27 Apr 2000, 19:20 UTC
Re: Bandwidth Products On EnronOnline. (Revised)
- From
- Cynthia Harkness cynthia.harkness@enron.com
- To
- Mark Taylor
- Cc
- Dale Neuner, David Forster, James Ginty, Jay Hawthorn, Jeff Blumenthal, Leonardo Pacheco, Rudi Zipter, Tana Jones, Tom Moran
- Bcc
- Dale Neuner, David Forster, James Ginty, Jay Hawthorn, Jeff Blumenthal, Leonardo Pacheco, Rudi Zipter, Tana Jones, Tom Moran
- Date
- Thu, 27 Apr 2000 12:20:00 -0700 (PDT)
See my answers below in red (formulated in close consultation with Jay
Hawthorn and Leonardo Pacheco).
Cynthia
Mark Taylor@ECT
04/27/00 04:04 PM
To: Leonardo Pacheco/Corp/Enron@Enron, David Forster/Corp/Enron@Enron, Dale
Neuner/HOU/ECT@ECT, Cynthia Harkness/Enron Communications@Enron Communications
cc: Jay Hawthorn/Enron Communications@Enron Communications, Tom
Moran/HOU/ECT@ECT, Rudi Zipter/HOU/ECT@ECT, Jeff Blumenthal/HOU/ECT@ECT, Tana
Jones/HOU/ECT@ECT, James Ginty/Corp/Enron@ENRON
Subject: Re: Bandwidth Products On EnronOnline. (Revised)
The hardest part of preparing the Long Descriptions is making sure all of the
terms used in th GTC's that need to be defined elsewhere are covered. I'll
have to leave the final determination to the people who drafted the GTC's. I
also have to point out I don't know much of anything about how bandwidth is
traded, but here are the comments I was able to come up with to the Long
Descriptions:
Bandwidth Units - This concept has been difficult for me - it's not entirely
clear to me where the definition of this comes from - is it the reference in
the box at the top of the relevant Annex? You are correct. If so, maybe we
should add a line something to the effect of 'Bandwidth Units shall mean DS-3
for this Transaction.' Or better yet you might consider a generic reference
to the relevant Annex that should apply which might let you delete the
sentence referring to the quality as well. We have changed the first sentence
of the long description to read " A US Bandwidth Transaction with Enron
Broadband Services, L.P. ("EBS") pursuant to which the Seller shall sell and
the Buyer shall buy the quantity of DS3 Bandwidth Units submitted by
Counterparty via the Website.
Does 'DSO' need to be defined somewhere? DS0 is a term generally known in the
industry and is only used in the calculation of the Contract Price in the
long description, so we chose not to define it - also the definition is
incredibly long, complex and technical. If you feel strongly about it, we
can include it, but since the long description tells you how many DS0's you
should include for calculation purposes, we didn't think that it was
necessary.
The way the different Price definitions fit together has also eluded me -
there is a formula in the Long Description and a different formula in the
GTC. The formula in the long description differs from the formula in the GTC
(and in the Master Agreement) in order to accomodate the way that the price
is being quoted on EnronOnline. The quote represents the variable component
of the "Unit Price" in the GTC's and the Master Agreement - In order not to
confuse people, we decided to include the formula in both the long
description and the confirmation so that customers could know that the Unit
Price was calculated using the price quoted. Unless industry trading
convention is to the contrary, the site makes more intuitive sense when the
volume quoted and the price quoted use the same units. If the volume is
Bandwidth Units and the price is a per mile number some counterparties (or
perhaps more likely their lawyers) may be confused. The GTC contains the
defined term 'Unit Price' which is in $/Bandwidth Unit. It seems to me that
if we can quote the price as the Unit Price and the volume as Bandwidth
Units, we can ignore the number of DSO's per Bandwidth Unit and the number of
DSO miles for the transaction.
Since they won't change from one product to the next, the two sentences
beginning with 'Any party entering into a Transaction...' could be moved to
the GTC. Since bandwidth is such a new product, we really wanted to highlight
to customers that if they intend to take physical delivery of bandwidth
(which is what we are offering) they will need to establish connectivity with
us. This is already in the GTC - but in an abundance of caution, we wanted
this fact highlighted, especially since connectivity will entail further
costs to the customer as well as signing documentation such as colocation
agreements, licenses etc. - this can be quite an involved process.
The term 'Contractual Currency' is not used int he GTC. Can the
parenthetical reference come out? (The EnronOnline people may care about
this more than I.) Agreed
If the numbers of miles and DSO's need to stay in the Long Descriptions, I
would suggest that you change the references to make it DSO's per Bandwidth
Unit (both where the number is introduced and in the price formula) and that
the unt of measure against which the price is quoted be 'per DSO mile per
month'. It is a quote for one DS0 mile of a Bandwidth Unit for a month.
