25 Apr 2001, 11:15 UTC
Re: Some Background on California Gas Price Spikes--The Other Side of the Story
- From
- Jeff Dasovich jeff.dasovich@enron.com
- To
- Rob Bradley
- Cc
- Alan Comnes, James D Steffes, Janel Guerrero, Joe Hartsoe, Karen Denne, Leslie Lawner, Paul Kaufman, Richard Shapiro, Sandra McCubbin, skean@enron.com, Susan J Mara
- Bcc
- Alan Comnes, James D Steffes, Janel Guerrero, Joe Hartsoe, Karen Denne, Leslie Lawner, Paul Kaufman, Richard Shapiro, Sandra McCubbin, skean@enron.com, Susan J Mara
- Date
- Wed, 25 Apr 2001 04:15:00 -0700 (PDT)
This is a very good synopsis of the gas crimes trials in California. Please note comments of Assembly Republican John Campbell---perhaps the sole bright spot in the California Legislature... Competing evidence clouds Calif. investigation Prompted in part by the California Public Utilities Commission, the California Assembly has been scrutinizing the role that interstate pipelines have played in the state,s current energy crisis. In the efforts to find a smoking gun, legislators have leaned heavily on a report prepared by The Brattle Group, a consultancy commissioned by utility Southern California Edison to dig up evidence of market power abuse. But the state,s biggest transporter of gas to California -- El Paso Natural Gas -- is not ready to take the rap. The pipeline has commissioned its own study, which it recently presented as evidence that it has not circumvented any laws or regulation. As reported in both the trade press and national media, SoCal Ed and the CPUC are pointing the finger of blame at El Paso for alleged manipulation of California border prices through affiliate deals and capacity hoarding. And exhibit A in their case against El Paso is The Brattle Group,s study of the California market. Richard Zeiger, a spokesman for Assembly Member Darrell Steinberg, chairman of the California Assembly Judiciary Committee, told Gas Daily that The Brattle Group,s market study proved that the surge in gas prices at the California border was not caused by normal market forces (GD 4/20). His remarks followed an oversight hearing during which Assembly members questioned Dynegy and El Paso officials about their involvement in the California market. El Paso presented a different version of events to the Assembly. In a report presented to legislators, a research group hired by El Paso concluded that a convergence of factors, not a conspiracy, caused the price run-up. Lukens Consulting Group, a Houston-based consultancy, was retained by El Paso to conduct work on several fronts. In its study of the California market, Lukens concluded that the increasing convergence of the gas and electricity businesses was one of the main culprits in the California gas price imbroglio. Assemblyman John Campbell, a Republican member of the oversight committee, said he "didn,t see any smoking gun" in either report. "We had our committee hearing, and we certainly had a lot on the Brattle Study and a little on the Lukens study. To some degree, I,m not sure that the California legislature is the best place to adjudicate the differences between these two studies," Campbell said. "I believe FERC is looking at this situation " and it would seem to me that that,s the appropriate place." Campbell said that the CPUC had been prodding the California legislature to give support to its claims of market power abuse by pipelines. "It,s being pushed basically by the Public Utilities Commission here, which believes that there was collusion" by pipeline companies to push up gas prices in California, he said. The CPUC, Campbell suggested, sought satisfaction before the California assembly when it had failed on the federal level: "There,s a concerted effort, not just on natural gas but on other things here in California, for entities and organizations here to point the finger elsewhere for the problems that we,re having in this state and I think you,re seeing some of that with the public utilities commission." Whether either report wins over the public incensed by high natural gas prices is a different matter entirely. In the meanwhile, the dueling California market studies seem to have taken on a life of their own. The Brattle Group Study, for instance, has become the center of a heavily litigated effort to force FERC to compel the release of market data by California market participants. Following on a request by SoCal Ed, which said it needed additional data