18 Apr 2001, 11:37 UTC
Are T&D Businesses Superfluous for Trading Operations?
- From
- SCIENTECH IssueAlert issuealert@scientech.com
- Date
- Wed, 18 Apr 2001 04:37:00 -0700 (PDT)
Today's IssueAlertSponsors: [IMAGE] The CIS Conferencec provides utility management personnel unequaled insight and current information on Customer Relationship Management (CRM), E-Commerce, Technologies and Marketing. Fifty-four sessions conducted by utility industry representatives will focus on issues facing the industry. Over 100 companies will exhibit the latest technologies and services. Former President George Bush is our Honored Keynote Speaker www.cisconference.org e-ProCom Europe for Utilities and Energy e-Business Conference & Exhibition ) May 22-23, 2001, Amsterdam, The Netherlands e-Commerce/e-Business/Integrating the Digital Utility/ Pan-European attendance from the major utilities and energy players can be found at the e-ProCom Europe: for Utilities & Energy e-Business. Call 31-346-590901 or email jhh@synergy-events.com or visit our web site at: www.e-procomseries.com. [IMAGE] In an exclusive SCIENTECH PowerHittersinterview, Jeff Sterba, CEO of Public Utility of New Mexico (PNM), shares some keys that have helped the small company find success in the wholesale power market. He also looks at issues affecting deregulation both in New Mexico and across the country. Read the questions Sterba was asked at: www.scientech.com [IMAGE] [IMAGE] April 18, 2001 Are TBusinesses Superfluous for Trading Operations? by Will McNamara Director, Electric Industry Analysis [News item from Power Finance & Risk] Vertically integrated power company Dynegy is likely to sell its electricity distribution business within the next few years to focus on its more profitable energy generation and trading activities, predict analysts familiar with the company. Anatol Feygin, senior equity analyst at J.P Morgan in New York, says a sale of Dynegy's transmission and distribution assets could fetch the company close to $1 billion. Analysis: There are two different ways to evaluate the speculation that Dynegy may be looking to sell its transmission and distribution (T&D) business. From a company-specific perspective, such a strategy would make sense for Dynegy, as it would allow the company to focus more exclusively on its trading and marketing operation, which has experienced truly spectacular growth over the last year. Although Dynegy has refused to deny or confirm reports that it is planning to sell its Tassets, the company's financial numbers clearly build a case for such a move. In addition, Dynegy's potential restructuring could very well be part of a larger trend in which those companies that place a high priority on their generation business see little value in remaining in the highly regulated and low-profit Tmarket. To be clear, Dynegy's Tsubsidiary is Illinois Power, based in Decatur, Ill., which serves more than 650,000 natural-gas and electric utility customers in a 15,000-square-mile area across Illinois. Dynegy acquired Illinois Power when it completed its merger with Illinova in February 2000. At the time, Dynegy maintained that a primary value of the acquisition was Illinois Power's Toperations and the fact that they would allow Dynegy to gain a foothold in the Illinois market. Of course, Dynegy also gained approximately 4,929 MW of generation that Illinois Power had previously structured in an unregulated subsidiary. Nevertheless, if Dynegy is planning to sell its Toperation, the sale would include Illinois Power and would represent a dramatic strategy turnaround for the company. Let's look at the unique reasons why Dynegy might be considering such a move. It's rather apropos that word begins to circulate of a sale of the company's Tbusiness at the same time that Dynegy releases its 1Q 2001 report, in which its earnings more than doubled. As it has in the past few quarters, Dynegy reported remarkable numbers, including a 73-percent increase in its earnings that resulted primarily from wholesale natural gas and electricity sales. Dynegy's recurring net income in the first quarter rose to $137.5 million or 41 cents per diluted share from $79.4 million or 26 cents in 1Q 2000. First-quarter revenues rose to $14.2 billion from $5.3 billion. Dynegy reportedly produced and sold 26.1 million megawatt hours of electricity in 1Q 2001, which represented a 19-percent increase over the same period in 2000. Dynegy continues to discount the role that California sales played in its earnings, despite the fact that it owns about 2,800 MW of capacity in the state (including joint ventures). Due to its presence in the state, Dynegy (along with a handful of other power suppliers) continues to be singled out as having gained a financial windfall from the California energy crisis. Yet even without California, cold weather in the Midwest during 1Q 2001 also benefited Dynegy (along with other natural gas and power producers such as Enron and Duke). Looking nationally, Dynegy has ownership stakes in about 13,000 MW of generating capacity and is on its way toward the goal of owning or controlling 70,000 MW by 2005. Consequently, it seems fairly clear that wholesale marketing and trading is where Dynegy is making most of its money. It only makes sense that the company would want to invest its existing capital resources (and any funds gained from selling its Tassets) into growing this part of its business. In contrast, in general Toperations typically only bring a return of equity of about 10 percent, given the fact that they are still heavily regulated by FERC. When 73 percent of its earnings are coming from wholesale operations, it is a no-brainer that Dynegy would move further and further into this market. Moving forward, Dynegy's business most likely will become more about managing its power sales and exchanges on its still-new trading platform (Dynegydirect), and less about operating a distribution system. As noted, I think Dynegy's business model fits into what appears to be a