7 Jul 2000, 09:26 UTC
Re: EOL GTC's for Weather Derivatives In Australia
- From
- Susan Musch susan.musch@enron.com
- To
- David Minns
- Date
- Fri, 7 Jul 2000 02:26:00 -0700 (PDT)
David, Based on the e-mail that I sent out on June 30th (and that I have attached below), I was under the presumption that the Enron party to the GTCs would be Enron Australia Finance Pty Ltd. This is because we are dealing with Australian weather derivatives and I was presuming (right or wrong) that such derivatives would be on the books of the Sydney trading office. Please let me know if this is not the case. Best regards, Susan
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
David Minns
07/06/2000 12:35 AM
To: John Viverito/Corp/Enron@ENRON
cc: Jonathan Whitehead/AP/Enron@Enron, Nicholas.O'Day@enron.com@ENRON, Susan
Musch/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, Justin
Timothy/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, Raymond
Yeow/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, Mark Taylor@ECT
Subject: Re: EOL GTC's for Weather Derivatives In Australia
John please see attached GTCs for Australian weather. They are essentially
the same as the example that was forwarded to B&M when they got the brief to
advise on weather derivatives last month.
I understand that B & M are having second thoughts on the gambling question
and are due to come in with an advice on the point.
There is also a question as to whether the Enron party will be Enron
Australia Finance Pty. Ltd. or Enron Japan KK. From a tax perspective Susan
what would you prefer?
On a related issue what Enron company is on the Passwords Applications and
ETAs that are being sent out? Although from a legal perspective it does not
matter it may increase acceptance if it were Enron Japan KK.
From: John Viverito@ENRON on 05-07-2000 05:19 CDT
To: David Minns/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT
cc: Jonathan Whitehead/AP/Enron@Enron, Nicholas.O'Day@enron.com
Subject: EOL GTC's for Weather Derivatives In Australia
David-
Please forward an electronic copy of the EOL GTC's for weather derivatives in
Australia. Thanks for your assistance.
Cheers,
John
Susan Musch
06/30/2000 11:30 AM
To: Jeff Blumenthal@ECT
cc: Heidi Mason/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, David
Minns/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, Stephen H Douglas@ECT, Paul
Quilkey/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT (bcc: Susan
Musch/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT)
Subject: Tax Advice on AUS and JPN CDD and HDD Weather Swaps
Below is a summary of the tax advice that I received from our outside
advisors in Tokyo and Sydney on the Sydney trading office entering into cash
settled weather derivative trades with Japanese counterparties:
Japanese Tax Advice
1. Swap, Options and Other Financial Derivative Transactions
Based on the current practice of the Japanese tax authorities, standard
swaps, options and similar financial transactions with symmetrical payment
flows should not be subject to withholding tax. However, to the extent that
Enron transactions involve asymmetrical payments, concern exists that imputed
interest from the imbedded loan could be subject to interest withholding tax.
2. Consumption Tax (VAT) and Excise Taxes
Although Japan imposes a 5% consumption tax (VAT), financial transactions are
generally not subject to the consumption tax, so cash settled derivative
transactions should generally not be subject to consumption tax. Japan
imposes various kinds of excise taxes. These excise taxes generally apply to
physical importation and domestic sale and delivery of covered products and
should generally not apply to purely financial derivatives transactions which
reference commodity prices.
3. Collateral for Derivatives Transactions
If Enron entities will take collateral from Japan-based customers in
connection with derivative transactions, depending upon the specific
arrangements, withholding tax liability might arise. For example, if an
Enron trading entity takes cash collateral from a Japan-based customer and
pays interest on it, such interest payments could be subject to local
withholding tax when paid to the Japanese resident customer.
Australian Tax Advice
1. Swap, Options and Other Financial Derivative Transactions
Based on the summaries of the products attached to Justin Timothy,s June 12th
e-mail to Mario Parra Cardoso and Dale Neuner:
(1) the swap income or deduction should be recognized on a due and payable
basis (rather than on an accrual basis over the term of the swap), and
(2) there should not be any interest withholding tax imposed on the swap
payments because there does not appear to be any linkage between the swap
payment and "interest" as defined for Australian tax purposes.
Note that there is an Australian tax proposal to impose withholding tax on
other Australian source income. Although no details are yet available, it is
expected that the Australian government will not impose withholding tax where
the income would constitute "business profits" of any entity in a treaty
country (such as Japan) which does not have permanent establishment in
Australia. Thus, based on the current proposal, it is unlikely that such a
withholding tax, if enacted, would apply to the swap payments. However, this
could change depending upon the rules actually enacted.
2. GST (VAT)
Effective July 1, 2000, the Goods and Services Tax ("GST") will tax at a 10%
rate the consumption of most goods and services in Australia. (It does not
apply to consumption outside of Australia, e.g. exports.)
A swap payment to a Japanese counterparty will be GST-free. This means that
the Australian trading office would be able to claim refunds on a portion of
the GST paid on its rents and other expenses.
Please let me know if you have any questions or need any additional
information.
Best regards,
Susan