to round out The Brattle Group report, FERC Chief ALJ Curtis Wagner issued subpoenas to the other three major pipelines that serve the state as well as to Sempra Energy Trading. Several parties resisted FERC,s call for market information, saying the requested data contained commercially sensitive information. FERC allowed the discovery process to move forward but only after attaching strict data protection rules restricting access to evidence (GD 4/23). Critics of the pipeline industry have already suffered one setback in their case. The commission recently dismissed the CPUC,s claim that El Paso rigged the auction of a large block of pipeline capacity in favor of affiliate El Paso Merchant Energy. In addressing the California Assembly, representatives of Dynegy said that FERC,s recent ruling on the California border controversy obviated the need for more investigation. The controversy, however, is far from over. FERC last month also ordered a hearing into whether El Paso Natural Gas and its affiliates manipulated capacity to drive up the price of gas delivered into California (GD 3/29). That hearing is likely to take place this summer. (RP00- 241, et al.) NH Rob Bradley 04/25/2001 09:13 AM To: Jeff Dasovich/NA/Enron@Enron cc: Alan Comnes/PDX/ECT@ECT, James D Steffes/NA/Enron@Enron, Janel Guerrero/Corp/Enron@Enron, Jeff Dasovich/NA/Enron@Enron, Joe Hartsoe/Corp/Enron@Enron, Karen Denne/Corp/Enron@Enron, Leslie Lawner/NA/Enron@Enron, Paul Kaufman/PDX/ECT@ECT, Richard Shapiro/NA/Enron@Enron, Sandra McCubbin/NA/Enron@Enron, skean@enron.com, Susan J Mara/NA/Enron@Enron Subject: Re: Some Background on California Gas Price Spikes--The Other Side of the Story Here is the Q&A I will give to Ken on this topic, and I invite any improvements: Question: "What is your opinion about the study of the Brattle Group (Dr. Paul Carpenter) that market power exercised by El Paso and Dynegy exacerbated the natural gas price spike at the California border that contributed to the electricity price spike." Answer: "I always discount conspiracy theories when prices rise or fall and believe fundamental forces of supply and demand explain prices in this instance. I will say, however, that the transmission grid must be more open and transparent to improve everyone's confidence in the economics behind price formation. Long term contracting in the wholesale commodity market should also reduce speculation about price manipulation." - Rob Jeff Dasovich Sent by: Jeff Dasovich 04/24/2001 06:57 PM To: Richard Shapiro/NA/Enron@Enron, skean@enron.com, James D Steffes/NA/Enron@Enron, Paul Kaufman/PDX/ECT@ECT, Leslie Lawner/NA/Enron@Enron, Joe Hartsoe/Corp/Enron@ENRON, Rob Bradley/Corp/Enron@ENRON, Janel Guerrero/Corp/Enron@Enron, Karen Denne/Corp/Enron@ENRON, Alan Comnes/PDX/ECT@ECT, Sandra McCubbin/NA/Enron@Enron, Susan J Mara/NA/Enron@ENRON cc: Subject: Some Background on California Gas Price Spikes--The Other Side of the Story Last week, I distributed a presentation that the Brattle Group gave before the California Inquisition (i.e., legislative gas oversight committee looking into the gas price spikes at the Cal border). The Brattle Group is a consulting firm that Edison has long used to beat up on SoCalGas (recall that Edison used to be a big gas customer when it owned power plants). Edison "arranged" for the Brattle Group to be the star witness at the Cal Leg gas hearing. Their job was to set up El Paso and Dynegy for the hit at hearings that took place the following day. Their message was simple (and simplistic): El Paso and Dynegy have market power. They have used the market power to drive up basis and thus the price of gas at the border (to "obscene" levels). That, in turn, has driven up electricity prices. Ken Lay is giving a gas talk tomorrow, and Rob Bradley asked that I provide the alternative view to the Edison/Brattle rant, in the event that he gets any questions on the topic. It's attached. Apologies, it's quick and dirty, but it provides the basics. Obviously no need for us to defend El Paso or Dynegy, but might be useful to offer a more rationale explanation than the one that the California Legislature is peddling. Finally, we were also fingered somewhat as culprits at the hearing (the California PUC FERC lawyer claimed that ENA and TW colluded to drive up basis when ENA controlled a portion of the capacity), but the overriding goal of the hearing was to go after EP and Dynegy. Best, Jeff