11 Jan 2001, 13:18 UTC
Re: Brazil coffee estimate: latest @35mm
- From
- Jeffrey A Shankman jeffrey.shankman@enron.com
- Date
- Thu, 11 Jan 2001 05:18:00 -0800 (PST)
Excellent work. Thanks for the update. Jeff
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
Robert Johnston
01/11/2001 12:50 PM
To: Jeffrey A Shankman/HOU/ECT@ECT, Gary Hickerson/HOU/ECT@ECT
cc: Scott Tholan/Corp/Enron@Enron, Rommel Aganon/Corp/Enron@Enron
Subject: Brazil coffee estimate: latest @35mm
After weeks of media reports and official Brazilian govt forecasts of a 25-27
million bag crop, we are finally getting to the real likely crop figure of 35
million bags, which we forecast in mid-November (see report below the Dow
story). I believe that this is the kind of information that can be a real
winner for the EGM Agricultural traders by clarifying the confusing and
misleading reports from Brazilian official sources.
RJ
---------------------- Forwarded by Robert Johnston/HOU/ECT on 01/11/2001
11:28 AM ---------------------------
From: Rommel Aganon @ ENRON 01/11/2001 10:19 AM
To: Robert Johnston/HOU/ECT@ECT
cc:
Subject: Brazil coffee estimate: latest @35mm
Robert, we hit another one on the head.
-- DJ MARKET TALK: Brazil 01-02 Coffee Crop Seen Near 35M Bags --
Contact us in London on 44-20-7842-9358 or in New York on 201-938-4435.
1614 GMT (Dow Jones) Brazil 01-02 crop seen in 35 million bag range, says
trader. However, much too early to put a firm figure on it with possibility of
weather, other upsets, he adds. (CHH)
Confidential
Enron North America Competitive Analysis
& Business Controls
TO: Gary Hickerson
FROM: Robert Johnston
CC: Erin Willis, Elsa Piekielniak, Vince Kaminski, Scott Tholan
RE: Brazilian Coffee Crop Forecast
DATE: 06 November 2000
1. 2000-2001 Crop
This crop flowered from September 1999 to January 2000 and was harvested from
April 2000 to November 2000. The peak of the harvest occurred in June/July.
The 2000-2001 crop is currently being exported, and exports from the crop
will continue into the first half of 2001. The consensus from our sources is
that this crop will be bigger than expected and total 32-33 million bags.
Brazil,s Ministry of Agriculture (Embrapa) is expected to release an official
total in the next 10 days, which may or may not be accurate. The most recent
government forecast called for 28.9 million bags. Growers have been issuing
similarly lower crop yield estimates for 2000-2001 as a way of calling
attention to a probable bad harvest and pressuring the government to provide
more generous financing subsidies.
The current dry weather impacts the 2001-2002 crop, not the 2000-2001 crop,
which is largely harvested. Crop receipts issued by cooperatives in Brazil
are 11 percent greater than they were in 1999-2000. Our top source in
London believes that the 2000-2001 crop has been largely discounted by the
market and that the focus should be on 2001-2002.
2. 2001-2002 Crop
This is the crop that should be currently flowering in Brazil, but was
impacted by the June frost and the October dry weather. The harvest for the
2001-2002 crop will run from April 2001 to November 2001 and will be exported
in the second half of 2001 and in the first half of 2002. The Brazilian
government is likely to release its 2001-2002 forecast in December or January
2001. The 1999 plantings garnered expectations of a 2001-2002 crop yield of
44-46 million bags. However, recent weather problems have caused a
significant downgrade of this forecast to between 33 and 40 million bags.
Other sources in contact with coffee growers in Brazil report the potential
for even greater damage to the 2001-2002 crop, in the range of up to a 50
percent drop, or 22-23 million bags. Agronomists from Cooxupe, the largest
coffee cooperative in Brazil, have already pegged their first estimate at
27.8 million bags. Again, however, it is critical to remember that growers
tend to exaggerate weather damage, which is then further exacerbated by
market rumors. As evidence, dry weather in the spring (Sept-Dec in Brazil)
of 1999 caused alarm regarding the 2000-2001 crop. Even though the dry
weather did not end until December 1999, there was still time for flowering,
which caused many market watchers to upgrade their forecasts.
While analysts and growers agree that the highly irregular status of the
coffee trees makes the 2001/2002 crop one of the most difficult to evaluate,
the occurrence of average to normal rainfall will greatly sharpen crop
forecasting efforts. It is most critical for the rest of November and
December. Recent rains since the last week of October have begun to address
the hydrological deficit in the soil. Continued, steady, well-dispersed
rains will help offset losses, but estimated irreversible damage to the
expected yield of 44-46 million bags from frost and dry weather to date will
be a minimum of 15 percent, making the new yield forecast no greater than
38-40 million bags. A shortage of significant rainfall between now and the
end of December could bring yield down to a 30 percent loss from the
forecast, in the range of 33-36 million bags.
Rain is particularly significant because the new planting in recent years has
been concentrated in the Cerrado (savannah) region of Northern Brazil. The
coffee can be mechanically harvested in this region, but requires significant
irrigation. The irrigation alone will only partially offset the dry
weather.
The frost damage from June 2000 accounts for a 75 percent crop loss in Parana
and a 20 percent crop loss in Sao Paulo, but these states only account for 20
percent of total Brazilian production. In Minas Gerais (almost 60 percent of
production), the crop losses are only 10 percent. Crop losses in Espiritu
Santo, which accounts for 10 percent of production, have been negligible.
Our sources will monitor rainfall and flowering/cherry formation on the
coffee trees, which must occur by January 2001. The recent rainfall is
viewed as promising and supports our basis for a 33 million bag estimate.