21 Sep 2000, 10:53 UTC
(no subject)
- From
- Susan J Mara susan.mara@enron.com
- Date
- Thu, 21 Sep 2000 03:53:00 -0700 (PDT)
Some corrections to the write-up for the first one for EES, some attribtuon changes (I think) and an additional valuation for EES. Also, includes changes to the write-ups for ENA and what I got from Tim Belden. I also have a note discussing Tim Belden's "philosophy" in giving me valuations. EES RAP '98 Enron raised the issue of the UDCs imposing an artificial cap on the PX credit for direct customers during the very first proceedings during which the method of CTC collection was raised. The CPUC shined us on. Later, we raised it in the very first Revenue Adjustment Proceeding (RAP '98) RAP '98 and ensured that it became part of WPTF's case as well. The way the "cap" worked, the UDCs would not pay ESPs the full PX credit when prices were high -- they would pay a credit that, when added to the other bill components, did not exceed the frozen rate for the direct access customer, thereby costing ESPs a lot of money potentially. It was clear in the previous CPUC direct access decisions that UDCs had no right to cap direct access credits. Because of our good case and the fact that the UDCs believed the chance of such high PX prices was LOW, the UDCs settled on this issue in 1999. 2000 NPV estimated by Dennis Benevides: $30 - 40 million % Attributed to Enron's GA Efforts: 90% Green Credit Legislation Enron and other green suppliers began work in 1998 to extend the credit given for sales of green power. The credit was scheduled to end by 2002. In 1999, the money specified in AB 1890 was being depleted rapidly and Green Mountain took the lead in pressing for legislation. We actively supported Green Mountain by lobbying legislators and other interest groups, working with environmental organisations, and spearheading legislative amendments. Although this bill became wrapped up in the San Diego crisis and ISO/PX issues, the green credit portion of the bill remained intact. We had also decided jointly to propose a ten-year credit and were very pleased and surprised that it survived into the final bill. Governor Davis is expected to sign the bill. 2000 NPV estimated by Dennis Benevides: $50 million % Attributed to Enron's GA Efforts: 25% RAP '99 Enron, through ARM, has successfully made its case that retail procurement and retail sales costs should be removed from the Distribution Charge that all customers pay. Direct Access customers would receive a credit on their bills in addition to the PX credit. Enron was the first party to raise these issues as part of RAP '98 and got a Commission decision in that case to determine the credit in RAP '99. In RAP '99, Enron chose to use ARM to litigate the case as a cheaper alternative. Hearings were completed in the Spring of 2000. ARM has negotiated settlement rates with certain parties and has convinced the Assigned Commissioner to draft his own decision to counteract the unfavorable ALJ decision. An additional credit of from $0.25 to $0.30/MWh is expected. The decision will be voted out within the next two months. 2000 NPV estimated by Dennis Benevides: $1 - 5 million % Attributed to Enron's GA Efforts: 75% San Diego Marketing Government Affairs worked closely with EES origination to help the staff understand the wildly fluctuating regulatory and political arena in San Diego and to assist its efforts to take advantage of the unique marketing opportunity afforded by volatile wholesale market prices. EES created a new Enron milestone. Beginning at a point with no personnel working on San Diego deals, EES moved in and was able to sign deals worth $1 million in three weeks time. EES has received kudos from the highest levels of Enron for this effort, which continues today. Martin Wenzel and Doug Condon of EES origination have stated their belief that these deals would not have happened with the assistance of Government Affairs. 2000 NPV estimated by Doug Condon: $1 million and growing % Attributed to Enron's GA Efforts: 90% ENA Note: Tim Belden, VP West Trading Desk, discussed with me how these valuations would be used. He found it difficult to assess Gov Affairs' contribution to the ENA dollars made. In the end, he settled on the concept that Government Affairs works, sometimes for years, to present ENA with an opportunity to make money and then it is up to ENA to run with it. So, the value Tim provides is the value ENA made with the opportunity. I think this is consistent with the way Dennis Benevides calculated the value for me. FTR Release April 1, 2000 I have spearheaded the release of firm transmission rights in CA since I joined the Company in 11/96. When I joined Enron, the plan of market participants was to have financial-only rights. I began working immediately to move people in the direction of physical rights. A very long and painful fight ensued, including a number of personal appearances by Bill Hogan. This culminated with an ISO decision to have physical-type FTRs and to release some, but not all, FTRs in April of this year. ENA actively participated in the auction and became the largest single purchaser of FTRs. The new congestion management approach, which Enron also spearheaded, will require 100% release of FTRs, but will not take effect until next year. This valuation looks only at the FTR release in 2000. 2000 NPV estimated by Tim Belden: $20 million % Attributed to Enron's Efforts: 90% ISO Price Caps Price caps have been discussed in California beginning a few days after the market opened in April 1998. Over the course of the last two years, Government Affairs had as a number one priority to provide rapid advance information on price caps, educate Board members on the effects of price caps, and, when appropriate, work to move price caps. By June, 2000, ENA had a substantial long position in the market in the West and had millions at risk when lower price caps began to be discussed in CA in mid June. Government Affairs, working with Dave Parquet and others, was instrumental in delaying the movement to lower price caps by six weeks, thereby giving ENA time to move out of those positions in an orderly fashion . The following events happened in 2000. We entered the year with a price cap of $750, having fought to raise it to that level in 1999. In March 2000, the ISO considered lowering the price cap to $500 but voted to leave it at $500, because the Board believed at the time that market power had been adequately mitigated. After the three very high-priced days in June, the ISO considered lowering the price cap to $250 with a vote on June 22. Government Affairs initiated an all-out lobbying effort to convince Board members and their constituents to oppose lower price caps. We also lobbied interest groups, banks, venture capitalists, NYMEX and others to weigh in on this issue with individual Board Members and the Board itself, going so far as to set up a special arrangement with the ISO staff to allow interested parties to address the Board telephonically. The vote on June 22 failed by ONE VOTE. Instead, the Board lowered the price cap to $500. The Board voted again on July 1 to lower the cap and again the vote failed by ONE VOTE. Finally, on August 1, the Board approved the $250 price cap, effective August 7. In the end, it was the end-use customers, Enron and the generators who opposed price caps. Utilities and munis favored them. Enron was the only party lobbying against the lower price caps (the generators gave up early in the fight) and had significant credibility with the end-use customer reps on the Board. 2000 NPV estimated by Tim Belden: $16 million % Attributed to Enron's Efforts: 70% New Market-Oriented Board Member The ISO recently held Board elections for the first time. Government Affairs actively sought market-oriented individuals to run for the Board and replace those that do not support competitive markets. Enron was successful in getting about five to run. The Members selected or confirmed by the EOB have been held up and we do not yet know the outcome of those Board seats. However, one seat of interest has been decided. Dave Parquet suggested a potential municipal representative who was extremely market-oriented (Michael Wood, Attorney for the City of Pittsburgh). Government Affairs worked with him closely to decide which seat to run for, help him prepare his application, suggest lobbying tactics, assist in lobbying and support him with other Board Members. He won the election and became a Board Member in early September. This effort is significant, because the munis voted nearly 100% in support of lower price caps. The position he took was one of those votes. All other things being equal, we have now added a vote on our side that could be instrumental in defeating further efforts to impose lower or additional price caps, given the close votes that have taken place thus far. 2000 NPV: Tim did not feel this is measurable at this time, but agreed it could be worth millions if future votes are as close as they have been % Attributed to Enron's Efforts: 100%