27 Nov 2000, 21:22 UTC
Re: Options the Governor's Considering
- From
- Steven J Kean steven.kean@enron.com
- Cc
- Alan Comnes, Jeff Dasovich, Joe Hartsoe, Karen Denne, Mary Hain, Mona L Petrochko, mpalmer@enron.com, Paul Kaufman, Richard Shapiro, Sandra McCubbin, Sarah Novosel, skean@enron.com
- Bcc
- Alan Comnes, Jeff Dasovich, Joe Hartsoe, Karen Denne, Mary Hain, Mona L Petrochko, mpalmer@enron.com, Paul Kaufman, Richard Shapiro, Sandra McCubbin, Sarah Novosel, skean@enron.com
- Date
- Mon, 27 Nov 2000 13:22:00 -0800 (PST)
Jeff Dasovich and I, along with several IEP members, met with Gov Davis' staff today, including his Chief of Staff, his Staff Director and two policy advisors on energy issues. They made the following points: The Governor is personally spending a great deal of time on electricity issues (and is forcing them to spend their time on it as well). The Governor recognizes that part of the problem is a supply shortage, but they put special emphasis on the view that in addition to supply shortfalls, a big part of the problem is a "dysfunctional market" -- a thinly veiled reference to price manipulation by people sitting in the room. The Governor's view is that all participants (regulators, utilities, customers and generators) must "behave responsibly". Everyone must "share the pain". The legislative battles are likely to start as soon as the legislature returns next week, and the Governor will be putting forth several legislative proposals in the next couple of weeks. While staff went out of its way to say that the list of proposals (in the attached e-mail) were unofficial and for discussion purposes only, it was fairly clear that they defined much of what the governor plans to propose. The meeting was not very encouraging nor did it provide much in the way of new information. The IEP group was on message, making the usual arguments about the need for forward contracting, expedited generation and transmission siting, a real retail market to promote demand side responses, etc. The staff is clearly focussed on forward contracting as part of the solution but remains committed to the idea that generators have to cough up some money and remain subject to rate caps, possible restrictions on sales outside the state (at least at peak times), etc. One approach they appear to be toying with is a "share the pain" proposal which would have utilities absorbing some of the deferred costs and consumers absorbing some of the deferred costs in the form of higher rates. That leaves generators ... who they might want to either agree to some refunds or provide power at lower going-forward prices. The staff says that they remain open to proposed solutions, but the Davis administration appears unwilling to spend any political capital to fix the problem. I think we are in for a lengthy legislative and PUC fight. We should, as always, provide consistent and reasonable solutions. I think we should prepare a document for distribution to staff, legislators (and anyone else) that takes the factual background and proposed solutions we have put forward (eg in Belden's presentation and the Seabron Adamson whitepaper) and wraps them in a more political context. In other words, we have already articulated the right answers; we now need to put a political rationale around our proposals -- a set of arguments which responds directly to the political opposition those answers are likely to encounter. Jeff will follow up with one of the staff members in particular (Kari Dohn) and I would suggest that Jeff and Sandi work together on putting the necessary political rhetoric around the solutions we have proposed. Jeff Dasovich Sent by: Jeff Dasovich 11/22/2000 04:00 PM To: skean@enron.com, Richard Shapiro/NA/Enron@Enron, Paul Kaufman/PDX/ECT@ECT, Sandra McCubbin/NA/Enron@Enron, Mona L Petrochko/NA/Enron@Enron, Susan J Mara/NA/Enron@ENRON, Joe Hartsoe/Corp/Enron@ENRON, Mary Hain/HOU/ECT@ECT, Sarah Novosel/Corp/Enron@ENRON, mpalmer@enron.com, Karen Denne/Corp/Enron@ENRON, Alan Comnes/PDX/ECT@ECT cc: Subject: Options the Governor's Considering Steve: FYI. Don't worry about the conference call, but thought it might be useful to review the proposals prior to Monday's meeting. See you Monday. Happy Thanksgiving to all. Best, Jeff ****************************************************************************** ************************************** Several IEP companies have been invited to a meeting with the Governor,s staff next Monday, November 27th. The following are some options, which the Governor,s office is considering. IEP is doing some preliminary research on some of these topics. IEP would like to arrange a teleconference call around noon on Monday, November 27th to discuss the Governor,s meeting. Please advise us as to whether your have been invited, and who you are sending. California,s electricity supply situation has two inter-related problems ) (1) high wholesale electricity costs, and (2) marginally adequate supply of generation ) both have combined to create a dysfunctional wholesale electricity market. The goals should be: To assure reliable electricity to California consumers for the lowest reasonable cost. o Consider requiring that all in-state generation be sold in state. o Consider re-asserting state authority over the operation, maintenance and safety practices of all in-state generating facilities, for public health and safety purposes. o Consider developing a state power authority to build generation and own/operate transmission. o Consider requiring utilities both to retain existing and to build new generation. o Consider providing utilities with authority to stabilize retail prices to be paid by consumers through development of an energy portfolio that reduces exposure to spot markets, including contracting forward for much more of their unmet power needs. o Consider extending consumer rate freeze. o Consider centralizing power plant dispatch like the other ISOs in the rest of the country. o Consider eliminating the ISO and assigning its functions to either a state or private entity that can acquire the transmission facilities, and control the electricity transmission grid (MUNIs have proposed this). o Consider sponsoring/supporting legislation to change the ISO and PX boards to increase accountability. o Expand energy conservation programs focused both on immediate peak demand reduction and on longer term, broader-based programs. o Aggressively work to site new generation and transmission facilities, to streamline permitting, and to develop renewable resources. o Call for/sponsor federal FERC reform legislation that would: o Impose a regional price cap that varies by time of day and year; o Set requirements for FERC to use its retroactive refund authority; o Improve FERC enforcement over price gouging practices; o Affirm the role of states to protect their customers from unjust prices. o Pressure the FERC to do its job to (1) bring about responsible seller behavior in wholesale electric markets through price controls and other market interventions as necessary, and (2) provide refunds to affected consumers.
