January 1, 2005. The following is an assessment of our risks: January 1, 2001 Roll-Off Current Mark January 1, 2005 Roll-Off PG&E ($57.8) million July 1, 2001 $155.9 million SCE ($85.6) million January 1, 2002 $21.4 million ________ ___________________ ___________ ___________________ Total ($143.4) million $177.3 million I have instructed Government Affairs to accept a deal that would extend the AB1890 Rate Freeze to January 1, 2005. Government Affairs understands the value of an extension of the Rate Freeze between April 1, 2002 and January 1, 2005, and our preference that the Rate Freeze in 2003. Also, Government Affairs understands are preference for a Rate Cap. Unfortunately, the utilities are not interested in our preferences due to their own needs. I offered Government Affairs some other refinements to such a settlement, including: 1) the PX credit be based on spot prices; 2) a retail adder to the PX credit; 3) no wholesale caps; and 4) the January 1, 2005 is a "no later than" date (which would make it more generic to cover all utilities with different circumstances). Of course, none of these amendments should be deal breakers. Once again, a settlement with correponding legislation does not look promising at this point in time. Roger