growing trend among companies heavily focused on generation and trading. First, over the last year there has been a slew of companies that have divided or are planning to divide their regulated and non-regulated businesses (AEP, UtiliCorp, Southern Company, Reliant and NRG, to name a few). The operations are being split not only to attract two different sets of investors, but also to allow a high-growth business such as independent power production or wholesale trading to grow independently from regulated operations. Second, I think we can look to AEP as a company that is charting what may become a more common path. Last fall, after completing its acquisition of CSW, AEP announced an extensive corporate restructuring that includes an exclusive focus on generation assets, wholesale marketing and trading. The company has no plans to expand its distribution assets, either domestically or internationally. AEP has not released its 1Q 2001 earnings report yet, but for year-end 2000 wholesale margins at the company were 41 cents per share higher than in 1999. AEP presently controls a generation portfolio of 38,000 MW and is a top 10 power marketer and top 20 natural gas trader in North America. Nevertheless, AEP's restructuring could take more than a year to accomplish, especially considering that the company may have pooling of interests restrictions related to its merger with CSW and other conditions that fall under PUHCA. Thus, it's evident why the power marketing and generation business is so appealing. In addition, it is also becoming clear that transmission and distribution businesses might be something to avoid unless a company only wants to remain in this heavily regulated side of the energy industry. I've already mentioned the low average return on equity associated with Toperations (also referred to as &wires businesses8 in some states). In addition, FERC continues to monitor interstate transmission activity, and oftentimes the policies affixed onto separate transmission systems can be divergent and extremely complicated. A company that owns or operates Tassets, especially ones that transcend regional boundaries, may find that the business causes an excessive amount of operational headaches that simply cannot be justified by its minimal profit opportunities. Siting is also a problem, as even when communities can be convinced of the need for new Tcapacity, they typically do not want it within their own view. As a result, the wires business is presently considered to be rather lethargic, considering its low risk / low rate of return characteristics. According to Reuters, electricity demand over the next 10 years is expected to increase by 20 to 25 percent. In contrast, transmission line capacity is expected to increase by only about 4 percent. The reasons for this disparity are that many companies are avoiding further investment in transmission capacity due to the inherent disadvantages associated with this business. Further, companies that presently own or operate transmission lines are impacted by FERC Order 2000, which mandates a plan for forming or joining a regional transmission organization (RTO) by Dec. 15 of this year. While RTO plans continue to remain a high priority, the siting or expansion of Tcapacity has become a secondary concern. Considering these many downsides to the wires business, Dynegy and other companies that look to sell their Tbusinesses may not have such an easy time with the divestiture. As noted, the business is heavily regulated and any potential sale would have to be approved by several layers of regulatory agencies. In addition, a company looking to purchase Tassets, assuming that the company is aware of all the risks involved, would most likely be a company that is only interested in Tand is not an active participant in the generation business. There are companies with this kind of business model. National Grid comes to mind as a leading example. The U.K. company is one of the world's largest independent transmission companies and for over a year has been attempting to establish a major presence in the transmission and distribution sectors of the industry, primarily in the United States. National Grid has acquired Niagara Mohawk, New England Electric System (NEES) and Eastern Utilities Associates (EAU), all Toperations located in the Northeastern United States. Dynegy's assets are located in the Midwest and do not seem consistent with National Grid's regional focus. However, the point to be made is that there are companies active in the United States that are aggressively pursuing Toperations, despite the seemingly obvious risks associated with this business. An archive list of previous IssueAlerts is available at www.scientech.com Reach thousands of utility analysts and decision makers every day. Your company can schedule a sponsorship of IssueAlert by contacting Nancy Spring via e-mail or calling (505)244-7613. Advertising opportunities are also available on our website. SCIENTECH is pleased to provide you with your free, daily IssueAlert. Let us know if we can help you with in-depth analyses or any other SCIENTECH information products. If you would like to refer a colleague to receive our free, daily IssueAlerts, please reply to this email and include their full name and email address or register directly on our site. If you no longer wish to receive this daily email, send a message to IssueAlert, and include the word "delete" in the subject line. SCIENTECH's IssueAlerts(SM) are compiled based on the independent analysis of SCIENTECH consultants. The opinions expressed in SCIENTECH's IssueAlerts are not intended to predict financial performance of companies discussed, or to be the basis for investment decisions of any kind. SCIENTECH's sole purpose in publishing its IssueAlerts is to offer an independent perspective regarding the key events occurring in the energy industry, based on its long-standing reputation as an expert on energy issues. Copyright 2001. SCIENTECH, Inc. All rights reserved.