14 Dec 2000, 11:11 UTC
Re: PT Kaltim Rima Coal v. AES Barbers Point/Third-party subpoena on Enron Coal Company
- From
- Heidi Mason heidi.mason@enron.com
- To
- Britt Davis
- Cc
- Becky Zikes, David Minns, harry.papadopoulos@enron.com, Richard B Sanders, Robert Quick, Wayne Gresham
- Bcc
- Becky Zikes, David Minns, harry.papadopoulos@enron.com, Richard B Sanders, Robert Quick, Wayne Gresham
- Date
- Thu, 14 Dec 2000 03:11:00 -0800 (PST)
Britt Please find below the answers to your queries re the AES shipment. Please do not hesitate to contact Harry or I if you need further information. David Minns (our in-house counsel) is actually on vacation until 2nd January 2001 and is not on email during this time. You may also be interested to know that we understand Glencore (a fellow Australian coal trading company) has received a similar subpoena re trading with AES during this period. Enron Coal Asia Pacific Pty Ltd (ECAP) was the counterparty to this deal. ECAP sold to AES approx 60 000 metric tonnes of coal +/-10% as per the contract signed 7th September. (The effective date of the agreement was 10 August 2000). The actually delivery amount was 54 152.35 metric tonnes a the cargo was loaded 3rd October 2000. ECAP is incorporated in Australia. The deal was negotiated by our Harry Papadopoulos and the contract signed here in Sydney by myself, Heidi Mason under delegated authority from Stuart Staley. (My delegated authority is based on Stu's prior approval which in this case was received via email on 6th September 2000) We have a copy of the contract here in Sydney, but as the coal was bought under LC and such LC was issued out of London, all shipping documentation for this load was forwarded to London to the attention of Claire Veijou and Cornelia Luptowitsch. London office also issued the invoice to AES on behalf of ECAP and this was done by Rebecca Millerchip or Maya Beyhem. Also, for your information, Harrry has prior travel plans that put him in China on the date of the hearing. While these could be changed, it would be less than desirable. Will it be necessary for the trader to be the Enron rep who appears on behalf of the company or could it ideally be someone from Houston (or London if needs be) simply because this is a long way to go for one appearance. John Bowman has resigned from Enron since the time this deal was done and therefore we have not advised him of this action. With thanks Heidi Mason Chief Financial Officer Enron Australia Britt Davis@ENRON 14/12/2000 08:43 AM To: Harry Papadopoulos/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, Heidi Mason/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, David Minns/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT cc: Wayne Gresham/HOU/ECT@ECT, Robert Quick/LON/ECT@ECT, Richard B Sanders/HOU/ECT@ECT, Becky Zikes/Corp/Enron@ENRON Subject: PT Kaltim Rima Coal v. AES Barbers Point/Third-party subpoena on Enron Coal Company PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL: ATTORNEY-CLIENT COMMUNICATION, ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT--URGENT Harry, Heidi and David, The above-referenced lawsuit is filed in the Southern District of New York by PT Kaltim Rima Coal, who allegedly had a long-term coal purchase agreement with AES Barbers Point, for delivery to AES in Hawaii. In brief, PT contends that AES breached that agreement through the use of a bogus force majeure letter, in order to allow AES to purchase coal from some Enron entity at a cheaper spot market price in September or October of this year. PT's attorneys, Lord, Bissell & Brook out of Chicago, have served us with a subpoena on Enron Coal Company. How they decided that Enron Coal Company was the correct entity is not something I yet know. I have been advised that Enron Coal Company is a long-dormant subsidiary of Enron Property. Although using Enron Coal Company's name throughout, the subpoena also references Harry, Riaz Rizvi, Allen Childress, Stuart Staley and/or John Bowman. I understand that we probably did do a deal (maybe more than one) with AES, but need to be corrected if I am wrong. The subpoena requests that a corporate representative for Enron Coal Company appear with documents on January 8 in Houston to be deposed about the deal with AES. I would like to respond tomorrow, by telefax, to PT's attorneys and advise that Enron Coal Company is the wrong company. If all I do is stall them, however, they can yank the information from us the hard way (assuming that we did do the deal in question) and eventually get what they want. The suit is for about $4,000,000, so it is worth the while of PT's attorneys to pursue this subpoena. Accordingly, I need one of you to tell me as soon as possible whether (a) we did such a deal with AES during the relevant time frame, and if so, the exact name of the Enron entity on the deal; (b) who the trader on the deal was; and, (c) who has the documents regarding the deal. Although I have briefly described the information I need, I also need to get the name of the right person to telefax the subpoena to for review, to see how broad the scope of the request for documents/witnesses really is. I would greatly appreciate this preliminary information by the close of business tomorrow, Thursday, in London/Australia. I apologize for the extremely short time frame. I was only given this subpoena last Friday, and have spent the days since chasing people down. Please don't shoot the messenger. Britt
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
----- Forwarded by Britt Davis/Corp/Enron on 12/13/2000 03:17 PM ----- Stuart Staley@ECT 12/13/2000 02:15 PM To: Britt Davis/Corp/Enron@ENRON cc: Robert Quick/LON/ECT@ECT, Wayne Gresham/HOU/ECT@ECT Subject: Re: subpoena Britt: Harry Papadopoulos, Heidi Mason, or David Minns in our Sydney office should have originals of this documentation. Thks, Stu