Since the short description indicates the period for the contract being
offered, we felt like the quotation was pretty clear. We are also a bit
sensitive to using too many defined terms referring to each other in the long
description. From a commercial perspective, we are comfortable that the
language used in the quote and the long description are clear and accurate.
Is the volume on the quotes page a monthly or total number? This needs to be
clear from the Long Description. If a Customer wanted to buy 5 of the OC3
Bandwidth Units quoted for the period from July 1- July 31, the Customer
would be entitled to 5 OC3's for the period from July 1 - July 31. I hope
that this is responsive to your question - we weren't entirely clear.
So for example, if you follow all of my suggestions, you might end up with
something like this:
A US Bandwidth Transaction with Enron Broadband Services, L.P. (&EBS8)
pursuant to which the Seller shall sell and the Buyer shall buy the quantity
of Bandwidth Units submitted by Counterparty via the Website. The price
shall be as submitted by the Counterparty via the Website. Annex A-1 of the
General Terms and Conditions shall apply to this Transaction.
The term of the Transaction shall begin at 12:00 a.m. (EST) on the Effective
Date and continue to 11:59:59 p.m. (EST) on the Termination Date. The
Effective Date is <Start Date> and the Termination Date is <Termination
Date>.
The Transaction shall be for Bandwidth between the New York Market Pooling
Point (111 8th Avenue, Suite 1517, New York, NY 10011, NPA-NXX: 212-462,
CLLI: NYCMNY83H62) and the Los Angeles Market Pooling Point (530 W. 6th
Street, Suite 300, Los Angeles, CA 90014, NPA-NXX: 213-362, CLLI:
LSAJCAWZH04).
The price is quoted in US Dollars.
The unit of measure against which the price is quoted is one Bandwidth Unit
per month and the quantity shown shall be in number of Bandwidth Units per
month.
If quoting the price as a per Bandwidth Unit number doesn't work it would be
more like this:
A US Bandwidth Transaction with Enron Broadband Services, L.P. (&EBS8)
pursuant to which the Seller shall sell and the Buyer shall buy the quantity
of Bandwidth Units submitted by Counterparty via the Website. The number of
DSO,s per Bandwidth Unit is 672. The price shall be as submitted by the
Counterparty via the Website. Annex A-1 of the General Terms and Conditions
will apply to this Transaction.
The term of the Transaction shall begin at 12:00 a.m. (EST) on the Effective
Date and continue to 11:59:59 p.m. (EST) on the Termination Date. The
Effective Date is <Start Date> and the Termination Date is <Termination
Date>.
The Transaction shall be for Bandwidth between the New York Market Pooling
Point (111 8th Avenue, Suite 1517, New York, NY 10011, NPA-NXX: 212-462,
CLLI: NYCMNY83H62) and the Los Angeles Market Pooling Point (530 W. 6th
Street, Suite 300, Los Angeles, CA 90014, NPA-NXX: 213-362, CLLI:
LSAJCAWZH04), for a total of 2,446 DSO miles.
The price is quoted in US Dollars.
The unit of measure against which the price is quoted is one DS0 mile per
month and the quantity shown shall be in number of Bandwidth Units per month.
Therefore, the Contract Price will be calculated as follows: price x the
number of DS0,s per Bandwidth Unit x the number of DS0 miles x the number of
Bandwidth Units.
Please let me know if you have any questions - I will go ahead and approve
the product in the system so you can proceed without me if necessary.
Mark
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
Leonardo Pacheco@ENRON 04/27/2000 01:38 PM To: Tana Jones/HOU/ECT@ECT, James Ginty/Corp/Enron@ENRON, Mark Taylor/HOU/ECT@ECT, Taffy Milligan/HOU/ECT@ECT cc: Subject: Bandwidth Products On EnronOnline. (Revised) FYI ---------------------- Forwarded by Leonardo Pacheco/Corp/Enron on 04/27/2000 12:36 PM --------------------------- Leonardo Pacheco 04/27/2000 01:07 PM To: Jay Hawthorn/Enron Communications@Enron Communications, Tom Moran/HOU/ECT@ECT, Mark Taylor/HOU/ECT@ECT, Rudi Zipter/HOU/ECT@ECT, Jeff Blumenthal/HOU/ECT@ECT cc: David Forster/Corp/Enron@Enron, Dale Neuner/HOU/ECT@ECT, Cynthia Harkness/Enron Communications@Enron Communications Subject: Bandwidth Products On EnronOnline. (Revised) Please note that we have added another product type (bringing the total number to three)!. We have built three new Products Types called US Bandwidth DS3 Physical Forward, US Bandwidth OC3 Physical Forward, and US Bandwidth OC3c Physical Forward. Please go into DataManager and approve these Product Types (look at attached Document for long descriptions). We are going life on the 1st of May. If you need help with the approval process contact Dale Neuner (ext. 39746) or myself (ext. 39938). Please Do Not Reject the Product Type. If you have questions or changes to the Product Type please contact me at your convenience. Thank you very much for your co-operation! Leonardo Pacheco ext. 39938