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
----- Forwarded by Jeff Dasovich/NA/Enron on 11/22/2000 03:44 PM ----- Susan J Mara 11/22/2000 03:05 PM To: "CHUDSON" <carol@iepa.com> cc: "Andy Brown \(E-mail\)" <abb@eslawfirm.com>, chudson@iepa.com, "Curtis Kebler \(E-mail\)" <curtis_l_kebler@reliantenergy.com>, "Delaney Hunter \(E-mail\)" <dhunter@smithandkempton.com>, "Greg Blue \(E-mail\)" <gtbl@dynegy.com>, "Jack Pigott \(E-mail\)" <jackp@calpine.com>, "Jeff Dasovich \(E-mail\)" <jdasovic@enron.com>, "Joe Ronan \(E-mail\)" <joer@calpine.com>, "John Stout \(E-mail\)" <John_H_Stout@reliantenergy.com>, jparker@HMOT.com, "Katie Kaplan \(E-mail\)" <kaplan@iepa.com>, kelly@hnks.com, "Kelly Norton \(E-mail\)" <knorton@mcnallytemple.com>, "Lynn Lednicky \(E-mail\)" <lale@dynegy.com>, marie_moretti@msn.com, mrmonagan@aol.com, "Bob Weisenmiller \(E-mail\)" <rbw@mrwassoc.com>, "Bob Escalante \(E-mail\)" <rescalante@riobravo-gm.com>, "Rob Lamkin \(E-mail\)" <rllamkin@seiworldwide.com>, "Jan Smutny-Jones \(E-mail\)" <smutny@iepa.com>, "Steven Kelly \(E-mail\)" <steven@iepa.com>, "Susan J Mara \(E-mail\)" <Susan_J_Mara@enron.com>, "McNally Temple Assn. Inc. \(Business Fax\)"@mail.cwo.com Subject: Re: Jeff Dasovich and Steve Kean are attending. Someone can be on a call -- me if no one else -- if Jeff and Steve are travelling at the time. Hey, does the Governor have to fly coach? "CHUDSON" <carol@iepa.com> 11/22/2000 12:47 PM To: "Katie Kaplan \(E-mail\)" <kaplan@iepa.com>, "Jeff Dasovich \(E-mail\)" <jdasovic@enron.com>, "Kelly Norton \(E-mail\)" <knorton@mcnallytemple.com>, "John Stout \(E-mail\)" <John_H_Stout@reliantenergy.com>, "Curtis Kebler \(E-mail\)" <curtis_l_kebler@reliantenergy.com>, "Rob Lamkin \(E-mail\)" <rllamkin@seiworldwide.com>, "Bob Weisenmiller \(E-mail\)" <rbw@mrwassoc.com>, "Susan J Mara \(E-mail\)" <Susan_J_Mara@enron.com>, "Andy Brown \(E-mail\)" <abb@eslawfirm.com>, "Bob Escalante \(E-mail\)" <rescalante@riobravo-gm.com>, "Greg Blue \(E-mail\)" <gtbl@dynegy.com>, "Jack Pigott \(E-mail\)" <jackp@calpine.com>, "Jan Smutny-Jones \(E-mail\)" <smutny@iepa.com>, "Joe Ronan \(E-mail\)" <joer@calpine.com>, "Lynn Lednicky \(E-mail\)" <lale@dynegy.com>, "McNally Temple Assn. Inc. \(Business Fax\)"@mail.cwo.com, "Steven Kelly \(E-mail\)" <steven@iepa.com>, "Susan J Mara \(E-mail\)" <Susan_J_Mara@enron.com>, <mrmonagan@aol.com>, <marie_moretti@msn.com>, "Delaney Hunter \(E-mail\)" <dhunter@smithandkempton.com>, <kelly@hnks.com>, <jparker@HMOT.com>, <chudson@iepa.com> cc: Subject: Jan Smutny-Jones, Exec Dir Independent Energy Producers Assn. 1112 I Street, Suite 380 Sacramento, CA 95814 PH: 916-448-9499 FX: 916-448-0182 iepa@iepa.com - Govs meeting Conf Call.doc